whassan's picture
Deploy Sensorflow Studio
93efd9d verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
18.4 kB
"""Self-evaluation: baseline vs BEV-fused labeler on identical scenes.
Generates N deterministic sequences with known ground truth, runs both
engines on the *same* sensor detection streams, evaluates both against ground
truth with the platform's existing metrics (BEV IoU from
sensorflow.metrics.perception_3d; ID-switch and fragmentation rates from
sensorflow.metrics.temporal_mot; plus nuScenes-style center-distance matching,
per-cohort recall, position error and IDF1 computed here), and produces a
comparison report mirroring the shape of the megaeval compare machinery
(headline_deltas / per-cohort deltas / policy / blockers / PROMOTE
recommendation). Every number is computed at runtime from the engine outputs.
Matching is center-distance based (2.0 m, nuScenes convention) rather than
IoU-thresholded, so the baseline's monocular depth error degrades recall and
position error smoothly instead of zeroing everything out; BEV IoU is still
reported for matched pairs.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
import math
from datetime import datetime, timezone
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, List, Optional
from uuid import uuid4
import numpy as np
from scipy.optimize import linear_sum_assignment
from sensorflow.bevfusion.engines import (
BASELINE_ENGINE, FUSED_ENGINE, run_baseline, run_fused,
)
from sensorflow.bevfusion.masklet import tracks_to_dicts
from sensorflow.bevfusion.scenes import (
SAFETY_CLASSES, SceneSequence, generate_sequences, gt_tracks,
)
from sensorflow.metrics.perception_3d import bev_iou
from sensorflow.metrics.temporal_mot import (
compute_id_swap_rate, compute_track_fragmentation_rate,
)
RUNS_DIR = Path("runs/bevfusion")
MATCH_DIST_M = 2.0
DEFAULT_POLICY = {
"max_recall_drop": 0.010,
"max_precision_drop": 0.015,
"max_safety_recall_drop": 0.005,
"max_cohort_recall_drop": 0.050,
"min_cohort_support": 20,
}
COHORT_EXPLANATIONS = {
"overall": "Fused existence evidence (noisy-OR of camera and LiDAR) plus "
"inverse-variance geometry gives higher recall and near-LiDAR "
"position accuracy wherever either sensor fires.",
"day": "Both sensors healthy: fusion mainly sharpens positions "
"(LiDAR-dominated inverse-variance weighting) and suppresses "
"single-modality ghosts at the decode threshold.",
"night": "The camera misses heavily in low light; LiDAR is unaffected by "
"darkness, so LiDAR existence evidence in the BEV grid recovers "
"the missed objects and the class comes from LiDAR geometry "
"templates or temporal continuity.",
"clear": "Nominal conditions; improvement is dominated by monocular depth "
"error being replaced by LiDAR geometry.",
"rain": "Rain degrades LiDAR at range (spray attenuation) and the camera "
"mildly; each modality covers part of the other's losses, so the "
"fused map keeps existence evidence where either survives.",
"occluded": "Camera line of sight is blocked; LiDAR (mounted higher, "
"sensing 3D structure) keeps partial returns, and masklet "
"propagation carries identity and a predicted box through the "
"remaining gap frames.",
"long_range": "Beyond ~45 m LiDAR thins out and monocular depth error "
"exceeds the match gate; fusion helps where LiDAR still "
"fires, and camera bearing keeps existence alive elsewhere.",
}
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ matching
def _match_frame(pred_boxes: List[Dict], gt_boxes: List, dist_m: float = MATCH_DIST_M):
"""Greedy center-distance matching. Returns (pairs, unmatched_pred_idx)."""
cands = []
for pi, p in enumerate(pred_boxes):
for gi, g in enumerate(gt_boxes):
d = math.hypot(p["bbox_3d"][0] - g.bbox_3d[0], p["bbox_3d"][1] - g.bbox_3d[1])
if d <= dist_m:
cands.append((d, pi, gi))
cands.sort()
used_p, used_g, pairs = set(), set(), []
for d, pi, gi in cands:
if pi in used_p or gi in used_g:
continue
pairs.append((pi, gi, d))
used_p.add(pi)
used_g.add(gi)
unmatched_pred = [i for i in range(len(pred_boxes)) if i not in used_p]
return pairs, unmatched_pred
def _gt_cohorts(gt, seq: SceneSequence) -> List[str]:
cohorts = ["overall", seq.time_of_day, seq.weather]
if gt.occluded:
cohorts.append("occluded")
if gt.distance > 40.0:
cohorts.append("long_range")
return cohorts
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ IDF1
def compute_idf1(pred_tracks: List[Dict], gt_tracks_list: List[Dict],
dist_m: float = MATCH_DIST_M) -> float:
"""IDF1 via optimal 1:1 track assignment (Hungarian on frame overlaps)."""
if not pred_tracks or not gt_tracks_list:
return 0.0
n_pred = sum(len(t["frames"]) for t in pred_tracks)
n_gt = sum(len(t["frames"]) for t in gt_tracks_list)
overlap = np.zeros((len(pred_tracks), len(gt_tracks_list)))
for i, pt in enumerate(pred_tracks):
pframes = {f["frame_id"]: f["bbox_3d"] for f in pt["frames"]}
for j, gt in enumerate(gt_tracks_list):
n = 0
for f in gt["frames"]:
pb = pframes.get(f["frame_id"])
if pb is not None and math.hypot(pb[0] - f["bbox_3d"][0],
pb[1] - f["bbox_3d"][1]) <= dist_m:
n += 1
overlap[i, j] = n
rows, cols = linear_sum_assignment(-overlap)
idtp = float(overlap[rows, cols].sum())
return round(2.0 * idtp / max(n_pred + n_gt, 1), 4)
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ engine evaluation
def evaluate_engine(sequences: List[SceneSequence],
preds_by_seq: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[Dict]]]) -> Dict:
"""Evaluate one engine's per-frame labels against ground truth."""
cohort_stats: Dict[str, Dict] = {}
class_stats: Dict[str, Dict] = {}
tp = fp = fn = 0
ious: List[float] = []
pos_errors: List[float] = []
class_correct = class_total = 0
safety_tp = safety_fn = 0
def _coh(name):
return cohort_stats.setdefault(name, {"n_gt": 0, "matched": 0,
"pos_errors": [], "ious": [], "fp": 0})
for seq in sequences:
preds = preds_by_seq[seq.sequence_id]
for frame in seq.frames:
pred_boxes = preds.get(frame.frame_id, [])
pairs, unmatched_pred = _match_frame(pred_boxes, frame.gt)
matched_gt = {gi for _, gi, _ in pairs}
for pi, gi, d in pairs:
p, g = pred_boxes[pi], frame.gt[gi]
tp += 1
iou = bev_iou(p["bbox_3d"], g.bbox_3d)
ious.append(iou)
pos_errors.append(d)
class_total += 1
if p["class_name"] == g.class_name:
class_correct += 1
if g.class_name in SAFETY_CLASSES:
safety_tp += 1
cs = class_stats.setdefault(g.class_name, {"n_gt": 0, "matched": 0})
cs["n_gt"] += 1
cs["matched"] += 1
for name in _gt_cohorts(g, seq):
c = _coh(name)
c["n_gt"] += 1
c["matched"] += 1
c["pos_errors"].append(d)
c["ious"].append(iou)
for gi, g in enumerate(frame.gt):
if gi in matched_gt:
continue
fn += 1
if g.class_name in SAFETY_CLASSES:
safety_fn += 1
class_stats.setdefault(g.class_name, {"n_gt": 0, "matched": 0})["n_gt"] += 1
for name in _gt_cohorts(g, seq):
_coh(name)["n_gt"] += 1
for pi in unmatched_pred:
fp += 1
_coh("overall")["fp"] += 1
_coh(seq.time_of_day)["fp"] += 1
_coh(seq.weather)["fp"] += 1
precision = tp / (tp + fp) if tp + fp else 0.0
recall = tp / (tp + fn) if tp + fn else 0.0
f1 = 2 * precision * recall / (precision + recall) if precision + recall else 0.0
# Tracking metrics via the platform's temporal MOT module + IDF1.
# Track ids restart per sequence (one tracker per sequence), so namespace
# them with the sequence id before pooling.
pred_tracks: List[Dict] = []
for seq in sequences:
for t in tracks_to_dicts(preds_by_seq[seq.sequence_id]):
t["track_id"] = f"{seq.sequence_id}:{t['track_id']}"
pred_tracks.append(t)
gts = gt_tracks(sequences)
id_switch_rate = compute_id_swap_rate(pred_tracks, gts)
frag_rate = compute_track_fragmentation_rate(pred_tracks, gts)
idf1 = compute_idf1(pred_tracks, gts)
cohorts = {}
for name, c in cohort_stats.items():
cohorts[name] = {
"n_gt": c["n_gt"],
"recall": round(c["matched"] / c["n_gt"], 4) if c["n_gt"] else None,
"position_error_m": round(float(np.mean(c["pos_errors"])), 4) if c["pos_errors"] else None,
"mean_iou": round(float(np.mean(c["ious"])), 4) if c["ious"] else None,
"false_positives": c["fp"],
}
per_class = {
cls: {"n_gt": s["n_gt"],
"recall": round(s["matched"] / s["n_gt"], 4) if s["n_gt"] else None}
for cls, s in sorted(class_stats.items())
}
return {
"headline": {
"precision": round(precision, 4),
"recall": round(recall, 4),
"f1": round(f1, 4),
"mean_iou": round(float(np.mean(ious)), 4) if ious else 0.0,
"position_error_m": round(float(np.mean(pos_errors)), 4) if pos_errors else None,
"class_accuracy": round(class_correct / class_total, 4) if class_total else None,
"safety_recall": round(safety_tp / (safety_tp + safety_fn), 4)
if safety_tp + safety_fn else None,
"id_switch_rate": round(id_switch_rate, 4),
"fragmentation_rate": round(frag_rate, 4),
"idf1": idf1,
},
"counts": {"tp": tp, "fp": fp, "fn": fn,
"pred_tracks": len(pred_tracks), "gt_tracks": len(gts)},
"cohorts": cohorts,
"per_class": per_class,
}
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ comparison report
# Metrics where lower is better.
_LOWER_IS_BETTER = {"position_error_m", "id_switch_rate", "fragmentation_rate"}
_HEADLINE_ORDER = ["precision", "recall", "f1", "mean_iou", "position_error_m",
"class_accuracy", "safety_recall", "id_switch_rate",
"fragmentation_rate", "idf1"]
def build_comparison(base_eval: Dict, cand_eval: Dict,
policy: Optional[Dict] = None) -> Dict:
"""Comparison report mirroring the megaeval compare shape
(headline_deltas / per-cohort / policy / blockers / recommendation)."""
policy = {**DEFAULT_POLICY, **(policy or {})}
bh, ch = base_eval["headline"], cand_eval["headline"]
headline_deltas = []
for m in _HEADLINE_ORDER:
b, c = bh.get(m), ch.get(m)
if b is None or c is None:
continue
delta = round(c - b, 4)
headline_deltas.append({
"metric": m, "baseline": b, "candidate": c, "delta": delta,
"improved": (delta < 0) if m in _LOWER_IS_BETTER else (delta > 0),
})
per_cohort = []
for name, b in base_eval["cohorts"].items():
c = cand_eval["cohorts"].get(name)
if not c or b["recall"] is None or c["recall"] is None:
continue
per_cohort.append({
"cohort": name,
"n_gt": c["n_gt"],
"recall_baseline": b["recall"], "recall_candidate": c["recall"],
"recall_delta": round(c["recall"] - b["recall"], 4),
"position_error_baseline_m": b["position_error_m"],
"position_error_candidate_m": c["position_error_m"],
"mean_iou_baseline": b["mean_iou"], "mean_iou_candidate": c["mean_iou"],
"explanation": COHORT_EXPLANATIONS.get(name, ""),
})
per_cohort.sort(key=lambda x: x["recall_delta"], reverse=True)
per_class = []
for cls, b in base_eval["per_class"].items():
c = cand_eval["per_class"].get(cls)
if not c or b["recall"] is None or c["recall"] is None:
continue
per_class.append({"class": cls, "n_gt": c["n_gt"],
"recall_baseline": b["recall"],
"recall_candidate": c["recall"],
"recall_delta": round(c["recall"] - b["recall"], 4)})
hd = {h["metric"]: h["delta"] for h in headline_deltas}
blockers: List[str] = []
if hd.get("recall", 0) < -policy["max_recall_drop"]:
blockers.append(f"headline recall dropped {hd['recall']:+.4f}")
if hd.get("precision", 0) < -policy["max_precision_drop"]:
blockers.append(f"headline precision dropped {hd['precision']:+.4f}")
if hd.get("safety_recall", 0) < -policy["max_safety_recall_drop"]:
blockers.append(f"safety recall dropped {hd['safety_recall']:+.4f}")
for c in per_cohort:
if c["n_gt"] >= policy["min_cohort_support"] and \
c["recall_delta"] < -policy["max_cohort_recall_drop"]:
blockers.append(
f"REGRESSION: cohort {c['cohort']} recall "
f"{c['recall_baseline']*100:.1f}% -> {c['recall_candidate']*100:.1f}%")
improvements = [f"{h['metric']}: {h['baseline']} -> {h['candidate']} "
f"({h['delta']:+.4f})" for h in headline_deltas if h["improved"]]
return {
"headline_deltas": headline_deltas,
"per_cohort": per_cohort,
"per_class": per_class,
"policy": policy,
"blockers": blockers,
"improvements": improvements,
"recommendation": "DO_NOT_PROMOTE" if blockers else "PROMOTE",
}
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ orchestration
def run_comparison(n_sequences: int = 6, frames_per_sequence: int = 24,
seed: int = 7, out_dir: Optional[Path] = None,
persist: bool = True) -> Dict:
"""Generate scenes, run both engines, evaluate both, build + persist report."""
sequences = generate_sequences(n_sequences=n_sequences,
frames_per_sequence=frames_per_sequence, seed=seed)
baseline_preds: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[Dict]]] = {}
fused_preds: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[Dict]]] = {}
fusion_stats = {"camera_detections": 0, "lidar_detections": 0, "fused_boxes": 0}
for qi, seq in enumerate(sequences):
baseline_preds[seq.sequence_id] = run_baseline(seq, seed, qi)
fused, stats = run_fused(seq, seed, qi)
fused_preds[seq.sequence_id] = fused
for k in fusion_stats:
fusion_stats[k] += stats[k]
base_eval = evaluate_engine(sequences, baseline_preds)
cand_eval = evaluate_engine(sequences, fused_preds)
comparison = build_comparison(base_eval, cand_eval)
n_frames = sum(len(s.frames) for s in sequences)
n_gt = sum(len(f.gt) for s in sequences for f in s.frames)
process_units = _record_process_units(fusion_stats, n_frames, n_gt)
report = {
"run_id": f"bevrun-{uuid4().hex[:10]}",
"created_at": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(),
"params": {"n_sequences": n_sequences,
"frames_per_sequence": frames_per_sequence, "seed": seed},
"engines": {"baseline": BASELINE_ENGINE, "candidate": FUSED_ENGINE},
"scale": {"frames": n_frames, "gt_boxes": n_gt, **fusion_stats},
"baseline": base_eval,
"candidate": cand_eval,
**comparison,
"process_units": process_units,
"notes": (
"Honest simulation: no learned features; detections are sampled from "
"ground truth with modality-specific failure models (camera: occlusion/"
"night misses + monocular depth ambiguity, good semantics; LiDAR: "
"accurate geometry, range/rain degradation, weak semantics). The "
"improvement arises at runtime from geometric+probabilistic fusion in "
"the BEV grid and masklet propagation — sensor complementarity is real."
),
}
if persist:
out = Path(out_dir) if out_dir else RUNS_DIR
out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
with open(out / f"{report['run_id']}.json", "w") as f:
json.dump(report, f, indent=2)
with open(out / "latest.json", "w") as f:
json.dump(report, f, indent=2)
return report
def _record_process_units(fusion_stats: Dict, n_frames: int, n_gt: int) -> Dict:
"""Record fusion-stage process units via the platform's accounting
(best effort: skipped silently if the evaluation store is unavailable)."""
units = {}
try:
from sensorflow.evaluation.process_units import ProcessMeter
from sensorflow.evaluation.records import get_store
meter = ProcessMeter(get_store(), run_id="bevfusion")
units["bev_camera_projection"] = meter.record(
"bev_camera_projection", fusion_stats["camera_detections"], factor=0.2)
units["bev_lidar_rasterization"] = meter.record(
"bev_lidar_rasterization", fusion_stats["lidar_detections"], factor=0.2)
units["bev_fusion"] = meter.record("bev_fusion", n_frames, factor=0.8)
units["masklet_tracking"] = meter.record(
"masklet_tracking", fusion_stats["fused_boxes"], factor=0.3)
units["label_evaluation"] = meter.record("label_evaluation", n_gt, factor=0.5)
units["total"] = sum(units.values())
except Exception:
units = {"total": 0, "note": "process accounting unavailable"}
return units
def latest_report(out_dir: Optional[Path] = None) -> Optional[Dict]:
path = (Path(out_dir) if out_dir else RUNS_DIR) / "latest.json"
if not path.exists():
return None
with open(path) as f:
return json.load(f)