sungguk's picture
Release visual answerability benchmark v1.0.0
e1ced61 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
10.3 kB
"""Independent replay of persisted certificate artifacts."""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
from concurrent.futures import ProcessPoolExecutor
from dataclasses import dataclass
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Any
from ..dsl.canonicalize import canonical_program_sha256
from ..executors import get_executor
from ..executors.reference_plot import ReferencePlotExecutor
from ..hashing import canonical_json_hash, sha256_file
from ..paths import repo_root
from ..renderers import render
from ..schema_io import load_schema, parse_json, validate
from ..sources.world_ops import world_sha256
from .build import certificate_id, program_from_dict
@dataclass(frozen=True)
class ReplayResult:
view_dir: str
ok: bool
errors: tuple[str, ...]
def _load(path: Path) -> dict[str, Any]:
value = parse_json(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
if not isinstance(value, dict):
raise ValueError(f"{path} must contain an object")
return value
def replay_view(view_dir: str | Path) -> ReplayResult:
"""Replay one persisted view without using builder in-memory objects."""
root = Path(view_dir)
errors: list[str] = []
try:
cert = _load(root / "certificate.json")
before_world = _load(root / "world_before.json")
after_world = _load(root / "world_after.json")
program = program_from_dict(_load(root / "program.json"))
manifest = _load(root / "render_manifest.json")
text_manifest = _load(root / "text_manifest.json")
except (OSError, ValueError, KeyError, TypeError) as exc:
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, (f"load failed: {exc}",))
if certificate_id(cert) != cert.get("certificate_id"):
errors.append("certificate content address mismatch")
schema_errors = validate(
cert, load_schema(repo_root() / "schemas" / "intervention_certificate.schema.json")
)
if schema_errors:
errors.append("certificate schema mismatch: " + "; ".join(schema_errors[:3]))
if program.base_id != cert.get("base_id"):
errors.append("program base-id mismatch")
if program.question_sha256 != cert.get("question_sha256"):
errors.append("program question hash mismatch")
if program.choices_sha256 != cert.get("choices_sha256"):
errors.append("program choices hash mismatch")
if canonical_program_sha256(program, world=before_world) != cert.get("program", {}).get(
"canonical_ast_sha256"
):
errors.append("canonical program hash mismatch")
if world_sha256(before_world) != cert.get("world_before_sha256"):
errors.append("world_before hash mismatch")
if world_sha256(after_world) != cert.get("world_after_sha256"):
errors.append("world_after hash mismatch")
if canonical_json_hash(manifest) != cert.get("renderer", {}).get("render_manifest_sha256"):
errors.append("render manifest hash mismatch")
image_path = root / "image.png"
node_map_path = root / "node_map.uint32.png"
diff_mask_path = root / "diff_mask.png"
if not image_path.exists():
errors.append("image.png missing")
elif sha256_file(image_path) != cert.get("renderer", {}).get("first_render_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted image hash mismatch")
if not node_map_path.exists():
errors.append("node_map.uint32.png missing")
elif sha256_file(node_map_path) != manifest.get("node_map_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted node-map hash mismatch")
if not diff_mask_path.exists():
errors.append("diff_mask.png missing")
elif sha256_file(diff_mask_path) != cert.get("renderer", {}).get("diff_mask_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted diff-mask hash mismatch")
executor = get_executor(program.dsl)
before = executor.execute(program, world=before_world)
after = executor.execute(program, world=after_world)
ex = cert.get("executor", {})
if before.trace_sha256 != ex.get("before_trace_sha256"):
errors.append("before executor trace mismatch")
if after.trace_sha256 != ex.get("after_trace_sha256"):
errors.append("after executor trace mismatch")
if before.answer_canonical != ex.get("before_answer_canonical"):
errors.append("before executor answer mismatch")
if after.answer_canonical != ex.get("after_answer_canonical"):
errors.append("after executor answer mismatch")
expected_status = {
"UNIQUE": "unique_answer",
"MISSING_INFORMATION": "missing_information",
"INVALID_REFERENT": "invalid_referent",
}.get(after.status)
if expected_status != ex.get("after_status"):
errors.append("after executor status mismatch")
try:
assets = render(
after_world,
renderer_id=str(cert["renderer"]["name"]),
seed=int(cert["renderer"]["seed"]),
width=int(manifest["width"]),
height=int(manifest["height"]),
)
except Exception as exc: # renderer failures must become a replay failure
errors.append(f"render replay failed: {exc}")
else:
if assets.rgba_sha256 != cert.get("renderer", {}).get("replay_render_sha256"):
errors.append("RGBA replay hash mismatch")
if assets.node_map_sha256 != manifest.get("node_map_sha256"):
errors.append("node-map replay hash mismatch")
if assets.render_manifest != manifest:
errors.append("render replay manifest mismatch")
if assets.text_manifest != text_manifest:
errors.append("text-manifest replay mismatch")
proof = cert.get("proof", {})
state = proof.get("state")
if state == "FULL" and (
not before.is_unique
or not after.is_unique
or before.answer_canonical != after.answer_canonical
or proof.get("answer") != after.answer_canonical
):
errors.append("FULL proof mismatch")
if state == "A_SAME" and (
not before.is_unique
or not after.is_unique
or before.answer_canonical != after.answer_canonical
):
errors.append("A_SAME proof mismatch")
if state == "A_CHANGED" and (
not before.is_unique
or not after.is_unique
or before.answer_canonical == after.answer_canonical
):
errors.append("A_CHANGED proof mismatch")
if state == "U_INVALID" and (
before.referent_cardinality != 1
or after.status != "INVALID_REFERENT"
or after.referent_cardinality == 1
):
errors.append("U_INVALID proof mismatch")
if proof.get("state") == "U_MISSING":
if after.status != "MISSING_INFORMATION":
errors.append("U_MISSING executor status mismatch")
for label in ("a", "b"):
path = root / f"completion_{label}.json"
if not path.exists():
errors.append(f"{path.name} missing")
continue
completion = _load(path)
if world_sha256(completion) != proof.get(f"completion_{label}_world_sha256"):
errors.append(f"completion {label} world hash mismatch")
result = executor.execute(program, world=completion)
expected = proof.get(f"completion_{label}_answer")
if result.answer_canonical != expected:
errors.append(f"completion {label} answer mismatch")
try:
observed = render(
completion,
renderer_id=str(cert["renderer"]["name"]),
seed=int(cert["renderer"]["seed"]),
width=int(manifest["width"]),
height=int(manifest["height"]),
)
except Exception as exc:
errors.append(f"completion {label} render failed: {exc}")
else:
if observed.rgba_sha256 != proof.get(f"observed_render_{label}_sha256"):
errors.append(f"completion {label} observed hash mismatch")
if proof.get("observed_render_a_sha256") != proof.get("observed_render_b_sha256"):
errors.append("completion observations differ")
reference = cert.get("reference_executor")
if isinstance(reference, dict):
ref_result = ReferencePlotExecutor().execute(program, world=after_world)
ref_status = {
"UNIQUE": "unique_answer",
"MISSING_INFORMATION": "missing_information",
"INVALID_REFERENT": "invalid_referent",
}.get(ref_result.status)
if ref_status != reference.get("after_status"):
errors.append("reference executor status mismatch")
if ref_result.answer_canonical != reference.get("after_answer_canonical"):
errors.append("reference executor answer mismatch")
if ref_result.trace_sha256 != reference.get("trace_sha256"):
errors.append("reference executor trace mismatch")
if (
ref_result.status != after.status
or ref_result.answer_canonical != after.answer_canonical
):
errors.append("reference executor disagrees with primary")
return ReplayResult(str(root), not errors, tuple(errors))
def replay_dataset(dataset_dir: str | Path, *, workers: int = 1) -> list[ReplayResult]:
"""Replay every referenced view, preserving manifest order across workers."""
if workers < 1:
raise ValueError("workers must be at least 1")
root = Path(dataset_dir)
view_dirs: list[Path] = []
with (root / "groups.jsonl").open("r", encoding="utf-8") as handle:
for line in handle:
if not line.strip():
continue
group = json.loads(line)
for view in group.get("views", []):
rel = view.get("artifact_dir")
if rel is None:
# Released schema v2 stores the image path; its parent is the
# canonical view artifact directory.
images = view.get("images") or []
rel = str(Path(images[0]["path"]).parent) if images else ""
view_dirs.append(root / str(rel))
if workers == 1:
return [replay_view(view_dir) for view_dir in view_dirs]
with ProcessPoolExecutor(max_workers=workers) as pool:
return list(pool.map(replay_view, view_dirs, chunksize=8))