| replicate,pmid,effect_label,published,reconstructed,ci_low,ci_high,published_conclusion,include_effect_size,rationale,absolute_log_difference,signed_log_ratio,same_positive_direction,null_conclusion_retained |
| 8404,33398753,"Italy, 7 April doubling",1.76,1.2383041226221332,1.0204380635960901,1.5026851259342286,positive,True,Article focal 7 April PM10 doubling contrast.,0.35157100855711043,-0.3515710085571104,True,False |
| 8404,33484722,OECD day-60 cases,1.02,1.1346876449,0.9566246783,1.3458946658,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.10655478303068808,0.10655478303068798,False,True |
| 8404,33484722,OECD day-60 deaths,1.03,1.0569050086,0.8657046289,1.2903340931,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.025786031733934765,0.02578603173393481,False,True |
| 8404,33484722,OECD day-80 cases,1.02,1.0752178952,0.9442740176,1.2243199544,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.0527207069532556,0.052720706953255564,False,True |
| 8404,33484722,OECD day-80 deaths,1.009,1.0262037331,0.8437855939,1.2480588782,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.016906555937543345,0.016906555937543376,False,True |
| 8404,34004167,Northern Italy incident cases,1.0,1.0056411416,1.003269188,1.008018703,null,False,Article reports only a rounded null ratio; retain for null-conclusion scoring.,0.005625289947063163,0.005625289947063163,False,False |
| 8404,34004167,Northern Italy incident deaths,1.0,1.0053099211,1.0041015542,1.0065197422,null,False,Article reports only a rounded null ratio; retain for null-conclusion scoring.,0.005295873175925636,0.005295873175925636,False,False |
| 8404,34488764,France continuous PM2.5,1.24,1.355144,1.192515,1.539952,positive,True,Matched continuous fully adjusted contrast.,0.0887963421308674,0.08879634213086743,True,False |
| 8404,36383802,Sao Jose O3 lag 2,1.061,0.6923651565024976,0.4690487681117765,1.0220035581129423,positive,True,"Article-specified pollutant, lag, and ratio contrast.",0.4268536393648502,-0.42685363936485027,False,False |
| 8404,36383802,Sao Jose NO2 lag 3,1.125,2.198039817831768,0.6869599128448366,7.032985404877874,positive,True,"Article-specified pollutant, lag, and ratio contrast.",0.6697829356440238,0.6697829356440238,True,False |
| 8404,38182658,UK PM2.5,1.13,1.0700745807495362,1.06764487994319,1.0725098109656321,positive,True,Bounded ratio-scale PM2.5 contrast.,0.05448928504439983,-0.05448928504439985,True,False |
| 8404,38788590,Brazil cancer mortality,1.01,0.9710111557808493,0.9287615171656768,1.0151827430665052,null,True,Matched PM2.5 ratio contrast in a bounded geographic slice.,0.03936765264926796,-0.039367652649267976,False,True |
| 8404,39377000,US stroke,1.132,0.9889294365,0.9726270555,1.0052318174,positive,False,Direction is interpretable; magnitude is excluded because the fitted outcome differs from the article subtype and age target.,0.13511827801747747,-0.1351182780174775,False,False |
| 8406,33227571,Sao Paulo AMI admissions,1.09,0.6502463055,0.2852171082,1.482450546,positive,True,High- versus low-pollution AMI admissions contrast.,0.516581752571469,-0.516581752571469,False,False |
| 8406,33398753,"Italy, 7 April doubling",1.76,1.1503218860519138,0.8942145943291312,1.4797795181622706,positive,True,Article focal 7 April PM10 doubling contrast.,0.42527200492514716,-0.4252720049251471,True,False |
| 8406,33484722,OECD day-60 cases,1.02,1.111084,0.98738,1.250287,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.08553348806396169,0.08553348806396162,False,True |
| 8406,33484722,OECD day-60 deaths,1.03,1.18695,1.004608,1.402389,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.14182818949963055,0.14182818949963052,False,False |
| 8406,33484722,OECD day-80 cases,1.02,1.064637,0.967775,1.171193,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.04283126869390256,0.04283126869390251,False,True |
| 8406,33484722,OECD day-80 deaths,1.009,1.077049,0.932485,1.244025,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.06526515251806601,0.065265152518066,False,True |
| 8406,34004167,Northern Italy incident cases,1.0,1.1559907083,1.0725488935,1.2459241027,null,False,Article reports only a rounded null ratio; retain for null-conclusion scoring.,0.1449577324151143,0.1449577324151143,False,False |
| 8406,34004167,Northern Italy incident deaths,1.0,0.9962815155,0.9844977775,1.0082062964,null,False,Article reports only a rounded null ratio; retain for null-conclusion scoring.,0.0037254152500808147,-0.0037254152500808147,False,True |
| 8406,34488764,France continuous PM2.5,1.24,1.3536898948,1.1923182787,1.5369019866,positive,True,Matched continuous fully adjusted contrast.,0.08772273969074679,0.08772273969074683,True,False |
| 8406,36383802,Sao Jose O3 lag 2,1.061,1.0263742977173338,0.9953033539791288,1.058415200554866,positive,True,"Article-specified pollutant, lag, and ratio contrast.",0.033179366821207534,-0.03317936682120754,True,False |
| 8406,36383802,Sao Jose NO2 lag 3,1.125,1.5249606083355989,1.2130071598296124,1.9171402560409747,positive,True,"Article-specified pollutant, lag, and ratio contrast.",0.30418554346976856,0.30418554346976856,True,False |
| 8406,38182658,UK PM2.5,1.13,1.7189892341,1.7076838423,1.7303694711,positive,True,Bounded ratio-scale PM2.5 contrast.,0.4195188307714526,0.41951883077145263,True,False |
| 8406,38788590,Brazil cancer mortality,1.01,1.017754138136571,0.9858916320293315,1.0506463915937743,null,True,Matched PM2.5 ratio contrast in a bounded geographic slice.,0.007648043505197127,0.0076480435051971335,False,True |
| 8406,39377000,US ischemic stroke,1.132,2.36,0.66,4.05,positive,False,The autonomous run's native additive slope is positive. Magnitude is excluded because additive and ratio scales are not directly comparable.,0.7346756392565276,0.7346756392565276,True,False |
| 8407,33398753,"Italy, 7 April doubling",1.76,0.8410536744546437,5.67073270539326e-05,12474.072047882559,positive,True,Article focal 7 April PM10 doubling contrast.,0.7384136079142956,-0.7384136079142956,False,False |
| 8407,33484722,OECD day-60 cases,1.02,1.1464274270821027,0.9734368915470697,1.350160300045027,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.11684789448025265,0.11684789448025268,False,True |
| 8407,33484722,OECD day-60 deaths,1.03,1.1809024534141734,0.9356988001469596,1.4903627152889276,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.13672013496135516,0.13672013496135513,False,True |
| 8407,33484722,OECD day-80 cases,1.02,1.0736874861887384,0.9399304761772739,1.2264788164830922,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.05129634524495696,0.051296345244957034,False,True |
| 8407,33484722,OECD day-80 deaths,1.009,1.0302730672642948,0.8437717668573186,1.2579972864980573,null,True,Matched reported event-day contrast.,0.02086413958243605,0.02086413958243615,False,True |
| 8407,34004167,Northern Italy incident cases,1.0,1.0064636709840817,1.0040938601550395,1.0088390749190959,null,False,Article reports only a rounded null ratio; retain for null-conclusion scoring.,0.006442871043987218,0.006442871043987218,False,False |
| 8407,34004167,Northern Italy incident deaths,1.0,1.0073831565054678,1.0064572801886127,1.008309884569308,null,False,Article reports only a rounded null ratio; retain for null-conclusion scoring.,0.007356034421389066,0.007356034421389066,False,False |
| 8407,38182658,UK PM2.5,1.13,0.7022175276,0.6962171726,0.7082695968,positive,True,Bounded ratio-scale PM2.5 contrast.,0.47572968730379656,-0.47572968730379656,False,False |
| 8407,38788590,Brazil cancer mortality,1.01,0.7941872236440768,0.6325054842161077,0.9971982250575784,null,True,Matched PM2.5 ratio contrast in a bounded geographic slice.,0.24038637834375898,-0.24038637834375892,False,False |
| 8407,39377000,US stroke bounded sensitivity,1.132,1.5171,1.472,1.5622,positive,False,Direction is interpretable; magnitude is excluded because the fitted outcome and presentation ratio differ from the article target.,0.2928146379909188,0.2928146379909189,True,False |
|
|
