whassan's picture
Deploy Sensorflow Studio (part 2)
6342806 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
9.31 kB
"""Corrected scenario ranking and stratified sampling with reweighting.
Fixes the audit's sampling findings for the legacy paths (F-020: arbitrary
rarity coefficients and confidence-from-rarity; "most interesting first"
ordering biasing P(failure) estimates):
1. Ranking is deterministic and evidence-decomposed (no unseeded randomness,
no collapsed opaque score without its components).
2. Evaluation sets are drawn by STRATIFIED sampling with explicit quotas, and
every drawn item carries an inverse-inclusion-probability weight so
fleet-level rates can be estimated without oversampling bias
(Horvitz-Thompson, same estimator megaeval.sampling already uses — that
implementation was verified correct, F-029).
3. Novelty is real geometry over embeddings: kNN distance and centroid
distance, with the trade-offs documented on each scorer.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from dataclasses import dataclass, field
from enum import Enum
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Sequence, Tuple
import numpy as np
class Stratum(str, Enum):
REPRESENTATIVE = "Representative"
NOMINAL = "Nominal"
RARE = "Rare"
SAFETY_CRITICAL = "SafetyCritical"
KNOWN_FAILURES = "KnownFailures"
NOVEL = "Novel"
DISTRIBUTION_SHIFTED = "DistributionShifted"
#: Default sampling quotas (fraction of the evaluation budget per stratum).
#: These are POLICY parameters — explicit, versioned, and overridable — not
#: buried magic numbers. They intentionally oversample rare/safety strata;
#: the HT weights below undo that oversampling for population estimates.
DEFAULT_QUOTAS: Dict[Stratum, float] = {
Stratum.REPRESENTATIVE: 0.30,
Stratum.NOMINAL: 0.15,
Stratum.RARE: 0.15,
Stratum.SAFETY_CRITICAL: 0.15,
Stratum.KNOWN_FAILURES: 0.10,
Stratum.NOVEL: 0.10,
Stratum.DISTRIBUTION_SHIFTED: 0.05,
}
@dataclass
class SampledItem:
item_id: str
stratum: Stratum
inclusion_probability: float
weight: float # 1 / inclusion_probability (Horvitz-Thompson)
@dataclass
class StratifiedSample:
items: List[SampledItem]
quotas: Dict[Stratum, int]
population_sizes: Dict[Stratum, int]
seed: int
def estimate_population_rate(self, indicator: Dict[str, float]) -> Optional[float]:
"""HT estimate of a population mean/rate from the stratified sample.
indicator: item_id -> 0/1 (or real-valued) outcome measured on the
sample. Returns sum(w_i * y_i) / sum over population size — i.e. the
stratum-weighted mean that recovers the true population rate under
oversampling (each stratum's sample mean weighted by its true share).
"""
total_pop = sum(self.population_sizes.values())
if total_pop == 0:
return None
est = 0.0
for stratum, pop in self.population_sizes.items():
in_stratum = [it for it in self.items if it.stratum == stratum
and it.item_id in indicator]
if not in_stratum:
if pop > 0:
return None # a non-empty stratum with no measurements: refuse
continue
stratum_mean = float(np.mean([indicator[it.item_id] for it in in_stratum]))
est += (pop / total_pop) * stratum_mean
return est
def stratified_sample(
population: Dict[Stratum, Sequence[str]],
budget: int,
quotas: Optional[Dict[Stratum, float]] = None,
seed: int = 0,
) -> StratifiedSample:
"""Draw a stratified sample with explicit quotas and HT weights.
- Quota fractions are converted to integer counts by largest-remainder
allocation (fixes the naive-rounding caveat noted in the audit, F-029).
- Sampling within a stratum is uniform without replacement, from a seeded
generator: same seed -> same sample, always.
- If a stratum has fewer items than its quota, the whole stratum is taken
(inclusion probability 1) and the leftover budget is redistributed to
the remaining strata proportionally.
"""
quotas = quotas or DEFAULT_QUOTAS
rng = np.random.default_rng(seed)
# Largest-remainder integer allocation of the budget.
fracs = {s: quotas.get(s, 0.0) for s in population}
total_frac = sum(fracs.values()) or 1.0
raw = {s: budget * f / total_frac for s, f in fracs.items()}
alloc = {s: int(v) for s, v in raw.items()}
remainders = sorted(raw, key=lambda s: raw[s] - alloc[s], reverse=True)
for s in remainders[: budget - sum(alloc.values())]:
alloc[s] += 1
# Cap at stratum size; redistribute leftovers deterministically.
leftover = 0
for s in sorted(alloc, key=lambda s: s.value):
n_avail = len(population[s])
if alloc[s] > n_avail:
leftover += alloc[s] - n_avail
alloc[s] = n_avail
while leftover > 0:
expandable = [s for s in sorted(alloc, key=lambda s: s.value)
if alloc[s] < len(population[s])]
if not expandable:
break
for s in expandable:
if leftover == 0:
break
alloc[s] += 1
leftover -= 1
items: List[SampledItem] = []
for s in sorted(population, key=lambda s: s.value):
ids = sorted(population[s]) # order-independence: canonical order first
k = alloc.get(s, 0)
if k == 0 or not ids:
continue
chosen = rng.choice(len(ids), size=k, replace=False)
p_inc = k / len(ids)
for idx in sorted(chosen.tolist()):
items.append(SampledItem(
item_id=ids[idx], stratum=s,
inclusion_probability=p_inc, weight=1.0 / p_inc,
))
return StratifiedSample(
items=items,
quotas=alloc,
population_sizes={s: len(v) for s, v in population.items()},
seed=seed,
)
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ novelty
def knn_novelty(embeddings: np.ndarray, reference: np.ndarray, k: int = 10) -> np.ndarray:
"""Novelty = mean Euclidean distance to the k nearest reference embeddings.
Trade-offs: sensitive to LOCAL density, so it finds points in sparse
pockets even inside the reference hull (good for multi-modal fleets);
cost is O(n_query * n_reference) without an index — use the VectorDB
interface (interfaces.py) with an ANN index at production scale. k too
small -> noisy; k too large -> smooths away small novel clusters.
"""
if len(reference) == 0:
return np.full(len(embeddings), np.inf)
k = min(k, len(reference))
# Chunked exact distances; replace with ANN via VectorDB in production.
out = np.empty(len(embeddings))
for i in range(0, len(embeddings), 1024):
chunk = embeddings[i:i + 1024]
d = np.linalg.norm(chunk[:, None, :] - reference[None, :, :], axis=2)
d.sort(axis=1)
out[i:i + 1024] = d[:, :k].mean(axis=1)
return out
def centroid_novelty(embeddings: np.ndarray, reference: np.ndarray) -> np.ndarray:
"""Novelty = distance to the reference centroid, scaled by mean spread.
Trade-offs: O(n) and index-free, but UNIMODAL — it misses novel points
that sit near the global centroid of a multi-modal distribution and
over-flags legitimate points on the far side of a wide mode. Use as a
cheap first pass; confirm with knn_novelty before routing on it.
"""
if len(reference) == 0:
return np.full(len(embeddings), np.inf)
centroid = reference.mean(axis=0)
spread = float(np.mean(np.linalg.norm(reference - centroid, axis=1))) or 1.0
return np.linalg.norm(embeddings - centroid, axis=1) / spread
# ------------------------------------------------------------------ ranking
@dataclass
class RankedScenario:
scenario_id: str
score: float
components: Dict[str, float] = field(default_factory=dict)
def rank_scenarios(
scenario_ids: Sequence[str],
component_scores: Dict[str, Dict[str, float]],
weights: Optional[Dict[str, float]] = None,
) -> List[RankedScenario]:
"""Deterministic, decomposed scenario ranking for REVIEW ordering only.
component_scores: component name -> {scenario_id -> score in [0, 1]}.
The returned score keeps its components attached so every ranking is
explainable. Ties break on scenario_id, so the order is fully
deterministic regardless of dict insertion order.
IMPORTANT: this ordering must never be used to SELECT an evaluation set —
"most interesting first" selection biases P(failure) estimates upward.
Selection goes through stratified_sample(); ranking only orders items
already selected (or a human review queue).
"""
weights = weights or {name: 1.0 for name in component_scores}
ranked = []
for sid in scenario_ids:
comps = {name: float(scores.get(sid, 0.0))
for name, scores in component_scores.items()}
total_w = sum(weights.get(n, 0.0) for n in comps) or 1.0
score = sum(comps[n] * weights.get(n, 0.0) for n in comps) / total_w
ranked.append(RankedScenario(scenario_id=sid, score=round(score, 9),
components=comps))
ranked.sort(key=lambda r: (-r.score, r.scenario_id))
return ranked