Download data/extracted/CS1.json from UWaterlooRFR/UWaterlooManagedRetreat: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 43.2 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/spaces/UWaterlooRFR/UWaterlooManagedRetreat/resolve/main/data/extracted/CS1.json
- Command line
-
hf download hf://spaces/UWaterlooRFR/UWaterlooManagedRetreat/data/extracted/CS1.json
-
curl -L -o CS1.json https://huggingface.co/spaces/UWaterlooRFR/UWaterlooManagedRetreat/resolve/main/data/extracted/CS1.json
43.2 kB
| [ | |
| { | |
| "case_id": "CS1", | |
| "chunk_index": 0, | |
| "section": "overview", | |
| "location": "Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana", | |
| "country": "USA", | |
| "country_normalized": "United States", | |
| "continent": "North America", | |
| "admin_area": "Louisiana", | |
| "source": "Pipeline Ver2 β Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement", | |
| "source_links": [ | |
| { | |
| "title": "Simms, J. R., Waller, H., Brunet, C., Jenkins, P., & Kofler, J. (2021). The long goodbye on a disappearing, ancestral island: A just retreat from Isle de Jean Charles. Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 11, 316-328. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "doi": "10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Jessee, N. (2022). Reshaping Louisiana's coastal frontier: Managed retreat as colonial decontextualization. Journal of Political Ecology.", | |
| "url": "https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/jpe/article/id/2835/" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (2021). Program development for the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement: Phase 2 report.", | |
| "url": "https://isledejeancharles.la.gov/sites/default/files/public/IDJC_Phase2Report_7-21-21.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Soundararajan, N. (2022). Evaluating the implementation of the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project [Master's thesis, University of Chicago].", | |
| "url": "https://knowledge.uchicago.edu/record/4964/files/Soundararajan_2022_Final_Thesis.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (n.d.). Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project.", | |
| "url": "https://locd.la.gov/programs/isle-de-jean-charles-resettlement-project" | |
| } | |
| ], | |
| "text": "Case study: Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement (Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana, USA)\nSection: CASE STUDY OVERVIEW\n\n**Case Name and Location:** Isle de Jean Charles (IDJC) Resettlement β Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, coastal Louisiana, United States of America.\n\n**Hazard(s):** The primary hazards driving retreat are coastal land loss through erosion and subsidence, sea-level rise, chronic flooding of the sole access road (Island Road), and hurricane storm surge. These hazards interact in a compounding relationship: subsidence exacerbates flooding, storm surge accelerates erosion, and the loss of protective wetlands amplifies all impacts. They are driven by natural processes and substantially accelerated by anthropogenic factors β particularly levee construction that cut off Mississippi River sediment replenishment, and oil and gas extraction that carved canals through wetlands and caused additional subsidence and saltwater intrusion (Jessee 2022; Birch et al. 2024).\n\n**Type of Retreat:** Community resettlement β a structured, voluntary relocation of the Island's permanent residents and displaced former residents to a newly developed inland site (\"The New Isle\"), approximately 40 miles north of Isle de Jean Charles, near Schriever in Terrebonne Parish. The program combines individual household assistance with community-scale master planning. It departs from standard HUD buyout models by allowing residents to retain ownership of their Island properties for cultural, recreational, and ceremonial use rather than requiring title transfer and demolition (OCD 2020a; OCD 2021).\n\n**Scale:** As of the Phase I census (October 2016), 26 active residential units housed 37 households and 99 total residents on the Island (OCD 2017). The program materials identify up to 42 eligible households across current and displaced former residents across multiple option types (OCD 2020b). The New Isle spans approximately 515 acres β some documents reference 508 acres, reflecting the surveyed parcel configuration prior to final transaction β and is planned for approximately 120 residential lots plus commercial, community, and recreational uses (OCD 2020a; OCD 2021).\n\n**Key Actors:** The primary implementing agency is the Louisiana Office of Community Development (OCD), Disaster Recovery Unit, which administers a $48.3 million federal grant from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), awarded through the National Disaster Resilience Competition (NDRC) (OCD 2017; OCD 2021). The Isle de Jean Charles Band of Biloxi-Chitimacha-Choctaw (BCC) Tribal leadership and the Lowlander Center (a nonprofit founded in 2010 and incorporated in 2013) were foundational to the original resettlement vision and contributed to the successful NDRC grant application (Jessee 2022). The United Houma Nation (UHN) also has members on the Island. Key planning partners included CSRS (prime engineering consultant), Waggonner & Ball (architecture), OLIN (landscape architecture), the Center for Planning Excellence (community engagement), and others (OCD 2021). The Louisiana Land Trust (LLT) acquired the New Isle site on behalf of the state and serves as development partner (OCD 2021).\n\n**Timeline:** The BCC Tribe began planning inland resettlement in approximately 2002 after the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers excluded the Island from regional hurricane protection (Jessee 2022; Simms et al. 2021). The Lowlander Center was founded in 2010 and incorporated in 2013 as a nonprofit collaborating with Tribal leaders (Jessee 2022). Louisiana received the HUD NDRC grant on January 25, 2016 (OCD 2017). Phase I (data gathering and engagement) ran JuneβNovember 2016. Phase II (site selection, acquisition, and master planning) ran December 2016βFebruary 2019. The LLT purchased the Evergreen site on December 28, 2018; the master plan received unanimous Terrebonne Parish Planning Commission approval on February 21, 2019 (OCD 2021). The formal program launched on March 9, 2019 (OCD 2020b). Infrastructure construction began in May 2020. Houses were under construction in 2021, with move-in expected in 2022; as of the most recent sources, the resettlement remains ongoing in Phase III (OCD 2021; Soundararajan 2022).\n\n**Key Outcomes:** The New Isle site was purchased, master-planned, and is under construction. Between the program's July 2017 launch and March 2019, 20 households moved into off-island rental housing through the Optional Relocation Assistance (ORA) program; the Phase 2 Report states \"nearly 20 island families\" were in ORA-funded rental units as of that report's coverage period (OCD 2021). By the later sources, 37 of 42 eligible households had applied to participate (Simms et al. 2021). The program introduced an innovative policy allowing residents to retain ownership of Island properties for non-residential use, explicitly described as \"a significant departure from traditional HUD-funded relocation programs\" (OCD 2020a; OCD 2021; Simms et al. 2021). However, the process was significantly marked by conflict between the state and BCC Tribal leadership. Jessee (2022) argues that the state systematically transformed the Tribal-driven resettlement β originally framed as cultural survival and self-determination β into a scalable \"managed retreat\" model, erasing Indigenous planning, weakening commitments to Tribal identity and governance, and failing to honor its partnership with the Tribe. Broader Louisiana coastal planning (the Coastal Master Plans and LA SAFE initiative) increasingly recognized managed retreat as a necessary adaptation strategy but β as Birch et al. (2024) document β produced only limited, largely non-scaled relocation action, without developing the social infrastructure or governance structures necessary to implement it systematically.\n\n---\n\n### Narrative Summary\n\nIsle de Jean Charles is a narrow strip of land in the southernmost Louisiana bayou, once encompassing over 22,000 acres and home to a community of predominantly American Indian ancestry β primarily members of the Isle de Jean Charles Band of Biloxi-Chitimacha-Choctaw (BCC) Tribe and the United Houma Nation. For over a century, the Island has been disappearing: subsidence from natural deltaic processes has combined with levee construction (which cut off sediment replenishment from the Mississippi River) and oil and gas extraction (which carved canals through wetlands, enabling saltwater intrusion and causing additional subsidence) to reduce the Island from over 22,000 acres to approximately 320 acres remaining (OCD 2020a; Jessee 2022). The Island's sole road floods regularly, cutting residents off from jobs, schools, and health care. After the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers excluded the Island from regional hurricane protection in 2002 based on a cost-benefit analysis that found protection extension unjustified, BCC Tribal leaders began planning an inland resettlement as \"an act of cultural survival\" β intending not simply to move houses, but to reunite a displaced Tribe, preserve heritage, and create a teaching and learning community (Jessee 2022).\n\nIn January 2016, HUD awarded Louisiana $48.3 million through the NDRC to implement the Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement β the first federally funded, community-scale, climate-driven resettlement in the United States. The state's OCD took the lead, conducting extensive community engagement over multiple phases, purchasing approximately 515 acres of farmland near Schriever, developing a detailed master plan in collaboration with residents, and beginning construction of \"The New Isle.\" The program offered eligible households either a new home at The New Isle (Option A), homebuyer assistance toward an existing home elsewhere in Louisiana (Option D), or an improved lot at the new site (Option B). A key innovation was allowing residents to retain ownership of their Island properties for cultural and recreational use, after residents made clear that demolition and title transfer were non-negotiable conditions of their non-participation (Simms et al. 2021; OCD 2020a).\n\nThe process was, however, deeply contested. Jessee (2022) documents β through five years of ethnographic research alongside Tribal leaders β how the state progressively transformed the Tribal-driven resettlement into a more generic managed-retreat model: opening eligibility broadly under Fair Housing Act rationale, replacing a planned Tribal community center with a parish recreation center, prioritizing individual property transfers over communal land ownership, erasing pre-NDRC Tribal planning from public timelines, and reducing commitments to Tribal identity, sovereignty, and reunification. Tribal leaders described this as a \"bait and switch,\" likening it to historical colonial land dispossession (Jessee 2022; Soundararajan 2022). Meanwhile, broader Louisiana coastal planning β analyzed by Birch et al. (2024) across the 2007, 2012, 2017, and 2023 Coastal Master Plans and the LA SAFE framework β increasingly recognized managed retreat as a necessary adaptation strategy, but consistently failed to develop the actionable governance structures, social infrastructure, or sustained funding mechanisms needed to implement relocation at scale. As of early 2022, house construction at The New Isle was nearing completion, but significant uncertainty remained about Tribal futures, community cohesion, and whether the process could serve as a replicable model for other communities.\n\n---" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "case_id": "CS1", | |
| "chunk_index": 1, | |
| "section": "coding_questions", | |
| "location": "Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana", | |
| "country": "USA", | |
| "country_normalized": "United States", | |
| "continent": "North America", | |
| "admin_area": "Louisiana", | |
| "source": "Pipeline Ver2 β Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement", | |
| "source_links": [ | |
| { | |
| "title": "Simms, J. R., Waller, H., Brunet, C., Jenkins, P., & Kofler, J. (2021). The long goodbye on a disappearing, ancestral island: A just retreat from Isle de Jean Charles. Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 11, 316-328. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "doi": "10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Jessee, N. (2022). Reshaping Louisiana's coastal frontier: Managed retreat as colonial decontextualization. Journal of Political Ecology.", | |
| "url": "https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/jpe/article/id/2835/" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (2021). Program development for the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement: Phase 2 report.", | |
| "url": "https://isledejeancharles.la.gov/sites/default/files/public/IDJC_Phase2Report_7-21-21.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Soundararajan, N. (2022). Evaluating the implementation of the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project [Master's thesis, University of Chicago].", | |
| "url": "https://knowledge.uchicago.edu/record/4964/files/Soundararajan_2022_Final_Thesis.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (n.d.). Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project.", | |
| "url": "https://locd.la.gov/programs/isle-de-jean-charles-resettlement-project" | |
| } | |
| ], | |
| "text": "Case study: Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement (Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana, USA)\nSection: CODING QUESTIONS\n\n---\n\n### Is there any evidence of a proactive or reactive trigger in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** Both **Proactive** and **Reactive** apply.\n\n**Narrative:** The BCC Tribe's initial resettlement planning began proactively in approximately 2002, following the Army Corps of Engineers' decision to exclude Isle de Jean Charles from the Morganza to the Gulf hurricane protection system β an anticipatory response to foreseeable future risk before major irreversible loss of habitability occurred (Jessee 2022; Simms et al. 2021). Tribal leaders described resettlement as a planned act of \"cultural survival\" for a community that had already experienced decades of land loss. The Lowlander Center was founded in 2010 and incorporated in 2013 specifically to support this Tribal-driven proactive planning (Jessee 2022).\n\nThe receipt of federal funding was tied reactively to Hurricane Isaac (August 28, 2012), which served as the qualifying disaster for the HUD National Disaster Resilience Competition. The Isaac landfall date defines program eligibility cutoffs for displaced former residents, and the NDRC competition itself was structured as a post-disaster resilience investment (OCD 2020b; OCD 2021). The OCD Background & Overview notes explicitly: \"This date marks Hurricane Isaac's landfall, which qualified the Resettlement for funding through HUD's National Disaster Resilience Competition\" (OCD 2021, p. 5).\n\nThe broader Louisiana Coastal Master Plans analyzed by Birch et al. (2024) were largely reactive in framing β responding to the compounded disasters of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita (2005) and subsequent major storms β though they did increasingly advocate for proactive relocation planning over time.\n\n**Coding:** Both **Reactive** and **Proactive** apply. The Tribal-driven planning was proactive (anticipatory risk reduction before catastrophic loss); the federal funding mechanism was reactive to a qualifying disaster event (Hurricane Isaac). The auditor's finding that the narrative should not overemphasize hurricane events as direct triggers for the project itself is accepted: hurricanes were contextual urgency factors, not the initiating trigger of the resettlement concept.\n\n---\n\n### Date, Number of households affected, Number of population affected, Total funding\n\n**Answer:**\n\n- **Date of HUD grant award:** January 25, 2016 (OCD 2017)\n- **Date of program launch:** March 9, 2019 (OCD 2020b)\n- **Date of New Isle site purchase:** December 28, 2018 (OCD 2021)\n- **Date of Planning Commission approval:** February 21, 2019 (OCD 2021)\n- **Households affected:** 26 active residential units housed 37 households and 99 total residents as of the October 2016 Phase I census (OCD 2017). Program materials identify up to 42 eligible households across all option categories (OCD 2020b; Simms et al. 2021). By later sources, 37 of 42 eligible households had applied (Simms et al. 2021).\n- **Population affected:** Approximately 99 residents on the Island at time of Phase I engagement (2016) (OCD 2017). The broader eligible community including off-Island displaced former residents is larger but not precisely quantified in the reviewed sources.\n- **Total funding:** $48.3 million (precisely $48,379,249) in HUD Community Development Block Grant β National Disaster Resilience (CDBG-NDR) funds for the IDJC Resettlement, part of a larger $92.6 million Louisiana NDRC award that also funded the LA SAFE planning process ($39.75 million) (OCD 2021; OCD 2020b; Birch et al. 2024).\n\n---\n\n### What is the occurrence of the hazard(s) considered in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **Multiple Hazards.**\n\n**Narrative:** The retreat decision addresses several interacting hazards: chronic coastal land loss through erosion and subsidence, sea-level rise, regular flooding of Island Road (the sole access route), hurricane storm surge, and saltwater intrusion that kills vegetation and accelerates wetland loss. These operate concurrently and in a compounding relationship. Louisiana's 2017 Coastal Master Plan included Isle de Jean Charles on a list of eleven locations that would experience flooding \"high enough to make daily life next to impossible, even without future hurricane damage\" (Jessee 2022, citing Clipp et al. 2017). This is coded as **Multiple Hazards** because multiple distinct hazard types drive the retreat decision simultaneously and interact in a cascading manner.\n\n---\n\n### What is the origin of the hazards considered in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **Natural Hazard** (primary), with significant anthropogenic exacerbation that is best characterized as accelerating natural processes rather than constituting an independent technological hazard.\n\n**Narrative:** The primary hazard processes β coastal subsidence, sea-level rise, wetland erosion, and hurricane storm surge β are natural in origin. However, they are substantially exacerbated by anthropogenic activities: levee construction since the early eighteenth century (cutting off sediment replenishment), oil and gas extraction (over 220,000 wells drilled in Louisiana; thousands of kilometers of canals cut through wetlands, enabling saltwater intrusion and subsidence), and the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill (Jessee 2022; Soundararajan 2022). These factors are described in sources as \"development-induced disaster\" (Jessee 2022).\n\nThe codebook defines **Technological Hazard** as \"related to the built environment and human technologies (industrial accident, dam collapse, oil spill, etc.)\" and **Natural Hazard** as natural processes such as earthquakes. The anthropogenic factors here are better characterized as exacerbating natural hazard processes rather than constituting an independent technological hazard event. Accordingly, the primary and most accurate coding is **Natural Hazard**, with narrative note of the substantial anthropogenic exacerbation. The auditor's correction on this point is accepted: overstating Technological Hazard as equally applicable was not warranted by the codebook definitions or source evidence.\n\n**Coding:** **Natural Hazard** (primary), with explanatory note of anthropogenic exacerbation throughout the narrative.\n\n---\n\n### Was this hazard considered in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **Coastal Flooding/Erosion** (primary); **Hurricane** (secondary); **Land Subsidence** (contributing).\n\n**Narrative:** The dominant hazard framing throughout all sources is coastal land loss through erosion and sea-level rise, classified here as **Coastal Flooding/Erosion**. The Island is surrounded by saltwater; its protective wetlands have largely disappeared; and storm surge and tidal flooding regularly inundate Island Road. The OCD documents state: \"The sole connecting road to the mainland β Island Road, built in 1953 β is often impassable due to high winds, tides, sea level rise or storm surge\" (OCD 2020a). **Hurricane** events are consistently cited as triggers of displacement and amplifiers of ongoing land loss β Katrina (2005), Gustav and Ike (2008), Isaac (2012), and Ida (2021) are all referenced (Jessee 2022; Soundararajan 2022; Birch et al. 2024). **Land Subsidence** is explicitly identified as a contributing process, driven by both natural deltaic dynamics and oil and gas extraction (Jessee 2022). Riverine or pluvial flooding is not the primary driver and is not separately coded.\n\n---\n\n### What was the geographic scale of the MR project?\n\n**Answer:** **Entire community** and **Individual homes.**\n\n**Narrative:** The resettlement is designed as a community-scale relocation β the entire permanent residential population of Isle de Jean Charles is the intended beneficiary, and the program involves the co-design and construction of a new settlement (\"The New Isle\") as a unified community development of approximately 120 lots (OCD 2021). This is not a neighborhood within a larger municipality but rather an entire small community (fewer than 100 people at time of program launch). At the same time, the program also offers individual households the option to receive homebuyer assistance toward purchasing an existing home elsewhere in Louisiana outside the 100-year floodplain (Option D), operating at the individual household level. The community scale is the primary design intent; individual assistance is an option for those who prefer not to join the new community. Both **Entire community** and **Individual homes** apply.\n\n---\n\n### Who or what was retreated?\n\n**Answer:** **Individuals** and **Groups/Neighbourhoods** (functioning as a community).\n\n**Narrative:** The primary beneficiaries are individual households and families β permanent residents and eligible displaced former residents of Isle de Jean Charles. However, the retreat is explicitly designed to maintain and reconstruct community cohesion: one of the stated goals is to \"create an opportunity for past island residents to rejoin the community in its new location\" and to co-design the new community with current and former residents (OCD 2021). The design process sought to replicate Island social patterns, lot spacing, density, and cultural identity at The New Isle. Thus, the retreat operates at both the individual household level and the community/group level. **Individuals** and **Groups/Neighbourhoods** (or communities) both apply. No retreat of critical infrastructure, hazard protection structures, or industrial assets is documented in the reviewed sources.\n\n---" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "case_id": "CS1", | |
| "chunk_index": 2, | |
| "section": "institutional_environment", | |
| "location": "Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana", | |
| "country": "USA", | |
| "country_normalized": "United States", | |
| "continent": "North America", | |
| "admin_area": "Louisiana", | |
| "source": "Pipeline Ver2 β Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement", | |
| "source_links": [ | |
| { | |
| "title": "Simms, J. R., Waller, H., Brunet, C., Jenkins, P., & Kofler, J. (2021). The long goodbye on a disappearing, ancestral island: A just retreat from Isle de Jean Charles. Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 11, 316-328. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "doi": "10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Jessee, N. (2022). Reshaping Louisiana's coastal frontier: Managed retreat as colonial decontextualization. Journal of Political Ecology.", | |
| "url": "https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/jpe/article/id/2835/" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (2021). Program development for the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement: Phase 2 report.", | |
| "url": "https://isledejeancharles.la.gov/sites/default/files/public/IDJC_Phase2Report_7-21-21.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Soundararajan, N. (2022). Evaluating the implementation of the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project [Master's thesis, University of Chicago].", | |
| "url": "https://knowledge.uchicago.edu/record/4964/files/Soundararajan_2022_Final_Thesis.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (n.d.). Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project.", | |
| "url": "https://locd.la.gov/programs/isle-de-jean-charles-resettlement-project" | |
| } | |
| ], | |
| "text": "Case study: Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement (Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana, USA)\nSection: INSTITUTIONAL ENVIRONMENT\n\n---\n\n### What is the focus or scope of the MR project?\n\n**Answer:** **Community buyout/retreat** (primary), with elements of **Individual buyout/retreat** (Option D) and a note that this is a modified community resettlement model β participation is not contingent upon a standard buyout of Island property.\n\n**Narrative:** The IDJC Resettlement is designed as a collective community relocation β a coordinated, master-planned resettlement of an entire community to a purpose-built new settlement. This aligns with the codebook definition of **Community buyout/retreat**: \"collective relocation of a neighborhood or settlement through coordinated planning and community engagement.\" The program also includes **Individual buyout/retreat** elements through Option D, which provides homebuyer assistance to individual households purchasing existing homes in Louisiana outside the new community.\n\nImportantly, the program explicitly departs from the standard buyout model: \"participation in the resettlement is not contingent upon a buyout. In other words, no one must give up their island home or property to receive assistance through the resettlement\" (OCD 2021, p. 46). This is a material program innovation β Island property is not purchased by the state, but instead restricted in use through a Homeowner Assistance Agreement. The primary coding remains **Community buyout/retreat** with the explicit qualification that this is a modified resettlement model without mandatory property purchase, and with **Individual buyout/retreat** as a secondary element via Option D.\n\n---\n\n### What legal constraints or requirements were identified during the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** Multiple legal issues are documented: **Relevant regulations/acts**, **Home acquisition**, **Land acquisition**, **Title(s) transfer**, **Compliance & enforcement**, **Legal authority over retreat**, and **Other** (Fair Housing Act constraints; federal tribal recognition issues).\n\n**Narrative:**\n\n- **Relevant regulations/acts:** HUD's CDBG-NDR regulations govern the entire program, including cost reasonableness requirements (2 CFR 200.403, 200.404) and the Fair Housing Act (FHA). The National Environmental Policy Act required environmental review before site acquisition. HUD regulations generally require vacated land to become permanent open space β a requirement the program innovatively modified to allow residents to retain ownership and cultural use of Island properties (OCD 2020a; OCD 2021).\n\n- **Home acquisition / Land acquisition:** The LLT acquired the 515-acre Evergreen site on behalf of the state (purchase price $11.7 million, option entered March 5, 2018, closed December 28, 2018) (OCD 2021). Program Option D facilitates individual home acquisition by participants within Louisiana. Complex land tenure on the Island β where Apache Corporation holds title to extensive holdings and many residents lease rather than own their land β is flagged as a complicating factor (Jessee 2022; OCD 2017).\n\n- **Title(s) transfer:** Option A participants receive title to a new home in The New Isle through a forgivable mortgage (100% of appraised value, forgiven at 20% per year over five years with primary residency compliance) (OCD 2020b; OCD 2021). Homeowner Assistance Agreements govern Island property, restricting residential use and most substantial repairs without requiring full title transfer to the state (OCD 2020a; OCD 2020b).\n\n- **Compliance & enforcement:** Participants must maintain homestead exemption, required insurance, and primary residency for five years under forgivable mortgage terms or face default; violation can trigger foreclosure on the new community home (OCD 2020b).\n\n- **Legal authority over retreat:** The lack of federal recognition of both the BCC Tribe and the United Houma Nation created significant constraints. Federally unrecognized tribes cannot directly access FEMA or Bureau of Indian Affairs resources, making reliance on state-administered federal block grants necessary (Soundararajan 2022). State officials cited the Fair Housing Act as precluding Tribe-exclusive programming; Tribal leaders disputed these legal interpretations and pointed to precedent of Fair Housing Act waivers in other contexts (Jessee 2022; OCD 2020a).\n\n- **Other:** The Fair Housing Act was invoked by OCD to open program eligibility to all Island residents regardless of tribal affiliation, rejecting the Tribe's request for a Tribe-exclusive program (OCD 2020a; Jessee 2022). This is a deeply contested legal interpretation documented in detail by Jessee (2022). Inheritance laws and complex multi-sibling land ownership on the Island were flagged in the Phase I report as complicating eligibility verification (OCD 2017).\n\n**Note on Land Rezoning:** The auditor correctly identified that Terrebonne Parish Planning Commission approval of the master plan (February 21, 2019) is more accurately characterized as a subdivision/site plan approval than a zoning reclassification. Accordingly, **Land rezoning** is not coded; the Planning Commission approval is captured under Relevant regulations/acts and local permitting requirements.\n\n---\n\n### What were the funding sources for the MR project?\n\n**Answer:** **Federal only** for the resettlement program itself.\n\n**Narrative:** The primary and effectively sole funding source for the IDJC Resettlement is a $48,379,249 HUD CDBG-NDR award (OCD 2021). The State of Louisiana (OCD) administered the grant, contributing state administrative capacity but not independently funding the resettlement. The Louisiana Housing Corporation administered the ORA program within the broader state structure. The Lowlander Center (nonprofit) supported early Tribal planning and contributed to the NDRC application, but was not a program funder. The Rockefeller Foundation co-sponsored the NDRC competition design at a national level, not as a project-level funder. BP Oil Spill settlement funds ($3 million via the Louisiana Trustee Implementation Group) funded fishing pier improvements on Island Road β a distinct project from the resettlement itself (Jessee 2022; Birch et al. 2024).\n\n**Coding:** **Federal only** for the resettlement program. The auditor's correction is accepted: coding \"Multiple funders\" for the resettlement project itself was not warranted β the state is an administrator, not an independent funder, and other entities funded ancillary activities rather than the resettlement program. The broader NDRC ecosystem (LA SAFE + IDJC together) involved $92.6 million in federal funds.\n\n---\n\n### What was considered to maintain (or improve) the tax base in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **New housing for BO recipients** and **Livelihoods supports.**\n\n**Narrative:** The master plan for The New Isle explicitly incorporates commercial and retail development to generate revenue and support economic sustainability. A market analysis identified revenue-generating opportunities including assisted living, light manufacturing, regional retail, local retail, plant nurseries, a farmers' market, RV/boat storage, and a solar farm, estimating potential for over $400,000 in annual revenue using a ground lease structure (OCD 2021). OCD documents explicitly state a goal to \"ensure that the community is economically sustainable in its new location\" (OCD 2021). The program also includes workforce development and job training programs as Phase III activities (OCD 2021).\n\nNew homes provided to eligible Option A participants contribute to the Terrebonne Parish property tax base at the receiving location. New homes are assessed at over $250,000 with estimated annual property taxes of approximately $1,700 after homestead exemption (OCD 2021).\n\n**Redevelopment of retreat lands** is not coded for the Island itself: the stated plan is to \"return the island's residential parcels to nature\" through hazardous waste removal, utility disconnection, and structure removal β leaving the Island \"in a state of rest\" (OCD 2021). This is the opposite of revenue-generating redevelopment, though Jessee (2022) and Soundararajan (2022) document a governance failure in which a local development firm sought to sell recreational lots on the Island, prompting public objection from Chief Naquin. The auditor's correction to remove \"Redevelopment of retreat lands\" from Island-side coding is accepted.\n\n**Coding:** **New housing for BO recipients** and **Livelihoods supports**; commercial development at the new site may qualify under a broader reading of tax base maintenance but is primarily coded as livelihoods support.\n\n---\n\n### What level/type of compensation mechanisms were considered in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **Free supports and services** (primary); **Other** (Island property retention policy; forgivable mortgage as full grant mechanism).\n\n**Narrative:** The IDJC Resettlement does not provide cash compensation for the Island property left behind. CDBG regulations explicitly list \"compensation payments\" as an ineligible activity (OCD 2020b). Instead, the program provides:\n\n- **Free supports and services (primary):** Eligible Option A households receive a new home built at The New Isle at no cost, with all closing costs covered and moving expenses covered at flat rates by household size (OCD 2020b). This constitutes non-monetary assistance β house provision, not purchase price compensation.\n\n- **Other β forgivable mortgage as effective grant:** Participants receive a forgivable mortgage valued at 100% of the new property's appraised value (Option A) or the amount of assistance awarded (Option D, up to $200,000), forgiven at 20% per year over five years with primary residency compliance β effectively a full grant of the new home if requirements are met (OCD 2020b; OCD 2021). Under Option D, homebuyer assistance up to $200,000 is provided toward purchasing an existing home in Louisiana.\n\n- **Other β innovative Island property retention:** Rather than requiring residents to sell or abandon Island properties (as in standard buyout programs), participants may retain ownership and cultural/recreational use of Island properties. This is described as \"a marked departure from traditional HUD-funded relocation programs\" (OCD 2020a; OCD 2021; Simms et al. 2021) and was a direct response to residents' non-negotiable insistence on keeping their ancestral land.\n\nThe auditor's correction is accepted: the forgivable mortgage is the core financial structure of the grant mechanism, not an \"additional incentive, bonus, or top-up\" in the usual sense. It is more accurately coded as **Free supports and services** (the new home itself) and **Other** (the forgivable mortgage structure and Island property retention policy). **Additional incentives, bonuses and top-ups** is not applied as a primary code.\n\n---" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "case_id": "CS1", | |
| "chunk_index": 3, | |
| "section": "planning_processes", | |
| "location": "Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana", | |
| "country": "USA", | |
| "country_normalized": "United States", | |
| "continent": "North America", | |
| "admin_area": "Louisiana", | |
| "source": "Pipeline Ver2 β Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement", | |
| "source_links": [ | |
| { | |
| "title": "Simms, J. R., Waller, H., Brunet, C., Jenkins, P., & Kofler, J. (2021). The long goodbye on a disappearing, ancestral island: A just retreat from Isle de Jean Charles. Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 11, 316-328. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "doi": "10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5", | |
| "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00682-5" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Jessee, N. (2022). Reshaping Louisiana's coastal frontier: Managed retreat as colonial decontextualization. Journal of Political Ecology.", | |
| "url": "https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/jpe/article/id/2835/" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (2021). Program development for the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement: Phase 2 report.", | |
| "url": "https://isledejeancharles.la.gov/sites/default/files/public/IDJC_Phase2Report_7-21-21.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Soundararajan, N. (2022). Evaluating the implementation of the Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project [Master's thesis, University of Chicago].", | |
| "url": "https://knowledge.uchicago.edu/record/4964/files/Soundararajan_2022_Final_Thesis.pdf" | |
| }, | |
| { | |
| "title": "Louisiana Office of Community Development. (n.d.). Isle de Jean Charles resettlement project.", | |
| "url": "https://locd.la.gov/programs/isle-de-jean-charles-resettlement-project" | |
| } | |
| ], | |
| "text": "Case study: Isle de Jean Charles Resettlement (Isle de Jean Charles, Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana, USA)\nSection: PLANNING PROCESSES\n\n---\n\n### What is the time horizon considered in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **Pre-retreat planning**, **Immediate risks: 1β5 years**, **Anticipated future risks: 10β100 years**, and **Post-retreat follow-up.**\n\n**Narrative:** The program involves extensive pre-retreat planning (Phases I and II, 2016β2019) including data gathering, site selection, master planning, environmental review, and policy development. The risks driving the retreat are both immediate (Island Road regularly floods, blocking access to work, school, and emergency services; the road was described as approaching impassability) and long-term (sea-level rise and land loss projections over decades). Louisiana's Coastal Master Plans and LA SAFE framework explicitly model 50-year and 100-year flood scenarios; the 2017 Coastal Master Plan included the Island among eleven locations where flooding would make daily life impossible (Jessee 2022; Birch et al. 2024). The program anticipates ongoing land loss that will eventually render the Island uninhabitable.\n\nPost-retreat follow-up is built into program structure through ongoing case management (Franklin & Associates; Start Corporation), the ORA transitional housing program, five-year occupancy monitoring and forgivable mortgage compliance, and intended community governance via a nonprofit and homeowners' association (OCD 2021). The Phase 2 Report notes that \"The New Isle is intended to allow for additional development to occur in subsequent phases over a longer period of time,\" indicating multi-generational planning intent (OCD 2021).\n\n---\n\n### What planning elements were considered in the MR decision process?\n\n**Answer:** **Top-down**, **Bottom-up/Participatory/collaborative** (contested in implementation), **Multi-sectoral**, **Multi-stage retreat**, **Degree of transparency**, **Coordination with other sectors and jurisdictions**, **Adaptive management**.\n\n**Narrative:**\n\n- **Top-down:** OCD led the planning process and held final decision-making authority. HUD set the regulatory framework. The state administered funding and made final policy determinations. Jessee (2022) documents how the state progressively centralized control despite Tribal leadership's prior ownership of the resettlement vision, and how state planners characterized their goal as creating a \"scalable and replicable model\" rather than honoring Tribal-specific aims.\n\n- **Bottom-up / Participatory/collaborative:** Multiple community meetings (at least six in Phase II), household interviews, three design charrettes, a nine-member Steering Committee (including five Island residents and representatives from BCC and UHN), and weekly Island visits were conducted (OCD 2021; Simms et al. 2021). Residents shaped site selection, house design, lot spacing, street naming, and the community name. However, Jessee (2022) argues the state used community engagement tactically while progressively marginalizing Tribal authority; Birch et al. (2024) note that LA SAFE \"stopped short of suggesting shared authority where community members led.\" The participatory elements are documented and real, but genuinely contested in their depth and authenticity.\n\n- **Multi-sectoral:** The planning team included engineers, architects, landscape planners, economists, social scientists, legal counsel, community engagement specialists, geotechnical experts, environmental assessors, and American Indian advisors (OCD 2021).\n\n- **Multi-stage retreat:** The program proceeds in four phases (Data Gathering; Site Selection/Master Planning; Development/Construction; Living in New Community). The ORA transitional housing program accommodated residents who moved in advance of house completion.\n\n- **Degree of transparency:** Stated commitment to transparency; land use data made publicly available online; policy documents and program options published (OCD 2017; OCD 2021). However, Tribal leaders and researchers documented instances of insufficient transparency β particularly around the Data Gathering report (which Tribal leaders characterized as a \"divide and conquer\" strategy), grant amendments, and the timeline of land acquisition (Jessee 2022; Soundararajan 2022).\n\n- **Coordination with other sectors and jurisdictions:** Terrebonne Parish (planning approval, road maintenance), Louisiana Housing Corporation (ORA program), LLT (land acquisition), HUD (federal oversight), and multiple state agencies. Cross-agency coordination was noted as a persistent challenge β for example, CPRA spent $3 million improving Island Road while OCD was conducting the resettlement, suggesting different agencies working at cross-purposes (Birch et al. 2024; Jessee 2022).\n\n- **Adaptive management:** Program policies were iteratively revised through six versions of the Program Policies document, and the Island property mortgage requirement was modified following community advocacy β originally proposed as a 40-year mortgage, ultimately replaced with the Homeowner Assistance Agreement (Jessee 2022; OCD 2020b).\n\n- **Cost-benefit analysis (CBA):** CBA is **not** coded as a planning element for the IDJC resettlement project itself. The Phase 2 Report explicitly states: \"Given the complex nature of resettlement, this process cannot be evaluated by a simple cost-benefit analysis" | |
| } | |
| ] |