FatUnc6969's picture
Publish reviewed Borderland v8 research artifact
2719bf4 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
22.8 kB
import json
import random
import sys
from collections import Counter
from pathlib import Path
from .context import actor_transition, wire
from .causal_dependencies import CausalDependencyAudit
from .dependencies import DEPENDENCIES, DependencyAudit, checkpoint_policy_response
from .manifests import digest, manifests, source_hash
COSTS = {"pulse": 2, "scan": 2, "turn_rotor": 2, "compare_seal": 2,
"bind_docket": 2, "challenge": 2, "support": 2, "cross_check": 2,
"test_checkpoint": 2, "escort": 2, "connect": 2, "energize": 2, "open_valve": 4}
PRIORITY = {"launch": 0, "leave_maze": 1, "end_osmosis": 1, "restore": 1,
"collect": 2, "lock_chamber": 3, "bank": 3, "energize": 3,
"board": 3, "arm_exit": 3, "bind_docket": 4, "escort": 4,
"install": 4, "observe_sensor": 5, "cross_check": 5, "challenge": 5,
"walk": 6, "deploy": 6, "interview": 6, "align_track": 6,
"open_valve": 7, "pulse": 7, "connect": 7, "open_scroll": 7,
"visit": 8, "set_latch": 8, "scan": 9, "rest": 9}
class PublicBaseline:
def __init__(self, kind, seed=0):
self.kind = kind
self.rng = random.Random(seed)
self.rule_stage = 0
self.learned_bit = None
def choose(self, transition):
public = wire(transition)
actions = public["legal_actions"]
if not actions:
raise ValueError("no_legal_actions")
if self.kind == "random":
return self.rng.choice(actions)
ordered = sorted(actions, key=lambda action: json.dumps(action, sort_keys=True))
if self.kind == "heuristic":
board = public["observation"]["board"]
phase = public["observation"]["phase"]
if phase == 1:
if board.get("live_sensor") is not None:
self.learned_bit = board["live_sensor"] ^ (board["latch"] & 1)
sequence = [("set_latch", {"value": 0}), ("pulse", {"fixture": "sensor"}),
("observe_sensor", {}), ("set_latch", {"value": 2 + (self.learned_bit or 0)}),
("pulse", {"fixture": "relay"}), ("pulse", {"fixture": "gate"}), ("lock_chamber", {})]
tag, arguments = sequence[min(self.rule_stage, len(sequence) - 1)]
self.rule_stage += 1
return {"tag": tag, "arguments": arguments}
if phase == 2:
for tag in ("leave_maze", "collect", "scan"):
matching = [action for action in ordered if action["tag"] == tag]
if matching and (tag != "scan" or not board.get("scanned")):
return matching[0]
for direction in ("south", "east", "north", "west"):
matching = [action for action in ordered if action["tag"] == "walk" and action["arguments"]["direction"] == direction]
if matching:
return matching[0]
if self.kind == "memoryless":
return ordered[0]
if self.kind == "cheapest_legal":
return min(ordered, key=lambda action: COSTS.get(action["tag"], 1))
if self.kind == "always_scan":
scans = [action for action in ordered if action["tag"] in {"scan", "observe_sensor"}]
return scans[0] if scans else ordered[0]
return min(ordered, key=lambda action: PRIORITY.get(action["tag"], 10))
class EvidenceAudit:
def __init__(self):
self.records = {}
self.events = []
@staticmethod
def contains(text, value, field=None):
try:
parsed = json.loads(text)
except (ValueError, TypeError):
return isinstance(value, (dict, list, str)) and str(value) in text
def search(candidate):
if field is None and candidate == value:
return True
if isinstance(candidate, dict):
if field is not None and field in candidate and candidate[field] == value:
return True
return any(search(item) for item in candidate.values())
if isinstance(candidate, list):
return any(search(item) for item in candidate)
return False
return search(parsed)
def observe(self, transition, step, context=None):
public = wire(transition)
observation = public["observation"]
board = observation["board"]
notebook = observation["notebook"]["text"]
evidence = [(field,board.get(field)) for field in ("live_sensor", "current_record", "current_claim", "record", "claim")]
evidence.extend(("record_revision",record) for record in board.get("records",[]))
for field,value in evidence:
if value is None:
continue
encoded = json.dumps(value, sort_keys=True)
key = field + ":" + encoded
if key not in self.records:
self.records[key] = {"field": field, "value": value, "exposed_step": step}
self.events.append({"category": "evidence_exposed", "step": step, "field": field})
if isinstance(value, dict) and value.get("supersedes"):
self.events.append({"category": "superseding_record_exposed", "step": step,
"record": value.get("id"), "supersedes": value["supersedes"]})
def revisions(text):
try: pending=[json.loads(text)]
except (ValueError,TypeError): return set()
found=set()
while pending:
value=pending.pop()
if isinstance(value,dict):
if isinstance(value.get('id'),str) and type(value.get('issued_at')) is int:
found.add(json.dumps(value,sort_keys=True))
pending.extend(value.values())
elif isinstance(value,list): pending.extend(value)
return found
notebook_revisions=revisions(notebook)
selected_revisions=set()
if context is not None:
for message in context:
if message['role']!='system': selected_revisions.update(revisions(message.get('content') or ''))
for record in self.records.values():
record["last_checked_step"] = step
if record['field']=='record_revision':
encoded=json.dumps(record['value'],sort_keys=True)
record['value_present_in_notebook']=encoded in notebook_revisions
if context is not None: record['value_present_in_selected_context']=encoded in selected_revisions
continue
scalar_field = record["field"] if not isinstance(record["value"], (dict, list)) else None
record["value_present_in_notebook"] = self.contains(notebook, record["value"], scalar_field)
if context is not None:
record["value_present_in_selected_context"] = any(
self.contains(message.get("content") or "", record["value"], scalar_field)
for message in context if message["role"] != "system")
if public.get("error"):
self.events.append({"category": "engine_action_rejected", "step": step,
"error": public["error"]})
if public.get("context_reset"):
self.events.append({"category": "context_reset", "step": step,
"notebook_chars": len(notebook)})
def run_episode(seed, policy=None, max_steps=256, output_path=None, *, generation_version=2,
archive_workload="standard", notebook_bytes=768, memory_profile="static", policy_factory=None):
from borderland import Campaign
from borderland_verify.reference import public_reference
campaign = Campaign.generated(seed, generation_version=generation_version, archive_workload=archive_workload,
notebook_bytes=notebook_bytes, memory_profile=memory_profile)
transition = campaign.reset()
if policy is None:
policy = public_reference(actor_transition(transition))
if policy_factory is None:
if isinstance(policy, PublicBaseline):
policy_factory = lambda: PublicBaseline(policy.kind, seed ^ 0xBA5E)
else:
policy_factory = type(policy)
audit = EvidenceAudit()
dependencies = (CausalDependencyAudit if generation_version == 3 else DependencyAudit)(campaign._world)
trace = []
category = "engine_terminal"
steps = 0
decisions = 0
controller_resets = 0
for steps in range(max_steps):
audit.observe(transition, steps)
dependencies.observe(transition, steps)
if transition.done:
break
try:
if hasattr(policy, "notebook"):
note = policy.notebook(actor_transition(transition))
if note is not None and note != wire(transition)["observation"]["notebook"]["text"]:
transition = campaign.replace_notebook(note)
dependencies.observe(transition, steps)
decisions += 1
action = policy.choose(actor_transition(transition))
before = transition
transition = campaign.step(action)
dependencies.record_decision(before, action, transition, steps)
trace.append({"action": wire(action), "transition": wire(transition)})
if generation_version == 3 and transition.context_reset:
policy = policy_factory()
controller_resets += 1
except Exception as error:
category = "policy_" + type(error).__name__
break
else:
category = "evaluator_step_budget"
if transition.done and category == "engine_terminal":
category = "engine_" + str(transition.outcome)
dependencies.observe(transition, decisions)
if output_path:
campaign.save_replay(output_path, visibility="public")
return {"seed": seed, "outcome": transition.outcome, "verified_escape": transition.outcome == "escaped",
"generation_version": generation_version, "archive_workload": archive_workload,
"memory_profile": memory_profile, "notebook_bytes": notebook_bytes,
"controller_resets": controller_resets,
"boarded_teammates": list(transition.observation.board.get("boarded", [])),
"accepted_actions": sum(row["transition"].get("error") is None for row in trace),
"allocated_decisions": decisions, "gameplay_reward": sum(row["transition"]["reward"] for row in trace),
"charge": wire(transition)["observation"]["charge"], "termination_category": category,
"simulator_truncated": transition.truncated, "evaluator_truncated": not transition.done,
"evidence": list(audit.records.values()), "diagnostics": audit.events,
"dependency_metrics": dependencies.report(), "trace": trace}
def run_suite(seeds, output_dir=None, *, split_manifests=None, generation_version=2,
archive_workload="standard", notebook_bytes=768, memory_profile="static"):
from borderland_verify.certificates import certify_twins
from borderland_verify.reference import run_privileged_reference
from borderland.worlds import causal_candidate
if type(generation_version) is not int or generation_version not in (2, 3):
raise ValueError("generation_version must be 2 or 3")
if archive_workload not in ("compact", "standard", "extended"):
raise ValueError("archive_workload must be compact, standard, or extended")
if type(notebook_bytes) is not int or notebook_bytes < 0:
raise ValueError("notebook_bytes must be a nonnegative integer")
if memory_profile not in ("static", "commissioning"):
raise ValueError("memory_profile must be static or commissioning")
if generation_version == 2 and notebook_bytes != 768:
raise ValueError("custom byte capacity requires generation three")
if generation_version == 2 and memory_profile != "static":
raise ValueError("commissioning requires generation three")
seeds = list(seeds)
output = Path(output_dir) if output_dir else None
if output:
output.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
frozen = manifests(generation_version) if split_manifests is None else split_manifests
if any(value["generation_version"] != generation_version for value in frozen.values()):
raise ValueError("split manifest generation mismatch")
configuration = dict(generation_version=generation_version, archive_workload=archive_workload,
notebook_bytes=notebook_bytes, memory_profile=memory_profile)
unit_count = (len(CausalDependencyAudit(causal_candidate(seeds[0], archive_workload=archive_workload,
notebook_bytes=notebook_bytes, memory_profile=memory_profile)).units)
if generation_version == 3 and seeds else len(DEPENDENCIES))
policies = []
failures = []
reference_name = "public_reference" if generation_version == 3 else "legal_history"
for kind in (reference_name, "memoryless", "heuristic", "random", "cheapest_legal", "always_scan"):
rows = []
for seed in seeds:
policy = None if kind == reference_name else PublicBaseline(kind, seed ^ 0xBA5E)
try:
path = output / f"{kind}-{seed}-replay.json" if output else None
row = run_episode(seed, policy, output_path=path, **configuration)
if not row["verified_escape"]:
failures.append({"policy": kind, "seed": seed, "category": row["termination_category"],
"outcome": row["outcome"]})
except Exception as error:
row = {"seed": seed, "verified_escape": False, "outcome": "not_started",
"termination_category": "generation_or_runner_" + type(error).__name__}
failures.append({"policy": kind, **row})
rows.append(row)
dependency_reports = [row["dependency_metrics"] for row in rows if "dependency_metrics" in row]
denominator = len(rows) * unit_count
matched = sum(report["dependencies_matched"] for report in dependency_reports)
opportunities = sum(report["opportunities"] for report in dependency_reports)
successful_opportunities = sum(report["dependencies_matched"] if generation_version == 3
else report["successful_opportunities"] for report in dependency_reports)
qualities = [report["notebook_quality"]["latest"] for report in dependency_reports
if report["notebook_quality"]["latest"] is not None]
scored_qualities = [quality for quality in qualities if quality["scorable"]]
discovered = sum(len(quality["supported_fields"]) if generation_version == 3
else quality["discovered_denominator"] for quality in scored_qualities)
retained = sum(len(quality["retained_correct"]) if generation_version == 3
else quality["retained_count"] for quality in scored_qualities)
policies.append({"name": kind, "student_type": "scripted non-LLM baseline", "episodes": rows,
"scope": ("Literal lexicographic current-view baseline; no memoryless ceiling or optimality claim."
if kind == "memoryless" else "Uniform random legal action baseline."
if kind == "random" else "Scripted public-observation controller; not an optimality bound."),
"denominator": len(seeds), "escapes": sum(row["verified_escape"] for row in rows),
"escape_rate": sum(row["verified_escape"] for row in rows) / len(rows) if rows else None,
"dependency_metrics": {"metric_kind": "preaction_fixed_unit_agreement" if generation_version == 3 else "action_state_agreement",
"causal_reliance": "not_identified",
"predefined_denominator": denominator,
"dependencies_matched": matched,
"dependency_agreement_rate": matched / denominator if denominator else None,
"opportunities": opportunities,
("first_choices_correct" if generation_version == 3 else "successful_opportunities"): successful_opportunities,
"opportunity_correctness": successful_opportunities / opportunities if opportunities else None,
**({"eligible_units": opportunities,
"eligible_reach": opportunities / denominator if denominator else None,
"completed_units": sum(report["completed_units"] for report in dependency_reports)}
if generation_version == 3 else {}),
"audit_unavailable_episodes": len(rows) - len(dependency_reports)},
"notebook_quality": {"scorable_episodes": len(scored_qualities),
"unscorable_episodes": len(qualities) - len(scored_qualities),
"audit_unavailable_episodes": len(rows) - len(qualities),
("supported_field_denominator_scored" if generation_version == 3 else "discovered_fact_denominator_scored"): discovered,
("retained_correct_fields" if generation_version == 3 else "retained_facts"): retained,
("information_coverage" if generation_version == 3 else "retention_rate"): retained / discovered if discovered else None},
"categories": dict(Counter(row["termination_category"] for row in rows))})
certificates = []
for seed in seeds if generation_version == 2 else ():
try:
certificates.append(certify_twins(seed))
except Exception as error:
certificates.append({"pass": False, "failures": ["certificate_" + type(error).__name__]})
privileged = []
for seed in seeds if generation_version == 2 else ():
try:
privileged.append({"seed": seed, **run_privileged_reference(seed)})
except Exception as error:
privileged.append({"seed": seed, "outcome": "not_started", "failure": type(error).__name__})
split_names = [name for name, manifest in frozen.items() if set(seeds).issubset(manifest["root_seeds"])]
checkpoint_behavior = {
kind: [checkpoint_policy_response(certificate, lambda kind=kind: PublicBaseline(kind))
for certificate in certificates]
for kind in (("memoryless", "heuristic", "random", "cheapest_legal", "always_scan")
if generation_version == 2 else ())}
reference_pass = bool(seeds) and policies[0]["escapes"] == len(seeds)
result = {"core_pass": (reference_pass and all(certificate.get("pass", False) for certificate in certificates))
if generation_version == 2 else None,
"configuration": configuration, "public_reference_pass": reference_pass,
"policies": policies, "certificates": certificates, "failures": failures,
"certificate_status": "measured" if generation_version == 2 else "unsupported_current_generation",
"matched_checkpoint_behavior": checkpoint_behavior,
"matched_checkpoint_status": "measured" if generation_version == 2 else "unsupported_current_generation",
"privileged_reference": {"status": "measured" if generation_version == 2 else "unsupported_current_generation", "episodes": privileged,
"escapes": sum(row["outcome"] == "escaped" for row in privileged),
"denominator": len(privileged),
"scope": ("Perfect-information diagnostic; does not establish fair solvability or optimality."
if generation_version == 2 else "The historical generation-two oracle and twin certificate are not run for generation three. No current oracle bound is available.")},
"comparison": {row["name"]: {"escape_rate": row["escape_rate"],
("escape_gap_to_public_reference" if generation_version == 3 else "escape_gap_to_legal_history"): policies[0]["escape_rate"] - row["escape_rate"] if seeds else None}
for row in policies},
"manifests": frozen, "manifest_hashes": {key: digest(value) for key, value in frozen.items()},
"receipt": {"source_hash": source_hash(), "python": sys.version, "seeds": list(seeds),
"unique_twin_root_groups": len({seed // 2 for seed in seeds}),
"configuration_hash": digest({"max_steps": 256, "policies": [row["name"] for row in policies],
**(configuration if generation_version == 3 else {})}),
"evaluation_split": split_names[0] if len(split_names) == 1 else "ad_hoc"},
"limitations": (["Frozen manifests hold out raid opponents and guard rotation 3; ad hoc seeds are separately declared in the receipt.",
"Full-campaign memoryless results allow physical memory side channels."]
if generation_version == 2 else
["Generation-three manifests are disjoint root fixtures. They do not hold out opponent families or prove held-out transfer.",
"Memoryless selects the literal first lexicographic legal action. Random selects uniformly. Neither is a memoryless ceiling or an oracle.",
"Current-view policies can read physical state. Failure of these literal policies does not bound stronger physical-memory strategies."])
+ ["Paired seeds share nuisance structure; episode counts are not independent family counts.",
"Evidence diagnostics describe observations, not model mental states."]}
if output:
(output / "evaluation.json").write_text(json.dumps(result, indent=2))
return result