File size: 275,236 Bytes
69062a9 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544 545 | {"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-045d9f98883becc4", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-045d9f98883becc4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-092cd51bcb5448d7", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-092cd51bcb5448d7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-12f6919745623d9a", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-919745623d9a-40241499"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-12f6919745623d9a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-12ff5dcc555c8bea", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-12ff5dcc555c8bea", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-192c0c6505c9c7e0", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-192c0c6505c9c7e0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-21a9351a0c613d68", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-21a9351a0c613d68", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-22ebf702279a5672", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-22ebf702279a5672", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2bd6d96052019d32", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d96052019d32-11163777", "ncb-evidence-d96052019d32-20682456"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2bd6d96052019d32", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2ef4c0bcc46bed37", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2ef4c0bcc46bed37", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2f7044d63c6a8771", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2f7044d63c6a8771", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-3368778ccb30dbe8", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-778ccb30dbe8-10618008", "ncb-evidence-778ccb30dbe8-16377156", "ncb-evidence-778ccb30dbe8-31603232"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-3368778ccb30dbe8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-34b0d6368d06370a", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d6368d06370a-20352396", "ncb-evidence-d6368d06370a-25834730", "ncb-evidence-d6368d06370a-36530087"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-34b0d6368d06370a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-36b84e80d6c50012", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-36b84e80d6c50012", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-3ecc90fbaac44bfe", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-3ecc90fbaac44bfe", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-41a540435c5c78bc", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-41a540435c5c78bc", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-449e7b4f8e2900f2", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-449e7b4f8e2900f2", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-4f545e6dc827f451", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-4f545e6dc827f451", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-530077d063ef312f", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-77d063ef312f-28219628", "ncb-evidence-77d063ef312f-29162300", "ncb-evidence-77d063ef312f-32693001"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-530077d063ef312f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-54ee5bbdf18fb340", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-5bbdf18fb340-37042481"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-54ee5bbdf18fb340", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-569510b14fd88380", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-569510b14fd88380", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5794ca4d9a4f492b", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-ca4d9a4f492b-19019455", "ncb-evidence-ca4d9a4f492b-26857596"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5794ca4d9a4f492b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-58774413687b61b9", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-58774413687b61b9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5f9f5d74554e0614", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-5d74554e0614-26857596", "ncb-evidence-5d74554e0614-41540091"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5f9f5d74554e0614", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5fb11c517888b8d9", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-1c517888b8d9-19309039", "ncb-evidence-1c517888b8d9-32119112", "ncb-evidence-1c517888b8d9-39067683"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5fb11c517888b8d9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6a1fd39ef4326482", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6a1fd39ef4326482", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6c51801ff315cd4f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6c51801ff315cd4f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6e7550292e8dbaff", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6e7550292e8dbaff", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6e919234505c3841", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9234505c3841-28219628", "ncb-evidence-9234505c3841-38409281"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6e919234505c3841", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-717b76df43cc7ce7", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-76df43cc7ce7-21030008", "ncb-evidence-76df43cc7ce7-25496759", "ncb-evidence-76df43cc7ce7-34038834"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-717b76df43cc7ce7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-75d84aea42f71e47", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-4aea42f71e47-32973425", "ncb-evidence-4aea42f71e47-35182842", "ncb-evidence-4aea42f71e47-37639979"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-75d84aea42f71e47", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-79370db65226ca4e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-79370db65226ca4e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-7f37d5578b3cc678", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-7f37d5578b3cc678", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-87da7810f0a4515f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-87da7810f0a4515f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-89a3d773c1c9f79a", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d773c1c9f79a-19846828", "ncb-evidence-d773c1c9f79a-38395200", "ncb-evidence-d773c1c9f79a-41419068"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-89a3d773c1c9f79a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-8a63ea377d95958e", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-ea377d95958e-38692473"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-8a63ea377d95958e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-913498386bc29d4b", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-98386bc29d4b-24319433", "ncb-evidence-98386bc29d4b-41904268"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-913498386bc29d4b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-92410531cc87b1c8", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-92410531cc87b1c8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-9345083b10556ec3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-9345083b10556ec3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-94dea5dc0bc79c8c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-94dea5dc0bc79c8c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-963d6d126e015ed1", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-6d126e015ed1-10618008", "ncb-evidence-6d126e015ed1-31082993", "ncb-evidence-6d126e015ed1-33479754"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-963d6d126e015ed1", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-9c7a47dbebfe1759", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-9c7a47dbebfe1759", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-a614b9f9882504d0", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-a614b9f9882504d0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-a8646216db807141", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-a8646216db807141", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-aab29b1d1c0b92a5", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-aab29b1d1c0b92a5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-add0ae4efa4206f4", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-ae4efa4206f4-30107268", "ncb-evidence-ae4efa4206f4-36750240"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-add0ae4efa4206f4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-aebaac8d15a9b19e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-aebaac8d15a9b19e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-b8fb8dbb05332d12", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-b8fb8dbb05332d12", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_null": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-bd91d6374d028fa2", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d6374d028fa2-17765748", "ncb-evidence-d6374d028fa2-20352396", "ncb-evidence-d6374d028fa2-23477989", "ncb-evidence-d6374d028fa2-41324786"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-bd91d6374d028fa2", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-c4f5cafd4fc66d6e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-c4f5cafd4fc66d6e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d39f4693f159c73e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d39f4693f159c73e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d502bc59cbfea3cf", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d502bc59cbfea3cf", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d9c2200f2c768244", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-200f2c768244-18762588", "ncb-evidence-200f2c768244-26857596", "ncb-evidence-200f2c768244-34038834"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d9c2200f2c768244", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-ddd73764077ec103", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-3764077ec103-26857596", "ncb-evidence-3764077ec103-35232800"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-ddd73764077ec103", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_null": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-e60c97d7572df957", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-97d7572df957-28219628"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-e60c97d7572df957", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_null": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-eaaa2769700eae0e", "derivation_rule": "two_model_reference_with_direct_conflicting_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-2769700eae0e-24957866", "ncb-evidence-2769700eae0e-42418870"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-eaaa2769700eae0e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 1, "known_null": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-ec4fe05bc8c819f7", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-e05bc8c819f7-28501823", "ncb-evidence-e05bc8c819f7-33735787", "ncb-evidence-e05bc8c819f7-40241499"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-ec4fe05bc8c819f7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f1d779bf3ff46410", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f1d779bf3ff46410", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f4db51596e08aa4e", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-51596e08aa4e-18590567", "ncb-evidence-51596e08aa4e-28219628"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f4db51596e08aa4e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f4e152e984bdd249", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f4e152e984bdd249", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f58df52cceca9d39", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f58df52cceca9d39", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-fc18a39ffb8c66fb", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-a39ffb8c66fb-17022794", "ncb-evidence-a39ffb8c66fb-39353988"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-fc18a39ffb8c66fb", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-fc82caeab42cbb0b", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-caeab42cbb0b-28219628", "ncb-evidence-caeab42cbb0b-29427578"], "reference_id": "ncb-external-transfer-fc82caeab42cbb0b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-34462bc3fe7aad1f", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-34462bc3fe7aad1f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-47bb812b9cbd8434", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-47bb812b9cbd8434", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-4a9f7d09a17c74f8", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-4a9f7d09a17c74f8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-661468a337ef8336", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-661468a337ef8336", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-6f8d67212a205367", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-6f8d67212a205367", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-936a5d784ee98820", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-936a5d784ee98820", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-971e3a317a0b72b1", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-971e3a317a0b72b1", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-c109790dc989f6d7", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-c109790dc989f6d7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-c92eff7950758b43", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-c92eff7950758b43", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-pending-d98528cc9b996755", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-pending-d98528cc9b996755", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-03136ab7c6bb7990", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-03136ab7c6bb7990", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-042202d5c660975c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-042202d5c660975c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-047feb6835500e20", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-047feb6835500e20", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-05c17620b6ff0817", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-05c17620b6ff0817", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-060910c2dae3c7c0", "derivation_rule": "two_model_reference_with_direct_conflicting_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-10c2dae3c7c0-31500674", "ncb-evidence-10c2dae3c7c0-35583796", "ncb-evidence-10c2dae3c7c0-42412230"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-060910c2dae3c7c0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-06e24b7117348843", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-06e24b7117348843", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-08c6866776e43268", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-866776e43268-28040544"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-08c6866776e43268", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-08efd1786e5b448a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-08efd1786e5b448a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0945ff60b5d68ba8", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0945ff60b5d68ba8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-09903e42ed156c26", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-3e42ed156c26-38422833", "ncb-evidence-3e42ed156c26-39212653"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-09903e42ed156c26", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-09bce8d2747a588b", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-09bce8d2747a588b", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0b054fd85acaa063", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0b054fd85acaa063", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0bccd4e0b2409e23", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0bccd4e0b2409e23", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0c04451321f8aa46", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0c04451321f8aa46", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0c84ae301c0de1ab", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0c84ae301c0de1ab", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0cdad63325891f3d", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d63325891f3d-31500674", "ncb-evidence-d63325891f3d-32468880"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0cdad63325891f3d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0cf9bf17a3cb10a7", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-bf17a3cb10a7-27001500", "ncb-evidence-bf17a3cb10a7-35604697"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0cf9bf17a3cb10a7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0d57166941ee6987", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0d57166941ee6987", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0efe8c9435d8ffdf", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0efe8c9435d8ffdf", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0f508c95b4a3bf2f", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-8c95b4a3bf2f-23236213", "ncb-evidence-8c95b4a3bf2f-32726311"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0f508c95b4a3bf2f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0f75dd716dd391af", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0f75dd716dd391af", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0fba59d9c8075ce0", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-0fba59d9c8075ce0", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-107375390c1725d9", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-75390c1725d9-31285817"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-107375390c1725d9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-113ed00f0e74744d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-113ed00f0e74744d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1329501baee4943a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1329501baee4943a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-138026bd7cce20e7", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-138026bd7cce20e7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-149b1f2aeda4fcb1", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-149b1f2aeda4fcb1", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1518a0abab435142", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1518a0abab435142", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-172d75bcc17dcce9", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-172d75bcc17dcce9", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1775e0699f7d950f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1775e0699f7d950f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1954832d44d0ebd1", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1954832d44d0ebd1", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-19802d4080b79f2e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-19802d4080b79f2e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1b8a8b0d4ec2f528", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-8b0d4ec2f528-1431963", "ncb-evidence-8b0d4ec2f528-32444544", "ncb-evidence-8b0d4ec2f528-41611638"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1b8a8b0d4ec2f528", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1bc0eeed8b9a00bc", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1bc0eeed8b9a00bc", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1c1c6743a2aa1468", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-6743a2aa1468-27421791", "ncb-evidence-6743a2aa1468-31251765", "ncb-evidence-6743a2aa1468-34289458"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1c1c6743a2aa1468", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1c4bb13eab05e379", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b13eab05e379-31313441", "ncb-evidence-b13eab05e379-37533450"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1c4bb13eab05e379", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1d2a9e0f4f0b8bc3", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1d2a9e0f4f0b8bc3", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1d647c3ac871d92d", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-7c3ac871d92d-20600983", "ncb-evidence-7c3ac871d92d-28371656", "ncb-evidence-7c3ac871d92d-35634207"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1d647c3ac871d92d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1d82194a9c52b4fa", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1d82194a9c52b4fa", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f13a7aee9fc1c7d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1f13a7aee9fc1c7d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f634e71dd689f9b", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1f634e71dd689f9b", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f683beae6c7e55d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1f683beae6c7e55d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f9b7b9991250bd7", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-7b9991250bd7-20600983", "ncb-evidence-7b9991250bd7-27445261", "ncb-evidence-7b9991250bd7-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-1f9b7b9991250bd7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-206dd8d45a4d9d89", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-206dd8d45a4d9d89", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2290e2c4612f7606", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2290e2c4612f7606", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-22dfa8274c94ef0c", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-22dfa8274c94ef0c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2387b1cf701bf90b", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2387b1cf701bf90b", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23a83dcb8dd0287e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-23a83dcb8dd0287e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23b8d8c0265298fd", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-23b8d8c0265298fd", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23d61a93cc5dbec1", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-23d61a93cc5dbec1", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23e29f207b2ce118", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9f207b2ce118-23774715", "ncb-evidence-9f207b2ce118-36346215", "ncb-evidence-9f207b2ce118-37121277", "ncb-evidence-9f207b2ce118-39261969"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-23e29f207b2ce118", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-24de654ccd87dce2", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-24de654ccd87dce2", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-25e7ef2da7f86162", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-ef2da7f86162-37645791", "ncb-evidence-ef2da7f86162-38618171"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-25e7ef2da7f86162", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-266504b3d4e53721", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-266504b3d4e53721", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2a373f053e882288", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2a373f053e882288", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2a5d5bc83ab86134", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2a5d5bc83ab86134", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2aa338cf718c206f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2aa338cf718c206f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2aadc4e4de851c0e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2aadc4e4de851c0e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2b20954defb2352a", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2b20954defb2352a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2b36f4bbee998e56", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2b36f4bbee998e56", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2b8c1957240b2b85", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2b8c1957240b2b85", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2da7ae8514465754", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2da7ae8514465754", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2dab47018aa41786", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2dab47018aa41786", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2dcda273dbedc219", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2dcda273dbedc219", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2ddc5b5c1ef8b93a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2ddc5b5c1ef8b93a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2e389c7806389508", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2e389c7806389508", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2f6ce6fa5ea95eeb", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-2f6ce6fa5ea95eeb", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-30329250c399e0e1", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9250c399e0e1-32468880", "ncb-evidence-9250c399e0e1-35583796"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-30329250c399e0e1", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-30a7ce77696eccff", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-30a7ce77696eccff", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-30f73b540a076be8", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-30f73b540a076be8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-31990e646f54d4e6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-31990e646f54d4e6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-319a1462bfdbc89d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-319a1462bfdbc89d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-31ff42faa1d10211", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-31ff42faa1d10211", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-32c06a5e43e74faa", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-32c06a5e43e74faa", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-349eb82545a4fed6", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b82545a4fed6-1431963", "ncb-evidence-b82545a4fed6-20352396", "ncb-evidence-b82545a4fed6-35592489"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-349eb82545a4fed6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3578a76ed8bf3578", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-a76ed8bf3578-20352396", "ncb-evidence-a76ed8bf3578-29575324", "ncb-evidence-a76ed8bf3578-38143346"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3578a76ed8bf3578", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3700ad906c849ad5", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3700ad906c849ad5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3942bdaedf8efb2a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3942bdaedf8efb2a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3ad601039168835a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3ad601039168835a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3b7b2226aa3bb7ce", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3b7b2226aa3bb7ce", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3ba54e0248b29adb", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3ba54e0248b29adb", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3bb5fd92cff87e34", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3bb5fd92cff87e34", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3cd280f660dfbcd4", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-80f660dfbcd4-27725313", "ncb-evidence-80f660dfbcd4-28371656", "ncb-evidence-80f660dfbcd4-29894827", "ncb-evidence-80f660dfbcd4-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3cd280f660dfbcd4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3e1160c83f5950a6", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-60c83f5950a6-28770039"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-3e1160c83f5950a6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-41408a5127ecaa01", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-8a5127ecaa01-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-41408a5127ecaa01", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-41e14c6dd1c2213b", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-41e14c6dd1c2213b", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-424e2babe414b942", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-424e2babe414b942", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-42b2c11ed186c2c9", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-42b2c11ed186c2c9", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-43b88d75579673af", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-43b88d75579673af", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-456c48345929eb71", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-456c48345929eb71", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-46c685780a6efe6d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-46c685780a6efe6d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-493d1fd9443c1c35", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-493d1fd9443c1c35", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-49789008a2790135", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-49789008a2790135", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-49fd02560669f081", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-49fd02560669f081", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4bafecc6ed3b9d87", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4bafecc6ed3b9d87", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4bec8588ceb4224d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4bec8588ceb4224d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4cdc34b013079f25", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-34b013079f25-32468880", "ncb-evidence-34b013079f25-35903637"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4cdc34b013079f25", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4cedbc48040eac27", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4cedbc48040eac27", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4d6ed37bb9324c72", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4d6ed37bb9324c72", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4f6f45a81e8e3370", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-45a81e8e3370-38896910", "ncb-evidence-45a81e8e3370-42141307"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4f6f45a81e8e3370", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4f93b1319bad7eb5", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4f93b1319bad7eb5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4ffc0faff41b9d25", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-4ffc0faff41b9d25", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-51f69ecdfc1f24b2", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-51f69ecdfc1f24b2", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-531f4a09678d2222", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-531f4a09678d2222", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-548cb9ea8bd9f8de", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-548cb9ea8bd9f8de", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-548d362dc2682286", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-548d362dc2682286", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-55457edaa703fbe4", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-55457edaa703fbe4", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-55b455d152ed1390", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-55b455d152ed1390", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-561d93190dd22ced", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-561d93190dd22ced", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5640b53a2dfaa1b8", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5640b53a2dfaa1b8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-56dfabf45f27a27d", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-56dfabf45f27a27d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-572d89238c32c460", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-572d89238c32c460", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-579c77d9f61e5f87", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-579c77d9f61e5f87", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5824fc854e2aa2db", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5824fc854e2aa2db", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-58864dfe748ed623", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-58864dfe748ed623", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-58a996a383e72e5b", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-96a383e72e5b-31313441", "ncb-evidence-96a383e72e5b-38077180"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-58a996a383e72e5b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-58fd062031fc801e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-58fd062031fc801e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5a12e0c7d2a28bde", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5a12e0c7d2a28bde", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5af5c999c214ab93", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5af5c999c214ab93", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5b0717b45335d600", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5b0717b45335d600", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5b85792fec387f31", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5b85792fec387f31", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5bbd3e8e8a1ab72c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5bbd3e8e8a1ab72c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5d4734ea98c9d333", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5d4734ea98c9d333", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5d5fd40a49dbf782", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5d5fd40a49dbf782", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5e6aa7181e35b605", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5e6aa7181e35b605", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5e9d9106292eb159", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9106292eb159-28371656", "ncb-evidence-9106292eb159-32037204", "ncb-evidence-9106292eb159-37342466"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-5e9d9106292eb159", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-60bd3b9afd76e376", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-60bd3b9afd76e376", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-611e67de29172a34", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-611e67de29172a34", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-61274f38e0112edd", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-61274f38e0112edd", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6130b7ec9d114c16", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b7ec9d114c16-28371656", "ncb-evidence-b7ec9d114c16-32037204", "ncb-evidence-b7ec9d114c16-37176617"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6130b7ec9d114c16", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-622e97baf8eece3c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-622e97baf8eece3c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-629feeb21e3e9864", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-629feeb21e3e9864", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-65466f9b282b22be", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-65466f9b282b22be", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6560b15c380073ca", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6560b15c380073ca", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-66560a7fd0e34141", "derivation_rule": "two_model_reference_with_direct_conflicting_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-0a7fd0e34141-31313441", "ncb-evidence-0a7fd0e34141-32037204", "ncb-evidence-0a7fd0e34141-38077180"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-66560a7fd0e34141", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-672ab5d3a6c11820", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-672ab5d3a6c11820", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-673bb19e90e472ee", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b19e90e472ee-25928822", "ncb-evidence-b19e90e472ee-26363140", "ncb-evidence-b19e90e472ee-32468880"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-673bb19e90e472ee", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-67542fa55426a130", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-67542fa55426a130", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-675abad09b88a363", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-675abad09b88a363", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-67bed34632da1fbb", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-67bed34632da1fbb", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-67d76c2c55e3d767", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-67d76c2c55e3d767", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-67de4555230bc27a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-67de4555230bc27a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-68bd56b0483a236c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-68bd56b0483a236c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-690059388e87cd26", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-690059388e87cd26", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-693510493058a91a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-693510493058a91a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-693e96c3edd41a98", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-693e96c3edd41a98", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6aa47e3b129ad9fb", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6aa47e3b129ad9fb", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6bedac272110f713", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6bedac272110f713", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6c7b0f8ae69a2d50", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6c7b0f8ae69a2d50", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6c9d8d248e03fd07", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-8d248e03fd07-25275678", "ncb-evidence-8d248e03fd07-28371656", "ncb-evidence-8d248e03fd07-31313441", "ncb-evidence-8d248e03fd07-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6c9d8d248e03fd07", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6d7bbb66ca61d088", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6d7bbb66ca61d088", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6efb2475137e21ce", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6efb2475137e21ce", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6f07b924f78e762d", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b924f78e762d-25309433", "ncb-evidence-b924f78e762d-26733864"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-6f07b924f78e762d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-704522685c487d81", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-704522685c487d81", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-70527a90423a8295", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-70527a90423a8295", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-709359ed74346ba9", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-709359ed74346ba9", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-717fef42ce5138d1", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-717fef42ce5138d1", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-721c4fa75e038ea4", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-721c4fa75e038ea4", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-73e0f34188f4c613", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-f34188f4c613-32468880"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-73e0f34188f4c613", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-740708798029c58d", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-08798029c58d-28371656", "ncb-evidence-08798029c58d-32037204", "ncb-evidence-08798029c58d-37683727", "ncb-evidence-08798029c58d-38335544", "ncb-evidence-08798029c58d-38948857", "ncb-evidence-08798029c58d-38962058"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-740708798029c58d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-75bd3855eddc86c8", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-3855eddc86c8-26565394", "ncb-evidence-3855eddc86c8-37549446"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-75bd3855eddc86c8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7761a54a90d0f99d", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7761a54a90d0f99d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-79182620041b5799", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-79182620041b5799", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-792968836011440a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-792968836011440a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7a87a86398becf44", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7a87a86398becf44", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7ab10eca62cc6fc7", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7ab10eca62cc6fc7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7be5e0886589fedd", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7be5e0886589fedd", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c005de1c12b32a7", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7c005de1c12b32a7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c173adc5485d7ce", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7c173adc5485d7ce", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c66a10417fcec23", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-a10417fcec23-1431963", "ncb-evidence-a10417fcec23-17413023", "ncb-evidence-a10417fcec23-35388950"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7c66a10417fcec23", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c8fd02a769bcd9a", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d02a769bcd9a-20600983", "ncb-evidence-d02a769bcd9a-28011131", "ncb-evidence-d02a769bcd9a-28371656", "ncb-evidence-d02a769bcd9a-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7c8fd02a769bcd9a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7cb3fe4a5738fae5", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7cb3fe4a5738fae5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7f4258667f94f44d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7f4258667f94f44d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7fc6845e80fabb9d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7fc6845e80fabb9d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7fe9235c8d5841b2", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-7fe9235c8d5841b2", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8014ff72ff0a06a0", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-ff72ff0a06a0-28371656", "ncb-evidence-ff72ff0a06a0-32037204", "ncb-evidence-ff72ff0a06a0-34100349"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8014ff72ff0a06a0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-80318de11aee33ca", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-80318de11aee33ca", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-815d879b9076393c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-815d879b9076393c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-81d14342bc5a3c18", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-4342bc5a3c18-32726311"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-81d14342bc5a3c18", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-81e24d3b130902a4", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-81e24d3b130902a4", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-822a9e3fd7a9cc40", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-822a9e3fd7a9cc40", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8317e3afc8d4d4c2", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-e3afc8d4d4c2-1431963", "ncb-evidence-e3afc8d4d4c2-41225656"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8317e3afc8d4d4c2", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8366c91b96faf9a6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8366c91b96faf9a6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-83e09f86b797842d", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9f86b797842d-30814340", "ncb-evidence-9f86b797842d-39479591"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-83e09f86b797842d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-83e8c22eb0f4831a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-83e8c22eb0f4831a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8482b5c202e5e323", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8482b5c202e5e323", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-86a81a5f3a28d98c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-86a81a5f3a28d98c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-872c426870a43fc0", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-872c426870a43fc0", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-88422a822641e7cd", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-2a822641e7cd-30833582", "ncb-evidence-2a822641e7cd-31260788", "ncb-evidence-2a822641e7cd-34489757"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-88422a822641e7cd", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8875a7bf33df9519", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8875a7bf33df9519", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-89c7369d95a29475", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-89c7369d95a29475", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8c2247d3d87d1686", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8c2247d3d87d1686", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8d7c71367a2043b9", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-71367a2043b9-25844325"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8d7c71367a2043b9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8d7fe2116b082179", "derivation_rule": "alignment_non_executable", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-8d7fe2116b082179", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9066c4a0d3bc2f9f", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-c4a0d3bc2f9f-28371656", "ncb-evidence-c4a0d3bc2f9f-32037204", "ncb-evidence-c4a0d3bc2f9f-36949599", "ncb-evidence-c4a0d3bc2f9f-37342466"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9066c4a0d3bc2f9f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-909dd51daf957cf4", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-909dd51daf957cf4", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-91575e683551f750", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-91575e683551f750", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9181e305d0e360a5", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9181e305d0e360a5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9211f485178e8764", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9211f485178e8764", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9306eed5ac12c7af", "derivation_rule": "two_model_reference_with_direct_conflicting_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-eed5ac12c7af-32468880", "ncb-evidence-eed5ac12c7af-35583796", "ncb-evidence-eed5ac12c7af-37829190"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9306eed5ac12c7af", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9346832a3ea94fed", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9346832a3ea94fed", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9448893bb6c6800c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9448893bb6c6800c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9586a5c1af2ea3f7", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9586a5c1af2ea3f7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-970b61f9cba924c6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-970b61f9cba924c6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9b0372d2c93e148a", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9b0372d2c93e148a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9b768a7494df75b2", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9b768a7494df75b2", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9c2e4221cf5ca105", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-4221cf5ca105-31285817"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9c2e4221cf5ca105", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9c418256797d0a86", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9c418256797d0a86", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9cb81ca19caf7d9d", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-1ca19caf7d9d-1431963", "ncb-evidence-1ca19caf7d9d-36530087"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9cb81ca19caf7d9d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9eaf2a23ddb73ea3", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-2a23ddb73ea3-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9eaf2a23ddb73ea3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9ec4c7f2ec1fad99", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9ec4c7f2ec1fad99", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9f890b1a7a66889e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-9f890b1a7a66889e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a02841671504d8cd", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a02841671504d8cd", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a1bf69b8f56d46c9", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a1bf69b8f56d46c9", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a1da46d7f5fa792d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a1da46d7f5fa792d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a20d5751ea756186", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-5751ea756186-35592489", "ncb-evidence-5751ea756186-36530087", "ncb-evidence-5751ea756186-37091519"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a20d5751ea756186", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a36ed4355870c674", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a36ed4355870c674", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a3f4263a0dce56cf", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a3f4263a0dce56cf", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a427d5471566b2cf", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a427d5471566b2cf", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a545812912502796", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a545812912502796", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a7bd041be62e2db4", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a7bd041be62e2db4", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a9e0ba33a876abc0", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-a9e0ba33a876abc0", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-acb1371a4d55e5b6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-acb1371a4d55e5b6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ad793f2b627c14db", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ad793f2b627c14db", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-adc64a42191e17f6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-adc64a42191e17f6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-adc7daee506cca47", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-adc7daee506cca47", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-afbfd52ab898aa8b", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d52ab898aa8b-33683528"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-afbfd52ab898aa8b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-afe1f83e3d954a8c", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-f83e3d954a8c-34280835", "ncb-evidence-f83e3d954a8c-38906983"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-afe1f83e3d954a8c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b0c4c5f349a00064", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-c5f349a00064-35583796"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b0c4c5f349a00064", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b22524a12bd4a0b9", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-24a12bd4a0b9-41225656", "ncb-evidence-24a12bd4a0b9-41271752"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b22524a12bd4a0b9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b274fb2db756fa8f", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-fb2db756fa8f-20139996", "ncb-evidence-fb2db756fa8f-20352396", "ncb-evidence-fb2db756fa8f-9769443"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b274fb2db756fa8f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b2bc1b3dc8d74234", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-1b3dc8d74234-25844325"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b2bc1b3dc8d74234", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"fragile": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b336c91ebd2e082c", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b336c91ebd2e082c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b5c857772b8292df", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b5c857772b8292df", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b6bcaf52ce24d411", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b6bcaf52ce24d411", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b9f9592e3da6c9ce", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-b9f9592e3da6c9ce", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ba299f6826289883", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ba299f6826289883", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bace4c130b60ece5", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bace4c130b60ece5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bc6d05b49560e9df", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bc6d05b49560e9df", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bd78b101a1f87be6", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b101a1f87be6-20352396", "ncb-evidence-b101a1f87be6-23477989", "ncb-evidence-b101a1f87be6-41233270", "ncb-evidence-b101a1f87be6-41611638"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bd78b101a1f87be6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bdabe2252485052d", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-e2252485052d-20139996", "ncb-evidence-e2252485052d-32119112", "ncb-evidence-e2252485052d-40691867"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bdabe2252485052d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bdc24737aa23b682", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bdc24737aa23b682", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bdd01753f9ebb90c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bdd01753f9ebb90c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-be6c2a9394bf0498", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-be6c2a9394bf0498", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-be9238714808b664", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-be9238714808b664", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bf6a4a4dabf8357f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-bf6a4a4dabf8357f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c1112f228bb27f06", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c1112f228bb27f06", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c1b8f2bee08cd388", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c1b8f2bee08cd388", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c2b02d58d24ba60d", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c2b02d58d24ba60d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c3a081875a1cf586", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-81875a1cf586-35388950", "ncb-evidence-81875a1cf586-40079562"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c3a081875a1cf586", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c631e745a39a4c34", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c631e745a39a4c34", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c64dac21d8591104", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c64dac21d8591104", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c671d3de1b2734cb", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d3de1b2734cb-29653095"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c671d3de1b2734cb", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c823298f5f12df8a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c823298f5f12df8a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c82528795d17b7c6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c82528795d17b7c6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c865d685dc0a2c5f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c865d685dc0a2c5f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c8acae9508ef35fd", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-ae9508ef35fd-36796856"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c8acae9508ef35fd", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c8faa8d62af041ef", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c8faa8d62af041ef", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c922885057dbc163", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c922885057dbc163", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c9246d08669f6265", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c9246d08669f6265", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c98428886dd0f1d9", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-c98428886dd0f1d9", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-caeb5a6d248ba33c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-caeb5a6d248ba33c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cb339bf30281cede", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-cb339bf30281cede", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cb86d4103ebb0e0c", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-d4103ebb0e0c-28040544"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-cb86d4103ebb0e0c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cc1c11b70cdbc35f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-cc1c11b70cdbc35f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cc2914e36309cad4", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-14e36309cad4-35592489", "ncb-evidence-14e36309cad4-36530087", "ncb-evidence-14e36309cad4-37091519"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-cc2914e36309cad4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ccf76ee04722df94", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ccf76ee04722df94", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ce5c0063d478e61d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ce5c0063d478e61d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ce9b34e85b1510c7", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ce9b34e85b1510c7", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cfe09363aec199e4", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9363aec199e4-26351318", "ncb-evidence-9363aec199e4-41420894"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-cfe09363aec199e4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cff1d7d2ccfb4083", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-cff1d7d2ccfb4083", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d0535a6cab6d913b", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-5a6cab6d913b-31313441", "ncb-evidence-5a6cab6d913b-38077180"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-d0535a6cab6d913b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d0e3c2468afe4539", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-d0e3c2468afe4539", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d37402dd791a12dc", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-d37402dd791a12dc", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d3b9d78a966173c6", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-d3b9d78a966173c6", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d4c0b42a60357a5d", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-d4c0b42a60357a5d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d6cbeb536d2b0163", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-d6cbeb536d2b0163", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-da6e0b38e7772e80", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-da6e0b38e7772e80", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-da99887ee1c161f8", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-da99887ee1c161f8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-dc2d5ad4964bca96", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-dc2d5ad4964bca96", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-dc6371e72c01cdcd", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-dc6371e72c01cdcd", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-de1363fa0a54a318", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-de1363fa0a54a318", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-de319955c8826c8c", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-9955c8826c8c-19076441", "ncb-evidence-9955c8826c8c-26876244", "ncb-evidence-9955c8826c8c-37045477", "ncb-evidence-9955c8826c8c-38270821"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-de319955c8826c8c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e035748f4f603bb4", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e035748f4f603bb4", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e1c33335981addda", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e1c33335981addda", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e2c8b315d5871123", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-b315d5871123-10911878", "ncb-evidence-b315d5871123-1431963", "ncb-evidence-b315d5871123-17413023"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e2c8b315d5871123", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e313edffc6da7a07", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e313edffc6da7a07", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e43def8c3b8cb4e9", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e43def8c3b8cb4e9", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e59458cf873b37f4", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-58cf873b37f4-1431963", "ncb-evidence-58cf873b37f4-20352396", "ncb-evidence-58cf873b37f4-41611638"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e59458cf873b37f4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e59b8563fe5abace", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e59b8563fe5abace", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e59e508b9cc05116", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e59e508b9cc05116", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 2, "fragile": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e5b2412738b16335", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e5b2412738b16335", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e5be6d84f8e872b5", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e5be6d84f8e872b5", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e61ccc72bef4061c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e61ccc72bef4061c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e655e7f3059cc2a2", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-e7f3059cc2a2-33338922"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e655e7f3059cc2a2", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e7c94f56c83e0651", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e7c94f56c83e0651", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e9887ba0003df877", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-e9887ba0003df877", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ea3fb846fbd7533c", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ea3fb846fbd7533c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ea89da536ec1b952", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-da536ec1b952-25146995", "ncb-evidence-da536ec1b952-32726311"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ea89da536ec1b952", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-eafa675a2857a0cb", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-eafa675a2857a0cb", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ebc1946b08c8a231", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ebc1946b08c8a231", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "all_three_models", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ec6d0cdd670ee6f6", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-0cdd670ee6f6-20600983", "ncb-evidence-0cdd670ee6f6-28371656", "ncb-evidence-0cdd670ee6f6-28521048", "ncb-evidence-0cdd670ee6f6-32037204"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ec6d0cdd670ee6f6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "known_positive", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ed8eabb252714493", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ed8eabb252714493", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-edbf888496455e86", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-edbf888496455e86", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ee627d7a5d823df0", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ee627d7a5d823df0", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f0173ff72ee52b5e", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f0173ff72ee52b5e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f143dbf87a77594f", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f143dbf87a77594f", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f3636d57e59fc807", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f3636d57e59fc807", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 1, "known_positive": 1}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f38be8ab6a8f07ce", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f38be8ab6a8f07ce", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f38d6fdbc4e79d95", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f38d6fdbc4e79d95", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f41a8c5978b01125", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f41a8c5978b01125", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"known_positive": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f6cf8c122d61317c", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f6cf8c122d61317c", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f7956622f7e3eaf8", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f7956622f7e3eaf8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f7c3e84a1cb3480d", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f7c3e84a1cb3480d", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f849744a3e72c7b0", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "confirm", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-744a3e72c7b0-23774715", "ncb-evidence-744a3e72c7b0-37522594"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f849744a3e72c7b0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "known_positive": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f84fe6980294c120", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f84fe6980294c120", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f8671ab0121baaa8", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-f8671ab0121baaa8", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-fa6a1c43897de76e", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-fa6a1c43897de76e", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["google:gemini-3.5-flash", "openai:gpt-5.5"], "agreement_pattern": "assessors_only", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-fa88cbf43e33f82f", "derivation_rule": "two_model_exact_construct_with_direct_evidence", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-cbf43e33f82f-32066697", "ncb-evidence-cbf43e33f82f-35754775"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-fa88cbf43e33f82f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "provisional", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-faaaeb165e293001", "derivation_rule": "question_contract_alignment_unresolved", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-faaaeb165e293001", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": ["openai:gpt-5.5", "openrouter:anthropic/claude-opus-4.8"], "agreement_pattern": "adjudicator_plus_assessor", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-feb70aa94fa7c90f", "derivation_rule": "existing_score_eligible_reference", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": ["ncb-evidence-0aa94fa7c90f-30259777", "ncb-evidence-0aa94fa7c90f-42412230"], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-feb70aa94fa7c90f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "multi_model_consensus", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "strict", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 1, "fragile": 2}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "literature", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ff4d46696cfed68a", "derivation_rule": "no_two_model_direct_evidence_reference", "disposition": "unresolved", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-scientific-ff4d46696cfed68a", "score_eligible": false, "source_adjudication_status": "unresolved", "source_label": "candidate_unknown", "strength": "evidence_gap", "vote_counts": {"candidate_unknown": 3}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-015db0b6e9d5687e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-015db0b6e9d5687e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0558f914b0d8e6af", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0558f914b0d8e6af", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-061d1b244a34b451", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-061d1b244a34b451", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-064719283da9679c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-064719283da9679c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-06e49e0c9bfc3666", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-06e49e0c9bfc3666", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-096741f8365b47ec", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-096741f8365b47ec", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0b1c1daa0a5f38a6", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0b1c1daa0a5f38a6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0bb6a3a9dc5929ae", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0bb6a3a9dc5929ae", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0cd02a3132b5afda", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0cd02a3132b5afda", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0cd265e25bb8f4a6", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0cd265e25bb8f4a6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0f0403a272133ad1", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0f0403a272133ad1", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-123acaf77fc95cf1", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-123acaf77fc95cf1", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1856779cf86705e9", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1856779cf86705e9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-18f6d3452bd64ce5", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-18f6d3452bd64ce5", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1a4801cd609a8bc9", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1a4801cd609a8bc9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1cb9ec13d30f0e3b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1cb9ec13d30f0e3b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1f7403bea6b8ee84", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1f7403bea6b8ee84", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-21a609397542ba4a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-21a609397542ba4a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-23b408524e23a84b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-23b408524e23a84b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-23f923def996294a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-23f923def996294a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-242d47d3594f6864", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-242d47d3594f6864", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-26a7e82fe849729e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-26a7e82fe849729e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-2724233ad72644a4", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-2724233ad72644a4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-2cdcd1655db50299", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-2cdcd1655db50299", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-314c6524cbe93809", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-314c6524cbe93809", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-31e032722d8da786", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-31e032722d8da786", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-32a5293904ed5896", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-32a5293904ed5896", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-35ab0b847aafb7de", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-35ab0b847aafb7de", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-3b26f2bc31391570", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-3b26f2bc31391570", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-3c97cab8cb18d560", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-3c97cab8cb18d560", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-43acbd197355fcc4", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-43acbd197355fcc4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-43c43273ba8985e4", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-43c43273ba8985e4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-45b6d43ce4f879ea", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-45b6d43ce4f879ea", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-45e4a4f6e1fc74d9", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-45e4a4f6e1fc74d9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-48888b0a50e6c685", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-48888b0a50e6c685", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-4d6f32ae88b34ae5", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-4d6f32ae88b34ae5", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-4eba4adfcf45c4c3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-4eba4adfcf45c4c3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-521bd6435c6d8390", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-521bd6435c6d8390", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-545812ed0777dcb3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-545812ed0777dcb3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-54c17f36d0f78ac8", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-54c17f36d0f78ac8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-564b9d40a50edcaa", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-564b9d40a50edcaa", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-56b080929487f10e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-56b080929487f10e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-577eca459126d08d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-577eca459126d08d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-58807756a4b61455", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-58807756a4b61455", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-58bbab3b5e3ff519", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-58bbab3b5e3ff519", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-59ef3adedd2d2f5d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-59ef3adedd2d2f5d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5ca3b178253860d3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5ca3b178253860d3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d0e6a346e90515f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d0e6a346e90515f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d46d95ce95c931d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d46d95ce95c931d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d87d9cb45790f0b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d87d9cb45790f0b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5eb1caa641a44211", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5eb1caa641a44211", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5f2cf87b065cc1d8", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5f2cf87b065cc1d8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5f540298959b95f9", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5f540298959b95f9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-611a2fe389785bcf", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-611a2fe389785bcf", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-61a83b2df86312b4", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-61a83b2df86312b4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-65ed609046c27500", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-65ed609046c27500", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6689cbe59e004145", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6689cbe59e004145", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ace315a9094473a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ace315a9094473a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ec87b076698475c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ec87b076698475c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ee77e7e1b81ebdc", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ee77e7e1b81ebdc", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6efee680423ceb0a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6efee680423ceb0a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6fa6169d2993bc1d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6fa6169d2993bc1d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-72743e2acf45d7e5", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-72743e2acf45d7e5", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7320409f0609fb6c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7320409f0609fb6c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7446a0a12b859ed8", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7446a0a12b859ed8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-75f27bf902a69eb3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-75f27bf902a69eb3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7911d5fcc3aee4ba", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7911d5fcc3aee4ba", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-792cb959ece29063", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-792cb959ece29063", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7e3903cc96c0849e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7e3903cc96c0849e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7e9f95804251f0a0", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7e9f95804251f0a0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7fbc16c903db656b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7fbc16c903db656b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7fcbe86bd9b2c850", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7fcbe86bd9b2c850", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-81b80b20688f3f90", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-81b80b20688f3f90", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-81bc0f58011fdf7d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-81bc0f58011fdf7d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-820e065fb07facd4", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-820e065fb07facd4", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-82c3329f50510efe", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-82c3329f50510efe", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-87f4857ed96a6164", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-87f4857ed96a6164", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-880fcb45e6645cae", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-880fcb45e6645cae", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-88779694dc46460f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-88779694dc46460f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-8969417a2a5f8ec6", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-8969417a2a5f8ec6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-91524ba0afb540ec", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-91524ba0afb540ec", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-91ca48ca8f7976aa", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-91ca48ca8f7976aa", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-92eebea972c19814", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-92eebea972c19814", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-98bf3913e77b446e", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-98bf3913e77b446e", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9976660e5ef9dac3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9976660e5ef9dac3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9b50e1327c3e6c6a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9b50e1327c3e6c6a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9bdffe881e48de4f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9bdffe881e48de4f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9ec90396df1939bd", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9ec90396df1939bd", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a08821ce404a9f53", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a08821ce404a9f53", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a17be850c0a76e0a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a17be850c0a76e0a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a536bee9bcacd85c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a536bee9bcacd85c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a9f4010d6ed3964c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a9f4010d6ed3964c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-aa9ca68bedbbb036", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-aa9ca68bedbbb036", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ac9cd68260b345b7", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ac9cd68260b345b7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b06c112fe652826c", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b06c112fe652826c", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b0ad25a9bd80f5a9", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b0ad25a9bd80f5a9", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b0c5075602b380ed", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b0c5075602b380ed", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b3381266246ed676", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b3381266246ed676", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b6e37ce62a4f72f8", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b6e37ce62a4f72f8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bbf85b6c044b210f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bbf85b6c044b210f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bc7a72687a803144", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bc7a72687a803144", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bd117704d246d32d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bd117704d246d32d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-be65950958048714", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-be65950958048714", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bfbbfbb8d1be3254", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bfbbfbb8d1be3254", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c0127a06d407afa7", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c0127a06d407afa7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c0dc3336ffe218d2", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c0dc3336ffe218d2", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c1154a14cd1e8ef3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c1154a14cd1e8ef3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c20a3d5f8e9e123f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c20a3d5f8e9e123f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c220a093f814e539", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c220a093f814e539", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c2d028849e27a38a", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c2d028849e27a38a", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c752b6285a527e82", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c752b6285a527e82", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c7fc286c99cc66c6", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c7fc286c99cc66c6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c93f76e6f75aeaeb", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c93f76e6f75aeaeb", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ca59e7bcf2e17f7b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ca59e7bcf2e17f7b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cb1ea057a92edbc7", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cb1ea057a92edbc7", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cc6a8be21390c788", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cc6a8be21390c788", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cc868c07af008306", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cc868c07af008306", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ce1212b806f25235", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ce1212b806f25235", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cfc8fee426568090", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cfc8fee426568090", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d240bf163611d308", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d240bf163611d308", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d7791ed71415a487", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d7791ed71415a487", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d85043ecf72b62d3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d85043ecf72b62d3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d916964e92a59eb0", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d916964e92a59eb0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-dd4beff29754d17d", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-dd4beff29754d17d", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ddef0966bc3b9b24", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ddef0966bc3b9b24", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-df080a369be8d182", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-df080a369be8d182", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-dfbe62737d4d8555", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-dfbe62737d4d8555", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e1ef0d8ef65b2b01", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e1ef0d8ef65b2b01", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e23fddfb3f829797", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e23fddfb3f829797", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e2684641edc8c6e6", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e2684641edc8c6e6", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e2967e8bdd4698b5", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e2967e8bdd4698b5", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e781a1d10147abaa", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e781a1d10147abaa", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e99377ceac8e5d23", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e99377ceac8e5d23", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e9fb3c58c1aaf079", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e9fb3c58c1aaf079", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ec601d06e6ff6b54", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ec601d06e6ff6b54", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ecf6d32180cfff58", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ecf6d32180cfff58", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ee7abc3b89d1d4cc", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ee7abc3b89d1d4cc", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "fragile", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-effa2f259eb5a69f", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-effa2f259eb5a69f", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f034e20c6a6bc7f8", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f034e20c6a6bc7f8", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f091755e09ca7583", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f091755e09ca7583", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f2d4eb788a04c639", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f2d4eb788a04c639", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f377cad3c090b549", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f377cad3c090b549", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f5dbfb11e9ef72d0", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f5dbfb11e9ef72d0", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f8423e8ba6d67c54", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f8423e8ba6d67c54", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f8fa9003aa7c9d3b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f8fa9003aa7c9d3b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f91a2cdb84ef6798", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f91a2cdb84ef6798", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f936b668e13706b3", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f936b668e13706b3", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f9b3b69c40a65738", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f9b3b69c40a65738", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-fcd62e593092700b", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-fcd62e593092700b", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
{"agreeing_models": [], "agreement_pattern": "not_applicable", "basis": "constructed_control", "benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-feb2bcefb03564db", "derivation_rule": "deterministic_control_construction", "disposition": "abstain", "evidence_ids": [], "reference_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-feb2bcefb03564db", "score_eligible": true, "source_adjudication_status": "construction_derived", "source_label": "known_null", "strength": "constructed", "vote_counts": {}}
|