ar9avg's picture
Clamp every grader return value strictly inside (0, 1)
98b87b7
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
10.4 kB
"""
Task definitions for the SQL agent benchmark.
Three difficulty tiers, each with 5 questions and a grader function.
Grader contract: grader(sql, rows, error, attempts) -> float strictly in (0, 1)
- rows: list[dict] from the executed SQL (may be empty)
- error: str | None
- attempts: int (1-indexed count of attempts taken)
All graders return values strictly in (_EPS, 1 - _EPS) so no path can
emit exact 0.0 or 1.0.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import re
from dataclasses import dataclass, field
from typing import Callable, Optional
from env.database import execute_query
# ─── Score clamping (strictly in (0, 1)) ──────────────────────────
_EPS = 0.05 # margin so :.2f/:.3f formatting never rounds to 0.00 or 1.00
def _clamp(x: float) -> float:
"""Clamp to strictly (0, 1). NaN/None β†’ 0.5."""
if x is None or x != x: # None or NaN
return 0.5
return max(_EPS, min(1.0 - _EPS, float(x)))
# ─── Task Definitions ─────────────────────────────────────────────
@dataclass
class TaskQuestion:
id: str
question: str
expected_columns: list[str] # at least these columns should appear
min_rows: int # minimum expected rows
max_rows: Optional[int] = None # None = no upper bound
hint_tables: list[str] = field(default_factory=list) # tables that must be touched
@dataclass
class Task:
id: str
name: str
difficulty: str # "easy" | "medium" | "hard"
description: str
questions: list[TaskQuestion]
grader: Callable # grader(question, sql, rows, error, attempts) -> float
# ─── Grader Helpers ───────────────────────────────────────────────
def _has_required_columns(rows: list[dict], required: list[str]) -> bool:
if not rows:
return False
row_keys = {k.lower() for k in rows[0].keys()}
return all(col.lower() in row_keys for col in required)
def _row_count_score(rows: list[dict], min_rows: int, max_rows: Optional[int]) -> float:
"""Returns a raw score in [0, 1]; graders must clamp before returning."""
n = len(rows)
if n == 0:
return 0.0
if n >= min_rows:
if max_rows is None or n <= max_rows:
return 1.0
return 0.5
return 0.5 * (n / min_rows)
# ─── Task 1: Simple Queries (Easy) ────────────────────────────────
_SIMPLE_QUESTIONS = [
TaskQuestion(
id="sq-01",
question="List all users from the USA.",
expected_columns=["name", "email", "country"],
min_rows=10,
max_rows=25,
hint_tables=["users"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="sq-02",
question="Show all products in the 'Electronics' category with their prices.",
expected_columns=["name", "price"],
min_rows=8,
max_rows=20,
hint_tables=["products"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="sq-03",
question="Find all orders with status 'delivered'.",
expected_columns=["id", "status"],
min_rows=30,
max_rows=50,
hint_tables=["orders"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="sq-04",
question="List all sellers and their countries.",
expected_columns=["name", "country"],
min_rows=10,
max_rows=10,
hint_tables=["sellers"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="sq-05",
question="Show all reviews with a rating of 5 stars.",
expected_columns=["rating"],
min_rows=15,
max_rows=35,
hint_tables=["reviews"],
),
]
def _grade_simple(
question: TaskQuestion,
sql: str,
rows: list[dict],
error: Optional[str],
attempts: int,
) -> float:
if error:
return _clamp(0.0)
col_ok = _has_required_columns(rows, question.expected_columns)
row_score = _row_count_score(rows, question.min_rows, question.max_rows)
if col_ok and row_score == 1.0:
return _clamp(1.0)
if col_ok or row_score >= 0.5:
return _clamp(0.5)
return _clamp(0.0)
_TASK_SIMPLE = Task(
id="simple_queries",
name="Simple Queries",
difficulty="easy",
description="Single-table SELECT queries with basic filters.",
questions=_SIMPLE_QUESTIONS,
grader=_grade_simple,
)
# ─── Task 2: Join Queries (Medium) ────────────────────────────────
_JOIN_QUESTIONS = [
TaskQuestion(
id="jq-01",
question="Show the total number of orders per user, including the user's name.",
expected_columns=["name"],
min_rows=10,
hint_tables=["users", "orders"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="jq-02",
question="List products along with the name of their seller.",
expected_columns=["name", "name"], # product name + seller name both called 'name'
min_rows=20,
hint_tables=["products", "sellers"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="jq-03",
question="Find the average rating for each product category.",
expected_columns=["category"],
min_rows=5,
max_rows=10,
hint_tables=["products", "reviews"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="jq-04",
question="Show the total revenue (sum of total_price) per seller.",
expected_columns=["name"],
min_rows=5,
hint_tables=["sellers", "products", "orders"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="jq-05",
question="List the top 5 most reviewed products with their review counts.",
expected_columns=["name"],
min_rows=5,
max_rows=5,
hint_tables=["products", "reviews"],
),
]
def _grade_join(
question: TaskQuestion,
sql: str,
rows: list[dict],
error: Optional[str],
attempts: int,
) -> float:
if error:
return _clamp(0.0)
col_ok = _has_required_columns(rows, [question.expected_columns[0]])
row_score = _row_count_score(rows, question.min_rows, question.max_rows)
base = 0.0
if col_ok and row_score == 1.0:
base = 1.0
elif col_ok or row_score >= 0.5:
base = 0.5
attempt_penalty = max(0.0, 0.1 * (attempts - 1))
return _clamp(base - attempt_penalty)
_TASK_JOIN = Task(
id="join_queries",
name="Join Queries",
difficulty="medium",
description="Multi-table JOINs with GROUP BY and aggregation.",
questions=_JOIN_QUESTIONS,
grader=_grade_join,
)
# ─── Task 3: Complex Queries (Hard) ───────────────────────────────
_COMPLEX_QUESTIONS = [
TaskQuestion(
id="cq-01",
question=(
"Find users who have placed more than 1 order, showing their name "
"and total number of orders, ordered by order count descending."
),
expected_columns=["name"],
min_rows=1,
hint_tables=["users", "orders"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="cq-02",
question=(
"For each product category, show the category name, number of products, "
"average price, and total stock. Use a CTE."
),
expected_columns=["category"],
min_rows=5,
max_rows=10,
hint_tables=["products"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="cq-03",
question=(
"Show each seller's name, their total sales revenue, and rank them "
"by revenue using a window function (RANK() or ROW_NUMBER())."
),
expected_columns=["name"],
min_rows=5,
hint_tables=["sellers", "products", "orders"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="cq-04",
question=(
"Find the top-rated product in each category (highest average review rating). "
"Show category, product name, and average rating."
),
expected_columns=["category", "name"],
min_rows=5,
max_rows=10,
hint_tables=["products", "reviews"],
),
TaskQuestion(
id="cq-05",
question=(
"Calculate the month-over-month order count for 2024, showing year, "
"month, order_count, and a running total."
),
expected_columns=["month"],
min_rows=6,
max_rows=12,
hint_tables=["orders"],
),
]
def _grade_complex(
question: TaskQuestion,
sql: str,
rows: list[dict],
error: Optional[str],
attempts: int,
) -> float:
if error:
return _clamp(0.0)
col_ok = _has_required_columns(rows, question.expected_columns)
row_score = _row_count_score(rows, question.min_rows, question.max_rows)
if not col_ok or row_score == 0.0:
return _clamp(0.0)
if row_score == 1.0 and col_ok:
base = 0.8 + (0.2 if attempts == 1 else 0.0)
else:
base = 0.4
attempt_penalty = 0.1 * (attempts - 1)
return _clamp(base - attempt_penalty)
_TASK_COMPLEX = Task(
id="complex_queries",
name="Complex Queries",
difficulty="hard",
description="CTEs, window functions, and nested aggregations.",
questions=_COMPLEX_QUESTIONS,
grader=_grade_complex,
)
# ─── Registry ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────
TASKS: dict[str, Task] = {
"simple_queries": _TASK_SIMPLE,
"join_queries": _TASK_JOIN,
"complex_queries": _TASK_COMPLEX,
}
def get_task(task_id: str) -> Task:
if task_id not in TASKS:
raise ValueError(f"Unknown task_id: {task_id!r}. Valid: {list(TASKS)}")
return TASKS[task_id]
def get_all_tasks() -> list[Task]:
return list(TASKS.values())
def grade_response(
task_id: str,
question_id: str,
sql: str,
rows: list[dict],
error: Optional[str],
attempts: int,
) -> float:
task = get_task(task_id)
question = next((q for q in task.questions if q.id == question_id), None)
if question is None:
raise ValueError(f"Unknown question_id {question_id!r} in task {task_id!r}")
# Graders already clamp internally; this is a final safety net.
return _clamp(task.grader(question, sql, rows, error, attempts))