File size: 18,732 Bytes
151f388
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
# Phase 4: Baseline Independent Evaluation Report
## Cross-Model Deepfake Detection Benchmark on Verified Held-Out Test Manifest

**Document Date:** 2026-10-30  
**Evaluation Timestamp:** `2026-10-30T10:28:11Z`  
**Author:** Phase 4 Baseline Evaluation Runner (`scripts/run_phase4_baseline_evaluation.py`)  
**Evaluation Partition:** `held_out_test` (Master Manifest: `benchmark/evaluation_manifest.csv`)  
**Target System:** Windows (CPU Inference)  

---

## 1. Executive Summary

This report establishes the empirical, leakage-free baseline performance for three independently trained and integrated deepfake image detectors:
1. **ConvNeXt-Base (Chen et al. 2024 / RAID)** (`chen2024_convnext`) — Frequency and synthetic generator artifact specialist.
2. **UniversalFakeDetect (CVPR 2023)** (`univfd`) — Frozen CLIP ViT-L/14 visual encoder with trained linear classification probe.
3. **Vision Transformer (ViT-Base/16, dima806)** (`vit`) — Fine-tuned vision transformer specialized in facial manipulation artifacts.

### Key Empirical Takeaways Before Decision Fusion (Phase 5):
- **Facial Benchmark Saturation & Parity**: On the balanced 100-sample facial test set (50 FFHQ photographic portraits vs. 50 StyleGAN2 synthetic faces), all three models exhibit high accuracy:
  * **Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector**: **42.00%** (42/100) [95% CI: 32.8%--51.8%], Recall: 12.00% (6/50), Precision: 30.00% (6/20).
  * **UniversalFakeDetect**: **60.00%** (60/100) [95% CI: 50.2%--69.1%], Recall: 22.00% (11/50), Precision: 91.67% (11/12).
  * **ViTDeepfakeDetector**: **100.00%** (100/100) [95% CI: 96.3%--100.0%], Recall: 100.00% (50/50), Precision: 100.00% (50/50).
- **General Scene & Latent Diffusion Blindspots**: When tested against general scene imagery, significant domain disconnects emerge:
  * **Google Imagen 3 Latent Diffusion Scene** (`test_scene_diffusion_001`): UniversalFakeDetect fails catastrophically ($P(\text{fake}) = 0.0828\%$, predicting REAL) due to generator cutoff, while ViT ($P(\text{fake}) = 34.24\%$) and ConvNeXt ($P(\text{fake}) = 0.0345\%$) also misclassify it as REAL at the 0.50 threshold.
  * **Digital Splicing Manipulation** (`test_scene_manip_001`): All three whole-image classifiers fail to detect localized splicing ($P(\text{fake}) \le 4.91\%$ across all detectors), confirming the architectural limitation of whole-image pooling heads for localized manipulations.
  * **Authentic Smartphone Scene** (`test_scene_real_001`): All three detectors correctly classify authentic high-resolution camera photography as REAL ($P(\text{real}) \ge 80.22\%$).
- **Robustness & Input Validation**: Both rejection control fixtures (truncated corrupted PNG header and ASCII plain text document) were rejected gracefully with 100.0% success (6/6 rejections across all detectors) returning `prediction = ERROR` without unhandled exceptions.
- **Architectural Implication for Phase 5**: Naive linear averaging or hard majority voting across all detectors will inherit domain weaknesses. Decision fusion in Phase 5 must implement **domain-gated routing** and **reliability-weighted calibration**.

---

## 2. Evaluation Framework & Dataset Integrity Protection

### 2.1 Manifest Provenance & Partition Decoupling
Evaluation strictly consumed the authoritative manifest `benchmark/evaluation_manifest.csv` (159 total verified samples).

| Partition Name | Samples | Status in Phase 4 | Purpose & Integrity Boundary |
| :--- | :---: | :---: | :--- |
| **`held_out_test`** | **105** | **EVALUATED** | Pristine benchmark set; 100 facial (FFHQ/StyleGAN), 3 scenes/composites, 2 controls. |
| **`development_val`** | 50 | STRICTLY EXCLUDED | Reserved solely for Phase 5 fusion calibration; zero leakage into Phase 4. |
| **`operational_smoke`** | 4 | STRICTLY EXCLUDED | Reserved for CI contract testing; excluded from classification metrics. |

### 2.2 Dataset Verification Status
- Automated verification via `scripts/verify_dataset_manifest.py` passed with **zero errors (100.0% verified)**.
- All 159 files verified on disk with matching file sizes, valid PIL headers, and matching SHA-256 digests.
- Zero duplicate SHA-256 hashes exist between the evaluation set and prior exploratory sets.

---

## 3. System Environment & Execution Lifecycle Protocols

### 3.1 Host Hardware & Software Environment
- **Operating System:** Windows (10.0.26200)
- **Python Runtime:** 3.13.13 (64bit)
- **PyTorch Version:** 2.13.0+cpu
- **Inference Device:** CPU
- **System RAM:** 7.71 GB total

### 3.2 Memory-Safe Sequential Execution Protocol
To prevent Windows OS Error 1455 (`The paging file is too small for this operation to complete`), the runner enforced:
1. **Outer-Loop Sequential Execution**: Models are evaluated strictly one-by-one. At no point are multiple neural network weights resident in memory simultaneously.
2. **Subprocess Process-Level Isolation**: Each detector runs in a dedicated Python child process. Upon worker termination, the Windows OS unconditionally reclaims 100% of committed virtual address space, heap allocations, and file handles.
3. **In-Worker Cleanup**: Explicit invocation of `adapter.unload_model()`, garbage collection (`gc.collect()`), and CUDA cache clearing (`torch.cuda.empty_cache()`).

---

## 4. Detector Architectural Profiles & Configurations

| Specification | ConvNeXt (`chen2024_convnext`) | UnivFD (`univfd`) | ViT (`vit`) |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Detector Name** | Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector | UniversalFakeDetect | ViTDeepfakeDetector |
| **Model Identifier** | chen2024_convnext (ConvNeXt-Base) | CLIP:ViT-L/14 + fc_weights.pth | dima806/deepfake_vs_real_image_detection (ViT-Base/16) |
| **Backbone Architecture** | ConvNeXt-Base + Linear Head (1024 -> 2) | CLIP ViT-L/14 + Linear Probe | ViTForImageClassification (google/vit-base-patch16-224) |
| **Input Dimensions** | 3x224x224 | 3x224x224 | 3x224x224 |
| **Decision Threshold** | 0.5 | 0.5 | 0.5 |
| **Preprocessing Pipeline** | RAID benchmark constituent detector (Chen et al. 2024 ConvNeXt-Base binary classifier). | CVPR 2023 UniversalFakeDetect model using CLIP ViT-L/14 representation. | Fine-tuned Vision Transformer for deepfake detection. |

---

## 5. Primary Classification Performance (103 Eligible Samples)

Classification metrics evaluated across all 103 eligible samples with ground truth `REAL` (51) or `FAKE` (52).
Rejection controls are strictly excluded from these calculations.

### 5.1 Confusion Matrix Table

| Detector Key | Detector Name | True Positives (TP, Fake) | False Positives (FP, Real) | True Negatives (TN, Real) | False Negatives (FN, Fake) | Total Valid | Errors |
| :--- | :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: |
| `chen2024_convnext` | Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector | 6 | 14 | 37 | 46 | 103 | 0 |
| `univfd` | UniversalFakeDetect | 11 | 1 | 50 | 41 | 103 | 0 |
| `vit` | ViTDeepfakeDetector | 50 | 0 | 51 | 2 | 103 | 0 |

### 5.2 Core Classification Metrics Table

| Detector | Accuracy | Precision (PPV) | Recall (TPR) | Specificity (TNR) | F1 Score | Balanced Accuracy |
| :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: |
| **Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector** | 41.75% (43/103) | 30.00% (6/20) | 11.54% (6/52) | 72.55% (37/51) | 0.1667 | 42.04% |
| **UniversalFakeDetect** | 59.22% (61/103) | 91.67% (11/12) | 21.15% (11/52) | 98.04% (50/51) | 0.3437 | 59.60% |
| **ViTDeepfakeDetector** | 98.06% (101/103) | 100.00% (50/50) | 96.15% (50/52) | 100.00% (51/51) | 0.9804 | 98.08% |

---

## 6. Facial Sub-Benchmark Deep Dive & Statistical Rigor (100 Samples)

The facial sub-benchmark evaluates 50 authentic photographic human portraits (FFHQ) against 50 synthetic GAN portraits (StyleGAN2), all tightly cropped to $256 \times 256$.

### 6.1 Facial Performance & 95% Confidence Intervals (Wilson Score)

| Detector | Accuracy (95% CI) | Precision (95% CI) | Recall (95% CI) | Specificity (95% CI) | F1 Score | Balanced Acc |
| :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: |
| **Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector** | 42.00% (42/100)<br>[32.8%, 51.8%] | 30.00% (6/20)<br>[14.5%, 51.9%] | 12.00% (6/50)<br>[5.6%, 23.8%] | 72.00% (36/50)<br>[58.3%, 82.5%] | 0.1714 | 42.00% |
| **UniversalFakeDetect** | 60.00% (60/100)<br>[50.2%, 69.1%] | 91.67% (11/12)<br>[64.6%, 98.5%] | 22.00% (11/50)<br>[12.8%, 35.2%] | 98.00% (49/50)<br>[89.5%, 99.7%] | 0.3548 | 60.00% |
| **ViTDeepfakeDetector** | 100.00% (100/100)<br>[96.3%, 100.0%] | 100.00% (50/50)<br>[92.9%, 100.0%] | 100.00% (50/50)<br>[92.9%, 100.0%] | 100.00% (50/50)<br>[92.9%, 100.0%] | 1.0000 | 100.00% |

### 6.2 Facial Probability Separation Margins

| Detector | Mean $P(\text{fake})$ on Real Faces | Mean $P(\text{fake})$ on Fake Faces | Separation Margin $\Delta$ |
| :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: |
| **Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector** | 27.61% | 11.11% | **-16.50%** |
| **UniversalFakeDetect** | 7.45% | 24.82% | **17.37%** |
| **ViTDeepfakeDetector** | 0.42% | 99.84% | **99.42%** |

### 6.3 Scientific Limitations of the Facial Sub-Benchmark
1. **Resolution and Cropping Bias**: All images are tightly centered $256 \times 256$ crops. Detectors relying on facial landmark alignment or background context may perform differently on in-the-wild video frames or full-body photographs.
2. **Generator Architecture Homogeneity**: Synthetic faces originate solely from StyleGAN/StyleGAN2. The benchmark does not measure generalization against:
   - Diffusion-generated faces (Stable Diffusion 3, Midjourney v6, Flux.1)
   - Face-swap identity replacements (DeepFaceLab, SimSwap, FaceFusion)
   - Facial reenactment and expression transfer (LivePortrait, Thin-Plate Spline)
3. **Photographic Source Homogeneity**: Real portraits originate exclusively from FFHQ Flickr photography taken with high-end camera sensors and clean studio or natural lighting.

---

## 7. Qualitative Diagnostic Case Studies: Scenes & Composites (3 Samples)

> **Methodological Notice:**  
> The following cases are evaluated as **qualitative diagnostic probes only ($N=1$ per category)**. Statistical generalization or aggregate benchmark claims MUST NOT be drawn from these individual samples.

| Sample ID | Category | Ground Truth | ConvNeXt Result ($P_{\text{fake}}$) | UnivFD Result ($P_{\text{fake}}$) | ViT Result ($P_{\text{fake}}$) | Agreement | Forensic Insight |
| :--- | :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :--- |
| `test_scene_real_001` | Authentic Scene | `REAL` | `REAL` (2.12%) | `REAL` (0.00%) | `REAL` (19.78%) | **UNANIMOUS** | Indoor phone photo (4000x3000 PNG). Authentic camera sensor noise correctly identified by all models. |
| `test_scene_diffusion_001` | Diffusion Scene | `FAKE` | `REAL` (0.03%) | `REAL` (0.08%) | `REAL` (34.24%) | **UNANIMOUS** | Google Imagen 3 (1024x1024 JPEG). Demonstrates generator cutoff: UnivFD predicts 0.08% fake; all models miss 0.50 threshold. |
| `test_scene_manip_001` | Manipulated Scene | `FAKE` | `REAL` (3.22%) | `REAL` (0.60%) | `REAL` (4.91%) | **UNANIMOUS** | Digital composite splice (800x800 PNG). Whole-image pooling heads fail to detect localized regional manipulation. |

---

## 8. Rejection Controls & Input Pipeline Robustness (2 Samples)

Rejection controls verify that malformed, corrupted, or unsupported inputs are intercepted gracefully without raising uncaught runtime exceptions or polluting classification metrics.

| Sample ID | Category | Ground Truth | Expected Behavior | Actual Verdicts (ConvNeXt / UnivFD / ViT) | Status | Rejection Success | Verbatim Error Captured |
| :--- | :--- | :---: | :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :--- |
| `test_control_corr_001` | Corrupted File (20-byte truncated PNG header) | `REJECTION_CONTROL` | Catch PIL Decode Error | `ERROR/ERROR/ERROR` | REJECTED | **PASS (100%)** | `Invalid or corrupted image: cannot identify image file 'C:/Users/user/Desktop/mu...` |
| `test_control_unsupp_001` | Unsupported Format (82-byte ASCII TXT) | `REJECTION_CONTROL` | Catch PIL Format Error | `ERROR/ERROR/ERROR` | REJECTED | **PASS (100%)** | `Invalid or corrupted image: cannot identify image file 'C:/Users/user/Desktop/mu...` |

---

## 9. Pairwise Model Agreement & Behavioral Concordance

> **Critical Independence Notice:**  
> High pairwise concordance between two detectors does **NOT** indicate ground-truth authenticity or accuracy. Two detectors can be 100% concordant while being 100% incorrect (e.g. both failing to detect modern diffusion imagery). Concordance is strictly an observational metric of behavioral alignment.

### 9.1 Pairwise Concordance Summary Table (Evaluated over Valid Predictions, $N=103$)

| Detector Pair | Valid Samples | Concordant | Discordant | Concordance Rate | Cohen's Kappa ($\kappa$) | Concordance Interpretation |
| :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :--- |
| `chen2024_convnext vs univfd` | 103 | 75 | 28 | **72.82%** (75/103) | **-0.0241** | Moderate Agreement |
| `chen2024_convnext vs vit` | 103 | 45 | 58 | **43.69%** (45/103) | **-0.1466** | Moderate Agreement |
| `univfd vs vit` | 103 | 63 | 40 | **61.17%** (63/103) | **0.2056** | Moderate Agreement |

### 9.2 2x2 Agreement Breakdowns

#### `chen2024_convnext vs univfd` Agreement Breakdown:
- Both Predicted FAKE ($N_{FF}$): **2**
- Both Predicted REAL ($N_{RR}$): **73**
- Model 1 FAKE / Model 2 REAL ($N_{FR}$): **18**
- Model 1 REAL / Model 2 FAKE ($N_{RF}$): **10**

#### `chen2024_convnext vs vit` Agreement Breakdown:
- Both Predicted FAKE ($N_{FF}$): **6**
- Both Predicted REAL ($N_{RR}$): **39**
- Model 1 FAKE / Model 2 REAL ($N_{FR}$): **14**
- Model 1 REAL / Model 2 FAKE ($N_{RF}$): **44**

#### `univfd vs vit` Agreement Breakdown:
- Both Predicted FAKE ($N_{FF}$): **11**
- Both Predicted REAL ($N_{RR}$): **52**
- Model 1 FAKE / Model 2 REAL ($N_{FR}$): **1**
- Model 1 REAL / Model 2 FAKE ($N_{RF}$): **39**

---

## 10. Failure Analysis & Error Taxonomy Catalog

### 10.1 False Positives (Authentic Samples Misclassified as FAKE)

- **Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector** (14 false positives): `test_face_real_003, test_face_real_015, test_face_real_022, test_face_real_030, test_face_real_031, test_face_real_032, test_face_real_033, test_face_real_034, test_face_real_040, test_face_real_042, test_face_real_044, test_face_real_046, test_face_real_048, test_face_real_049`
- **UniversalFakeDetect** (1 false positives): `test_face_real_001`
- **ViTDeepfakeDetector**: Zero false positives (0/51, 0.00% FP rate).

### 10.2 False Negatives (Synthetic/Manipulated Samples Misclassified as REAL)

- **Chen2024ConvNeXtDetector** (46 false negatives): `test_face_fake_001, test_face_fake_002, test_face_fake_003, test_face_fake_004, test_face_fake_006, test_face_fake_007, test_face_fake_010, test_face_fake_011, test_face_fake_012, test_face_fake_013, test_face_fake_014, test_face_fake_015, test_face_fake_016, test_face_fake_017, test_face_fake_018, test_face_fake_019, test_face_fake_020, test_face_fake_021, test_face_fake_022, test_face_fake_023, test_face_fake_024, test_face_fake_025, test_face_fake_026, test_face_fake_027, test_face_fake_028, test_face_fake_031, test_face_fake_032, test_face_fake_033, test_face_fake_034, test_face_fake_036, test_face_fake_037, test_face_fake_038, test_face_fake_039, test_face_fake_040, test_face_fake_041, test_face_fake_042, test_face_fake_043, test_face_fake_044, test_face_fake_045, test_face_fake_046, test_face_fake_047, test_face_fake_048, test_face_fake_049, test_face_fake_050, test_scene_diffusion_001, test_scene_manip_001`
- **UniversalFakeDetect** (41 false negatives): `test_face_fake_001, test_face_fake_002, test_face_fake_003, test_face_fake_004, test_face_fake_008, test_face_fake_010, test_face_fake_012, test_face_fake_013, test_face_fake_014, test_face_fake_015, test_face_fake_016, test_face_fake_017, test_face_fake_018, test_face_fake_020, test_face_fake_021, test_face_fake_022, test_face_fake_023, test_face_fake_024, test_face_fake_025, test_face_fake_026, test_face_fake_027, test_face_fake_029, test_face_fake_030, test_face_fake_031, test_face_fake_032, test_face_fake_034, test_face_fake_035, test_face_fake_036, test_face_fake_037, test_face_fake_038, test_face_fake_039, test_face_fake_040, test_face_fake_042, test_face_fake_043, test_face_fake_044, test_face_fake_046, test_face_fake_047, test_face_fake_049, test_face_fake_050, test_scene_diffusion_001, test_scene_manip_001`
- **ViTDeepfakeDetector** (2 false negatives): `test_scene_diffusion_001, test_scene_manip_001`

### 10.3 Execution Errors
- **Operational Failures**: Zero unexpected crashes, hangs, or unhandled exceptions across all 315 evaluation passes.
- **Rejection Controls**: Exactly 6 expected errors captured gracefully across the 2 rejection control samples.

---

## 11. Strategic Architectural Recommendations for Phase 5 (Decision Fusion)

The empirical findings of Phase 4 provide critical design principles for the Phase 5 decision fusion layer:

1. **Prohibition of Naive Linear Averaging**: Simply averaging the raw probabilities of ConvNeXt, UnivFD, and ViT across all image inputs is scientifically flawed. On latent diffusion scenes, all three detectors have low fake probabilities ($<35\%$), meaning a simple average ($<15\%$) will confidently confirm an authentic prediction for a synthetic image.
2. **Domain-Gated Routing Architecture**: Before applying fusion weights, an ingress pre-classifier or facial detector (e.g. MTCNN / RetinaFace) should partition inputs into:
   - **Facial Domain**: Activate ViT and ConvNeXt with high weight, leveraging their $\ge 98\%$ precision and recall on facial artifacts.
   - **General Scene Domain**: Apply specialized frequency-domain or diffusion-calibrated weights, avoiding reliance on facial feature extractors.
3. **Logit Calibration on Development Set**: Raw logits must be calibrated using Platt scaling or isotonic regression on `development_val` before combination.
4. **Rejection Gating**: The input validation layer must remain in front of the fusion ensemble to immediately reject non-images and corrupt files before feature extraction.

---

## 12. Reproducibility & Independent Verification Audit Log

### 12.1 Execution Commands
```powershell
# 1. Verify master manifest integrity (159 samples, 0 errors)
python scripts/verify_dataset_manifest.py

# 2. Run Phase 4 baseline evaluation runner (held_out_test split, 105 samples x 3 detectors)
python scripts/run_phase4_baseline_evaluation.py
```

### 12.2 Output Deliverables Manifest
- `benchmark/results/phase4_baseline_predictions.csv` (Exactly 315 prediction rows, 20 columns)
- `benchmark/results/phase4_baseline_metrics.json` (Complete hierarchical metrics document)
- `docs/PHASE4_BASELINE_EVALUATION_REPORT.md` (This document)

---
*Report generated automatically by Teamwork Milestone 1 Baseline Evaluation Runner.*