translorentz commited on
Commit
e12ca67
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 9c26d83

Retire the economy-fidelity scatter for the clearer two-panel dense trade-off chart; correct the dense-slice family list

Browse files
README.md CHANGED
@@ -186,8 +186,8 @@ the benchmark, namely both channels as text, the content as a rendered
186
  image with the instruction as text, the instruction as a rendered image
187
  with the content as text, and both channels combined into a single image.
188
  The second slice covers long prose documents, the extraction, reasoning,
189
- transcription and calculation families at tiers four and five rendered at
190
- the dense profile, where a document runs to roughly eight thousand
191
  characters in English and where optical compression can save tokens. The
192
  third slice covers the structured family, machine-oriented text at the same
193
  long tiers and the same dense profile, so that the economy and the fidelity
@@ -560,18 +560,18 @@ between the task families far more than between the models.
560
 
561
  ![Each model's task profile, ranked](charts/en/7_model_task_cascade.png)
562
 
563
- The third places each task family on the trade-off between the tokens saved
564
- and the accuracy lost on long dense documents, for all three models. The
565
- top-right region, real savings with little accuracy loss, is occupied only
566
- by the tasks that do not depend on reading exact strings, namely reasoning
567
- and instruction over prose. Every task that must read exactly sits
568
- elsewhere. Prose retrieval and transcription fall to the bottom right,
569
- saving the same tokens but losing almost everything, and structured machine
570
- text occupies the left half, keeping most of its accuracy but costing more
571
- tokens than the text it replaced. No task that requires exact reading
572
- achieves both the saving and the fidelity.
573
 
574
- ![The economy-fidelity trade-off](charts/en/4_economy_vs_fidelity.png)
575
 
576
  Pooled-language versions of every chart, plus the full family-by-model
577
  grid, are in the charts directory alongside the per-language sets.
@@ -676,8 +676,8 @@ per-family chart shows the transcription collapse at the bottom, the
676
  retrieval curve shows the loss deepening with document length, the cascade
677
  shows GPT 5.5's instruction-channel failure, the economy bars show the
678
  larger relative prose saving discussed in the language comparison, and the
679
- trade-off plane shows the prose retrieval families lying on the floor of
680
- the accuracy axis.
681
 
682
  ![Accuracy by modality condition, Chinese](charts/zh/1_modality_gradient.png)
683
 
@@ -689,7 +689,7 @@ the accuracy axis.
689
 
690
  ![When imaging saves input tokens, Chinese](charts/zh/6_economy_bars.png)
691
 
692
- ![The Chinese economy-fidelity trade-off](charts/zh/4_economy_vs_fidelity.png)
693
 
694
  ## Synthesis
695
 
 
186
  image with the instruction as text, the instruction as a rendered image
187
  with the content as text, and both channels combined into a single image.
188
  The second slice covers long prose documents, the extraction, reasoning,
189
+ transcription, calculation and instruction families at tiers four and five
190
+ rendered at the dense profile, where a document runs to roughly eight thousand
191
  characters in English and where optical compression can save tokens. The
192
  third slice covers the structured family, machine-oriented text at the same
193
  long tiers and the same dense profile, so that the economy and the fidelity
 
560
 
561
  ![Each model's task profile, ranked](charts/en/7_model_task_cascade.png)
562
 
563
+ The third sets what imaging saves against what it costs on the long dense
564
+ documents, family by family, in two aligned panels over shared rows. A
565
+ family would need a rightward bar in both panels for imaging to be a clean
566
+ win, and none has one. Reasoning and instruction over prose come closest,
567
+ saving a quarter to a third of input tokens at a cost of eight and
568
+ seventeen points respectively. The prose retrieval families save the same
569
+ tokens whilst losing sixty-seven and ninety-two points. Structured machine
570
+ text and the line-oriented invoices of the calculation family keep their
571
+ accuracy losses moderate but cost more to image than to tokenise. No family
572
+ that requires exact reading achieves both the saving and the fidelity.
573
 
574
+ ![The dense-document trade-off](charts/en/9_dense_tradeoff.png)
575
 
576
  Pooled-language versions of every chart, plus the full family-by-model
577
  grid, are in the charts directory alongside the per-language sets.
 
676
  retrieval curve shows the loss deepening with document length, the cascade
677
  shows GPT 5.5's instruction-channel failure, the economy bars show the
678
  larger relative prose saving discussed in the language comparison, and the
679
+ trade-off panels show the prose retrieval families losing everything that
680
+ imaging saves, with extraction at minus one hundred points.
681
 
682
  ![Accuracy by modality condition, Chinese](charts/zh/1_modality_gradient.png)
683
 
 
689
 
690
  ![When imaging saves input tokens, Chinese](charts/zh/6_economy_bars.png)
691
 
692
+ ![The Chinese dense-document trade-off](charts/zh/9_dense_tradeoff.png)
693
 
694
  ## Synthesis
695
 
charts/9_dense_tradeoff.png ADDED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: 989c2bbaccc49b9b284500d2b6d76eb27b5f9049f10b46e50fe2ee93e91fc229
  • Pointer size: 130 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 64.3 kB
charts/en/9_dense_tradeoff.png ADDED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: 242486b8b2c0dd6e5eb3d2c348432c19961bf174b30edfb2db2dfec736072cd5
  • Pointer size: 130 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 65.2 kB
charts/zh/9_dense_tradeoff.png ADDED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: dd7ed47d96b8df8448c2795988de42dc968af2ec2284eb5e080c04340cd8b20c
  • Pointer size: 130 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 65.1 kB