File size: 73,833 Bytes
aefa98b
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
file,tier,year,title,venue,doi,relevance,theme,threat_screen,screen_note,fulltext_verified,C1,C2,C3,C4,C5,openalex_id
References/datasets/2026_Luay_Time_Matters_Temporal_NetFlow_Features_for_ML_Based_Network_.pdf,core,2026,Time Matters: Temporal NetFlow Features for ML-Based Network Intrusion Detection,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2026.3688204,3,datasets,partial,Temporal NetFlow feature datasets and time analysis; partial C2 time-based aspects.,yes,none,none,none,none,none,W4416082591
References/evaluation/2026_Thanh_A_transfer_aware_deployment_oriented_evaluation_framework_fo.pdf,core,2026,"A transfer-aware, deployment-oriented evaluation framework for NetFlow-based intrusion detection systems (TAN-IDS)",PLoS ONE,10.1371/journal.pone.0346801,3,evaluation,partial,Transfer-aware cross-dataset NetFlow IDS evaluation with 8-feature interface; overlaps C2 cross-source generalisation.,yes,none,partial,none,none,none,W7151801175
References/datasets/2026_Popescu_Apreutesei_GreenNIDS_A_Benchmark_Workflow_and_Analysis_Dataset_for_NetF.pdf,core,2026,GreenNIDS: A Benchmark Workflow and Analysis Dataset for NetFlow Intrusion Detection Experiments,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2610.25366,3,datasets,partial,"NetFlow benchmark workflow across dataset versions, binary/multiclass; overlaps C2 baseline, no LOSO",yes,none,partial,none,none,none,W7223058914
References/evaluation/2026_Pangestu_A_Leakage_Aware_Evaluation_Framework_for_Class_Imbalance_Han.pdf,core,2026,A Leakage-Aware Evaluation Framework for Class Imbalance Handling in CNN-BiLSTM Network Intrusion Detection on UNSW-NB15,Equivalent Jurnal Ilmiah Sosial Teknik,10.59261/jequi.v8i4.434,3,evaluation,partial,"Leakage-aware evaluation with class weights, SMOTE, ADASYN, CTGAN on UNSW-NB15; partial C1 and C3, not NetFlow.",yes,partial,none,partial,none,none,W7222945120
References/evaluation/2026_Iskandarova_Leakage_Controlled_Cross_Dataset_Evaluation_of_Self_Supervis.pdf,core,2026,Leakage-Controlled Cross-Dataset Evaluation of Self-Supervised Graph-Based Network Intrusion Detection,Computer and decision making.,10.1922/comdem.v3i3s.18688,3,evaluation,high,"Leakage-controlled cross-dataset protocol on NF-v2 datasets, port shortcut probes; substantially C1 and C2.",yes,partial,none,none,none,none,W7222889871
References/multiclass/2026_Xin_Multi_Class_Multi_Tier_Network_Intrusion_Detection_A_Compreh.pdf,core,2026,"Multi-Class, Multi-Tier Network Intrusion Detection: A Comprehensive and Reproducible Benchmark",arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2609.36039,3,multiclass,high,"Multi-tier binary/family/fine benchmark on corrected CIC-IDS2017 with leakage care; overlaps C5 and C2, not NetFlow.",yes,partial,partial,none,none,partial,W7214890733
References/evaluation/2026_Roy_Unmasking_Shortcut_Learning_in_IoT_Intrusion_Detection_A_For.pdf,core,2026,"Unmasking Shortcut Learning in IoT Intrusion Detection: A Forensic, Multi-Paradigm Evaluation of Feature Dependence and Data Leakage",arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2609.28725,3,evaluation,partial,"Shortcut/leakage audit with PCAP-disjoint splits on IoT flows; partial C1, different dataset.",yes,partial,partial,none,none,none,W7214314603
References/evaluation/2026_Galal_Provenance_Not_Behaviour_A_Serialisation_Artifact_in_Edge_II.pdf,core,2026,"Provenance, Not Behaviour: A Serialisation Artifact in Edge-IIoTset and a Leakage-Free Benchmark for Precision-Agriculture Intrusion Detection",arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2608.15761,3,evaluation,partial,"Serialisation shortcut artifact in Edge-IIoTset yielding perfect scores; source-shortcut audit, overlaps C1 concept.",yes,partial,partial,none,none,none,W7203697085
References/evaluation/2026_Hakim_Cross_Domain_Generalization_Failure_in_Lightweight_Intrusion.pdf,core,2026,Cross-Domain Generalization Failure in Lightweight Intrusion Detection Models for IIoT Networks,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2607.00553,3,evaluation,partial,"Cross-domain failure across three IIoT datasets, port shortcut via XAI; partial C1 and C2.",yes,partial,partial,none,none,none,W7167033814
References/evaluation/2026_Shaheen_Leakage_Aware_Evaluation_of_Intrusion_Detection_Systems_for_.pdf,core,2026,Leakage-Aware Evaluation of Intrusion Detection Systems for Rare and Unseen Attacks under Temporal Distribution Shift,International Journal of Electrical and Electronic Engineering & Telecommunications,10.18178/ijeetc.15.5.367-377,3,evaluation,partial,"Time-based split, leakage-free cleaning, duplicate filtering, class-weighted XGBoost on CSE-CIC-IDS2018; partial C1, C2, C3.",yes,partial,partial,partial,none,none,W7213984235
References/evaluation/2026_Elangovan_Cross_Dataset_Temporal_and_Semantic_Generalization_of_Intrus.pdf,core,2026,Cross-Dataset Temporal and Semantic Generalization of Intrusion Detection Models for the Future Internet,Future Internet,10.3390/fi18040194,3,evaluation,partial,"Temporal and cross-dataset generalization of IDS with macro-F1; overlaps C2, not NetFlow v3",yes,none,partial,none,none,none,W7148426725
References/evaluation/2026_Abdessamad_Feature_Selection_Versus_Feature_Extraction_for_IoT_Intrusio.pdf,core,2026,Feature Selection Versus Feature Extraction for IoT Intrusion Detection Under Temporal Evaluation,International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications,10.14569/ijacsa.2026.0170851,3,evaluation,partial,"Random vs temporal splits leakage on TON-IoT; supports C1/C2 time-based splits, not NetFlow v3.",yes,partial,partial,none,none,none,W7204709966
References/imbalance/2026_Wolf_Systematic_Evaluation_of_Synthetic_Data_Augmentation_for_Mul.pdf,core,2026,Systematic Evaluation of Synthetic Data Augmentation for Multi-class NetFlow Traffic,Communications in computer and information science,10.1007/978-3-032-25314-9_10,3,imbalance,high,"Synthetic augmentation evaluation for multi-class NetFlow; no abstract, likely overlaps C3; verify full text.",yes,none,none,partial,none,none,W4402706502
References/models/2026_Butt_Evaluating_Tabular_Representation_Learning_for_Network_Intru.pdf,core,2026,Evaluating Tabular Representation Learning for Network Intrusion Detection,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2605.02519,3,models,none,Systematic evaluation of tabular representation learning vs transformer baselines on NetFlow datasets; relevant baselines.,,,,,,,W7160250946
References/imbalance/2026_Dinh_Investigating_Oversampling_Techniques_to_Mitigate_Class_Imba.pdf,core,2026,Investigating Oversampling Techniques to Mitigate Class Imbalance in Network Intrusion Detection Datasets,Pragmatic Cybersecurity,10.53941/pc.2026.100004,3,imbalance,partial,Oversampling comparison on UNSW-NB15 and ToN-IoT; overlaps C3 but not NetFlow long tail,yes,none,none,partial,none,none,W7161289456
References/evaluation/2026_Youssef_Stream_Assembly_Is_an_Uncontrolled_Treatment_in_Streaming_In.pdf,core,2026,Stream Assembly Is an Uncontrolled Treatment in Streaming Intrusion-Detection Benchmarks,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2605.24696,3,evaluation,partial,"Stream assembly/split as uncontrolled treatment on CICIDS2017, LITNET; evaluation validity overlapping C1/C2 split concerns.",yes,partial,none,none,none,none,W7160519071
References/hierarchical/2026_Zhang_HCE_Boost_hierarchy_constrained_expert_boosting_for_imbalanc.pdf,core,2026,HCE-Boost: hierarchy-constrained expert boosting for imbalanced multiclass intrusion detection,Scientific Reports,10.1038/s41598-026-72791-6,3,hierarchical,partial,"Hierarchy-constrained expert boosting, leakage-controlled imbalanced multiclass; overlaps C5 and C3 partially.",yes,none,none,none,none,partial,W7214045367
References/datasets/2026_Uddin_BigFlow_NIDS_dataset_DataInBrief.pdf,core,2026,BigFlow-NIDS: A large-scale dataset for network intrusion detection in big data environment,Data in Brief,10.1016/j.dib.2026.112530,3,datasets,,the thesis dataset paper (provided by student),yes (read by assistant),,,,,,
References/hierarchical/2025_Kamal_Enhanced_Hybrid_Deep_Learning_Models_Based_Anomaly_Detection.pdf,core,2025,Enhanced Hybrid Deep Learning Models-Based Anomaly Detection Method for Two-Stage Binary and Multi-Class Classification of Attacks in Intrusion Detection Systems,Algorithms,10.3390/a18020069,3,hierarchical,partial,Two-stage binary then multi-class with SMOTE/ADASYN variants; partial C5 and C3.,yes,none,none,partial,none,partial,W4406907824
References/survey/2025_Goldschmidt_Network_intrusion_datasets_A_survey_limitations_and_recommen.pdf,core,2025,"Network intrusion datasets: A survey, limitations, and recommendations",Computers & Security,10.1016/j.cose.2025.104510,3,survey,none,2025 survey of network intrusion datasets with limitations; Chapter 2 core. Abstract missing.,,,,,,,W4410301505
References/datasets/2025_Joshua_MAWIFlow_Benchmark_Realistic_Flow_Based_Evaluation_for_Netwo.pdf,core,2025,MAWIFlow Benchmark: Realistic Flow-Based Evaluation for Network Intrusion Detection,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2506.17041,3,datasets,partial,Flow benchmark across 2011/2016/2021 with temporal drift; partial C2 time splits,,,,,,,W4417539490
References/evaluation/2025_Langendonck_PPT_GNN_A_Practical_Pretrained_Spatio_Temporal_Graph_Neural_.pdf,core,2025,PPT-GNN: A Practical Pretrained Spatio-Temporal Graph Neural Network for Network Security,IEEE European Symposium on Security and Privacy Workshops (EuroS&PW),10.1109/eurospw67616.2025.00026,3,evaluation,partial,"Flags leakage and overlapping-subgraph overestimation, temporal evaluation in GNN NIDS; partial C1 but GNN, not NetFlow v3 audit.",,,,,,,W4413886826
References/hierarchical/2025_Uddin_Hierarchical_classification_for_intrusion_detection_system_E.pdf,core,2025,Hierarchical classification for intrusion detection system: Effective design and empirical analysis,Ad Hoc Networks,10.1016/j.adhoc.2025.103982,3,hierarchical,high,Three-level benign/category/subtype hierarchical IDS vs flat; substantially C5; datasets unclear from abstract.,yes,none,none,none,none,substantial,W4413097839
References/hierarchical/2025_Vasudevan_Sequential_Binary_Classification_for_Intrusion_Detection.pdf,core,2025,Sequential Binary Classification for Intrusion Detection,IEEE International Conference on Machine Learning for Communication and Networking (ICMLCN),10.1109/icmlcn64995.2025.11139879,3,hierarchical,partial,Hierarchical cascade of binary classifiers for imbalance on IDS benchmarks; overlaps C5/C3.,yes,none,none,partial,none,partial,W4413967817
References/datasets/2025_Luay_Temporal_Analysis_of_NetFlow_Datasets_for_NIDS_arXiv2503.04404.pdf,seed,2025,Luay_Temporal_Analysis_of_NetFlow_Datasets_for_NIDS_arXiv2503.04404,arXiv,,3,manual,,added manually from the BigFlow reference list / seed list,,,,,,,
References/evaluation/2024_Cantone_Machine_Learning_in_Network_Intrusion_Detection_A_Cross_Data.pdf,core,2024,Machine Learning in Network Intrusion Detection: A Cross-Dataset Generalization Study,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2024.3472907,3,evaluation,partial,Cross-dataset generalisation of ML-NIDS on CIC datasets; overlaps C2 but not NetFlow v3.,,,,,,,W4403094383
References/evaluation/2024_Flood_Bad_Design_Smells_in_Benchmark_NIDS_Datasets.pdf,core,2024,Bad Design Smells in Benchmark NIDS Datasets,IEEE European Symposium on Security and Privacy,10.1109/eurosp60621.2024.00042,3,evaluation,partial,Audit of benchmark NIDS dataset design flaws and bias; overlaps C1 but not NetFlow v3,,,,,,,W4401752687
References/evaluation/2024_Sudyana_Quality_Analysis_in_IDS_Dataset_Impact_on_Model_Generalizati.pdf,core,2024,Quality Analysis in IDS Dataset: Impact on Model Generalization,IEEE Conference on Communications and Network Security,10.1109/cns62487.2024.10735570,3,evaluation,partial,"Label/contamination errors in CREMEv2 harming generalization; dataset quality audit relevant to C1, not NetFlow.",,,,,,,W4403937312
References/models/2023_Manocchio_FlowTransformer_A_transformer_framework_for_flow_based_netwo.pdf,core,2023,FlowTransformer: A transformer framework for flow-based network intrusion detection systems,Expert Systems with Applications,10.1016/j.eswa.2023.122564,3,models,none,FlowTransformer; transformer flow-NIDS framework evaluated on NetFlow datasets; model baseline.,,,,,,,W4388948449
References/hierarchical/2023_Verkerken_A_Novel_Multi_Stage_Approach_for_Hierarchical_Intrusion_Dete.pdf,core,2023,A Novel Multi-Stage Approach for Hierarchical Intrusion Detection,IEEE Transactions on Network and Service Management,10.1109/tnsm.2023.3259474,3,hierarchical,partial,"Multi-stage hierarchical IDS on CIC-2017/2018; partial C5, not NetFlow v3.",,,,,,,W4352976871
References/evaluation/2023_Layeghy_Explainable_Cross_domain_Evaluation_of_ML_based_Network_Intr.pdf,core,2023,Explainable Cross-domain Evaluation of ML-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems,Computers & Electrical Engineering,10.1016/j.compeleceng.2023.108692,3,evaluation,partial,"Cross-domain evaluation of ML NIDS; no abstract, judged by title; overlaps C2 cross-source.",,,,,,,W4361296232
References/evaluation/2023_Chua_Evaluation_of_Machine_Learning_Algorithms_in_Network_Based_I.pdf,core,2023,Evaluation of Machine Learning Algorithms in Network-Based Intrusion Detection Using Progressive Dataset,Symmetry,10.3390/sym15061251,3,evaluation,partial,Train-early test-later long-term ML-IDS evaluation; overlaps C2 temporal splits,,,,,,,W4380630221
References/evaluation/2023_Apruzzese_SoK_Pragmatic_Assessment_of_Machine_Learning_for_Network_Int.pdf,core,2023,SoK: Pragmatic Assessment of Machine Learning for Network Intrusion Detection,IEEE European Symposium on Security and Privacy,10.1109/eurosp57164.2023.00042,3,evaluation,partial,"SoK on pragmatic assessment of ML-NIDS; evaluation validity, partial C1/C2.",,,,,,,W4385412220
References/multiclass/2023_Bacevi_ius_Machine_Learning_Algorithms_for_Raw_and_Unbalanced_Intrusion.pdf,core,2023,Machine Learning Algorithms for Raw and Unbalanced Intrusion Detection Data in a Multi-Class Classification Problem,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app13127328,3,multiclass,partial,Multi-class on raw imbalanced CIC-IDS2017/2018 without merging classes; overlaps C2/C3.,,,,,,,W4381661839
References/evaluation/2023_Ceschin_Machine_Learning_In_Security_A_Stream_of_Problems.pdf,core,2023,Machine Learning (In) Security: A Stream of Problems,Digital Threats Research and Practice,10.1145/3617897,3,evaluation,none,"Pitfalls of ML in security: concept drift, evaluation, data collection; must-cite for validity.",,,,,,,W3097652319
References/evaluation/2023_D_hooge_Characterizing_the_Impact_of_Data_Damaged_Models_on_Generali.pdf,core,2023,Characterizing the Impact of Data-Damaged Models on Generalization Strength in Intrusion Detection,Journal of Cybersecurity and Privacy,10.3390/jcp3020008,3,evaluation,partial,"Cross-dataset generalization CICIDS2017 to CSE-CIC-IDS2018 across model families; partial C2 cross-source, not NetFlow v3.",,,,,,,W4362589953
References/evaluation/2022_Sarhan_Evaluating_Standard_Feature_Sets_Towards_Increased_Generalis.pdf,core,2022,Evaluating Standard Feature Sets Towards Increased Generalisability and Explainability of ML-Based Network Intrusion Detection,Big Data Research,10.1016/j.bdr.2022.100359,3,evaluation,partial,Standard feature sets and generalisability across datasets; partial C2. Abstract missing.,,,,,,,W3196585642
References/imbalance/2022_CENG_Z_Dengesiz_Ml_Tabanl_N_ds_Veri_Setlerinin_S_n_fland_rma_Perfor.pdf,core,2022,Dengesiz Ml-Tabanlı Nıds Veri Setlerinin Sınıflandırma Performanslarının Karşılaştırılması,European Journal of Science and Technology,10.31590/ejosat.1157441,3,imbalance,partial,"Binary classification on four NF datasets with undersampling; Turkish; partial C3, no leakage or LOSO",,,,,,,W4310649496
References/evaluation/2022_Carri_n_Improving_the_Reliability_of_Network_Intrusion_Detection_Sys.pdf,core,2022,Improving the Reliability of Network Intrusion Detection Systems Through Dataset Integration,IEEE Transactions on Emerging Topics in Computing,10.1109/tetc.2022.3178283,3,evaluation,partial,Dataset integration for NIDS generalization (UNK22 merged datasets); overlaps C1/C2 merged-dataset concerns,,,,,,,W4226502373
References/evaluation/2022_Apruzzese_The_Cross_Evaluation_of_Machine_Learning_Based_Network_Intru.pdf,seed,2022,The Cross-Evaluation of Machine Learning-Based Network Intrusion Detection Systems,IEEE Transactions on Network and Service Management,10.1109/tnsm.2022.3157344,3,evaluation,partial,Cross-evaluation model for ML-NIDS across labeled datasets; overlaps C2 cross-source evaluation.,,,,,,,W4220846496
References/evaluation/2022_D_hooge_Discovering_Non_Metadata_Contaminant_Features_in_Intrusion_D.pdf,core,2022,Discovering Non-Metadata Contaminant Features in Intrusion Detection Datasets,"Conference on Privacy, Security and Trust",10.1109/pst55820.2022.9851974,3,evaluation,partial,Contaminant/shortcut features across six IDS datasets via blind generalization; overlaps C1 but not NetFlow v3.,,,,,,,W4293093574
References/evaluation/2022_Layeghy_Benchmarking_the_Benchmark_Comparing_Synthetic_and_Real_Worl.pdf,seed,2022,Benchmarking the Benchmark - Comparing Synthetic and Real-World Network Ids Datasets,Journal of Information Security and Applications,10.1016/j.jisa.2023.103689,3,evaluation,partial,Benign-traffic statistics of synthetic vs real NIDS datasets; partial C1 dataset validity.,,,,,,,W4390517705
References/bigdata/2022_Abushwereb_An_accurate_IoT_Intrusion_Detection_Framework_using_Apache_S.pdf,core,2022,An accurate IoT Intrusion Detection Framework using Apache Spark,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2203.04347,3,bigdata,high,Spark MLlib IDS on full BoT-IoT (about 73M records); prior art for C4.,yes,none,none,none,partial,none,W4221139739
References/bigdata/2022_Atefinia_Performance_Evaluation_of_Apache_Spark_MLlib_Algorithms_on_a.pdf,core,2022,Performance Evaluation of Apache Spark MLlib Algorithms on an Intrusion Detection Dataset,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2212.05269,3,bigdata,partial,"Spark MLlib classifiers on CSE-CIC-IDS2018 (about 16M flows); partial C4, no learning curves or 60M+.",,,,,,,W4311411053
References/models/2022_Grinsztajn_Why_do_tree_based_models_still_outperform_deep_learning_on_t.pdf,seed,2022,Why do tree-based models still outperform deep learning on tabular data?,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2207.08815,3,models,none,Why trees beat DL on tabular data; GBM vs DL baseline justification.,,,,,,,W4286231567
References/datasets/2021_Sarhan_NetFlow_Datasets_for_Machine_Learning_Based_Network_Intrusio.pdf,seed,2021,NetFlow Datasets for Machine Learning-Based Network Intrusion Detection Systems,"Lecture notes of the Institute for Computer Sciences, Social Informatics and Telecommunications Engineering",10.1007/978-3-030-72802-1_9,3,datasets,none,"NF-UNSW/ToN/BoT/CSE NetFlow benchmark paper; foundation of C1. Abstract missing, judged by title.",,,,,,,W3102359135
References/datasets/2021_Sarhan_Towards_a_Standard_Feature_Set_for_Network_Intrusion_Detecti.pdf,seed,2021,Towards a Standard Feature Set for Network Intrusion Detection System Datasets,Mobile Networks and Applications,10.1007/s11036-021-01843-0,3,datasets,none,NetFlow standard feature set for NIDS datasets; basis of v2 datasets. Abstract missing.,,,,,,,W3161394766
References/evaluation/2021_Engelen_Troubleshooting_an_Intrusion_Detection_Dataset_the_CICIDS201.pdf,seed,2021,Troubleshooting an Intrusion Detection Dataset: the CICIDS2017 Case Study,IEEE Security and Privacy Workshops (SPW),10.1109/spw53761.2021.00009,3,evaluation,partial,"CICIDS2017 flow construction and label problems audit; partial C1, not NetFlow v3 or merged.",,,,,,,W3180062783
References/imbalance/2021_Bulavas_Study_of_Multi_Class_Classification_Algorithms_Performance_o.pdf,core,2021,Study of Multi-Class Classification Algorithms’ Performance on Highly Imbalanced Network Intrusion Datasets,Informatica,10.15388/21-infor457,3,imbalance,partial,Multi-class classifiers on highly imbalanced NIDS datasets keeping rare classes; partial C3 and C2.,,,,,,,W3198395019
References/models/2021_Shwartz_Ziv_Tabular_data_Deep_learning_is_not_all_you_need.pdf,core,2021,Tabular data: Deep learning is not all you need,Information Fusion,10.1016/j.inffus.2021.11.011,3,models,none,Tabular DL vs XGBoost; must-cite tabular baseline,,,,,,,W3172701880
References/models/2021_Gorishniy_Revisiting_Deep_Learning_Models_for_Tabular_Data.pdf,seed,2021,Revisiting Deep Learning Models for Tabular Data,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2106.11959,3,models,none,"Revisiting tabular DL (FT-Transformer, ResNet baselines); tabular DL baseline.",,,,,,,W3174082502
References/datasets/2020_Alsaedi_TON_IoT_Telemetry_Dataset_A_New_Generation_Dataset_of_IoT_an.pdf,seed,2020,TON_IoT Telemetry Dataset: A New Generation Dataset of IoT and IIoT for Data-Driven Intrusion Detection Systems,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2020.3022862,3,datasets,none,"TON_IoT dataset paper; source of NF-ToN-IoT, multi-class labels.",,,,,,,W3085955590
References/evaluation/2020_Daniel_Dos_and_Don_ts_of_Machine_Learning_in_Computer_Security.pdf,seed,2020,Dos and Don'ts of Machine Learning in Computer Security,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2010.09470,3,evaluation,partial,"ML-security pitfalls (leakage, sampling bias); general, supports C1 motivation, not NetFlow-specific.",,,,,,,W3092978542
References/imbalance/2020_Mulyanto_Effectiveness_of_Focal_Loss_for_Minority_Classification_in_N.pdf,core,2020,Effectiveness of Focal Loss for Minority Classification in Network Intrusion Detection Systems,Symmetry,10.3390/sym13010004,3,imbalance,partial,Focal loss for NIDS minority classes on NSL-KDD/UNSW/Bot-IoT; prior art for focal in C3.,,,,,,,W3116162736
References/imbalance/2020_Menon_Long_tail_learning_via_logit_adjustment.pdf,seed,2020,Long-tail learning via logit adjustment,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2007.07314,3,imbalance,none,Logit adjustment for long-tail; C3 strategy.,,,,,,,W3042496707
References/hierarchical/2020_Sarnovsk_Hierarchical_Intrusion_Detection_Using_Machine_Learning_and_.pdf,core,2020,Hierarchical Intrusion Detection Using Machine Learning and Knowledge Model,Symmetry,10.3390/sym12020203,3,hierarchical,partial,"Multi-stage hierarchical IDS: normal vs attack, class, type; partial C5, older datasets.",,,,,,,W3003727567
References/hierarchical/2020_Zhong_Applying_big_data_based_deep_learning_system_to_intrusion_de.pdf,core,2020,Applying big data based deep learning system to intrusion detection,Big Data Mining and Analytics,10.26599/bdma.2020.9020003,3,hierarchical,partial,Big-data hierarchical deep learning system for small-sample attacks; overlaps C5 and C4 but not NetFlow v3.,,,,,,,W3042945059
References/datasets/2019_Ring_A_survey_of_network_based_intrusion_detection_data_sets.pdf,seed,2019,A survey of network-based intrusion detection data sets,Computers & Security,10.1016/j.cose.2019.06.005,3,datasets,none,Key survey of network-based IDS datasets (Ring et al.). Abstract missing.,,,,,,,W2924689635
References/datasets/2019_Koroniotis_Towards_the_development_of_realistic_botnet_dataset_in_the_I.pdf,seed,2019,Towards the development of realistic botnet dataset in the Internet of Things for network forensic analytics: Bot-IoT dataset,Future Generation Computer Systems,10.1016/j.future.2019.05.041,3,datasets,none,"Bot-IoT dataset paper; source of NF-BoT-IoT. Abstract missing, judged by title.",,,,,,,W2898761242
References/imbalance/2019_Cui_Class_Balanced_Loss_Based_on_Effective_Number_of_Samples.pdf,seed,2019,Class-Balanced Loss Based on Effective Number of Samples,IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition/Proceedings - IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition/Proceedings,10.1109/cvpr.2019.00949,3,imbalance,none,"Class-balanced loss, effective number; C3 imbalance strategy foundation.",,,,,,,W2963691377
References/models/2019_Xu_Modeling_Tabular_data_using_Conditional_GAN.pdf,core,2019,Modeling Tabular data using Conditional GAN,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.1907.00503,3,models,none,CTGAN tabular synthesis; foundational generative oversampler baseline.,,,,,,,W2954395498
References/imbalance/2018_Douzas_Improving_imbalanced_learning_through_a_heuristic_oversampli.pdf,seed,2018,Improving imbalanced learning through a heuristic oversampling method based on k-means and SMOTE,Information Sciences,10.1016/j.ins.2018.06.056,2,imbalance,none,k-means SMOTE; SMOTE variant candidate for C3. Abstract missing.,,,,,,,W2766296277
References/imbalance/2018_Fern_ndez_SMOTE_for_Learning_from_Imbalanced_Data_Progress_and_Challen.pdf,seed,2018,"SMOTE for Learning from Imbalanced Data: Progress and Challenges, Marking the 15-year Anniversary",Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research,10.1613/jair.1.11192,2,imbalance,none,SMOTE 15-year review; SMOTE variants background for C3.,,,,,,,W2800788706
References/models/2018_Mirsky_Kitsune_Ensemble_of_Autoencoders_arXiv1802.09089.pdf,seed,2018,Mirsky_Kitsune_Ensemble_of_Autoencoders_arXiv1802.09089,arXiv,,3,manual,,added manually from the BigFlow reference list / seed list,,,,,,,
References/imbalance/2016_Branco_A_Survey_of_Predictive_Modeling_on_Imbalanced_Domains.pdf,core,2016,A Survey of Predictive Modeling on Imbalanced Domains,ACM Computing Surveys,10.1145/2907070,3,imbalance,none,Survey of predictive modeling on imbalanced domains; foundational for C3.,,,,,,,W2490420619
References/models/2016_Chen_XGBoost.pdf,core,2016,XGBoost,ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining (KDD),10.1145/2939672.2939785,3,models,none,XGBoost: must-cite GBM baseline,,,,,,,W2295598076
References/bigdata/2015_Meng_MLlib_Machine_Learning_in_Apache_Spark.pdf,core,2015,MLlib: Machine Learning in Apache Spark,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.1505.06807,3,bigdata,none,MLlib paper; must-cite for Spark pipeline (C4).,,,,,,,W410850256
References/models/2014_Chen_xgboost_Extreme_Gradient_Boosting.pdf,seed,2014,xgboost: Extreme Gradient Boosting,,10.32614/cran.package.xgboost,2,models,none,R package entry for XGBoost; cite original paper; GBM baseline.,,,,,,,W4399647672
References/imbalance/2002_Chawla_SMOTE_Synthetic_Minority_Over_sampling_Technique.pdf,seed,2002,SMOTE: Synthetic Minority Over-sampling Technique,Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research,10.1613/jair.953,3,imbalance,none,Original SMOTE; foundational for C3.,,,,,,,W2148143831
References/datasets/2026_Almusawy_Intrusion_Detection_in_Industrial_IoT_Networks_using_NetFlow.pdf,background,2026,Intrusion Detection in Industrial IoT Networks using NetFlow and Machine Learning Techniques on the NF-ToN-IoT-v2 Dataset,Basrah Researches Sciences,10.56714/bjrs.52.1.9,2,datasets,partial,"ML on NF-ToN-IoT-v2 with imbalance handling; single source, partial C3.",,,,,,,W7166873127
References/evaluation/2026_Dharini_Efficient_detection_of_intrusions_in_TON_IoT_dataset_using_h.pdf,background,2026,Efficient detection of intrusions in TON-IoT dataset using hybrid feature selection approach,Scientific Reports,10.1038/s41598-026-37834-y,2,evaluation,partial,"TON-IoT removing IP/port identifiers to curb bias; touches C1 shortcut idea, single dataset.",,,,,,,W7128193682
References/evaluation/2026_Kamal_Shared_Autoencoder_Based_Unified_Intrusion_Detection_Across_.pdf,background,2026,Shared Autoencoder-Based Unified Intrusion Detection Across Heterogeneous Datasets for Binary and Multi-Class Classification Using a Hybrid CNN–DNN Model,Machine Learning and Knowledge Extraction,10.3390/make8020053,2,evaluation,partial,"Unified model across CSE-CIC-2018, NF-BoT-IoT-v2, IoT-23, binary and multiclass; partial C2 cross-dataset.",,,,,,,W7131094981
References/evaluation/2026_Martins_Feature_Relevance_is_Contextual_A_Class_Specific_and_Cross_D.pdf,background,2026,Feature Relevance is Contextual: A Class-Specific and Cross-Dataset Analysis for Network Intrusion Detection,Simpósio Brasileiro de Cibersegurança (SBSeg),10.5753/sbseg.2026.27016,2,evaluation,partial,"Class-specific, cross-dataset feature relevance analysis; partial C2 cross-source insight.",,,,,,,W7223091622
References/evaluation/2026_Ruohonen_Lost_in_Translation_Intrusion_Detection_Research_with_Kaggle.pdf,background,2026,Lost in Translation: Intrusion Detection Research with “Kaggle Datasets”,,10.33774/coe-2026-hd0xx,2,evaluation,partial,Position paper on Kaggle IDS dataset provenance and reproducibility; C1 background.,,,,,,,W7162204548
References/hierarchical/2026_Mahdi_SCDF_CNN_BiGRU_A_Spatial_Contextual_Dual_Feature_Fusion_Fram.pdf,background,2026,SCDF-CNN-BiGRU: A Spatial-Contextual Dual Feature Fusion Framework for Multi dataset Hierarchical Network Intrusion Detection,Journal of Engineering,10.31026/j.eng.2026.09.12,2,hierarchical,partial,Hierarchical multi-dataset CNN-BiGRU NIDS; partial C5.,,,,,,,W7206197252
References/evaluation/2026_Yuszairulakhbar_Large_Scale_Binary_Network_Intrusion_Classification_Using_a_.pdf,background,2026,Large-Scale Binary Network Intrusion Classification Using a 1D Convolutional Neural Network on CSE-CIC-IDS2018: Performance Evaluation and Methodological Audit,International Journal of Research and Innovation in Applied Science,10.51584/ijrias.2026.11080099,2,evaluation,partial,1D-CNN on CSE2018 with methodological audit incl. SMOTE; partial C1.,,,,,,,W7212320986
References/evaluation/2026_Shaik_LightGBM_Based_Intrusion_Detection_on_the_UNSW_NB15_Dataset_.pdf,background,2026,LightGBM-Based Intrusion Detection on the UNSW-NB15 Dataset: Feature Selection and Evaluation Across Validation Protocols,International Journal of Intelligent Systems and Data Science,10.67231/f3fc1g20,2,evaluation,partial,LightGBM on UNSW-NB15 across validation protocols; partial C1 evaluation validity.,,,,,,,W7203998378
References/evaluation/2026_Bilal_Dataset_centric_evaluation_of_federated_intrusion_detection_.pdf,background,2026,Dataset-centric evaluation of federated intrusion detection models in IoT networks,Scientific Reports,10.1038/s41598-025-32567-w,2,evaluation,partial,"Cross-dataset federated IDS evaluation on three IoT datasets with label harmonisation; partial C2, not NetFlow v3.",,,,,,,W7124437390
References/evaluation/2026_Alsarayreh_An_Improved_Explainable_Hybrid_CNN_LSTM_Framework_with_Leaka.pdf,background,2026,An Improved Explainable Hybrid CNN–LSTM Framework with Leakage-Aware Evaluation for Network Traffic Intrusion Detection,Engineering Technology & Applied Science Research,10.48084/etasr.18257,2,evaluation,partial,"Leakage-aware CNN-LSTM, merged dataset; binary only; partial C1.",,,,,,,W7202241647
References/imbalance/2026_Khudhur_Machine_learning_approaches_for_intrusion_Detection_in_IOT_n.pdf,background,2026,Machine learning approaches for intrusion Detection in IOT networks,مجلة الشرق الأوسط للعلوم الإنسانية والثقافية,10.56961/mejhss.v6i3.1740,2,imbalance,partial,SMOTE inside CV on multiclass CICIoT2023 with GBMs; partial C3.,,,,,,,W7214548189
References/evaluation/2026_Moczkodan_Do_Transformers_Actually_Help_Intrusion_Detection_A_Temporal.pdf,background,2026,Do Transformers Actually Help Intrusion Detection? A Temporal Sequence Evaluation on CIC-IDS2017,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2606.11098,2,evaluation,partial,Transformers vs classical on CIC-IDS2017 with leakage-free splits; partial C1/C5 baselines.,,,,,,,W7164181721
References/evaluation/2026_Hakim_Cross_Domain_Generalization_Failure_in_Lightweight_Intrusion.pdf,background,2026,Cross-Domain Generalization Failure in Lightweight Intrusion Detection Models for IIoT Networks,SSRN Electronic Journal,10.2139/ssrn.7030580,2,evaluation,partial,"Cross-domain generalisation failure in IIoT; no abstract, judged by title; partial C2.",,,,,,,W7171654082
References/evaluation/2026_Alsaedi_Bidirectional_Cross_Dataset_Generalization_and_Label_Efficie.pdf,background,2026,Bidirectional Cross-Dataset Generalization and Label-Efficient Adaptation for 5G Network Intrusion Detection,Wadi Alshatti University Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences,10.5281/zenodo.21678600,2,evaluation,partial,Bidirectional cross-dataset generalization for 5G NIDS; partial C2.,,,,,,,W7171734614
References/hierarchical/2026_Alenezi_Adversarially_Robust_Hierarchical_Intrusion_Detection_Using_.pdf,background,2026,Adversarially Robust Hierarchical Intrusion Detection Using Hybrid Deep Learning and Metaheuristic Optimization,Research Square,10.21203/rs.3.rs-9314868/v1,2,hierarchical,partial,"Hierarchical hybrid DL with focal loss and robustness; preprint, partial C3 and C5.",,,,,,,W7160390472
References/evaluation/2026_Wang_Bias_in_the_Shadows_Explore_Shortcuts_in_Encrypted_Network_T.pdf,background,2026,Bias in the Shadows: Explore Shortcuts in Encrypted Network Traffic Classification,International Workshop on Quality of Service,10.1109/iwqos70441.2026.11661209,2,evaluation,partial,"Shortcut features in encrypted traffic datasets; analogous to C1 but raw-byte NTC, not NetFlow.",,,,,,,W7124434574
References/evaluation/2026_Choi_Mitigating_Cross_Domain_Performance_Degradation_in_Time_Seri.pdf,background,2026,Mitigating Cross-Domain Performance Degradation in Time-Series NIDS via LoRA,Electronics,10.3390/electronics15132773,2,evaluation,partial,Cross-domain degradation across benchmark datasets with LoRA adaptation; partial C2.,,,,,,,W7165734575
References/evaluation/2026_Vo_Evaluating_Long_Term_Performance_of_ML_based_Intrusion_Detec.pdf,background,2026,Evaluating Long-Term Performance of ML-based Intrusion Detection Systems under Temporal and Structural Changes,Tạp chí Khoa học và Công nghệ Trường Đại học Công nghệ Đông Á,10.65153/bw356376,2,evaluation,partial,Chronological split evaluation of ML IDS on CIC17/18 and LUFlow; partial C2.,,,,,,,W7155647202
References/evaluation/2026_Spanos_Evaluating_ML_based_Intrusion_Detection_Systems_The_Illusion.pdf,background,2026,Evaluating ML-based Intrusion Detection Systems: The Illusion of Model Efficacy,arXiv (Cornell University),,2,evaluation,partial,Generalization to unseen attacks exposes illusion of efficacy; partial C2 holdout evaluation.,,,,,,,W7208794462
References/hierarchical/2026_Nagaraju_AI_Driven_NIDS_A_Flow_Based_Approach_to_Threat_Detection.pdf,background,2026,AI-Driven NIDS: A Flow-Based Approach to Threat Detection,International Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology,10.22214/ijraset.2026.79633,2,hierarchical,partial,Confidence-gated cascade on merged CIC-IDS flows; 5 classes; relates to C5 only loosely.,,,,,,,W7153494527
References/evaluation/2026_Lazi_Evaluating_transferability_of_machine_learning_models_for_DD.pdf,background,2026,Evaluating transferability of machine learning models for DDoS detection,Repository of the University of Primorsk (University of Primorska),,2,evaluation,partial,Cross-domain transferability of 13 ML-NIDS to real traffic; overlaps C2 generalisation gap.,,,,,,,W7221486211
References/hierarchical/2026_Mchina_Adaptive_Decision_Level_Intrusion_Detection_for_Known_and_Ze.pdf,background,2026,Adaptive Decision-Level Intrusion Detection for Known and Zero-Day Attacks,Network,10.3390/network6020023,2,hierarchical,partial,Hierarchical CNN plus autoencoder cascade on CSE-CIC-IDS2018; partial C5.,,,,,,,W7153199326
References/imbalance/2026_Singh_GENIE_IDS_Failure_steered_Closed_loop_Generative_discriminat.pdf,background,2026,GENIE-IDS: Failure-steered Closed-loop Generative-discriminative Learning for Long-tailed Network Intrusion Detection,International journal of intelligent engineering and systems,10.22266/ijies2026.1130.59,2,imbalance,partial,Generative augmentation for long-tail NIDS with group-aware splits; partial C3.,,,,,,,W7222759799
References/imbalance/2026_Kwari_Enhanced_multiclass_intrusion_detection_on_imbalanced_IoT_Ne.pdf,background,2026,Enhanced multiclass intrusion detection on imbalanced IoT NetFlow traffic using a three-tier stacked time-distributed LSTM with SMOTENC-based class balancing,Scientific Reports,10.1038/s41598-026-75619-5,2,imbalance,partial,"SMOTENC with stacked LSTM on NF-BoT-IoT under leakage-free protocol; partial C3, small class set.",,,,,,,W7223152107
References/imbalance/2026_Sutradhar_Systematically_Optimized_CNN_Transformer_with_Focal_Loss_for.pdf,background,2026,Systematically Optimized CNN-Transformer with Focal Loss for Imbalanced Intrusion Detection on NSL-KDD,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2610.08066,2,imbalance,partial,"Focal loss vs SMOTE ablation on NSL-KDD; partial C3, old dataset.",,,,,,,W7220902461
References/imbalance/2026_Debelie_Class_Specific_GAN_Based_Minority_Data_Augmentation_for_Cybe.pdf,background,2026,Class-Specific GAN-Based Minority Data Augmentation for Cyberattack Detection Using the UWF-ZeekData22 Dataset,Technologies,10.3390/technologies14020117,2,imbalance,partial,Class-specific GAN augmentation on Zeek data; partial C3,,,,,,,W7128737348
References/imbalance/2026_Debelie_Class_Specific_GAN_Augmentation_for_Imbalanced_Intrusion_Det.pdf,background,2026,Class-Specific GAN Augmentation for Imbalanced Intrusion Detection: A Comparative Study Using the UWF-ZeekData22 Dataset,Future Internet,10.3390/fi18040200,2,imbalance,partial,GAN-variant augmentation comparison on UWF-ZeekData22 extreme imbalance; overlaps C3 partially.,,,,,,,W7152990282
References/hierarchical/2026_Mortatha_Hybrid_WOA_boosting_and_GNN_Framework_for_Multi_protocol_IoT.pdf,background,2026,Hybrid WOA-boosting and GNN Framework for Multi-protocol IoT Intrusion Detection and Attack Classification Using the CICIoMT-2024 Dataset,International journal of intelligent engineering and systems,10.22266/ijies2026.0630.25,2,hierarchical,partial,"Hierarchical binary-family-subtype on CICIoMT2024; partial C5, not NetFlow.",,,,,,,W7165775483
References/evaluation/2026_Rodr_guez_A_rule_based_label_harmonization_framework_for_cross_dataset.pdf,background,2026,A rule-based label harmonization framework for cross-dataset IoT intrusion detection,Internet of Things,10.1016/j.iot.2026.102030,2,evaluation,partial,"Cross-dataset IoT evaluation with label harmonization; overlaps C2 generalisation, not NetFlow.",,,,,,,W7170171081
References/evaluation/2026_Hung_An_Explainable_XGBoost_Based_Framework_for_IoT_Attack_Detect.pdf,background,2026,An Explainable XGBoost-Based Framework for IoT Attack Detection with Unseen Attack Family Evaluation,Sensors,10.3390/s26103005,2,evaluation,partial,XGBoost with unseen attack family evaluation on CICIoT2023; partial overlap C2 generalisation.,,,,,,,W7160875250
References/datasets/2025_Veerabhadrappa_Enhancing_Network_Security_with_a_Multi_Modal_Auto_Encoder_f.pdf,background,2025,Enhancing Network Security with a Multi-Modal Auto-Encoder for Netflow Traffic Analysis,Informatica,10.31449/inf.v49i18.9727,2,datasets,partial,Multimodal autoencoder merging latent spaces across NetFlow datasets; partial C1/C2 context,,,,,,,W4417308568
References/models/2025_Kamal_AE_DTNN_Autoencoder_Dense_Transformer_Neural_Network_Model_f.pdf,background,2025,AE-DTNN: Autoencoder–Dense–Transformer Neural Network Model for Efficient Anomaly-Based Intrusion Detection Systems,Machine Learning and Knowledge Extraction,10.3390/make7030078,2,models,partial,"Transformer with ADASYN-ENN and class weights on NF-BoT-IoT-v2; partial C3, single dataset.",,,,,,,W4413008541
References/models/2025_Lu_a_TE_G_SAGE_Explainable_Edge_Aware_Graph_Neural_Networks_for_N.pdf,background,2025,TE-G-SAGE: Explainable Edge-Aware Graph Neural Networks for Network Intrusion Detection,Modelling—International Open Access Journal of Modelling in Engineering Science,10.3390/modelling6040165,2,models,partial,Explainable GNN on NF-UNSW-NB15-v3 with chronological evaluation vs XGBoost; touches C2 time split.,,,,,,,W4417277139
References/hierarchical/2025_Yan_Adversarial_Hierarchical_Aware_Edge_Attention_Learning_Metho.pdf,background,2025,Adversarial Hierarchical-Aware Edge Attention Learning Method for Network Intrusion Detection,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app15147915,2,hierarchical,partial,"Graph edge attention with hierarchical multi-grained detection module; partial C5, likely NetFlow data, abstract truncated.",,,,,,,W4412473253
References/imbalance/2025_Menssouri_A_Conditional_Tabular_GAN_Enhanced_Intrusion_Detection_Syste.pdf,background,2025,A Conditional Tabular GAN-Enhanced Intrusion Detection System for Rare Attacks in IoT Networks,IEEE International Conference on Communications workshops,10.1109/iccworkshops67674.2025.11162182,2,imbalance,partial,CTGAN+SMOTEENN for rare attacks on CSE-CIC-IDS2018; overlaps C3 partially.,,,,,,,W4414406220
References/imbalance/2025_Nawaz_Multi_Class_Network_Intrusion_Detection_with_Class_Imbalance.pdf,background,2025,Multi-Class Network Intrusion Detection with Class Imbalance via LSTM & SMOTE,IEEE International Conference on High Performance Computing and Communications; IEEE International Conference on Smart City; IEEE International Conference on Data Science and Systems (HPCC/SmartCity/DSS),10.1109/hpcc67675.2025.00123,2,imbalance,partial,LSTM with SMOTE and focal loss multiclass; partial C3,,,,,,,W4415745540
References/multiclass/2025_ALzaher_Intrusion_Detection_Using_Machine_Learning_and_Deep_Learning.pdf,background,2025,Intrusion Detection Using Machine Learning and Deep Learning,International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications,10.14569/ijacsa.2025.0160844,2,multiclass,partial,"ML/DL with SMOTE binary and multiclass on NF-UNSW-NB15-v2; partial C2/C3, random split, no audit.",,,,,,,W4413953771
References/imbalance/2025_Li_Mitigating_Class_Imbalance_in_Network_Intrusion_Detection_wi.pdf,background,2025,Mitigating Class Imbalance in Network Intrusion Detection with Feature-Regularized GANs,Future Internet,10.3390/fi17050216,2,imbalance,partial,Feature-regularized GAN augmentation vs SMOTE/ADASYN on CIC datasets; partial C3.,,,,,,,W4410317035
References/imbalance/2025_Wang_CSCVAE_NID_A_Conditionally_Symmetric_Two_Stage_CVAE_Framewor.pdf,background,2025,CSCVAE-NID: A Conditionally Symmetric Two-Stage CVAE Framework with Cost-Sensitive Learning for Imbalanced Network Intrusion Detection,Entropy,10.3390/e27111086,2,imbalance,partial,Two-stage CVAE augmentation plus cost-sensitive learning; overlaps C3 partially.,,,,,,,W4415412514
References/imbalance/2025_Anbiaee_FIGS_A_Realistic_Intrusion_Detection_Framework_for_Highly_Im.pdf,background,2025,FIGS: A Realistic Intrusion-Detection Framework for Highly Imbalanced IoT Environments,Electronics,10.3390/electronics14142917,2,imbalance,partial,GAN plus SMOTE for highly imbalanced IoT IDS; partial C3 oversampling comparison.,,,,,,,W4412530720
References/imbalance/2025_Al_Ajlan_GAN_AHR_A_GAN_Based_Adaptive_Hybrid_Resampling_Algorithm_for.pdf,background,2025,GAN-AHR: A GAN-Based Adaptive Hybrid Resampling Algorithm for Imbalanced Intrusion Detection,Electronics,10.3390/electronics14173476,2,imbalance,partial,CGAN/BSMOTE adaptive resampling on NF-UNSW-NB15; touches C3 on a single NetFlow dataset.,,,,,,,W4413885283
References/hierarchical/2025_Uddin_A_Scalable_Hierarchical_Intrusion_Detection_System_for_Inter.pdf,background,2025,A Scalable Hierarchical Intrusion Detection System for Internet of Vehicles,IEEE Internet of Things Journal,10.1109/jiot.2025.3590966,2,hierarchical,partial,"Hierarchical classification IDS for IoV edge/cloud; partial C5, vehicular domain.",,,,,,,W4413267776
References/hierarchical/2025_Mahmoud_XI2S_IDS_An_Explainable_Intelligent_2_Stage_Intrusion_Detect.pdf,background,2025,XI2S-IDS: An Explainable Intelligent 2-Stage Intrusion Detection System,Future Internet,10.3390/fi17010025,2,hierarchical,partial,Two-stage binary then multiclass IDS with SHAP for low-frequency attacks; partial C5.,,,,,,,W4406181061
References/models/2025_Hollmann_Accurate_predictions_on_small_data_with_a_tabular_foundation.pdf,background,2025,Accurate predictions on small data with a tabular foundation model,Nature,10.1038/s41586-024-08328-6,2,models,none,"TabPFN tabular foundation model; small-data limit, optional baseline.",,,,,,,W4406170795
References/evaluation/2025_Mohammed_The_effects_of_data_quality_on_machine_learning_performance_.pdf,background,2025,The effects of data quality on machine learning performance on tabular data,Information Systems,10.1016/j.is.2025.102549,2,evaluation,none,Data quality effects on tabular ML performance; background for label noise/duplicates arguments.,,,,,,,W4408444355
References/imbalance/2025_Luo_An_Improved_Binary_Simulated_Annealing_Algorithm_and_TPE_FL_.pdf,background,2025,An Improved Binary Simulated Annealing Algorithm and TPE-FL-LightGBM for Fast Network Intrusion Detection,Electronics,10.3390/electronics14020231,2,imbalance,partial,"Focal-loss LightGBM for imbalance; GBM plus focal, partial C3",,,,,,,W4406179827
References/imbalance/2024_Kamal_Advanced_Hybrid_Transformer_CNN_Deep_Learning_Model_for_Effe.pdf,background,2024,Advanced Hybrid Transformer-CNN Deep Learning Model for Effective Intrusion Detection Systems with Class Imbalance Mitigation Using Resampling Techniques,Future Internet,10.3390/fi16120481,2,imbalance,partial,Hybrid Transformer-CNN with resampling for imbalance; partial overlap with C3.,,,,,,,W4405722007
References/imbalance/2024_Talukder_Machine_learning_based_network_intrusion_detection_for_big_a.pdf,background,2024,"Machine learning-based network intrusion detection for big and imbalanced data using oversampling, stacking feature embedding and feature extraction",arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2401.12262,2,imbalance,partial,"Random oversampling plus stacking on big imbalanced data, UNSW-NB15/CIC datasets; partial C3, not NetFlow.",,,,,,,W4391212083
References/hierarchical/2024_Alsharaiah_An_innovative_network_intrusion_detection_system_NIDS_Hierar.pdf,background,2024,An innovative network intrusion detection system (NIDS): Hierarchical deep learning model based on Unsw-Nb15 dataset,International Journal of Data and Network Science,10.5267/j.ijdns.2024.1.007,2,hierarchical,partial,"Hierarchical LSTM-attention on UNSW-NB15; binary results, partial C5",,,,,,,W4391012104
References/imbalance/2024_Atuhurra_Dealing_with_Imbalanced_Classes_in_Bot_IoT_Dataset.pdf,background,2024,Dealing with Imbalanced Classes in Bot-IoT Dataset,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2403.18989,2,imbalance,partial,SMOTE on Bot-IoT binary; touches C3 on single dataset.,,,,,,,W4393335283
References/evaluation/2024_Sudyana_Improving_Generalization_of_ML_Based_IDS_With_Lifecycle_Base.pdf,background,2024,"Improving Generalization of ML-Based IDS With Lifecycle-Based Dataset, Auto-Learning Features, and Deep Learning",IEEE Transactions on Machine Learning in Communications and Networking,10.1109/tmlcn.2024.3402158,2,evaluation,partial,"Cross-dataset generalization via lifecycle dataset and CNN on five datasets; not NetFlow v3, touches C2",,,,,,,W4396982373
References/evaluation/2024_Medina_Arco_Methodology_for_the_Detection_of_Contaminated_Training_Datas.pdf,background,2024,Methodology for the Detection of Contaminated Training Datasets for Machine Learning-Based Network Intrusion-Detection Systems,Sensors,10.3390/s24020479,2,evaluation,partial,"Detects contaminated labels in UGR'16 training data; label-quality validity, relates to C1.",,,,,,,W4390788944
References/imbalance/2024_Shanmugam_Addressing_Class_Imbalance_in_Intrusion_Detection_A_Comprehe.pdf,background,2024,Addressing Class Imbalance in Intrusion Detection: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Machine Learning Approaches,Electronics,10.3390/electronics14010069,2,imbalance,partial,"Resampling vs ML under varying imbalance on flow data; overlaps C3 partly, dataset unclear.",,,,,,,W4405849044
References/imbalance/2024_Mel_cias_GPT_and_Interpolation_Based_Data_Augmentation_for_Multiclass.pdf,background,2024,GPT and Interpolation-Based Data Augmentation for Multiclass Intrusion Detection in IIoT,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2024.3360879,2,imbalance,partial,GPT and SMOTE variant augmentation multiclass on IIoT; overlaps C3 but not NetFlow.,,,,,,,W4391454421
References/hierarchical/2024_Dhar_Cascaded_Machine_Learning_Approach_with_Data_Augmentation_fo.pdf,background,2024,Cascaded Machine Learning Approach with Data Augmentation for Intrusion Detection System,International Journal of Computer Network and Information Security,10.5815/ijcnis.2024.04.02,2,hierarchical,partial,"Two-step cascaded IDS with subclass attack classification and augmentation; partial C5, dataset unknown from abstract.",,,,,,,W4401219835
References/bigdata/2024_Elmoutaoukkil_Network_intrusion_detection_in_big_datasets_using_Spark_envi.pdf,background,2024,Network intrusion detection in big datasets using Spark environment and incremental learning,IAES International Journal of Artificial Intelligence,10.11591/ijai.v13.i4.pp4414-4421,2,bigdata,partial,Spark incremental LDA on UNSW-NB15; overlaps C4 but small dataset.,,,,,,,W4403209765
References/drift_xai/2024_Amalapuram_SOUL_A_Semi_supervised_Open_world_continUal_Learning_method_.pdf,background,2024,SOUL: A Semi-supervised Open-world continUal Learning method for Network Intrusion Detection,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2412.00911,2,drift_xai,partial,Continual learning NID showing temporal performance decay; partial C2 time splits.,,,,,,,W4405033686
References/survey/2023_Bilot_Graph_Neural_Networks_for_Intrusion_Detection_A_Survey.pdf,background,2023,Graph Neural Networks for Intrusion Detection: A Survey,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2023.3275789,2,survey,none,GNN-IDS survey; background on graph-based alternatives.,,,,,,,W4376480418
References/evaluation/2023_Kelani_Feature_Based_Transfer_Learning_Intrusion_Detection_System.pdf,background,2023,Feature Based Transfer Learning Intrusion Detection System.,The Atrium (University of Guelph),,2,evaluation,partial,Cross-dataset transfer CICIDS2018 to USB-IDS; overlaps C2 cross-source idea but feature learning only.,,,,,,,W7201915980
References/imbalance/2023_Jamoos_A_New_Data_Balancing_Approach_Based_on_Generative_Adversaria.pdf,background,2023,A New Data-Balancing Approach Based on Generative Adversarial Network for Network Intrusion Detection System,Electronics,10.3390/electronics12132851,2,imbalance,partial,GAN-based data balancing for NIDS; partial C3 oversampling comparison.,,,,,,,W4382402531
References/datasets/2023_Neto_CICIoT2023_A_Real_Time_Dataset_and_Benchmark_for_Large_Scale.pdf,background,2023,CICIoT2023: A Real-Time Dataset and Benchmark for Large-Scale Attacks in IoT Environment,Sensors,10.3390/s23135941,2,datasets,none,"CICIoT2023 dataset; background, not NetFlow v3",,,,,,,W4382281941
References/datasets/2023_Sebastian_Towards_a_better_labeling_process_for_network_security_datas.pdf,background,2023,Towards a better labeling process for network security datasets,arXiv (Cornell University),10.48550/arxiv.2305.01337,2,datasets,partial,Labeling ontology for network datasets; relates to label validity (C1 background).,,,,,,,W4367860298
References/imbalance/2023_Balla_The_Effect_of_Dataset_Imbalance_on_the_Performance_of_SCADA_.pdf,background,2023,The Effect of Dataset Imbalance on the Performance of SCADA Intrusion Detection Systems,Sensors,10.3390/s23020758,2,imbalance,partial,"Compares OSS, NearMiss, SMOTE, ADASYN on CICIDS2017 and SCADA; binary only, partial C3.",,,,,,,W4313828799
References/multiclass/2023_Alkadi_Toward_Improved_Machine_Learning_Based_Intrusion_Detection_f.pdf,background,2023,Toward Improved Machine Learning-Based Intrusion Detection for Internet of Things Traffic,Computers,10.3390/computers12080148,2,multiclass,partial,"Multiclass IoT IDS on UNSW, BoT, ToN, Edge-IIoT preprocessing impact; weak C2 overlap.",,,,,,,W4385345588
References/imbalance/2023_Rao_An_Imbalanced_Generative_Adversarial_Network_Based_Approach_.pdf,background,2023,An Imbalanced Generative Adversarial Network-Based Approach for Network Intrusion Detection in an Imbalanced Dataset,Sensors,10.3390/s23010550,2,imbalance,partial,GAN oversampling for NIDS minority classes; relates to C3 generative baseline.,,,,,,,W4313586675
References/imbalance/2023_Yang_Machine_Learning_Based_Intrusion_Detection_for_Rare_Class_Ne.pdf,background,2023,Machine Learning-Based Intrusion Detection for Rare-Class Network Attacks,Electronics,10.3390/electronics12183911,2,imbalance,partial,Geometric SMOTE with KDE for rare-class attacks; partial C3,,,,,,,W4386838446
References/imbalance/2023_Bagui_Resampling_Imbalanced_Network_Intrusion_Datasets_to_Identify.pdf,background,2023,Resampling Imbalanced Network Intrusion Datasets to Identify Rare Attacks,Future Internet,10.3390/fi15040130,2,imbalance,partial,"Resampling ratios and split-order (leakage-related) for rare attacks, binary only; partial C3.",,,,,,,W4361277487
References/imbalance/2023_Mirsadeghi_Learning_From_Few_Cyber_Attacks_Addressing_the_Class_Imbalan.pdf,background,2023,Learning From Few Cyber-Attacks: Addressing the Class Imbalance Problem in Machine Learning-Based Intrusion Detection in Software-Defined Networking,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2023.3341755,2,imbalance,partial,"Data and classifier-level imbalance strategies on InSDN; partial C3, different dataset.",,,,,,,W4389633842
References/imbalance/2023_Song_CSK_CNN_Network_Intrusion_Detection_Model_Based_on_Two_Layer.pdf,background,2023,CSK-CNN: Network Intrusion Detection Model Based on Two-Layer Convolution Neural Network for Handling Imbalanced Dataset,Information,10.3390/info14020130,2,imbalance,partial,"Cluster-SMOTE plus undersampling with two-layer CNN, binary then type; partial C3/C5.",,,,,,,W4321243464
References/imbalance/2023_Abedzadeh_A_Reinforcement_Learning_Framework_with_Oversampling_and_Und.pdf,background,2023,A Reinforcement Learning Framework with Oversampling and Undersampling Algorithms for Intrusion Detection System,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app132011275,2,imbalance,partial,RL with SMOTE variant on CSE-CIC-IDS2018; C3 background,,,,,,,W4387618363
References/imbalance/2023_Peng_CBF_IDS_Addressing_Class_Imbalance_Using_CNN_BiLSTM_with_Foc.pdf,background,2023,CBF-IDS: Addressing Class Imbalance Using CNN-BiLSTM with Focal Loss in Network Intrusion Detection System,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app132111629,2,imbalance,partial,CNN-BiLSTM with focal loss on three datasets; partial C3 (focal).,,,,,,,W4387909662
References/imbalance/2023_Zhang_Deep_Long_Tailed_Learning_A_Survey.pdf,background,2023,Deep Long-Tailed Learning: A Survey,IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,10.1109/tpami.2023.3268118,2,imbalance,none,Long-tailed deep learning survey (vision); background for C3,,,,,,,W4366352743
References/hierarchical/2023_Gao_A_Fusional_Intrusion_Detection_Method_Based_on_the_Hierarchi.pdf,background,2023,A Fusional Intrusion Detection Method Based on the Hierarchical Filtering and Progressive Detection Model,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2023.3335669,2,hierarchical,partial,Binary filter then CNN progressive detection for minority classes; overlaps C5 on other datasets.,,,,,,,W4388878432
References/evaluation/2023_Figueiredo_Deep_Learning_Model_Transposition_for_Network_Intrusion_Dete.pdf,background,2023,Deep Learning Model Transposition for Network Intrusion Detection Systems,Electronics,10.3390/electronics12020293,2,evaluation,partial,LSTM NIDS claiming cross-environment transposition; touches cross-dataset generalisation.,,,,,,,W4313646283
References/imbalance/2023_Liu_Intrusion_Detection_Model_Based_on_Improved_Transformer.pdf,background,2023,Intrusion Detection Model Based on Improved Transformer,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app13106251,2,imbalance,partial,"Transformer with Borderline-SMOTE and two-stage learning; overlaps C3, C5 partially.",,,,,,,W4377091294
References/bigdata/2023_Chliah_Hybrid_Machine_Learning_Based_Approach_for_Anomaly_Detection.pdf,background,2023,Hybrid Machine Learning-Based Approach for Anomaly Detection using Apache Spark,International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications,10.14569/ijacsa.2023.0140496,2,bigdata,partial,Spark MLlib k-means+KNN anomaly detection; overlaps C4 loosely.,,,,,,,W4368275854
References/imbalance/2023_Amien_Intrusion_detection_system_for_imbalance_ratio_class_using_w.pdf,background,2023,Intrusion detection system for imbalance ratio class using weighted XGBoost classifier,TELKOMNIKA (Telecommunication Computing Electronics and Control),10.12928/telkomnika.v21i5.24735,2,imbalance,partial,"Class-weighted XGBoost on Bot-IoT; class weights for C3, GBM baseline.",,,,,,,W4385660077
References/bigdata/2022_Gad_A_Distributed_Intrusion_Detection_System_using_Machine_Learn.pdf,background,2022,A Distributed Intrusion Detection System using Machine Learning for IoT based on ToN-IoT Dataset,International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications,10.14569/ijacsa.2022.0130667,2,bigdata,partial,"Distributed ML IDS on ToN-IoT; partial C4, likely small scale.",,,,,,,W4285236840
References/datasets/2022_Ferrag_Edge_IIoTset_A_New_Comprehensive_Realistic_Cyber_Security_Da.pdf,background,2022,Edge-IIoTset: A New Comprehensive Realistic Cyber Security Dataset of IoT and IIoT Applications for Centralized and Federated Learning,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2022.3165809,2,datasets,none,Edge-IIoTset dataset; not NetFlow,,,,,,,W4226319939
References/models/2022_Sarhan_Feature_extraction_for_machine_learning_based_intrusion_dete.pdf,background,2022,Feature extraction for machine learning-based intrusion detection in IoT networks,Digital Communications and Networks,10.1016/j.dcan.2022.08.012,2,models,partial,Feature extraction generalisation across NetFlow datasets; slight overlap with C2.,,,,,,,W3197995211
References/evaluation/2022_Abdulmajeed_MLIDS22_IDS_Design_by_Applying_Hybrid_CNN_LSTM_model_on_Mixe.pdf,background,2022,MLIDS22- IDS Design by Applying Hybrid CNN-LSTM model on Mixed-Datasets,Informatica,10.31449/inf.v46i8.4348,2,evaluation,partial,"Mixing CIC-2017/2018 datasets; cross-dataset decline noted, partial C2",,,,,,,W4309937910
References/imbalance/2022_Mbow_Handling_class_Imbalance_problem_in_Intrusion_Detection_Syst.pdf,background,2022,Handling class Imbalance problem in Intrusion Detection System based on deep learning,International Journal of Networking and Computing,10.15803/ijnc.12.2_467,2,imbalance,partial,"SMOTE-Tomek with DL for NIDS; C3 background, not NetFlow",,,,,,,W4286367234
References/imbalance/2022_Alqarni_Improving_Intrusion_Detection_for_Imbalanced_Network_Traffic.pdf,background,2022,Improving Intrusion Detection for Imbalanced Network Traffic using Generative Deep Learning,International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications,10.14569/ijacsa.2022.01304109,2,imbalance,partial,CTGAN oversampling for NIDS imbalance; touches C3,,,,,,,W4285222314
References/imbalance/2022_Khanam_Towards_an_Effective_Intrusion_Detection_Model_Using_Focal_L.pdf,background,2022,Towards an Effective Intrusion Detection Model Using Focal Loss Variational Autoencoder for Internet of Things (IoT),Sensors,10.3390/s22155822,2,imbalance,partial,Class-wise focal loss VAE oversampling for IoT imbalance; overlaps C3 method family only.,,,,,,,W4289860735
References/hierarchical/2022_Kong_A_Hierarchical_Intrusion_Detection_System_Based_on_Machine_L.pdf,background,2022,A Hierarchical Intrusion Detection System Based on Machine Learning,Journal of Physics Conference Series,10.1088/1742-6596/2294/1/012033,2,hierarchical,partial,Hierarchical detection for imbalance on CIC-IDS; overlaps C5 on non-NetFlow data.,,,,,,,W4283259819
References/hierarchical/2022_ElDahshan_Meta_Heuristic_Optimization_Algorithm_Based_Hierarchical_Int.pdf,background,2022,Meta-Heuristic Optimization Algorithm-Based Hierarchical Intrusion Detection System,Computers,10.3390/computers11120170,2,hierarchical,partial,Three-stage hierarchical IDS with binary-balanced splits and metaheuristic ELM; partial C5.,,,,,,,W4310153191
References/drift_xai/2022_Neupane_Explainable_Intrusion_Detection_Systems_X_IDS_A_Survey_of_Cu.pdf,background,2022,"Explainable Intrusion Detection Systems (X-IDS): A Survey of Current Methods, Challenges, and Opportunities",IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2022.3216617,2,drift_xai,none,Explainable IDS survey; background,,,,,,,W4313116287
References/drift_xai/2022_Le_Classification_and_Explanation_for_Intrusion_Detection_Syste.pdf,background,2022,Classification and Explanation for Intrusion Detection System Based on Ensemble Trees and SHAP Method,Sensors,10.3390/s22031154,2,drift_xai,none,Ensemble trees plus SHAP on large IoT IDS data; tree-ensemble and XAI background.,,,,,,,W4210659135
References/models/2021_Maseer_Benchmarking_of_Machine_Learning_for_Anomaly_Based_Intrusion.pdf,background,2021,Benchmarking of Machine Learning for Anomaly Based Intrusion Detection Systems in the CICIDS2017 Dataset,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2021.3056614,2,models,none,Benchmark of 10 ML algorithms on CICIDS2017; baseline background.,,,,,,,W3126814579
References/evaluation/2021_Jeune_Machine_Learning_for_Misuse_Based_Network_Intrusion_Detectio.pdf,background,2021,"Machine Learning for Misuse-Based Network Intrusion Detection: Overview, Unified Evaluation and Feature Choice Comparison Framework",IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2021.3075066,2,evaluation,partial,"Unified evaluation of misuse NIDS across datasets, new metrics; overlaps evaluation protocol.",,,,,,,W3157770576
References/evaluation/2021_Verkerken_Towards_Model_Generalization_for_Intrusion_Detection_Unsuper.pdf,background,2021,Towards Model Generalization for Intrusion Detection: Unsupervised Machine Learning Techniques,Journal of Network and Systems Management,10.1007/s10922-021-09615-7,2,evaluation,partial,"Model generalization of unsupervised IDS; abstract missing, judged by title; touches cross-dataset C2.",,,,,,,W3205605959
References/hierarchical/2021_Piskozub_MalPhase_Fine_Grained_Malware_Detection_Using_Network_Flow_D.pdf,background,2021,MalPhase: Fine-Grained Malware Detection Using Network Flow Data,ACM Asia Conference on Computer and Communications Security (ASIA CCS),10.1145/3433210.3453101,2,hierarchical,partial,Multi-phase flow-based malware detection/family classification; touches C5 only loosely,,,,,,,W3166061103
References/imbalance/2021_Alsameraee_Toward_Constructing_a_Balanced_Intrusion_Detection_Dataset.pdf,background,2021,Toward Constructing a Balanced Intrusion Detection Dataset,Samarra Journal of Pure and Applied Science,10.54153/sjpas.2020.v2i3.86,2,imbalance,partial,SMOTE adaptation for multiclass CICIDS2017; partial C3,,,,,,,W3112098972
References/hierarchical/2021_Qaddoura_A_Multi_Stage_Classification_Approach_for_IoT_Intrusion_Dete.pdf,background,2021,A Multi-Stage Classification Approach for IoT Intrusion Detection Based on Clustering with Oversampling,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app11073022,2,hierarchical,partial,"Multi-stage clustering plus oversampling IoT IDS; staged pipeline and imbalance, partial C3/C5.",,,,,,,W3149086027
References/hierarchical/2021_Qaddoura_A_Multi_Layer_Classification_Approach_for_Intrusion_Detectio.pdf,background,2021,A Multi-Layer Classification Approach for Intrusion Detection in IoT Networks Based on Deep Learning,Sensors,10.3390/s21092987,2,hierarchical,partial,Two-stage deep IDS with oversampling for IoT; overlaps C5 and C3 but small scale.,,,,,,,W3158729335
References/imbalance/2021_Ahsan_A_comparative_analysis_of_CGAN_based_oversampling_for_anomal.pdf,background,2021,A comparative analysis of CGAN‐based oversampling for anomaly detection,IET Cyber-Physical Systems Theory & Applications,10.1049/cps2.12019,2,imbalance,partial,CGAN oversampling compared with SMOTE/ADASYN; C3 background,,,,,,,W3210728649
References/imbalance/2021_Engelmann_Conditional_Wasserstein_GAN_based_oversampling_of_tabular_da.pdf,background,2021,Conditional Wasserstein GAN-based oversampling of tabular data for imbalanced learning,Expert Systems with Applications,10.1016/j.eswa.2021.114582,2,imbalance,none,"CWGAN tabular oversampling; foundational for C3 generative oversampling; abstract missing, judged by title",,,,,,,W3081094761
References/hierarchical/2021_Mendon_a_Intrusion_Detection_System_Based_on_Fast_Hierarchical_Deep_C.pdf,background,2021,Intrusion Detection System Based on Fast Hierarchical Deep Convolutional Neural Network,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2021.3074664,2,hierarchical,partial,"Tree-CNN hierarchical IDS on DDoS/web attacks; relates to C5, not NetFlow v2/v3 or end-to-end metrics.",,,,,,,W3157189912
References/hierarchical/2021_Souza_Multiclass_decomposition_and_Artificial_Neural_Networks_for_.pdf,background,2021,Multiclass decomposition and Artificial Neural Networks for intrusion detection and identification in Internet of Things environments,Simpósio Brasileiro de Cibersegurança (SBSeg),10.5753/sbseg.2021.17308,2,hierarchical,partial,"Two-stage OVA+ANN on Bot-IoT; two-stage multiclass relates to C5, but only one dataset.",,,,,,,W3204364147
References/survey/2021_L_nsk_Deep_Learning_Based_Intrusion_Detection_Systems_A_Systematic.pdf,background,2021,Deep Learning-Based Intrusion Detection Systems: A Systematic Review,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2021.3097247,2,survey,none,Systematic review of DL IDS; background.,,,,,,,W3185244527
References/datasets/2020_Hindy_A_Taxonomy_of_Network_Threats_and_the_Effect_of_Current_Data.pdf,background,2020,A Taxonomy of Network Threats and the Effect of Current Datasets on Intrusion Detection Systems,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2020.3000179,2,datasets,none,Dataset survey and threat taxonomy,,,,,,,W3033213260
References/survey/2020_Ahmad_Network_intrusion_detection_system_A_systematic_study_of_mac.pdf,background,2020,Network intrusion detection system: A systematic study of machine learning and deep learning approaches,Transactions on Emerging Telecommunications Technologies,10.1002/ett.4150,2,survey,none,ML/DL NIDS systematic study; background.,,,,,,,W3093410479
References/evaluation/2020_Anjum_Cross_Dataset_Evaluation_for_IoT_Network_Intrusion_Detection.pdf,background,2020,Cross Dataset Evaluation for IoT Network Intrusion Detection,UWM Digital Commons (University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee),,2,evaluation,partial,"Cross-dataset evaluation IoTID20 to Bot-IoT; thesis-style generalisation background, not NetFlow; partial C2.",,,,,,,W3155878966
References/imbalance/2020_Jiang_Network_Intrusion_Detection_Combined_Hybrid_Sampling_With_De.pdf,background,2020,Network Intrusion Detection Combined Hybrid Sampling With Deep Hierarchical Network,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2020.2973730,2,imbalance,none,"OSS+SMOTE hybrid sampling with CNN-BiLSTM; hierarchical refers to feature hierarchy, not classes.",,,,,,,W3005805195
References/imbalance/2020_Karata_Increasing_the_Performance_of_Machine_Learning_Based_IDSs_on.pdf,background,2020,Increasing the Performance of Machine Learning-Based IDSs on an Imbalanced and Up-to-Date Dataset,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2020.2973219,2,imbalance,partial,Imbalance handling with ML on CSE-CIC-IDS2018; overlaps C3 but not NetFlow or long tail.,,,,,,,W3006165800
References/datasets/2020_Elsayed_InSDN_A_Novel_SDN_Intrusion_Dataset.pdf,background,2020,InSDN: A Novel SDN Intrusion Dataset,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2020.3022633,2,datasets,none,"InSDN dataset paper; background on datasets, not NetFlow benchmark.",,,,,,,W3084346886
References/imbalance/2020_Shahriar_G_IDS_Generative_Adversarial_Networks_Assisted_Intrusion_Det.pdf,background,2020,G-IDS: Generative Adversarial Networks Assisted Intrusion Detection System,IEEE Annual International Computer Software and Applications Conference (COMPSAC),10.1109/compsac48688.2020.0-218,2,imbalance,partial,GAN-based synthetic sampling for imbalanced IDS data on NSL-KDD; foundational-style imbalance approach.,,,,,,,W3032712624
References/imbalance/2020_Gonzalez_Cuautle_Synthetic_Minority_Oversampling_Technique_for_Optimizing_Cla.pdf,background,2020,Synthetic Minority Oversampling Technique for Optimizing Classification Tasks in Botnet and Intrusion-Detection-System Datasets,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app10030794,2,imbalance,partial,SMOTE for botnet and IDS datasets; overlaps C3 SMOTE use.,,,,,,,W3001147583
References/imbalance/2020_Zhou_BBN_Bilateral_Branch_Network_With_Cumulative_Learning_for_Lo.pdf,background,2020,BBN: Bilateral-Branch Network With Cumulative Learning for Long-Tailed Visual Recognition,IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition/Proceedings - IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition/Proceedings,10.1109/cvpr42600.2020.00974,2,imbalance,none,BBN long-tailed recognition; foundational long-tail method relevant to C3.,,,,,,,W3034601242
References/evaluation/2020_Wilson_A_Survey_of_Unsupervised_Deep_Domain_Adaptation.pdf,background,2020,A Survey of Unsupervised Deep Domain Adaptation,ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology,10.1145/3400066,2,evaluation,none,Unsupervised deep domain adaptation survey; background for cross-source shift (C2).,,,,,,,W2940156133
References/bigdata/2020_Est_vez_Pereira_Network_Anomaly_Detection_Using_Machine_Learning_Techniques.pdf,background,2020,Network Anomaly Detection Using Machine Learning Techniques,XoveTIC Conference (XoveTIC),10.3390/proceedings2020054008,2,bigdata,partial,"Spark streaming/MLlib anomaly detection; overlaps C4 but small scale, no learning curves.",,,,,,,W3065802839
References/models/2020_Jiang_Network_Intrusion_Detection_Based_on_PSO_Xgboost_Model.pdf,background,2020,Network Intrusion Detection Based on PSO-Xgboost Model,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2020.2982418,2,models,none,PSO-XGBoost on NSL-KDD with macro metrics; GBM baseline background.,,,,,,,W3012981875
References/hierarchical/2019_Zhang_Network_Intrusion_Detection_Based_on_Deep_Hierarchical_Netwo.pdf,background,2019,Network Intrusion Detection: Based on Deep Hierarchical Network and Original Flow Data,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2019.2905041,2,hierarchical,partial,Deep hierarchical LeNet-LSTM on raw flows CICIDS2017; hierarchical models background for C5.,,,,,,,W2925211503
References/bigdata/2019_Khan_A_Scalable_and_Hybrid_Intrusion_Detection_System_Based_on_th.pdf,background,2019,A Scalable and Hybrid Intrusion Detection System Based on the Convolutional-LSTM Network,Symmetry,10.3390/sym11040583,2,bigdata,none,"Scalable hybrid Conv-LSTM IDS; scalability claim, background for big-data NIDS.",,,,,,,W2937220155
References/survey/2019_Liu_Machine_Learning_and_Deep_Learning_Methods_for_Intrusion_Det.pdf,background,2019,Machine Learning and Deep Learning Methods for Intrusion Detection Systems: A Survey,Applied Sciences,10.3390/app9204396,2,survey,none,ML/DL IDS survey with taxonomy; background.,,,,,,,W2980576170
References/hierarchical/2019_Khan_TSDL_A_Two_Stage_Deep_Learning_Model_for_Efficient_Network_I.pdf,background,2019,TSDL: A Two-Stage Deep Learning Model for Efficient Network Intrusion Detection,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2019.2899721,2,hierarchical,partial,Two-stage DL (binary then multiclass); partial C5,,,,,,,W2913330314
References/hierarchical/2019_Ahmim_A_Novel_Hierarchical_Intrusion_Detection_System_Based_on_Dec.pdf,background,2019,A Novel Hierarchical Intrusion Detection System Based on Decision Tree and Rules-Based Models,International Conference on Distributed Computing in Smart Systems and the Internet of Things (DCOSS-IoT),10.1109/dcoss.2019.00059,2,hierarchical,partial,"Hierarchical tree/rule IDS on CICIDS2017; partial C5, binary focus.",,,,,,,W2905872522
References/models/2019_Vinayakumar_Deep_Learning_Approach_for_Intelligent_Intrusion_Detection_S.pdf,background,2019,Deep Learning Approach for Intelligent Intrusion Detection System,IEEE Access,10.1109/access.2019.2895334,2,models,none,DNN IDS benchmark across datasets; common baseline citation,,,,,,,W2926701059
References/bigdata/2018_Hafsa_Comparative_Study_between_Big_Data_Analysis_Techniques_in_In.pdf,background,2018,Comparative Study between Big Data Analysis Techniques in Intrusion Detection,Big Data and Cognitive Computing,10.3390/bdcc3010001,2,bigdata,partial,"Spark Structured Streaming and MLlib IDS on Azure; partial overlap with C4, small scale.",,,,,,,W2906602321
References/survey/2017_Hodo_Shallow_and_Deep_Networks_Intrusion_Detection_System_A_Taxon.pdf,background,2017,Shallow and Deep Networks Intrusion Detection System: A Taxonomy and Survey,Strathprints: The University of Strathclyde institutional repository (University of Strathclyde),10.48550/arxiv.1701.02145,2,survey,none,Shallow and deep IDS taxonomy survey,,,,,,,W2576897537
References/datasets/2017_Sharafaldin_Towards_a_Reliable_Intrusion_Detection_Benchmark_Dataset.pdf,background,2017,Towards a Reliable Intrusion Detection Benchmark Dataset,Software Networking,10.13052/jsn2445-9739.2017.009,2,datasets,none,Dataset evaluation criteria (Gharib); background on dataset quality,,,,,,,W2732560875
References/imbalance/2017_Khan_Cost_Sensitive_Learning_of_Deep_Feature_Representations_From.pdf,background,2017,Cost-Sensitive Learning of Deep Feature Representations From Imbalanced Data,IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks and Learning Systems,10.1109/tnnls.2017.2732482,2,imbalance,none,Cost-sensitive deep learning for imbalanced data; foundational method for C3.,,,,,,,W1753659477
References/hierarchical/2016_Hussain_A_two_stage_hybrid_classification_technique_for_network_intr.pdf,background,2016,A two-stage hybrid classification technique for network intrusion detection system,International Journal of Computational Intelligence Systems,10.1080/18756891.2016.1237186,2,hierarchical,partial,"SVM then ANN two-stage on KDD classes; partial C5, old dataset",,,,,,,W2526290843