openenvforge commited on
Commit
44084af
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 8323096

3amBench v0.2.0

Browse files
This view is limited to 50 files because it contains too many changes.   See raw diff
Files changed (50) hide show
  1. .gitignore +0 -6
  2. README.md +176 -24
  3. docs/calibration-status.md +40 -0
  4. manifest.jsonl +30 -30
  5. null/afx-e1-s01/solve.sh +3 -0
  6. null/afx-e1-s02/solve.sh +3 -0
  7. null/afx-e1-s03/solve.sh +3 -0
  8. null/afx-e1-s04/solve.sh +3 -0
  9. null/afx-e1-s05/solve.sh +3 -0
  10. null/afx-e1-s06/solve.sh +3 -0
  11. null/afx-e1-s07/solve.sh +3 -0
  12. null/afx-e1-s08/solve.sh +3 -0
  13. null/afx-e1-s09/solve.sh +3 -0
  14. null/afx-e2-s01/solve.sh +3 -0
  15. null/afx-e2-s02/solve.sh +3 -0
  16. null/afx-e2-s03/solve.sh +3 -0
  17. null/afx-e2-s04/solve.sh +3 -0
  18. null/afx-e2-s05/solve.sh +3 -0
  19. null/afx-e2-s06/solve.sh +3 -0
  20. null/afx-e2-s07/solve.sh +3 -0
  21. null/afx-e2-s08/solve.sh +3 -0
  22. null/afx-e2-s09/solve.sh +3 -0
  23. null/afx-e3-s01/solve.sh +3 -0
  24. null/afx-e3-s02/solve.sh +3 -0
  25. null/afx-e3-s03/solve.sh +3 -0
  26. null/afx-e3-s04/solve.sh +3 -0
  27. null/afx-e3-s05/solve.sh +3 -0
  28. null/afx-e3-s06/solve.sh +3 -0
  29. null/afx-e3-s07/solve.sh +3 -0
  30. null/afx-e3-s08/solve.sh +3 -0
  31. null/afx-e3-s09/solve.sh +3 -0
  32. null/afx-e4-s01/solve.sh +3 -0
  33. null/afx-e4-s02/solve.sh +3 -0
  34. null/afx-e4-s03/solve.sh +3 -0
  35. null/afx-e4-s04/solve.sh +3 -0
  36. null/afx-e4-s05/solve.sh +3 -0
  37. null/afx-e4-s06/solve.sh +3 -0
  38. null/afx-e4-s07/solve.sh +3 -0
  39. null/afx-e4-s08/solve.sh +3 -0
  40. null/afx-e4-s09/solve.sh +3 -0
  41. null/afx-e5-s01/solve.sh +3 -0
  42. null/afx-e5-s02/solve.sh +3 -0
  43. null/afx-e5-s03/solve.sh +3 -0
  44. null/afx-e5-s04/solve.sh +3 -0
  45. null/afx-e5-s05/solve.sh +3 -0
  46. null/afx-e5-s06/solve.sh +3 -0
  47. null/afx-e5-s07/solve.sh +3 -0
  48. null/afx-e5-s08/solve.sh +3 -0
  49. null/afx-e5-s09/solve.sh +3 -0
  50. openenv/alertforge_env/README.md +1 -1
.gitignore CHANGED
@@ -4,10 +4,4 @@ __pycache__/
4
  .venv/
5
  .DS_Store
6
  dist/
7
- .claude/
8
- .claude-flow/
9
- CLAUDE.md
10
- .mcp.json
11
- .swarm/
12
- .hive-mind/
13
  *.egg-info/
 
4
  .venv/
5
  .DS_Store
6
  dist/
 
 
 
 
 
 
7
  *.egg-info/
README.md CHANGED
@@ -28,49 +28,162 @@ atomic checks, so the reward is dense.
28
 
29
  | | |
30
  |---|---|
31
- | Tasks | 30 (5 workflows × 3 tiers × 2 seeds), plus unlimited fresh ones from the generator / OpenEnv server |
32
- | Checks per task | 59-189 (easy 59-67, medium 112-139, hard 167-189) |
33
- | Reward | `reward` in [0, 1] plus 15 diagnostic keys, identical in every task |
34
- | Grader | promtool 3.5.0 + amtool 0.28.1 + stdlib Python + PyYAML; 0.7-7 s per grade, deterministic |
35
- | Formats | Harbor tasks (this repo) and an OpenEnv server with per-step reward (`openenv/alertforge_env`) |
36
 
37
  ## Quick start
38
 
39
  ```bash
40
  # oracle (expect mean 1.0) and no-op (expect 0.0)
41
- uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.1.0 -d 3ambench@0.1.0 -a oracle -n 4
42
- uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.1.0 -d 3ambench@0.1.0 -a nop -n 4
43
  # your model on the 5-task smoke set
44
- uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.1.0 -d 3ambench-mini@0.1.0 -a terminus-2 -m <model>
 
 
45
  ```
46
 
 
 
 
 
47
  Tasks set `[agent] network_mode = "no-network"`, because this repo ships the solutions (see Anti-hacking).
48
  Harbor enforces that on Linux Docker hosts and sandboxed providers. **Docker Desktop on macOS cannot enforce it**
49
  (its VM kernel lacks `CONFIG_NFT_FIB_INET`), and Harbor refuses the task. For local smoke runs on a Mac, use
50
  `scripts/harbor_local.sh`, which runs a temp copy without the network override. Those runs are not leaderboard-safe.
51
 
52
- **OpenEnv (multi-turn, per-step reward):**
 
53
  ```python
54
  from alertforge_env.client import AlertForgeEnv
55
- with AlertForgeEnv(base_url="https://openenvforge-3ambench-env.hf.space").sync() as env:
56
  obs = env.reset(seed=7, split="train", workflow="missed-page-postmortem", tier="medium")
57
  obs = env.step({"tool": "read_file", "path": "README.md"})
58
  obs = env.step({"tool": "write_file", "path": "rules/service-health.yml", "content": "..."})
59
  print(obs.reward, obs.done) # parity mode: rewards sum to the Harbor reward
60
  ```
61
 
62
- **Fresh tasks (training, private held-out sets):** `python generator/generate.py --master-seed <secret>`.
 
63
 
64
  ## Try it
65
 
66
  - **Replay runs in the browser:** [3amBench Replay](https://huggingface.co/spaces/openenvforge/3ambench-replay)
67
- steps through recorded runs (tool calls, file diffs, the reward curve, and which checks pass after each step).
 
68
  Its data comes from `scripts/record_reference_runs.py`, `scripts/record_agent_runs.sh` and `scripts/export_runs.py`;
69
  the page itself is in `space/`.
70
  - **Run the environment locally** and open the web interface at http://localhost:8000/web:
71
  ```bash
72
- docker run -p 8000:8000 -e ENABLE_WEB_INTERFACE=true ghcr.io/devesh-maheshwari/3ambench-env:0.1.0
73
  ```
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
74
 
75
  ## What a task looks like
76
 
@@ -120,8 +233,9 @@ missing `continue` gives Jaccard ½, and a correct burn alert on top of broken S
120
  | `req_alerts`, `req_repairs`, `req_recording`, `req_routing`, `req_inhibit` | per-category scores |
121
  | `fire_rate`, `silent_rate`, `label_rate`, `check_pass_rate` | raw diagnostic pass rates (non-zero for a no-op) |
122
  | `syntax_ok`, `tamper` | all files load / a forbidden construct was used (tamper zeroes the reward) |
 
123
 
124
- ## Reward spread (measured, v0.1.0)
125
 
126
  | Policy | reward | notes |
127
  |---|---|---|
@@ -136,8 +250,7 @@ Adversaries (all 30 tasks, local gate): always-fire, rename, catch-all route, in
136
  Receiver nulling, over-broad inhibition, band thresholds, per-pod alerts, `for`-only fixes, deleting untouched
137
  rules → `outcome` 0 and reward ≤ 0.4.
138
 
139
- Real-model baselines are **not published yet**; they need API spend (planned milestone M-H: leaderboard,
140
- failure gallery, dense-vs-outcome GRPO curve).
141
 
142
  ## How it was built: Skill2Env, but procedural
143
 
@@ -172,9 +285,9 @@ equivalent of Skill2Env's freeze boundary.
172
  14.4x burn-rate rule, and `slo-architect` covers burn-rate alerting. We downloaded ten SRE-adjacent Skill2Env
173
  tasks. The closest one (`task_slo-architect_lgre556n`) grades burn-rate policy by comparing YAML fields, and none
174
  run promtool or amtool.
175
- - [camel-ai/seta-env](https://github.com/camel-ai/seta-env) task 1114: Alertmanager routing and inhibition checked with
176
- amtool. 3amBench's routing checks are end-to-end: the chain case routes the labels the agent's own alert
177
- carries.
178
  - Community rule sets: [samber/awesome-prometheus-alerts](https://github.com/samber/awesome-prometheus-alerts),
179
  [kubernetes-mixin](https://github.com/kubernetes-monitoring/kubernetes-mixin); Google SRE Workbook ch. 5.
180
 
@@ -185,17 +298,56 @@ equivalent of Skill2Env's freeze boundary.
185
  Unsupported constructs fail closed.
186
  - Seven alert templates host the defects, not a large upstream corpus.
187
  - The routing chain case uses the agent's static labels, not labels observed in `ALERTS`.
188
- - The easy tier may saturate for frontier models; this is unmeasured.
 
189
  - **Contamination:** SkillHub skills (and any skill-augmented agent) already contain near-identical burn-rate
190
  recipes, and this repo ships solutions. Evaluate on a private-seed build, and report whether the agent had
191
  `SKILL.md`.
192
  - English only.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
193
 
194
  ## Repository layout
195
 
196
- `tasks/` (Harbor tasks) · `registry.json` (`3ambench`, `3ambench-mini`) · `manifest.jsonl` (one row per
197
- task) · `partial/`, `null/` (reference policies) · `skill/`, `workflows/` · `generator/generate.py` + `src/alertforge/` (the generator and grader source) ·
198
- `openenv/alertforge_env/` (OpenEnv server) · `space/` (static replay viewer) · `scripts/` · `tests/` (pytest).
 
 
 
 
 
199
 
200
  ## License and citation
201
 
@@ -205,6 +357,6 @@ Apache-2.0; see `NOTICE.md` for attribution of adapted community rules (CC BY 4.
205
  @misc{3ambench2026,
206
  title = {3amBench: a behaviorally graded, dense-reward RL environment for Prometheus alerting as code},
207
  year = {2026},
208
- note = {Harbor dataset and OpenEnv environment; generator package alertforge v0.1.0}
209
  }
210
  ```
 
28
 
29
  | | |
30
  |---|---|
31
+ | Tasks | 30 core (5 workflows × 3 tiers × 2 seeds) and 45 expert (5 families × 9 seeds, see [Expert tier](#expert-tier-v02)), plus unlimited fresh ones from the generator / OpenEnv server |
32
+ | Checks per task | 59-189 (easy 59-67, medium 112-139, hard 167-189); expert 128-232 |
33
+ | Reward | `reward` in [0, 1] plus 15 diagnostic keys (core) or 26 (expert), identical within a tier |
34
+ | Grader | promtool 3.5.0 + amtool 0.28.1 + stdlib Python + PyYAML; deterministic; core 0.7-7 s, expert about 0.5-12 s per grade (one process) |
35
+ | Formats | Harbor tasks (this repo has the 30 core tasks; the Hugging Face dataset has all 75) and an OpenEnv server with per-step reward for the core tier (`openenv/alertforge_env`) |
36
 
37
  ## Quick start
38
 
39
  ```bash
40
  # oracle (expect mean 1.0) and no-op (expect 0.0)
41
+ uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.2.0 -d 3ambench@0.2.0 -a oracle -n 4
42
+ uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.2.0 -d 3ambench@0.2.0 -a nop -n 4
43
  # your model on the 5-task smoke set
44
+ uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.2.0 -d 3ambench-mini@0.2.0 -a terminus-2 -m <model>
45
+ # expert tier: the 15 leaderboard tasks (all 45: -d 3ambench-expert@0.2.0)
46
+ uvx harbor run --repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.2.0 -d 3ambench-expert-lb@0.2.0 -a terminus-2 -m <model>
47
  ```
48
 
49
+ The core tasks in `3ambench@0.2.0` are the `3ambench@0.1.1` tasks with their fictional company domains moved to
50
+ reserved `.example` names (and the version stamp); checks, scenarios and grader are unchanged, and every recorded
51
+ v0.1.1 run regrades to the same reward, so v0.1.1 numbers stay comparable.
52
+
53
  Tasks set `[agent] network_mode = "no-network"`, because this repo ships the solutions (see Anti-hacking).
54
  Harbor enforces that on Linux Docker hosts and sandboxed providers. **Docker Desktop on macOS cannot enforce it**
55
  (its VM kernel lacks `CONFIG_NFT_FIB_INET`), and Harbor refuses the task. For local smoke runs on a Mac, use
56
  `scripts/harbor_local.sh`, which runs a temp copy without the network override. Those runs are not leaderboard-safe.
57
 
58
+ **OpenEnv (multi-turn, per-step reward)**, against a local server started as in [Try it](#try-it). The client
59
+ needs `pip install "openenv-core==0.3.0"` and a clone of this repo on `PYTHONPATH=openenv`:
60
  ```python
61
  from alertforge_env.client import AlertForgeEnv
62
+ with AlertForgeEnv(base_url="http://localhost:8000").sync() as env:
63
  obs = env.reset(seed=7, split="train", workflow="missed-page-postmortem", tier="medium")
64
  obs = env.step({"tool": "read_file", "path": "README.md"})
65
  obs = env.step({"tool": "write_file", "path": "rules/service-health.yml", "content": "..."})
66
  print(obs.reward, obs.done) # parity mode: rewards sum to the Harbor reward
67
  ```
68
 
69
+ **Fresh tasks (training, private held-out sets):** `python generator/generate.py --master-seed <secret> --out <dir>`
70
+ (needs promtool and amtool; without `--out` it overwrites this repo's tasks).
71
 
72
  ## Try it
73
 
74
  - **Replay runs in the browser:** [3amBench Replay](https://huggingface.co/spaces/openenvforge/3ambench-replay)
75
+ steps through recorded runs (tool calls, file diffs, the reward curve, which checks pass after each step, and
76
+ for expert runs which tickets were solved).
77
  Its data comes from `scripts/record_reference_runs.py`, `scripts/record_agent_runs.sh` and `scripts/export_runs.py`;
78
  the page itself is in `space/`.
79
  - **Run the environment locally** and open the web interface at http://localhost:8000/web:
80
  ```bash
81
+ docker run -p 8000:8000 -e ENABLE_WEB_INTERFACE=true ghcr.io/devesh-maheshwari/3ambench-env:0.2.0
82
  ```
83
+ The image is built for linux/amd64 and linux/arm64. To build it yourself from a clone:
84
+ `docker build -f openenv/alertforge_env/server/Dockerfile -t 3ambench-env .` (then run `3ambench-env`).
85
+
86
+ ## Leaderboard (core, 6 tasks: af-001, af-009, af-013, af-017, af-021, af-029)
87
+
88
+ <!-- LEADERBOARD:core -->
89
+ | Agent | Model | Runs | Mean reward | Solved |
90
+ |---|---|---|---|---|
91
+ | claude-code | claude-opus-5-5 | 12 | 1.000 | 12/12 |
92
+ | codex | gpt-6-astra | 12 | 1.000 | 12/12 |
93
+ | terminus-2 | gpt-oss-120b | 13 | 0.436 | 3/13 |
94
+
95
+ 37 runs on 6 tasks.
96
+ <!-- /LEADERBOARD -->
97
+
98
+ The runs were recorded on the v0.1.1 tasks; their saved workspaces, read with the renamed domains, regrade to the
99
+ same rewards on the 0.2.0 tasks. Local Harbor runs on Docker Desktop (agent network enabled, so not sealed). Frontier agents saturate this subset;
100
+ the dense reward separates weaker models (gpt-oss-120b scores between 0.03 and 0.37 on every unsolved run instead of 0).
101
+ v0.2 adds the expert tier below. Every run can be replayed step by step in the
102
+ [replay Space](https://huggingface.co/spaces/openenvforge/3ambench-replay).
103
+
104
+ ## Expert tier (v0.2)
105
+
106
+ A core task is a short list of change requests on a small repo. An expert task is a week of a team's
107
+ observability queue on a large legacy one: 45 tasks, five families of nine seeds, each at a different fictional
108
+ company with its own services, teams and history. The starting repo has 62-85 alerting rules in 14-22 files, SLI
109
+ recording rules, an SLO catalog, an ownership file, ADRs, runbooks, a CI script, and an Alertmanager config shared
110
+ with two other Prometheus servers (41-53 receivers, legacy `match:` routes next to `matchers:`). The queue holds two
111
+ or three symptom tickets and two to seven routine requests.
112
+
113
+ | Family | The week |
114
+ |---|---|
115
+ | E1 quiet pager | Nobody was paged: an outage where the Down alert could not fire once the targets went away, an error-ratio page that never fired, a replica-lag alert stuck in pending, a postmortem action item asking for a traffic-floor page |
116
+ | E2 storm after a deploy | Too many pages: one per pod during a database failover, false pages from canaries and rollouts, a cluster outage that paged every service owner |
117
+ | E3 reorg + routing migration | A team split that routing never caught up with: alerts that still carry the old team, a team with no route, SRE still everyone's first pager, a channel being archived, warnings muted by unrelated criticals |
118
+ | E4 latency SLO rollout | A latency SLO going live: SLI recording rules that are wrong during a rollout, slow requests that never page, burn alerts to add |
119
+ | E5 legacy cleanup after an on-call survey | The work arrives as raw answers to an on-call survey: a consumer stall that never fired, a nightly batch that stopped without a ticket, a disk prediction that pages for the backup job, dead runbook links, a legacy service to remove. Some answers need nothing from this repo, and some alerts have to stay as they are |
120
+
121
+ What makes it realistic:
122
+
123
+ - Tickets read like tickets. A symptom ticket says what happened in the reporter's words ("17 pages for one
124
+ database failover", "KafkaConsumerStalled has never fired") and points at an incident packet: PagerDuty and Slack
125
+ exports, a postmortem, `query_range` pulls of the night that `bin/range2test` turns into promtool tests. It never
126
+ says which rule is wrong.
127
+ - Policy lives in the repo, not in the ticket: SLOs and windows in the catalog, the paging policy in the README,
128
+ ownership in `teams/ownership.yaml`, the burn-rate policy in an ADR. A new hire would have to look there too.
129
+ - The repo has a past: two routing syntaxes, a team split half done, rules that moved with their team, decoy alerts
130
+ that look broken and aren't, alerts other teams own.
131
+ - No two tasks share a company, an org chart or a queue, so a fix can't be copied from a sibling task.
132
+
133
+ **Grading** is behavioral and dense, as in the core tier. Promtool replays every hidden scenario group once (plus a
134
+ re-run where a deadline window needs one) and the grader reads which alerts fire, minute by minute; routing goes through amtool and inhibition through the strict
135
+ Alertmanager simulator. A symptom ticket is an outcome check: when the incident replays, the right page reaches the
136
+ right team, and it stays quiet on normal traffic, deploys, flaps and the noise that started the ticket. Alerts are
137
+ counted after inhibition, so muting everything doesn't make a quiet pager look fixed. Routine requests (routes,
138
+ inhibitions, label moves, burn alerts, recording rules, annotations, legacy removals) are checked the same way.
139
+ Untouched rules, receivers and routes have to keep working; a rewritten but equivalent rule is replayed, not
140
+ compared as text. Each requirement scores s in [-0.25, 1] against the starting repo, and `reward` = 0.6 · solved +
141
+ 0.4 · progress as in [Reward](#reward); expert progress also loses 0.75 weight units for each leave-as-is alert the
142
+ run changes, and `solved` requires all of them intact. A symptom ticket weighs 5-10 against 2-3 for a routine request, so the
143
+ tickets carry 55-82% of a task's weight. `diagnosis` is the weighted mean s over the symptom tickets and `routine`
144
+ the same over the rest: among runs that don't solve a task, they tell finding the cause apart from doing the easy
145
+ part of the queue. Expert tasks have 128-232 checks and the same anti-hacking defenses, plus tamper checks on reads
146
+ of `ALERTS`.
147
+
148
+ **Calibration, honestly:** frontier agents solve most expert tasks, in minutes (3-5 minutes per task in our pilot
149
+ runs). The tier is not built to rank frontier models against each other. It is aimed at separating mid-size and
150
+ open models, where the dense reward and the diagnosis/routine split show how far a run got, and at RL training on a
151
+ realistic repo. A harder frontier tier is in development; there is no frontier-hardness result yet.
152
+
153
+ ### Leaderboard (v0.2.0, expert: the 15 tasks of `3ambench-expert-lb@0.2.0`, 3 per family)
154
+
155
+ <!-- LEADERBOARD:expert -->
156
+ | Agent | Model | Runs | Tasks | Mean reward | Solved | Diagnosis | Routine |
157
+ |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
158
+ | claude-code | claude-opus-5-5 | 14 | 14/15 | 1.000 | 14/14 | 1.000 | 1.000 |
159
+ | codex | gpt-6-astra | 15 | 15/15 | 0.960 | 14/15 | 1.000 | 1.000 |
160
+ | claude-code | claude-fable-5-1 | 14 | 14/15 | 0.956 | 13/14 | 1.000 | 1.000 |
161
+ | codex | gpt-5.6-sol | 15 | 15/15 | 0.912 | 13/15 | 0.967 | 1.000 |
162
+ | claude-code | claude-sonnet-5 | 14 | 14/15 | 0.762 | 9/14 | 0.903 | 1.000 |
163
+ | claude-code | claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 | 14 | 14/15 | 0.346 | 2/14 | 0.473 | 0.927 |
164
+ | terminus-2 | gpt-oss-120b | 10 | 10/15 | 0.065 | 0/10 | 0.071 | 0.345 |
165
+
166
+ 96 runs on 15 tasks; 2 runs flagged invalid are not counted.
167
+ <!-- /LEADERBOARD -->
168
+
169
+ The 15 tasks are `3ambench-expert-lb@0.2.0`: the development pilot set (3 per family,
170
+ `scripts/expert_calibrate.py --pilot`), not a calibrated or held-out selection. These are unbalanced local
171
+ development runs on Docker Desktop (agent network enabled, so not sealed), not a held-out model comparison, and the
172
+ rows cover different tasks (the Tasks column), so compare them with care. The two historical `afx-e5-s08` trials
173
+ (Opus and Astra) are excluded because their survey evidence differs from the current task. Astra and Sol were re-run
174
+ on the current task, so they cover all 15 tasks; Opus, Fable, Sonnet and Haiku have no valid `afx-e5-s08` run yet
175
+ and cover 14. gpt-oss-120b covers 10: the provider budget cap stopped it before afx-e2-s03, afx-e3-s04, afx-e4-s04
176
+ and afx-e5-s03, and it has no `afx-e5-s08` run. Every saved output was regraded with the released task's own
177
+ grader. Six runs score higher than Harbor's verifier gave them at the time, because of the grader fixes listed in
178
+ the CHANGELOG; the final 0.2.0 changes (reserved domains, ingress series, the two grader fixes) change no recorded
179
+ score. Infrastructure failures are excluded when present. Every run, with the
180
+ tickets it solved, can be replayed in the [replay Space](https://huggingface.co/spaces/openenvforge/3ambench-replay).
181
+
182
+ To build the 45 tasks yourself: `pip install .` from a clone, then `alertforge expert --out <dir> --seeds 1-9`
183
+ (promtool and amtool on the path, or in `AF_PROMTOOL` and `AF_AMTOOL`). It runs each task's acceptance gate as well,
184
+ and it reproduces the released tasks byte for byte.
185
+
186
+ See [calibration status](docs/calibration-status.md) for the calibration protocol and what is still open.
187
 
188
  ## What a task looks like
189
 
 
233
  | `req_alerts`, `req_repairs`, `req_recording`, `req_routing`, `req_inhibit` | per-category scores |
234
  | `fire_rate`, `silent_rate`, `label_rate`, `check_pass_rate` | raw diagnostic pass rates (non-zero for a no-op) |
235
  | `syntax_ok`, `tamper` | all files load / a forbidden construct was used (tamper zeroes the reward) |
236
+ | `diagnosis`, `routine` | expert tier only: weighted mean `s` over the symptom tickets, and over the rest of the queue. Tickets carry at least 55% of an expert task's weight, so among runs that don't solve a task these say whether the progress came from diagnosing or from routine edits |
237
 
238
+ ## Reward spread (measured on the v0.1.0 tasks, before the 0.1.1 fairness fixes)
239
 
240
  | Policy | reward | notes |
241
  |---|---|---|
 
250
  Receiver nulling, over-broad inhibition, band thresholds, per-pod alerts, `for`-only fixes, deleting untouched
251
  rules → `outcome` 0 and reward ≤ 0.4.
252
 
253
+ Real-model results are in the two leaderboards above; a dense-vs-outcome GRPO training curve is not published yet.
 
254
 
255
  ## How it was built: Skill2Env, but procedural
256
 
 
285
  14.4x burn-rate rule, and `slo-architect` covers burn-rate alerting. We downloaded ten SRE-adjacent Skill2Env
286
  tasks. The closest one (`task_slo-architect_lgre556n`) grades burn-rate policy by comparing YAML fields, and none
287
  run promtool or amtool.
288
+ - [camel-ai/seta-env](https://github.com/camel-ai/seta-env) task 1114: an Alertmanager routing and inhibition task. Its
289
+ tests run amtool only for `check-config` and check routes and inhibitions by reading the YAML. 3amBench's routing
290
+ checks are end-to-end: the chain case routes the labels the agent's own alert carries.
291
  - Community rule sets: [samber/awesome-prometheus-alerts](https://github.com/samber/awesome-prometheus-alerts),
292
  [kubernetes-mixin](https://github.com/kubernetes-monitoring/kubernetes-mixin); Google SRE Workbook ch. 5.
293
 
 
298
  Unsupported constructs fail closed.
299
  - Seven alert templates host the defects, not a large upstream corpus.
300
  - The routing chain case uses the agent's static labels, not labels observed in `ALERTS`.
301
+ - Frontier agents solved every run on the two easy tasks measured (af-001, af-013), so the easy tier likely
302
+ saturates for them.
303
  - **Contamination:** SkillHub skills (and any skill-augmented agent) already contain near-identical burn-rate
304
  recipes, and this repo ships solutions. Evaluate on a private-seed build, and report whether the agent had
305
  `SKILL.md`.
306
  - English only.
307
+ - Expert tier (v0.2 candidates): hidden scenarios replay through promtool, whose samples sit exactly on the
308
+ evaluation ticks. A target that leaves service discovery is marked stale on the next sample; a real
309
+ Prometheus 3.5 server writes those stale markers about two scrape intervals after the last scrape, so an
310
+ `absent()` Down alert pages 1-2 minutes later in production than in the replay. The graders accept
311
+ `absent()` Down alerts with `for` up to 10m, which in production page 11-13 minutes after the targets went
312
+ away, against the 10 minutes the task README asks for. Window corners that depend on the scrape and
313
+ evaluation phases are graded as promtool sees them: `[90s]` on a 1m scrape passes in the replay, but on a
314
+ real server it is empty for about half of all phase pairs.
315
+ - Expert tier: when a counter stops (consumer offsets, requests), a stated deadline is counted from the last
316
+ sample that still increased, the earliest the stop can have happened. When a series goes away, it is counted
317
+ from the minute its stale marker is written (see above for how that differs from a real server).
318
+ - Expert tier: a routing fix that sits below an unfixed catch-all route earns nothing on its own route checks,
319
+ because the catch-all takes the alerts first. That is Alertmanager's first-match routing, kept on purpose: a
320
+ run that misses the catch-all also loses the route tickets behind it.
321
+ - Expert tier: `cluster` is a target label on `up` only; request counters and histograms in the hidden data
322
+ don't carry it.
323
+ - Expert tier: every hidden scenario holds what the world's targets export at healthy levels: request counters for
324
+ every service whose pods are up; the histograms, pool gauges and cAdvisor series the repo's rules read about those
325
+ services; the ingress controller's request counters (`nginx_ingress_controller_requests`) for every HTTP service;
326
+ and the exporter series a ticket needs. Targets that go down or leave discovery get stale markers. The ingress
327
+ counts the same requests and status codes as the app's own counters, and while a service has no target up it
328
+ answers 502 (targets down) or 503 (none left) for the traffic clients keep sending. Not simulated: the ingress
329
+ latency histogram and config-reload gauge, and fleet exporters (node, Postgres, Redis, Kafka, JVM) beyond those a
330
+ ticket needs. The repo's fleet alerts and its ingress latency and reload alerts therefore never fire in the replay,
331
+ and an alert that reads only those series cannot be graded on them. A scenario still starts without history: at
332
+ its first evaluation `rate()` has no value yet, so a floor rule that reads a missing counter as zero traffic sees
333
+ zero there, and its `for` is what keeps it quiet.
334
+ - Expert tier: an untouched alert counts as intact when it behaves the same. Its text may change (formatting,
335
+ operand order, a static label equal to what its expression already yields, an identical second copy) as long as
336
+ its `for`, thresholds, windows and functions stay and it fires with the same labels at every minute of every
337
+ hidden scenario. An alert that fires in none of them can only be kept as written.
338
+ - Expert tier: an alert needs the labels the task's README names, with their values; it may carry others, which are
339
+ judged by where the alert is delivered, not by their presence.
340
 
341
  ## Repository layout
342
 
343
+ `tasks/` (Harbor tasks: this repository holds the 30 core tasks; the Hugging Face dataset adds the 45 expert `afx-*`
344
+ tasks that `registry.json` also lists, so run those with `--repo https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench@v0.2.0`
345
+ or build them with `alertforge expert`) · `registry.json` (`3ambench`, `3ambench-mini`, `3ambench-expert`,
346
+ `3ambench-expert-lb`, all 0.2.0) · `manifest.jsonl` (one row per core task) · `partial/`, `null/` (reference
347
+ policies) · `skill/`, `workflows/` · `generator/generate.py` + `src/alertforge/` (the generator and grader source;
348
+ `src/alertforge/expert/` builds the expert tier) · `openenv/alertforge_env/` (OpenEnv server) · `space/` (static
349
+ replay viewer) · `scripts/` (`export_runs.py` and `leaderboard.py` produce the replay data and the leaderboard tables,
350
+ from a GitHub clone; the dataset does not ship `space/`) · `tests/` (pytest).
351
 
352
  ## License and citation
353
 
 
357
  @misc{3ambench2026,
358
  title = {3amBench: a behaviorally graded, dense-reward RL environment for Prometheus alerting as code},
359
  year = {2026},
360
+ note = {Harbor dataset and OpenEnv environment; generator package alertforge v0.2.0}
361
  }
362
  ```
docs/calibration-status.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # Calibration status (v0.2.0)
2
+
3
+ The expert tier separates mid-size and open models clearly, but it does not separate frontier agents: they solve
4
+ almost every expert task, usually in a few minutes. v0.2.0 makes no frontier-difficulty claim.
5
+
6
+ ## What the v0.2.0 leaderboard is
7
+
8
+ - One attempt per task and model on the 15 tasks of `3ambench-expert-lb@0.2.0` (3 per family), run locally through
9
+ Harbor on Docker Desktop with the agent's network enabled. These are development runs, not a sealed, held-out
10
+ comparison.
11
+ - Every stored run was graded with the release grader. The fictional company domains were renamed to reserved
12
+ `.example` names after the runs; stored workspaces and trajectories are read through that rename, and all 171
13
+ stored runs (96 expert, 73 core, plus 2 excluded) regrade to the same scores they had before it.
14
+ - Coverage differs by model and the table says so: two `afx-e5-s08` attempts (Opus and Astra) are excluded because
15
+ that task's survey wording was corrected after they ran; Astra and Sol were rerun on the corrected task, the other
16
+ models were not. gpt-oss-120b ran on 10 tasks because its hosted API had a spending cap.
17
+ - Every failure in these runs was triaged before it was counted. Failures caused by the task or the grader
18
+ (an unstated requirement, scenario data that punished a valid fix, ambiguous wording) were fixed in the
19
+ generator or grader and the stored runs regraded; only genuine model mistakes count as failures.
20
+
21
+ ## Rules for counting results
22
+
23
+ - Mechanical acceptance gates come before any model measurement: the reference solution scores 1, an alternative
24
+ valid solution scores 1, doing nothing scores 0, a partial solution lands in its band, and every scripted cheat
25
+ stays in its band.
26
+ - A lower score caused by ambiguity, grader errors, missing evidence or infrastructure is not a model failure and not
27
+ a hardening result.
28
+ - `scripts/expert_calibrate.py` requires a balanced pilot before any difficulty verdict: two declared models, three
29
+ preselected tasks per family and three valid attempts per model and task. Missing cells produce `collect`, not a
30
+ verdict. Duplicate and invalid runs never count as extra attempts, and historical results are regraded against
31
+ the current task artifacts before use. Report models separately: a pooled average can hide saturation by the
32
+ stronger model.
33
+ - Before fresh measurements, freeze task and grader hashes, seeds, model and harness settings, reasoning and
34
+ sampling settings, resource, tool and network limits, attempt counts and the retry and exclusion rules, and keep
35
+ every raw trajectory, final workspace, result and exclusion.
36
+
37
+ ## Frontier tier
38
+
39
+ A harder frontier tier is in development. It is held out of this release so that it can be measured on tasks no
40
+ model has seen; it will ship as its own version once a calibrated measurement supports it.
manifest.jsonl CHANGED
@@ -1,30 +1,30 @@
1
- {"task_id": "af-001-slo-onboarding-easy-s1", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["chat-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 66, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.167133, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.27, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
2
- {"task_id": "af-002-slo-onboarding-easy-s2", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["loyalty-api"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 66, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.258651, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.27, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
3
- {"task_id": "af-003-slo-onboarding-medium-s1", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["loyalty-svc", "ingest-gw"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 139, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.254341, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.0, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
4
- {"task_id": "af-004-slo-onboarding-medium-s2", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["orders-worker", "media-api"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 138, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.250639, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.61, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
5
- {"task_id": "af-005-slo-onboarding-hard-s1", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["shipping-api", "chat-edge", "cart-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 176, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.212933, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.26, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
6
- {"task_id": "af-006-slo-onboarding-hard-s2", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["fraud-svc", "wishlist-api", "inventory-svc"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 181, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208439, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.51, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
7
- {"task_id": "af-007-alert-storm-cleanup-easy-s1", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["orders-svc"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 64, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.285102, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.03, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
8
- {"task_id": "af-008-alert-storm-cleanup-easy-s2", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["catalog-api"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 64, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.262312, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.0, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
9
- {"task_id": "af-009-alert-storm-cleanup-medium-s1", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["report-worker", "billing-svc"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 124, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 4, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.253641, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.01, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
10
- {"task_id": "af-010-alert-storm-cleanup-medium-s2", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["checkout-worker", "cart-edge"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 116, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 4, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.230701, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.67, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
11
- {"task_id": "af-011-alert-storm-cleanup-hard-s1", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["inventory-svc", "ledger-gw", "ratings-svc"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 176, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 6, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208481, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.55, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
12
- {"task_id": "af-012-alert-storm-cleanup-hard-s2", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["fraud-api", "promo-svc", "auth-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 182, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 6, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.182729, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 5.79, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
13
- {"task_id": "af-013-missed-page-postmortem-easy-s1", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["pricing-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 62, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.239609, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.16, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
14
- {"task_id": "af-014-missed-page-postmortem-easy-s2", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "data_query", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["coupon-svc"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 59, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.283333, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 0.73, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
15
- {"task_id": "af-015-missed-page-postmortem-medium-s1", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["coupon-api", "orders-svc"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 137, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.260517, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.07, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
16
- {"task_id": "af-016-missed-page-postmortem-medium-s2", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["orders-edge", "tax-edge"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 132, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.236505, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.2, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
17
- {"task_id": "af-017-missed-page-postmortem-hard-s1", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "data_query", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["ledger-api", "payments-edge", "billing-api"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 173, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 3, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.21644, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.44, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
18
- {"task_id": "af-018-missed-page-postmortem-hard-s2", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["feed-edge", "search-edge", "geo-gw"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 167, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 3, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.213061, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.48, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
19
- {"task_id": "af-019-latency-slo-easy-s1", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["ledger-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 61, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.167133, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.3, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
20
- {"task_id": "af-020-latency-slo-easy-s2", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["wishlist-api"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 67, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.250133, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.3, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
21
- {"task_id": "af-021-latency-slo-medium-s1", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["export-edge", "refund-gw"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 137, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.213043, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.79, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
22
- {"task_id": "af-022-latency-slo-medium-s2", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["invoice-api", "notify-worker"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 132, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.261538, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.45, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
23
- {"task_id": "af-023-latency-slo-hard-s1", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["ingest-worker", "chat-gw", "tax-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 178, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.2056, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.35, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
24
- {"task_id": "af-024-latency-slo-hard-s2", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["wishlist-gw", "fraud-worker", "stock-gw"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 179, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.177933, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.58, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
25
- {"task_id": "af-025-team-reorg-migration-easy-s1", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["loyalty-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 61, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208333, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 0.81, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
26
- {"task_id": "af-026-team-reorg-migration-easy-s2", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["ingest-worker"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 61, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208333, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 0.82, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
27
- {"task_id": "af-027-team-reorg-migration-medium-s1", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "transform_convert", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["pricing-worker", "inventory-worker"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 112, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.267826, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.93, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
28
- {"task_id": "af-028-team-reorg-migration-medium-s2", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["report-svc", "export-svc"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 112, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.27513, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.92, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
29
- {"task_id": "af-029-team-reorg-migration-hard-s1", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "transform_convert", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["payments-gw", "fraud-svc", "profile-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 181, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.202898, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 5.37, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
30
- {"task_id": "af-030-team-reorg-migration-hard-s2", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "transform_convert", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["media-edge", "identity-svc", "payments-api"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 189, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.253119, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 6.29, "generator_version": "0.1.0"}
 
1
+ {"task_id": "af-001-slo-onboarding-easy-s1", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["chat-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 66, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.167133, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.38, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
2
+ {"task_id": "af-002-slo-onboarding-easy-s2", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["loyalty-api"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 66, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.258651, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.25, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
3
+ {"task_id": "af-003-slo-onboarding-medium-s1", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["loyalty-svc", "ingest-gw"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 139, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.254341, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.96, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
4
+ {"task_id": "af-004-slo-onboarding-medium-s2", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["orders-worker", "media-api"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 138, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.250639, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.99, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
5
+ {"task_id": "af-005-slo-onboarding-hard-s1", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["shipping-api", "chat-edge", "cart-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 176, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.212933, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.78, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
6
+ {"task_id": "af-006-slo-onboarding-hard-s2", "workflow": "slo-onboarding", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["fraud-svc", "wishlist-api", "inventory-svc"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 181, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208439, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 5.17, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
7
+ {"task_id": "af-007-alert-storm-cleanup-easy-s1", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["orders-svc"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 64, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.285102, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.09, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
8
+ {"task_id": "af-008-alert-storm-cleanup-easy-s2", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["catalog-api"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 64, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.262312, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.11, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
9
+ {"task_id": "af-009-alert-storm-cleanup-medium-s1", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["report-worker", "billing-svc"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 124, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 4, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.253641, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.3, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
10
+ {"task_id": "af-010-alert-storm-cleanup-medium-s2", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["checkout-worker", "cart-edge"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 116, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 4, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.230701, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.89, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
11
+ {"task_id": "af-011-alert-storm-cleanup-hard-s1", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["inventory-svc", "ledger-gw", "ratings-svc"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 176, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 6, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208481, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 5.23, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
12
+ {"task_id": "af-012-alert-storm-cleanup-hard-s2", "workflow": "alert-storm-cleanup", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "harden_secure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "adversarial_corpus", "persona": "on_call_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["fraud-api", "promo-svc", "auth-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 182, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 6, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.182729, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 6.33, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
13
+ {"task_id": "af-013-missed-page-postmortem-easy-s1", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["pricing-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 62, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.239609, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.19, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
14
+ {"task_id": "af-014-missed-page-postmortem-easy-s2", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "data_query", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["coupon-svc"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 59, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.283333, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 0.74, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
15
+ {"task_id": "af-015-missed-page-postmortem-medium-s1", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["coupon-api", "orders-svc"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 137, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.260517, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.0, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
16
+ {"task_id": "af-016-missed-page-postmortem-medium-s2", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["orders-edge", "tax-edge"], "n_requirements": 10, "n_checks": 132, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.236505, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.48, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
17
+ {"task_id": "af-017-missed-page-postmortem-hard-s1", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "data_query", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["ledger-api", "payments-edge", "billing-api"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 173, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 3, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.21644, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 5.36, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
18
+ {"task_id": "af-018-missed-page-postmortem-hard-s2", "workflow": "missed-page-postmortem", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "repair_debug", "primary_verifier_pattern": "behavioral_simulation", "persona": "incident_commander", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["feed-edge", "search-edge", "geo-gw"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 167, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 3, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.213061, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.88, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
19
+ {"task_id": "af-019-latency-slo-easy-s1", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["ledger-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 61, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.167133, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.97, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
20
+ {"task_id": "af-020-latency-slo-easy-s2", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["wishlist-api"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 67, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.250133, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.75, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
21
+ {"task_id": "af-021-latency-slo-medium-s1", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["export-edge", "refund-gw"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 137, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.213043, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.34, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
22
+ {"task_id": "af-022-latency-slo-medium-s2", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["invoice-api", "notify-worker"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 132, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.261538, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 3.07, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
23
+ {"task_id": "af-023-latency-slo-hard-s1", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["ingest-worker", "chat-gw", "tax-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 178, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.2056, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 4.95, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
24
+ {"task_id": "af-024-latency-slo-hard-s2", "workflow": "latency-slo", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "author_to_constraints", "primary_verifier_pattern": "differential_equivalence", "persona": "performance_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["wishlist-gw", "fraud-worker", "stock-gw"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 179, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.177933, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 7.44, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
25
+ {"task_id": "af-025-team-reorg-migration-easy-s1", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["loyalty-gw"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 61, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208333, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.2, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
26
+ {"task_id": "af-026-team-reorg-migration-easy-s2", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "easy", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "urgent-pager", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["ingest-worker"], "n_requirements": 5, "n_checks": 61, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 1, "req_repairs": 1, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 1, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.208333, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 1.2, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
27
+ {"task_id": "af-027-team-reorg-migration-medium-s1", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "transform_convert", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "novice", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["pricing-worker", "inventory-worker"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 112, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.267826, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.72, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
28
+ {"task_id": "af-028-team-reorg-migration-medium-s2", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "medium", "archetype": "operate_configure", "primary_verifier_pattern": "regression_suite", "persona": "platform_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "practitioner", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["report-svc", "export-svc"], "n_requirements": 9, "n_checks": 112, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 2, "req_repairs": 3, "req_recording": 1, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 1}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.27513, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 2.47, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
29
+ {"task_id": "af-029-team-reorg-migration-hard-s1", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "transform_convert", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "terse", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "prometheusrule", "services": ["payments-gw", "fraud-svc", "profile-edge"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 181, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.202898, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 5.48, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
30
+ {"task_id": "af-030-team-reorg-migration-hard-s2", "workflow": "team-reorg-migration", "tier": "hard", "archetype": "transform_convert", "primary_verifier_pattern": "exact_state", "persona": "site_reliability_engineer", "tone": "neutral", "expertise": "expert", "rules_format": "plain", "services": ["media-edge", "identity-svc", "payments-api"], "n_requirements": 14, "n_checks": 189, "req_counts": {"req_alerts": 3, "req_repairs": 5, "req_recording": 2, "req_routing": 2, "req_inhibit": 2}, "oracle_reward": 1.0, "partial_reward": 0.253119, "null_reward": 0.0, "grader_seconds": 9.48, "generator_version": "0.2.0"}
null/afx-e1-s01/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s02/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s03/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s04/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s05/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s06/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s07/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s08/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e1-s09/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s01/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s02/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s03/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s04/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s05/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s06/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s07/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s08/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e2-s09/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s01/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s02/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s03/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s04/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s05/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s06/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s07/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s08/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e3-s09/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s01/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s02/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s03/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s04/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s05/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s06/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s07/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s08/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e4-s09/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s01/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s02/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s03/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s04/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s05/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s06/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s07/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s08/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
null/afx-e5-s09/solve.sh ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+ # null: no-op (equivalent to harbor -a nop)
3
+ exit 0
openenv/alertforge_env/README.md CHANGED
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ tags: [openenv, rl-environment, harbor, prometheus, alertmanager, sre, dense-rew
13
 
14
  # 3amBench / AlertForge: OpenEnv server
15
 
16
- Multi-turn version of the [3amBench Harbor dataset](https://huggingface.co/datasets/<you>/3ambench): the agent edits a Prometheus/Alertmanager
17
  repo with tools, and every step is graded by the same `grade.py` Harbor uses (promtool + amtool replays of hidden
18
  outage scenarios).
19
 
 
13
 
14
  # 3amBench / AlertForge: OpenEnv server
15
 
16
+ Multi-turn version of the [3amBench Harbor dataset](https://huggingface.co/datasets/openenvforge/3ambench): the agent edits a Prometheus/Alertmanager
17
  repo with tools, and every step is graded by the same `grade.py` Harbor uses (promtool + amtool replays of hidden
18
  outage scenarios).
19