coqar-clarifications / code /scale_export.py
rvashurin's picture
Publish paired CoQAR clarification datasets
833376d verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
19.4 kB
"""Export paired CoQAR runs without model calls or silently dropping failures."""
from collections import Counter, defaultdict
from datetime import datetime, timezone
import hashlib
import json
import math
from pathlib import Path
import statistics
from scale_client import read_calls, read_cost_summary
def _hash(value):
return hashlib.sha256(json.dumps(value, ensure_ascii=False, sort_keys=True,
allow_nan=False).encode()).hexdigest()
def _save(path, value):
temporary = path.with_suffix(path.suffix + ".tmp")
temporary.write_text(json.dumps(value, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2, allow_nan=False))
temporary.replace(path)
def _call(identifier, by_id, story, question, stage, menu=None, selected_id=None):
attempts = by_id.get(identifier, [])
completed = [call for call in attempts if call.get("status") == "completed"]
call = completed[0] if completed else None
errors = ["multiple_completed_attempts"] if len(completed) > 1 else []
if call:
request = call["request"]
if _hash(request) != call.get("request_sha256"):
errors.append("request_hash_mismatch")
try:
prefix = "Input JSON:\n"
if not request["input"].startswith(prefix):
raise ValueError("Unexpected input prefix")
payload = json.loads(request["input"][len(prefix):])
if payload.get("story") != story or payload.get("question") != question:
errors.append("input_story_or_question_mismatch")
expected = {"story", "question"} | ({"menu", "selected_id"} if stage == "render"
else {"samples"} if stage == "audit" else set())
if set(payload) != expected:
errors.append("unexpected_model_visible_fields")
if stage == "render" and (payload.get("menu") != menu
or payload.get("selected_id") != selected_id):
errors.append("render_menu_or_selection_mismatch")
except (ValueError, TypeError, KeyError):
errors.append("invalid_saved_input")
try:
if json.loads(call["text"]) != call.get("parsed"):
errors.append("response_text_parsed_mismatch")
except (ValueError, TypeError, KeyError):
errors.append("invalid_saved_response_text")
extracted = "".join(part.get("text", "") for item in call.get("response", {}).get("output", [])
if item.get("type") == "message" for part in item.get("content", [])
if part.get("type") == "output_text")
if extracted != call.get("text"):
errors.append("response_body_text_mismatch")
return call, attempts, errors
def _menu_errors(menu):
if not isinstance(menu, dict):
return ["missing_menu"]
errors = []
items = menu.get("items", [])
if not isinstance(items, list) or not 1 <= len(items) <= 5:
return ["invalid_item_count"]
if any(not isinstance(item, dict) for item in items):
return ["invalid_item_type"]
ids = [item.get("id") for item in items]
if any(not isinstance(value, str) or not value for value in ids) or len(set(ids)) != len(ids):
errors.append("invalid_item_ids")
masses = [item.get("probability") for item in items]
if any(type(p) not in (int, float) or not math.isfinite(p) or p < 0 for p in masses):
errors.append("invalid_probabilities")
elif not math.isclose(sum(masses), 1, abs_tol=0.02):
errors.append("probabilities_do_not_sum_to_one")
if menu.get("status") == "already_answerable":
if not (menu.get("gap") == "" and menu.get("constraints") == []
and len(items) == 1 and ids == ["unchanged"] and masses == [1]):
errors.append("already_answerable_contract")
elif menu.get("status") != "underspecified" or "unchanged" in ids:
errors.append("underspecified_contract")
return errors
def _audit_map(audit, expected):
fields = {"sample_index": int, "answerable": bool, "answer": str, "answer_cluster": str,
"contradiction": bool, "contradiction_evidence": str, "unrelated_addition": bool,
"selected_state_compliant": bool, "evidence": str}
items = audit.get("assessments", []) if isinstance(audit, dict) else []
valid = (isinstance(items, list) and len(items) == expected and all(
isinstance(item, dict) and set(item) == set(fields)
and all(type(item[key]) is kind for key, kind in fields.items()) for item in items))
if not valid or sorted(item["sample_index"] for item in items) != list(range(expected)):
return {}, False
return {item["sample_index"]: item for item in items}, True
def export_run(run_dir: Path, metadata: dict, subset: dict, config: dict) -> dict:
"""Include every planned example/draw and every saved network attempt."""
run_dir = Path(run_dir)
examples = subset["examples"]
conditions = config.get("conditions", ["original", "modified"])
expected = config.get("samples_per_example", 5)
jobs = {}
for condition in conditions:
for example in examples:
name = hashlib.sha256(example["id"].encode()).hexdigest()[:24] + ".json"
path = run_dir / "examples" / condition / name
jobs[condition, example["id"]] = json.loads(path.read_text()) if path.exists() else {}
calls = read_calls(run_dir / "api.sqlite") if (run_dir / "api.sqlite").exists() else []
by_id = defaultdict(list)
for call in calls:
by_id[call["id"]].append(call)
temporary = run_dir / "requests.jsonl.tmp"
with temporary.open("w") as handle:
for call in calls:
handle.write(json.dumps(call, ensure_ascii=False, allow_nan=False) + "\n")
temporary.replace(run_dir / "requests.jsonl")
source_path = Path(__file__).resolve().parent / config["source_path"]
source = {row["id"]: row for row in json.loads(source_path.read_text())["data"]}
summary = {"metadata": metadata, "exported_utc": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(),
"configuration": config, "conditions": {}, "cost": read_cost_summary(run_dir / "api.sqlite")
if calls else {}, "judgment_source": "Raw Luna audits; no human or Codex review",
"limitations": ["Mechanical ablation does not guarantee unanswerability.",
"Repeated question turns from one story are statistically dependent.",
"Answer clusters, coherence, and state compliance are model judgments.",
"Diversity is conditional on audited valid samples and may reflect judge error."]}
for condition in conditions:
exported, counts, question_metrics, all_errors = {}, Counter(), [], []
counts.update({key: 0 for key in (
"samples_recorded", "samples_completed_calls", "samples_valid_format_and_provenance",
"samples_exactly_unchanged", "samples_raw_empty_addition", "samples_expected_noop_contract",
"samples_business_contract_errors", "samples_provenance_errors", "samples_audited",
"raw_audit_complete_and_coherent", "raw_audit_contradictions", "raw_audit_state_compliant",
"raw_audit_complete_and_state_compliant", "audit_answerable_evidence_not_exact_substring")})
distinct, disagreement = [], []
for example in examples:
eid, question = example["id"], example["question"]
story = example[condition + "_story"]
job = jobs[condition, eid]
prefix = f"{metadata['experiment_fingerprint'][:12]}/{condition}/{eid}"
provenance = []
raw = source.get(example["story_id"], {})
raw_question = next((q for q in raw.get("questions", [])
if q["turn_id"] == example["turn_id"]), {})
if raw.get("story") != example["original_story"] or question not in raw_question.get("paraphrase", []):
provenance.append("source_story_or_question_mismatch")
if job and (job.get("id") != eid or job.get("input_story") != story
or job.get("question") != question or job.get("condition") != condition):
provenance.append("job_input_mismatch")
if job and job.get("metadata", {}).get("experiment_fingerprint") != metadata["experiment_fingerprint"]:
provenance.append("job_experiment_mismatch")
menu = job.get("menu")
menu_call, menu_attempts, menu_check = _call(job.get("menu_call_id", prefix + "/menu"), by_id, story, question, "menu")
menu_errors = _menu_errors(menu)
if menu_call and menu_call.get("parsed") != menu:
menu_check.append("menu_response_mismatch")
counts["jobs_recorded"] += bool(job)
counts["jobs_marked_complete"] += bool(job.get("complete"))
counts["menus_completed"] += bool(menu_call)
counts["menu_business_contract_valid"] += bool(menu_call and not menu_errors)
counts["menus_already_answerable"] += bool(isinstance(menu, dict) and menu.get("status") == "already_answerable")
counts["menus_already_answerable_contract_valid"] += bool(
isinstance(menu, dict) and menu.get("status") == "already_answerable" and not menu_errors)
audit_call, audit_attempts, audit_check = _call(job.get("audit_call_id", prefix + "/audit"), by_id, story, question, "audit")
audit = job.get("audit")
assessments, audit_valid = _audit_map(audit, expected)
if audit_call and audit_call.get("parsed") != audit:
audit_check.append("audit_response_mismatch")
audit_valid = bool(audit_valid and audit_call and not audit_check)
counts["audit_groups_valid_schema"] += audit_valid
actual = {sample["sample_index"]: sample for sample in job.get("samples", [])}
if len(actual) != len(job.get("samples", [])) or any(i not in range(expected) for i in actual):
provenance.append("duplicate_or_invalid_sample_indices")
clarifications, clusters, compliant_clusters, unchanged = [], [], [], 0
for index in range(expected):
sample = actual.get(index, {"sample_index": index, "missing": True})
call, attempts, checks = _call(sample.get("api_call_id", prefix + f"/sample/{index}"), by_id, story, question,
"render", menu, sample.get("selected_id"))
raw_value = call.get("parsed") if call else None
value = raw_value if isinstance(raw_value, dict) else {}
addition = value.get("addition")
business = []
if call and (value.get("status") == "already_answerable" and addition != ""
or value.get("status") == "completed" and not str(addition or "").strip()):
business.append("render_status_addition_contract")
if call and (not isinstance(menu, dict) or sample.get("selected_id") not in
[item.get("id") for item in menu.get("items", [])]):
checks.append("selected_item_missing")
mismatch = (sample["raw_parsed"] != raw_value if "raw_parsed" in sample else
sample.get("addition") != addition or sample.get("status") != value.get("status"))
if call and not sample.get("missing") and mismatch:
checks.append("sample_parsed_response_mismatch")
shape = (set(value) == {"status", "addition", "justification"}
and value.get("status") in ("completed", "already_answerable")
and isinstance(addition, str) and isinstance(value.get("justification"), str))
if shape and not sample.get("missing"):
reconstructed = story + ("\n\n" + addition.strip() if addition.strip() else "")
if sample.get("clarified_story") != reconstructed:
checks.append("clarified_story_reconstruction_mismatch")
valid = bool(call and shape and sample.get("valid_format") and not checks and not provenance and not menu_check)
exact = bool(valid and sample.get("clarified_story") == story)
unchanged += exact
counts["samples_recorded"] += not sample.get("missing", False)
counts["samples_completed_calls"] += bool(call)
counts["samples_valid_format_and_provenance"] += valid
counts["samples_exactly_unchanged"] += exact
counts["samples_raw_empty_addition"] += bool(call and addition == "")
counts["samples_expected_noop_contract"] += bool(valid and exact and addition == ""
and value.get("status") == "already_answerable")
counts["samples_business_contract_errors"] += bool(business)
counts["samples_provenance_errors"] += bool(checks or provenance)
assessment = assessments.get(index) if audit_valid else None
evidence_match = None
if assessment:
counts["samples_audited"] += 1
complete = valid and assessment["answerable"] and not assessment["contradiction"]
counts["raw_audit_complete_and_coherent"] += complete
counts["raw_audit_contradictions"] += assessment["contradiction"]
counts["raw_audit_state_compliant"] += assessment["selected_state_compliant"]
counts["raw_audit_complete_and_state_compliant"] += complete and assessment["selected_state_compliant"]
evidence_match = bool(assessment["evidence"] and assessment["evidence"] in sample.get("clarified_story", ""))
counts["audit_answerable_evidence_not_exact_substring"] += assessment["answerable"] and not evidence_match
if complete:
clusters.append(assessment["answer_cluster"])
if assessment["selected_state_compliant"]:
compliant_clusters.append(assessment["answer_cluster"])
clarifications.append({**sample, "generation_call": call, "generation_attempts": attempts,
"provenance_errors": checks, "business_contract_errors": business,
"audit_assessment": assessment, "audit_evidence_is_exact_substring": evidence_match})
counts["questions_all_outputs_exactly_unchanged"] += unchanged == expected
hist = Counter(clusters)
distinct.append(len(hist))
n = len(clusters)
pair = 1 - sum(c * (c - 1) for c in hist.values()) / (n * (n - 1)) if n >= 2 else None
if pair is not None:
disagreement.append(pair)
question_metrics.append({"id": eid, "raw_complete_answers": n, "answer_clusters": dict(hist),
"pairwise_disagreement": pair, "complete_state_compliant": len(compliant_clusters)})
errors = [*job.get("errors", []), *provenance, *menu_check, *audit_check]
counts["groups_provenance_errors"] += bool(provenance or menu_check or audit_check)
all_errors.extend({"id": eid, "error": error} for error in errors)
exported[eid] = {"original_story": example["original_story"], "modified_story": example["modified_story"],
"input_story": story, "question": question, "removed_sentences": example["removed_sentences"],
"applied_removed_sentences": example["removed_sentences"] if condition == "modified" else [],
"flags": example["flags"], "missing": not bool(job),
"interpretation_stage": {"menu": menu, "call": menu_call, "attempts": menu_attempts,
"business_contract_errors": menu_errors},
"clarifications": clarifications, "audit": audit, "audit_call": audit_call,
"audit_attempts": audit_attempts, "errors": errors}
planned = len(examples) * expected
audit_planned = condition == "modified" and config.get("audit_damaged_outputs", True)
summary["conditions"][condition] = {"expected_examples": len(examples), "expected_samples": planned,
"counts": dict(counts), "missing_samples": planned - counts["samples_recorded"],
"unaudited_samples": planned - counts["samples_audited"],
"audit_planned": audit_planned,
"raw_complete_fraction_of_planned": counts["raw_audit_complete_and_coherent"] / planned if audit_planned else None,
"mean_distinct_raw_complete_answers": statistics.mean(distinct) if audit_planned else None,
"mean_pairwise_disagreement": statistics.mean(disagreement) if disagreement else None,
"questions_with_two_raw_complete_answers": len(disagreement), "per_question": question_metrics,
"errors": all_errors}
_save(run_dir / f"{condition}_validation.json", {"metadata": metadata, "condition": condition,
"samples": exported, "errors": all_errors})
_save(run_dir / "summary.json", summary)
lines = ["# CoQAR dev: paired two-step v2 run", "", "All planned examples and draws are retained, including missing or failed outputs.", "",
"Judgments below are raw Luna audits, without human or Codex corrections. Exact unchanged counts are mechanical checks.", "",
"| Condition | Planned draws | Recorded | Valid format + provenance | Exactly unchanged | Audited | Raw complete + coherent |", "|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|"]
for condition, metrics in summary["conditions"].items():
c = metrics["counts"]
complete = c.get("raw_audit_complete_and_coherent", 0) if metrics["audit_planned"] else "not audited"
lines.append(f"| {condition} | {metrics['expected_samples']} | {c.get('samples_recorded', 0)} | {c.get('samples_valid_format_and_provenance', 0)} | {c.get('samples_exactly_unchanged', 0)} | {c.get('samples_audited', 0)} | {complete} |")
cost = summary["cost"]
lines += ["", f"Known token cost: ${cost.get('known_cost_usd', 0):.6f}. Conservative accounted amount: ${cost.get('accounted_usd', 0):.6f}, including input premium and unresolved reservations.", "",
"Input sentence deletion does not guarantee missing evidence. Completion and diversity judgments are exploratory model measurements. Unaudited samples contribute no successes to the planned-draw fraction; their outcomes remain unknown.", "",
"[Original validation](original_validation.json) · [Damaged validation](modified_validation.json) · [Full metrics](summary.json) · [Every request attempt](requests.jsonl)"]
path = run_dir / "report.md"
path.write_text("\n".join(lines) + "\n")
return summary