five-desks / source /five_desks /tasks /security.py
rca-umb's picture
Five Desks v1: tasks, calibration, source
1138ff6 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
11.1 kB
"""Security desk: SSH brute-force triage and first-match firewall rules."""
import ipaddress
import random
from ..grading import Part
from .base import Instance, csv_text
USERS = ["alice", "bob", "carol", "dave", "erin", "frank", "deploy", "backup"]
PROBE_USERS = ["root", "admin", "test", "oracle", "ubuntu", "postgres", "git"]
def _ext_ip(rng):
net = rng.choice(["203.0.113", "198.51.100", "192.0.2", "100.64.7", "45.83.12"])
return f"{net}.{rng.randrange(2, 254)}"
def _int_ip(rng):
return f"10.{rng.randrange(0, 4)}.{rng.randrange(0, 255)}.{rng.randrange(2, 254)}"
def _fmt(seconds):
return f"{seconds // 3600:02d}:{seconds % 3600 // 60:02d}:{seconds % 60:02d}"
def auth_log(rng: random.Random, level: int, task_id: str) -> Instance:
while True:
inst = _auth_once(rng, level, task_id)
if inst is not None:
return inst
def _auth_once(rng, level, task_id):
threshold = {1: 5, 2: 5, 3: rng.choice([4, 5, 6])}[level]
window_min = {1: 10, 2: 10, 3: rng.choice([5, 10, 15])}[level]
host = rng.choice(["web01", "bastion", "db-02", "gw1"])
events = [] # (seconds, kind, user, ip)
start = rng.randrange(1 * 3600, 20 * 3600)
def failures(ip, count, t0, spacing, users):
t = t0
for _ in range(count):
user = rng.choice(users)
kind = "invalid" if user in PROBE_USERS and rng.random() < 0.6 else "fail"
events.append((t, kind, user, ip))
t += rng.randrange(*spacing)
return t
used_ips = set()
def fresh(maker):
while True:
ip = maker(rng)
if ip not in used_ips:
used_ips.add(ip)
return ip
# The real compromise.
attacker = fresh(_ext_ip)
victim = rng.choice(USERS)
t_attack = start + rng.randrange(600, 5400)
n_fail = threshold + rng.randrange(0, 4)
burst = max(5, (window_min * 60 - 30) // (n_fail + 1))
t = failures(attacker, n_fail, t_attack, (5, burst), PROBE_USERS + [victim])
success_t = t + rng.randrange(3, 20)
if success_t - t_attack >= window_min * 60:
return None
events.append((success_t, "accept", victim, attacker))
# Benign logins from inside the network.
for _ in range({1: 4, 2: 5, 3: 6}[level]):
user = rng.choice(USERS)
ip = fresh(_int_ip)
t0 = start + rng.randrange(0, 7200)
if rng.random() < 0.4:
events.append((t0, "fail", user, ip))
t0 += rng.randrange(5, 40)
events.append((t0, "accept", user, ip))
allowlist = []
if level >= 2:
# Noisy IP that never gets in.
failures(fresh(_ext_ip), threshold + 3, start + rng.randrange(0, 6000), (2, 30), PROBE_USERS)
# A real user who mistypes a few times, below the threshold, from outside.
ip = fresh(_ext_ip)
user = rng.choice([u for u in USERS if u != victim])
t = failures(ip, threshold - 1, start + rng.randrange(0, 6000), (8, 40), [user])
events.append((t + 10, "accept", user, ip))
if level == 3:
# An allowlisted scanner that fails a lot and then succeeds.
scanner = fresh(_ext_ip)
allowlist.append(scanner)
t = failures(scanner, threshold + 2, start + rng.randrange(0, 6000), (2, 20), PROBE_USERS)
events.append((t + 5, "accept", "backup", scanner))
# A slow guesser: enough failures in total, but spread over more than the window.
slow = fresh(_ext_ip)
t0 = start + rng.randrange(0, 4000)
gap = window_min * 60 // (threshold - 2) + 20
t = t0
for _ in range(threshold + 1):
events.append((t, "fail", rng.choice(USERS), slow))
t += gap
events.append((t, "accept", rng.choice(USERS), slow))
events.sort()
# Verify the ground truth by brute force over the final log.
allowed = set(allowlist)
hits = []
for when, kind, user, ip in events:
if kind != "accept" or ip in allowed:
continue
recent = [e for e in events if e[3] == ip and e[1] in ("fail", "invalid")
and when - window_min * 60 <= e[0] < when]
if len(recent) >= threshold:
hits.append((when, user, ip))
if len(hits) != 1 or hits[0][2] != attacker:
return None
if len({e[0] for e in events}) != len(events):
return None
lines = []
for when, kind, user, ip in events:
if kind == "accept":
msg = f"Accepted password for {user} from {ip}"
elif kind == "invalid":
msg = f"Failed password for invalid user {user} from {ip}"
else:
msg = f"Failed password for {user} from {ip}"
lines.append(f"{_fmt(when)} {host} sshd: {msg}")
files = {"auth.log": "\n".join(lines) + "\n"}
rules = ["# Triage rule",
f"- A compromise is an 'Accepted' login from an IP that had at least {threshold} failed attempts "
f"(any user, including invalid users) from that same IP in the {window_min} minutes before the accepted login."]
if level == 3:
files["allowlist.txt"] = "\n".join(allowlist) + "\n"
rules.append("- IPs in allowlist.txt are internal scanners: never report them.")
rules.append("- Exactly one compromise is present.")
files["triage_rule.md"] = "\n".join(rules) + "\n"
question = "Find the compromise in auth.log: report (1) the source IP, (2) the account that was logged into, and (3) the time of the accepted login."
parts = [Part("ip", "text", attacker, '"<ip>"'),
Part("user", "text", victim, '"<user>"'),
Part("time", "text", _fmt(success_t), '"HH:MM:SS"')]
return Instance(task_id, "cybersecurity", question, files, parts, max_steps=10)
# ---------------------------------------------------------------- firewall
def _net_pool(rng, level):
prefixes = {1: [8, 16, 24], 2: [16, 24, 24, 28], 3: [12, 20, 22, 26, 27, 29]}[level]
nets = []
for _ in range(6):
plen = rng.choice(prefixes)
base = ipaddress.ip_address(rng.choice([
f"10.{rng.randrange(256)}.{rng.randrange(256)}.{rng.randrange(256)}",
f"172.{rng.randrange(16, 32)}.{rng.randrange(256)}.{rng.randrange(256)}",
f"192.168.{rng.randrange(256)}.{rng.randrange(256)}",
]))
nets.append(ipaddress.ip_network(f"{base}/{plen}", strict=False))
return nets
def _port_spec(rng, level):
roll = rng.random()
if roll < 0.25:
return "any"
if level >= 2 and roll < 0.5:
lo = rng.choice([1000, 2000, 3000, 8000, 5000])
return f"{lo}-{lo + rng.choice([99, 499, 999])}"
return str(rng.choice([22, 53, 80, 123, 443, 3306, 5432, 8080]))
def _port_matches(spec, port):
if spec == "any":
return True
if "-" in spec:
lo, hi = map(int, spec.split("-"))
return lo <= port <= hi
return int(spec) == port
def _addr_matches(spec, addr):
return spec == "any" or ipaddress.ip_address(addr) in ipaddress.ip_network(spec)
def _sample_in(rng, net):
return str(net.network_address + rng.randrange(net.num_addresses))
def _near_miss(rng, net):
# An address just outside the network, which naive prefix reading may misjudge.
side = rng.choice([-1, 1])
edge = net.network_address - 1 - rng.randrange(0, 3) if side < 0 else net.broadcast_address + 1 + rng.randrange(0, 3)
return str(edge)
def firewall(rng: random.Random, level: int, task_id: str) -> Instance:
while True:
inst = _firewall_once(rng, level, task_id)
if inst is not None:
return inst
def _firewall_once(rng, level, task_id):
n_rules = {1: 4, 2: 6, 3: 8}[level]
n_packets = {1: 5, 2: 7, 3: 9}[level]
protos = ["tcp", "udp"] + (["any"] if level == 3 else [])
nets = _net_pool(rng, level)
rules = []
for idx in range(n_rules):
rules.append({
"num": (idx + 1) * 10,
"action": rng.choice(["allow", "deny"]) if idx else "allow",
"proto": rng.choice(protos),
"src": rng.choice([str(n) for n in nets] + ["any"]),
"dst": rng.choice([str(n) for n in nets]),
"port": _port_spec(rng, level),
})
def decide(pkt):
for r in rules:
if ((r["proto"] == "any" or r["proto"] == pkt["proto"]) and _addr_matches(r["src"], pkt["src"])
and _addr_matches(r["dst"], pkt["dst"]) and _port_matches(r["port"], pkt["port"])):
return r["action"], str(r["num"])
return "deny", "default"
packets = []
for i in range(n_packets):
rule = rng.choice(rules)
proto = rule["proto"] if rule["proto"] != "any" else rng.choice(["tcp", "udp"])
src_net = ipaddress.ip_network(rule["src"]) if rule["src"] != "any" else rng.choice(nets)
dst_net = ipaddress.ip_network(rule["dst"])
src = _sample_in(rng, src_net)
dst = _near_miss(rng, dst_net) if level >= 2 and rng.random() < 0.3 else _sample_in(rng, dst_net)
spec = rule["port"]
if spec == "any":
port = rng.choice([22, 80, 443, 8443, 3389, 25])
elif "-" in spec:
lo, hi = map(int, spec.split("-"))
port = rng.choice([lo, hi, rng.randrange(lo, hi + 1), hi + 1])
else:
port = int(spec)
if rng.random() < 0.15:
proto = "udp" if proto == "tcp" else "tcp"
packets.append({"id": f"P{i + 1}", "proto": proto, "src": src, "dst": dst, "port": port})
verdicts = {p["id"]: decide(p) for p in packets}
allowed = sorted((pid for pid, (act, _) in verdicts.items() if act == "allow"), key=lambda s: int(s[1:]))
if not (1 <= len(allowed) <= n_packets - 1):
return None
deciders = {v[1] for v in verdicts.values()}
if len(deciders) < 3:
return None
# Ask about a packet that is not decided by the first rule it superficially resembles.
query = rng.choice([p["id"] for p in packets if verdicts[p["id"]][1] != "10"] or [packets[0]["id"]])
rule_lines = ["# Firewall policy (evaluated top to bottom; the first matching rule decides; no match = deny)"]
for r in rules:
rule_lines.append(f"rule {r['num']}: {r['action']} proto {r['proto']} from {r['src']} to {r['dst']} port {r['port']}")
files = {
"rules.txt": "\n".join(rule_lines) + "\n",
"packets.csv": csv_text(["id", "proto", "src", "dst", "dst_port"],
[[p["id"], p["proto"], p["src"], p["dst"], p["port"]] for p in packets]),
}
question = (f"Apply rules.txt to every packet in packets.csv. Report (1) the ids of all allowed packets and "
f"(2) which rule decides packet {query} (its rule number, or \"default\" if no rule matches).")
parts = [Part("allowed", "items", allowed, '["P1", ...]'),
Part("deciding_rule", "rule", verdicts[query][1], '"<rule number or default>"')]
return Instance(task_id, "cybersecurity", question, files, parts, max_steps=8)