Datasets:

piotrwilam
/

AtlasOpenCoder

DOI:

License:

Dataset card Files Files and versions

xet

Community

AtlasOpenCoder / validation /paper1 /C3_YARDSTICK_NATS.json

piotrwilam

AtlasOpenCoder v1: the battery, the artefacts and both papers' manifests

9b7bd53 9 days ago

Raw History Blame Contribute Delete

10.6 kB

{
 "what": "[TBC: 2] Appendix C.3's three-yardstick ablation comparison, in nats over the random sets' mean rather than in control standard deviations",
 "why": "the control's spread is long-tailed at 83.9 B and 2,034 B -- about twice its own mean and still rising with the mask count -- so a control standard deviation has no converged denominator there. Nats over the random mean need no spread.",
 "definition": {
  "rise_over_random_mean": "the loss with the yardstick's carrier set zeroed, minus the mean loss over the size-matched random masks, in nats, at the construct's own positions. Signed.",
  "yardsticks": {
   "v": "code-coordinate",
   "twenty": "20-cell",
   "one": "one pooled cell"
  },
  "paired_difference": "per construct, one yardstick's rise minus another's, then the median over constructs. C.3's pre-registered test is this paired median for code-coordinate minus one cell; the difference of the two medians is a different number and is reported beside it so they cannot be confused.",
  "sign_test": "count above zero over the 16 constructs; one-sided for a yardstick's own effect, two-sided for a paired difference, which has no prior direction",
  "interval": "construct bootstrap, 10000 resamples, 95% percentile, seed 20261024",
  "mask_count": "20 random masks (the only run carrying all three yardsticks); the nats figures do not use the control's spread"
 },
 "fixed_before_computing": true,
 "per_reference": {
  "pretrain_iter_0001000": {
   "tokens_b": 4.19,
   "n_constructs": 16,
   "n_random_masks": 20,
   "constructs": [
    "AsyncFor",
    "AsyncWith",
    "DictComp",
    "For",
    "GeneratorExp",
    "If",
    "IfExp",
    "Import",
    "ImportFrom",
    "Lambda",
    "ListComp",
    "NamedExpr",
    "SetComp",
    "Try",
    "While",
    "With"
   ],
   "per_yardstick": {
    "v": {
     "label": "code-coordinate",
     "median": 0.31736799170659813,
     "ci95": [
      0.25827566369477173,
      0.6373604348241058
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 13,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0106353759765625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 4.792004325303352
    },
    "twenty": {
     "label": "20-cell",
     "median": 0.0804447503073149,
     "ci95": [
      0.041080018227475534,
      0.13615402585038794
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 13,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0106353759765625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 1.0846374640024175
    },
    "one": {
     "label": "one pooled cell",
     "median": 0.2493086871156831,
     "ci95": [
      0.12978681858987862,
      0.4382023281597607
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 15,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0002593994140625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 3.604666612719516
    }
   },
   "paired_differences": {
    "v_minus_one": {
     "label": "code-coordinate minus one pooled cell",
     "median": -0.06087687829562638,
     "ci95": [
      -0.08877719226097502,
      0.09233965513954934
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 7,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.803619384765625
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": 0.06805930459091503,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": -0.550793847251202
    },
    "v_minus_twenty": {
     "label": "code-coordinate minus 20-cell",
     "median": 0.23145569457879844,
     "ci95": [
      0.08746025102947824,
      0.43312744407916615
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.004180908203125
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": 0.23692324139928322,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 4.051964631989781
    },
    "twenty_minus_one": {
     "label": "20-cell minus one pooled cell",
     "median": -0.18362727318849403,
     "ci95": [
      -0.2609247664304384,
      -0.13717200358708737
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 1,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.000518798828125
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": -0.1688639368083682,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": -3.006940604421712
    }
   }
  },
  "pretrain_iter_0020000": {
   "tokens_b": 83.9,
   "n_constructs": 16,
   "n_random_masks": 20,
   "constructs": [
    "AsyncFor",
    "AsyncWith",
    "DictComp",
    "For",
    "GeneratorExp",
    "If",
    "IfExp",
    "Import",
    "ImportFrom",
    "Lambda",
    "ListComp",
    "NamedExpr",
    "SetComp",
    "Try",
    "While",
    "With"
   ],
   "per_yardstick": {
    "v": {
     "label": "code-coordinate",
     "median": 0.41704369298158595,
     "ci95": [
      0.09019889946452353,
      1.0242787754777725
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0020904541015625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 3.528367989492356
    },
    "twenty": {
     "label": "20-cell",
     "median": 0.2708738023878575,
     "ci95": [
      0.04504704123627068,
      0.6859939469300675
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0020904541015625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 3.112056513655431
    },
    "one": {
     "label": "one pooled cell",
     "median": 0.5094131345528695,
     "ci95": [
      0.26161540713880466,
      1.1865427449572508
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0020904541015625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 8.815660962819022
    }
   },
   "paired_differences": {
    "v_minus_one": {
     "label": "code-coordinate minus one pooled cell",
     "median": -0.20651603383966965,
     "ci95": [
      -0.3327571873863544,
      -0.029954622138776976
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 4,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.076812744140625
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": -0.09236944157128357,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": -3.484891080951722
    },
    "v_minus_twenty": {
     "label": "code-coordinate minus 20-cell",
     "median": 0.09404114462853108,
     "ci95": [
      0.027846967535359646,
      0.2468891510596638
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.004180908203125
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": 0.14616989059372842,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 0.7136233166390268
    },
    "twenty_minus_one": {
     "label": "20-cell minus one pooled cell",
     "median": -0.36119617916295654,
     "ci95": [
      -0.4976666747063656,
      -0.10214471277020393
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 3,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.021270751953125
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": -0.238539332165012,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": -6.571049422756383
    }
   }
  },
  "pretrain_iter_0484865": {
   "tokens_b": 2034.0,
   "n_constructs": 16,
   "n_random_masks": 20,
   "constructs": [
    "AsyncFor",
    "AsyncWith",
    "DictComp",
    "For",
    "GeneratorExp",
    "If",
    "IfExp",
    "Import",
    "ImportFrom",
    "Lambda",
    "ListComp",
    "NamedExpr",
    "SetComp",
    "Try",
    "While",
    "With"
   ],
   "per_yardstick": {
    "v": {
     "label": "code-coordinate",
     "median": 0.8719431820510113,
     "ci95": [
      0.570621380886483,
      1.3930869714977843
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 15,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0002593994140625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 7.489065664394015
    },
    "twenty": {
     "label": "20-cell",
     "median": 0.4008911185284054,
     "ci95": [
      0.13539211108134452,
      0.7153082427337092
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0020904541015625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 3.7190927958719113
    },
    "one": {
     "label": "one pooled cell",
     "median": 0.7278566784016687,
     "ci95": [
      0.28435153114027,
      1.1038517673495944
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 14,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.0020904541015625
     },
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 6.751319823606835
    }
   },
   "paired_differences": {
    "v_minus_one": {
     "label": "code-coordinate minus one pooled cell",
     "median": 0.1603320029874642,
     "ci95": [
      -0.04934741405858856,
      0.36600575955386105
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 9,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.803619384765625
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": 0.1440865036493426,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 1.153958151111993
    },
    "v_minus_twenty": {
     "label": "code-coordinate minus 20-cell",
     "median": 0.34183138513412215,
     "ci95": [
      0.004652235980914909,
      0.6233588064592468
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 12,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.076812744140625
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": 0.47105206352260587,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": 1.8621819064581682
    },
    "twenty_minus_one": {
     "label": "20-cell minus one pooled cell",
     "median": -0.19407677253975442,
     "ci95": [
      -0.3487958484494751,
      -0.057863492996264476
     ],
     "sign_test": {
      "n_above_zero": 3,
      "n": 16,
      "p": 0.021270751953125
     },
     "difference_of_medians_nats": -0.32696555987326326,
     "median_control_units_for_reference": -1.936092199893086
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "pre_registered_test": {
  "statistic": "median over constructs of (code-coordinate rise - one-cell rise), paired",
  "in_nats": {
   "pretrain_iter_0001000": {
    "median": -0.06087687829562638,
    "ci95": [
     -0.08877719226097502,
     0.09233965513954934
    ],
    "n_above_zero": 7,
    "n": 16,
    "p": 0.803619384765625
   },
   "pretrain_iter_0020000": {
    "median": -0.20651603383966965,
    "ci95": [
     -0.3327571873863544,
     -0.029954622138776976
    ],
    "n_above_zero": 4,
    "n": 16,
    "p": 0.076812744140625
   },
   "pretrain_iter_0484865": {
    "median": 0.1603320029874642,
    "ci95": [
     -0.04934741405858856,
     0.36600575955386105
    ],
    "n_above_zero": 9,
    "n": 16,
    "p": 0.803619384765625
   }
  },
  "in_control_units_as_C3_stated_it": {
   "pretrain_iter_0001000": -0.550793847251202,
   "pretrain_iter_0020000": -3.484891080951722,
   "pretrain_iter_0484865": 1.153958151111993
  }
 },
 "minutes": 0.0006532986958821614,
 "provenance": {
  "inputs": [
   "validation/paper1/ablation_splits/ABLATION_*.json"
  ],
  "reference": null,
  "battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad",
  "code_commit": "8bcfd04",
  "design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026"
 }
}

	{
	"what": "[TBC: 2] Appendix C.3's three-yardstick ablation comparison, in nats over the random sets' mean rather than in control standard deviations",
	"why": "the control's spread is long-tailed at 83.9 B and 2,034 B -- about twice its own mean and still rising with the mask count -- so a control standard deviation has no converged denominator there. Nats over the random mean need no spread.",
	"definition": {
	"rise_over_random_mean": "the loss with the yardstick's carrier set zeroed, minus the mean loss over the size-matched random masks, in nats, at the construct's own positions. Signed.",
	"yardsticks": {
	"v": "code-coordinate",
	"twenty": "20-cell",
	"one": "one pooled cell"
	},
	"paired_difference": "per construct, one yardstick's rise minus another's, then the median over constructs. C.3's pre-registered test is this paired median for code-coordinate minus one cell; the difference of the two medians is a different number and is reported beside it so they cannot be confused.",
	"sign_test": "count above zero over the 16 constructs; one-sided for a yardstick's own effect, two-sided for a paired difference, which has no prior direction",
	"interval": "construct bootstrap, 10000 resamples, 95% percentile, seed 20261024",
	"mask_count": "20 random masks (the only run carrying all three yardsticks); the nats figures do not use the control's spread"
	},
	"fixed_before_computing": true,
	"per_reference": {
	"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
	"tokens_b": 4.19,
	"n_constructs": 16,
	"n_random_masks": 20,
	"constructs": [
	"AsyncFor",
	"AsyncWith",
	"DictComp",
	"For",
	"GeneratorExp",
	"If",
	"IfExp",
	"Import",
	"ImportFrom",
	"Lambda",
	"ListComp",
	"NamedExpr",
	"SetComp",
	"Try",
	"While",
	"With"
	],
	"per_yardstick": {
	"v": {
	"label": "code-coordinate",
	"median": 0.31736799170659813,
	"ci95": [
	0.25827566369477173,
	0.6373604348241058
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 13,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0106353759765625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 4.792004325303352
	},
	"twenty": {
	"label": "20-cell",
	"median": 0.0804447503073149,
	"ci95": [
	0.041080018227475534,
	0.13615402585038794
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 13,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0106353759765625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 1.0846374640024175
	},
	"one": {
	"label": "one pooled cell",
	"median": 0.2493086871156831,
	"ci95": [
	0.12978681858987862,
	0.4382023281597607
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 15,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0002593994140625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 3.604666612719516
	}
	},
	"paired_differences": {
	"v_minus_one": {
	"label": "code-coordinate minus one pooled cell",
	"median": -0.06087687829562638,
	"ci95": [
	-0.08877719226097502,
	0.09233965513954934
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 7,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.803619384765625
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": 0.06805930459091503,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": -0.550793847251202
	},
	"v_minus_twenty": {
	"label": "code-coordinate minus 20-cell",
	"median": 0.23145569457879844,
	"ci95": [
	0.08746025102947824,
	0.43312744407916615
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.004180908203125
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": 0.23692324139928322,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 4.051964631989781
	},
	"twenty_minus_one": {
	"label": "20-cell minus one pooled cell",
	"median": -0.18362727318849403,
	"ci95": [
	-0.2609247664304384,
	-0.13717200358708737
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 1,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.000518798828125
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": -0.1688639368083682,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": -3.006940604421712
	}
	}
	},
	"pretrain_iter_0020000": {
	"tokens_b": 83.9,
	"n_constructs": 16,
	"n_random_masks": 20,
	"constructs": [
	"AsyncFor",
	"AsyncWith",
	"DictComp",
	"For",
	"GeneratorExp",
	"If",
	"IfExp",
	"Import",
	"ImportFrom",
	"Lambda",
	"ListComp",
	"NamedExpr",
	"SetComp",
	"Try",
	"While",
	"With"
	],
	"per_yardstick": {
	"v": {
	"label": "code-coordinate",
	"median": 0.41704369298158595,
	"ci95": [
	0.09019889946452353,
	1.0242787754777725
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0020904541015625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 3.528367989492356
	},
	"twenty": {
	"label": "20-cell",
	"median": 0.2708738023878575,
	"ci95": [
	0.04504704123627068,
	0.6859939469300675
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0020904541015625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 3.112056513655431
	},
	"one": {
	"label": "one pooled cell",
	"median": 0.5094131345528695,
	"ci95": [
	0.26161540713880466,
	1.1865427449572508
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0020904541015625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 8.815660962819022
	}
	},
	"paired_differences": {
	"v_minus_one": {
	"label": "code-coordinate minus one pooled cell",
	"median": -0.20651603383966965,
	"ci95": [
	-0.3327571873863544,
	-0.029954622138776976
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 4,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.076812744140625
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": -0.09236944157128357,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": -3.484891080951722
	},
	"v_minus_twenty": {
	"label": "code-coordinate minus 20-cell",
	"median": 0.09404114462853108,
	"ci95": [
	0.027846967535359646,
	0.2468891510596638
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.004180908203125
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": 0.14616989059372842,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 0.7136233166390268
	},
	"twenty_minus_one": {
	"label": "20-cell minus one pooled cell",
	"median": -0.36119617916295654,
	"ci95": [
	-0.4976666747063656,
	-0.10214471277020393
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 3,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.021270751953125
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": -0.238539332165012,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": -6.571049422756383
	}
	}
	},
	"pretrain_iter_0484865": {
	"tokens_b": 2034.0,
	"n_constructs": 16,
	"n_random_masks": 20,
	"constructs": [
	"AsyncFor",
	"AsyncWith",
	"DictComp",
	"For",
	"GeneratorExp",
	"If",
	"IfExp",
	"Import",
	"ImportFrom",
	"Lambda",
	"ListComp",
	"NamedExpr",
	"SetComp",
	"Try",
	"While",
	"With"
	],
	"per_yardstick": {
	"v": {
	"label": "code-coordinate",
	"median": 0.8719431820510113,
	"ci95": [
	0.570621380886483,
	1.3930869714977843
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 15,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0002593994140625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 7.489065664394015
	},
	"twenty": {
	"label": "20-cell",
	"median": 0.4008911185284054,
	"ci95": [
	0.13539211108134452,
	0.7153082427337092
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0020904541015625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 3.7190927958719113
	},
	"one": {
	"label": "one pooled cell",
	"median": 0.7278566784016687,
	"ci95": [
	0.28435153114027,
	1.1038517673495944
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 14,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.0020904541015625
	},
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 6.751319823606835
	}
	},
	"paired_differences": {
	"v_minus_one": {
	"label": "code-coordinate minus one pooled cell",
	"median": 0.1603320029874642,
	"ci95": [
	-0.04934741405858856,
	0.36600575955386105
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 9,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.803619384765625
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": 0.1440865036493426,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 1.153958151111993
	},
	"v_minus_twenty": {
	"label": "code-coordinate minus 20-cell",
	"median": 0.34183138513412215,
	"ci95": [
	0.004652235980914909,
	0.6233588064592468
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 12,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.076812744140625
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": 0.47105206352260587,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": 1.8621819064581682
	},
	"twenty_minus_one": {
	"label": "20-cell minus one pooled cell",
	"median": -0.19407677253975442,
	"ci95": [
	-0.3487958484494751,
	-0.057863492996264476
	],
	"sign_test": {
	"n_above_zero": 3,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.021270751953125
	},
	"difference_of_medians_nats": -0.32696555987326326,
	"median_control_units_for_reference": -1.936092199893086
	}
	}
	}
	},
	"pre_registered_test": {
	"statistic": "median over constructs of (code-coordinate rise - one-cell rise), paired",
	"in_nats": {
	"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
	"median": -0.06087687829562638,
	"ci95": [
	-0.08877719226097502,
	0.09233965513954934
	],
	"n_above_zero": 7,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.803619384765625
	},
	"pretrain_iter_0020000": {
	"median": -0.20651603383966965,
	"ci95": [
	-0.3327571873863544,
	-0.029954622138776976
	],
	"n_above_zero": 4,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.076812744140625
	},
	"pretrain_iter_0484865": {
	"median": 0.1603320029874642,
	"ci95": [
	-0.04934741405858856,
	0.36600575955386105
	],
	"n_above_zero": 9,
	"n": 16,
	"p": 0.803619384765625
	}
	},
	"in_control_units_as_C3_stated_it": {
	"pretrain_iter_0001000": -0.550793847251202,
	"pretrain_iter_0020000": -3.484891080951722,
	"pretrain_iter_0484865": 1.153958151111993
	}
	},
	"minutes": 0.0006532986958821614,
	"provenance": {
	"inputs": [
	"validation/paper1/ablation_splits/ABLATION_*.json"
	],
	"reference": null,
	"battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad",
	"code_commit": "8bcfd04",
	"design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026"
	}
	}