File size: 8,270 Bytes
b96b491 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 | # Data dictionary: `data/main_study/`
Anonymized data from the main paired-preference study: 94 analyzed
participants (48 text, 46 audio) rating 100 PRISM prompt pairs, 20 per
participant. ParticipantIDs are remapped from Firebase anonymous UIDs to
`P001..P094`. No Prolific IDs, timestamps, or session metadata that could
re-identify a participant are included, and every justification was
manually reviewed before release.
## Human ratings
### `participant_table_clean.csv`
One row per analyzed participant (n = 94).
| column | type | description |
|---|---|---|
| ParticipantID | str | `P001`..`P094` |
| Modality | str | `text` or `audio` |
| SurveyCompleted | bool | reached the post-survey form |
| assignedTrialIDs | str | comma-separated PromptIDs assigned (20 per participant) |
| postSurveyDifficulty | int | self-reported difficulty, 1–5 |
| Age | int | years |
| Gender, Race, Ethnicity | str | self-reported |
| EnglishProficiency | str | Native speaker / Fluent / Conversational |
| Country | str | always `United States` in this sample |
| Education | str | self-reported, six levels |
| TotalSessionDuration | float | total session, ms |
| PassedAttention | bool | always True (failed participants are excluded) |
| AvgTrialDuration | float | mean trial duration, ms |
### `recruitment_summary.csv`
Counts per condition before exclusions: `Recruited`, `Completed`, and
`PassedAttention` (text 53/49/48, audio 53/51/46). Used for Table 5.
### `long_audio_table_normalized.csv` / `long_text_table_normalized.csv`
One row per (participant × rated response). The main analysis inputs.
| column | type | description |
|---|---|---|
| PromptID | str | `<conv_id>_<turn_no>`, matches `prompt_stim_table` |
| ParticipantID | str | `P001`..`P094` |
| AudioClip | str | filename of the rated response (`.mp3`; also the response key in the text table) |
| TrialNumber | int | 0 = attention check, 1–20 = real trials |
| IsAttentionCheck | bool | |
| PresentedFirst | bool | this response was shown first on the trial |
| Rating | int | 1–100 response-quality rating |
| qualityRating | int | audio only: 1–100 audio-quality rating |
| overallPreference | str | the participant's A / Tie / B choice for the pair |
| revisedAfterBothRated | bool | a rating was edited after both were set |
| L | float | shrunk logit of Rating, `log(p / (1 − p))` with `p = (Rating + 0.5) / 101` |
| L_adjusted | float | L with the condition's mean position bias (second-shown minus first-shown) removed from second-shown responses |
| user_mean, user_sd | float | participant's mean and SD of L_adjusted |
| L_centered | float | L_adjusted − user_mean |
| z | float | L_centered / user_sd |
| Pref_Num | float | 1 = this response preferred, 0.5 = tie, 0 = the other response |
| Pref_Nom | int | the pair's choice: 1 = A, 2 = Tie, 3 = B |
| z_binned | int | decile of z, used in descriptive plots |
### `long_audio_table_clean.csv` / `long_text_table_clean.csv`
The same rows without the participant-normalization columns.
### `audio_data_table_clean.csv` / `text_data_table_clean.csv`
One row per (participant × trial), with responses A and B side by side:
both ratings and quality ratings, preference, justification, task
duration, relisten counts (audio), and rating-change counts.
### `justifications_by_prompt_participant.csv`
Free-text justifications with `prompt`, `participantID`, `modality`.
### `justifications_by_prompt_respondent.csv`
The same justifications without participant or prompt keys
(`PreferenceJustificationText`, `Modality`), as used by the TF-IDF
analysis.
## Stimulus tables
### `prompt_stim_table.csv`
One row per prompt pair: the user query, prior conversation history, and
the two audio clip names.
### `survey_long_format.csv`
One row per (PromptID × response): `AudioClip`, `AudioLength`,
`TextResponse`, `TextLength`, and `PrismRating`, the original PRISM
respondent's own rating. PrismRating is a human baseline, not an AI
rating.
### `stimulus_topic_codes.csv`, `stimulus_topic_codes_raw.csv`, `stimulus_topics.json`
Inductive topic coding of the 100 prompts (Table 19).
- `stimulus_topics.json` is the induced topic list (11 topics), with the
generation counts and merges that produced it.
- `stimulus_topic_codes_raw.csv` has one row per (prompt × coder), with
the supporting quote and a `context_dependent` flag.
- `stimulus_topic_codes.csv` is the adjudicated code per prompt, joined
with that prompt's cross-modal gap, winner flip, and modality-slope
BLUP.
The coders are two LLMs (Gemini 3.6 Flash and GPT-4o), so every field
is model-generated.
## Synthetic (AI) ratings
### `synth_long_audio_table.csv` / `synth_long_text_table.csv`
GPT-4o ratings of the same stimuli, in the same long schema as the human
tables. Text: `gpt-4o-2024-11-20`; audio: `gpt-4o-audio-preview-2024-12-17`.
These are the ratings used in the paper's Tables 3–4.
`synth_long_*_table_gpt4o.csv` holds the same rows under the per-model
name, plus a `model` column.
### `synth_long_{audio,text}_table_<model>.csv`
The same procedure with two more rater families (Tables 6–8):
| suffix | text model | audio model (audio-native) |
|---|---|---|
| `_gemini_36_flash` | `gemini-3.6-flash` | `gemini-3.6-flash` |
| `_qwen35_omni_flash` | `qwen3.5-flash` | `qwen3.5-omni-flash` |
Each adds a `model` column. Every rater makes 10 independent
generations per pair (`synthNo` 1–10), with presentation order
counterbalanced 5/5. `PresentedFirst` records the order actually shown,
and `Rating` is mapped back to the original A/B assignment. Audio models
take the waveform directly, with no speech-to-text step.
`qualityRating` in the audio tables is exploratory. Raters agree poorly
on it (panel ICC(2,k) = 0.32, against 0.83 for the response rating), and
each rater's quality score tracks its own content rating more than
objective DistillMOS.
### `synthetic_ratings_10x.csv` / `synthetic_ratings_10x_<model>.csv`
The raw wide model output behind the `synth_long_*` tables (converted by
`analysis/01_data_prep/03_synth_to_long_csv_multi.py`). One row per
prompt with:
- the PRISM conversation fields (`user_id`, `conv_id`, `turn_no`,
`query`, both responses and lengths, audio filenames and durations);
- ten rating blocks per modality: `text_rating_{a,b}_<i>`,
`text_justification_<i>`, `text_order_a_first_<i>`, and the audio
equivalents, including `audio_quality_rating_{a,b}_<i>`;
- `mos_rating_{a,b}` from DistillMOS.
`user_id` and `conv_id` are PRISM's own published identifiers, not
study participants. The `*_justification_*` columns are model-generated
text.
### `synthetic_ratings_fullcorpus_gemini_36_flash.csv`
Gemini 3.6 Flash ratings of the **full** unguided PRISM corpus (10,800
prompt pairs), not just the 100 study pairs, in both modalities. It uses
the same model, prompts, settings, and output schema as the study's
Gemini ratings, but makes **one** generation per pair instead of ten, and
it has no DistillMOS columns. Audio is the full-corpus Kokoro TTS
(`stimuli/main_study/audio_full_zips/`); `audio_file_{1,2}` join to
`full_audio_index.csv` on `audio_file`.
One row per pair with:
- the PRISM conversation fields as above, plus `unsum_hist` / `sum_hist`
(unsummarized and summarized conversation history) and `prev_hist`
(the history given to the model; empty for first turns);
- one rating block per modality, in the same layout as the 10x files
with `<i>` = 1: `text_rating_{a,b}_1`, `text_justification_1`,
`text_order_a_first_1`, `response_rating_{a,b}_1`,
`audio_quality_rating_{a,b}_1`, `justification_1`,
`audio_order_a_first_1`. Ratings are 1–100 and mapped back to the
original A/B assignment;
- `rater_model` (`gemini_36_flash`) and `row_id` (0–10,799, the pair's
position in the corpus).
Presentation order was drawn per pair and modality (seed 0) and is
balanced (A first in 49.7% of text and 50.0% of audio pairs). These
ratings are not used in the paper's analyses.
## Provenance
The human tables were generated by
`analysis/01_data_prep/02_convert_main_json_to_csv.py` from a Firestore
export of the live study, then anonymized. The stimulus tables come from
`analysis/01_data_prep/01_build_stim_tables.py`. Analysis outputs are in
`results/`, not here.
|