Datasets:
DOI:
License:
{
"what": "A1.1b: the ablation read as a rank among the control masks",
"why": "the control is long-tailed at 83.9 B and 2,034 B -- SD ~2.2x its own mean and still rising at 200 masks -- so a control unit has no converged denominator there. A rank has none to converge.",
"definition": {
"rank_from_top": "1 + the number of random masks whose loss rise is at or above the carrier set's",
"exact_one_sided_p": "(1 + #{random >= carrier}) / (1 + n_masks)",
"floor": "the smallest p an n-mask control allows is 1/(n+1); at n = 320 that is 0.00312, just under Holm's first threshold of 0.05/16 = 0.003125, which is why 320 and not 200 were drawn",
"holm": "Holm-Bonferroni at alpha = 0.05 across the 16 constructs, separately at each reference",
"old_set": "the same rank for the 84 B carrier set removed at the end, against the SAME masks",
"mask_check": "the mean and SD recomputed from the FIRST 200 per-mask values are compared with the 23 Oct run's stored figures to within 1e-06; a mismatch means different masks and stops the read"
},
"fixed_before_computing": true,
"baseline_prefix": 200,
"mask_check": {
"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
"n_constructs_checked_against_23_oct": 16,
"n_constructs": 16
},
"pretrain_iter_0020000": {
"n_constructs_checked_against_23_oct": 16,
"n_constructs": 16
},
"pretrain_iter_0484865": {
"n_constructs_checked_against_23_oct": 16,
"n_constructs": 16
}
},
"per_reference": {
"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
"tokens_b": 4.19,
"n_constructs": 16,
"n_masks": 320,
"floor_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"holm_first_threshold": 0.003125,
"floor_can_clear_holm": true,
"n_exceeding_every_mask": 2,
"constructs_exceeding_every_mask": [
"Lambda",
"Try"
],
"n_holm_significant": 2,
"constructs_holm_significant": [
"Lambda",
"Try"
],
"median_rank_from_top": 63.5,
"n_p_below_0.05_uncorrected": 3,
"old_set": null,
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.1417616092162448,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.07012812873128527,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07163348048495954,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 59,
"n_random_below": 261,
"rank_from_top": 60,
"share_below": 0.815625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.18691588785046728,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.20135072762003325,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.1391150025534445,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06223572506658877,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 40,
"n_random_below": 280,
"rank_from_top": 41,
"share_below": 0.875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.1277258566978193,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"DictComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.10147391727992527,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.050006443547959536,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05146747373196574,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 51,
"n_random_below": 269,
"rank_from_top": 52,
"share_below": 0.840625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.16199376947040497,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"For": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.18285812355942976,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.0949608547221171,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08789726883731266,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 5,
"n_random_below": 315,
"rank_from_top": 6,
"share_below": 0.984375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.018691588785046728,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"GeneratorExp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.15341256596715258,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.07657122607461066,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07684133989254192,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 46,
"n_random_below": 274,
"rank_from_top": 47,
"share_below": 0.85625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.14641744548286603,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"If": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.007977972562978164,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.04470708500032912,
"control_mean_nats": 0.036729112437350955,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 242,
"n_random_below": 78,
"rank_from_top": 243,
"share_below": 0.24375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.7570093457943925,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"IfExp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.1362532886366048,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.05776264846402532,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07849064017257948,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 95,
"n_random_below": 225,
"rank_from_top": 96,
"share_below": 0.703125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.29906542056074764,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Import": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.27605540935809714,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.20250309682809323,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07355231253000391,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 79,
"n_random_below": 241,
"rank_from_top": 80,
"share_below": 0.753125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.24922118380062305,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"ImportFrom": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.12070604471059987,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.009377542825845839,
"control_mean_nats": -0.11132850188475403,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 168,
"n_random_below": 152,
"rank_from_top": 169,
"share_below": 0.475,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.5264797507788161,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Lambda": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.7078969826300936,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.6330618923355357,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07483509029455793,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"ListComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.1092176328455734,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.026037895380694343,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08317973746487906,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 90,
"n_random_below": 230,
"rank_from_top": 91,
"share_below": 0.71875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.2834890965732087,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"NamedExpr": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.06559552901830479,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.1530518639355142,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08745633491720942,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 261,
"n_random_below": 59,
"rank_from_top": 262,
"share_below": 0.184375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.8161993769470405,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"SetComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.11136166093313093,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.04279677342566719,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06856488750746374,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 66,
"n_random_below": 254,
"rank_from_top": 67,
"share_below": 0.79375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.2087227414330218,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Try": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 1.3229805639758707,
"rise_over_random_nats": 1.2464003089046862,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07658025507118438,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"While": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.014500070499991025,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.03628052254800188,
"control_mean_nats": 0.021780452048010858,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 233,
"n_random_below": 87,
"rank_from_top": 234,
"share_below": 0.271875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.7289719626168224,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"With": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.28541309173618057,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.1778578936820847,
"control_mean_nats": 0.10755519805409586,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 17,
"n_random_below": 303,
"rank_from_top": 18,
"share_below": 0.946875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.056074766355140186,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
}
}
},
"pretrain_iter_0020000": {
"tokens_b": 83.9,
"n_constructs": 16,
"n_masks": 320,
"floor_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"holm_first_threshold": 0.003125,
"floor_can_clear_holm": true,
"n_exceeding_every_mask": 8,
"constructs_exceeding_every_mask": [
"DictComp",
"GeneratorExp",
"IfExp",
"Lambda",
"ListComp",
"NamedExpr",
"SetComp",
"Try"
],
"n_holm_significant": 8,
"constructs_holm_significant": [
"DictComp",
"GeneratorExp",
"IfExp",
"Lambda",
"ListComp",
"NamedExpr",
"SetComp",
"Try"
],
"median_rank_from_top": 9.5,
"n_p_below_0.05_uncorrected": 8,
"old_set": {
"n_constructs": 16,
"n_exceeding_every_mask": 1,
"constructs_exceeding_every_mask": [
"Try"
],
"n_holm_significant": 1,
"median_rank_from_top": 117.5,
"n_p_below_0.05_uncorrected": 4
},
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.03523392910916123,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.03348632161364622,
"control_mean_nats": 0.0017476074955150168,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 76,
"n_random_below": 244,
"rank_from_top": 77,
"share_below": 0.7625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.2398753894080997,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.09800286217450394,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 301,
"n_random_below": 19,
"rank_from_top": 302,
"share_below": 0.059375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.940809968847352,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.0490670496454606,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.030745030828648746,
"control_mean_nats": 0.018322018816811857,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 97,
"n_random_below": 223,
"rank_from_top": 98,
"share_below": 0.696875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.3052959501557632,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.18220664636017014,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 3,
"n_random_below": 317,
"rank_from_top": 4,
"share_below": 0.990625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.012461059190031152,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"DictComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.48711215427943655,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.4298615909755536,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05725056330388293,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.00564692798925881,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 260,
"n_random_below": 60,
"rank_from_top": 261,
"share_below": 0.1875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.8130841121495327,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"For": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.0788237883653009,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.08949680173872253,
"control_mean_nats": -0.010673013373421626,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 19,
"n_random_below": 301,
"rank_from_top": 20,
"share_below": 0.940625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.06230529595015576,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.01794954477366506,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 171,
"n_random_below": 149,
"rank_from_top": 172,
"share_below": 0.465625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.5358255451713395,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"GeneratorExp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.9429304660274287,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.8968278772675142,
"control_mean_nats": 0.04610258875991441,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.18608261485995303,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 9,
"n_random_below": 311,
"rank_from_top": 10,
"share_below": 0.971875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.03115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"If": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.06999209164169384,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.06632515703567532,
"control_mean_nats": 0.003666934606018528,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 17,
"n_random_below": 303,
"rank_from_top": 18,
"share_below": 0.946875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.056074766355140186,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.014989544597008964,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 128,
"n_random_below": 192,
"rank_from_top": 129,
"share_below": 0.6,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.40186915887850466,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"IfExp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 1.1635968880727887,
"rise_over_random_nats": 1.0711667547892527,
"control_mean_nats": 0.09243013328353604,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.16443624813109636,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 62,
"n_random_below": 258,
"rank_from_top": 63,
"share_below": 0.80625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.19626168224299065,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Import": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.17150603807889553,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.024193727282378175,
"control_mean_nats": 0.14731231079651735,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 138,
"n_random_below": 182,
"rank_from_top": 139,
"share_below": 0.56875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.43302180685358255,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.11024042276235768,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 251,
"n_random_below": 69,
"rank_from_top": 252,
"share_below": 0.215625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.7850467289719626,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"ImportFrom": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.2848721650930557,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.43324503256724417,
"control_mean_nats": 0.14837286747418849,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 296,
"n_random_below": 24,
"rank_from_top": 297,
"share_below": 0.075,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.9252336448598131,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.1401679699237537,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 266,
"n_random_below": 54,
"rank_from_top": 267,
"share_below": 0.16875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.8317757009345794,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Lambda": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 3.844317145878449,
"rise_over_random_nats": 3.837937072486299,
"control_mean_nats": 0.0063800733921501275,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.05142466863617301,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 105,
"n_random_below": 215,
"rank_from_top": 106,
"share_below": 0.671875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.3302180685358255,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"ListComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.565710187563436,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.5202486617386641,
"control_mean_nats": 0.045461525824771906,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.09841740433939838,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 59,
"n_random_below": 261,
"rank_from_top": 60,
"share_below": 0.815625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.18691588785046728,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"NamedExpr": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.5067045245415125,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.4328448565509646,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07385966799054788,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.20884753343386553,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 49,
"n_random_below": 271,
"rank_from_top": 50,
"share_below": 0.846875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.1557632398753894,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"SetComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.6881910665386224,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.6455035687135866,
"control_mean_nats": 0.0426874978250358,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.01583829628029454,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 200,
"n_random_below": 120,
"rank_from_top": 201,
"share_below": 0.375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.6261682242990654,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Try": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 3.5069999124854805,
"rise_over_random_nats": 3.4998270750280702,
"control_mean_nats": 0.007172837457410067,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.09140870977938177,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"While": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.06427306234153035,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.06492174298421333,
"control_mean_nats": 0.000648680642682977,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 287,
"n_random_below": 33,
"rank_from_top": 288,
"share_below": 0.103125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.897196261682243,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.012056895694054603,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 147,
"n_random_below": 173,
"rank_from_top": 148,
"share_below": 0.540625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.46105919003115264,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"With": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.013242842895643925,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.0034807841106415816,
"control_mean_nats": 0.009762058785002343,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 149,
"n_random_below": 171,
"rank_from_top": 150,
"share_below": 0.534375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.4672897196261682,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.15001671867711197,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 5,
"n_random_below": 315,
"rank_from_top": 6,
"share_below": 0.984375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.018691588785046728,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
}
}
},
"pretrain_iter_0484865": {
"tokens_b": 2034.0,
"n_constructs": 16,
"n_masks": 320,
"floor_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"holm_first_threshold": 0.003125,
"floor_can_clear_holm": true,
"n_exceeding_every_mask": 8,
"constructs_exceeding_every_mask": [
"AsyncWith",
"GeneratorExp",
"If",
"IfExp",
"Lambda",
"ListComp",
"Try",
"With"
],
"n_holm_significant": 8,
"constructs_holm_significant": [
"AsyncWith",
"GeneratorExp",
"If",
"IfExp",
"Lambda",
"ListComp",
"Try",
"With"
],
"median_rank_from_top": 2.5,
"n_p_below_0.05_uncorrected": 11,
"old_set": {
"n_constructs": 16,
"n_exceeding_every_mask": 4,
"constructs_exceeding_every_mask": [
"GeneratorExp",
"IfExp",
"Lambda",
"Try"
],
"n_holm_significant": 4,
"median_rank_from_top": 33.0,
"n_p_below_0.05_uncorrected": 5
},
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"carrier_rise_nats": -0.28349481836519597,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.27300053677600156,
"control_mean_nats": -0.01049428158919443,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 315,
"n_random_below": 5,
"rank_from_top": 316,
"share_below": 0.015625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.9844236760124611,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.046018336537248405,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 225,
"n_random_below": 95,
"rank_from_top": 226,
"share_below": 0.296875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.7040498442367601,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.4033340231443827,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.3663012905859293,
"control_mean_nats": 0.03703273255845339,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.1525754706504252,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 24,
"n_random_below": 296,
"rank_from_top": 25,
"share_below": 0.925,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.0778816199376947,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"DictComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.33314869160554883,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.2643692378859437,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06877945371960517,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 6,
"n_random_below": 314,
"rank_from_top": 7,
"share_below": 0.98125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.021806853582554516,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.22630855404600814,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 19,
"n_random_below": 301,
"rank_from_top": 20,
"share_below": 0.940625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.06230529595015576,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"For": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.10947780882247238,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.10335725028700557,
"control_mean_nats": 0.006120558535466809,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 12,
"n_random_below": 308,
"rank_from_top": 13,
"share_below": 0.9625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.040498442367601244,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.016702145681601,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 148,
"n_random_below": 172,
"rank_from_top": 149,
"share_below": 0.5375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.46417445482866043,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"GeneratorExp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.5844476452938796,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.5488085963399277,
"control_mean_nats": 0.03563904895395183,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.4551018119463457,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"If": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.35956109269265674,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.3496391834620516,
"control_mean_nats": 0.009921909230605144,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.0030725273047236823,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 202,
"n_random_below": 118,
"rank_from_top": 203,
"share_below": 0.36875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.632398753894081,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"IfExp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 1.6695803925395007,
"rise_over_random_nats": 1.5807033639350263,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08887702860447447,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.8262225513656931,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"Import": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.6679911613464355,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.484318252710196,
"control_mean_nats": 0.18367290863623956,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 54,
"n_random_below": 266,
"rank_from_top": 55,
"share_below": 0.83125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.17133956386292834,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.04502850312453077,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 207,
"n_random_below": 113,
"rank_from_top": 208,
"share_below": 0.353125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.6479750778816199,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"ImportFrom": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.39929918142465404,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.10829020314491683,
"control_mean_nats": 0.2910089782797372,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 143,
"n_random_below": 177,
"rank_from_top": 144,
"share_below": 0.553125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.4485981308411215,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.17609676947960473,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 188,
"n_random_below": 132,
"rank_from_top": 189,
"share_below": 0.4125,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.5887850467289719,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Lambda": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 4.991929735212277,
"rise_over_random_nats": 4.991729124280877,
"control_mean_nats": 0.00020061093140012683,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 3.5500454863843824,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"ListComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 1.0094922351353057,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.9592243367437328,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05026789839157295,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.15053607848695094,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 50,
"n_random_below": 270,
"rank_from_top": 51,
"share_below": 0.84375,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.1588785046728972,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"NamedExpr": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.06876956193875117,
"rise_over_random_nats": -0.0524427229228116,
"control_mean_nats": 0.12121228486156277,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 206,
"n_random_below": 114,
"rank_from_top": 207,
"share_below": 0.35625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.6448598130841121,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.36871654788653085,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 19,
"n_random_below": 301,
"rank_from_top": 20,
"share_below": 0.940625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.06230529595015576,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"SetComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.48361611850370645,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.4344779458142783,
"control_mean_nats": 0.049138172689428175,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 3,
"n_random_below": 317,
"rank_from_top": 4,
"share_below": 0.990625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.012461059190031152,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.16865868374780968,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 40,
"n_random_below": 280,
"rank_from_top": 41,
"share_below": 0.875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.1277258566978193,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"Try": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 6.004058102428913,
"rise_over_random_nats": 5.953725562189787,
"control_mean_nats": 0.050332540239125964,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 4.19116915589571,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
}
},
"While": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.10473492604876872,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.08015122678602932,
"control_mean_nats": 0.024583699262739404,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 32,
"n_random_below": 288,
"rank_from_top": 33,
"share_below": 0.9,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.102803738317757,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
},
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.29686423732873496,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 4,
"n_random_below": 316,
"rank_from_top": 5,
"share_below": 0.9875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.01557632398753894,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"With": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.5767353416553564,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.5483998310095298,
"control_mean_nats": 0.028335510645826657,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 0,
"n_random_below": 320,
"rank_from_top": 1,
"share_below": 1.0,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"exceeds_every_mask": true,
"holm_significant": true
},
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.11006864053862442,
"old_set": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 313,
"n_random_below": 7,
"rank_from_top": 314,
"share_below": 0.021875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.9781931464174455,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
}
}
}
},
"minutes": 7.145007451375326e-05,
"provenance": {
"inputs": [
"ablation_ranks/FULL_*.json"
],
"reference": null,
"battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad",
"code_commit": "d22522d",
"design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026"
},
"clause_for_paper2_4_3_and_paper1_4_8": "Taken one at a time against 320 random sets, 2 of 16 constructs exceed every random set at 4.19 B tokens, 8 at 84 B and 8 at the end, and 2, 8, 8 remain clear at 0.05 after a Holm correction; the floor of 1/321 is the resolution a 320-set control allows, and the paper's claim is the one over constructs."
}
{
"what": "A1.1b: the ablation read as a rank among the control masks",
"why": "the control is long-tailed at 83.9 B and 2,034 B -- SD ~2.2x its own mean and still rising at 200 masks -- so a control unit has no converged denominator there. A rank has none to converge.",
"definition": {
"rank_from_top": "1 + the number of random masks whose loss rise is at or above the carrier set's",
"exact_one_sided_p": "(1 + #{random >= carrier}) / (1 + n_masks)",
"floor": "the smallest p an n-mask control allows is 1/(n+1); at n = 320 that is 0.00312, just under Holm's first threshold of 0.05/16 = 0.003125, which is why 320 and not 200 were drawn",
"holm": "Holm-Bonferroni at alpha = 0.05 across the 16 constructs, separately at each reference",
"old_set": "the same rank for the 84 B carrier set removed at the end, against the SAME masks",
"mask_check": "the mean and SD recomputed from the FIRST 200 per-mask values are compared with the 23 Oct run's stored figures to within 1e-06; a mismatch means different masks and stops the read"
},
"fixed_before_computing": true,
"baseline_prefix": 200,
"mask_check": {
"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
"n_constructs_checked_against_23_oct": 16,
"n_constructs": 16
},
"pretrain_iter_0020000": {
"n_constructs_checked_against_23_oct": 16,
"n_constructs": 16
},
"pretrain_iter_0484865": {
"n_constructs_checked_against_23_oct": 16,
"n_constructs": 16
}
},
"per_reference": {
"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
"tokens_b": 4.19,
"n_constructs": 16,
"n_masks": 320,
"floor_p": 0.003115264797507788,
"holm_first_threshold": 0.003125,
"floor_can_clear_holm": true,
"n_exceeding_every_mask": 2,
"constructs_exceeding_every_mask": [
"Lambda",
"Try"
],
"n_holm_significant": 2,
"constructs_holm_significant": [
"Lambda",
"Try"
],
"median_rank_from_top": 63.5,
"n_p_below_0.05_uncorrected": 3,
"old_set": null,
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.1417616092162448,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.07012812873128527,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07163348048495954,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 59,
"n_random_below": 261,
"rank_from_top": 60,
"share_below": 0.815625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.18691588785046728,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.20135072762003325,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.1391150025534445,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06223572506658877,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 40,
"n_random_below": 280,
"rank_from_top": 41,
"share_below": 0.875,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.1277258566978193,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"DictComp": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.10147391727992527,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.050006443547959536,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05146747373196574,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,
"n_random_at_or_above": 51,
"n_random_below": 269,
"rank_from_top": 52,
"share_below": 0.840625,
"exact_one_sided_p": 0.16199376947040497,
"exceeds_every_mask": false,
"holm_significant": false
}
},
"For": {
"carrier_rise_nats": 0.18285812355942976,
"rise_over_random_nats": 0.0949608547221171,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08789726883731266,
"current": {
"n_masks": 320,