roseking's picture
Add lean source and binary files (part 65)
720fa25 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
20.2 kB
import OAI.Dynamics.TriangleBilliards.RegularRays
namespace OAI
open MeasureTheory Set
open scoped ENNReal symmDiff
noncomputable section
namespace TriangularBilliards
open Filter
open scoped Topology
lemma crossMap_flight (p x v : ℂ) (t : ℝ) :
crossMap v (x + t • v - p) = crossMap v (x - p) := by
rw [show x + t • v - p = (x - p) + t • v by abel,
map_add, map_smul, crossMap_self, smul_zero, add_zero]
lemma crossMap_abs_le (v : Circle) (x : ℂ) : |crossMap v x| ≤ ‖x‖ := by
calc
|crossMap v x| ≤ ‖x * star (v : ℂ)‖ := Complex.abs_im_le_norm _
_ = ‖x‖ := by rw [norm_mul, norm_star, Circle.norm_coe, mul_one]
lemma wallReflection_fixed_vertex (Q : Triangle) (i k : Fin 3) (hk : k ≠ i + 2) :
wallReflection Q i (Q.vertex k) = Q.vertex k := by
have h : k = i ∨ k = i + 1 ∨ k = i + 2 := by fin_cases i <;> fin_cases k <;> decide
rcases h with rfl | rfl | h
· simp [wallReflection, reflect]
· change Q.vertex i + reflect (Q.tangent i) (Q.tangent i) = Q.vertex (i + 1)
rw [reflect_tangent (Q.tangent_ne_zero i), Triangle.tangent]
abel
· exact False.elim (hk h)
namespace Admissible
lemma wall_ne_next {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) (n : ℕ) :
(z.iterate n).collision.wall ≠ (z.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall := by
intro he
let i := (z.iterate n).collision.wall
have h0 : Q.basis.coord (i + 2) (z.iterate (n + 1)).pos = 0 :=
(Q.side_coord_zero_iff (z.iterate_on_side n) (i + 2)).mpr rfl
have hp : 0 < Q.slope (i + 2) (z.iterate (n + 1)).vel :=
(z.iterate (n + 1)).inward.2 (i + 2) h0
have h1 : Q.basis.coord (i + 2) (z.iterate (n + 2)).pos = 0 := by
apply (Q.side_coord_zero_iff (z.iterate_on_side (n + 1)) (i + 2)).mpr
rw [← he]
change Q.basis.coord (i + 2) ((z.iterate (n + 1)).pos +
(z.iterate (n + 1)).collision.delay • ((z.iterate (n + 1)).vel : ℂ)) = 0 at h1
rw [Q.coord_shift, h0, zero_add] at h1
exact (ne_of_gt (mul_pos (z.iterate (n + 1)).collision.positive hp)) h1
lemma dist_iterate_le_dist_time {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) (m n : ℕ) :
dist (z.iterate m).pos (z.iterate n).pos ≤ dist (z.time m) (z.time n) := by
rcases le_total m n with h | h
· rw [Real.dist_eq, abs_sub_comm, abs_of_nonneg (sub_nonneg.mpr (z.time_strictMono.monotone h))]
exact z.dist_iterate_le_time h
· rw [dist_comm (z.iterate m).pos, dist_comm (z.time m), Real.dist_eq, abs_sub_comm,
abs_of_nonneg (sub_nonneg.mpr (z.time_strictMono.monotone h))]
exact z.dist_iterate_le_time h
lemma positions_converge_of_bounded_time {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q)
(hb : BddAbove (range z.time)) :
∃ p : ℂ, Tendsto (fun n => (z.iterate n).pos) atTop (𝓝 p) := by
have ht := tendsto_atTop_ciSup z.time_strictMono.monotone hb
apply cauchySeq_tendsto_of_complete
rw [Metric.cauchySeq_iff]
intro ε hε
obtain ⟨N, hN⟩ := Metric.cauchySeq_iff.mp ht.cauchySeq ε hε
exact ⟨N, fun m hm n hn => lt_of_le_of_lt (z.dist_iterate_le_dist_time m n) (hN m hm n hn)⟩
/-- If infinitely many collisions accumulated in finite distance, their
common limit would have to be a vertex, not an arbitrary boundary point. -/
lemma limit_is_vertex {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) {p : ℂ}
(hp : Tendsto (fun n => (z.iterate n).pos) atTop (𝓝 p)) : ∃ k, p = Q.vertex k := by
have hc (i : Fin 3) : Tendsto (fun n => Q.basis.coord i (z.iterate n).pos) atTop
(𝓝 (Q.basis.coord i p)) :=
(Q.basis.coord i).continuous_of_finiteDimensional.continuousAt.tendsto.comp hp
have hnonneg (i : Fin 3) : 0 ≤ Q.basis.coord i p :=
ge_of_tendsto' (hc i) (fun n => (z.iterate n).inward.1 i)
have hz : ∃ i, Q.basis.coord i p = 0 := by
by_contra hn
push Not at hn
have hpos (i : Fin 3) : 0 < Q.basis.coord i p := lt_of_le_of_ne (hnonneg i) (hn i).symm
have he : ∀ᶠ n : ℕ in atTop, ∀ i, 0 < Q.basis.coord i (z.iterate n).pos :=
eventually_all.mpr fun i => (hc i).eventually (lt_mem_nhds (hpos i))
obtain ⟨N, hN⟩ := eventually_atTop.mp he
have hzero := (Q.side_coord_zero_iff (z.iterate_on_side N)
((z.iterate N).collision.wall + 2)).mpr rfl
have hpositive := hN (N + 1) (Nat.le_succ N) ((z.iterate N).collision.wall + 2)
linarith
by_contra hn
push Not at hn
obtain ⟨i, hi⟩ := Q.boundary_open_side hnonneg hz hn
have hpos (j : Fin 3) (hj : j ≠ i + 2) : 0 < Q.basis.coord j p := by
apply lt_of_le_of_ne (hnonneg j)
intro hj0
exact hj ((Q.side_coord_zero_iff hi j).mp hj0.symm)
have he : ∀ᶠ n : ℕ in atTop, ∀ j, j ≠ i + 2 → 0 < Q.basis.coord j (z.iterate n).pos := by
apply eventually_all.mpr
intro j
by_cases hj : j = i + 2
· exact Eventually.of_forall fun _ h => False.elim (h hj)
· exact ((hc j).eventually (lt_mem_nhds (hpos j hj))).mono fun _ h _ => h
obtain ⟨N, hN⟩ := eventually_atTop.mp he
have hw (n : ℕ) (hn : N ≤ n + 1) : (z.iterate n).collision.wall = i := by
apply add_right_cancel (b := (2 : Fin 3))
by_contra h
have hz := (Q.side_coord_zero_iff (z.iterate_on_side n)
((z.iterate n).collision.wall + 2)).mpr rfl
have hp := hN (n + 1) hn ((z.iterate n).collision.wall + 2) h
linarith
exact z.wall_ne_next N ((hw N (by omega)).trans (hw (N + 1) (by omega)).symm)
/-- Absolute angular momentum about a fixed point. -/
def momentum {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) (p : ℂ) : ℝ :=
|crossMap z.vel (z.pos - p)|
lemma momentum_next {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) (p : ℂ)
(hp : wallReflection Q z.collision.wall p = p) : z.next.momentum p = z.momentum p := by
have hx := wallReflection_fixed_side Q z.collision.on_side
have h := crossMap_reflect (Q.tangent_ne_zero z.collision.wall) (z.vel : ℂ)
(z.pos + z.collision.delay • (z.vel : ℂ) - p)
rw [← wallReflection_sub, hx, hp, crossMap_flight] at h
change |crossMap (reflect (Q.tangent z.collision.wall) z.vel)
(z.pos + z.collision.delay • (z.vel : ℂ) - p)| = |crossMap (z.vel : ℂ) (z.pos - p)|
rw [h, abs_neg]
lemma momentum_tendsto_zero {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) {p : ℂ}
(hp : Tendsto (fun n => (z.iterate n).pos) atTop (𝓝 p)) :
Tendsto (fun n => (z.iterate n).momentum p) atTop (𝓝 0) := by
have hnorm : Tendsto (fun n => ‖(z.iterate n).pos - p‖) atTop (𝓝 0) := by
simpa only [sub_self, norm_zero] using (hp.sub_const p).norm
apply squeeze_zero (fun n => abs_nonneg _) (fun n => crossMap_abs_le _ _) hnorm
lemma eventually_wall_fixed_of_vertex_limit {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) (k : Fin 3)
(hp : Tendsto (fun n => (z.iterate n).pos) atTop (𝓝 (Q.vertex k))) :
∀ᶠ n : ℕ in atTop, wallReflection Q (z.iterate n).collision.wall (Q.vertex k) = Q.vertex k := by
have hc := (Q.basis.coord k).continuous_of_finiteDimensional.continuousAt.tendsto.comp
(hp.comp (tendsto_add_atTop_nat 1))
have hk : Q.basis.coord k (Q.vertex k) = 1 := Q.basis.coord_apply_eq k
filter_upwards [hc.eventually (lt_mem_nhds (by rw [hk]; norm_num : 0 <
Q.basis.coord k (Q.vertex k)))] with n hn
apply wallReflection_fixed_vertex
intro he
have hz := (Q.side_coord_zero_iff (z.iterate_on_side n) k).mpr he
change 0 < Q.basis.coord k (z.iterate (n + 1)).pos at hn
linarith
/-- Non-Zeno is proved, not added as an admissibility hypothesis: finite
accumulation would approach a vertex, where conservation of absolute
angular momentum forces this regular ray to aim through that vertex. -/
lemma time_not_bddAbove {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) : ¬ BddAbove (range z.time) := by
intro hb
obtain ⟨p, hp⟩ := z.positions_converge_of_bounded_time hb
obtain ⟨k, rfl⟩ := z.limit_is_vertex hp
have he := z.eventually_wall_fixed_of_vertex_limit k hp
obtain ⟨N, hN⟩ := eventually_atTop.mp he
have hconst (n : ℕ) (hn : N ≤ n) :
(z.iterate n).momentum (Q.vertex k) = (z.iterate N).momentum (Q.vertex k) := by
induction n, hn using Nat.le_induction with
| base => rfl
| succ n hn ih =>
exact ((z.iterate n).momentum_next (Q.vertex k) (hN n hn)).trans ih
have ht : Tendsto (fun n => (z.iterate n).momentum (Q.vertex k)) atTop
(𝓝 ((z.iterate N).momentum (Q.vertex k))) :=
tendsto_const_nhds.congr' (eventually_atTop.mpr ⟨N, fun n hn => (hconst n hn).symm⟩)
have hm := tendsto_nhds_unique ht (z.momentum_tendsto_zero hp)
apply (z.iterate N).regular
simp only [vertexExceptional, mem_iUnion]
refine ⟨[], k, ?_⟩
exact abs_eq_zero.mp hm
lemma time_unbounded_above {Q : Triangle} (z : Admissible Q) (t : ℝ) :
∃ n : ℕ, t < z.time n := by
by_contra hn
push Not at hn
apply z.time_not_bddAbove
exact ⟨t, fun _ ⟨n, hn'⟩ => hn' ▸ hn n⟩
end Admissible
lemma reflect_neg (e v : ℂ) : reflect e (-v) = -reflect e v := by
simp [reflect]
lemma vertexExceptional_neg_iff (Q : Triangle) (x : ℂ) (v : Circle) :
(x, -v) ∈ vertexExceptional Q ↔ (x, v) ∈ vertexExceptional Q := by
simp only [vertexExceptional, mem_iUnion, aimingAt, mem_ofPred_eq, Circle.coe_neg]
have he (p : ℂ) : crossMap (-(v : ℂ)) (x - p) = -crossMap v (x - p) := by
simp [crossMap]
simp only [he, neg_eq_zero]
/-- The two genuine recursively generated rays, joined at an interior state. -/
structure TwoRays (Q : Triangle) (z : Phase) where
interior_pos : z.1 ∈ Q.table
forward : Admissible Q
backward : Admissible Q
forward_pos : forward.pos = z.1
backward_pos : backward.pos = z.1
forward_vel : forward.vel = z.2
backward_vel : backward.vel = -z.2
noncomputable def regularRays (Q : Triangle) (z : Phase) (hx : z.1 ∈ Q.table)
(hr : z ∉ vertexExceptional Q) : TwoRays Q z where
interior_pos := hx
forward := ⟨z.1, z.2, Q.inward_of_table hx, hr⟩
backward := ⟨z.1, -z.2, Q.inward_of_table hx, by rwa [vertexExceptional_neg_iff]⟩
forward_pos := rfl
backward_pos := rfl
forward_vel := rfl
backward_vel := rfl
namespace TwoRays
variable {Q : Triangle} {z : Phase} (r : TwoRays Q z)
def time : ℤ → ℝ
| .ofNat 0 => -r.backward.time 1
| .ofNat (n + 1) => r.forward.time (n + 1)
| .negSucc n => -r.backward.time (n + 2)
def point : ℤ → ℂ
| .ofNat 0 => (r.backward.iterate 1).pos
| .ofNat (n + 1) => (r.forward.iterate (n + 1)).pos
| .negSucc n => (r.backward.iterate (n + 2)).pos
def direction : ℤ → Circle
| .ofNat n => (r.forward.iterate n).vel
| .negSucc n => -(r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel
def wall : ℤ → Fin 3
| .ofNat 0 => r.backward.collision.wall
| .ofNat (n + 1) => (r.forward.iterate n).collision.wall
| .negSucc n => (r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall
lemma zero_before : r.time 0 < 0 := by
change -r.backward.time 1 < 0
have h := r.backward.time_strictMono (Nat.zero_lt_succ 0)
rw [r.backward.time_zero] at h
exact neg_neg_of_pos h
lemma zero_after : 0 < r.time 1 := by
change 0 < r.forward.time 1
have h := r.forward.time_strictMono (Nat.zero_lt_succ 0)
rwa [r.forward.time_zero] at h
lemma increasing : StrictMono r.time := by
apply strictMono_int_of_lt_succ
intro n
cases n with
| ofNat n =>
cases n with
| zero => exact lt_trans r.zero_before r.zero_after
| succ n => exact r.forward.time_strictMono (Nat.lt_succ_self (n + 1))
| negSucc n =>
cases n with
| zero => exact neg_lt_neg (r.backward.time_strictMono (by omega : 1 < 2))
| succ n => exact neg_lt_neg (r.backward.time_strictMono (Nat.lt_succ_self (n + 2)))
lemma unbounded_above (t : ℝ) : ∃ n : ℤ, t < r.time n := by
obtain ⟨n, hn⟩ := r.forward.time_unbounded_above t
exact ⟨Int.ofNat (n + 1), lt_trans hn (r.forward.time_strictMono (Nat.lt_succ_self n))⟩
lemma unbounded_below (t : ℝ) : ∃ n : ℤ, r.time n < t := by
obtain ⟨n, hn⟩ := r.backward.time_unbounded_above (-t)
refine ⟨Int.negSucc n, ?_⟩
change -r.backward.time (n + 2) < t
have h := r.backward.time_strictMono (by omega : n < n + 2)
linarith
lemma on_side (n : ℤ) : r.point n ∈ Q.side (r.wall n) := by
cases n with
| ofNat n =>
cases n with
| zero => exact r.backward.iterate_on_side 0
| succ n => exact r.forward.iterate_on_side n
| negSucc n => exact r.backward.iterate_on_side (n + 1)
lemma middle_point :
r.point 0 = z.1 - r.backward.time 1 • (z.2 : ℂ) := by
change (r.backward.iterate 1).pos = _
rw [r.backward.iterate_flight 0, r.backward.time_zero, sub_zero]
change r.backward.pos + r.backward.time 1 • (r.backward.vel : ℂ) = _
rw [r.backward_pos, r.backward_vel, Circle.coe_neg, smul_neg, sub_eq_add_neg]
lemma start_point : z.1 = r.point 0 + (-r.time 0) • (r.direction 0 : ℂ) := by
rw [r.middle_point]
change z.1 = z.1 - r.backward.time 1 • (z.2 : ℂ) +
(- -r.backward.time 1) • (r.forward.vel : ℂ)
rw [neg_neg, r.forward_vel]
abel
lemma flight (n : ℤ) : r.point (n + 1) = r.point n +
(r.time (n + 1) - r.time n) • (r.direction n : ℂ) := by
cases n with
| ofNat n =>
cases n with
| zero =>
change r.point 1 = r.point 0 + (r.time 1 - r.time 0) • (r.direction 0 : ℂ)
rw [r.middle_point]
change (r.forward.iterate 1).pos = z.1 - r.backward.time 1 • (z.2 : ℂ) +
(r.forward.time 1 - -r.backward.time 1) • (r.forward.vel : ℂ)
rw [r.forward.iterate_flight 0, r.forward.time_zero, sub_zero]
change r.forward.pos + r.forward.time 1 • (r.forward.vel : ℂ) = _
rw [r.forward_pos, r.forward_vel, sub_neg_eq_add, add_smul]
abel
| succ n => exact r.forward.iterate_flight (n + 1)
| negSucc n =>
have h := r.backward.iterate_flight (n + 1)
cases n with
| zero =>
change (r.backward.iterate 1).pos = (r.backward.iterate 2).pos +
(-r.backward.time 1 - -r.backward.time 2) • (-(r.backward.iterate 1).vel : Circle)
rw [Circle.coe_neg, smul_neg, h]
rw [show -r.backward.time 1 - -r.backward.time 2 =
r.backward.time 2 - r.backward.time 1 by ring]
abel
| succ n =>
change (r.backward.iterate (n + 2)).pos = (r.backward.iterate (n + 3)).pos +
(-r.backward.time (n + 2) - -r.backward.time (n + 3)) •
(-(r.backward.iterate (n + 2)).vel : Circle)
rw [Circle.coe_neg, smul_neg, h]
rw [show -r.backward.time (n + 2) - -r.backward.time (n + 3) =
r.backward.time (n + 3) - r.backward.time (n + 2) by ring]
abel
lemma middle_flight (t : ℝ) :
r.point 0 + (t - r.time 0) • (r.direction 0 : ℂ) = z.1 + t • (z.2 : ℂ) := by
rw [r.middle_point]
change z.1 - r.backward.time 1 • (z.2 : ℂ) +
(t - -r.backward.time 1) • (r.forward.vel : ℂ) = _
rw [r.forward_vel, sub_neg_eq_add, add_smul]
abel
lemma inside (n : ℤ) (t : ℝ) (h0 : r.time n < t) (h1 : t < r.time (n + 1)) :
r.point n + (t - r.time n) • (r.direction n : ℂ) ∈ Q.table := by
cases n with
| ofNat n =>
cases n with
| zero =>
change r.point 0 + (t - r.time 0) • (r.direction 0 : ℂ) ∈ Q.table
rw [r.middle_flight]
rcases lt_trichotomy t 0 with ht | rfl | ht
· have h : -t < r.backward.time 1 := by change -r.backward.time 1 < t at h0; linarith
have hp := r.backward.iterate_inside 0 (t := -t)
(by rw [r.backward.time_zero]; linarith) h
change r.backward.pos + (-t - r.backward.time 0) • (r.backward.vel : ℂ) ∈ Q.table at hp
simpa only [r.backward.time_zero, sub_zero, r.backward_pos, r.backward_vel,
Circle.coe_neg, smul_neg, neg_smul, neg_neg] using hp
· simpa only [zero_smul, add_zero] using r.interior_pos
· have hp := r.forward.iterate_inside 0 (t := t)
(by rw [r.forward.time_zero]; exact ht) h1
change r.forward.pos + (t - r.forward.time 0) • (r.forward.vel : ℂ) ∈ Q.table at hp
simpa only [r.forward.time_zero, sub_zero, r.forward_pos, r.forward_vel] using hp
| succ n => exact r.forward.iterate_inside (n + 1) h0 h1
| negSucc n =>
have ht0 : r.backward.time (n + 1) < -t := by
cases n with
| zero => change t < -r.backward.time 1 at h1; linarith
| succ n => change t < -r.backward.time (n + 2) at h1; linarith
have ht1 : -t < r.backward.time (n + 2) := by
change -r.backward.time (n + 2) < t at h0
linarith
have hp := r.backward.iterate_inside (n + 1) ht0 ht1
change (r.backward.iterate (n + 2)).pos + (t - -r.backward.time (n + 2)) •
(-(r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel : Circle) ∈ Q.table
rw [Circle.coe_neg, smul_neg, r.backward.iterate_flight (n + 1)]
convert hp using 1
module
lemma specular (n : ℤ) :
(r.direction n : ℂ) = reflect (Q.tangent (r.wall n)) (r.direction (n - 1) : ℂ) := by
cases n with
| ofNat n =>
cases n with
| zero =>
change (r.forward.vel : ℂ) = reflect (Q.tangent r.backward.collision.wall)
(-(r.backward.iterate 1).vel : Circle)
change (r.forward.vel : ℂ) = reflect (Q.tangent r.backward.collision.wall)
(-reflectedDirection Q r.backward.collision.wall r.backward.vel : Circle)
rw [Circle.coe_neg, reflect_neg]
change (r.forward.vel : ℂ) = -reflect (Q.tangent r.backward.collision.wall)
(reflect (Q.tangent r.backward.collision.wall) r.backward.vel)
rw [reflect_involutive (Q.tangent_ne_zero _), r.forward_vel, r.backward_vel,
Circle.coe_neg, neg_neg]
| succ n =>
change ((r.forward.iterate n).next.vel : ℂ) = reflect
(Q.tangent (r.forward.iterate n).collision.wall) (r.direction (Int.ofNat (n + 1) - 1) : ℂ)
rw [show Int.ofNat (n + 1) - 1 = Int.ofNat n by change (↑(n + 1) : ℤ) - 1 = ↑n; omega]
rfl
| negSucc n =>
change (-(r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel : Circle) = reflect
(Q.tangent (r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall)
(r.direction (Int.negSucc n - 1) : ℂ)
rw [show Int.negSucc n - 1 = Int.negSucc (n + 1) by omega]
change (-(r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel : Circle) = reflect
(Q.tangent (r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall)
(-reflectedDirection Q (r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall
(r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel : Circle)
rw [Circle.coe_neg, Circle.coe_neg, reflect_neg]
change -((r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel : ℂ) = -reflect
(Q.tangent (r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall)
(reflect (Q.tangent (r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).collision.wall)
(r.backward.iterate (n + 1)).vel)
rw [reflect_involutive (Q.tangent_ne_zero _)]
/-- The full two-sided, non-Zeno, specular chain, assembled from actual exits. -/
def chain : FlightChain Q z where
time := r.time
point := r.point
direction := r.direction
wall := r.wall
increasing := r.increasing
unbounded_below := r.unbounded_below
unbounded_above := r.unbounded_above
zero_before := r.zero_before
zero_after := r.zero_after
on_side := r.on_side
flight := r.flight
inside := r.inside
start_point := r.start_point
start_direction := r.forward_vel.symm
specular := r.specular
end TwoRays
lemma exists_chain_of_not_exceptional (Q : Triangle) (z : Phase) (hx : z.1 ∈ Q.table)
(hr : z ∉ vertexExceptional Q) : Nonempty (FlightChain Q z) :=
⟨(regularRays Q z hx hr).chain⟩
lemma ae_position_in_table (Q : Triangle) : ∀ᵐ z ∂phaseMeasure Q, z.1 ∈ Q.table := by
rw [ae_iff]
rw [show {a : Phase | a.1 ∉ Q.table} = Q.tableᶜ ×ˢ (univ : Set Circle) by
ext a; simp]
rw [phaseMeasure, Measure.prod_prod, Measure.smul_apply,
Measure.restrict_apply Q.measurableSet_table.compl]
simp only [compl_inter_self, measure_empty, smul_zero, zero_mul]
/-- Complete regular trajectories exist for almost every initial state under
exact normalized area-angular measure; all collisions and both infinite
ends have been constructed above, with no completeness hypothesis. -/
lemma ae_exists_chain (Q : Triangle) :
∀ᵐ z ∂phaseMeasure Q, Nonempty (FlightChain Q z) := by
have hr : ∀ᵐ z ∂phaseMeasure Q, z ∉ vertexExceptional Q := by
rw [ae_iff]
convert phaseMeasure_vertexExceptional Q using 2
ext a; simp
filter_upwards [ae_position_in_table Q, hr] with z hx hz
exact exists_chain_of_not_exceptional Q z hx hz
end TriangularBilliards
end
end OAI