Spaces:

ThomasHeisig
/

MHRN-Space

Paused

MHRN-Space / src /dashboard /static /scientific-progress.json
Sync GitHub main 6bb97fb9a95926f8118bd61bec366af28afa0e5c (part 8)
c4e7f6b verified 1 day ago
29.5 kB
{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "as_of": "2026-09-27",
  "as_of_commit": "f9d926a9209dc17a11fbe29c6c82074824f75aa0",
  "title": "MHRN scientific maturity timeline",
  "scope_note": "Scientific maturity is intentionally separate from engineering maturity. Scores summarize registered questions, frozen protocols, collected DATA, human-reviewed EVID, independent replication and attribution. They do not measure intelligence, consciousness or biological equivalence. Gewichteter Bearbeitungsindex, keine Wahrscheinlichkeit. Berechnungskorrektur vom 24.10.2026 bei unveraenderten Kriterien; kein neuer Evidenzgewinn. Pflichtpruefungen gelten unabhaengig vom Prozentwert.",
  "integrity_note": "Repository checks reduce attribution and text-recycling risk but cannot certify plagiarism-freedom. External similarity review and human source verification remain pre-submission requirements.",
  "status_scale": {
    "met": 1,
    "partial": 0.5,
    "open": 0,
    "not_applicable": null
  },
  "weights": {
    "research_question": 0.15,
    "protocol": 0.2,
    "data": 0.2,
    "reviewed_evidence": 0.2,
    "independent_replication": 0.15,
    "attribution": 0.1
  },
  "stages": [
    {
      "stage": 0,
      "name": "Einzelne Nervenzelle",
      "score": 0.925,
      "status": "advanced",
      "claim_boundary": "Die eingefrorene Stage-0-Konformitätsstudie stützt den numerischen Modellvertrag für Izhikevich-2003 und lif-current-v1 im deklarierten Operating Envelope. Das ist Modell-/Softwarekonformität, keine biologische Gleichwertigkeit, keine allgemeine Langzeittrajektorien-Identität und keine unabhängige Replikation.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Explizite Forschungsfrage/Hypothesen",
          "sources": [
            "research/registry/questions.empirical.yaml",
            "RQ-EVAL-006",
            "research/registry/hypotheses.empirical.yaml",
            "H-EVAL-006-A",
            "H-EVAL-006-B",
            "H-EVAL-006-C"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Vorab eingefrorenes konfirmatorisches Einzelzell-Protokoll",
          "sources": [
            "research/preregistrations/operational/single_neuron_conformance_v2.json",
            "scripts/stage0_conformance_v2_confirm.py",
            "tests/test_single_neuron_contract.py"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Quellengebundene konfirmatorische Referenz-DATA",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE0-20260916-MODEL-CONFORMANCE-V2/DATA/confirmatory_result.json",
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE0-20260916-MODEL-CONFORMANCE-V2/report.md",
            "research/generated/verification/single_neuron_scientific_readiness.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Human Review und kanonische EvidenceEngine-Promotion für den scoped Stage-0-Claim abgeschlossen",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE0-20260916-MODEL-CONFORMANCE-V2/human_scientific_review.json",
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE0-20260918-MODEL-CONFORMANCE-V2-PROMO-R1/manifest.json",
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE0-20260918-MODEL-CONFORMANCE-V2-PROMO-R1/human_review.json",
            "research/registry/evidence/EVID-2026-18.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Externer Brian2-Referenzvergleich und interne Promotion-Replikation vorhanden; keine unabhängig autorisierte Replikation",
          "sources": [
            "research/preregistrations/operational/single_neuron_conformance_v2.json",
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE0-20260916-MODEL-CONFORMANCE-V2/DATA/confirmatory_result.json",
            "research/generated/verification/single_neuron_scientific_readiness.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Modell-, Literatur- und Quellenattribution",
          "sources": [
            "research/specifications/NEURON_MODEL_EXPERIMENT_AXIS.md",
            "research/registry/questions.empirical.yaml",
            "research/publications/2026-09-17_recursive-epistemics_v1.8/REFERENCES.md",
            "research/publications/2026-09-17_recursive-epistemics_v1.8/parts/03_research_object.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Kanonische EVID-Promotion für CLAIM-EVAL-006 ist mit EVID-2026-18 abgeschlossen.",
        "Unabhängige Replikation separat definieren und außerhalb derselben Autoren-/Toolkette durchführen; erst sie kann die verbleibenden 7,5 % schließen.",
        "Die Stage-0-Aussage weiterhin strikt auf den präregistrierten V2-Modellvertrag begrenzen; keine biologische Gleichwertigkeit oder universelle Langzeittrajektorienidentität ableiten."
      ],
      "criterion_contracts": {
        "reviewed_evidence": {
          "weight": 0.2,
          "partial_semantics": "Human scientific review completed with a scoped decision, but canonical EVID registration is not yet complete.",
          "met_semantics": "Human scientific review completed and the scoped claim is registered through the canonical EvidenceEngine promotion path.",
          "decomposition": {
            "human_scientific_review_fraction": 0.5,
            "canonical_evidence_engine_promotion_fraction": 0.5
          },
          "anti_gaming_rule": "A positive result alone cannot change this criterion. The partial state reflects completion of the human-review sub-gate, not result favorability."
        },
        "independent_replication": {
          "weight": 0.15,
          "partial_semantics": "External reference comparison exists, but no independently authored replication has been completed.",
          "met_semantics": "A preregistered replication meeting the explicit independence definition has been completed and reviewed.",
          "decomposition": {
            "external_reference_comparison_fraction": 0.5,
            "independent_authorship_replication_fraction": 0.5
          },
          "anti_conflation_rule": "An EvidenceEngine-conformant internal rerun can never satisfy the independent-authorship half of this criterion."
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "stage": 1,
      "name": "Kleines SNN",
      "score": 0.85,
      "status": "active",
      "claim_boundary": "Stage 1 besitzt jetzt zwei getrennte kanonische, human-reviewte EVID-Linien: Topologie EVID-2026-19 im 64-Neuronen/246-Kanten-Regime und Temporal Order EVID-2026-20 im sechsneuronigen Zweikanal-Task. Der Temporal-Human-Review dokumentiert Perfect-Score-Sättigung und die simultane Bedingung als nicht-inferentiellen Task-Adequacy-Control. Das begründet weder Kognition, Lernen/Gedächtnis, Skalierbarkeit, biologische Äquivalenz, 5D-Überlegenheit noch unabhängige Replikation.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Explizite registrierte Stage-1-Forschungsfragen und Hypothesen",
          "sources": [
            "research/registry/questions.yaml",
            "RQ-SNN-003",
            "H-SNN-003-B",
            "RQ-TEMP-002",
            "H-TEMP-002-A"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Präregistrierte wissenschaftliche Small-SNN-Protokolle über den Softwarevertrag hinaus",
          "sources": [
            "research/preregistrations/PREREG-S1-TOPO-V2.json",
            "research/preregistrations/PREREG-S1-TOPO-V3-R1-TIME-RESOLVED.json",
            "research/preregistrations/PREREG-S1-TEMP-ORDER-V2.json",
            "research/preregistrations/PREREG-S1-TEMP-PROMO-R1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Source-bound Stage-1-DATA aus zentraler Topologielinie und task-basierter Temporal-Order-Linie",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TOPO-V2-20260918",
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TOPO-V3-R1-20260918",
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TEMP-ORDER-V2-20260919",
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TOPO-PROMO-R1-20260927",
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TEMP-PROMO-R1-20260927"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Human Review + EvidenceEngine-Promotion für Topologie- und Temporal-Order-Claims",
          "sources": [
            "CLAIM-S1-TOPO-001",
            "EVID-2026-19",
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TOPO-PROMO-R1-20260927/human_review.json",
            "CLAIM-S1-TEMP-001",
            "EVID-2026-20",
            "research/experiments/EXP-S1-TEMP-PROMO-R1-20260927/human_review.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Referenz-/Cross-Implementation-Replikation offen",
          "sources": [
            "INDEPENDENT_REPLICATION.md",
            "research/registry/stage1_baseline.json",
            "research/decisions/2026-09-25_stage1_scientific_consolidation.md"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Methoden-, Modell-, Literatur- und Claim-Grenzen dokumentiert",
          "sources": [
            "research/publications/2026-09-17_recursive-epistemics_v1.8/parts/04_empirical_programme.md",
            "research/publications/papers/2026-09-20_topology-dynamics_v0.1/PAPER.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Topologie als unabhängig implementierte Referenz-/Cross-Implementation-Replikation präregistrieren, um den nächsten 7,5-%-Schritt zu adressieren.",
        "Temporal-Order-Decoder/Task separat mit schwierigeren, präregistrierten Gap-/Channel-Swap-/Perturbationskontrollen stress-testen; dies ändert EVID-2026-20 nicht rückwirkend.",
        "CLAIM-S1-EFFICIENCY-001 / H-SNN-003-C getrennt als prospektive untested Effizienzlinie weiterentwickeln; keine post-hoc Effizienzbeobachtung als EVID verwenden."
      ],
      "criterion_contracts": {
        "reviewed_evidence": {
          "weight": 0.2,
          "partial_semantics": "Human scientific review of the Stage-1 topology and Temporal-Order interpretations is complete, but canonical EvidenceEngine EVID registration is not complete.",
          "met_semantics": "Human scientific review is complete and a scoped Stage-1 claim is registered through the canonical EvidenceEngine promotion path.",
          "decomposition": {
            "human_scientific_review_fraction": 0.5,
            "canonical_evidence_engine_promotion_fraction": 0.5
          },
          "anti_gaming_rule": "A positive DATA result or accepted interpretation cannot by itself create EVID or complete this criterion."
        },
        "independent_replication": {
          "weight": 0.15,
          "partial_semantics": "A separately controlled external or independently authored replication contributes only when the explicit independence definition is satisfied.",
          "met_semantics": "A preregistered replication meeting the explicit independence definition has been completed and reviewed.",
          "anti_conflation_rule": "The V3-R1 internal replication and the separate Temporal-Order task can never be counted as independent replication of the topology claim."
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "stage": 2,
      "name": "Stabiles rekurrentes SNN",
      "score": 0.75,
      "status": "advanced",
      "claim_boundary": "Stabile deterministische Runs stützen Stabilität im geprüften Bereich; sie sind kein Nachweis von Gedächtnis oder Kognition.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Registrierte Forschungsfragen",
          "sources": [
            "research/registry/questions.yaml",
            "RQ-SNN-001"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Long-run/Determinismus-Protokolle",
          "sources": [
            "research/protocols",
            "tests/test_recurrent_snn_contract.py"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Ausgeführte quellengebundene DATA",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-20260908200906-01"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Wissenschaftliche Auswertung mit enger Claim-Grenze",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-20260908200906-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Methoden-/Quellenbindung",
          "sources": [
            "research/publications/2026-09-13_recursive-epistemics_v1.5/FORSCHUNGSBERICHT.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Task-relevante Rekurrenz-Ablation gegen feed-forward/yoked controls durchführen.",
        "Skalierung getrennt von Stabilität prüfen.",
        "Unabhängige Replikation registrieren."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 3,
      "name": "Plastisches Nervengewebe",
      "score": 0.65,
      "status": "advanced",
      "claim_boundary": "STDP, Drei-Faktor-Lernen, Homöostase und Strukturplastizität sind implementierte Mechanismen; ihre wissenschaftliche Wirksamkeit bleibt interventions- und EVID-gebunden.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Registrierte RQ/Hypothesen",
          "sources": [
            "RQ1",
            "RQ3",
            "RQ5",
            "RQ10"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Kontrollierte Lern- und Ablationsprotokolle",
          "sources": [
            "src/experiments/learning_lab.py",
            "scripts/run_stage3_reference.py"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Ausgeführte DATA / Referenzen",
          "sources": [
            "research/generated/verification/plastic_neural_tissue_reference_alpha3.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Promotete menschlich geprüfte EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Mechanismus-Attribution",
          "sources": [
            "research/publications/2026-09-13_recursive-epistemics_v1.5/FORSCHUNGSBERICHT.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Präregistrierte learning-on/off-, sham- und information-destroyed Kontrollen ausführen.",
        "Held-out Generalisierung statt Gewichtsänderung als Endpunkt prüfen.",
        "R2-Evidenzschluss mit externer Prüfung abschließen."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 4,
      "name": "Spezialisierte neuronale Areale",
      "score": 0.65,
      "status": "advanced",
      "claim_boundary": "Modality-specific pathways und Gateway-Verträge sind technisch vorhanden; E01-E05 bleiben DATA bis zur unabhängigen wissenschaftlichen Prüfung.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "MSBA-Forschungsfragen registriert",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-MSBA-E01",
            "RQ-MSBA-E02",
            "RQ-MSBA-E03",
            "RQ-MSBA-E04",
            "RQ-MSBA-E05"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Matched-control Protokolle",
          "sources": [
            "src/experiments/msba_lab.py"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "E01-E05 DATA vorhanden",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-20260914074039-90",
            "research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-20260914074039-94"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängig geprüfte EVID-Promotion",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Literatur-/Methodenattribution",
          "sources": [
            "research/publications/2026-09-14_stage4-specialized-areas_v1.5-addendum"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "E01-E05 unabhängig reviewen und nur freigegebene Claims promoten.",
        "Dynamisch materialisierte multimodale Netzwerke getrennt skalieren.",
        "Codec/Gateway-Beitrag durch Frozen/Random/Shuffle-Ablationen isolieren."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 5,
      "name": "Integriertes künstliches Nervensystem",
      "score": 0.65,
      "status": "advanced",
      "claim_boundary": "Der geschlossene Regelkreis ist in einer synthetischen deterministischen Umgebung belegt; reale Embodiment- oder biologische Interozeptionsclaims sind nicht gedeckt.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Embodiment-RQ/Hypothesen registriert",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-EMB-001",
            "RQ6",
            "RQ7",
            "RQ8",
            "RQ9"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Closed-loop Referenzprotokoll",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE5-20260914-INTEGRATED-NERVOUS-SYSTEM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Closed-loop DATA vorhanden",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-STAGE5-20260914-INTEGRATED-NERVOUS-SYSTEM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Promotete EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige closed-loop Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Quellen-/Grenzenattribution",
          "sources": [
            "research/publications/2026-09-14_stage5-integrated-nervous-system_v1.5-addendum"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Matched-disturbance, yoked replay und interrupted-feedback Kontrollen ausführen.",
        "H-EMB-001-B präregistriert testen.",
        "Reale Adapter als separaten safety-gated Studienzweig behandeln."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 6,
      "name": "Gedächtnis und Weltmodell",
      "score": 0.45,
      "status": "active",
      "claim_boundary": "Working/episodic foundations und Ein-Schritt-Vorhersage sind keine Semantization, kein hierarchisches Predictive Coding und kein generatives Weltmodell.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Memory/World-model RQ registriert",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-MEM-002",
            "RQ-WM-001"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Mechanismus-spezifische confirmatory Protokolle",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-EMP-20260910/016-memory_delayed_information_v1",
            "research/experiments/EXP-EMP-20260910/017-world_model_prediction_v1"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "SNN-involved confirmatory DATA",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-EMP-20260910/016-memory_delayed_information_v1",
            "research/experiments/EXP-EMP-20260910/017-world_model_prediction_v1"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Menschlich freigegebene EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Related-work/Claim-Grenzen dokumentiert",
          "sources": [
            "research/publications/2026-09-15_stage6-memory-world-model_v1.5-addendum"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Semanticization als expliziten Mechanismus mit Replay/Konsolidierung und Ablationen definieren.",
        "Prediction Error neuronalen Mechanismus statt Telemetrie implementieren und testen.",
        "Mehrschrittiges aktionskonditioniertes Weltmodell gegen reine Beobachtungsprädiktion testen.",
        "Confirmatory SNN-involved DATA und unabhängige Replikation erzeugen."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 7,
      "name": "Selbstmodell und verkörperte Identität",
      "score": 0.325,
      "status": "early",
      "claim_boundary": "Versionierte technische Identität und Behavior State sind Grundlagen, aber kein kausales Selbstmodell und kein Bewusstseinsnachweis.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Selbstmodell-spezifische RQ",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-PROFILE-001",
            "RQ6",
            "RQ7"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Kausale self/other Interventionsprotokolle",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-EMP-20260910/018-behavior_profile_control_v1"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Kausale Selbstmodell-DATA",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-EMP-20260910/018-behavior_profile_control_v1"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Promotete EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Explizite Related-work-Zuordnung",
          "sources": [
            "research/frontiers/STAGES_8_10_FOUNDATIONS.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Observer-only self-versus-external action attribution präregistrieren.",
        "Coupled-state restore als notwendige technische Vorbedingung schließen.",
        "Begriffe Selbstmodell/Selbst ausschließlich operational verwenden."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 8,
      "name": "Autonome lebenslange Entwicklung",
      "score": 0.4,
      "status": "planned",
      "claim_boundary": "Interferenz-Screens und Forschungsplanung sind keine Evidenz für autonomes lebenslanges Lernen.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Continual-learning RQ registriert",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-LIFE-001",
            "RQ-GEN-001",
            "RQ-REPL-001"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Präregistrierbare Retention-/Interferenzprotokolle",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/STAGES_8_10_EXPERIMENT_BACKLOG.md"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Vorläufer-DATA",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/EXP-LIFE-0001-R1"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Promotete EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Related-work-Mapping",
          "sources": [
            "research/frontiers/STAGES_8_10_FOUNDATIONS.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Shared-network continual-learning protocol ohne Learned-State-Reset ausführen.",
        "Replay/Consolidation und Stabilitäts-Plastizitäts-Gating getrennt abladieren.",
        "Resource-matched Baselines und unabhängige Replikation verlangen."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 9,
      "name": "Hochintegrierte künstliche Kognition",
      "score": 0.3,
      "status": "planned",
      "claim_boundary": "Architektur- und Experimententwürfe sind keine beobachtete integrierte Kognition.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Kognitions-RQ registriert",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-CNS-103",
            "RQ-CNS-105",
            "RQ-CNS-110",
            "RQ-MEM-002",
            "RQ-WM-001"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Operationalisierte, kontrastierende Protokolle",
          "sources": [
            "research/experiments/STAGES_8_10_EXPERIMENT_BACKLOG.md"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Stage-9 confirmatory DATA",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Promotete EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Related-work-Mapping",
          "sources": [
            "research/frontiers/STAGES_8_10_FOUNDATIONS.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Attention, planning, multimodale Integration und Konsolidierung einzeln operationalisieren.",
        "Matched-budget Ablationen definieren.",
        "Keine Fähigkeit aus UI-/Telemetrieintegration ableiten."
      ]
    },
    {
      "stage": 10,
      "name": "Bewusstseinsforschung",
      "score": 0.3,
      "status": "frontier",
      "claim_boundary": "Diese Stufe ist ausschließlich eine Forschungs- und Governance-Frontier. Kein Score begründet Bewusstsein, Sentienz oder moralischen Status.",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "research_question",
          "status": "met",
          "label": "Operationale Frontier-RQ registriert",
          "sources": [
            "RQ-CNS-101",
            "RQ-CNS-108",
            "RQ-CNS-109",
            "RQ-EPI-101",
            "RQ-WEL-101"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "protocol",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Ethik-/Abbruch-/Interventionsrahmen",
          "sources": [
            "research/protocols/COGNITION_CONSCIOUSNESS.md",
            "research/ethics/AI_WELFARE_POLICY.md"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "data",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Claim-relevante DATA",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "reviewed_evidence",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Promotete EVID",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "independent_replication",
          "status": "open",
          "label": "Unabhängige adversariale Replikation",
          "sources": []
        },
        {
          "id": "attribution",
          "status": "partial",
          "label": "Theorie-/Related-work-Mapping",
          "sources": [
            "research/frontiers/STAGES_8_10_FOUNDATIONS.md"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "next_scientific_steps": [
        "Kontrastierende operationalisierte Vorhersagen präregistrieren.",
        "Ethik- und Stop-Governance vor Experimenten extern prüfen.",
        "Unabhängige adversariale Replikation als Mindestbedingung festschreiben."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "calculation_method": "sum(weights[criterion.id] * status_scale[criterion.status]); stage mean is unweighted; no implicit caps; all six criteria mandatory",
  "method_document": "docs/05-quality/SCIENTIFIC_MATURITY_METHOD.md",
  "score_recalculated_on": "2026-10-24"
}