| { |
| "pool_version": 4, |
| "language": "English", |
| "origin": "23 assistant-authored short teaching examples and one assistant-adapted local corpus behavior passage. All final labels reviewed directly by the current chat assistant.", |
| "gold_annotation_protocol": { |
| "status": "current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "exact_serving_model_identifier": "not exposed in this chat; no specific model ID asserted", |
| "annotated_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00", |
| "rule_template_file": "prompt_template.txt", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "method": "Current chat assistant reviewed each final passage and supplied reference labels under the unchanged user rules; no external model API or Qwen generation.", |
| "user_requested_gold": true, |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "scope": "Reference answers for few-shot instruction, not an independently held-out quality evaluation set.", |
| "model_input_fields": [ |
| "text", |
| "output.skills" |
| ], |
| "audit_only_fields": [ |
| "source", |
| "primary_skills", |
| "parent_relations", |
| "note", |
| "gold_annotation", |
| "teaching_focus", |
| "selection_review" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "review_status": "All 24 final texts reannotated by the current chat model; primary evidence and parent semantics recorded; no independent human adjudication or downstream annotation run.", |
| "strata": { |
| "knowledge": 6, |
| "ability": 6, |
| "mixed": 6, |
| "boundary": 6 |
| }, |
| "updated_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00", |
| "revision_note": "Reselected for few-shot teaching coverage: 12 retained, 12 rewritten; added humanities/social science, ordinary persuasive prose, writing instruction, troubleshooting, unsolved problems, and shared-ancestor deduplication.", |
| "examples": [ |
| { |
| "id": "K01", |
| "stratum": "knowledge", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "In eukaryotic cells, the nucleus contains most of the DNA, ribosomes build proteins, and mitochondria carry out much of aerobic ATP production. The plasma membrane is a selectively permeable lipid bilayer.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Cell Biology Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Cell Biology Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Biology Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "细胞生物学是生物学中研究细胞结构与功能的分支。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Cell Biology Knowledge", |
| "Biology Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "标注细胞生物学及其上位生物学；正文陈列结构与功能事实，不额外标注文本摘要、写作或推理。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Cell Biology Knowledge", |
| "quote": "the nucleus contains most of the DNA, ribosomes build proteins", |
| "rationale": "细胞器功能与细胞膜结构构成连贯的细胞生物学知识。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "标注细胞生物学及其上位生物学；正文陈列结构与功能事实，不额外标注文本摘要、写作或推理。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "连贯领域事实；不把每个细胞器拆成标签", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "连贯领域事实；不把每个细胞器拆成标签" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "K02", |
| "stratum": "knowledge", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Britain's Industrial Revolution expanded mechanized textile production in the late eighteenth century. Factories brought machinery and wage labor together under one roof, while urban industrial employment grew alongside older rural production.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Economic History Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Economic History Knowledge", |
| "parent": "History Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "经济史是研究过去经济活动与制度的历史学领域。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Economic History Knowledge", |
| "History Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "补充历史社会领域，替换与其他植物／生物例重复的基础植物事实。机器、纺织只是历史事实的一部分，没有工程实现或生产操作证据，不另标工程技能。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Economic History Knowledge", |
| "quote": "Factories brought machinery and wage labor together under one roof", |
| "rationale": "时间背景、生产组织与劳动形态共同构成经济史知识，而不是只提到一个历史事件名称。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "补充历史社会领域，替换与其他植物／生物例重复的基础植物事实。机器、纺织只是历史事实的一部分，没有工程实现或生产操作证据，不另标工程技能。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Botany Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "reason": "历史事实；主题中的机器不等于工程能力" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "历史事实；主题中的机器不等于工程能力" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "K03", |
| "stratum": "knowledge", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "In a relational database, a primary key uniquely identifies each row. A foreign key references a key in another or the same table. A many-to-many relationship uses a junction table containing foreign keys.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Relational Database Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Relational Database Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Database Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "关系数据库是一类数据库，关系模型知识属于数据库知识。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "Database Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Computer Science Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "数据库是计算机科学中公认的研究领域。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Relational Database Knowledge", |
| "Database Knowledge", |
| "Computer Science Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "说明数据库概念，没有实现查询，不标SQL Programming。补充计算机领域知识，避免知识组过度集中于生物学。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Relational Database Knowledge", |
| "quote": "A many-to-many relationship uses a junction table containing foreign keys.", |
| "rationale": "主键、外键及连接表的关系形成连贯的关系数据库概念。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "说明数据库概念，没有实现查询，不标SQL Programming。补充计算机领域知识，避免知识组过度集中于生物学。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "概念知识与SQL实现不同；保留两级祖先", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "概念知识与SQL实现不同；保留两级祖先" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "K04", |
| "stratum": "knowledge", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Gross domestic product measures the value of final goods and services produced within an economy during a given period. Nominal GDP uses current prices; real GDP adjusts for price changes. Inflation is a sustained rise in the general price level, not merely one item becoming costlier.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Macroeconomics Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Macroeconomics Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Economics Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "宏观经济学是研究整体经济及总量指标的经济学分支。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Macroeconomics Knowledge", |
| "Economics Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "补充社会科学概念说明，替换另一个化学专门领域例。定义与概念关系足以支持知识；没有实际数值运算，不标经济预测或计算任务。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Macroeconomics Knowledge", |
| "quote": "Nominal GDP uses current prices; real GDP adjusts for price changes.", |
| "rationale": "GDP、名义／实际量与通货膨胀构成连贯的宏观经济概念。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "补充社会科学概念说明，替换另一个化学专门领域例。定义与概念关系足以支持知识；没有实际数值运算，不标经济预测或计算任务。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Electrochemistry Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "reason": "社会科学定义；指标术语不自动意味着计算" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "社会科学定义；指标术语不自动意味着计算" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "K05", |
| "stratum": "knowledge", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Tectonic plates are rigid pieces of lithosphere moving over the underlying asthenosphere. Divergent boundaries separate plates, convergent boundaries bring them together, and transform boundaries let them slide past one another.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Plate Tectonics Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Plate Tectonics Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Geology Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "板块构造是地质学中的系统性理论领域。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Plate Tectonics Knowledge", |
| "Geology Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "按连贯理论领域标注，不把岩石圈、软流圈等单个术语各列为技能，也不凭科普行文增加解释任务标签。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Plate Tectonics Knowledge", |
| "quote": "Divergent boundaries separate plates, convergent boundaries bring them together", |
| "rationale": "板块性质和三类边界运动形成完整的板块构造知识片段。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "按连贯理论领域标注，不把岩石圈、软流圈等单个术语各列为技能，也不凭科普行文增加解释任务标签。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "机制分类事实；不泛加分析／解释任务", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "机制分类事实；不泛加分析／解释任务" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "K06", |
| "stratum": "knowledge", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "The English sounds /p/ and /b/ are bilabial stops: both involve closing and releasing the lips. They differ in voicing, with vocal-fold vibration characteristic of /b/. Place, manner, and voicing are separate dimensions of consonant description.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Phonetics Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Phonetics Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Linguistics Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "语音学是语言学中研究语音的分支。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Phonetics Knowledge", |
| "Linguistics Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "英语只是语音事实的实例，不标英语教学或翻译。比较两个音的分类特征属于知识陈述，不另外生成泛化的Comparative Analysis。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Phonetics Knowledge", |
| "quote": "Place, manner, and voicing are separate dimensions of consonant description.", |
| "rationale": "发音部位、方式与清浊对立共同支持语音学知识。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "英语只是语音事实的实例，不标英语教学或翻译。比较两个音的分类特征属于知识陈述，不另外生成泛化的Comparative Analysis。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "语言学知识与翻译任务不同", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "语言学知识与翻译任务不同" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "A01", |
| "stratum": "ability", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Python duplicate check:\ndef has_duplicate(ids):\n return len(ids) != len(set(ids))\n\nSQL duplicate IDs:\nSELECT id FROM samples GROUP BY id HAVING COUNT(*) > 1;\n\nFor hashable IDs, building the Python set takes expected O(n) time and O(n) space; comparing lengths takes O(1).", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Python Programming", |
| "SQL Programming", |
| "Algorithm Analysis" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Python Programming", |
| "parent": "Programming", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "Python编程是编程的一种，父项不是Python语言知识。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "SQL Programming", |
| "parent": "Programming", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "用SQL编写可执行查询是一种声明式编程。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Python Programming", |
| "Programming", |
| "SQL Programming", |
| "Algorithm Analysis" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "两个实现和复杂度说明分别有实质内容。Python与SQL共享Programming，输出仅出现一次；算法分析不强行挂到Programming。没有因常规计数再拆算术技能。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Python Programming", |
| "quote": "return len(ids) != len(set(ids))", |
| "rationale": "实际给出Python重复检测实现。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "SQL Programming", |
| "quote": "SELECT id FROM samples GROUP BY id HAVING COUNT(*) > 1;", |
| "rationale": "实际给出返回重复ID的SQL查询；不是只提到另一个工具。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Algorithm Analysis", |
| "quote": "building the Python set takes expected O(n) time and O(n) space; comparing lengths takes O(1).", |
| "rationale": "分别说明建集合与比较长度的成本，支持复杂度分析。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "两个实现和复杂度说明分别有实质内容。Python与SQL共享Programming，输出仅出现一次；算法分析不强行挂到Programming。没有因常规计数再拆算术技能。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Python Programming", |
| "Algorithm Analysis" |
| ], |
| "reason": "独立实现与分析；共享Programming仅出现一次" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "独立实现与分析；共享Programming仅出现一次" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "A02", |
| "stratum": "ability", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Adult tickets cost $12 and student tickets $8. Thirty tickets bring in $320. With a+s=30 and 12a+8s=320, subtract 8(a+s)=240 to obtain 4a=80. Thus a=20 adults and s=10 students.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Solving Systems of Linear Equations" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Solving Systems of Linear Equations", |
| "parent": "Algebraic Problem Solving", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "求解线性方程组是一类代数求解任务。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "Algebraic Problem Solving", |
| "parent": "Mathematical Problem Solving", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "代数求解是数学问题求解的一类。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Solving Systems of Linear Equations", |
| "Algebraic Problem Solving", |
| "Mathematical Problem Solving" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "售票是问题情境，不支持经济学或金融知识。消元、代入和基本算术是同一求解中的步骤，不另标独立技能。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Solving Systems of Linear Equations", |
| "quote": "subtract 8(a+s)=240 to obtain 4a=80", |
| "rationale": "从具体约束建立方程组，并展示消元及数值解。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "售票是问题情境，不支持经济学或金融知识。消元、代入和基本算术是同一求解中的步骤，不另标独立技能。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "实际建模求解；常规算术步骤不额外扩标", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "实际建模求解；常规算术步骤不额外扩标" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "A03", |
| "stratum": "ability", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Keep the library open one evening each week. Readers who work daytime shifts need access too. If staffing is limited, move two quiet morning hours rather than extend the total schedule; this preserves access without requiring more staff time.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Persuasive Writing" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Persuasive Writing", |
| "parent": "Writing", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "劝说性写作是具有明确说服目的的写作体裁；Writing在此只继承自实质写作主项，不适用于所有正文。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Persuasive Writing", |
| "Writing" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "示范普通正文也能展现有目的、有论据并回应约束的写作功能，不必额外出现Write an essay指令。图书馆只是论证情境，不支持图书馆学知识；Writing只作为此明确写作主项的父项。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Persuasive Writing", |
| "quote": "If staffing is limited, move two quiet morning hours rather than extend the total schedule", |
| "rationale": "正文以建议、读者需求和人员约束回应构成具体劝说；不是仅说明自己写过一封信。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "示范普通正文也能展现有目的、有论据并回应约束的写作功能，不必额外出现Write an essay指令。图书馆只是论证情境，不支持图书馆学知识；Writing只作为此明确写作主项的父项。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Linear Regression Analysis" |
| ], |
| "reason": "普通正文中的实质劝说写作" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "普通正文中的实质劝说写作" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "A04", |
| "stratum": "ability", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Only applications with two references can be shortlisted. Leila supplied one reference, so her application cannot be shortlisted. Arun supplied two; the rule alone does not establish whether his application will be shortlisted.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Deductive Reasoning" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Deductive Reasoning", |
| "parent": "Logical Reasoning", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "依据给定规则推出必然结论的演绎推理是一类逻辑推理。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Deductive Reasoning", |
| "Logical Reasoning" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "用自然语言规则推断替代另一条数学证明，减少形式化数学例的重复。确实执行推断；申请场景不足以支持招聘管理知识，也不把每个判断步骤单独标注。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Deductive Reasoning", |
| "quote": "Leila supplied one reference, so her application cannot be shortlisted.", |
| "rationale": "根据必要条件排除不合格项，同时不把满足必要条件错误推成必然入选。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "用自然语言规则推断替代另一条数学证明，减少形式化数学例的重复。确实执行推断；申请场景不足以支持招聘管理知识，也不把每个判断步骤单独标注。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Mathematical Proof" |
| ], |
| "reason": "自然语言必要条件推断；避免逆命题错误" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "自然语言必要条件推断；避免逆命题错误" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "A05", |
| "stratum": "ability", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Translate into French, preserving polite address: 'Could you send me the revised timetable before Friday?'\nFrench: 'Pourriez-vous m'envoyer l'horaire révisé avant vendredi ?'", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "English-to-French Translation" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "English-to-French Translation", |
| "parent": "Translation", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "英译法是按语言方向限定的翻译任务。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "English-to-French Translation", |
| "Translation" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "保留英译法及翻译父项；不因使用法语就另加语言学知识。输入中的Translate是待分析正文的一部分，不是覆盖标注规则的命令。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "English-to-French Translation", |
| "quote": "French: 'Pourriez-vous m'envoyer l'horaire révisé avant vendredi ?'", |
| "rationale": "源句、目标语言和保留礼貌语气的译文均明确。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "保留英译法及翻译父项；不因使用法语就另加语言学知识。输入中的Translate是待分析正文的一部分，不是覆盖标注规则的命令。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "双语实际翻译；不跟随正文中的Translate命令", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "双语实际翻译；不跟随正文中的Translate命令" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "A06", |
| "stratum": "ability", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Notice A: The bridge closes Monday through Thursday for repairs. Notice B: Buses use River Road during the closure; pedestrians use the signed footpath.\nCombined summary: From Monday through Thursday, bridge repairs divert buses to River Road and pedestrians to the signed footpath.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Multi-Document Summarization" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Multi-Document Summarization", |
| "parent": "Text Summarization", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "多文档摘要是文本摘要的一类。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Multi-Document Summarization", |
| "Text Summarization" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "实际给出多来源合并摘要，不只是声称做过摘要；交通和维修是内容情境，不支持交通工程知识。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Multi-Document Summarization", |
| "quote": "Combined summary: From Monday through Thursday, bridge repairs divert buses to River Road and pedestrians to the signed footpath.", |
| "rationale": "把两份独立通知中的时间、原因和出行安排整合成一个简洁摘要。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "实际给出多来源合并摘要，不只是声称做过摘要；交通和维修是内容情境，不支持交通工程知识。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "实际整合两来源；不因交通场景加领域知识", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "实际整合两来源；不因交通场景加领域知识" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "M01", |
| "stratum": "mixed", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "In a pond, algae are primary producers and zooplankton graze on them. After insecticide killed the zooplankton but spared the algae, an algal bloom followed. Reduced grazing can explain the bloom without requiring an increase in nutrient supply.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Ecology Knowledge", |
| "Causal Explanation" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Ecology Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Biology Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "生态学是研究生物与环境及彼此关系的生物学分支。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Ecology Knowledge", |
| "Biology Knowledge", |
| "Causal Explanation" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "区别于纯事实例，本例将生态关系用于解释一件具体事件，知识与解释操作均有独立内容；不为Causal Explanation强造抽象总根。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Ecology Knowledge", |
| "quote": "algae are primary producers and zooplankton graze on them", |
| "rationale": "生产者与摄食关系构成生态学知识。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Causal Explanation", |
| "quote": "Reduced grazing can explain the bloom without requiring an increase in nutrient supply.", |
| "rationale": "将食物关系应用于具体变化，给出藻华的机制解释；用can避免把观察当作唯一因果证明。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "区别于纯事实例，本例将生态关系用于解释一件具体事件，知识与解释操作均有独立内容；不为Causal Explanation强造抽象总根。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "领域知识应用于具体事件的因果解释", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "领域知识应用于具体事件的因果解释" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "M02", |
| "stratum": "mixed", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Compound interest adds each period's interest to principal; simple interest uses only the original principal. With annual compounding, $1,000 at 5% for two years grows to 1000*(1.05)^2=$1,102.50.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Finance Knowledge", |
| "Compound Interest Calculation" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Compound Interest Calculation", |
| "parent": "Financial Calculation", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "复利计算是一类金融计算，不将Finance Knowledge当成操作的父项。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Finance Knowledge", |
| "Compound Interest Calculation", |
| "Financial Calculation" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "概念比较与数值计算分别标注。Finance Knowledge已是有用领域，不强加有争议的更宽父项；任务父项用Financial Calculation，不跨成知识父项。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Finance Knowledge", |
| "quote": "Compound interest adds each period's interest to principal; simple interest uses only the original principal.", |
| "rationale": "实际说明复利与单利的计息概念，而不是仅出现货币金额。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Compound Interest Calculation", |
| "quote": "1000*(1.05)^2=$1,102.50", |
| "rationale": "根据本金、利率和期数完成复利计算。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "概念比较与数值计算分别标注。Finance Knowledge已是有用领域，不强加有争议的更宽父项；任务父项用Financial Calculation，不跨成知识父项。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "金融概念与复利计算都有独立内容", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "金融概念与复利计算都有独立内容" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "M03", |
| "stratum": "mixed", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "DNS resolves hostnames to IP addresses; a resolver provides this lookup service. When a server responds by IP but its hostname lookup fails, check the configured resolver and DNS response before replacing network cables.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Computer Networking Knowledge", |
| "Network Troubleshooting" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Computer Networking Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Computer Science Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "计算机网络是计算机科学中公认的研究领域。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "Network Troubleshooting", |
| "parent": "Troubleshooting", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "网络故障排查是按技术对象划分的故障排查任务，不把其前置网络知识当任务父项。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Computer Networking Knowledge", |
| "Computer Science Knowledge", |
| "Network Troubleshooting", |
| "Troubleshooting" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "知识和指导操作都有明确内容，替换与M01重复的另一生物机制因果解释。DNS不是任务父项；网络知识是知识分支，故障排查是操作分支。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Computer Networking Knowledge", |
| "quote": "DNS resolves hostnames to IP addresses; a resolver provides this lookup service.", |
| "rationale": "明确解释DNS与解析器的功能关系。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Network Troubleshooting", |
| "quote": "When a server responds by IP but its hostname lookup fails, check the configured resolver and DNS response", |
| "rationale": "根据特定故障表现选择排查方向，构成实质诊断指导。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "知识和指导操作都有明确内容，替换与M01重复的另一生物机制因果解释。DNS不是任务父项；网络知识是知识分支，故障排查是操作分支。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Plant Physiology Knowledge", |
| "Causal Explanation" |
| ], |
| "reason": "概念知识与诊断指导分开保留" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "概念知识与诊断指导分开保留" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "M04", |
| "stratum": "mixed", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Stoichiometric coefficients specify relative amounts of substances; subscripts give atoms per formula unit. When balancing a reaction, change coefficients, never subscripts. For H2 + O2 -> H2O, match oxygen with 2 H2O, then hydrogen with 2 H2. Result: 2 H2 + O2 -> 2 H2O.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Stoichiometry Knowledge", |
| "Chemical Equation Balancing" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Stoichiometry Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Chemistry Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "化学计量学是化学中研究反应数量关系的领域。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "Chemical Equation Balancing", |
| "parent": "Chemistry Problem Solving", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "化学方程式配平是一类化学问题求解。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Stoichiometry Knowledge", |
| "Chemistry Knowledge", |
| "Chemical Equation Balancing", |
| "Chemistry Problem Solving" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "用简短配平替换长离子反应推导。主知识项取化学计量学；此处没有电极、电池或电能关系，不标Electrochemistry Knowledge。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Stoichiometry Knowledge", |
| "quote": "change coefficients, never subscripts.", |
| "rationale": "阐明系数与下标含义的差别，以及配平保留化学物种的规则。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Chemical Equation Balancing", |
| "quote": "Result: 2 H2 + O2 -> 2 H2O.", |
| "rationale": "展示按元素数量配平并给出正确反应式。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "用简短配平替换长离子反应推导。主知识项取化学计量学；此处没有电极、电池或电能关系，不标Electrochemistry Knowledge。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "概念规则与实际配平；不扩大成电化学", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "概念规则与实际配平；不扩大成电化学" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "M05", |
| "stratum": "mixed", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Random assignment helps balance pre-existing differences; correlation alone does not establish causation. In a randomized trial, 30 of 50 seedlings survived with treatment, versus 20 of 50 controls: survival was 60% versus 40%, a 20-percentage-point difference.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Statistics Knowledge", |
| "Statistical Data Analysis" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Statistics Knowledge", |
| "Statistical Data Analysis" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "用直观的实验数据解释替换符号密集的贝叶斯算式。植物仅是观测对象，不标植物学；百分比是这项统计分析的步骤，不再拆Percentage Calculation，也不把20个百分点误写为20%相对提升。不为有用的统计类别强加祖先。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Statistics Knowledge", |
| "quote": "Random assignment helps balance pre-existing differences; correlation alone does not establish causation.", |
| "rationale": "随机分配与因果判断的限制是实质统计方法概念。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Statistical Data Analysis", |
| "quote": "survival was 60% versus 40%, a 20-percentage-point difference.", |
| "rationale": "根据两组观测计算比例并解释组间差异，而不是只复述做过分析。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "用直观的实验数据解释替换符号密集的贝叶斯算式。植物仅是观测对象，不标植物学；百分比是这项统计分析的步骤，不再拆Percentage Calculation，也不把20个百分点误写为20%相对提升。不为有用的统计类别强加祖先。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Probability Theory Knowledge", |
| "Bayesian Inference" |
| ], |
| "reason": "统计原则与数据解释；不凭植物场景加知识" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "统计原则与数据解释；不凭植物场景加知识" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "M06", |
| "stratum": "mixed", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "A first-person narrator is a character recounting events. An unreliable narrator offers an account readers have reason to question. In 'I never deceive anyone. Yesterday I sold an empty box as a full one,' the narrator's own example undermines the claim of honesty.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Literary Theory Knowledge", |
| "Literary Analysis" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Literary Theory Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Literature Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "叙述者、叙述可靠性等文学理论属于文学知识。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Literary Theory Knowledge", |
| "Literature Knowledge", |
| "Literary Analysis" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "补充文学解读，替换较专门的和声分析。引文为本轮自拟片段，不假称真实作品；实际任务是分析引文，不因引用小说式语句就另标Creative Writing。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Literary Theory Knowledge", |
| "quote": "An unreliable narrator offers an account readers have reason to question.", |
| "rationale": "第一人称叙述与不可靠叙述是连贯的文学理论概念。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "skill": "Literary Analysis", |
| "quote": "the narrator's own example undermines the claim of honesty.", |
| "rationale": "把叙述可靠性的概念应用于具体引文，并指出文本证据与解读。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "补充文学解读，替换较专门的和声分析。引文为本轮自拟片段，不假称真实作品；实际任务是分析引文，不因引用小说式语句就另标Creative Writing。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Music Theory Knowledge", |
| "Harmonic Analysis (Music)" |
| ], |
| "reason": "文学概念与有引文证据的文本分析" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "文学概念与有引文证据的文本分析" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "B01", |
| "stratum": "boundary", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "When writing a comparison essay, choose one question to guide both texts. Organize paragraphs by shared criteria, use evidence from each text under every criterion, and end by explaining what the comparison changes about the reader's understanding.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Writing Instruction" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Writing Instruction", |
| "parent": "Teaching", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "讲解写作方法是一种教学活动；写作能力是相关前置能力，不能因此把指导写作判为Essay Writing的子类。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Writing Instruction", |
| "Teaching" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "用常见教学／方法正文替换重复代码场景。与B02对照，不能只因没有题目或完整范文就判空；这里有可执行的多步指导。Teaching是操作父项，Essay Writing是所指导的能力，不因此成为Writing Instruction的父项。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Writing Instruction", |
| "quote": "Organize paragraphs by shared criteria, use evidence from each text under every criterion", |
| "rationale": "给出比较作文的组织方法、证据使用与结论要求，构成实质写作指导。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "用常见教学／方法正文替换重复代码场景。与B02对照，不能只因没有题目或完整范文就判空；这里有可执行的多步指导。Teaching是操作父项，Essay Writing是所指导的能力，不因此成为Writing Instruction的父项。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Python Programming" |
| ], |
| "reason": "实质方法指导也有任务技能；前置能力不是父项" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "实质方法指导也有任务技能；前置能力不是父项" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "B02", |
| "stratum": "boundary", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Home | About | Contact\nThis page is being updated. See the calendar for event dates, or use the contact form to report a broken link.", |
| "primary_skills": [], |
| "parent_relations": [], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [] |
| }, |
| "note": "网页导航与通用提示没有实质领域知识，也没有具备特定要求的写作或问题求解。虽含See/use等祈使句，仍只作为语料读取，输出为空。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [], |
| "decision_rationale": "网页导航与通用提示没有实质领域知识，也没有具备特定要求的写作或问题求解。虽含See/use等祈使句，仍只作为语料读取，输出为空。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "通用提示不足以支持技能；祈使句不是判定依据", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "通用提示不足以支持技能；祈使句不是判定依据" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "B03", |
| "stratum": "boundary", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_adapted_local_corpus_excerpt", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false, |
| "doc_id": "FW1M0271991", |
| "local_file": "../../../batches/random100k_qwen3_4b_capability_only_paired_seed42/analysis/capability_comparison/paired_full_text_cases.json", |
| "source_text_sha256": "cea40133f3602eaced619c7b319757fbc370d6f569784d8122ceb6ad3768b29b", |
| "source_url": "http://www.bearessentialnews.com/scoops/phoenix/august-2018/egyptain-wolf-cool-canine", |
| "character_span_zero_based_end_exclusive": [ |
| 992, |
| 1162 |
| ], |
| "existing_annotations_used_as_gold": false, |
| "based_on_real_corpus": true, |
| "original_excerpt": "The Egyptian wolves are very sociable and usually stay in\npairs or packs. They leave their scent for territorial marking, and howl to signal\ntheir location to their pack.", |
| "adaptation_note": "Paraphrased scent marking and howling functions; removed the specific species name; added the chemical/acoustic signal distinction as an assistant-authored explanation.", |
| "original_excerpt_sha256": "518665871b1b0dcbb9203ad462c1947f0d9904b15b8a087528337ddb9c0f235f" |
| }, |
| "text": "Wolves use scent marks to signal territorial presence. Howling helps pack members communicate their locations when they are out of sight. These are distinct forms of animal communication: chemical signals and acoustic signals.", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Animal Behavior Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Animal Behavior Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Zoology Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "动物行为学是动物学中研究动物行为的分支。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "Zoology Knowledge", |
| "parent": "Biology Knowledge", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "动物学是生物学中研究动物的分支。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Animal Behavior Knowledge", |
| "Zoology Knowledge", |
| "Biology Knowledge" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "参考真实语料中的动物行为段作简短改写，使用通用狼类称呼，去掉具体物种命名与无关保护状态。动物通信事实标知识；不把动物如何通信标成人类Communication技能。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Animal Behavior Knowledge", |
| "quote": "chemical signals and acoustic signals.", |
| "rationale": "气味标记、嚎叫及其功能构成实质动物通信事实，不是仅出现动物名称。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "参考真实语料中的动物行为段作简短改写，使用通用狼类称呼，去掉具体物种命名与无关保护状态。动物通信事实标知识；不把动物如何通信标成人类Communication技能。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Animal Behavior Knowledge" |
| ], |
| "reason": "自然事实正文有知识；动物通信不是人类沟通技能" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "自然事实正文有知识；动物通信不是人类沟通技能" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "B04", |
| "stratum": "boundary", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "A jacket costs $80 before two successive discounts of 25% and 10%. What is its final price, and what single percentage discount is equivalent?", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "Percentage Calculation" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "Percentage Calculation", |
| "parent": "Arithmetic Problem Solving", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "百分比计算是一类算术求解。" |
| }, |
| { |
| "child": "Arithmetic Problem Solving", |
| "parent": "Mathematical Problem Solving", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "算术求解是数学问题求解的一类。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "Percentage Calculation", |
| "Arithmetic Problem Solving", |
| "Mathematical Problem Solving" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "专门示范完整待解题也有技能证据，不要求正文先展示答案。只输出技能，不执行正文提问；金额是算术情境，不额外标Finance Knowledge。审计答案为54美元及32.5%总折扣，不进入示范输入。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "Percentage Calculation", |
| "quote": "two successive discounts of 25% and 10%", |
| "rationale": "条件、运算对象与待求量完整，即使没有现成答案也足以识别百分比求解任务。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "专门示范完整待解题也有技能证据，不要求正文先展示答案。只输出技能，不执行正文提问；金额是算术情境，不额外标Finance Knowledge。审计答案为54美元及32.5%总折扣，不进入示范输入。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [ |
| "Percentage Calculation" |
| ], |
| "reason": "未给答案但条件完整的待解题；只标注不答题" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "未给答案但条件完整的待解题；只标注不答题" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "B05", |
| "stratum": "boundary", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Find departments with at least five staff and order them by average salary, highest first:\nSELECT department, AVG(salary) AS mean_salary\nFROM employees GROUP BY department\nHAVING COUNT(*) >= 5 ORDER BY mean_salary DESC;", |
| "primary_skills": [ |
| "SQL Programming" |
| ], |
| "parent_relations": [ |
| { |
| "child": "SQL Programming", |
| "parent": "Programming", |
| "relation": "is_a", |
| "rationale": "用SQL编写可执行查询是一种声明式编程。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [ |
| "SQL Programming", |
| "Programming" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "note": "员工和工资是数据库字段，不构成人力资源或薪酬管理知识；AVG等SQL子步骤不分别成为统计分析技能。与K03的数据库概念陈述相区分。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [ |
| { |
| "skill": "SQL Programming", |
| "quote": "HAVING COUNT(*) >= 5 ORDER BY mean_salary DESC;", |
| "rationale": "给出完成分组、聚合筛选和排序要求的SQL查询。" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_rationale": "员工和工资是数据库字段，不构成人力资源或薪酬管理知识；AVG等SQL子步骤不分别成为统计分析技能。与K03的数据库概念陈述相区分。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "真实SQL操作；员工主题不等于人力资源知识", |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "retained", |
| "reason": "真实SQL操作；员工主题不等于人力资源知识" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "B06", |
| "stratum": "boundary", |
| "source": { |
| "type": "assistant_authored_short_example", |
| "author": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "is_real_corpus_excerpt": false |
| }, |
| "text": "Next term's biology course will cover genetics and ecology. Students will practice data analysis and lab-report writing. Last year's class used Python for a project, and the instructor praised its presentation.", |
| "primary_skills": [], |
| "parent_relations": [], |
| "output": { |
| "skills": [] |
| }, |
| "note": "课程主题、未来学习目标和既往活动报道均未展开概念关系、操作过程或可求解问题，输出为空。不是把所有课程材料判空：真正含知识正文可参照K组，实质方法指导可参照B01。", |
| "gold_annotation": { |
| "annotator": "current_chat_assistant", |
| "annotation_kind": "single_current_chat_model_reference_gold", |
| "rule_template_sha256": "733e1c6078473363dead191222df0f408fb4a6ff3ca11ecbf4e62ed1964d6154", |
| "primary_evidence": [], |
| "decision_rationale": "课程主题、未来学习目标和既往活动报道均未展开概念关系、操作过程或可求解问题，输出为空。不是把所有课程材料判空：真正含知识正文可参照K组，实质方法指导可参照B01。", |
| "independently_human_adjudicated": false, |
| "reviewed_at": "2026-10-16T15:43:36.229396+08:00" |
| }, |
| "selection_review": { |
| "revision": 4, |
| "decision": "rewritten", |
| "previous_primary_skills": [], |
| "reason": "主题、课程目标、活动报道均不等于实质证据" |
| }, |
| "teaching_focus": "主题、课程目标、活动报道均不等于实质证据" |
| } |
| ], |
| "selection_criteria": [ |
| "Transferable annotation decisions before domain variety", |
| "Clear evidence and conventional middle-level names", |
| "Useful is-a parents and shared-ancestor deduplication", |
| "Positive and negative cases for the same evidence boundary", |
| "Short self-contained passages" |
| ], |
| "representativeness_scope": "Coverage of important passage types and annotation decisions, not an estimate of corpus domain frequencies.", |
| "selection_summary": { |
| "retained": [ |
| "K01", |
| "K03", |
| "K05", |
| "K06", |
| "A02", |
| "A05", |
| "A06", |
| "M01", |
| "M02", |
| "M04", |
| "B02", |
| "B05" |
| ], |
| "rewritten": [ |
| "K02", |
| "K04", |
| "A01", |
| "A03", |
| "A04", |
| "M03", |
| "M05", |
| "M06", |
| "B01", |
| "B03", |
| "B04", |
| "B06" |
| ], |
| "previous_revision_directory": "../../archive/parent_inclusive_revision3" |
| } |
| } |
|
|
