A Pfaffian Proof and Generalization of a Conjecture of Sun Zhiwei

Let p be an odd prime, let n=(p-1)/2, and let χ=(cdot{p}), with χ(0)=0. For ainmathbb F_p^times define \[ D_a(x)=\det_{1\le i,j\le n}(x+χ(i^2-aj)), \qquad D_a^{(0)}(x)=\det_{0\le i,j\le n}(x+χ(i^2-aj)). \] We prove \[ D_a(0)=0 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad p\equiv 3 \pmod 4 \quadand\quad χ(a n!)=1. \] For pequiv3pmod4 we also give explicit Pfaffian-square factorizations of D_a(x) and D_a^{(0)}(x). Let s_p=(-1)^{lfloor(p+1)/8rfloor}. If χ(a n!)=1, then s_pD_a(x)/x=s_pD_a^{(0)}(x) is a positive integer square. If χ(a n!)=-1, then there is a positive integer σ such that \[ s_pD_a(x)=σ^2(nx-1),\qquad s_pD_a^{(0)}(x)=-σ^2\bigl(n+(2n+1)x\bigr). \] The case a=n! settles Sun's Conjecture 4.1.