Spaces:
Sleeping
Sleeping
| #!/usr/bin/env python3 | |
| # -*- coding: utf-8 -*- | |
| """Validate structured evidence, domain invariants, and human science approval. | |
| Pass a domain-specific topic.json containing claims, scenes and assertion checks. | |
| This deliberately refuses to claim a diagram has been proved correct by a string check. | |
| """ | |
| import argparse,json,re,sys | |
| from pathlib import Path | |
| from domain_router import route | |
| def review(topic, require_review=False): | |
| errors=[];warnings=[] | |
| title=topic.get('title','') | |
| domain=topic.get('topic',topic.get('domain')) | |
| resolved=route(title,domain if domain in ('astronomy','biology','physics','chemistry','geography','general') else None) | |
| ids=set() | |
| for c in topic.get('claims',[]): | |
| if isinstance(c,list): | |
| if len(c)<3:errors.append('claims entry incomplete');continue | |
| cid,statement,url=c[0:3] | |
| else: | |
| cid,statement,url=c.get('id'),c.get('statement'),c.get('sources',[]) | |
| if cid in ids:errors.append(f'duplicate claim id: {cid}') | |
| ids.add(cid) | |
| if not statement:errors.append(f'{cid}: missing statement') | |
| urls=[url] if isinstance(url,str) else url | |
| if not urls or not all(re.match(r'^https://',u) for u in urls):errors.append(f'{cid}: no attributable HTTPS source') | |
| if len(ids)<2:errors.append('At least two independent source-traced claims are needed') | |
| scenes=topic.get('scenes',[]) | |
| if len(scenes)<5:errors.append('Insufficient scenes; need observable mechanism and recap') | |
| for i,sc in enumerate(scenes): | |
| if isinstance(sc,list):continue | |
| if not sc.get('text') and not sc.get('lines'):errors.append(f'scene[{i}]: no voiced scientific explanation') | |
| if not sc.get('heading'):errors.append(f'scene[{i}]: missing teaching title') | |
| if not sc.get('role') and not sc.get('lines'):errors.append(f'scene[{i}]: missing voice role') | |
| tags=set(topic.get('mechanism_tags',[])) | |
| req=set(resolved['required_mechanism_tags']) | |
| if not tags: warnings.append('Mechanism tags not recorded. Must review scene-to-claim alignment by hand.') | |
| elif req-tags:errors.append('Missing domain-specific mechanisms: '+', '.join(sorted(req-tags))) | |
| approvals=topic.get('science_review',{}) | |
| if not approvals.get('visual_truth_approved'): | |
| warnings.append('Human reviewed diagram truth not signed') | |
| if require_review:errors.append('Publication requires explicit human diagram review') | |
| if not approvals.get('sources_opened'): | |
| warnings.append('Sources are listed but not marked as inspected') | |
| if require_review:errors.append('Publication requires opened sources') | |
| if not approvals.get('misconceptions_checked'): | |
| warnings.append('Misconception checklist not acknowledged') | |
| if require_review:errors.append('Publication requires misconception audit') | |
| result={'domain':resolved['domain'],'science_structural_pass':not errors,'manual_approval_required':True,'hard_errors':errors,'warnings':warnings,'required_diagram_invariants':resolved['required_mechanism_tags']} | |
| return result | |
| if __name__=='__main__': | |
| p=argparse.ArgumentParser();p.add_argument('--topic',required=True);p.add_argument('--publish',action='store_true');p.add_argument('--output');a=p.parse_args() | |
| result=review(json.loads(Path(a.topic).read_text(encoding='utf-8')),a.publish) | |
| if a.output:Path(a.output).write_text(json.dumps(result,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2),encoding='utf-8') | |
| print(json.dumps(result,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2));sys.exit(0 if result['science_structural_pass'] else 2) | |