File size: 1,272 Bytes
929e74d
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Constrained optimal control on the pendulum (held-out N=40, tracking spec ISE ≤ 0.8× prior)

PRIOR (spec-unaware): median ISE = 0.0333, median ∫u² = 6.730  (ISE = 1.0× ⇒ violates the 0.8× spec)
STEERED toward  min ∫u²  s.t. ISE ≤ 0.8× prior  (barrier λ=200.0):
  meets spec: 0.95   median ISE = 0.0272   median ∫u² = 7.247   certified 1.00
  energy used vs prior (the cost of the tighter spec): +8%
  ENERGY REGRET vs per-plant constrained oracle: median +0.1% (n=38)

energy-vs-spec constrained-optimal frontier (steered):
  ρ     median ISE_max   median ∫u² (meeting spec)   meets   certified
  0.70   0.0233          4.988                  0.50     0.88
  0.80   0.0266          6.786                  0.95     1.00
  0.90   0.0299          6.924                  1.00     1.00
  1.00   0.0333          6.708                  1.00     1.00

INTERPRETATION: a non-quadratic, hard-CONSTRAINED optimal-control problem solved through
the differentiable non-linear pendulum — minimise control energy subject to a tracking
spec. The spec-unaware prior violates the tighter spec; steering meets it at the minimum
energy (near the per-plant constrained optimum), staying certified; a tighter spec costs
more energy (the constrained-optimal frontier).