AtlasOpenCoder / validation /paper1 /SCOPE_OVERLAP.json
piotrwilam's picture
AtlasOpenCoder v1: the battery, the artefacts and both papers' manifests
9b7bd53
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
65.5 kB
{ "question": "one role, two tokens: the indented `\u2581for` against the module-level `for` (piece id 2461)", "space": "product (24 x 6144), standardised against the C yardstick as stored", "overlap_convention": "primary = |intersection| / K with K = 7,373 (the programme's convention, in which the twin ceiling band is 0.57-0.64); Jaccard beside", "scope_groups": { "module": [ "module" ], "indented": [ "function", "method" ] }, "source": "the record's `hs|` per-scope accumulators, read from the dataset (A50)", "rows": { "pretrain_iter_0484865|For": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 219, "keys_read_A": 888, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1512, "keys_read_B": 1896, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3552 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 501, "keys_read_A": 1512, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888, "keys_read_B": 3552, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1896 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 219, "keys_read_A": 864, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1488, "keys_read_B": 1872, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3384 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 501, "keys_read_A": 1488, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 864, "keys_read_B": 3384, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1872 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8367014783670148, "jaccard": 0.7192491547161012, "n_common": 6169 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8501288485012884, "jaccard": 0.7393253125737203, "n_common": 6268 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.49423572494235724, "jaccard": 0.32822914790127905, "n_common": 3644 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5022378950223789, "jaccard": 0.33532554559449423, "n_common": 3703 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.48650481486504815, "jaccard": 0.32144457388654896, "n_common": 3587 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5014241150142411, "jaccard": 0.33460041632726945, "n_common": 3697 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7789910782494789, "twin2": 0.7835335288535271 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.49263623405906304, "twin1|indented": 0.5054657394252614, "twin2|module": 0.4871980561297838, "twin2|indented": 0.4882926159558409 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.580194719064027, "twin1|indented": 10.973163413781815, "twin2|module": 10.479219868072326, "twin2|indented": 10.985311383537582 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8367014783670148, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.590695412546604, "twin2": 0.6002593613227427, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.5814556654238936, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.5992867563624574 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Assert": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 224, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 960, "keys_read_B": 1296, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2016 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 496, "keys_read_A": 960, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 2016, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1296 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 223, "keys_read_A": 648, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 984, "keys_read_B": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1968 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 497, "keys_read_A": 984, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 648, "keys_read_B": 1968, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1176 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8802387088023871, "jaccard": 0.7860949612403101, "n_common": 6490 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9106198291061983, "jaccard": 0.835906374501992, "n_common": 6714 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5794113657941137, "jaccard": 0.40786709948443767, "n_common": 4272 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5749355757493557, "jaccard": 0.40344532216617496, "n_common": 4239 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5716804557168046, "jaccard": 0.4002468901338904, "n_common": 4215 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5665265156652651, "jaccard": 0.3952124136625982, "n_common": 4177 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7991381783805762, "twin2": 0.8061621087688127 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6194432163936026, "twin1|indented": 0.624371859207884, "twin2|module": 0.6077112205788465, "twin2|indented": 0.6076857125822155 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.764934761924334, "twin1|indented": 10.8728329318008, "twin2|module": 10.775216059781792, "twin2|indented": 10.950504578055211 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8802387088023871, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.6582434514637905, "twin2": 0.6531587057010786, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.6494607087827428, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.6436055469953775 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Delete": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 223, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 936, "keys_read_B": 1104, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2328 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 497, "keys_read_A": 936, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 2328, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1104 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 232, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 984, "keys_read_B": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2184 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 488, "keys_read_A": 984, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 2184, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1176 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8814593788145938, "jaccard": 0.7880441372620347, "n_common": 6499 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9112979791129798, "jaccard": 0.8370499563971596, "n_common": 6719 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5720873457208735, "jaccard": 0.40064589665653494, "n_common": 4218 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5697816356978164, "jaccard": 0.3983878615457563, "n_common": 4201 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5678828156788281, "jaccard": 0.3965337626669192, "n_common": 4187 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5613725756137258, "jaccard": 0.3902140096162911, "n_common": 4139 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7756202347782186, "twin2": 0.7773092497207742 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.7173112813957793, "twin1|indented": 0.7011515746223583, "twin2|module": 0.7403135896281599, "twin2|indented": 0.7022094398186428 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 12.085165826662855, "twin1|indented": 11.30971398593233, "twin2|module": 12.294678535519385, "twin2|indented": 11.395903065488655 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8814593788145938, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.649022926604093, "twin2": 0.6464071395599323, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.6442529619941529, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.6368672103400523 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|If": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 206, "keys_read_A": 888, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1488, "keys_read_B": 1680, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3312 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 514, "keys_read_A": 1488, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888, "keys_read_B": 3312, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1680 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 211, "keys_read_A": 888, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1512, "keys_read_B": 1728, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3264 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 509, "keys_read_A": 1512, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888, "keys_read_B": 3264, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1728 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8661331886613319, "jaccard": 0.7638755980861244, "n_common": 6386 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8910891089108911, "jaccard": 0.8035714285714286, "n_common": 6570 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.48718296487182966, "jaccard": 0.3220369374215528, "n_common": 3592 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.47904516479045167, "jaccard": 0.31496343855894415, "n_common": 3532 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.47687508476875085, "jaccard": 0.31308993766696347, "n_common": 3516 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.46995795469957957, "jaccard": 0.3071536211328783, "n_common": 3465 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7598516828481621, "twin2": 0.7524121527949844 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5241997215727696, "twin1|indented": 0.5283336411589648, "twin2|module": 0.5190828313476089, "twin2|indented": 0.5279320967800187 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.63732311957946, "twin1|indented": 11.050674253478668, "twin2|module": 10.5725272609113, "twin2|indented": 10.990907960995989 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8661331886613319, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.5624804259317256, "twin2": 0.5530848731600376, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.5505793924209207, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.542593172564986 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Import": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 259, "keys_read_A": 648, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1056, "keys_read_B": 1104, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 461, "keys_read_A": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 648, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1104 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 267, "keys_read_A": 696, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1056, "keys_read_B": 1152, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 453, "keys_read_A": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 696, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1152 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8154075681540757, "jaccard": 0.6883444011907488, "n_common": 6012 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8520276685202767, "jaccard": 0.7422022684310019, "n_common": 6282 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.45992133459921336, "jaccard": 0.29863496257155436, "n_common": 3391 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.44147565441475656, "jaccard": 0.2832651640414237, "n_common": 3255 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.43727112437271126, "jaccard": 0.2798125325464329, "n_common": 3224 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.42425064424250647, "jaccard": 0.2692373902564985, "n_common": 3128 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7317717203749083, "twin2": 0.7000024983598336 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5314995255148924, "twin1|indented": 0.4885263072269768, "twin2|module": 0.5344947848957791, "twin2|indented": 0.483440581910673 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.079812329697038, "twin1|indented": 10.946706819018592, "twin2|module": 10.936750968085313, "twin2|indented": 10.913896535784456 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8154075681540757, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.5640385894876914, "twin2": 0.5414171656686627, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.5362608117099136, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.5202927478376581 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|ImportFrom": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 251, "keys_read_A": 720, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1176, "keys_read_B": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1536 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 469, "keys_read_A": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 720, "keys_read_B": 1536, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1056 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 283, "keys_read_A": 696, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1176, "keys_read_B": 1008, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1344 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 437, "keys_read_A": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 696, "keys_read_B": 1344, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1008 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.827749898277499, "jaccard": 0.706120559990744, "n_common": 6103 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8624711786247118, "jaccard": 0.7581972099678074, "n_common": 6359 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.44757900447579, "jaccard": 0.28831032675170365, "n_common": 3300 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.45598806455988067, "jaccard": 0.2953267744202389, "n_common": 3362 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.4344228943442289, "jaccard": 0.2774841895521095, "n_common": 3203 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.43998372439983724, "jaccard": 0.282037906451052, "n_common": 3244 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7079984198304543, "twin2": 0.7193722969141134 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6047506505215346, "twin1|indented": 0.5728919342906499, "twin2|module": 0.6018297908212258, "twin2|indented": 0.5723573784454544 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.913702919685887, "twin1|indented": 10.742621844738114, "twin2|module": 10.924118522514672, "twin2|indented": 10.686936646202616 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.827749898277499, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.540717679829592, "twin2": 0.5508766180566934, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.5248238571194495, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.5315418646567261 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Match": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 292, "keys_read_A": 816, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1440, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2568 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 428, "keys_read_A": 1440, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 816, "keys_read_B": 2568, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 272, "keys_read_A": 792, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1560, "keys_read_B": 1656, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2760 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 448, "keys_read_A": 1560, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 792, "keys_read_B": 2760, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1656 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8235453682354537, "jaccard": 0.7000230574129582, "n_common": 6072 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8573172385731724, "jaccard": 0.7502670623145401, "n_common": 6321 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36199647361996473, "jaccard": 0.22099859236565372, "n_common": 2669 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.37379628373796286, "jaccard": 0.2298582151793161, "n_common": 2756 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.35345178353451784, "jaccard": 0.21466227347611203, "n_common": 2606 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36240336362403364, "jaccard": 0.22130197117773728, "n_common": 2672 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.5237786001851661, "twin2": 0.5517561866133035 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.604736076147773, "twin1|indented": 0.5773317715512506, "twin2|module": 0.6022265316250777, "twin2|indented": 0.577153958489291 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.261030143231409, "twin1|indented": 11.045206612760216, "twin2|module": 11.20456946984615, "twin2|indented": 11.005863816680879 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8235453682354537, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.4395586297760211, "twin2": 0.45388669301712786, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.4291831357048749, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.44005270092226617 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Pass": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 235, "keys_read_A": 408, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1800 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 485, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 408, "keys_read_B": 1800, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1056 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 255, "keys_read_A": 552, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 1128, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1752 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 465, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 552, "keys_read_B": 1752, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1128 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8128305981283059, "jaccard": 0.6846795384439621, "n_common": 5993 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.850400108504001, "jaccard": 0.739735724398301, "n_common": 6270 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36660789366607893, "jaccard": 0.2244457361122644, "n_common": 2703 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36172521361725213, "jaccard": 0.22079642354499546, "n_common": 2667 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.35006103350061035, "jaccard": 0.2121660501438553, "n_common": 2581 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.35833446358334464, "jaccard": 0.21827495042961004, "n_common": 2642 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.5118599175683294, "twin2": 0.4823998438142107 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6566721077150748, "twin1|indented": 0.6783524296433262, "twin2|module": 0.6593787033033601, "twin2|indented": 0.6861196163272973 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.687988807541995, "twin1|indented": 11.316053530157436, "twin2|module": 11.725397446498638, "twin2|indented": 11.383489526900533 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8128305981283059, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.4510261972301018, "twin2": 0.4450191890538962, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.43066911396629404, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.44084765559819794 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Raise": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 231, "keys_read_A": 768, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1176, "keys_read_B": 1104, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1920 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 489, "keys_read_A": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 768, "keys_read_B": 1920, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1104 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 224, "keys_read_A": 840, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1224, "keys_read_B": 1224, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1872 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 496, "keys_read_A": 1224, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 840, "keys_read_B": 1872, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1224 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8786111487861115, "jaccard": 0.7835026608611514, "n_common": 6478 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9028889190288892, "jaccard": 0.8229694647051552, "n_common": 6657 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.43523667435236674, "jaccard": 0.2781485654849614, "n_common": 3209 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.43035399430353993, "jaccard": 0.2741726432212909, "n_common": 3173 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.42316560423165606, "jaccard": 0.26836401169791846, "n_common": 3120 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.43333785433337857, "jaccard": 0.27659942862089865, "n_common": 3195 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.6206984223497541, "twin2": 0.6143480949477259 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6497560566382261, "twin1|indented": 0.6664057244738324, "twin2|module": 0.6463524991843819, "twin2|indented": 0.6686320597624875 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.611621528076384, "twin1|indented": 11.062406227207438, "twin2|module": 10.629809483504488, "twin2|indented": 11.199002324907934 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8786111487861115, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.49536894103118245, "twin2": 0.4898116702686014, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.4816301327570238, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.49320778017906763 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|Try": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 234, "keys_read_A": 816, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1392, "keys_read_B": 1536, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2616 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 486, "keys_read_A": 1392, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 816, "keys_read_B": 2616, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1536 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 218, "keys_read_A": 744, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1320, "keys_read_B": 1440, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2544 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 502, "keys_read_A": 1320, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 744, "keys_read_B": 2544, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1440 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9051946290519463, "jaccard": 0.826808721506442, "n_common": 6674 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9207920792079208, "jaccard": 0.8532110091743119, "n_common": 6789 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6394954563949545, "jaccard": 0.4700428671119529, "n_common": 4715 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6329852163298522, "jaccard": 0.46304196844925094, "n_common": 4667 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6298657262986572, "jaccard": 0.45971094832706394, "n_common": 4644 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6302726163027261, "jaccard": 0.4601445687691851, "n_common": 4647 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.8678021550513708, "twin2": 0.8610665292482577 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6675254438106751, "twin1|indented": 0.6969912161819668, "twin2|module": 0.6632215276968201, "twin2|indented": 0.6928352704072607 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.845948831033278, "twin1|indented": 12.082910031422605, "twin2|module": 11.846853185096652, "twin2|indented": 12.017044977294514 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.9051946290519463, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.7064728798321845, "twin2": 0.6992807911297573, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.6958345819598442, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.6962840875037458 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|While": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 222, "keys_read_A": 792, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1200, "keys_read_B": 1464, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2760 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 498, "keys_read_A": 1200, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 792, "keys_read_B": 2760, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1464 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 227, "keys_read_A": 696, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1296, "keys_read_B": 1464, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2592 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 493, "keys_read_A": 1296, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 696, "keys_read_B": 2592, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1464 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9085853790858538, "jaccard": 0.8324841555859327, "n_common": 6699 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9233690492336905, "jaccard": 0.8576467624086672, "n_common": 6808 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6218635562186355, "jaccard": 0.45123511465406946, "n_common": 4585 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6127763461277634, "jaccard": 0.44172858818928434, "n_common": 4518 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6169808761698088, "jaccard": 0.44611160145140727, "n_common": 4549 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.6068086260680863, "jaccard": 0.43555295950155765, "n_common": 4474 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.871157031031843, "twin2": 0.8697690704694778 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6431264394502421, "twin1|indented": 0.6628078792772994, "twin2|module": 0.6457535224526888, "twin2|indented": 0.6580951829557005 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.863286862660713, "twin1|indented": 10.930678495696911, "twin2|module": 10.811608714763853, "twin2|indented": 10.87532223925902 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.9085853790858538, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.6844305120167189, "twin2": 0.6744290192566055, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.6790565756082998, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.6678608747574265 } }, "pretrain_iter_0484865|With": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 228, "keys_read_A": 792, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1440, "keys_read_B": 1632, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2976 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 492, "keys_read_A": 1440, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 792, "keys_read_B": 2976, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1632 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 230, "keys_read_A": 768, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1368, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2952 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 490, "keys_read_A": 1368, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 768, "keys_read_B": 2952, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8971924589719246, "jaccard": 0.8135530685032591, "n_common": 6615 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9191645191916452, "jaccard": 0.850420378968503, "n_common": 6777 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5590668655906686, "jaccard": 0.3879894578313253, "n_common": 4122 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5724942357249424, "jaccard": 0.4010451306413302, "n_common": 4221 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5551335955513359, "jaccard": 0.3842110203698489, "n_common": 4093 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.566933405669334, "jaccard": 0.39560855574484194, "n_common": 4180 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.8097736563862076, "twin2": 0.8168187143853567 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6000844644079387, "twin1|indented": 0.6372377936314773, "twin2|module": 0.5914900720982249, "twin2|indented": 0.6232903131091304 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.969433806302906, "twin1|indented": 11.110609388329868, "twin2|module": 11.06769649386643, "twin2|indented": 11.105893200602852 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8971924589719246, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.6231292517006802, "twin2": 0.6380952380952382, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.618745275888133, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.6318972033257747 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|For": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 219, "keys_read_A": 888, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1512, "keys_read_B": 1896, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3552 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 501, "keys_read_A": 1512, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888, "keys_read_B": 3552, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1896 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 219, "keys_read_A": 864, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1488, "keys_read_B": 1872, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3384 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 501, "keys_read_A": 1488, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 864, "keys_read_B": 3384, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1872 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.883358198833582, "jaccard": 0.7910846592979472, "n_common": 6513 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8944798589447986, "jaccard": 0.8091031775242301, "n_common": 6595 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.38532483385324834, "jaccard": 0.2386392272154557, "n_common": 2841 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.37284687372846875, "jaccard": 0.22914061848795533, "n_common": 2749 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3788145937881459, "jaccard": 0.23366518865556765, "n_common": 2793 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.37623762376237624, "jaccard": 0.23170731707317074, "n_common": 2774 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.6447565780937478, "twin2": 0.644951223885097 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.4538366177006248, "twin1|indented": 0.48475584479730705, "twin2|module": 0.45001163102375463, "twin2|indented": 0.4821183596384465 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.048047876534698, "twin1|indented": 12.138915178894434, "twin2|module": 10.989904699421535, "twin2|indented": 12.22699630257363 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.883358198833582, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.43620451404882543, "twin2": 0.42207891908490713, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.4288346384154767, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.4259173959772762 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Assert": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 224, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 960, "keys_read_B": 1296, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2016 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 496, "keys_read_A": 960, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 2016, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1296 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 223, "keys_read_A": 648, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 984, "keys_read_B": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1968 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 497, "keys_read_A": 984, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 648, "keys_read_B": 1968, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1176 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8813237488132375, "jaccard": 0.787827352085354, "n_common": 6498 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9042452190424521, "jaccard": 0.8252258942938483, "n_common": 6667 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.4296758442967584, "jaccard": 0.2736223872862325, "n_common": 3168 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.4200461142004611, "jaccard": 0.2658597304489656, "n_common": 3097 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.42343686423436866, "jaccard": 0.26858224363386096, "n_common": 3122 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.42126678421266783, "jaccard": 0.2668384879725086, "n_common": 3106 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.6088554265730068, "twin2": 0.5966918137163499 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5548910927100358, "twin1|indented": 0.5662564757449368, "twin2|module": 0.5554268820401863, "twin2|indented": 0.5641766230522147 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.427298775163756, "twin1|indented": 12.141103321852729, "twin2|module": 11.42183346478922, "twin2|indented": 12.164750257186284 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8813237488132375, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.4875346260387811, "twin2": 0.47660818713450287, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.48045552477685444, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.47799322868574945 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Delete": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 223, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 936, "keys_read_B": 1104, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2328 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 497, "keys_read_A": 936, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 2328, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1104 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 232, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 984, "keys_read_B": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2184 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 488, "keys_read_A": 984, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 2184, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1176 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9075003390750034, "jaccard": 0.8306641837368094, "n_common": 6691 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9081784890817849, "jaccard": 0.8318012422360248, "n_common": 6696 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3615895836158958, "jaccard": 0.2206953642384106, "n_common": 2666 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36864234368642346, "jaccard": 0.22597273029597606, "n_common": 2718 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36660789366607893, "jaccard": 0.2244457361122644, "n_common": 2703 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.35982639359826396, "jaccard": 0.21938311419829654, "n_common": 2653 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.47006617579545634, "twin2": 0.4879277535422973 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5985648615324984, "twin1|indented": 0.6280567273538284, "twin2|module": 0.5984185103859484, "twin2|indented": 0.6314531602196679 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.790463110885078, "twin1|indented": 12.07171809164211, "twin2|module": 10.815918003615922, "twin2|indented": 12.134459553062113 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.9075003390750034, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.3984456732924824, "twin2": 0.4062173068300703, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.4039754894634584, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.3965027649080855 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|If": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 206, "keys_read_A": 888, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1488, "keys_read_B": 1680, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3312 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 514, "keys_read_A": 1488, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888, "keys_read_B": 3312, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1680 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 211, "keys_read_A": 888, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1512, "keys_read_B": 1728, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3264 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 509, "keys_read_A": 1512, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888, "keys_read_B": 3264, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1728 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8860707988607079, "jaccard": 0.7954462437598928, "n_common": 6533 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9161806591618066, "jaccard": 0.8453259917407083, "n_common": 6755 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.38206971382069715, "jaccard": 0.23614720429206137, "n_common": 2817 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.35467245354672455, "jaccard": 0.21556343252823346, "n_common": 2615 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.38464668384646683, "jaccard": 0.23811922753988246, "n_common": 2836 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3466702834667028, "jaccard": 0.20968006562756358, "n_common": 2556 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.6147893938600566, "twin2": 0.5773852098832354 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.4736846205945193, "twin1|indented": 0.5071178123730137, "twin2|module": 0.47142642470440765, "twin2|indented": 0.506214061923838 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.928461998480428, "twin1|indented": 12.116677949696854, "twin2|module": 10.833272533698452, "twin2|indented": 12.116482009693826 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8860707988607079, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.4311954691565897, "twin2": 0.400275524261442, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.4341037808051431, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.3912444512475126 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Import": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 259, "keys_read_A": 648, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1056, "keys_read_B": 1104, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 461, "keys_read_A": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 648, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1104 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 267, "keys_read_A": 696, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1056, "keys_read_B": 1152, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 453, "keys_read_A": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 696, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1152 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8805099688050997, "jaccard": 0.786527744124061, "n_common": 6492 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8455174284551743, "jaccard": 0.7323778195488722, "n_common": 6234 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.21280347212803472, "jaccard": 0.11907110875009486, "n_common": 1569 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.19910484199104841, "jaccard": 0.11055881909926193, "n_common": 1468 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2076495320764953, "jaccard": 0.11585319712447975, "n_common": 1531 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.193950901939509, "jaccard": 0.10738960648843497, "n_common": 1430 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.38636395922758476, "twin2": 0.3604249747104094 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.4247319962272667, "twin1|indented": 0.5158134610117019, "twin2|module": 0.42483167918873416, "twin2|indented": 0.5046066536671432 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.463188470399803, "twin1|indented": 11.958855693968829, "twin2|module": 10.42088023153593, "twin2|indented": 11.915887899071587 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8455174284551743, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.25168431183830603, "twin2": 0.2354828360603144, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.24558870709015077, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.2293872313121591 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|ImportFrom": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 251, "keys_read_A": 720, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1176, "keys_read_B": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1536 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 469, "keys_read_A": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 720, "keys_read_B": 1536, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1056 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 283, "keys_read_A": 696, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1176, "keys_read_B": 1008, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1344 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 437, "keys_read_A": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 696, "keys_read_B": 1344, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1008 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8839007188390072, "jaccard": 0.7919552801069388, "n_common": 6517 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8615217686152177, "jaccard": 0.756730998332142, "n_common": 6352 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2979791129797911, "jaccard": 0.17507371105267353, "n_common": 2197 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.30353994303539944, "jaccard": 0.17892548768787975, "n_common": 2238 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2962159229621592, "jaccard": 0.17385766597675528, "n_common": 2184 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2971653329716533, "jaccard": 0.17451214655515732, "n_common": 2191 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.42933099972495725, "twin2": 0.43988171106145035 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5291730806639433, "twin1|indented": 0.5959897475430017, "twin2|module": 0.5310040724411432, "twin2|indented": 0.5986377314381219 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.606412522641039, "twin1|indented": 12.251224914957058, "twin2|module": 10.587703334924967, "twin2|indented": 12.189199601672236 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8615217686152177, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.34587531486146095, "twin2": 0.35232997481108314, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.3438287153652393, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.3449307304785894 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Match": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 292, "keys_read_A": 816, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1440, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2568 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 428, "keys_read_A": 1440, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 816, "keys_read_B": 2568, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 272, "keys_read_A": 792, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1560, "keys_read_B": 1656, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2760 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 448, "keys_read_A": 1560, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 792, "keys_read_B": 2760, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1656 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8419910484199105, "jaccard": 0.727102365893652, "n_common": 6208 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.884714498847145, "jaccard": 0.7932627994649155, "n_common": 6523 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2606808626068086, "jaccard": 0.1498752339363693, "n_common": 1922 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.28048284280482844, "jaccard": 0.16311721091654835, "n_common": 2068 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2647497626474976, "jaccard": 0.15257151789901516, "n_common": 1952 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.2686830326868303, "jaccard": 0.15518997258127692, "n_common": 1981 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.4153840018226051, "twin2": 0.4361144735707798 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.4848306856062311, "twin1|indented": 0.5474037560419177, "twin2|module": 0.48757816756955147, "twin2|indented": 0.5417412827608085 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.387295091620027, "twin1|indented": 12.980231658364728, "twin2|module": 11.409381995202494, "twin2|indented": 12.813321290137793 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8419910484199105, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.30960051546391754, "twin2": 0.33311855670103097, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.31443298969072164, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.31910438144329895 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Pass": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 235, "keys_read_A": 408, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 1056, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1800 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 485, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 408, "keys_read_B": 1800, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1056 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 255, "keys_read_A": 552, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 672, "keys_read_B": 1128, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1752 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 465, "keys_read_A": 672, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 552, "keys_read_B": 1752, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1128 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8429404584294046, "jaccard": 0.7285195170554448, "n_common": 6215 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8555540485555405, "jaccard": 0.747570514339891, "n_common": 6308 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.36633663366336633, "jaccard": 0.22424242424242424, "n_common": 2701 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3614539536145395, "jaccard": 0.22059432166211407, "n_common": 2665 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.35385867353858674, "jaccard": 0.214962511328994, "n_common": 2609 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3613183236131832, "jaccard": 0.22049329581195165, "n_common": 2664 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.45534509006596546, "twin2": 0.43754291349135394 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.6278089245149941, "twin1|indented": 0.6603596906221568, "twin2|module": 0.6301643234666872, "twin2|indented": 0.6632557853596468 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.423092293974463, "twin1|indented": 12.956898334833719, "twin2|module": 11.436185297756538, "twin2|indented": 12.849509610510383 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8429404584294046, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.4345937248592116, "twin2": 0.42880128720836685, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.4197908286403862, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.42864038616251005 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Raise": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 231, "keys_read_A": 768, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1176, "keys_read_B": 1104, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1920 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 489, "keys_read_A": 1176, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 768, "keys_read_B": 1920, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1104 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 224, "keys_read_A": 840, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1224, "keys_read_B": 1224, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1872 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 496, "keys_read_A": 1224, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 840, "keys_read_B": 1872, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1224 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.8756272887562729, "jaccard": 0.7787696019300362, "n_common": 6456 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.902346399023464, "jaccard": 0.822068454219696, "n_common": 6653 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.34951851349518515, "jaccard": 0.2117676062125072, "n_common": 2577 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.33541299335412994, "jaccard": 0.2014992259431272, "n_common": 2473 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.34151634341516346, "jaccard": 0.20592083742230946, "n_common": 2518 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.33961752339617524, "jaccard": 0.2045417415454991, "n_common": 2504 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.4622857708358416, "twin2": 0.4525028618022961 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5620399827530682, "twin1|indented": 0.6027758360804942, "twin2|module": 0.5608977670624172, "twin2|indented": 0.5997008973068305 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.932158508077997, "twin1|indented": 12.273826026502052, "twin2|module": 10.910683158671302, "twin2|indented": 12.320449985974872 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.8756272887562729, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.39916356877323417, "twin2": 0.3830545229244114, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.39002478314745975, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.38785625774473353 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|Try": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 234, "keys_read_A": 816, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1392, "keys_read_B": 1536, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2616 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 486, "keys_read_A": 1392, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 816, "keys_read_B": 2616, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1536 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 218, "keys_read_A": 744, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1320, "keys_read_B": 1440, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2544 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 502, "keys_read_A": 1320, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 744, "keys_read_B": 2544, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1440 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.909127899091279, "jaccard": 0.8333954991918439, "n_common": 6703 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9211989692119897, "jaccard": 0.853909982398793, "n_common": 6792 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.37189746371897464, "jaccard": 0.22842385871376208, "n_common": 2742 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3788145937881459, "jaccard": 0.23366518865556765, "n_common": 2793 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.3752882137528821, "jaccard": 0.23098756156607397, "n_common": 2767 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.37094805370948053, "jaccard": 0.22770793439347264, "n_common": 2735 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.5153547791182302, "twin2": 0.5314401638933871 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5595780690766173, "twin1|indented": 0.6053306704018194, "twin2|module": 0.560446523373435, "twin2|indented": 0.6043124949231101 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.244799008662968, "twin1|indented": 12.517025411789634, "twin2|module": 11.296134408383919, "twin2|indented": 12.548186838577049 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.909127899091279, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.40907056541846937, "twin2": 0.41667909891093535, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.41280023869908994, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.4080262568998956 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|While": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 222, "keys_read_A": 792, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1200, "keys_read_B": 1464, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2760 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 498, "keys_read_A": 1200, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 792, "keys_read_B": 2760, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1464 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 227, "keys_read_A": 696, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1296, "keys_read_B": 1464, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2592 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 493, "keys_read_A": 1296, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 696, "keys_read_B": 2592, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1464 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9072290790722908, "jaccard": 0.8302097554921186, "n_common": 6689 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9331344093313441, "jaccard": 0.874650394101195, "n_common": 6880 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5016953750169537, "jaccard": 0.33484203856250566, "n_common": 3699 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5023735250237352, "jaccard": 0.33544647708748415, "n_common": 3704 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.5019666350196663, "jaccard": 0.3350837483023993, "n_common": 3701 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.49830462498304623, "jaccard": 0.33182803468208094, "n_common": 3674 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.7287131766756595, "twin2": 0.7240647486891474 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5211520219778905, "twin1|indented": 0.5497564607896354, "twin2|module": 0.5240914150285622, "twin2|indented": 0.5451050253333309 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 11.498973569470488, "twin1|indented": 11.94131792458267, "twin2|module": 11.46246346124288, "twin2|indented": 11.907355692016468 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.9072290790722908, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.5529974585139782, "twin2": 0.5537449544027507, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.5532964568694871, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.5492599790701151 } }, "pretrain_iter_0001000|With": { "n_prompts_and_keys": { "twin1|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 228, "keys_read_A": 792, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1440, "keys_read_B": 1632, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2976 }, "twin1|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 492, "keys_read_A": 1440, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 792, "keys_read_B": 2976, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1632 }, "twin2|module": { "prompts_A": 240, "prompts_B": 230, "keys_read_A": 768, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1368, "keys_read_B": 1608, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 2952 }, "twin2|indented": { "prompts_A": 480, "prompts_B": 490, "keys_read_A": 1368, "keys_refused_other_scope_A": 768, "keys_read_B": 2952, "keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1608 } }, "ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": { "module": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.91862199918622, "jaccard": 0.8494920356202182, "n_common": 6773 }, "indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.9235046792350468, "jaccard": 0.8578808113896939, "n_common": 6809 } }, "between_scope_within_twin": { "twin1": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.34897599348975994, "jaccard": 0.2113694241353816, "n_common": 2573 }, "twin2": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.34463583344635834, "jaccard": 0.2081933633756657, "n_common": 2541 } }, "between_scope_cross_twin": { "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.347212803472128, "jaccard": 0.21007713769899886, "n_common": 2560 }, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": { "overlap_share_of_K": 0.34422894344228944, "jaccard": 0.20789646133682832, "n_common": 2538 } }, "cosine_between_scopes": { "twin1": 0.5358564256389813, "twin2": 0.5331723394383544 }, "sparsity": { "twin1|module": 0.5173322144741307, "twin1|indented": 0.5560069845687248, "twin2|module": 0.515160978560194, "twin2|indented": 0.5499067409963388 }, "centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": { "twin1|module": 10.927160410808343, "twin1|indented": 12.465324365288694, "twin2|module": 10.914641043138706, "twin2|indented": 12.469420647531651 }, "ceiling_used_is_the_lower_of_the_two": 0.91862199918622, "share_of_ceiling": { "twin1": 0.3798907426546582, "twin2": 0.3751661006939318, "twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": 0.37797135685811306, "twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": 0.3747231655101137 } } }, "skipped": {}, "reconstruction_check": { "pretrain_iter_0484865": { "construct": "For", "twin": "twin1", "max_abs_difference": 0.00067778694265197, "max_abs_value": 3.4610732905566692, "relative": 0.00019583143312835096, "tolerance_relative": 0.002, "tolerance_is": "the float16 resolution of the stored means, not an arbitrary cut", "verdict": "reproduced" }, "pretrain_iter_0001000": { "construct": "For", "twin": "twin1", "max_abs_difference": 0.0004962170605993244, "max_abs_value": 3.0779873674036935, "relative": 0.00016121478140369605, "tolerance_relative": 0.002, "tolerance_is": "the float16 resolution of the stored means, not an arbitrary cut", "verdict": "reproduced" } }, "acceptance": { "n_per_scope": "240 module and 480 indented A prompts at every construct and reference, as the design states; B is 206-292 module and 428-514 indented, since B's prompts are drawn per subtype", "module_profile_from_module_cells_only": "every accumulator read is checked for its scope key and keys of other scopes are counted as refused (keys_refused_other_scope_*)", "ceiling_band": "the design asks for 0.57-0.64. That band is the PILOT's, as the draft's own Section 4 says ('for `for` at layer 22 on the pilot'). The battery's own band for `For` in the product space is 0.8717-0.9060 over the 35 trained pretraining references (0.2934 untrained), and B3 reports 0.8717 at 0484865 from the derived tree. B4's per-scope ceilings, 0.8367 module and 0.8501 indented, sit just below the whole-construct value, which is what a third and two thirds of the prompts should give. The two routes were checked against each other: the unscoped `h|` accumulator route gives ceiling 0.8717 and sparsity 0.5054 for `For` at 0484865, the derived tree gives 0.8717 and 0.5054." }, "provenance": { "inputs": [ "record/pretrain_iter_0484865/twin{1,2}__{c}_{A,B}_acc.npz", "record/pretrain_iter_0001000/twin{1,2}__{c}_{A,B}_acc.npz" ], "reference": "pretrain_iter_0484865", "battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad", "code_commit": "c9fa313", "design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026" } }
{
"question": "one role, two tokens: the indented `\u2581for` against the module-level `for` (piece id 2461)",
"space": "product (24 x 6144), standardised against the C yardstick as stored",
"overlap_convention": "primary = |intersection| / K with K = 7,373 (the programme's convention, in which the twin ceiling band is 0.57-0.64); Jaccard beside",
"scope_groups": {
"module": [
"module"
],
"indented": [
"function",
"method"
]
},
"source": "the record's `hs|` per-scope accumulators, read from the dataset (A50)",
"rows": {
"pretrain_iter_0484865|For": {
"n_prompts_and_keys": {
"twin1|module": {
"prompts_A": 240,
"prompts_B": 219,
"keys_read_A": 888,
"keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1512,
"keys_read_B": 1896,
"keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3552
},
"twin1|indented": {
"prompts_A": 480,
"prompts_B": 501,
"keys_read_A": 1512,
"keys_refused_other_scope_A": 888,
"keys_read_B": 3552,
"keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1896
},
"twin2|module": {
"prompts_A": 240,
"prompts_B": 219,
"keys_read_A": 864,
"keys_refused_other_scope_A": 1488,
"keys_read_B": 1872,
"keys_refused_other_scope_B": 3384
},
"twin2|indented": {
"prompts_A": 480,
"prompts_B": 501,
"keys_read_A": 1488,
"keys_refused_other_scope_A": 864,
"keys_read_B": 3384,
"keys_refused_other_scope_B": 1872
}
},
"ceiling_within_scope_across_twins": {
"module": {
"overlap_share_of_K": 0.8367014783670148,
"jaccard": 0.7192491547161012,
"n_common": 6169
},
"indented": {
"overlap_share_of_K": 0.8501288485012884,
"jaccard": 0.7393253125737203,
"n_common": 6268
}
},
"between_scope_within_twin": {
"twin1": {
"overlap_share_of_K": 0.49423572494235724,
"jaccard": 0.32822914790127905,
"n_common": 3644
},
"twin2": {
"overlap_share_of_K": 0.5022378950223789,
"jaccard": 0.33532554559449423,
"n_common": 3703
}
},
"between_scope_cross_twin": {
"twin1_module_vs_twin2_indented": {
"overlap_share_of_K": 0.48650481486504815,
"jaccard": 0.32144457388654896,
"n_common": 3587
},
"twin2_module_vs_twin1_indented": {
"overlap_share_of_K": 0.5014241150142411,
"jaccard": 0.33460041632726945,
"n_common": 3697
}
},
"cosine_between_scopes": {
"twin1": 0.7789910782494789,
"twin2": 0.7835335288535271
},
"sparsity": {
"twin1|module": 0.49263623405906304,
"twin1|indented": 0.5054657394252614,
"twin2|module": 0.4871980561297838,
"twin2|indented": 0.4882926159558409
},
"centre_of_mass_layers_1_22": {
"twin1|module": 10.580194719064027,
"twin1|indented": 10.973163413781815,
"twin2|module": 10.479219868072326,