instruction
stringlengths
15
26.1k
Roll's critique ([Roll, 1977][1]) can be summarized as follows (quoting [Wikipedia][2]): 1. **Mean-variance tautology:** Any mean-variance efficient portfolio $R_{p}$ satisfies the CAPM equation exactly: $$ E(R_{i})-R_{f}=\beta_{{ip}}[E(R_{p})-R_{f}]. $$ Mean-variance efficiency of the market portfolio is equiv...
Roll's critique ([Roll, 1977][1]) can be summarized as follows (quoting [Wikipedia][2]): 1. **Mean-variance tautology:** Any mean-variance efficient portfolio $R_{p}$ satisfies the CAPM equation exactly: $$ E(R_{i})-R_{f}=\beta_{{ip}}[E(R_{p})-R_{f}]. $$ Mean-variance efficiency of the market portfolio is equiv...
I am investigating various versions of the Fama and French factor models. Performance of the models is compared on the basis of Squared Sharpe Ratios. [Bariallas et al. (2020, JFQA)][1] propose a test that does only require the factors as inputs and does not rely on test assets. However, I can not quite get my head aro...
I have the impression that asset pricing models typically concern nominal rather than real (inflation-adjusted) prices/returns. If this is indeed so, **why is that?** (I suppose adjustment for inflation might not make a big difference when using daily data but it could become important when using monthly (or even lower...
I have the impression that asset pricing models typically concern nominal rather than real (inflation-adjusted) prices/returns. If this is indeed so, **why is that?** (I suppose adjustment for inflation might not make a big difference when using daily data but it could become important when using monthly (or even lower...
I'm learning [QuantLib-Python][1] and trying to replicate an Interest Rate Swap valuation on a custom curve constructed by passing lists of dates and discounting factors. Please see my code below import QuantLib as ql today = ql.Date(31, ql.May, 2023) ql.Settings.instance().setEvaluationDate(toda...
I'm using this formula to price sovereign CDSs according to CDS Returns, Augustin, Saleh and Xu (2020), Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control. [![enter image description here][1]][1] [1]: https://i.stack.imgur.com/oOP4M.png As you can see, the highlighted part will become negative in the case the spread...
I am investigating various versions of nested and nonnested Fama and French factor models. Performance of the models is compared on the basis of Squared Sharpe Ratios. [Bariallas et al. (2020, JFQA)][1] propose a test that does only require the factors as inputs and does not rely on test assets. However, I can not quit...
I have the impression that asset pricing models such as the CAPM or Fama & French 3 factor model typically concern nominal rather than real (inflation-adjusted) prices/returns. If this is indeed so, **why is that?** Here is my guess. In cross-sectional asset pricing, there is no inherent time dimension (that is why...
I have a conceptual question regarding zero-coupon bonds. Say a bond issuer has issued a bond for funding itself, this bond has been split by the issuer (for simplicity assuming issuer is the same as market maker). The issuer sells the bond at a deep discount to the face value. This discount becomes the capital gain...
I was reading [Smile Dynamics II](https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1493302) by Lorenzo Bergomi. It is clear to me that on page 2 $$ V_t^{T_1,T_2}=\frac{(T_2-t)V^{T_2}_{t}-(T_1-t)V^{T_1}_{t}}{T_2-T_1} $$ is the fair strike of a forward-starting variance swap that starts accumulating variance at ...
Except Zipline, are there any other Pythonic algorithmic trading library I can choose? Especially, for backtesting? Update: Since Quantopian closed, there are some Zipline forks like: https://pypi.org/project/zipline-reloaded/ https://www.quantrocket.com/zipline/ https://zipline-trader.readthedocs.io/en/la...
I have been reading about factor models recently. One of the ways in which the developer of these models (Barra/ Axioma) measure the accuracy of their models is by calculating the bias statistic for the risk forecasts provided by these models. Basically, the process to calculate bias statistic has four legs - a....
I have the impression that asset pricing models such as the CAPM or Fama & French 3 factor model typically concern nominal rather than real (inflation-adjusted) prices/returns. If this is indeed so, **why is that?** Here is my guess. In cross-sectional asset pricing, there is no inherent time dimension (that is why...
In [this question][6], I asked whether it is better to use clustered or GMM-based standard errors for estimating and testing asset pricing models such as the CAPM. However, I then realized that I am not sure how to set up the panel data model needed for obtaining the clustered standard errors, because the $\beta$s are ...
How to set up a panel data model for estimating the CAPM?
Consider estimating an asset pricing model such as the CAPM or a multifactor model using monthly data. [Petersen (2009)][2] section "Asset pricing application" suggests use of standard errors clustered by time, as this addresses the problem of cross-sectional correlation. (Meanwhile, serial correlation is not much of a...
Suppose we are given a dataset with $T$ time periods and $N$ assets or portfolios. We are interested in estimating and testing an augmented CAPM or a multifactor model with an additional factor: the asset's idiosyncratic volatility. In the case of the augmented CAPM, the model is $$ \mu^*_{i}=\beta_i \mu^*_{m}+\gamma...
Here is my guess: If we were to estimate a simple CAPM by GMM, we could use the equation $(12.23)$ from Cochrane ["Asset Pricing"][1] (2005) section 12.2 (p. 241). In his notation, the moments are $$ g_T(b) = \begin{bmatrix} E(R^e_t-a-\beta f_t) \\ E[(R^e_t-a-\beta f_t)f_t] \\ E(R^e-\beta \lambda) \end{bmatrix} = ...
I am trying to wrap my head around GMM estimation of a single factor model such as the CAPM. I started by asking [How come the cross-sectional CAPM equation produces $N$ moment conditions (not $1$)?][3] and am now following it up. Equation $(12.23)$ in Cochrane ["Asset Pricing"][1] (2005) section 12.2 (p. 241) says the...
With **time-constant** expected value of market's excess return, we can estimate the CAPM using GMM as follows. Equation $(12.23)$ in Cochrane ["Asset Pricing"][1] (2005) section 12.2 (p. 241) says the moments are $$ g_T(b) = \begin{bmatrix} E(R^e_t-a-\beta f_t) \\ E[(R^e_t-a-\beta f_t)f_t] \\ E(R^e-\beta \lambda) \e...
I am not able to make quantlib match bloomber price, maybe I don't use the right parameters into `ql.Schedule` or `ql.FixedRateBond` I have a price of : 90.012 instead of 93.508 [Huge spread between my result and bloomberg] **Below is my code :** import QuantLib as ql todaysDate= ql.Date(2,6,20...
I am not able to make quantlib match bloomber price, maybe I don't use the right parameters into `ql.Schedule` or `ql.FixedRateBond` I have a price of : 90.012 instead of 93.508 [Huge spread between my result and bloomberg] **Below is the reproducible example :** import QuantLib as ql todaysDat...
I need a fast package for backtesting in R. I'm going to optimize a lot so I'll be running my strategies many millions of times. I know about packages like `quantstrat` or `SIT` but they are terribly slow for my purposes, I have one strategy, I'm not going to model 20 portfolios at the same time and such. Which packa...
Is there a way to widen the 95% VAR by changing the distribution of a portfolio of stocks? When calculating 95% VAR of my portfolio using the holdings based approach (which requires the covariance matrix), more than 5% of the time it exceeds the upper/lower bounds. This is expected since in general the market has fatt...
Wider VAR for portfolio risk?
If I understand the question correctly, you have a covariance matrix, you assume that your market factors are normally distributed, you calculate VaR, and the VaR comes out "too small". You're looking for a way to incrase the VaR being calculated, that would pass muster with others who might review / challenge / valida...
For focus, let us restrict the scope of this to vanilla options-based positions/strategies. In a lot of the accounts that I've seen of those that engage in this sort of investment/trading strategy (Nassim Taleb, among others), from my view, the entry conditions seem relatively apparent, e.g., potentially, one either...
Input/References on Generating Exit Signals for Positions that Profit Very Highly from Extreme and "Unpredictable" Events?
Why the higher the fixed rate of a swap is, the higher the DV01 will be?
Is there a way to widen the 95% VaR by changing the distribution of a portfolio of stocks? When calculating 95% VaR of my portfolio using the holdings based approach (which requires the covariance matrix), more than 5% of the time it exceeds the upper/lower bounds. This is expected since in general the market has fatt...
Wider VaR for portfolio risk?
Carry and roll-down are intuitively relatively simple concepts. Imagine you trade a 10y Swap, where you pay fixed and receive 6m floating rates. Imagine that: - Your fixed rate is: $r_{10}$ - Your first 6m floating coupon is $c_0$ (which gets fixed at inception of the Swap trade, because the floating rates are fixe...
[![enter image description here][1]][1]A call price is bounded when $\sigma\sqrt{T}$ goes to $0$ and $\infty $ by: $$C_{inf} = e^{-rT}[F-K] \leq C \leq C_{sup}=S $$ Now a simple rearrangement of Black-Scholes formula gives: $$ C = N_1S - e^{-rT}N_2K = e^{-rT}N_2[F-K] + [N_1-N_2]S$$ $$ = \frac{N_2}{N_1}...
[![enter image description here][1]][1]A call price is bounded when $\sigma\sqrt{T}$ goes to $0$ and $\infty $ by: $$C_{inf} = e^{-rT}[F-K] \leq C \leq C_{sup}=S $$ Now a simple rearrangement of Black-Scholes formula gives: $$ C = N_1S - e^{-rT}N_2K = e^{-rT}N_2[F-K] + [N_1-N_2]S$$ $$ = \frac{N_2}{N_1}...
[![enter image description here][1]][1]A call price is bounded when $\sigma\sqrt{T}$ goes to $0$ and $\infty $ by: $$C_{inf} = e^{-rT}[F-K] \leq C \leq C_{sup}=S $$ Now a simple rearrangement of Black-Scholes formula gives: $$ C = N_1S - e^{-rT}N_2K = e^{-rT}N_2[F-K] + [N_1-N_2]S$$ $$ = \frac{N_2}{N_1}...
I am creating a RAROC/FTP model for different loan types on a credit union balance sheet. I am stuck on how to calculate the funding benefit of equity that would be netted out of my cost of funds benchmark. An example below shows the funding benefit @ 0.17%. Does anyone know where that may be sourced from or what cal...
Given the following SDE: $$ d\psi_t = \rho dt + \mu \psi_t dX_t$$, where $G(t) = \rho t$, $\rho = \frac{1}{T}$ $\psi_0 =0$, $T=1$, $\mu > 0$ and $X_t$ is a standard Brownian Motion (assume we know one specific path of $\psi_t$). Further, $E$ denote the mathematical expectation and $1$ the indicator function. The goa...
[![enter image description here][1]][1]A call price is bounded when $\sigma\sqrt{T}$ goes to $0$ and $\infty $ by: $$C_{inf} = e^{-rT}[F-K] \leq C \leq C_{sup}=S $$ Now a simple rearrangement of Black-Scholes formula gives: $$ C = N_1S - e^{-rT}N_2K = e^{-rT}N_2[F-K] + [N_1-N_2]S$$ $$ = \frac{N_2}{N_1}...
I need a fast package for backtesting in R. I'm going to optimize a lot so I'll be running my strategies many millions of times. I know about packages like `quantstrat` or `SIT` but they are terribly slow for my purposes, I have one strategy, I'm not going to model 20 portfolios at the same time and such. Which packa...
I am looking to do some basic portfolio constructions as an experiment to learn more about it. I have been researching a bit and what I have found is that one of the purposes of factors models (Fama-French e.g.) is that it would allow us to model the variance/covariance of the factor portfolios themselves rather than t...
I have return data on several stocks that is regressed on two models. If I now want to compare if the estimated alpha differences between the two models are different from 0, do I use a unpaired t-test or a paired t-test?
I have been reading AFML and I am having trouble understanding snippet 3.1 which provides the following code: ``` def getDailyVol(close,span0=100): # daily vol, reindexed to close df0=close.index.searchsorted(close.index-pd.Timedelta(days=1)) df0=df0[df0>0] df0=pd.Series(close.index[df0-1], index=...
I have been reading AFML and I am having trouble understanding snippet 3.1 which provides the following code: ``` def getDailyVol(close,span0=100): # daily vol, reindexed to close df0=close.index.searchsorted(close.index-pd.Timedelta(days=1)) df0=df0[df0>0] df0=pd.Series(close.index[df0-1], index=...
I have been reading AFML (Marcos López de Prado ) and I am having trouble understanding snippet 3.1 which provides the following code: ``` def getDailyVol(close,span0=100): # daily vol, reindexed to close df0=close.index.searchsorted(close.index-pd.Timedelta(days=1)) df0=df0[df0>0] df0=pd.Series(...
I have been reading AFML ( Marcos López de Prado ) and I am having trouble understanding snippet 3.1 which provides the following code: ``` def getDailyVol(close,span0=100): # daily vol, reindexed to close df0=close.index.searchsorted(close.index-pd.Timedelta(days=1)) df0=df0[df0>0] df0=pd.Series...
Let's say I want to run a series of regressions for zero-cost portfolio Y that goes long on stocks based on high variable x and short stocks with a low variable of x. How do I run the regression, for example, for CAPM? Is it: $$Y - r_f = a + b(market-r_f) + e$$ or $$Y = a + b(market-r_f) + e$$ Is it the fir...
At its most basic the volatility of an instrument is the standard deviation of its return series over time calculated as percentage change of the price series. How would this work for interest rate swaps where the "price" is a rate and is expressed as a percentage? I would be inclined to proceed using the percentage...
My question is about chapter 3 in the ninth edition of "Options, futures and other derivatives" by John C. Hull, subchapter 5 under the heading "Changing the Beta of a Portfolio". In the final paragraph, they explain how one can reduce the Beta of a portfolio by reducing the number of short contracts proportional to...
Why reduce number of short contracts to reduce beta, and take long positions to increase it?
Roll's critique ([Roll, 1977][1]) can be summarized as follows (quoting [Wikipedia][2]): 1. **Mean-variance tautology:** Any mean-variance efficient portfolio $R_{p}$ satisfies the CAPM equation exactly: $$ E(R_{i})-R_{f}=\beta_{{ip}}[E(R_{p})-R_{f}]. $$ Mean-variance efficiency of the market portfolio is equiv...
If I run the below CDS pricing example (from https://github.com/lballabio/QuantLib-SWIG/blob/master/Python/examples/cds.py) using the UpfrontCdsHelper instead of the SpreadCdsHelper, I get the following error if I try to rerun for an earlier date relative to the initial date I used (e.g. rerun for May 15, 2006 after ru...
In the context of interest rate derivatives, we often speak of the spot date. But of course, there is not a "the" spot date, because there are multiple spot dates, for example for different currencies. There isn't necessarily even a single spot date for a currency. For example, SOFR and USD LIBOR swaps both have a t...
What is the scope of spot lags and spot dates?
I came across this passage in a book about PCA and denoising of Markowitz: > But eigenvalues that are important from risk perspective are least important ones from portfolio optimization perspective. > Information matrix mixes the returns and has Reciprocal values 1/λ k of the eigenvalues of the covariance matrix λ...
I know there is a large controversy about whether or not technical trading rules are profitable and research results depend on asset classes, time frames, trading costs, risk-adjusted return calculation, etc. Compared to this complexity it seems rather simple to statistically test, if resistance levels exist. One w...
Do resistance levels for financial securities prices exist?
Has anyone seen R script for GMM estimation and testing of asset pricing models such as Fama-French 3-factor or similar? Ideally, I would like to have R scripts corresponding to Cochrane "Asset Pricing" (2005) chapter 12 and related chapters. Now, I have looked around and found some bits for the CAPM (including in t...
I am trying to figure out whether an options structure is short or long skew without just having someone tell me the answer. I'd like to calculate the number myself. Assuming I am creating a butterfly at strike 90, 100, 110: 1. for strike 110: skew = IV of put @ strike 110 - IV of put @ strike 111 2. for strike 100...
I am trying to figure out whether an options structure is short or long skew without just having someone tell me the answer. I'd like to calculate the number myself. Assuming I am creating a butterfly at strike 90, 100, 110: 1. for strike 110: skew = IV of put @ strike 110 - IV of put @ strike 111 2. for strike 100...
I am trying to figure out whether an options structure is short or long skew without just having someone tell me the answer. I'd like to calculate the number myself. Assuming I am creating a risk reversal at strike 90, 110: 1. for strike 110: skew = IV of call @ strike 110 - IV of call @ strike 111 2. for strike 90...
There are many definitions / concepts of skew. For a good overview of 'skew' you might like [Mixon, What does implied volatility skew measure?][1] What you have done in your example is calculate the slope of the implied volatility smile/skew at two different strikes and then compared the slopes at these two differen...
Can anyone help me with the stochvol package in r? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used volplot function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output.
Can anyone help me with the stochvol package in r? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used volplot function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. When...
Can anyone help me with the stochvol package in r? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used volplot function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. When...
Is there a practical way to calculate a delta threshold for rebalancing when gamma scalping? I know it does not effect expected P&L, but what about optimizing for P&L sharpe ratio after transaction costs?
This is probably a question that should be addressed by the Helpdesk. Anyways, in terms of your questions: 1. The SOFR curve is indeed constructed using swap rates, from very short dated weekly swaps to long dated tenors (e.g. 50 years). If you think the choice of instruments is not appropriate, e.g. short dated SOF...
This is probably a question that should be addressed by the Helpdesk. Anyways, in terms of your questions: 1. The SOFR curve is indeed constructed using swap rates, from very short dated weekly swaps to long dated tenors (e.g. 50 years). If you think the choice of instruments is not appropriate, e.g. short dated SOF...
Can anyone help me with the `stochvol` package in R? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used `volplot` function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. ...
I'm using QuantLib in Python to calculate the z-spread of a bond. I have a `RelinkableYieldTermStructureHandle` for the yield curve, but I'm getting a **TypeError** when I try to pass this handle to the `ql.BondFunctions.zSpread()` function. Wrong number or type of arguments for overloaded function 'BondFunction...
Can anyone help me with the `stochvol` package in R? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used `volplot` function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. ...
Can anyone help me with the `stochvol` package in R? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used `volplot` function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. ...
Can anyone help me with the `stochvol` package in R? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used `volplot` function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. ...
I am trying to run a delta-hedge experiment for an American Put option but there's a (systematic) hedge error which I cannot seem to understand or fix. My implementation is found in the bottom of this post. **My question:** What is causing the hedge error observed in the bottom plot? TLDR: I am delta-hedging...
I am trying to run a delta-hedge experiment for an American Put option but there's a (systematic) hedge error which I cannot seem to understand or fix. My implementation is found in the bottom of this post. **My question:** What is causing the hedge error observed in the bottom plot? I have noticed that the error...
Can anyone help me with the `stochvol` package in R? I estimated the volatilities using this package but I am not being able to understand how to download the estimated volatilities. I used `volplot` function to plot the volatilities but not understanding how to download that output. I have used the following code. ...
I have a stochastic volatility model of a commodity price as follows: ln(pt ) − m = ρp (ln(pt−1) − m) + exp(σt)ut ut ∼ IID(0, 1) σt − μ = ρσ(σt−1 − μ) + ηεt εt ∼ IID(0, 1) Can anyone help me estimate the expectation of the price which follows a Markov chain process? I have estimated the parameters a...
I have a stochastic volatility model of a commodity price as follows: ln(pt ) − m = ρ (ln(pt−1) − m) + exp(σt)ut ut ∼ IID(0, 1) σt − μ = ρσ(σt−1 − μ) + ηεt εt ∼ IID(0, 1) Can anyone help me estimate the expectation of the price which follows a Markov chain process? I have estimated the parameter...
I am trying to run a delta-hedge experiment for an American Put option but there's a (systematic) hedge error which I cannot seem to understand or fix. My implementation is found in the bottom of this post. **My question:** What is causing the hedge error observed in the bottom plot? I have noticed that the error...
I am trying to run a delta-hedge experiment for an American Put option but there's a (systematic) hedge error which I cannot seem to understand or fix. My implementation is found in the bottom of this post. **My question:** What is causing the hedge error observed in the bottom plot? I have noticed that the error...
I am trying to run a delta-hedge experiment for an American Put option but there's a (systematic) hedge error which I cannot seem to understand or fix. My implementation is found in the bottom of this post. **My question:** What is causing the hedge error observed in the bottom plot? I have noticed that the error...
I know that the need for a portfolio/strategy to be self-financing (the purchase of a new asset needs to be funded by selling of an older one/ones) is very helpful when attempting to price derivatives due being able to create replications of the derivative's payoffs, etc. However, do we gain anything (such as a "wro...
Is the self-financing condition necessary/"useful" in practice outside of replication/valuation?
As I was working on this paper https://hal.science/hal-00319947/document by Emmanuel Gobet, I came across this paragraph that says to price a barrier option on (for example) two correlated assets, you can derive two biased estimators that acts like bounds and average them to estimate the price of the option. This looks...
I read everywhere that you create delta neutral positions to prevent being affected by directional change, and while I certainly agree for basic delta neutral options (a hedged vanilla for example), can't we find options that are delta neutral but not symmetrical in changes to the underlying? Imagine your payoff is...
Consider the single factor model in time series form, e.g: $$ r_t^i = \alpha_i + \beta_i f_t +\epsilon^i_t \tag{1} $$ Here $i$ is not an exponent but a superscript, e.g. it represents the return on security $i$. Assuming we have a single factor model, which then states that: $$ \mathbb{E}[r^i] =\alpha_i ...
I am trying to wrap my head around the statement that time series regression should not be used for testing a factor model when the factor is not a return. This has been mentioned in multiple posts, and there are specific posts about that, too, e.g. [this][1] and [this][2]. Cochrane explains this at the end of section ...
Why not use a time series regression when the factor is not a return?
I am trying to wrap my head around the statement that time series regression should not be used for testing a factor model when the factor is not a return. This has been mentioned in multiple posts, and there are specific posts about that, too, e.g. [this][1] and [this][2]. Cochrane explains this at the end of section ...
I have a stochastic volatility model for commodity price which follows an AR(1) process: ln(pt ) − m = ρ (ln(pt−1) − m) + exp(σt)ut ut ∼ IID(0, 1) σt − μ = ρσ(σt−1 − μ) + ηεt εt ∼ IID(0, 1) After estimating the above process, I use the estimated parameters to solve a small open economy model where t...
I am trying to derive the credit spread using an hypothetical portfolio of a long corporate bond plus a short treasury bond, which have the exact cashflows. I should be able to get the credit spread in theory but they don't seem to match. Here are the assumptions. | | | | -------- | -------------- | | maturit...
Say I build a US treasury curve or swap by bootstrapping 2/3/5/7/10/20/30y on the run bonds. Say I have a prepayment model and an OAS model and I can generate key rate dv01s for the book as dBookNPV / dYield(i) where i is in [2, … , 30]. I can then dynamically hedge by shorting the right amount of all the on the runs t...
Should one use the 30y bond alongside shorter tenors to hedge a MBS book?
I'm preparing for the Flow Traders test. What are the beste sources for this? I've used https://arithmetic.zetamac.com/ before, but I'm curious if there is anything better available as well.
For example in [this][1] post it is asked where one can practice for trader's mental math test. Now I can understand why as a trader you'd practice mental health test, but in this day and age can someone please explain to me what the use is of being able to calculate eg -8/2.3 without a calculator? Is it to train...
I never worked as a trader, which means I cannot answer the specific question. However, I have seen (from both sides) plenty of similar applications like HackerRank, Leetcode and the like. Personally, my experience makes me question the usefulness of such tests in finding valuable candidates. That said, **I think th...
I never worked as a trader, which means I cannot answer the specific question. However, I have seen (from both sides) plenty of similar applications like HackerRank, Leetcode and the like. Personally, my experience makes me question the usefulness of such tests in finding valuable candidates. That said, **I think th...
One of the points of Roll's critique ([Roll, 1977][1]) can be summarized as follows (quoting [Wikipedia][2]): 1. **Mean-variance tautology:** Any mean-variance efficient portfolio $R_{p}$ satisfies the CAPM equation exactly: $$ E(R_{i})-R_{f}=\beta_{{ip}}[E(R_{p})-R_{f}]. $$ Mean-variance efficiency of the mark...
Roll's critique ([Roll, 1977][1]) can be summarized as follows (quoting [Wikipedia][2]): 1. **Mean-variance tautology:** Any mean-variance efficient portfolio $R_{p}$ satisfies the CAPM equation exactly: $$ E(R_{i})-R_{f}=\beta_{{ip}}[E(R_{p})-R_{f}]. $$ Mean-variance efficiency of the market portfolio is equiv...
Roll's critique ([Roll, 1977][1]) can be summarized as follows (quoting [Wikipedia][2]): 1. **Mean-variance tautology:** Any mean-variance efficient portfolio $R_{p}$ satisfies the CAPM equation exactly: $$ E(R_{i})-R_{f}=\beta_{{ip}}[E(R_{p})-R_{f}]. $$ Mean-variance efficiency of the market portfolio is equiv...