solidprivacy commited on
Commit
cdc3709
·
1 Parent(s): 062eb6e

remove prematurely adopted WP04 claim from active tree

Browse files
workpackage_claims/SCRUB-WP_REPOSITORY_CONVERGENCE_ISSUE_STATE_RECONCILIATION.md DELETED
@@ -1,124 +0,0 @@
1
- # Workpackage claim — SCRUB-WP_REPOSITORY_CONVERGENCE_ISSUE_STATE_RECONCILIATION
2
-
3
- Status: release candidate; independent assurance pending
4
- Role: `implementation_operations`
5
- Issue: #119
6
- PR: #120
7
- Branch: `wp/repository-convergence-issue-state-reconciliation`
8
- Starting main: `268d967db95d923a73a3979ffce2d0cab586e499`
9
- Started: 2026-09-05 Europe/Amsterdam
10
-
11
- ## Objective
12
-
13
- Reconcile stale open GitHub issues against accepted `main` without erasing assurance history or falsely closing the one remaining deployed live-app verification gate.
14
-
15
- ## Source-derived finding
16
-
17
- At package start GitHub returned 18 open historical/current Premium/governance issues:
18
-
19
- ```text
20
- #74 #75 #76 #77
21
- #79 #81 #84 #86 #88 #89
22
- #96 #98 #100 #105
23
- #106 #107 #109 #112
24
- ```
25
-
26
- The issue set does not represent 18 current blockers.
27
-
28
- Independent evidence already present in GitHub shows:
29
-
30
- - final PR #73 recovery head received blind PASS in #77 and PR #73 merged; #74/#75/#76 are prior failed/repaired dispatch states;
31
- - Premium contract/state/staged-workspace lines were merged and later App-Shell defects were repaired by newer candidates;
32
- - fresh issue #105 assurance ultimately PASSed PR #104 V2 and PR #104 merged, technically superseding the old #93 PASS / #92 FAIL source-state conflict;
33
- - issue #109 records blind PASS for PR #108 marker/compact-placeholder repair and PR #108 is merged;
34
- - issue #112 records blind PASS for PR #111 Dutch-address precision repair and PR #111 is merged;
35
- - issue #96 explicitly remained open after those technical repairs because the required consolidated deployed live-app retest was not yet proven.
36
-
37
- ## Reviewed disposition candidate
38
-
39
- No issue mutation is authorized by implementation alone. The intended action after fresh independent PASS is:
40
-
41
- ### Keep open
42
-
43
- ```text
44
- #96
45
- ```
46
-
47
- #96 becomes the single residual current Premium/App-Shell gate. Its current description must state that PR #104, PR #108 and PR #111 are repaired/assured/merged and that the remaining requirement is one consolidated deployed live-app retest after both live-regression repairs.
48
-
49
- ### Close with evidence-aware comments
50
-
51
- ```text
52
- #74 #75 #76 #77
53
- #79 #81 #84 #86 #88 #89
54
- #98 #100 #105
55
- #106 #107 #109 #112
56
- ```
57
-
58
- These closures mean the individual candidate/repair/assurance cycles are no longer current open work. They do **not** rewrite historical FAIL/INDETERMINATE/PASS outcomes and do **not** claim #96's final live test occurred.
59
-
60
- ## Repository scope
61
-
62
- Authorized:
63
-
64
- - update `WORKPACKAGES.md` so WP-CONVERGENCE-03 is completed and WP-CONVERGENCE-04 is the one current package;
65
- - update `CHANGELOG.md` with actual PR #118 PASS/merge/exact-main evidence and this package;
66
- - update D045 status from pending candidate language to independently assured/merged;
67
- - update R6/R11/R12 current risk wording to actual merged state;
68
- - update the temporary convergence ledger with accepted main, resolved validation authority and the exact reviewed issue-disposition candidate;
69
- - add one narrow contract test for current queue and disposition invariants;
70
- - write the mandatory handover.
71
-
72
- Not authorized:
73
-
74
- - product/runtime/UI/recognizer/review/export/Scrub Key/reinsert changes;
75
- - Stage-2 persistence/AI-egress changes;
76
- - a new permanent issue ledger/framework;
77
- - closing #96 without actual live evidence;
78
- - claiming the final live retest was performed;
79
- - mutating GitHub issue state before fresh independent assurance.
80
-
81
- ## Validation history
82
-
83
- Three pre-green CI cycles exposed only contract-definition defects in the new governance test; no product/runtime code was involved:
84
-
85
- ```text
86
- run 33931758642 / job 101211615952
87
- 1 failed, 1271 passed in 8.98s
88
- cause: parser treated explanatory PR references as keep-open issue IDs
89
-
90
- run 33931829877 / job 101211823357
91
- 1 failed, 1271 passed in 8.61s
92
- cause: inconsistent residual-gate wording (live retest vs live-app retest)
93
-
94
- run 33931948111 / job 101212181362
95
- 1 failed, 1271 passed in 14.43s
96
- cause: ledger stated no evidence proved the retest but did not explicitly state status `remains unproven`
97
- ```
98
-
99
- The remediations narrowed the parser to the reviewed fenced issue lists and standardized the safety-critical residual-gate wording; the exact 17-close/1-keep disposition was not weakened.
100
-
101
- Pre-final green candidate:
102
-
103
- ```text
104
- head b33b7e765ede9b9d99586b82b846035143d3782a
105
- Tests run 33932036674
106
- job 101212447162
107
- synthetic merge candidate 3ff5521ea1ec14de277945c680a5d97cd2a96a09
108
- 1272 passed in 14.68s
109
- SUCCESS
110
- ```
111
-
112
- A final full `Tests` run is still required after the mandatory implementation handover is committed; that resulting exact SHA is the only head eligible for fresh blind assurance.
113
-
114
- ## Acceptance
115
-
116
- 1. Exactly one current executable workpackage: WP-CONVERGENCE-04.
117
- 2. PR #118/D045 is represented as PASSed/merged/exact-main verified.
118
- 3. The reviewed disposition contains exactly 17 closure candidates and exactly one retained Premium gate, #96.
119
- 4. #96 is absent from the closure set.
120
- 5. The unresolved consolidated deployed live-app retest remains explicit in WORKPACKAGES, RISK_REGISTER and the temporary ledger.
121
- 6. Existing product-risk and human-review boundaries remain unchanged.
122
- 7. Full final exact-head `Tests` is green.
123
- 8. Fresh blind `governance_release_assurance` PASSes exact candidate before merge or issue mutation.
124
- 9. After authorized merge, exact-main Tests/HF sync/path-ignore behavior is independently verified before applying/confirming issue closeout.