| PromptID,ParticipantID,Arm,TrialNumber,overallPreference,Justification |
| 107_3,AC2-018,audio_context,13,A,Audio A is slightly better as it focuses more on the positives that AI can contribute to climate change whereas Audio B then reminds the user that AI is only part of the solution. |
| 107_3,AC2-019,audio_context,11,A,"Judging on both qualities I would lean slightly towards A. I think B was a little more thorough in answering the question, but the vocal qualities of A was much better. Weighing both together, I would prefer A as my model." |
| 1233_2,AC2-001,audio_context,5,B,"Concise, to the point." |
| 1233_2,AC2-010,audio_context,15,B,short answer |
| 1233_2,AC2-018,audio_context,2,B,Audio B is much more concise and the audio quality is much better than Audio A. |
| 1233_2,AC2-019,audio_context,7,A,B had some unusually long pauses between words. |
| 1294_1,AC2-001,audio_context,15,B,Gave additional help at the end with where to find resources |
| 1294_1,AC2-013,audio_context,13,A,Response A better answered the users question by providing more wide ranging examples. |
| 1294_1,AC2-019,audio_context,3,B,"The both answer the question adequately, but B sounds more human. It is better paced and less mispronunciations." |
| 1347_1,AC2-001,audio_context,3,B,Stresses the importance of consulting a professional. |
| 1347_1,AC2-010,audio_context,2,B,gave the best advice to the user |
| 1347_1,AC2-013,audio_context,9,B,Response B did answer the users question and it was a thoughtful response but both responses cold have used a little more detail. |
| 1347_1,AC2-024,audio_context,6,A,"The beginning tonality and speed for Audio A was largely consistent, to which the delivery for app names were quicker than Audio B, and the main emphasis of calorie deficit for apps, to which talk to a professional is more cleanly stated than Audio B." |
| 1519_1,AC2-013,audio_context,14,A,Response A answered the users question correctly. |
| 1519_1,AC2-025,audio_context,4,B,"They were both quality responses, but Audio B was a little bit better because she asked if he wanted more information at the the end of it." |
| 1604_1,AC2-013,audio_context,3,B,Response B was better organized and more conversational. Great details and content. |
| 1604_1,AC2-025,audio_context,14,Tie,They were both pretty good answers and the audio quality was the same on both. |
| 1604_1,AC2-026,audio_context,2,B,"I prefer option B much more because the response goes step by step by tell you about one way you can earn on tiktok, and then explain more in depth afterwards. I also like that the AI also has a good disclaimer that TikTok payouts really depend on following, etc." |
| 1623_1,AC2-013,audio_context,2,A,The response for A was much more thoughtful for the users interests and the question was answered adequately. |
| 1623_1,AC2-025,audio_context,12,A,Audio A the response was more to the point and succinct and nice and tight. Audio B was a little bit weird cause she thanked the user and called him Falcon and stuff. |
| 1623_1,AC2-026,audio_context,8,A,"Response B was all over the place and going off topic, Response A is direct and sounds more humanlike." |
| 1669_2,AC2-005,audio_context,2,Tie,N/A |
| 1669_2,AC2-018,audio_context,9,A,Audio B's response repeats itself and is not needed whereas Audio A's response is more direct and to the point. |
| 1669_2,AC2-025,audio_context,2,B,Audio B was too long winded. Audio A with nice and succinct and to the point. |
| 1669_2,AC2-026,audio_context,12,B,I like how response B handles this type of situation and reiterates the fact that they'll be shutting down this sort of unsafe conversation but they can continue to assist if there's anything else. I also like that B encourages them to talk to someone if they don't feel well. |
| 1788_2,AC2-018,audio_context,3,B,Audio B comes across as more direct whereas Audio A comes across as more pandering. |
| 1788_2,AC2-019,audio_context,4,Tie,"They both has short, accurate replies and responded clearly." |
| 1788_2,AC2-025,audio_context,6,A,Audio A just seemed more polished and professional. |
| 1788_2,AC2-026,audio_context,11,B,Both responses were perfect at addressing this type of situation but I like B more just because they get more direct to the point faster and let the user know that whenever they need theyll be there to assist them whenever. |
| 1877_1,AC2-018,audio_context,6,A,Audio A comes across with better audio quality while Audio B has some unnatural pacing. |
| 1877_1,AC2-019,audio_context,5,B,"They were both ok, A said 15 30 minutes instead of 15 to 30 minutes." |
| 1877_1,AC2-026,audio_context,7,A,"Both responses were very good, but I liked A's better because of the support and encouragement at the end of the response." |
| 2209_1,AC2-018,audio_context,11,A,The response for Audio A is more on on-point and aligns better with the user's query than Audio B does. |
| 2209_1,AC2-019,audio_context,12,Tie,"Both of these audio sound relatively human. They still both have tells, but neither are as large as previous. Their answers as sound and they expand on the idea to give more details." |
| 2230_1,AC2-001,audio_context,11,B,Responses felt more neatly laid out. |
| 2230_1,AC2-018,audio_context,5,Tie,Both Audio A and Audio B are very similar with some similar issues with the pacing and flow of the audio quality. |
| 2230_1,AC2-019,audio_context,2,B,The pacing on A was very fast and not human paced. It had many mispronunciations. |
| 2341_1,AC2-001,audio_context,7,Tie,Neither gives a single answer right away. |
| 2341_1,AC2-010,audio_context,3,Tie,both gave great answers |
| 2341_1,AC2-013,audio_context,15,B,Response B more fully answered the users question but it was a vague request from the user to begin with. |
| 2341_1,AC2-019,audio_context,6,A,Both gave a good answer. B has a bit slower and robotic sounding voice |
| 2349_2,AC2-002,audio_context,1,B,"This one adjusted the price question first, and for the majority of the response, unlike Audio A." |
| 2349_2,AC2-010,audio_context,5,A,to the point |
| 2349_2,AC2-013,audio_context,8,A,The users question was not extremely clear. Response A attempted to answer the question to the best of it's ability with some success. |
| 2349_2,AC2-014,audio_context,3,A,Short and straight to the point. |
| 2500_1,AC2-003,audio_context,2,B,The response better answers the users question |
| 2500_1,AC2-013,audio_context,4,B,Response B provided added benefits and discussed a though evaluation of the users query. |
| 2500_1,AC2-025,audio_context,5,B,"I like how she included ""thoughtful planning and policy"" in Audio B. Both of the audio quality seemed to go to me." |
| 268_1,AC2-013,audio_context,12,Tie,"Both responses give a valid answer to the users question which was an unknown answer but, the response was accurate." |
| 268_1,AC2-024,audio_context,1,B,"Audio B cuts off the fluff, removes words such as ""so"", and delivers a more crisp tonality, with more mature sentence structures, such as using the word ""stated.""" |
| 268_1,AC2-025,audio_context,9,A,I like how she included that one would have to ask Donald Trump directly about his opinion on cats. So I chose audio A |
| 268_1,AC2-026,audio_context,6,B,"Both responses are good, but I like audio B's direct approach saying that Donald Trump has never mentioned cats before A's did." |
| 2817_1,AC2-003,audio_context,9,Tie,both answers are incorrect |
| 2817_1,AC2-013,audio_context,11,A,The response B answered the users question and was more accurate. |
| 2817_1,AC2-025,audio_context,11,Tie,They were both wrong because Red Byron won the championship in 1949. |
| 2817_1,AC2-026,audio_context,3,Tie,"I was a bit confused with this trial hearing that the answers to the user's question about who won the first Nascar Championship. Both answers had the same persons name but not the year, hence being a little confusing knowing one of the responses are in the wrong, as they both describe 2 completely different years." |
| 2826_2,AC2-018,audio_context,15,B,The response of Audio A is poor as there is no homeowner insurance that would pay for solar panel installation - so this makes Audio B the much better response. |
| 2826_2,AC2-024,audio_context,2,A,"Audio A has less spaces in between words with less vague references to home ownership insurance usage, such as stating ""typically"" rather than ""may or may not"", as referenced by Audio B." |
| 2826_2,AC2-025,audio_context,1,B,Audio B sounded more accurate as to what insurance companies typically cover. |
| 2826_2,AC2-026,audio_context,10,B,I like option B a little bit more just because I think they get to the point a little bit faster and lets the user know to check with their insurance to see everything that is covered for solar panels. |
| 2865_2,AC2-018,audio_context,7,Tie,Both Audio A and Audio B are very well presented and both have excellent audio quality so it is a tie between the two. |
| 2865_2,AC2-019,audio_context,8,A,"The tone and pacing of A is much better. B has uneven speed (slow and fast), and has a robotic echo." |
| 2865_2,AC2-025,audio_context,8,B,I prefer to audio B because she included how they're endangered due to habitat loss. |
| 2865_2,AC2-026,audio_context,9,Tie,"Both responses were pretty much the same, but I do appreciate option B for going over the endangerment of the smallest monkey species." |
| 2879_1,AC2-018,audio_context,8,B,"Audio B is slightly better as it is more direct whereas Audio A starts with the phrase ""sorry for the inconvenience"" which is unnecessary and not needed." |
| 2879_1,AC2-019,audio_context,13,Tie,Neither of them answered the question. Chat bots are able to tell the current time. |
| 2879_1,AC2-026,audio_context,4,Tie,"I think both responses are fine as they both acknowledge that they don't have the time, but give the user a solution to help them anyways." |
| 3045_2,AC2-011,audio_context,1,A,Audio A sounded more natural and reasonable based on the conversation histoy. |
| 3045_2,AC2-018,audio_context,10,Tie,Both Audio A and Audio B are very thorough and clear in both the response and the audio quality - so I am satisfied with both responses. |
| 3045_2,AC2-019,audio_context,10,Tie,The both provided accurate information and responded well. The vocals are both about the same in quality. |
| 3049_3,AC2-010,audio_context,1,A,the audio made more sense when the ai spoke |
| 3049_3,AC2-018,audio_context,14,A,The audio quality of Audio B is unnatural and doesn't have great flow which makes Audio A the much better choice. |
| 3049_3,AC2-019,audio_context,9,Tie,"Both have a very bad pacing, and feel like early stage TTS systems." |
| 446_1,AC2-001,audio_context,6,A,Gave a straight up answer. |
| 446_1,AC2-013,audio_context,10,B,Response B was a bit more comprehensive in its answer and more directed at the user's request. |
| 446_1,AC2-019,audio_context,15,B,"B was a little more clear, it gave alternatives to the question and was a little more in depth." |
| 462_1,AC2-001,audio_context,10,Tie,Both gave wrong information/names. |
| 462_1,AC2-013,audio_context,1,Tie,Both responses give clear feedback to the users request in detail without extra unnecessary information. |
| 462_1,AC2-024,audio_context,3,A,"Audio A not only makes effort to consolidate the initial statement of pixel art being participating through broad form of expression through mediums, not only through imagery tactics, as strictly stated by Option B, but also through storytelling and delivery. Additionally, Option A stated the source and location of the pixel artist. Option A sounded like a personal extension, as if it's choices were theirs." |
| 471_3,AC2-013,audio_context,5,B,"Response B did answer the users question to a degree but, overall it could have had better details and context." |
| 471_3,AC2-025,audio_context,15,Tie,They were both okay responses about racism. Her answers seemed true to me. Also the audio quality was the same on both. |
| 623_2,AC2-013,audio_context,6,B,Response B was a bit more comprehensive in the answering the users question. |
| 623_2,AC2-024,audio_context,5,A,"Audio A made sure to start the sentence with eligible activities for everyone, which smoothens the sentences later on, while maintaining proper sentence speed before every bullet point number. Additionally, it made sure to separate event details from consent choices offered for each event. Audio B separated family members for event with inconsistency, to which can offer confusion, and a slowness." |
| 623_2,AC2-025,audio_context,7,Tie,It's a tie. I thought the escape room edition was kinda cool though. |
| 623_2,AC2-026,audio_context,5,Tie,"I think both responses are generally the same listing options to do for this person's birthday outing, if i had to choose I think it would be B based on the fact I believe it listed a few more options than A." |
| 633_1,AC2-013,audio_context,7,B,Response B was very detailed and defined in the answer. Good job. |
| 633_1,AC2-024,audio_context,4,A,"Audio A made a more in depth approach to industry broad reports to the multi-faceted skills of the artist, beyond contribution, such as a skill analysis of the artist. Option B made heavy emphasis on the artist's broad impact to consolidate the artists title as one of the greatest, which can sound vague. Speed is slower for Option B than A." |
| 633_1,AC2-025,audio_context,13,Tie,"They were both pretty good responses, so I gave them a tie. Maybe response B a little bit more because it included his top hat." |
| 633_1,AC2-026,audio_context,13,A,I like both options because they both state they cant form opinions but I like A's a smidge more just because they give off some more history about the band member. |
| 725_6,AC2-018,audio_context,1,A,I like Audio A by just a small margin as the audio quality sounds more natural whereas the audio quality of Audio B sounds slightly disjointed and robotic at a couple points. |
| 725_6,AC2-024,audio_context,7,B,"Audio B mentioned a much broader spectrum of colors, and went further on camouflage behaviors such as stripes and spots." |
| 725_6,AC2-025,audio_context,3,Tie,They both were quality response and they both had good audio quality so it's a tie. |
| 725_6,AC2-026,audio_context,14,A,I prefer the tone of A more but both responses were pretty much that same and descriptive. |
| 858_1,AC2-018,audio_context,4,B,Audio A is very repetitive from the original response while Audio B is more original and adds extra insight (although with some repetition still) |
| 858_1,AC2-019,audio_context,14,A,Both do a very good job of detailing what you can do in the game but A goes in deeper depth and shows a better understanding of the game. |
| 858_1,AC2-025,audio_context,10,B,"They were both pretty good responses, but I think response B audio B was a little bit better, more detailed." |
| 858_1,AC2-026,audio_context,1,Tie,"I think both options are very good, both using follow ups with the users original question, and laying out everything there is to do in red dead. I think I prefer B a little bit over A just because that response felt like it kept giving many more reasons to want to want and then ask afterwards if there was anything else they'd like to know." |
| 987_5,AC2-018,audio_context,12,B,Both the quality of the response (including use of examples) of Audio B and the audio quality of Audio B is much better as compared to Audio A. |
| 987_5,AC2-019,audio_context,1,A,"Both had pronunciation errors, but B had more. It also seemed more static and robotic" |
| 987_5,AC2-026,audio_context,15,B,I prefer tone B over A and their more casual approach to the conversation of the human species. |
|
|
