agent-shootout / analysis_test.json
raihan-js's picture
Agent Shootout: 960 test runs, dev runs, questions, analysis, card
ae210b5 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
54.6 kB
{
"name": "test",
"n": {
"react": 240,
"plan_execute": 240,
"supervisor": 240,
"draft_verify": 240
},
"summary": {
"react": {
"n": 240,
"correct": {
"k": 143,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.5958333333333333,
"lo": 0.5307970729955163,
"hi": 0.658471871980454
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 144,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.6,
"lo": 0.5350156969769947,
"hi": 0.6624821596774741
},
"invented": {
"k": 7,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.029166666666666667,
"lo": 0.011805285518544028,
"hi": 0.05916855454550887
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 8,
"n": 495
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 6,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.009228601454783297,
"hi": 0.05361747542837168
},
"precise": {
"k": 108,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.45,
"lo": 0.38594097734958605,
"hi": 0.5153093156616189
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 121,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.5041666666666667,
"lo": 0.43911879953299476,
"hi": 0.5691103635609939
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 26,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.10833333333333334,
"lo": 0.07199802833706971,
"hi": 0.1546949031187915
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 105,
"n": 122,
"rate": 0.860655737704918,
"lo": 0.7862944586798188,
"hi": 0.9166823992308936
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 6,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.009228601454783297,
"hi": 0.05361747542837168
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 2,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.0010108034032671538,
"hi": 0.029776977411869524
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 4662.7625,
"lo": 4117.5069791666665,
"hi": 5218.640104166666
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 2.9625,
"lo": 2.7625,
"hi": 3.1625
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 2.8625,
"lo": 2.525,
"hi": 3.183333333333333
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 16.242932229212496,
"lo": 15.206994727691137,
"hi": 17.321820671708117
},
"latency_p50": 14.133107692500062,
"latency_p95": 31.46573680455009,
"tokens_per_correct": 7825.615384615385,
"statuses": {
"answered": 234,
"llm_error": 3,
"budget_exhausted": 3
}
},
"plan_execute": {
"n": 240,
"correct": {
"k": 148,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.6166666666666667,
"lo": 0.5519365268822892,
"hi": 0.6784767343173119
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 148,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.6166666666666667,
"lo": 0.5519365268822892,
"hi": 0.6784767343173119
},
"invented": {
"k": 2,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.0010108034032671538,
"hi": 0.029776977411869524
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 3,
"n": 418
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.002585256185220348,
"hi": 0.03609367948354552
},
"precise": {
"k": 119,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.49583333333333335,
"lo": 0.4308896364390062,
"hi": 0.5608812004670052
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 109,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.45416666666666666,
"lo": 0.39000530581535187,
"hi": 0.5194740923373329
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.015252810401278712
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 17,
"n": 19,
"rate": 0.8947368421052632,
"lo": 0.668623335543234,
"hi": 0.9869878356282226
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 3,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.002585256185220348,
"hi": 0.03609367948354552
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 22,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.09166666666666666,
"lo": 0.058340998102745914,
"hi": 0.13549387552856768
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 10535.304166666667,
"lo": 10101.385416666666,
"hi": 10993.776354166666
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 9.1,
"lo": 8.875,
"hi": 9.333333333333334
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 5.145833333333333,
"lo": 4.8125,
"hi": 5.516770833333332
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 43.514581331825,
"lo": 41.93668660201886,
"hi": 45.222450028120704
},
"latency_p50": 40.34787665000022,
"latency_p95": 69.52476457054998,
"tokens_per_correct": 17084.277027027027,
"statuses": {
"answered": 237,
"budget_exhausted": 3
}
},
"supervisor": {
"n": 240,
"correct": {
"k": 156,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.65,
"lo": 0.5860064380044503,
"hi": 0.7102362048394801
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 156,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.65,
"lo": 0.5860064380044503,
"hi": 0.7102362048394801
},
"invented": {
"k": 7,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.029166666666666667,
"lo": 0.011805285518544028,
"hi": 0.05916855454550887
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 8,
"n": 404
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.002585256185220348,
"hi": 0.03609367948354552
},
"precise": {
"k": 131,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.5458333333333333,
"lo": 0.48052590766266706,
"hi": 0.6099946941846481
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 94,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.39166666666666666,
"lo": 0.329511185646006,
"hi": 0.4565332046104391
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.015252810401278712
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 15,
"n": 17,
"rate": 0.8823529411764706,
"lo": 0.6355908378987497,
"hi": 0.9854206831596976
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 2,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.0010108034032671538,
"hi": 0.029776977411869524
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 6,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.009228601454783297,
"hi": 0.05361747542837168
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 7494.275,
"lo": 6958.342708333333,
"hi": 8049.065208333333
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 7.475,
"lo": 7.1457291666666665,
"hi": 7.816770833333332
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.341666666666667,
"lo": 3.875,
"hi": 4.845833333333333
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 36.57701968078337,
"lo": 34.30809345392126,
"hi": 39.06719019857014
},
"latency_p50": 30.638799395500428,
"latency_p95": 75.16971426800015,
"tokens_per_correct": 11529.653846153846,
"statuses": {
"answered": 238,
"budget_exhausted": 2
}
},
"draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"correct": {
"k": 153,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.6375,
"lo": 0.5731938486259539,
"hi": 0.6983630298347869
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 153,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.6375,
"lo": 0.5731938486259539,
"hi": 0.6983630298347869
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.004166666666666667,
"lo": 0.0001054853026353906,
"hi": 0.022995275839816712
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 1,
"n": 490
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.002585256185220348,
"hi": 0.03609367948354552
},
"precise": {
"k": 116,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.48333333333333334,
"lo": 0.41857851033687177,
"hi": 0.5485048459759146
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 120,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.5,
"lo": 0.435002044307265,
"hi": 0.5649979556927349
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 17,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.07083333333333333,
"lo": 0.04180181849629345,
"hi": 0.11099022311296901
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 102,
"n": 119,
"rate": 0.8571428571428571,
"lo": 0.7811516057939495,
"hi": 0.914523197620356
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 2,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.0010108034032671538,
"hi": 0.029776977411869524
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 2,
"n": 240,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.0010108034032671538,
"hi": 0.029776977411869524
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 4904.970833333334,
"lo": 4366.409583333333,
"hi": 5517.3099999999995
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 3.1166666666666667,
"lo": 2.9248958333333333,
"hi": 3.3292708333333327
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 3.004166666666667,
"lo": 2.691666666666667,
"hi": 3.3666666666666667
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 18.345630585412476,
"lo": 17.187574390155785,
"hi": 19.61587535197487
},
"latency_p50": 15.605844864500341,
"latency_p95": 37.55892375174989,
"tokens_per_correct": 7694.071895424837,
"statuses": {
"answered": 238,
"budget_exhausted": 2
}
}
},
"by_type": {
"react": {
"neighbour": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 54,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.675,
"lo": 0.5610629543955514,
"hi": 0.7755404148225465
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 55,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.6875,
"lo": 0.5741109261435504,
"hi": 0.7865253688912327
},
"invented": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 3,
"n": 175
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"precise": {
"k": 47,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.5875,
"lo": 0.4718483404252045,
"hi": 0.6964754070624058
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 31,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.3875,
"lo": 0.28056513312478215,
"hi": 0.5030244574981009
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 35,
"n": 40,
"rate": 0.875,
"lo": 0.7319670826382796,
"hi": 0.9581403738613833
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 2,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.0030420861648095977,
"hi": 0.08740715593059226
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 5140.6125,
"lo": 4378.8121875,
"hi": 6064.200312499998
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 3.475,
"lo": 3.1625,
"hi": 3.825
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 2.5375,
"lo": 2.225,
"hi": 2.8875
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 14.899579906625004,
"lo": 13.719111950193108,
"hi": 16.183935713803127
},
"latency_p50": 14.184063417500056,
"latency_p95": 26.290267258300304,
"tokens_per_correct": 7615.722222222223,
"statuses": {
"answered": 80
}
},
"pair": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 33,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4125,
"lo": 0.3035245929375941,
"hi": 0.5281516595747955
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 33,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4125,
"lo": 0.3035245929375941,
"hi": 0.5281516595747955
},
"invented": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 4,
"n": 202
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 5,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0625,
"lo": 0.02060307230201024,
"hi": 0.139857075297639
},
"precise": {
"k": 21,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.2625,
"lo": 0.1704092511004082,
"hi": 0.372850830212432
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 51,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.6375,
"lo": 0.5223872787351915,
"hi": 0.742105104628382
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 13,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.1625,
"lo": 0.08946164172252927,
"hi": 0.2618368938251129
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 26,
"n": 27,
"rate": 0.9629629629629629,
"lo": 0.8102943825869554,
"hi": 0.9990627429080553
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 5,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0625,
"lo": 0.02060307230201024,
"hi": 0.139857075297639
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 5473.0875,
"lo": 4295.169375,
"hi": 6844.826249999999
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 2.8625,
"lo": 2.525,
"hi": 3.2253124999999985
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.3125,
"lo": 3.6371875,
"hi": 5.0375
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 21.696216419837477,
"lo": 19.75746864446247,
"hi": 23.715541888226227
},
"latency_p50": 20.674941820999834,
"latency_p95": 39.77054403484989,
"tokens_per_correct": 13268.09090909091,
"statuses": {
"answered": 75,
"llm_error": 2,
"budget_exhausted": 3
}
},
"topic": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 56,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.7,
"lo": 0.587240676918624,
"hi": 0.7974260708533272
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 56,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.7,
"lo": 0.587240676918624,
"hi": 0.7974260708533272
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 1,
"n": 118
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"precise": {
"k": 40,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.5,
"lo": 0.38604788336490936,
"hi": 0.6139521166350905
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 39,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4875,
"lo": 0.374057481444439,
"hi": 0.6018953312968145
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 13,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.1625,
"lo": 0.08946164172252927,
"hi": 0.2618368938251129
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 44,
"n": 55,
"rate": 0.8,
"lo": 0.6702714937123857,
"hi": 0.8957040830742319
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 3374.5875,
"lo": 2847.654375,
"hi": 4034.6703124999985
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 2.55,
"lo": 2.2875,
"hi": 2.85
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 1.7375,
"lo": 1.4125,
"hi": 2.125
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 12.133000361175007,
"lo": 11.064410227286878,
"hi": 13.40819750614095
},
"latency_p50": 10.865475614500156,
"latency_p95": 25.261461383499814,
"tokens_per_correct": 4820.839285714285,
"statuses": {
"answered": 79,
"llm_error": 1
}
}
},
"plan_execute": {
"neighbour": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 46,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.575,
"lo": 0.45938881143093807,
"hi": 0.684890234547658
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 46,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.575,
"lo": 0.45938881143093807,
"hi": 0.684890234547658
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 2,
"n": 121
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"precise": {
"k": 43,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.5375,
"lo": 0.42241752800483506,
"hi": 0.6497235734616018
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 35,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4375,
"lo": 0.3267639534337789,
"hi": 0.5530024286118196
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 5,
"n": 5,
"rate": 1.0,
"lo": 0.4781762498950185,
"hi": 1.0
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 11,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.1375,
"lo": 0.07068783270387868,
"hi": 0.23272087082472567
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 11020.6625,
"lo": 10391.241875,
"hi": 11677.730625
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 9.6,
"lo": 9.25,
"hi": 9.9625
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.7625,
"lo": 4.4,
"hi": 5.1625
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 43.47477806971249,
"lo": 41.29210363721121,
"hi": 45.77206251318684
},
"latency_p50": 42.71445037900003,
"latency_p95": 62.56062081810028,
"tokens_per_correct": 19166.369565217392,
"statuses": {
"answered": 80
}
},
"pair": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 39,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4875,
"lo": 0.374057481444439,
"hi": 0.6018953312968145
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 39,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4875,
"lo": 0.374057481444439,
"hi": 0.6018953312968145
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 1,
"n": 185
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"precise": {
"k": 26,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.325,
"lo": 0.22445958517745335,
"hi": 0.4389370456044486
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 44,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.55,
"lo": 0.43467397909415295,
"hi": 0.6615136155101845
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 8,
"n": 9,
"rate": 0.8888888888888888,
"lo": 0.517503485082663,
"hi": 0.9971908632534008
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 8,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.1,
"lo": 0.04417094015362904,
"hi": 0.18756510746343164
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 12205.8625,
"lo": 11327.363125,
"hi": 13098.1675
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 9.5625,
"lo": 9.1375,
"hi": 9.975
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 6.9625,
"lo": 6.25,
"hi": 7.7
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 51.22233577435004,
"lo": 48.072291185331906,
"hi": 54.35105865909752
},
"latency_p50": 51.00230995749985,
"latency_p95": 74.7210915991499,
"tokens_per_correct": 25037.666666666668,
"statuses": {
"answered": 77,
"budget_exhausted": 3
}
},
"topic": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 63,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.7875,
"lo": 0.6817141914403442,
"hi": 0.8710635049024182
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 63,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.7875,
"lo": 0.6817141914403442,
"hi": 0.8710635049024182
},
"invented": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 0,
"n": 112
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"precise": {
"k": 50,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5096452355928878,
"hi": 0.7308068300531951
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 30,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.375,
"lo": 0.2691931699468049,
"hi": 0.49035476440711223
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 4,
"n": 5,
"rate": 0.8,
"lo": 0.2835820638819105,
"hi": 0.9949492366205319
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 8379.3875,
"lo": 7891.1353125000005,
"hi": 8868.634062500001
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 8.1375,
"lo": 7.8375,
"hi": 8.425
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 3.7125,
"lo": 3.35,
"hi": 4.1
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 35.84663015141247,
"lo": 33.91847839999649,
"hi": 37.80713505319684
},
"latency_p50": 35.989453414500076,
"latency_p95": 50.18679588584968,
"tokens_per_correct": 10640.492063492064,
"statuses": {
"answered": 80
}
}
},
"supervisor": {
"neighbour": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 50,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5096452355928878,
"hi": 0.7308068300531951
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 50,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5096452355928878,
"hi": 0.7308068300531951
},
"invented": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 3,
"n": 119
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 2,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.0030420861648095977,
"hi": 0.08740715593059226
},
"precise": {
"k": 46,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.575,
"lo": 0.45938881143093807,
"hi": 0.684890234547658
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 27,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.3375,
"lo": 0.2355261379836508,
"hi": 0.4519056143741682
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 3,
"n": 4,
"rate": 0.75,
"lo": 0.19412044968324338,
"hi": 0.9936905367902902
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 7313.5125,
"lo": 6453.8478125,
"hi": 8246.09125
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 7.5125,
"lo": 6.9496875000000005,
"hi": 8.1
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 3.3,
"lo": 2.875,
"hi": 3.8125
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 31.88942538897504,
"lo": 29.021263239147274,
"hi": 35.038905332707834
},
"latency_p50": 27.782996034999996,
"latency_p95": 61.61553300259983,
"tokens_per_correct": 11701.62,
"statuses": {
"answered": 79,
"budget_exhausted": 1
}
},
"pair": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 39,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4875,
"lo": 0.374057481444439,
"hi": 0.6018953312968145
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 39,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4875,
"lo": 0.374057481444439,
"hi": 0.6018953312968145
},
"invented": {
"k": 4,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.05,
"lo": 0.013789393976461804,
"hi": 0.12309873644315295
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 5,
"n": 184
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"precise": {
"k": 29,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.3625,
"lo": 0.257894895371618,
"hi": 0.47761272126480847
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 43,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.5375,
"lo": 0.42241752800483506,
"hi": 0.6497235734616018
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 9,
"n": 9,
"rate": 1.0,
"lo": 0.6637328831200572,
"hi": 1.0
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 3,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0375,
"lo": 0.0078011872657166945,
"hi": 0.1057019850165086
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 9541.5125,
"lo": 8514.366875,
"hi": 10674.7075
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 8.275,
"lo": 7.6625,
"hi": 8.900312499999998
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 6.85,
"lo": 5.9625,
"hi": 7.912812499999998
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 48.97332868358759,
"lo": 44.97483250042538,
"hi": 53.44273134014696
},
"latency_p50": 40.76687422499981,
"latency_p95": 93.42753260044992,
"tokens_per_correct": 19572.333333333332,
"statuses": {
"answered": 79,
"budget_exhausted": 1
}
},
"topic": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 67,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.8375,
"lo": 0.738163106174887,
"hi": 0.9105383582774708
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 67,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.8375,
"lo": 0.738163106174887,
"hi": 0.9105383582774708
},
"invented": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 0,
"n": 101
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"precise": {
"k": 56,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.7,
"lo": 0.587240676918624,
"hi": 0.7974260708533272
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 24,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.3,
"lo": 0.20257392914667274,
"hi": 0.4127593230813758
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 3,
"n": 4,
"rate": 0.75,
"lo": 0.19412044968324338,
"hi": 0.9936905367902902
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 5627.8,
"lo": 4925.610625,
"hi": 6451.754999999999
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 6.6375,
"lo": 6.1625,
"hi": 7.175312499999998
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 2.875,
"lo": 2.2496875,
"hi": 3.6253124999999984
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 28.868304969787495,
"lo": 25.795144673928778,
"hi": 32.25879643505779
},
"latency_p50": 23.36504237400004,
"latency_p95": 59.36499078505034,
"tokens_per_correct": 6719.761194029851,
"statuses": {
"answered": 80
}
}
},
"draft_verify": {
"neighbour": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 55,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.6875,
"lo": 0.5741109261435504,
"hi": 0.7865253688912327
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 55,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.6875,
"lo": 0.5741109261435504,
"hi": 0.7865253688912327
},
"invented": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 0,
"n": 167
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"precise": {
"k": 50,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5096452355928878,
"hi": 0.7308068300531951
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 29,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.3625,
"lo": 0.257894895371618,
"hi": 0.47761272126480847
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 33,
"n": 37,
"rate": 0.8918918918918919,
"lo": 0.7458240639225211,
"hi": 0.9697480349312504
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 5489.4,
"lo": 4626.826562499999,
"hi": 6589.136249999999
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 3.675,
"lo": 3.3125,
"hi": 4.0875
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 2.725,
"lo": 2.375,
"hi": 3.1375
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 16.615184554099947,
"lo": 15.087480989479259,
"hi": 18.36544555999024
},
"latency_p50": 15.086127549999674,
"latency_p95": 31.875419317200247,
"tokens_per_correct": 7984.581818181819,
"statuses": {
"answered": 80
}
},
"pair": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 38,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.475,
"lo": 0.3621335816771527,
"hi": 0.5897721586232292
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 38,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.475,
"lo": 0.3621335816771527,
"hi": 0.5897721586232292
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 1,
"n": 204
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 2,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.0030420861648095977,
"hi": 0.08740715593059226
},
"precise": {
"k": 23,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.2875,
"lo": 0.19176047197196505,
"hi": 0.3995451133120205
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 54,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.675,
"lo": 0.5610629543955514,
"hi": 0.7755404148225465
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 9,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.1125,
"lo": 0.052751513145687524,
"hi": 0.20284659191699014
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 24,
"n": 26,
"rate": 0.9230769230769231,
"lo": 0.7486970833046261,
"hi": 0.9905446089962873
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 2,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.0030420861648095977,
"hi": 0.08740715593059226
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0125,
"lo": 0.00031642252763270626,
"hi": 0.0676877844639224
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 5734.625,
"lo": 4596.4078125,
"hi": 7039.654375
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 3.025,
"lo": 2.7,
"hi": 3.3875
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.425,
"lo": 3.7,
"hi": 5.2875
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 24.68968023782503,
"lo": 22.367267009846586,
"hi": 27.37757369498288
},
"latency_p50": 22.823655185999996,
"latency_p95": 44.393457606950086,
"tokens_per_correct": 12072.894736842105,
"statuses": {
"answered": 78,
"budget_exhausted": 2
}
},
"topic": {
"n": 80,
"correct": {
"k": 60,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.75,
"lo": 0.6406365240931501,
"hi": 0.8401203554931442
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 60,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.75,
"lo": 0.6406365240931501,
"hi": 0.8401203554931442
},
"invented": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 0,
"n": 119
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"precise": {
"k": 43,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.5375,
"lo": 0.42241752800483506,
"hi": 0.6497235734616018
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 37,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.4625,
"lo": 0.3502764265383982,
"hi": 0.577582471995165
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 8,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.1,
"lo": 0.04417094015362904,
"hi": 0.18756510746343164
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 45,
"n": 56,
"rate": 0.8035714285714286,
"lo": 0.6756670140758856,
"hi": 0.897651697398921
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 80,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.045064035067692285
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 3490.8875,
"lo": 3018.62125,
"hi": 4118.74375
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 2.65,
"lo": 2.4125,
"hi": 2.9375
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 1.8625,
"lo": 1.55,
"hi": 2.2375
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 13.732026964312444,
"lo": 12.481436694222802,
"hi": 15.247287595535848
},
"latency_p50": 12.02661608849985,
"latency_p95": 25.778273784249855,
"tokens_per_correct": 4654.516666666666,
"statuses": {
"answered": 80
}
}
}
},
"by_language": {
"react": {
"en": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 78,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.65,
"lo": 0.5576053298889572,
"hi": 0.7347976904589064
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 78,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.65,
"lo": 0.5576053298889572,
"hi": 0.7347976904589064
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 1,
"n": 241
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 6,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.05,
"lo": 0.018567586782669152,
"hi": 0.10565385451871234
},
"precise": {
"k": 67,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.5583333333333333,
"lo": 0.46482699631641244,
"hi": 0.6488918893958241
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 46,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.38333333333333336,
"lo": 0.2960718855817267,
"hi": 0.4764972061883906
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 34,
"n": 41,
"rate": 0.8292682926829268,
"lo": 0.6794391205510903,
"hi": 0.9284847118477055
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 6,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.05,
"lo": 0.018567586782669152,
"hi": 0.10565385451871234
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 6087.108333333334,
"lo": 5172.839166666667,
"hi": 7125.482291666666
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 3.566666666666667,
"lo": 3.3,
"hi": 3.8666666666666667
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 3.8916666666666666,
"lo": 3.3833333333333333,
"hi": 4.45
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 18.882056816141677,
"lo": 17.25480292140625,
"hi": 20.61635642455835
},
"latency_p50": 16.170416821000003,
"latency_p95": 38.82878485090006,
"tokens_per_correct": 9364.78205128205,
"statuses": {
"answered": 114,
"llm_error": 3,
"budget_exhausted": 3
}
},
"ja": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 65,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.5416666666666666,
"lo": 0.44828808949464594,
"hi": 0.6329400722046816
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 66,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.55,
"lo": 0.4565452197361518,
"hi": 0.6409283624620679
},
"invented": {
"k": 6,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.05,
"lo": 0.018567586782669152,
"hi": 0.10565385451871234
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 7,
"n": 254
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"precise": {
"k": 41,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.3416666666666667,
"lo": 0.25755434765186574,
"hi": 0.4338005971849513
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 75,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5319881382860177,
"hi": 0.7116863294298656
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 26,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.21666666666666667,
"lo": 0.14668149429210206,
"hi": 0.30112851306566935
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 71,
"n": 81,
"rate": 0.8765432098765432,
"lo": 0.7846553019524447,
"hi": 0.9391797507486828
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 3238.4166666666665,
"lo": 2841.116875,
"hi": 3708.79125
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 2.3583333333333334,
"lo": 2.15,
"hi": 2.5833333333333335
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 1.8333333333333333,
"lo": 1.5416666666666667,
"hi": 2.1333333333333333
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 13.603807642283313,
"lo": 12.615631499548321,
"hi": 14.669484549111617
},
"latency_p50": 12.171010697000042,
"latency_p95": 24.41258910824997,
"tokens_per_correct": 5978.615384615385,
"statuses": {
"answered": 120
}
}
},
"plan_execute": {
"en": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 76,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6333333333333333,
"lo": 0.5405001010775285,
"hi": 0.7194175923349626
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 76,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6333333333333333,
"lo": 0.5405001010775285,
"hi": 0.7194175923349626
},
"invented": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 0,
"n": 202
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.00518557495832136,
"hi": 0.07132319415690505
},
"precise": {
"k": 65,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.5416666666666666,
"lo": 0.44828808949464594,
"hi": 0.6329400722046816
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 49,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.4083333333333333,
"lo": 0.31950487206573147,
"hi": 0.5017966216253057
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 3,
"n": 3,
"rate": 1.0,
"lo": 0.2924017738212866,
"hi": 1.0
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 3,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.00518557495832136,
"hi": 0.07132319415690505
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 8,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.06666666666666667,
"lo": 0.029219184313796408,
"hi": 0.12713674823921287
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 11574.8,
"lo": 10952.90875,
"hi": 12310.476666666667
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 9.666666666666666,
"lo": 9.383333333333333,
"hi": 10.008333333333333
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 5.875,
"lo": 5.375,
"hi": 6.45
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 48.131968115983305,
"lo": 46.0436630240973,
"hi": 50.52015160614747
},
"latency_p50": 46.23616495100009,
"latency_p95": 70.41112354644964,
"tokens_per_correct": 18276.0,
"statuses": {
"answered": 117,
"budget_exhausted": 3
}
},
"ja": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 72,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6,
"lo": 0.5066106947209386,
"hi": 0.688332206288702
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 72,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6,
"lo": 0.5066106947209386,
"hi": 0.688332206288702
},
"invented": {
"k": 2,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.016666666666666666,
"lo": 0.0020248223376930826,
"hi": 0.05890921946702682
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 3,
"n": 216
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"precise": {
"k": 54,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.45,
"lo": 0.3590716375379322,
"hi": 0.5434547802638482
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 60,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.5,
"lo": 0.4073692674401972,
"hi": 0.5926307325598028
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 14,
"n": 16,
"rate": 0.875,
"lo": 0.6165237631507364,
"hi": 0.9844863961845861
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 14,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.11666666666666667,
"lo": 0.06527215050994278,
"hi": 0.18799509038680826
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 9495.808333333332,
"lo": 8980.906666666666,
"hi": 10054.652291666667
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 8.533333333333333,
"lo": 8.233333333333333,
"hi": 8.841666666666667
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.416666666666667,
"lo": 4.074791666666667,
"hi": 4.808333333333334
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 38.8971945476667,
"lo": 36.876720475200415,
"hi": 41.219446329670056
},
"latency_p50": 37.08055272299998,
"latency_p95": 63.92635531449997,
"tokens_per_correct": 15826.347222222223,
"statuses": {
"answered": 120
}
}
},
"supervisor": {
"en": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 82,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6833333333333333,
"lo": 0.5921530675200315,
"hi": 0.7652151295210592
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 82,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6833333333333333,
"lo": 0.5921530675200315,
"hi": 0.7652151295210592
},
"invented": {
"k": 4,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.03333333333333333,
"lo": 0.009155505556836708,
"hi": 0.08314872142851014
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 5,
"n": 210
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.00518557495832136,
"hi": 0.07132319415690505
},
"precise": {
"k": 69,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.575,
"lo": 0.48146500638716716,
"hi": 0.6647440519626395
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 44,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.36666666666666664,
"lo": 0.2805824076650374,
"hi": 0.45949989892247145
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 5,
"n": 6,
"rate": 0.8333333333333334,
"lo": 0.35876542100232517,
"hi": 0.9957892554855106
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 2,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.016666666666666666,
"lo": 0.0020248223376930826,
"hi": 0.05890921946702682
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 7772.825,
"lo": 6887.339166666667,
"hi": 8752.190208333333
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 7.525,
"lo": 7.008333333333334,
"hi": 8.091666666666667
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.533333333333333,
"lo": 3.8333333333333335,
"hi": 5.358541666666666
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 37.14477098554175,
"lo": 33.81255627308042,
"hi": 40.860329643922576
},
"latency_p50": 31.31566045349973,
"latency_p95": 84.59239826610037,
"tokens_per_correct": 11374.865853658537,
"statuses": {
"answered": 118,
"budget_exhausted": 2
}
},
"ja": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 74,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6166666666666667,
"lo": 0.5235027938116095,
"hi": 0.7039281144182733
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 74,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.6166666666666667,
"lo": 0.5235027938116095,
"hi": 0.7039281144182733
},
"invented": {
"k": 3,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.00518557495832136,
"hi": 0.07132319415690505
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 3,
"n": 194
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"precise": {
"k": 62,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.5166666666666667,
"lo": 0.42366365483270746,
"hi": 0.6088277437806595
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 50,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.4166666666666667,
"lo": 0.3273676700032787,
"hi": 0.5101784457977024
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 10,
"n": 11,
"rate": 0.9090909090909091,
"lo": 0.5872200830116173,
"hi": 0.9977010277861857
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 5,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.041666666666666664,
"lo": 0.013665384116789567,
"hi": 0.09455879997593716
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 7215.725,
"lo": 6573.718541666666,
"hi": 7899.5356249999995
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 7.425,
"lo": 7.008125000000001,
"hi": 7.858541666666666
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 4.15,
"lo": 3.591666666666667,
"hi": 4.783333333333333
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 36.009268376025005,
"lo": 32.969458317534425,
"hi": 39.28087824737818
},
"latency_p50": 30.165310451000096,
"latency_p95": 68.91385750649988,
"tokens_per_correct": 11701.175675675675,
"statuses": {
"answered": 120
}
}
},
"draft_verify": {
"en": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 78,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.65,
"lo": 0.5576053298889572,
"hi": 0.7347976904589064
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 78,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.65,
"lo": 0.5576053298889572,
"hi": 0.7347976904589064
},
"invented": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 0,
"n": 237
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 3,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.025,
"lo": 0.00518557495832136,
"hi": 0.07132319415690505
},
"precise": {
"k": 66,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.55,
"lo": 0.4565452197361518,
"hi": 0.6409283624620679
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 51,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.425,
"lo": 0.33525594803736053,
"hi": 0.5185349936128327
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 36,
"n": 43,
"rate": 0.8372093023255814,
"lo": 0.6929891276350901,
"hi": 0.9319479055385308
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 2,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.016666666666666666,
"lo": 0.0020248223376930826,
"hi": 0.05890921946702682
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 6250.991666666667,
"lo": 5316.125625,
"hi": 7318.0912499999995
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 3.675,
"lo": 3.3916666666666666,
"hi": 4.0
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 3.9583333333333335,
"lo": 3.441666666666667,
"hi": 4.591666666666667
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 20.584169203508303,
"lo": 18.716761582390596,
"hi": 22.701093019966226
},
"latency_p50": 17.311286832499263,
"latency_p95": 42.847340501400005,
"tokens_per_correct": 9616.910256410256,
"statuses": {
"answered": 118,
"budget_exhausted": 2
}
},
"ja": {
"n": 120,
"correct": {
"k": 75,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5319881382860177,
"hi": 0.7116863294298656
},
"gold_hit": {
"k": 75,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.625,
"lo": 0.5319881382860177,
"hi": 0.7116863294298656
},
"invented": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"invented_mentions": {
"k": 1,
"n": 253
},
"no_citation": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"precise": {
"k": 50,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.4166666666666667,
"lo": 0.3273676700032787,
"hi": 0.5101784457977024
},
"extra_citation": {
"k": 69,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.575,
"lo": 0.48146500638716716,
"hi": 0.6647440519626395
},
"no_tool_runs": {
"k": 17,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.14166666666666666,
"lo": 0.08474472949451575,
"hi": 0.21710689824337648
},
"unsupported_quote": {
"k": 66,
"n": 76,
"rate": 0.868421052631579,
"lo": 0.7713042073923877,
"hi": 0.9350584323239128
},
"not_answered": {
"k": 0,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.0,
"lo": 0.0,
"hi": 0.03027297257742007
},
"tool_failure_runs": {
"k": 1,
"n": 120,
"rate": 0.008333333333333333,
"lo": 0.00021095947812170912,
"hi": 0.04555551323359298
},
"tokens": {
"mean": 3558.95,
"lo": 3177.007916666667,
"hi": 4008.126666666666
},
"llm_calls": {
"mean": 2.558333333333333,
"lo": 2.3583333333333334,
"hi": 2.783333333333333
},
"tool_calls": {
"mean": 2.05,
"lo": 1.7833333333333334,
"hi": 2.341666666666667
},
"latency_s": {
"mean": 16.107091967316645,
"lo": 14.795578360194575,
"hi": 17.553400923702508
},
"latency_p50": 14.631814708000093,
"latency_p95": 29.773031990149953,
"tokens_per_correct": 5694.32,
"statuses": {
"answered": 120
}
}
}
},
"paired_correct": {
"react vs plan_execute": {
"n": 240,
"a": 143,
"b": 148,
"only_a": 25,
"only_b": 30,
"p": 0.5900533317766354
},
"react vs supervisor": {
"n": 240,
"a": 143,
"b": 156,
"only_a": 18,
"only_b": 31,
"p": 0.08543313315739454
},
"react vs draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"a": 143,
"b": 153,
"only_a": 6,
"only_b": 16,
"p": 0.052478790283203125
},
"plan_execute vs supervisor": {
"n": 240,
"a": 148,
"b": 156,
"only_a": 16,
"only_b": 24,
"p": 0.26818725105476915
},
"plan_execute vs draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"a": 148,
"b": 153,
"only_a": 21,
"only_b": 26,
"p": 0.5600646295802106
},
"supervisor vs draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"a": 156,
"b": 153,
"only_a": 22,
"only_b": 19,
"p": 0.755228657504631
}
},
"paired_invented": {
"react vs plan_execute": {
"n": 240,
"a": 7,
"b": 2,
"only_a": 7,
"only_b": 2,
"p": 0.1796875
},
"react vs supervisor": {
"n": 240,
"a": 7,
"b": 7,
"only_a": 5,
"only_b": 5,
"p": 1.0
},
"react vs draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"a": 7,
"b": 1,
"only_a": 6,
"only_b": 0,
"p": 0.03125
},
"plan_execute vs supervisor": {
"n": 240,
"a": 2,
"b": 7,
"only_a": 2,
"only_b": 7,
"p": 0.1796875
},
"plan_execute vs draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"a": 2,
"b": 1,
"only_a": 2,
"only_b": 1,
"p": 1.0
},
"supervisor vs draft_verify": {
"n": 240,
"a": 7,
"b": 1,
"only_a": 7,
"only_b": 1,
"p": 0.0703125
}
},
"wrong_kinds": {
"react": {
"real but wrong article": 84,
"invented": 7,
"not answered": 6
},
"plan_execute": {
"real but wrong article": 87,
"not answered": 3,
"invented": 2
},
"supervisor": {
"real but wrong article": 74,
"invented": 7,
"no citation": 1,
"not answered": 2
},
"draft_verify": {
"real but wrong article": 83,
"no citation": 1,
"invented": 1,
"not answered": 2
}
},
"node_tokens": {
"react": {
"react.agent": {
"tokens_per_question": 4576.145833333333,
"share": 0.9814237446864028
},
"react.force": {
"tokens_per_question": 86.61666666666666,
"share": 0.01857625531359718
}
},
"plan_execute": {
"step.agent": {
"tokens_per_question": 9516.325,
"share": 0.9032795683402591
},
"step.force": {
"tokens_per_question": 418.00416666666666,
"share": 0.03967651622145065
},
"synth": {
"tokens_per_question": 397.375,
"share": 0.03771841740054175
},
"planner": {
"tokens_per_question": 203.6,
"share": 0.019325498037748474
}
},
"supervisor": {
"researcher.agent": {
"tokens_per_question": 6268.775,
"share": 0.8364751760510523
},
"supervisor": {
"tokens_per_question": 625.1791666666667,
"share": 0.08342090017602326
},
"writer": {
"tokens_per_question": 301.20416666666665,
"share": 0.040191234864835716
},
"researcher.force": {
"tokens_per_question": 299.1166666666667,
"share": 0.03991268890808873
}
},
"draft_verify": {
"draft.agent": {
"tokens_per_question": 4662.529166666666,
"share": 0.9505722511092064
},
"revise.agent": {
"tokens_per_question": 142.85833333333332,
"share": 0.029125215661323166
},
"draft.force": {
"tokens_per_question": 99.58333333333333,
"share": 0.020302533229470444
}
}
},
"noise_floor": {
"react": {
"n": 36,
"right_to_wrong": 3,
"wrong_to_right": 1,
"changed": 4,
"identical_answers": 5,
"correct_run1": 21,
"correct_run2": 19,
"tokens_run1": 3842.1388888888887,
"tokens_run2": 3996.25
},
"plan_execute": {
"n": 36,
"right_to_wrong": 1,
"wrong_to_right": 0,
"changed": 1,
"identical_answers": 5,
"correct_run1": 22,
"correct_run2": 21,
"tokens_run1": 10785.222222222223,
"tokens_run2": 10884.694444444445
},
"supervisor": {
"n": 36,
"right_to_wrong": 1,
"wrong_to_right": 1,
"changed": 2,
"identical_answers": 2,
"correct_run1": 21,
"correct_run2": 21,
"tokens_run1": 7794.027777777777,
"tokens_run2": 8232.666666666666
},
"draft_verify": {
"n": 36,
"right_to_wrong": 2,
"wrong_to_right": 3,
"changed": 5,
"identical_answers": 3,
"correct_run1": 21,
"correct_run2": 22,
"tokens_run1": 4069.0555555555557,
"tokens_run2": 3928.8611111111113
}
},
"dominance": [
"react dominates plan_execute",
"react dominates supervisor",
"supervisor dominates plan_execute",
"draft_verify dominates plan_execute",
"draft_verify dominates supervisor"
]
}