conversations
listlengths
3
3
context
stringlengths
18
70.9k
pericope_ref
stringlengths
9
277
source
stringclasses
5 values
source_tier
int64
0
2
variation
stringclasses
5 values
lint_flags
unknown
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
God; If they are not wholly false, they are entitled to reyerence." But when the Reasoning itself rests on the hypothesis (in which way a categorical Conclusion may be drawn £rom a hypothetical Premiss,) this is what is called a hypothetical Syllogism; and rules have been devised for ascertaining the validity of such a...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 107
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop": [ "structure:" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
' "^ Constructive gism : if A is B, C is D ; C is not D, there- gj^^®^"^ fore A is not B. Again, " if the crops are not bad, com must be cheap," for a major; then, "but the crops are not bad, therefore com must be cheap," is Constructive. "Com is not cheap, therefore the crops are bad," is Destructive. " If every incre...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 109
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=20w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
And note, that a Conditional Proposition ^^^^^^^^^1^^^^,^ may (like the categorical A) be converted iyCmditionai* megmium; i e. you may take the contradictory of the no ELEMENTS OF LOGIC. [Book II. conseqrientf as an antecedent, and the contradictory of the antecedent, as a consequent : e. g, " if this man is not sick,...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 110
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
In the Destructive form, whether you have one Ante- cedent with several Consequents, or several Antecedents either with one, or with several Consequents ; in all these cases, if you deny the whole of the Consequent or Con- sequents, you may in the conclusion deny the whole of the Antecedent or Antecedents : e, g. ^ if ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 113
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
3d. That is most properly called a destrue- Dettructiye tiv€ Dilemma^ which has (like the constructive *®"****- ones) a disjunctive minor Premiss; L e. when you have several Antecedents with each a different Consequent; which Consequents (instead of wholly denying them, as in the case lately mentioned) you disjunctivel...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 114
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
.^^chines joined, ^c. he is inconsistent ; he did join, ^c therefore he is inconsistent;" and again, "if -<Eschines did not join, ^c. he is unpatriotic ; he did not, ^c. there^ fore he is unpatriotic." Now an opponent might deny either of the minor Premises in the above Syllogisms, but he could not deny both ; and ther...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 115
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
ordinary practice, as the readiest way of trying their vali- dity, (their own rules being quite sufficient for that pur- pose ;) but only that we should he able, if required, to sub- ject any argument whatever to the test of Aristotle's Dictum, in order to show that all Reasoning turns upon one simple principle. Of Ent...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 119
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=19w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage here" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Chaf. IV. « T] SYNTHETICAL COMPENDIUM. 119 2d. When you have a string of Syllogisms, in the first figure, in which the Conclusion of each is made the Pro- miss of the next, till you arrive at the main or ultimate Con- clusion of all, you may sometimes state these briefly, in a form called Sorites : in which the predica...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 120
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
IdO ELEMENTS OP LOGIC. [Book II. (in the 1st Fig.) incompatible with correctness. (See Chap. iiL ^ 4.) Hypothetical ^ ^^^^^ °^ Conditional Syllogisms may in *'**"'®* like manner be abridged into a Sorites; e, g. if A is B. C is D; if C is D. E is F; if E is F. G is H J but A is B, therefore G is H. " If the Scriptures ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 121
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It is evident that you may, for brevity, substitute for any term an equivalent; as in the last exam- *' ^ Equiyalenta. pie, ** i/," for " Logic ;" " such," for " a use- ful study," 4*^. The doctrine of Conversion, laid down in the Second Chapter, furnishes many equivalent propo- sitions, since each is equivalent to its...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 123
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=23w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Let it be observed then, that a noun expresses ^ejnew we take of an object And its being viewed as am olject, i e. as one, or again as several, depends on our arbitrary choice; e, g, we may consider a troop of cavalry as one object ; or we may make any single horse with its rideri or any separate man or horse, or any l...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 126
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* If this experiment be tried on a Syllogism which has really negative Premises, the only effect will be to change that fault into another : viz. an excess of Terms, or (which is substantially the same) an undistributed middle ; e. g, " an enslaved people is not happy ; the English are not enslaved ; therefore they are...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 124
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
1S8 ELEMENTS OF LOGIC. [BocMt li: Such terms may be said to be in contradictory opposi- tion to each other. "'"**' ***" On the other hand, Contrary terms, i. e. contra those which, coming under some one class, are '^^'"^ the most different of all that belong to that class, as •• wise" and " foolish," both denoting ment...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 130
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Cmjf. V. f 3] SUPPLEMENT TO CHAP. 1. w^ Generalization (as has been remarked) implies abstrac- tion, but it is not the same thing ; for there may be abstrac- tion without generalization : when we are speaking of an Individual, it is usually an abstract notion that we form ; e. g. suppose we are speaking of the present ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 131
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
and when the Grenus is called a whole, and is said to con- tain the Species, this is only a metaphorical expression, signifying that it comprehends the Species, in its own more extensive signification : e. ^. if I predicate of Csesar that he is an animal^ I say the truth indeed, but not the whole truth; for he is not o...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 133
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
♦ " The impression produced on the mind by a Singular Term, may be compared to the distinct view taken in by the eye, of any object (suppose some particular man) near at hand, in a clear light, which enables us to distinguish the features of the individual: in a fainter light, or rather farther off, we merely perceive ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 134
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
in, you must call the differentia; as " rationality^' to " man j" and whatever you consider as rather an iueom- paniment (or result) of that difference, you must call the froperty; as the " use of speech" seems to be a result of rationality.] But very many properties which belong to the whole of a species are not pecul...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 136
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* This seems to me a clearer and more correct description of the two kinds of accident than the one given by Aldrich ; viz, that a Separable Accident may be aduaUy separated, and an Inseparable, only in thought^ " ut Mantuanum esse, a Virgil io." For surely " to be the author of the ^neid" was another In- separable Acc...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 137
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
sessions, under the name of " stock ;" the Naturalist, suitably to his purpose, classes them as " quadru- peds*^ which term would include wolves, deer, ^c.^ which to the former would be a most improper classiiScation : the Ck)mmissary, again, would class them with com, cheese, fish, ^c, as "provision;" that which is mo...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 139
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Purta, or any of them short of aU, most contain less (i e, have a narrower signification) than the thing diyided. 2d All the Parts together most he exactly equal to the thing divided ; (therefore we must he careful to ascertain that the summum genus may he predicated of everf term placed under it, and of nothing elsa) ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 140
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It is plain, then, that it is logically only, i. e. in our mode of speaking, that a Genus is said to contain (or rather comprehend) its Species; while meta/physically, (i. e. in our conceptions,) a Species contains, i, e. implies, its Genus. Care must be taken not to confound a physical Division with a logical; which b...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 142
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Lastly, the Essential Definition is divided into phy sical {i. e. natural) and logical jox metaphysical; the physical Definition lays down the real parts of the essence which are actually separable; the logical, lays down the ideal parts of it, which cannot be separated except in the mind : thus, a plant would be defin...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 143
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop": [ "structure:" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* In Chap, ii, S 3, of Book IV. the doctrine here laid down will be more fully developed. Aldrich, having given us an instance of a Nominal Definition^ the absurd one of " homo, qui ex humo," has led some to con- clude that the Nominal Definition must be founded on the «^ mology ; or at least that such was his meaning....
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 146
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=18w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
♦ This would be inferred according to the principle of " ex- ceptio probat regalom," an exception proves a rule. The force of the maxim is this, (for it is not properly confined to the case where an exception^ strictly so called, is mentioned,) that the mention of any circumstance introduced into the statement of a thi...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 147
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* He is far more confused in his discussion of Fallacies than in any other part of his treatise; of which this one instance may serve: alter having distinguished Fallacies into those in the expression, and those in the matter (" in dictione," and " extra dictionem,") he observes of one or two of these last, that they a...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 151
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
The rules already given enable us to de- MIgtaket as . . to the office velop the principles on which all reasoning is conducted, whatever be the Subject-matter of it, and to ascertain the validity or feUaciousness of any apparent argument, as £ir as the form of expression is con- cerned ; that being alone the proper pr...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 152
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
. I do point out in which Term of an Argument it is to be sought for; directing our attention to the middle Term, as the one on the ambiguity of which a Fallacy is likely to be built It will be useful, however, to class and describe the different kinds of ambiguity which are to be met with; and also the various Avays i...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 154
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=19w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
object, and all kinds of knowledge for its proper subject- matter; with all that train of vague and groundless speculations which have led to such interminable confusion and mistakes, and afforded a pretext for such clamorous censures. It is important, therefore, that rules should be given for a division of Fallacies i...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 155
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
158 ELEMENTS OF LOGIC. [Boo i UL should enable one to know the full and exact meanix*^ of every term in existence? The utmost that can be done is to give some general rules that may assist us in this work ; which is done in the first two chapters of Book II. The very author of the objection says, " This (the comprehens...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 158
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Material Fu- '^^® remaining class {viz. where the Concla- 1^^ sion does follow from the Premises) may be called the Material, or Non-logical Fallacies: of these there are two kinds ; * 1st when the Premises are such as ought not to hare been assumed; 2d. when the Con- clusion is not the one required, but irrelevant; wh...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 159
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
The remaining kind, " petitio principii" (begging the question,) takes place when a Premiss, whether true or fiilse, is either plainly equivalent to the Conclusion, or depends on it for its own reception. It is to be observed, however, that in all correct Reasoning the Premises must, virtually, imply the Conclusion ; s...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 161
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
1st It seems by most persons to be taken for granted that a Fallacy is to be dreaded merely as a Importance . , of detecUng weapon feshioned and wielded by a skilful soph- ist; or, if they allow that a man may with honest intentions slide into one unconsciously, in the heat of argument, still they seem to suppose that ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 162
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
♦ " Men imagine," sajrs Bacon, " that their minds have the command of Language; but it often happens that Language bears rule over their mind." Some of the weak and absurd ar- guments which are often urged against Suicide may be traced to the influence of words on thoughts. When a Christian moralist is called on for a ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 165
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Another instance of the strong influence of. ^ ° Influence of words on our ideas may be adduced from a words on widely different subject: most persons feel a eertain degree of surprise on first hearing of the result of iKmie late experiments of the Agricultural Chemists, by which they have ascertained that universally ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 164
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=18w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It is surely wiser and safer to confine ourselves to such argu- ments as will bear the test of a close examination, than to re- sort to soch as may indeed at the first glance be more specious and appear stronger, but which, when exposed, will too often leave a man a dupe to the fallacies on the opposite side. But it is...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 167
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Thus much, as to the extensive practical influence of Fallacies, and the consequent high importance of detect- ing and exposing them. ^ ^ly- The second remark is, that while sound ^«^^2 reasoning is ever the more readily admitteio, the more clearly it is perceived to be such. Fallacy, on the contrary, being rejected as...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 168
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
I a] OF FALLACIES. m when ]rou single out one step in the course of the reason- ing, and exhibit it as a Syllogism with one Premiss true and the other false, the sophistry is easily perceived. To use another illustration, it is true in a course of argument, as in Mechanics, that " nothing is stronger than its weak- est...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 170
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It should be added that a close observation and Logical analysis of Fallacious arguments, as it tends (according to what has been already said) to form a habit of mind well suited for the practical detection of Fallacies ; so, for that lieve the best-established truths of religion, but are ready to be- lM(lr« any thing...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 171
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
major, and Undistributed middle. Fallacies of this class are very much kept out of sight, being seldom perceived even by those who employ them ; but of their practical importance there can be no doubt, tince it is notorious that a weak argument is always, in practice, detrimenial ; and that there is no absurdity so gro...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 173
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=18w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* For some instances of important ambigoities, see Appendix. to 6x our attention strongly and steadily on the important terms of an argument •** One case, which maybe regarded as coming p^^^^^ under the head of Ambiguous middle, is, what 'w*"** 18 called, *^Fallacia Figura Dictionis!^ the Fallacy built on the grammatic...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 175
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
' trusted :"* here the Sophist proceeds on the hypothesis that he who forms a project must be a projector : where- as the bad sense that commonly attaches to the latter word, is not at all implied in the former. • Adun Smith's Wealth of Nations: Usury. 1^ ELEMENTS OF LOGIC. [Book IB. This Fallacy m^y often be considere...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 176
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
more than in asserting two distinct propositions) distinctly and avowedly. This Fallacy may be referred, as has been said, to the head of Ambiguous middle. In all Reasoning it is very common to state one of the Premises in form of a question, and when that is admitted, or supposed to be admitted, ^then to fiH up the re...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 180
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Ihey are applied. Words which &U under this first bead are what are the most strictly called equivocal. 2dly. There are several terms in the use of •ecoud inteo-which it is necessary to notice the distinction between first and second intentioTL* The ** first-intention" of a Term (according to the usual ac* ceptation of...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 183
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
who are ** chosen," as fit to receive a firhdl reward^ having made a right use of those advantages ; as when our Lord says, •' many are called, but few chosen." • There are various ways in which words come Accidental to have two meanings: 1st. by accident; (i. g. eq«>^o««*oa when there is no perceptible connexion betwe...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 182
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=18w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
3dly. When two or more things are con- ^^^j^,,,^^ nected by resemblaiu:e or analogy, they will •»***n*^*«y* frequently have the same name. Thus a '* blade of grass," and the contrivance in building called a ^ dove- taU^" are so called from their resemblance to the blade\ • In a few instances the Secoi^d-intention, or p...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 185
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
In all these cases (of this 3rd head) one of the mean- ings of the word is called by Logicians proper, i, e. orig- inal or primary; the other improper, secondary, or trans- ferred: thus, sweet is originally and properly applied to tastes; secondarily and improperly (i. e. by analogy) to sounds : thus, also, dove-tail i...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 186
wisdom_logic
2
{ "slop": [ "it sounds like you" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Ambiguities of this kind belong practically to the first head: there being no perceived connexion between the different senses. The remedy for ambiguity is a Definition of the Term which is suspected of being used in two senses; viz. a Nominal, not necessarily a Real Definition: as was re- marked in Book II. Chap. v. B...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 188
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Of those cases where the ambiguity arises from ths coniezt, there are several species; some of which Logi- cians have enumerated, but have neglected to refer them, in the first place, to one common class; {viz, the one un- der which they are here placed ;) and have even arranged some under the head of Fallacies " in di...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 189
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
To this head may be referred the Fallacy by which men have sometimes been led to admit, or pretend to ad- mit, the doctrine of Necessity; e. g. "he who necessa- rily goes or stays {i. e. in reality, ' who necessarily gon, or who necessarily stay^) is not a free agent; 3rou must necessarily go or stay, (i. e. *you must ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 190
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
This is a Fallacy with which men are extremely apt to deceive themselves: for when a multitude of pariiculars are presented to the mind, many are too weak or too in- dolent to take a comprehensive view of them; but con* fine their attention to each single point, by turns; and then decide, infer, and act, accordingly : ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 192
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop": [ "structure:", "1. acknowledge" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
bined; therefore they are qualities unfriendly to each other." The other kind of ambiguity arising from the panaci.^ context, and which is the last case of Am- **®°**'* big^ous middle that I shall notice, is the "fallacia acci' dentist together with its converse, *'fallacia a dido se* eundum quid ad dictum simpliciter ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 193
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Ig4 ELEMENTS OP LOGIC. [Book III sentiments, is a gross Fallacy; and snch a one as per- haps the authors of the ahove would much object to, if it were assumed of them that they were adverse to "the cause of liberty throughout the world," and to "a fidr representation of the people," from their objecting to join ^ with ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 194
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=20w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
this, we must not too hastily pronounce the argument &]- lacious ; for it may be perfectly &ir at the commencement (^anargument to assume a Premiss that is not more evi* dent than the Conclusion, or is even ever so paradoxical, provided you proceed to prove fairly that Premiss: and in like manner it is both usual and &...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 195
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Undue as- '^^^ *^®^ hesidi is, the felsity, or, at least, un- nimption. j^^ assumption, of a Premiss, when it is not equivalent to, or dependent on, the Conclusion; which, as has been before said, seems to correspond nearly with the meaning of Logicians, when they speak of " non causa pro causa" This name indeed would ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 197
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=23w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
• In mauy cases, a Sign (see RkeL Part I.) from which one might fairly infer a certain phenomenon, is mistaken for the Cause of it : as if one should suppose the falling of mercury to be a cause' of rain, of which it certainly is an indication. Whereas the fact will often be the very reverse; e.g, a great deal of money...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 198
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
One of the many contrivances employed foipaiiacyof this purpose, is what may be called the ** Fal- ^^n^** lacy of references ,•" which is particularly common in popular theological works. It is of course a circumstance which adds great weight to any assertion, that it shall seem to be supported by many passages of Scri...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 200
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
This very same Fallacy is often resorted to on the op- posite side: an attempt is made to invalidate some argu* ment firom Example, by pointing out a differerue between the two cases : though they agree in every thing that is essential to the question. It should he added that we may often he ^'^ ctknOaOoaot ceivod, not...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 201
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
guilty of some serious ofience, which he wishes to extenii- ate» though he is unable distinctly to prove that it is not such, yet if he can succeed in making the audience laugh at some casual matter, he has gained practically the same point So also if any one has pointed out the extenuating circumstances in some partic...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 203
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
In all these cases, as has been before observed, if the fidlacy we are now treating of be employed for the ap* parent establishment, not of the ultimate Conclusion, but (as it very commonly happens) of a Premiss^ (t. e. if the Premiss required be assumed on the ground that some proposition resembling it has been proved...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 204
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
rest Along with these is usually enumerated ** o/rgumen^ turn ad ignorantiam" which is here omitted, as being evidently nothing more than the employment of same kind of Fallacy, in the widest sense of that word, towards such as are likely to be deceived by it. It appears then (to speak rather more technically) that in ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 206
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
taon it is often both allowable and necessary to establish, in order to silence those who will not yield to fair general argument; or to convince those whose weakness and prejudices would not allow them to assign to it its due weight : it is thus that our Lord on many occasions silen- ces the cavils of the Jews ; as in...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 207
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=12w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
calls for, or as is likely to excite in those particular readers or hearers, the emotions required, it is a common Rhetorical artifice to turn their attention to some object which will call forth these feelings; and when they are too much excited to be capable of judging calmly, it will not be difficult to turn their P...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 209
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Mathematics in that place, (to which neglect they attiihut* ed the late general decline in those studies,) shifted their ground, and contended that that University was never fiunous for Mathematicians: which not only does not establish, but absolutely overthrows, their own original assertion; for if it never succeeded ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 210
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* This is, as has been said, the principal engine employed by the adversaries of our Faith : they find numerous " objections'* against various parts of Scripture ; to some of which no satisfac- tory answer can be given; and the incautious hearer is apt, while his attention is fixed on these, to forget that there are in...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 212
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
How happy it is for mankind that in the moat momentooM m ELEMENTS OF LOGIC. [Boos IIL FWiacTof Another form of igrioratio eleneki^ which is ptfT^the ^^ rather the more serviceable on the side qaeatioD. ^^ ^^ respondent, is, to prove or disprove sofne part of that which is required, and dwell on that, suppress- ing all ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 214
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Hence the danger of ever advancing more than can be well maintained;* since the refutation of thai will concerns of life their decision is generally formed for them by external circumstances: which thus saves them not only from the perplexity of doubt and the danger of delay, but also from the pain of regret; since we ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 215
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Before we dismiss the subject of Fallacies, it may not be improper to mention the just and ingenious remark, that Jests are Fallacies;* i. e. Falla- cies 80 palpable as not to be likely to deceive any one, but yet bearing just that resemblence of argument which is calculated to amuse by the contrast ; in the same man- ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 217
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
I shall subjoin some general remarks on the legitimate province of Reasoning, and on its connexion with Induc- tive philosophy, and with Rhetoric: on which points much misapprehension has prevailed, tending to throw obscurity over the design and use of the Science under consideration. * See Mm6 exceUent remarks on ** I...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 218
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
908 ON THE PROVINCE OF REASONINa [Booi IV. one of the very first principles it establishes, is, that all Reasoning, on whatever subject, is one and the same pro- cess, which may be clearly exhibited in the form of Syl- ' logisma It is hardly to be supposed, therefore, that this was the deliberate meaning of those write...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 220
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
" Induction is distinct from Syllogism : Induction is a process of Reasoning ;" therefore " There is a process of Reasoning distinct from Sj^Jogism." Here, " Induction," which is the middle Term, is used in diHerent senses in the two Premises. Anaiysiiof ^ ^^^ process of reasoning by which we ^^ deduce, from our observ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 221
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
These errors have been incidentally adverted to in the foregoing part of this work; but it may be desirable, before we dismiss the subject, to offer on these points some further remarks, which could not have been there in- troduced without too great an. interruption to the devel- opment of the system. Little or nothing...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 219
wisdom_logic
2
{ "slop": [ "many theologians" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Whether the Premiss may fiiirly be assumed, of Preinises or not, IS a point which cannot be decided without a competent knowledge of the natur e of the subject; e. g, in Natural Philosophv, in which the circumstanc^tnat in any case afiect the result, are usually far more clearly ascertained, a single instance is often ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 223
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=20w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* I have selected an instance in which Induction is the only groand we have to rest on ; no reason, that I know of, having ever been assigned that could have led us to conjecture this curioas fact a priori. 813 ON THE PROVINCE OP REASONENG. [Book IV. -_ And here it may be remarked, that the or- The more ^ ' ^^^jjjl^'^'...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 224
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
In maintaining the negative side of the above question, three things are to be premised : first, that it is not con- tended that discoveries of any kind of Truth can be made (or at least are usually made) without Reasoning; only, that Reasoning is not the whole of the process, nor the whole of that which is important t...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 226
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It is on this ground, indeed, that the justly-celebrated author of tlie Philosophy of Rhetoric objects to the Syllo- gism altogether, as necessarily involving a petiiio princi- pii; an objection which, of course, he would not have been disposed to bring forward, had he perceived that, whether well or ill-ibunded, it li...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 227
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop": [ "structure:" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
The ten Categoriesf or Predicaments, which Aristotle and other Logical writers have treated ^ * On this point there are some valuable remarks in the Philoso- phy of Rhetoric itself,^ Book IV. Chap. vii. t The Categories ennmerated hf Aristotle, are oi^fo, ir^y, irocoi', ffjptfflrrc, irod, irtfrc, «ci<r0at, Ixcty, vouXw...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 229
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
313 ON THE PROVINCE OF REASONING. [Book IV. ranee of it, and also our consciousness that we possess, in what we already know, the means to ascertain the truth of it ; that we have a right, in short, to bear our testimony to its truth. To all practical purposes, indeed, a Truth of this de- scription may be as completely...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 232
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
With respect to the meaning of the Terms in question, •• Discovery," and " New Truth;" it matters not whether we confine ourselves to the narrowest sense, or admit the widest, provided we do but disiingwish: there certainly Twokindsof ^* ^^ kinds of " New Truth" and of " Die- sense in which they are ever used. First, s...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 230
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
• Hence the futility of the attempt of Clarke, and others, to demonstrate (in the mathematical sense) the existence of a Deity. This can only be done by covertly assuming in the Premises the very point to be proved. No matter of fact can be Inathematieally demonstrated; thongh it may be proved in nich a manner as to le...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 234
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=19w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
But to return : it is of the utmost importance tndiiutruG- to distinguish these two kinds of Discovery of Truth. In relation to the former, as I have said, the "word information!^ is most strictly applied; the communication of the latter is more properly called *^ instruction,*^ I speak of the u^ual practice; for it wo...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 235
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=12w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
ON THE PROVINCE OP REASONINa [Boot IT* phrsicai i>i» ^ ^^® hitherto spok^i of the employment of eovenM. argument in the establishment of those hypo- thetical Truths (as they may be called) which relate only to our own abstract notions; it is not, howerer, meant to be insinuated that there is no room for Reasoning in th...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 237
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage doesn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
*And the doubtfulness is muUipUed^ if both Premises are uncertain. For since it is only on the supposition of both Premises being true, that we can calculate on the truth of the ConclusioD, we must state in numbers the chances against each Premiss being true, and then multiply these together, to judge of the degree of ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 239
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
the terms *' planet." and " inhabited," and of all the other terms in the language, he cannot thence be certain that the planets are, or are not, inhabited. It has probably been the source of much perplexity, that the term "true" has been applied iTuKscriminately to two such different classes of propositions. The term ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 242
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Those Discoveries of general laws of Nature, &c. of which we have been speaking, being of that character which we have described by the name of ** Logical Die- coveries," to him who is in possession of all the Premises from which they are deduced; but being, to the multitude (who are unacquainted with many of those Pre...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 246
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
In foUotoing, indeed, and taking in a demonstration, nothing is called for but pure Reasoning; but the astump- tion of Premises is not a part of Reasoning, in the strict and technical sense of that term. Accordingly, there are many who can follow a Mathematical demonstration, or any other train or argument, who would n...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 249
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=16w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
Something has, indeed, been done in this way by more than one writer ; and more might plications of probably be accomplished by one who should fully comprehend and carefully bear in mind the princi- ples of Logic, properly so called ; but it would hardly be possible to build up any thing like a regular Science re- spec...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 254
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=19w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
In the other department, precepts have been Rhetorical given by Aristotle and other Rhetorical writers, *^^*^- as a part of their plan. How far these precepts are to be considered as belonging to the present sjrstem, — whether "method" is to be regarded as a part of ■t^^c, — whether the matter of Logic is to be include...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 258
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
MS OH THE PROVINCE OF REABONINa. [Booc IV. Vwbaioiias- It is by no means to be supposed that all ttSSn'for Verbal Questions are trifling and firivolous. It ***** is often of the highest importance to settle cor- rectly the meaning of a word, either according to ordinary use, or according to the meaning of any particula...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 262
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage isn’t" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* Yet the charge of equiyocation is sometimes unjustly brought against a writer, in consequence of a gratnitons as- sumption of our own. An Eastern writer, e, g. may be 8})eakiiig of *' beasts of burden ;" and the reader may chance to have the idea occur to his mind of Horses and Mules; he thence takes for granted that...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 263
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=13w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
♦ Prom which our word Priest is derived, but which (it Is remarkable) is never translated " Priest" in our version of the Scriptures, but " Elder." ikUF. y. § 1.J REAUSM. M Chap. V. Of Realism, Nothing has a greater tendency to lead to the mistake just noticed, and thus to produce undetected Verbal Glues- tions and fru...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 265
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
t66i Tt an^aivuv. 'E«i ^Iv o^y rQv xpartav oiatdp dvaft^*90^i7irov c«I iXtlBis ioTtVf 571 T4i€ rt vriffdfst' iroffv yd^ koI fy 6fi9^ r4 S^XotfiafStf itTt». 'E«i ii Ttiy hvripiaw o^acuv, ^AINET AI /Uv hitoitat ry ^xV^' *% vpotniYoptas r6U n ny/ic^Miv, Zraw tiinif ipSponros, | ^c3oir' OY MHN rC AAHOES' dXA& ^tfiXXoy mtdy...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 266
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
tf» ON THE PROVINCE OF REASONING. [Book IV that if they were descended (or might have descended) from the same stock, they were of the same Species, and if otherwise, of two : this is the &ct, which they endeaToar to ascertain, hy such indications as are to he £)und. For it is to he further ohserved, that this fact bei...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 268
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop": [ "structure:" ], "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=15w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* There are few, and but a few, other Species to which the same observations will in a great degree apply ; I mean in whidi the JHfsrmUa which canstiiuUs the Species, and the mark If CbUt.V,il.) REALISM. S&» Hence it is that Species, in the case of organized beings, appears to be something real, and independent of our ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 269
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
The feet is, that •* unity" and ** sameness" are in such cases employed, not in the primary sense, but to denote perfect similarity. When we say that ten thousand diffe- rent persons have all "one and the same" Idea in their minds, or are all of **one and the same" Opinion, we mean no more than that they are all thinki...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 271
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
«S6 ON THE PROVINCE OF REASONINa. (BookIY. ANALOGY. Courage, e. g. consists in the relation in which one stands {h rS ©i^*"' "^^^ ^P^^* Arist.) towards dangers; Temperance or Intemperance, towards bodily pleasures, ^e. When it is said, therefore, of two coura- geous men, that they have both the same quality, the only m...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 272
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It is not intended to recommend the disuse of the words ''same," "identical," 4*^. in this transferred s^se; which, if it were desirable would be utterly impracticable ; but merely a steady attention to the ambiguity thus intro- duced, and watchfulness against the errors thence arising.* * It is with vjords as with mon...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 274
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
* I mean that many writers have sought an explanation of the frinutry sense of identity (viz, personal) by looking to the seeoTid- ary. Any grown man, e, g, is, in the primary sense, the same per- son he was when a child: this sameness is, I conceive, a simple notion, which it is vain to attempt explaining by any other...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 275
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=12w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
.The words and phrases which may be employed as ambiguous middle terms are of course innimierable: bat it may be in several respects of service to the learner, to explain the ambig^ty of a few of those most frequently occurring in the most important discussions, and whose double meaning has been the most frequently ove...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 277
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_bullets", "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=14w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
these ezpresrions, {as some have inadverteDdy done,) in leference, necessarHy, to the notion which may exist, in the atUhof^s mind, of the object in question ; of which the notions conveyed to others by the word may often M\ short ; nor again should we regard the sense in which they un- derstand ' him, as necessarily h...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 278
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=12w)" ] }
[ { "from": "system", "value": "Follow these commitments in every response.\n\nREADING METHOD: Read at the level of the full passage — the pericope, the argument, the narrated scene — never an isolated verse pulled free of it. Attend closely to the specific words, grammar, and scope-limits the passage uses; t...
It may be worth mentioning in this plaoe, that the va- rious forms of stating an Argument are sometimes spoken of as different kinds of Argument : as when we speak of a Categorical or Hypothetical Argument, or of one in the first or some other figure ; though every logician knows that the sa!ne individual Argument may ...
Whately, Elements of Logic, part 280
wisdom_logic
2
{ "think_slop_structural": [ "markdown_emphasis", "long_sentences(mean=17w)" ], "answer_prefix_collapse": [ "whately’s passage is" ] }