Datasets:
DOI:
License:
{
"what": "the ablation effect with the control's spread shown to have settled",
"definition": {
"effect_nats": "the rise in loss at the construct's positions when its carrier set is zeroed, over the unablated baseline",
"control": "size-matched random sets, drawn once at the largest mask count",
"effect_control_units": "(effect - control mean) / control SD, SIGNED",
"nested_prefixes": [
50,
100,
200
],
"settle_criterion": "the control SD changes by < 5% when the mask count doubles",
"also_reported": "the 84 B set removed at the end, under the SAME masks"
},
"fixed_before_computing": true,
"per_reference": {
"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
"tokens_b": 4.19,
"n_constructs": 16,
"median_loss_rise_nats": 0.1390074489264248,
"median_control_mean_nats": 0.07696309440225975,
"median_control_sd_nats": 0.07620258625252987,
"median_effect_control_units": 0.7943581974474601,
"median_old_set_control_units": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"n_constructs_with_settled_control": 14,
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.1417616092162448,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08038861264670599,
"control_sd_nats": 0.07446927091857777,
"effect_control_units": 0.824138544832029,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.07697220053727741,
"control_sd": 0.07271919467741918,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.07482252268866761,
"control_sd": 0.07387664654241856,
"change_from_half": 0.0159167310657635
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.08038861264670599,
"control_sd": 0.07446927091857777,
"change_from_half": 0.00802180937948965
}
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.20135072762003325,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06156300331824099,
"control_sd_nats": 0.11531251364375548,
"effect_control_units": 1.2122511242244711,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.03207577592191786,
"control_sd": 0.11337761071459246,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.05815755771616331,
"control_sd": 0.11886184046594253,
"change_from_half": 0.04837136465289981
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.06156300331824099,
"control_sd": 0.11531251364375548,
"change_from_half": 0.029860944507283094
}
}
},
"DictComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.10147391727992527,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05354072795595473,
"control_sd_nats": 0.05586206913669492,
"effect_control_units": 0.8580632630466597,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.049961585570355106,
"control_sd": 0.05693305509326991,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.04664670163757975,
"control_sd": 0.056467083187731894,
"change_from_half": 0.008184558246077646
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.05354072795595473,
"control_sd": 0.05586206913669492,
"change_from_half": 0.010714455517837342
}
}
},
"For": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.18285812355942976,
"control_mean_nats": 0.09022689034942268,
"control_sd_nats": 0.04546743777855046,
"effect_control_units": 2.0373092862889766,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.08829732178267573,
"control_sd": 0.04730098581089935,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.08572932384371432,
"control_sd": 0.046984033363232154,
"change_from_half": 0.006700757758713844
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.09022689034942268,
"control_sd": 0.04546743777855046,
"change_from_half": 0.0322789568310779
}
}
},
"GeneratorExp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.15341256596715258,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07771904343880941,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06655396421490126,
"effect_control_units": 1.1373255285580057,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.08128458073901608,
"control_sd": 0.07441516069117195,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.0769966593006537,
"control_sd": 0.0676470507918739,
"change_from_half": 0.09095068580697112
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.07771904343880941,
"control_sd": 0.06655396421490126,
"change_from_half": 0.01615867305635666
}
}
},
"If": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.007977972562978164,
"control_mean_nats": 0.04078499483585741,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06064753993224987,
"effect_control_units": -0.8040386708728713,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.029619628031454716,
"control_sd": 0.05884965047487917,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.03805102547927616,
"control_sd": 0.06114123058633032,
"change_from_half": 0.038939570464048036
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.04078499483585741,
"control_sd": 0.06064753993224987,
"change_from_half": 0.00807459466134513
}
}
},
"IfExp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.1362532886366048,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07753755729645476,
"control_sd_nats": 0.10952458298018404,
"effect_control_units": 0.5360963698056107,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.06893467040111605,
"control_sd": 0.1157882855097551,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.08101583839704578,
"control_sd": 0.1088582534494417,
"change_from_half": 0.059850891044841995
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.07753755729645476,
"control_sd": 0.10952458298018404,
"change_from_half": 0.006121074972526702
}
}
},
"Import": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.27605540935809714,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05500138356135427,
"control_sd_nats": 0.28911905540888977,
"effect_control_units": 0.7645778500628913,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.13540024390587427,
"control_sd": 0.25966565237031575,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.09543071013230525,
"control_sd": 0.30000358429539836,
"change_from_half": 0.15534565914615334
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.05500138356135427,
"control_sd": 0.28911905540888977,
"change_from_half": 0.03628132947835432
}
}
},
"ImportFrom": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.12070604471059987,
"control_mean_nats": -0.11292477240929251,
"control_sd_nats": 0.28899532560081365,
"effect_control_units": -0.026925253151172255,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": -0.13610319724449763,
"control_sd": 0.2947687698459127,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": -0.12106147032517668,
"control_sd": 0.29652816784835223,
"change_from_half": 0.005968739508460218
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": -0.11292477240929251,
"control_sd": 0.28899532560081365,
"change_from_half": 0.025403462686860032
}
}
},
"Lambda": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.7078969826300936,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07638863150806474,
"control_sd_nats": 0.1780334080529203,
"effect_control_units": 3.547133979114265,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.0811519647017121,
"control_sd": 0.18649468790105897,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.0702563974478592,
"control_sd": 0.18089927444124734,
"change_from_half": 0.03000307152330345
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.07638863150806474,
"control_sd": 0.1780334080529203,
"change_from_half": 0.015842332133055685
}
}
},
"ListComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.1092176328455734,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08493081374216777,
"control_sd_nats": 0.05214785302411451,
"effect_control_units": 0.46572999068964127,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.07801823110144722,
"control_sd": 0.05128535679343409,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.0779336889867247,
"control_sd": 0.05028222580519038,
"change_from_half": 0.019559793495911523
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.08493081374216777,
"control_sd": 0.05214785302411451,
"change_from_half": 0.03710311524696966
}
}
},
"NamedExpr": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.06559552901830479,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08299217120195078,
"control_sd_nats": 0.15379944477569202,
"effect_control_units": -0.966113372105878,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.09841340028322691,
"control_sd": 0.1358206250586567,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.09089884165005836,
"control_sd": 0.15448619055784432,
"change_from_half": 0.1374280636032013
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.08299217120195078,
"control_sd": 0.15379944477569202,
"change_from_half": 0.00444535385119206
}
}
},
"SetComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.11136166093313093,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06995252142702833,
"control_sd_nats": 0.05709862927449889,
"effect_control_units": 0.7252212536842203,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.06352794826333262,
"control_sd": 0.05552613076950158,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.06383679008725901,
"control_sd": 0.05524608013602645,
"change_from_half": 0.005043582716715275
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.06995252142702833,
"control_sd": 0.05709862927449889,
"change_from_half": 0.033532680217512364
}
}
},
"Try": {
"loss_rise_nats": 1.3229805639758707,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08047792392468081,
"control_sd_nats": 0.07793590158648196,
"effect_control_units": 15.942622267254336,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.09863440530769531,
"control_sd": 0.07952112804402821,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.09205586397588254,
"control_sd": 0.08364715977704826,
"change_from_half": 0.05188598092742853
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.08047792392468081,
"control_sd": 0.07793590158648196,
"change_from_half": 0.0682779691000745
}
}
},
"While": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.014500070499991025,
"control_mean_nats": 0.02532068686423091,
"control_sd_nats": 0.0533823449252388,
"effect_control_units": -0.7459536934915528,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.014475219616444313,
"control_sd": 0.0465635942583351,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.02027651013669757,
"control_sd": 0.052149600496015226,
"change_from_half": 0.11996509991666293
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.02532068686423091,
"control_sd": 0.0533823449252388,
"change_from_half": 0.023638616930876946
}
}
},
"With": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.28541309173618057,
"control_mean_nats": 0.10686337692929204,
"control_sd_nats": 0.11134175803437488,
"effect_control_units": 1.603618605983968,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.07919153811676205,
"control_sd": 0.11727919978805054,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.10498692526349039,
"control_sd": 0.11821038193541772,
"change_from_half": 0.007939874667034127
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.10686337692929204,
"control_sd": 0.11134175803437488,
"change_from_half": 0.05810508170758978
}
}
}
}
},
"pretrain_iter_0020000": {
"tokens_b": 83.9,
"n_constructs": 16,
"median_loss_rise_nats": 0.32930909617916604,
"median_control_mean_nats": 0.029468978038834845,
"median_control_sd_nats": 0.06520509574750491,
"median_effect_control_units": 2.2744803940150446,
"median_old_set_control_units": 0.25217550042929493,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"n_constructs_with_settled_control": 7,
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.03523392910916123,
"control_mean_nats": 0.009207959960909973,
"control_sd_nats": 0.0527802591501842,
"effect_control_units": 0.4931004426142616,
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.09800286217450394,
"old_set_control_units": -2.03126744471545,
"overlap_share": 0.09277092092770921,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.009712171923659078,
"control_sd": 0.05401444572105152,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.013287561315216532,
"control_sd": 0.0548468751027608,
"change_from_half": 0.015411236209073139
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.009207959960909973,
"control_sd": 0.0527802591501842,
"change_from_half": 0.03767973925049698
}
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.0490670496454606,
"control_mean_nats": 0.016892564086010614,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06603225403366762,
"effect_control_units": 0.4872540856025497,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.18220664636017014,
"old_set_control_units": 2.503535350919135,
"overlap_share": 0.08843076088430761,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.00975773083744564,
"control_sd": 0.05796070197823647,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.019295573926512807,
"control_sd": 0.06541971846378135,
"change_from_half": 0.12869092731736842
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.016892564086010614,
"control_sd": 0.06603225403366762,
"change_from_half": 0.00936316426102316
}
}
},
"DictComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.48711215427943655,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05895201468710992,
"control_sd_nats": 0.058461857021149415,
"effect_control_units": 7.323751953986572,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.00564692798925881,
"old_set_control_units": -0.9117925672215174,
"overlap_share": 0.10565577105655771,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.057095309870583574,
"control_sd": 0.05467663336136289,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.060298488115777704,
"control_sd": 0.05500042041155489,
"change_from_half": 0.0059218541868160945
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.05895201468710992,
"control_sd": 0.058461857021149415,
"change_from_half": 0.06293473002012404
}
}
},
"For": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.0788237883653009,
"control_mean_nats": -0.005831884802225122,
"control_sd_nats": 0.05628805740377246,
"effect_control_units": 1.5039721936087345,
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.01794954477366506,
"old_set_control_units": -0.21527941326018837,
"overlap_share": 0.1345449613454496,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": -0.0019733800674635125,
"control_sd": 0.058791222178086966,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": -0.0008565286638198621,
"control_sd": 0.05316406784567731,
"change_from_half": 0.09571419208405309
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": -0.005831884802225122,
"control_sd": 0.05628805740377246,
"change_from_half": 0.058761296580302234
}
}
},
"GeneratorExp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.9429304660274287,
"control_mean_nats": 0.045924642164694635,
"control_sd_nats": 0.07026396708556316,
"effect_control_units": 12.766227998063577,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.18608261485995303,
"old_set_control_units": 1.994734691318846,
"overlap_share": 0.10212939102129391,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.05018359665943236,
"control_sd": 0.06647307875814161,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.05356056518361,
"control_sd": 0.06801271764086765,
"change_from_half": 0.023161841026318738
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.045924642164694635,
"control_sd": 0.07026396708556316,
"change_from_half": 0.0331004189037548
}
}
},
"If": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.06999209164169384,
"control_mean_nats": 0.010382499292297138,
"control_sd_nats": 0.04110286021896996,
"effect_control_units": 1.4502541193443625,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.014989544597008964,
"old_set_control_units": 0.1120857594865275,
"overlap_share": 0.14702292147022922,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.008255076904011793,
"control_sd": 0.04515409400001112,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.009305139086546656,
"control_sd": 0.04357469410437656,
"change_from_half": 0.03497799990481866
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.010382499292297138,
"control_sd": 0.04110286021896996,
"change_from_half": 0.05672636231216447
}
}
},
"IfExp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 1.1635968880727887,
"control_mean_nats": 0.0904549363445646,
"control_sd_nats": 0.08996444420669161,
"effect_control_units": 11.928511993723884,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.16443624813109636,
"old_set_control_units": 0.822339452423683,
"overlap_share": 0.12152448121524481,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.073831124920398,
"control_sd": 0.07988230388441087,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.08514596498571336,
"control_sd": 0.07729915675837926,
"change_from_half": 0.032336913188800935
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.0904549363445646,
"control_sd": 0.08996444420669161,
"change_from_half": 0.16384767932076355
}
}
},
"Import": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.17150603807889553,
"control_mean_nats": 0.14907715338927024,
"control_sd_nats": 0.3658181955801989,
"effect_control_units": 0.06131156120884688,
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.11024042276235768,
"old_set_control_units": -0.7088700870669986,
"overlap_share": 0.09277092092770921,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.19691356145418584,
"control_sd": 0.3640286057526969,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.16668782600989684,
"control_sd": 0.38955024186773185,
"change_from_half": 0.0701088752689207
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.14907715338927024,
"control_sd": 0.3658181955801989,
"change_from_half": 0.060921657175073564
}
}
},
"ImportFrom": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.2848721650930557,
"control_mean_nats": 0.15431532052846986,
"control_sd_nats": 0.3537066733266881,
"effect_control_units": -1.2416714717052744,
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.1401679699237537,
"old_set_control_units": -0.8325635693625575,
"overlap_share": 0.1300691713006917,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.19383159344012837,
"control_sd": 0.40014396447450784,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.1691726677234349,
"control_sd": 0.36093071237710644,
"change_from_half": 0.09799785971756066
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.15431532052846986,
"control_sd": 0.3537066733266881,
"change_from_half": 0.020015030039534445
}
}
},
"Lambda": {
"loss_rise_nats": 3.844317145878449,
"control_mean_nats": 0.00734456040110672,
"control_sd_nats": 0.11237321991844913,
"effect_control_units": 34.14490203503903,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.05142466863617301,
"old_set_control_units": 0.39226524137206237,
"overlap_share": 0.09955242099552421,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.02216957066829006,
"control_sd": 0.11605356360266506,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.016817804294793556,
"control_sd": 0.11885757285475408,
"change_from_half": 0.024161336929636817
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.00734456040110672,
"control_sd": 0.11237321991844913,
"change_from_half": 0.0545556566616831
}
}
},
"ListComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.565710187563436,
"control_mean_nats": 0.04598607758277563,
"control_sd_nats": 0.058988780681309055,
"effect_control_units": 8.810558617722677,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.09841740433939838,
"old_set_control_units": 0.8888355743422908,
"overlap_share": 0.1072833310728333,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.05084220713165202,
"control_sd": 0.05278940112537269,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.05108475079391205,
"control_sd": 0.053901093890635354,
"change_from_half": 0.021059014528739168
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.04598607758277563,
"control_sd": 0.058988780681309055,
"change_from_half": 0.0943893049925212
}
}
},
"NamedExpr": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.5067045245415125,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08598682465843681,
"control_sd_nats": 0.1381672498392479,
"effect_control_units": 3.044988594421355,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.20884753343386553,
"old_set_control_units": 0.8892172994567978,
"overlap_share": 0.1106740811067408,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.08925274353760955,
"control_sd": 0.13043114800065714,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.09813286627714471,
"control_sd": 0.1376499279182459,
"change_from_half": 0.05534552158930928
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.08598682465843681,
"control_sd": 0.1381672498392479,
"change_from_half": 0.0037582433120434593
}
}
},
"SetComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.6881910665386224,
"control_mean_nats": 0.042045391991659076,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06904917964597186,
"effect_control_units": 9.35776033632657,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.01583829628029454,
"old_set_control_units": -0.3795424630058351,
"overlap_share": 0.10877526108775261,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.048236272492384796,
"control_sd": 0.07192388744134365,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.04252370795622718,
"control_sd": 0.0681788686620092,
"change_from_half": 0.05206919303949798
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.042045391991659076,
"control_sd": 0.06904917964597186,
"change_from_half": 0.012765113312119497
}
}
},
"Try": {
"loss_rise_nats": 3.5069999124854805,
"control_mean_nats": 0.008112612049058087,
"control_sd_nats": 0.016387161280720205,
"effect_control_units": 213.5139357268014,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.09140870977938177,
"old_set_control_units": 5.083009577035351,
"overlap_share": 0.11962566119625662,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.005804273245111116,
"control_sd": 0.020041492333215977,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.006825821303017444,
"control_sd": 0.01705307648968047,
"change_from_half": 0.14911144309261962
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.008112612049058087,
"control_sd": 0.016387161280720205,
"change_from_half": 0.039049564421014496
}
}
},
"While": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.06427306234153035,
"control_mean_nats": 0.009395956681793527,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06437793746134221,
"effect_control_units": -1.1443208951445638,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.012056895694054603,
"old_set_control_units": 0.04133308889957717,
"overlap_share": 0.1322392513223925,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.0017898373343392475,
"control_sd": 0.08296276092362456,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.0047816021878853525,
"control_sd": 0.06868665490975395,
"change_from_half": 0.17207848262201855
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.009395956681793527,
"control_sd": 0.06437793746134221,
"change_from_half": 0.06273005220698083
}
}
},
"With": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.013242842895643925,
"control_mean_nats": 0.011836023595450239,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06187422448908029,
"effect_control_units": 0.022736758509869726,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.15001671867711197,
"old_set_control_units": 2.233251345332792,
"overlap_share": 0.11230164112301641,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.017711884390030637,
"control_sd": 0.06475053904301009,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.01690025166874491,
"control_sd": 0.06677951508491509,
"change_from_half": 0.031335276460899605
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.011836023595450239,
"control_sd": 0.06187422448908029,
"change_from_half": 0.0734550196957459
}
}
}
}
},
"pretrain_iter_0484865": {
"tokens_b": 2034.0,
"n_constructs": 16,
"median_loss_rise_nats": 0.4434750708240446,
"median_control_mean_nats": 0.04459396345509829,
"median_control_sd_nats": 0.101282471985147,
"median_effect_control_units": 3.9724019611208714,
"median_old_set_control_units": 1.4878997515448695,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"n_constructs_with_settled_control": 5,
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"loss_rise_nats": -0.28349481836519597,
"control_mean_nats": -0.004141877565468466,
"control_sd_nats": 0.09090661169195136,
"effect_control_units": -3.072966152850912,
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.046018336537248405,
"old_set_control_units": -0.46065361135319466,
"overlap_share": 0.12491523124915231,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.002960402540196987,
"control_sd": 0.10977578974129501,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.0031671502962923605,
"control_sd": 0.09689818150858727,
"change_from_half": 0.1173082722798531
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": -0.004141877565468466,
"control_sd": 0.09090661169195136,
"change_from_half": 0.06183366626034083
}
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.4033340231443827,
"control_mean_nats": 0.04121691075673031,
"control_sd_nats": 0.08326448330284396,
"effect_control_units": 4.348998492797757,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.1525754706504252,
"old_set_control_units": 1.3374076854433727,
"overlap_share": 0.12491523124915231,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.05447902117855838,
"control_sd": 0.0722462925553795,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.04458568143192672,
"control_sd": 0.07940976039695598,
"change_from_half": 0.0991534317983918
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.04121691075673031,
"control_sd": 0.08326448330284396,
"change_from_half": 0.04854218028890746
}
}
},
"DictComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.33314869160554883,
"control_mean_nats": 0.07071836169276936,
"control_sd_nats": 0.08789377761715891,
"effect_control_units": 2.9857668771031065,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.22630855404600814,
"old_set_control_units": 1.770207136060835,
"overlap_share": 0.13400244134002443,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.05525828488019064,
"control_sd": 0.05985619568182976,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.06500582424231956,
"control_sd": 0.06712043168075799,
"change_from_half": 0.12136147171032777
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.07071836169276936,
"control_sd": 0.08789377761715891,
"change_from_half": 0.3094936283366635
}
}
},
"For": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.10947780882247238,
"control_mean_nats": 0.010131784197726756,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06582097520050888,
"effect_control_units": 1.5093368690164524,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.01878995130187498,
"control_sd": 0.07879425661632666,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.013082778341960845,
"control_sd": 0.07083673284673245,
"change_from_half": 0.10099116498226303
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.010131784197726756,
"control_sd": 0.06582097520050888,
"change_from_half": 0.07080729791810178
}
}
},
"GeneratorExp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.5844476452938796,
"control_mean_nats": 0.035983900563970946,
"control_sd_nats": 0.10077274486577012,
"effect_control_units": 5.442580188328358,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.4551018119463457,
"old_set_control_units": 4.15904034310708,
"overlap_share": 0.136986301369863,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.03221541203823176,
"control_sd": 0.07621036919729668,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.0380310469109394,
"control_sd": 0.09120965396576333,
"change_from_half": 0.19681422523535952
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.035983900563970946,
"control_sd": 0.10077274486577012,
"change_from_half": 0.1048473542460364
}
}
},
"If": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.35956109269265674,
"control_mean_nats": 0.014602089335271335,
"control_sd_nats": 0.06614890646477284,
"effect_control_units": 5.21488595644572,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.0009864413689659784,
"control_sd": 0.05750314501317101,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.009061317614590109,
"control_sd": 0.0661141794175751,
"change_from_half": 0.14974892942693374
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.014602089335271335,
"control_sd": 0.06614890646477284,
"change_from_half": 0.0005252586888874329
}
}
},
"IfExp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 1.6695803925395007,
"control_mean_nats": 0.09807059324618102,
"control_sd_nats": 0.12704239543163412,
"effect_control_units": 12.369963538187559,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.8262225513656931,
"old_set_control_units": 5.73156666044884,
"overlap_share": 0.14010579140105792,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.07216520683839903,
"control_sd": 0.10539213460247229,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.09276796584172779,
"control_sd": 0.1170695958333502,
"change_from_half": 0.11080012066293213
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.09807059324618102,
"control_sd": 0.12704239543163412,
"change_from_half": 0.08518693113522231
}
}
},
"Import": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.6679911613464355,
"control_mean_nats": 0.2067819512807403,
"control_sd_nats": 0.5338665245460941,
"effect_control_units": 0.8639035954873294,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.04502850312453077,
"old_set_control_units": -0.30298481121987586,
"overlap_share": 0.13644378136443783,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.2503646293053257,
"control_sd": 0.4163067418142329,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.22358004826765762,
"control_sd": 0.47749893179037756,
"change_from_half": 0.14698822726116276
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.2067819512807403,
"control_sd": 0.5338665245460941,
"change_from_half": 0.1180475787545048
}
}
},
"ImportFrom": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.39929918142465404,
"control_mean_nats": 0.3053303906550773,
"control_sd_nats": 0.6306770623842866,
"effect_control_units": 0.1489966836820194,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.17609676947960473,
"old_set_control_units": -0.20491251209755815,
"overlap_share": 0.15583887155838871,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.3111477206303521,
"control_sd": 0.5412168690380921,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.29736307235864473,
"control_sd": 0.6114758781721801,
"change_from_half": 0.1298167391917398
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.3053303906550773,
"control_sd": 0.6306770623842866,
"change_from_half": 0.03140137640343646
}
}
},
"Lambda": {
"loss_rise_nats": 4.991929735212277,
"control_mean_nats": 0.0027443798379197183,
"control_sd_nats": 0.2206156058554959,
"effect_control_units": 22.614834231819,
"old_set_rise_nats": 3.5500454863843824,
"old_set_control_units": 16.079103256502894,
"overlap_share": 0.14281839142818392,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": -0.023112881490960645,
"control_sd": 0.16765162715974635,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.019191930051893066,
"control_sd": 0.255697807649815,
"change_from_half": 0.5251734324425857
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.0027443798379197183,
"control_sd": 0.2206156058554959,
"change_from_half": 0.13720180910727678
}
}
},
"ListComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 1.0094922351353057,
"control_mean_nats": 0.04967884079453909,
"control_sd_nats": 0.10544084815607174,
"effect_control_units": 9.102861093454665,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.15053607848695094,
"old_set_control_units": 0.9565290820036338,
"overlap_share": 0.1368506713685067,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.040957609300080904,
"control_sd": 0.07563639350586561,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.048295518795245795,
"control_sd": 0.08657541251869905,
"change_from_half": 0.14462639618036674
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.04967884079453909,
"control_sd": 0.10544084815607174,
"change_from_half": 0.21790754543962507
}
}
},
"NamedExpr": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.06876956193875117,
"control_mean_nats": 0.12596267584138235,
"control_sd_nats": 0.1481659450630539,
"effect_control_units": -0.38600714812227555,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.36871654788653085,
"old_set_control_units": 1.6383918176463663,
"overlap_share": 0.15828021158280212,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.12253260256388292,
"control_sd": 0.12590425230737176,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.1348136754754266,
"control_sd": 0.1392517577411379,
"change_from_half": 0.10601314244081841
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.12596267584138235,
"control_sd": 0.1481659450630539,
"change_from_half": 0.06401489982257183
}
}
},
"SetComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.48361611850370645,
"control_mean_nats": 0.047971016153466266,
"control_sd_nats": 0.12115369168281258,
"effect_control_units": 3.595805429443986,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.16865868374780968,
"old_set_control_units": 0.9961534470638398,
"overlap_share": 0.13332429133324292,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.04034758711829402,
"control_sd": 0.0890889986567625,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.04497180372325294,
"control_sd": 0.09844815950135838,
"change_from_half": 0.10505405814083035
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.047971016153466266,
"control_sd": 0.12115369168281258,
"change_from_half": 0.23063439983498027
}
}
},
"Try": {
"loss_rise_nats": 6.004058102428913,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05115264310801402,
"control_sd_nats": 0.10179219910452389,
"effect_control_units": 58.48095936318501,
"old_set_rise_nats": 4.19116915589571,
"old_set_control_units": 40.671255255391216,
"overlap_share": 0.1510918215109182,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": false,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.0492579280820489,
"control_sd": 0.09490302553987032,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.04918416814640165,
"control_sd": 0.09507277083534466,
"change_from_half": 0.0017886183765872205
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.05115264310801402,
"control_sd": 0.10179219910452389,
"change_from_half": 0.07067668492397816
}
}
},
"While": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.10473492604876872,
"control_mean_nats": 0.02937096390753573,
"control_sd_nats": 0.0815333813065776,
"effect_control_units": 0.9243325976860118,
"old_set_rise_nats": 0.29686423732873496,
"old_set_control_units": 3.2807822898376418,
"overlap_share": 0.139698901396989,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.023764760701686406,
"control_sd": 0.07539988663856684,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.02633927176082761,
"control_sd": 0.08192370771693841,
"change_from_half": 0.08652295605753146
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.02937096390753573,
"control_sd": 0.0815333813065776,
"change_from_half": 0.004764511046173121
}
}
},
"With": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.5767353416553564,
"control_mean_nats": 0.0311484616668894,
"control_sd_nats": 0.07156714294438483,
"effect_control_units": 7.623426862414295,
"old_set_rise_nats": -0.11006864053862442,
"old_set_control_units": -1.9732113983543298,
"overlap_share": 0.1345449613454496,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.04099817354232064,
"control_sd": 0.07125355547982533,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.038457578016178856,
"control_sd": 0.07123073115643466,
"change_from_half": 0.0003203253962130851
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.0311484616668894,
"control_sd": 0.07156714294438483,
"change_from_half": 0.004722846199786372
}
}
}
}
}
},
"minutes": 7.058382034301758e-05,
"provenance": {
"inputs": [
"_abl_dl/validation/ablation/FULL_*.json"
],
"reference": null,
"battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad",
"code_commit": "f7c2832",
"design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026"
}
}
{
"what": "the ablation effect with the control's spread shown to have settled",
"definition": {
"effect_nats": "the rise in loss at the construct's positions when its carrier set is zeroed, over the unablated baseline",
"control": "size-matched random sets, drawn once at the largest mask count",
"effect_control_units": "(effect - control mean) / control SD, SIGNED",
"nested_prefixes": [
50,
100,
200
],
"settle_criterion": "the control SD changes by < 5% when the mask count doubles",
"also_reported": "the 84 B set removed at the end, under the SAME masks"
},
"fixed_before_computing": true,
"per_reference": {
"pretrain_iter_0001000": {
"tokens_b": 4.19,
"n_constructs": 16,
"median_loss_rise_nats": 0.1390074489264248,
"median_control_mean_nats": 0.07696309440225975,
"median_control_sd_nats": 0.07620258625252987,
"median_effect_control_units": 0.7943581974474601,
"median_old_set_control_units": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"n_constructs_with_settled_control": 14,
"per_construct": {
"AsyncFor": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.1417616092162448,
"control_mean_nats": 0.08038861264670599,
"control_sd_nats": 0.07446927091857777,
"effect_control_units": 0.824138544832029,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.07697220053727741,
"control_sd": 0.07271919467741918,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.07482252268866761,
"control_sd": 0.07387664654241856,
"change_from_half": 0.0159167310657635
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.08038861264670599,
"control_sd": 0.07446927091857777,
"change_from_half": 0.00802180937948965
}
}
},
"AsyncWith": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.20135072762003325,
"control_mean_nats": 0.06156300331824099,
"control_sd_nats": 0.11531251364375548,
"effect_control_units": 1.2122511242244711,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {
"50": {
"n_masks": 50,
"control_mean": 0.03207577592191786,
"control_sd": 0.11337761071459246,
"change_from_half": null
},
"100": {
"n_masks": 100,
"control_mean": 0.05815755771616331,
"control_sd": 0.11886184046594253,
"change_from_half": 0.04837136465289981
},
"200": {
"n_masks": 200,
"control_mean": 0.06156300331824099,
"control_sd": 0.11531251364375548,
"change_from_half": 0.029860944507283094
}
}
},
"DictComp": {
"loss_rise_nats": 0.10147391727992527,
"control_mean_nats": 0.05354072795595473,
"control_sd_nats": 0.05586206913669492,
"effect_control_units": 0.8580632630466597,
"old_set_rise_nats": null,
"old_set_control_units": null,
"overlap_share": null,
"n_masks_reached": 200,
"control_sd_settled": true,
"control_stability": {