Donne120
best move
f4cfd3f
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
20.4 kB
import re
import sympy
from sympy import symbols, solve, simplify, expand, factor, integrate, diff
from typing import Dict, Any, List, Tuple
def is_math_question(question: str) -> bool:
"""
Determine if a question is likely a math problem.
Args:
question: The user's question
Returns:
True if it appears to be a math question
"""
# Convert to lowercase for case-insensitive matching
question_lower = question.lower()
# IMPORTANT: Check for numbers and math operators first
# This prevents non-math questions from being misidentified
has_math_elements = bool(re.search(r'[0-9+\-*/^=()]', question_lower))
if not has_math_elements:
return False
# Keywords often found in math questions
math_keywords = [
"solve", "calculate", "evaluate", "find", "compute", "derive", "simplify",
"factor", "expand", "integrate", "differentiate", "equation", "expression",
"polynomial", "function", "graph", "plot", "value", "=", "+", "-", "*", "/",
"sqrt", "square", "cube", "sum", "difference", "product", "quotient", "remainder"
]
# Check for math keywords (with the added security that we already have math symbols)
for keyword in math_keywords:
if keyword in question_lower:
return True
# If we have math symbols but no specific keywords, do a more thorough check
# for mathematical patterns
math_patterns = [
r"\d+\s*[\+\-\*\/\^\=]\s*\d+", # Basic operations: 3 + 4, 5*6
r"[xyz]\s*[\+\-\*\/\^\=]\s*\d+", # Variables with operations: x + 5
r"\d+\s*[\+\-\*\/\^\=]\s*[xyz]", # Operations with variables: 5 + x
r"solve\s+for\s+[xyz]", # "Solve for x"
r"find\s+[xyz]", # "Find x"
]
for pattern in math_patterns:
if re.search(pattern, question_lower):
return True
# Default: if we have numbers and operators but no specific patterns,
# assume it might be a math question
return has_math_elements and ("+" in question_lower or "-" in question_lower or
"*" in question_lower or "/" in question_lower or
"=" in question_lower)
def extract_math_expression(question: str) -> str:
"""
Extract the mathematical expression from a text question.
Fixed to correctly handle expressions like "2x+4=0 find x"
"""
# Clean up the question and remove extra whitespace
question = ' '.join(question.strip().split())
# First check for equations with equals sign
has_equals = '=' in question
if has_equals:
# Extract the part of the string containing the equation
# This regex stops at common keywords that would follow an equation
equation_pattern = r'([^=]+=.+?)(?:\s+(?:find|solve|for|where|when)\b|$)'
equation_match = re.search(equation_pattern, question)
if equation_match:
return equation_match.group(1).strip()
# If no equation was found or extracted, try other methods
cleaned_question = question
# Check for common instruction formats and strip them
instruction_patterns = [
r"^(find|solve|calculate|evaluate|compute)[\s\w]+:",
r"^(find|solve|calculate|evaluate|compute)[\s\w]+when",
r"^(find|solve|calculate|evaluate|compute)[\s\w]+if",
r"^(find|solve|calculate|evaluate|compute)[\s\w]+for[\s\w]+in",
]
for pattern in instruction_patterns:
match = re.match(pattern, question.lower())
if match:
cleaned_question = question[match.end():].strip()
break
# Look for common words that indicate the end of a math expression
end_markers = ['find', 'solve', 'for', 'where', 'when']
for marker in end_markers:
marker_pattern = rf'\s+{marker}\s+'
if re.search(marker_pattern, cleaned_question.lower()):
# Split at the marker and take the part before it
parts = re.split(marker_pattern, cleaned_question.lower(), 1)
cleaned_question = parts[0].strip()
break
# Additional check for end markers without spaces
if has_equals: # Only apply this logic if we know there's an equals sign
for marker in end_markers:
if marker in cleaned_question.lower():
# Find the position where the marker starts
marker_pos = cleaned_question.lower().find(marker)
# Only process if marker is not at the start
if marker_pos > 0:
# Check what's before the marker
if cleaned_question[marker_pos-1] in " =+-*/^()0123456789":
# This looks like a marker following an equation
cleaned_question = cleaned_question[:marker_pos].strip()
break
# Look for equations in the cleaned question
equation_pattern = r'([0-9a-zA-Z\+\-\*\/\^\(\)\s=\.]+\=[0-9a-zA-Z\+\-\*\/\^\(\)\s\.]+)'
equation_match = re.search(equation_pattern, cleaned_question)
if equation_match:
return equation_match.group(1).strip()
# If no equation found, look for any mathematical expression
expression_pattern = r'([0-9a-zA-Z\+\-\*\/\^\(\)\s\.]+)'
expr_match = re.search(expression_pattern, cleaned_question)
if expr_match:
return expr_match.group(1).strip()
# If all else fails, return the cleaned question
return cleaned_question
def preprocess_expression(expr_str: str) -> str:
"""
Preprocess the expression to make it compatible with sympy.
"""
if not expr_str:
return expr_str
# Replace ^ with ** for exponentiation
expr_str = expr_str.replace('^', '**')
# Handle implicit multiplication cases
# 2x → 2*x (number followed by variable)
expr_str = re.sub(r'(\d)([a-zA-Z])', r'\1*\2', expr_str)
# Handle coefficient next to parentheses: 2(x+1) → 2*(x+1)
expr_str = re.sub(r'(\d)(\()', r'\1*\2', expr_str)
# Handle closing then opening parentheses: (x+1)(x+2) → (x+1)*(x+2)
expr_str = re.sub(r'(\))(\()', r'\1*\2', expr_str)
# Handle variable next to parentheses: x(y+1) → x*(y+1)
expr_str = re.sub(r'([a-zA-Z])(\()', r'\1*\2', expr_str)
# Remove any extra spaces to avoid parsing issues
expr_str = expr_str.replace(' ', '')
return expr_str
def extract_variable_to_solve(question: str) -> str:
"""
Extract which variable to solve for from the question.
Returns the variable or empty string if none found.
"""
# Common patterns for indicating variables to solve
patterns = [
r"solve\s+for\s+([a-zA-Z])",
r"find\s+([a-zA-Z])",
r"calculate\s+([a-zA-Z])",
r"determine\s+([a-zA-Z])"
]
question_lower = question.lower()
for pattern in patterns:
match = re.search(pattern, question_lower)
if match:
return match.group(1)
# Default to 'x' if no specific variable mentioned
return 'x'
def generate_solving_steps(math_expr: str, var, solutions) -> List[str]:
"""
Generate detailed step-by-step explanations for solving an equation.
Args:
math_expr: The original mathematical expression
var: The variable being solved for
solutions: The solutions found
Returns:
List of steps as strings
"""
steps = []
# Add initial step showing the equation
steps.append(f"Starting with the equation: {math_expr}")
# Generate detailed algebraic steps
if '=' in math_expr:
left, right = math_expr.split('=', 1)
left = left.strip()
right = right.strip()
# Step 1: Move all terms to one side
steps.append(f"Step 1: Rearrange to get all terms on the left side")
steps.append(f"{left} - ({right}) = 0")
try:
# Try to simplify and show the standard form
left_expr = sympy.sympify(preprocess_expression(left))
right_expr = sympy.sympify(preprocess_expression(right))
standard_form = left_expr - right_expr
if var in str(standard_form):
# Only show if it's actually different from the previous step
if str(standard_form) != f"{left} - ({right})":
steps.append(f"Step 2: Simplify the equation")
steps.append(f"{standard_form} = 0")
# Step 3: Isolate the variable
steps.append(f"Step 3: Isolate the variable {var}")
# Handle linear equations in a special way for better explanations
if str(var) in str(standard_form) and "**" not in str(standard_form) and "/" + str(var) not in str(standard_form):
# It's likely a linear equation, extract the coefficient
try:
# Get coefficient of x
coef = sympy.Poly(standard_form, sympy.Symbol(str(var))).all_coeffs()[0]
constant = -sympy.Poly(standard_form, sympy.Symbol(str(var))).all_coeffs()[1]
# Show steps for linear equation
steps.append(f"{coef}*{var} = {constant}")
steps.append(f"{var} = {constant}/{coef}")
# Simplify the result if possible
simplified = sympy.simplify(constant / coef)
if simplified != constant / coef:
steps.append(f"{var} = {simplified}")
except:
# If the specific approach fails, use a generic message
steps.append(f"Solving for {var}...")
else:
# For non-linear equations, be more generic
steps.append(f"Solving the equation for {var}...")
except Exception as e:
# If symbolic processing fails, fall back to generic steps
steps.append(f"Step 2: Solve for {var}")
else:
# For expressions without equals sign
steps.append(f"Setting the expression equal to zero: {math_expr} = 0")
steps.append(f"Solving for {var}...")
# Add final solutions with verification
if len(solutions) == 1:
steps.append(f"Solution: {var} = {solutions[0]}")
# Add verification step
try:
# Verify by substituting back into the original equation
if '=' in math_expr:
left, right = math_expr.split('=', 1)
left_expr = sympy.sympify(preprocess_expression(left))
right_expr = sympy.sympify(preprocess_expression(right))
# Substitute the solution
left_result = left_expr.subs(sympy.Symbol(str(var)), solutions[0])
right_result = right_expr.subs(sympy.Symbol(str(var)), solutions[0])
steps.append(f"Verification: Substitute {var} = {solutions[0]} back into the equation")
steps.append(f"Left side: {left} = {left_result}")
steps.append(f"Right side: {right} = {right_result}")
steps.append(f"Since {left_result} = {right_result}, the solution is correct.")
except:
pass # Skip verification if it fails
elif len(solutions) > 1:
steps.append(f"Multiple solutions found:")
for i, sol in enumerate(solutions, 1):
steps.append(f"Solution {i}: {var} = {sol}")
else:
steps.append("No solutions found.")
return steps
def solve_math_problem(question: str) -> Tuple[str, List[str]]:
"""
Solve a math problem using symbolic computation.
Args:
question: The math question
Returns:
Tuple of (answer, steps)
"""
# Clean up the question
question = question.strip()
try:
# Extract the actual equation or expression
math_expr = extract_math_expression(question)
print(f"Original question: '{question}'")
print(f"Extracted expression: '{math_expr}'")
# Add safety check
if not math_expr or "find" in math_expr.lower() or "solve" in math_expr.lower():
# Failed to extract properly
print("Warning: Extraction may not have been clean")
# Preprocess the expression (replace ^ with **, handle implicit multiplication)
processed_expr = preprocess_expression(math_expr)
print(f"Processed expression: '{processed_expr}'")
# Safety check for invalid expressions
if "find" in processed_expr.lower() or "solve" in processed_expr.lower():
processed_expr = re.sub(r'(find|solve)[a-zA-Z]*', '', processed_expr, flags=re.IGNORECASE)
print(f"Fixed processed expression: '{processed_expr}'")
# If it's an equation (contains =), solve it
if '=' in processed_expr:
left, right = processed_expr.split('=', 1)
left = sympy.sympify(left.strip())
right = sympy.sympify(right.strip())
# Move all terms to left side
equation = left - right
# Get the variables
variables = list(equation.free_symbols)
if not variables:
return "No variables found to solve for.", []
# Solve for the first variable (usually x)
var = variables[0]
solutions = sympy.solve(equation, var)
# Format the solution
if solutions:
result = f"{var} = {', '.join(map(str, solutions))}"
# Generate steps
steps = generate_solving_steps(math_expr, var, solutions)
return result, steps
else:
return "No solutions found. The equation may be inconsistent.", []
else:
# Check for variables to determine if we need to solve something
try:
expr = sympy.sympify(processed_expr)
variables = list(expr.free_symbols)
if variables:
# There are variables but no '=' sign - assume it's set to 0
var = variables[0] # Usually solve for x
equation = expr
solutions = sympy.solve(equation, var)
if solutions:
result = f"{var} = {', '.join(map(str, solutions))}"
steps = [
f"Interpreting the expression as an equation: {math_expr} = 0",
f"Solving for {var}: {var} = {', '.join(map(str, solutions))}"
]
return result, steps
else:
return "No solutions found when setting the expression to zero.", []
else:
# Just evaluate the expression - no variables
result = sympy.N(expr)
steps = [f"Evaluating expression: {math_expr}", f"Result: {result}"]
return f"Result: {result}", steps
except Exception as e:
print(f"Error in expression evaluation: {str(e)}")
return f"Error evaluating expression: {str(e)}", [f"Failed to process: {processed_expr}", f"Error: {str(e)}"]
except Exception as e:
print(f"Math solver error: {str(e)}")
return f"Error solving math problem: {str(e)}", [f"Failed to parse: {math_expr}", f"Error details: {str(e)}"]
def debug_math_solver(question: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Debug function to help diagnose issues with the math solver.
Returns detailed information about the parsing and solving process.
"""
result = {
"original_question": question,
"is_math_question": is_math_question(question),
"extracted_expression": extract_math_expression(question),
"variable_to_solve": extract_variable_to_solve(question),
}
try:
# Process the expression
result["processed_expression"] = preprocess_expression(result["extracted_expression"])
# Try to parse with sympy
if '=' in result["processed_expression"]:
left, right = result["processed_expression"].split('=', 1)
result["parsed_left"] = str(sympy.sympify(left))
result["parsed_right"] = str(sympy.sympify(right))
result["equation"] = str(sympy.sympify(left) - sympy.sympify(right))
else:
result["parsed_expression"] = str(sympy.sympify(result["processed_expression"]))
# Get full solution
answer, steps = solve_math_problem(question)
result["answer"] = answer
result["steps"] = steps
result["success"] = True
except Exception as e:
result["error"] = str(e)
result["success"] = False
return result
# Test cases function to verify the solver works properly
def run_test_cases():
"""Run a series of test cases to verify the math solver works correctly."""
test_cases = [
"2x+4=0 find x",
"solve for x: 3x - 6 = 0",
"what is 2 + 2?",
"find the value of x if 5x + 10 = 25",
"solve the equation 3y - 9 = 0",
"x^2 - 4 = 0",
"find the roots of x^2 - 5x + 6 = 0"
]
results = []
for case in test_cases:
answer, steps = solve_math_problem(case)
results.append({
"question": case,
"answer": answer,
"steps": steps
})
return results
# Add this function to your math_solver.py file
def format_math_solution(answer: str, steps: List[str]) -> str:
"""
Format the math solution in a clean, readable way with proper spacing and layout.
Args:
answer: The final answer string
steps: List of solution steps
Returns:
Properly formatted markdown string for display
"""
# Format the main answer with bold styling and clear separation
formatted_solution = f"### {answer}\n\n"
# Add a heading for the solution steps
formatted_solution += "**Solution Steps:**\n\n"
# Format each step with proper spacing and numbering where appropriate
step_number = 1
for step in steps:
# Skip the initial repeat of the question
if step.startswith("Starting with"):
formatted_solution += f"1️⃣ {step}\n\n"
step_number = 2
# Format verification section specially
elif step.startswith("Verification"):
formatted_solution += f"\n**Verification:**\n"
formatted_solution += f"- {step.replace('Verification: ', '')}\n"
# Format left side/right side specially for alignment
elif step.startswith("Left side:"):
formatted_solution += f"- {step}\n"
elif step.startswith("Right side:"):
formatted_solution += f"- {step}\n"
elif step.startswith("Since"):
formatted_solution += f"- {step}\n\n"
# Format regular solution steps
elif step.startswith("Step"):
formatted_solution += f"{step_number}️⃣ {step.replace('Step ' + str(step_number-1) + ':', '')}\n\n"
step_number += 1
# Handle special cases for multiple solutions
elif step.startswith("Multiple solutions found"):
formatted_solution += f"\n**{step}**\n\n"
elif step.startswith("Solution "):
formatted_solution += f"- {step}\n"
# Format any mathematical expressions specially
elif "=" in step and not step.startswith("Result"):
formatted_solution += f"```\n{step}\n```\n\n"
# Default formatting for other steps
else:
formatted_solution += f"{step}\n\n"
return formatted_solution