Scale-0 S0-R3 replay-cadence 20260916T112742Z — S0R3_REPLAY_CADENCE_STABILITY_RULER_STRUCTURAL_REPAIR_BUT_VALUE_INSUFFICIENT_HOLD

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/README_S0R3_REPLAY_CADENCE_STABILITY_RULER.md

@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+# MANN-GPT Scale-0 S0-R3 Replay-Cadence Stability Ruler
+
+Run: 20260916T112742Z
+Control: 20260915T130704Z / 915058fd3e853ca62fe9d35f55d536f10e3ff5d7e90a150a96bffea9cd5215bd
+LR scale: 0.6
+Replay interval: 4
+Replay LM coef: 0.1
+Causal coef: 1.0
+Candidate opt: 0.0006933628862113668
+Candidate real: 0.00010005143676994445
+Q2 repaired: True
+GM repaired: True
+GM replication: {'ZH_ZH': 6, 'ZH_EN': 4, 'EN_ZH': 5}
+Structural safety: True
+Value retention: False
+Loadback: 0.0
+Verdict: S0R3_REPLAY_CADENCE_STABILITY_RULER_STRUCTURAL_REPAIR_BUT_VALUE_INSUFFICIENT_HOLD
+
+Non-promotional; latest.json is never modified.

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/formal_p3a_parent_en_zh.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,97 @@
+panel_id,family,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_drop_penalty,control_median_penalty,target_minus_control_median,target_positive,target_beats_control_median
+0,A,6.019963264465332,5.418574333190918,0.10793638229370117,0.024330615997314453,0.08360576629638672,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.039619445800781,4.858102798461914,0.24937152862548828,0.008605003356933594,0.2407665252685547,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.766942977905273,5.850250244140625,0.04501914978027344,-0.009850502014160156,0.054869651794433594,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.348169803619385,5.865943431854248,0.11466217041015625,0.004283428192138672,0.11037874221801758,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.136372089385986,5.899996757507324,0.0291290283203125,-0.06219482421875,0.0913238525390625,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.000216960906982,5.701890468597412,0.07204103469848633,0.0093994140625,0.06264162063598633,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.491674423217773,5.026910781860352,0.026599884033203125,-0.011713981628417969,0.038313865661621094,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.818170070648193,5.234874725341797,0.0865182876586914,0.09728860855102539,-0.010770320892333984,1.0,0.0
+0,B,5.789393424987793,5.008559226989746,0.11676025390625,0.03028583526611328,0.08647441864013672,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.526734352111816,6.602429389953613,0.031284332275390625,-0.008998870849609375,0.040283203125,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.719339370727539,7.98140811920166,0.09389972686767578,-0.08698129653930664,0.18088102340698242,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.262524604797363,4.997443199157715,0.11504650115966797,0.04218339920043945,0.07286310195922852,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.979926586151123,5.608522415161133,0.18387699127197266,0.01535654067993164,0.16852045059204102,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.166228294372559,6.689446449279785,0.11812114715576172,-0.1096658706665039,0.22778701782226562,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.152134895324707,6.895201206207275,0.008512020111083984,0.021389484405517578,-0.012877464294433594,1.0,0.0
+0,B,5.523052215576172,5.321475505828857,0.07593107223510742,-0.0031228065490722656,0.07905387878417969,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.717556953430176,5.626131057739258,-0.06714391708374023,-0.04378700256347656,-0.023356914520263672,0.0,0.0
+1,A,7.216421604156494,7.264467239379883,0.08600330352783203,-0.057454586029052734,0.14345788955688477,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.596123218536377,5.702930450439453,0.03517723083496094,0.01190185546875,0.023275375366210938,1.0,1.0
+1,A,7.550176620483398,7.389592170715332,0.0008397102355957031,0.019747257232666016,-0.018907546997070312,1.0,0.0
+1,A,7.139939308166504,7.0581769943237305,0.1994771957397461,-0.11237859725952148,0.3118557929992676,1.0,1.0
+1,A,6.628729343414307,6.255247116088867,0.06496763229370117,0.1256084442138672,-0.060640811920166016,1.0,0.0
+1,A,4.920778274536133,4.879457473754883,0.06966066360473633,0.04293346405029297,0.02672719955444336,1.0,1.0
+1,A,8.08430290222168,8.06397819519043,0.057831764221191406,-0.009685516357421875,0.06751728057861328,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.751842021942139,6.076531410217285,-0.033008575439453125,-0.1607666015625,0.12775802612304688,0.0,1.0
+1,B,7.017712593078613,6.254220962524414,0.06541919708251953,0.07915496826171875,-0.013735771179199219,1.0,0.0
+1,B,7.640701770782471,7.385994911193848,0.009853363037109375,0.021066665649414062,-0.011213302612304688,1.0,0.0
+1,B,5.7498650550842285,5.394067287445068,0.14406538009643555,-0.022770404815673828,0.16683578491210938,1.0,1.0
+1,B,4.959395408630371,4.25008487701416,0.08894824981689453,0.06850433349609375,0.02044391632080078,1.0,1.0
+1,B,7.583463668823242,7.860748291015625,-0.01672840118408203,-0.043582916259765625,0.026854515075683594,0.0,1.0
+1,B,9.397283554077148,9.734847068786621,0.07018470764160156,-0.06231689453125,0.13250160217285156,1.0,1.0
+1,B,7.340692520141602,7.137928009033203,0.2776956558227539,0.025479793548583984,0.2522158622741699,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.577747344970703,5.641398906707764,0.009027957916259766,-0.018860340118408203,0.02788829803466797,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.139690399169922,7.13723087310791,0.020233154296875,0.015085220336914062,0.0051479339599609375,1.0,1.0
+2,A,8.070062637329102,7.890480995178223,0.08166790008544922,0.02205657958984375,0.05961132049560547,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.535146713256836,5.6213884353637695,0.034458160400390625,-0.034759521484375,0.06921768188476562,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.231945991516113,7.641596794128418,0.06369972229003906,-0.04863691329956055,0.11233663558959961,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.147367477416992,7.314199924468994,0.024114131927490234,-0.15280675888061523,0.17692089080810547,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.704164028167725,5.394942283630371,0.3063192367553711,-0.04765796661376953,0.3539772033691406,1.0,1.0
+2,A,6.729550361633301,6.7896270751953125,0.19049406051635742,0.028486251831054688,0.16200780868530273,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.132236957550049,6.014204978942871,0.001552581787109375,-0.01971721649169922,0.021269798278808594,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.472309112548828,4.245044708251953,0.27076244354248047,-0.060779571533203125,0.3315420150756836,1.0,1.0
+2,B,7.300587177276611,6.464529037475586,0.3275456428527832,0.04407358169555664,0.28347206115722656,1.0,1.0
+2,B,4.307799339294434,4.178083419799805,0.04603862762451172,-0.009349822998046875,0.055388450622558594,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.870345115661621,5.445815086364746,0.03063678741455078,0.012404441833496094,0.018232345581054688,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.493014335632324,5.1151885986328125,0.0021071434020996094,0.032546043395996094,-0.030438899993896484,1.0,0.0
+2,B,5.8540449142456055,5.056144714355469,0.12839460372924805,0.00595855712890625,0.1224360466003418,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.166607856750488,6.841738224029541,-0.09356927871704102,-0.1448836326599121,0.051314353942871094,0.0,1.0
+3,A,4.084619522094727,4.684825897216797,0.04107189178466797,-0.07251453399658203,0.11358642578125,1.0,1.0
+3,A,6.9441609382629395,6.40209436416626,0.06810283660888672,0.0583348274230957,0.009768009185791016,1.0,1.0
+3,A,4.220216751098633,4.752200126647949,0.059151649475097656,-0.000637054443359375,0.05978870391845703,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.862133979797363,6.198591232299805,0.10675907135009766,0.010938644409179688,0.09582042694091797,1.0,1.0
+3,A,7.255556583404541,6.750860691070557,0.0857234001159668,0.07078218460083008,0.014941215515136719,1.0,1.0
+3,A,4.7156524658203125,4.605517387390137,0.021324634552001953,0.019956111907958984,0.0013685226440429688,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.905387878417969,6.2513532638549805,-0.014888286590576172,-0.0009827613830566406,-0.013905525207519531,0.0,0.0
+3,A,7.213876724243164,7.645022392272949,0.07390022277832031,0.034356117248535156,0.039544105529785156,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.159878730773926,5.933773994445801,-0.014210700988769531,-0.0013384819030761719,-0.01287221908569336,0.0,0.0
+3,B,7.198740005493164,6.710226058959961,0.07957172393798828,0.06537485122680664,0.01419687271118164,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.917898178100586,5.799933433532715,0.026191234588623047,0.0659799575805664,-0.03978872299194336,1.0,0.0
+3,B,4.638642311096191,4.739227294921875,0.03657245635986328,-0.034087181091308594,0.07065963745117188,1.0,1.0
+3,B,8.148868560791016,7.870272159576416,0.15359830856323242,-0.002468585968017578,0.15606689453125,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.365971565246582,6.0249738693237305,0.12945938110351562,0.07963132858276367,0.04982805252075195,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.24326229095459,5.927950859069824,-0.024419307708740234,-0.034752845764160156,0.010333538055419922,0.0,1.0
+3,B,5.426121711730957,5.309136390686035,-0.011395454406738281,-0.029124736785888672,0.01772928237915039,0.0,1.0
+4,A,6.98004674911499,7.355348587036133,0.11796998977661133,0.0057735443115234375,0.11219644546508789,1.0,1.0
+4,A,7.331599235534668,6.71392822265625,0.04623699188232422,0.038596153259277344,0.007640838623046875,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.783809185028076,4.567298889160156,0.12357902526855469,-0.013843536376953125,0.1374225616455078,1.0,1.0
+4,A,9.378543853759766,9.249550819396973,0.0692605972290039,0.014932632446289062,0.054327964782714844,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.499950885772705,6.4120192527771,-0.1151127815246582,-0.046268463134765625,-0.06884431838989258,0.0,0.0
+4,A,4.175739288330078,4.310961723327637,0.028563499450683594,0.0470576286315918,-0.018494129180908203,1.0,0.0
+4,A,5.976424694061279,5.940329551696777,0.11616706848144531,0.03636884689331055,0.07979822158813477,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.978265762329102,5.738199234008789,0.1390399932861328,0.06378650665283203,0.07525348663330078,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.044516563415527,4.560728073120117,0.16465139389038086,0.05754566192626953,0.10710573196411133,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.655045986175537,6.382108688354492,0.04596710205078125,0.02473735809326172,0.02122974395751953,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.334702491760254,5.990806579589844,0.04631757736206055,0.028224945068359375,0.018092632293701172,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.208494186401367,5.11013126373291,0.02092123031616211,-0.0016150474548339844,0.022536277770996094,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.132963180541992,5.915611267089844,0.08775663375854492,-0.02764749526977539,0.11540412902832031,1.0,1.0
+4,B,4.808032035827637,2.9127626419067383,0.5496244430541992,0.11010050773620605,0.43952393531799316,1.0,1.0
+4,B,8.146952629089355,7.880576133728027,0.02878427505493164,0.052584171295166016,-0.023799896240234375,1.0,0.0
+4,B,6.529354095458984,5.981487274169922,0.1752643585205078,0.049222469329833984,0.12604188919067383,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.900872230529785,5.928976058959961,0.17815065383911133,0.020421504974365234,0.1577291488647461,1.0,1.0
+5,A,6.169695854187012,5.790492057800293,0.026254653930664062,0.06662750244140625,-0.04037284851074219,1.0,0.0
+5,A,6.501131057739258,6.368910789489746,-0.1115422248840332,-0.041481971740722656,-0.07006025314331055,0.0,0.0
+5,A,7.335206031799316,7.0959014892578125,-0.03633308410644531,0.03679037094116211,-0.07312345504760742,0.0,0.0
+5,A,7.602707862854004,7.384736061096191,0.05341911315917969,0.03502464294433594,0.01839447021484375,1.0,1.0
+5,A,7.47166633605957,7.309038162231445,0.04349231719970703,0.005721569061279297,0.037770748138427734,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.9211649894714355,5.553442478179932,0.05805683135986328,0.023449420928955078,0.0346074104309082,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.038049697875977,3.7174575328826904,0.20325422286987305,0.039090871810913086,0.16416335105895996,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.7860026359558105,6.966621398925781,0.0010232925415039062,-0.015683650970458984,0.01670694351196289,1.0,1.0
+5,B,7.305431842803955,6.686206817626953,0.025109291076660156,0.003956317901611328,0.021152973175048828,1.0,1.0
+5,B,5.096794128417969,4.859342575073242,0.035172462463378906,0.05492115020751953,-0.019748687744140625,1.0,0.0
+5,B,8.184976577758789,8.286407470703125,0.008446693420410156,0.028106689453125,-0.019659996032714844,1.0,0.0
+5,B,6.340791702270508,6.682149410247803,-0.02540731430053711,-0.11567020416259766,0.09026288986206055,0.0,1.0
+5,B,6.730380058288574,6.924185752868652,0.03748798370361328,0.06761646270751953,-0.03012847900390625,1.0,0.0
+5,B,5.2804670333862305,4.296088695526123,0.025414466857910156,0.05945539474487305,-0.03404092788696289,1.0,0.0
+5,B,6.831133842468262,6.630465507507324,-0.5155057907104492,0.064453125,-0.5799589157104492,0.0,0.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/formal_p3a_parent_q2.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,97 @@
+seq_len,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_ko_nll,control_ko_nll
+1024,11.223404884338379,9.501367568969727,9.840409278869629,9.477180480957031
+1024,11.138046264648438,11.050651550292969,11.173860549926758,11.01569938659668
+1024,6.7918572425842285,6.764646053314209,6.904298782348633,6.863805770874023
+1024,7.367758750915527,6.71068000793457,6.7892608642578125,6.64642858505249
+1024,6.993464469909668,6.391009330749512,6.942434787750244,6.343750953674316
+1024,9.649653434753418,7.416498184204102,8.548986434936523,7.366870880126953
+1024,8.882111549377441,6.692122459411621,6.898027420043945,6.694538116455078
+1024,6.9546966552734375,5.269890785217285,5.758641719818115,5.274958610534668
+1024,9.278295516967773,8.185773849487305,8.499702453613281,8.261168479919434
+1024,8.428910255432129,6.8019514083862305,6.973625659942627,7.159056663513184
+1024,6.7614288330078125,5.619472980499268,5.740984916687012,5.558110237121582
+1024,7.668444633483887,6.540014743804932,6.8588080406188965,6.583617210388184
+1024,8.728883743286133,7.841454029083252,8.173020362854004,7.905290126800537
+1024,10.348103523254395,8.29606819152832,8.509960174560547,8.217207908630371
+1024,8.144102096557617,5.077950477600098,5.0365214347839355,4.943144798278809
+1024,7.493818759918213,6.191952705383301,6.290902137756348,6.382911682128906
+1024,9.177875518798828,8.724915504455566,8.77627182006836,8.747665405273438
+1024,7.719755172729492,6.425362586975098,6.613062858581543,6.480803489685059
+1024,6.8468475341796875,6.429306507110596,6.442789554595947,6.4420905113220215
+1024,7.50094747543335,5.657805442810059,5.828052997589111,5.756124019622803
+1024,7.913882732391357,7.086408615112305,7.180924415588379,7.157972812652588
+1024,9.12494945526123,8.39597225189209,8.474491119384766,8.173332214355469
+1024,8.069528579711914,6.217680931091309,6.538241863250732,6.1552734375
+1024,7.788102626800537,5.579123497009277,5.593672752380371,5.475197792053223
+1024,6.523205280303955,5.078560829162598,5.029038429260254,4.949659824371338
+1024,9.49740219116211,8.345518112182617,8.344945907592773,8.235432624816895
+1024,9.252983093261719,8.367958068847656,8.437026023864746,8.281397819519043
+1024,8.142059326171875,6.262001991271973,5.987926483154297,6.0302019119262695
+1024,10.045355796813965,8.908894538879395,9.643827438354492,8.518317222595215
+1024,11.649142265319824,9.705668449401855,9.680924415588379,9.980795860290527
+1024,7.033880710601807,5.984440803527832,6.278815746307373,5.965679168701172
+1024,10.54144287109375,9.215856552124023,9.118685722351074,9.206438064575195
+1536,8.409096717834473,7.630921840667725,7.809179306030273,7.728487968444824
+1536,7.908998966217041,6.7630205154418945,7.284106254577637,6.779388904571533
+1536,6.339378833770752,3.7898170948028564,3.7997353076934814,3.764694929122925
+1536,10.600903511047363,9.249032974243164,9.966120719909668,9.257759094238281
+1536,5.465552806854248,4.457137584686279,4.340002536773682,4.573268890380859
+1536,10.571945190429688,9.67810344696045,9.995227813720703,9.65849781036377
+1536,10.312911987304688,8.192933082580566,8.23470687866211,7.738410472869873
+1536,11.189569473266602,10.696146011352539,11.002039909362793,10.69428539276123
+1536,10.086085319519043,8.502069473266602,8.533733367919922,8.228267669677734
+1536,8.000818252563477,8.632608413696289,8.476557731628418,8.696083068847656
+1536,11.119075775146484,10.310758590698242,10.402628898620605,10.308176040649414
+1536,9.60386848449707,9.123124122619629,9.132290840148926,9.060815811157227
+1536,6.332882881164551,5.757181167602539,5.87281608581543,5.469363689422607
+1536,8.89117431640625,6.812036037445068,7.8877482414245605,6.7390241622924805
+1536,9.562071800231934,9.543027877807617,9.618215560913086,9.544200897216797
+1536,10.635573387145996,9.694071769714355,9.652692794799805,9.688530921936035
+1536,9.525308609008789,7.634369850158691,7.754746437072754,7.5966620445251465
+1536,8.629144668579102,7.333592891693115,7.582006931304932,7.428210258483887
+1536,12.114716529846191,10.498763084411621,11.291570663452148,10.544010162353516
+1536,8.426520347595215,6.890489101409912,7.551159381866455,6.906360149383545
+1536,11.03581428527832,10.161867141723633,10.550896644592285,9.808527946472168
+1536,10.44478702545166,9.271862030029297,10.02932071685791,8.870201110839844
+1536,11.511859893798828,10.808122634887695,10.683881759643555,10.809048652648926
+1536,6.626771926879883,5.266434669494629,5.228494167327881,5.244720935821533
+1536,10.699114799499512,10.004444122314453,10.082366943359375,9.945709228515625
+1536,5.926167964935303,6.185838222503662,6.992773532867432,6.213562965393066
+1536,8.677196502685547,7.082599639892578,7.334869384765625,6.895051002502441
+1536,7.836477756500244,5.910635948181152,6.349971771240234,5.943601608276367
+1536,10.962981224060059,10.045263290405273,10.089658737182617,9.848539352416992
+1536,7.89932918548584,6.514604091644287,6.648293495178223,6.490837097167969
+1536,8.145200729370117,6.9210615158081055,6.923543930053711,6.953271389007568
+1536,10.103715896606445,9.486441612243652,9.815948486328125,9.538592338562012
+2048,9.00386905670166,7.269274711608887,7.413247108459473,7.231840133666992
+2048,8.879674911499023,7.8512372970581055,8.287213325500488,7.821991443634033
+2048,10.603822708129883,8.419445037841797,8.372087478637695,8.45755386352539
+2048,9.171838760375977,9.16073989868164,9.210232734680176,9.102279663085938
+2048,9.360213279724121,7.296492099761963,7.346826553344727,7.28376579284668
+2048,7.5499749183654785,6.007574081420898,6.163900375366211,6.016928672790527
+2048,9.213156700134277,7.35596227645874,7.471564292907715,7.24515962600708
+2048,8.727643966674805,7.241860389709473,7.545536994934082,7.233145713806152
+2048,10.998631477355957,9.464235305786133,9.637524604797363,9.408746719360352
+2048,8.490470886230469,7.877993583679199,7.947662353515625,7.805736541748047
+2048,9.036670684814453,7.696629524230957,8.417292594909668,7.604790687561035
+2048,4.357437610626221,3.721762180328369,3.707294464111328,3.586850643157959
+2048,7.873176574707031,6.802797794342041,7.001646041870117,6.740487098693848
+2048,5.865801811218262,4.411369323730469,4.503826141357422,4.387042045593262
+2048,9.522163391113281,8.525635719299316,8.584784507751465,8.50054931640625
+2048,11.103334426879883,10.153996467590332,10.194854736328125,10.15697956085205
+2048,8.838040351867676,8.618439674377441,8.614689826965332,8.605558395385742
+2048,6.775654315948486,5.772386074066162,5.826645851135254,5.788331985473633
+2048,7.231169700622559,5.0275373458862305,5.232268333435059,4.641429901123047
+2048,7.285470962524414,5.466498851776123,5.531638145446777,5.349606990814209
+2048,8.185060501098633,6.352217197418213,6.4214582443237305,6.1254072189331055
+2048,7.07222843170166,6.399200439453125,6.38668155670166,6.363402843475342
+2048,9.218400001525879,7.965768814086914,7.985605716705322,8.187652587890625
+2048,10.102404594421387,7.773960113525391,8.356107711791992,7.710009574890137
+2048,8.132225036621094,8.345005989074707,8.516670227050781,8.357033729553223
+2048,11.208714485168457,9.628678321838379,9.674928665161133,9.835061073303223
+2048,7.557587623596191,5.55859375,5.562273025512695,5.858292102813721
+2048,9.155303955078125,8.08923053741455,8.553722381591797,7.912885665893555
+2048,7.457683563232422,6.710964679718018,6.907635688781738,6.560090065002441
+2048,10.285143852233887,10.597102165222168,10.630670547485352,10.56725788116455
+2048,10.833179473876953,9.652349472045898,9.70248031616211,9.601346015930176
+2048,6.616604804992676,4.781582832336426,4.894094944000244,4.7527055740356445

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/formal_p3a_parent_zh_en.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@
+panel_id,family,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_drop_penalty,control_median_penalty,target_minus_control_median,target_positive,target_beats_control_median
+0,A,7.386061668395996,7.111676216125488,0.1487751007080078,-0.009999275207519531,0.15877437591552734,1.0,1.0
+0,A,4.739749908447266,4.042544841766357,0.03917694091796875,0.07277441024780273,-0.033597469329833984,1.0,0.0
+0,A,5.206624507904053,3.530656099319458,0.036993980407714844,-0.026650667190551758,0.0636446475982666,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.013764381408691,4.365102767944336,0.4104909896850586,0.3152780532836914,0.09521293640136719,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.033939838409424,4.942495346069336,0.3122119903564453,0.1121225357055664,0.2000894546508789,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.145827293395996,3.798326253890991,0.18571114540100098,-0.007926225662231445,0.19363737106323242,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.306499481201172,6.57078742980957,0.02500629425048828,-0.006283283233642578,0.03128957748413086,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.635249137878418,5.204448699951172,0.40317249298095703,-0.12433910369873047,0.5275115966796875,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.38240385055542,4.924223899841309,0.47917938232421875,0.004345893859863281,0.47483348846435547,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.097745418548584,5.019270896911621,0.20928287506103516,0.09342718124389648,0.11585569381713867,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.987015247344971,3.693197250366211,0.08213543891906738,0.2629985809326172,-0.1808631420135498,1.0,0.0
+0,B,8.488517761230469,5.990900039672852,0.06566190719604492,0.23067665100097656,-0.16501474380493164,1.0,0.0
+1,A,3.450761556625366,2.6833231449127197,0.3144521713256836,0.008819818496704102,0.3056323528289795,1.0,1.0
+1,A,4.367733001708984,3.221841812133789,0.43749403953552246,0.12375521659851074,0.3137388229370117,1.0,1.0
+1,A,6.042033672332764,6.356808185577393,-0.09817075729370117,-0.09937715530395508,0.0012063980102539062,0.0,1.0
+1,A,6.005559921264648,5.977637767791748,-0.08484935760498047,-0.023051738739013672,-0.0617976188659668,0.0,0.0
+1,A,6.780006408691406,5.251924514770508,0.25293827056884766,0.26157188415527344,-0.008633613586425781,1.0,0.0
+1,A,4.541420936584473,4.151168346405029,0.21122217178344727,-0.02323007583618164,0.2344522476196289,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.304755210876465,3.01965594291687,0.10656404495239258,0.6404669284820557,-0.5339028835296631,1.0,0.0
+1,B,5.046105861663818,4.685175895690918,-0.027647018432617188,0.05079317092895508,-0.07844018936157227,0.0,0.0
+1,B,6.230146408081055,3.79762864112854,0.4175426959991455,0.14129233360290527,0.27625036239624023,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.76273250579834,6.273894786834717,0.07646512985229492,0.04877042770385742,0.0276947021484375,1.0,1.0
+1,B,8.799347877502441,9.45311164855957,-0.1219940185546875,-0.16353416442871094,0.04154014587402344,0.0,1.0
+1,B,6.303501129150391,5.166484355926514,0.01699352264404297,0.30638933181762695,-0.289395809173584,1.0,0.0
+2,A,6.353827953338623,3.860283851623535,0.5442142486572266,0.4058365821838379,0.13837766647338867,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.094280242919922,4.695484161376953,0.1082468032836914,-0.0010962486267089844,0.10934305191040039,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.771566390991211,5.092715263366699,0.0927267074584961,0.15853071212768555,-0.06580400466918945,1.0,0.0
+2,A,6.4932379722595215,4.312280654907227,0.3457303047180176,-0.008867740631103516,0.3545980453491211,1.0,1.0
+2,A,6.349065780639648,5.900271415710449,0.29609203338623047,-0.19646024703979492,0.4925522804260254,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.4471435546875,5.155091285705566,1.1938848495483398,0.1173858642578125,1.0764989852905273,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.414554595947266,5.426938533782959,0.25575876235961914,-0.029030799865722656,0.2847895622253418,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.3746185302734375,4.193408012390137,0.3643326759338379,0.07360315322875977,0.2907295227050781,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.143357276916504,5.419426918029785,0.6924037933349609,-0.0318145751953125,0.7242183685302734,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.377829551696777,3.6950907707214355,0.3095412254333496,0.295459508895874,0.014081716537475586,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.302234649658203,4.117687225341797,0.3670682907104492,0.1959667205810547,0.17110157012939453,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.273164749145508,4.547956943511963,1.161332607269287,0.062207698822021484,1.0991249084472656,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.06500244140625,3.3640148639678955,0.06817412376403809,0.365429162979126,-0.2972550392150879,1.0,0.0
+3,A,4.084223747253418,3.889528751373291,-0.012889623641967773,0.05744791030883789,-0.07033753395080566,0.0,0.0
+3,A,5.876840591430664,4.2815470695495605,0.056206703186035156,0.0732874870300293,-0.01708078384399414,1.0,0.0
+3,A,6.815805912017822,4.606088638305664,1.1318073272705078,0.16271591186523438,0.9690914154052734,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.791860580444336,3.2132527828216553,0.25284337997436523,0.36746811866760254,-0.1146247386932373,1.0,0.0
+3,A,6.411648750305176,4.1012797355651855,0.8361783027648926,0.1959066390991211,0.6402716636657715,1.0,1.0
+3,B,7.721489429473877,6.819558143615723,0.3186216354370117,0.17269563674926758,0.14592599868774414,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.593963623046875,4.063920497894287,0.6897158622741699,0.24272775650024414,0.4469881057739258,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.210901260375977,5.06607723236084,0.16222238540649414,0.07636642456054688,0.08585596084594727,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.604500770568848,4.264030456542969,0.0942535400390625,0.15112686157226562,-0.056873321533203125,1.0,0.0
+3,B,5.892999172210693,5.499224662780762,0.07483291625976562,0.028207778930664062,0.04662513732910156,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.39762020111084,4.814671039581299,0.1718144416809082,0.14815568923950195,0.02365875244140625,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.7242536544799805,2.27126407623291,2.393510341644287,-0.012993574142456055,2.406503915786743,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.28041934967041,3.6853044033050537,0.6810939311981201,0.10305619239807129,0.5780377388000488,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.966358184814453,6.339971542358398,0.11410331726074219,0.006931304931640625,0.10717201232910156,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.6375861167907715,4.943280220031738,0.048424720764160156,0.09874582290649414,-0.050321102142333984,1.0,0.0
+4,A,4.983036994934082,3.6802146434783936,0.36577439308166504,0.08132553100585938,0.28444886207580566,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.989748001098633,5.133969306945801,0.033392906188964844,-0.04832124710083008,0.08171415328979492,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.989826202392578,4.521656513214111,0.6720280647277832,0.0764155387878418,0.5956125259399414,1.0,1.0
+4,B,8.138908386230469,4.801026821136475,0.3914027214050293,0.2079606056213379,0.1834421157836914,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.624453544616699,4.2818684577941895,0.3654155731201172,0.17417001724243164,0.19124555587768555,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.926816463470459,3.8589026927948,0.35820889472961426,0.027757644653320312,0.33045125007629395,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.698741912841797,4.957859992980957,0.3144826889038086,0.17769956588745117,0.13678312301635742,1.0,1.0
+4,B,8.066125869750977,7.197623252868652,0.14666032791137695,0.011372566223144531,0.13528776168823242,1.0,1.0
+5,A,10.380549430847168,10.290138244628906,-0.06183338165283203,-0.00045871734619140625,-0.061374664306640625,0.0,0.0
+5,A,5.923989295959473,4.251646995544434,0.862647533416748,0.14638233184814453,0.7162652015686035,1.0,1.0
+5,A,4.50358772277832,3.828361988067627,-0.06132388114929199,0.05468893051147461,-0.1160128116607666,0.0,0.0
+5,A,6.896921157836914,5.782556533813477,0.09146547317504883,0.10944795608520508,-0.01798248291015625,1.0,0.0
+5,A,4.1510772705078125,2.5856504440307617,1.3816823959350586,-0.04740762710571289,1.4290900230407715,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.568187713623047,3.841646671295166,1.2565374374389648,0.048819541931152344,1.2077178955078125,1.0,1.0
+5,B,8.335905075073242,7.308801651000977,0.0666971206665039,0.04704093933105469,0.01965618133544922,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.187668800354004,5.7428483963012695,0.058640480041503906,0.13492965698242188,-0.07628917694091797,1.0,0.0
+5,B,7.298949241638184,4.205690383911133,0.08099842071533203,1.0083322525024414,-0.9273338317871094,1.0,0.0
+5,B,4.963496208190918,4.323677062988281,0.02123737335205078,0.04965400695800781,-0.02841663360595703,1.0,0.0
+5,B,5.655405044555664,5.522614002227783,0.17800045013427734,-0.07474279403686523,0.2527432441711426,1.0,1.0
+5,B,4.829167366027832,2.7375760078430176,0.7570464611053467,0.16857337951660156,0.5884730815887451,1.0,1.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/formal_p3a_parent_zh_zh.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@
+panel_id,family,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_drop_penalty,control_median_penalty,target_minus_control_median,target_positive,target_beats_control_median
+0,A,5.798529624938965,5.618100643157959,-0.003143787384033203,0.039225101470947266,-0.04236888885498047,0.0,0.0
+0,A,4.73171854019165,4.580249786376953,0.038175106048583984,-0.039383888244628906,0.07755899429321289,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.7646098136901855,6.125486373901367,0.1631922721862793,0.1257038116455078,0.037488460540771484,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.796359062194824,5.7869415283203125,0.04099082946777344,0.03073406219482422,0.010256767272949219,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.949052333831787,5.6857500076293945,0.054090023040771484,0.08217477798461914,-0.028084754943847656,1.0,0.0
+0,A,4.694995880126953,4.148642539978027,-0.08166837692260742,-0.025429725646972656,-0.056238651275634766,0.0,0.0
+0,B,5.63124942779541,5.379204750061035,0.012591838836669922,-0.0198211669921875,0.03241300582885742,1.0,1.0
+0,B,4.05907678604126,3.4691407680511475,0.057109832763671875,-0.003539562225341797,0.06064939498901367,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.8304643630981445,6.577199459075928,0.18610811233520508,0.023535728454589844,0.16257238388061523,1.0,1.0
+0,B,8.758149147033691,8.538763999938965,0.02593994140625,-0.010468482971191406,0.036408424377441406,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.012813568115234,6.399392127990723,0.050884246826171875,0.04443359375,0.006450653076171875,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.500657081604004,7.355673313140869,0.011555194854736328,-0.06038856506347656,0.07194375991821289,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.41769552230835,5.1553544998168945,0.15341758728027344,0.006826877593994141,0.1465907096862793,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.835265159606934,6.0204362869262695,-0.009128093719482422,-0.015472888946533203,0.006344795227050781,0.0,1.0
+1,A,5.503486156463623,4.9642181396484375,0.4724583625793457,-0.04106760025024414,0.5135259628295898,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.808685302734375,5.519881248474121,0.07369422912597656,-0.0011625289916992188,0.07485675811767578,1.0,1.0
+1,A,3.805159091949463,4.112948417663574,0.007817745208740234,-0.13939881324768066,0.1472165584564209,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.5309739112854,4.681615829467773,0.4668302536010742,0.025554180145263672,0.44127607345581055,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.720916748046875,6.354050636291504,0.20736980438232422,-0.03130054473876953,0.23867034912109375,1.0,1.0
+1,B,4.6888837814331055,4.716795921325684,0.08974695205688477,0.048066139221191406,0.04168081283569336,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.510076522827148,6.162215709686279,0.1374068260192871,0.03077840805053711,0.10662841796875,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.727377891540527,6.879817008972168,0.0435175895690918,-0.005013465881347656,0.04853105545043945,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.670482635498047,5.825544357299805,0.05989837646484375,-0.060692787170410156,0.1205911636352539,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.697613716125488,4.964826583862305,0.06902599334716797,0.02272510528564453,0.04630088806152344,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.950783729553223,7.723801136016846,0.18865346908569336,-0.03717851638793945,0.2258319854736328,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.570270538330078,5.79271125793457,0.08435916900634766,-0.0029745101928710938,0.08733367919921875,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.110150337219238,4.019155979156494,0.028687000274658203,0.07859277725219727,-0.04990577697753906,1.0,0.0
+2,A,5.725166320800781,5.164761543273926,0.10503292083740234,0.010881900787353516,0.09415102005004883,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.8833208084106445,4.692278861999512,0.06332540512084961,0.11545562744140625,-0.05213022232055664,1.0,0.0
+2,A,9.001199722290039,8.955938339233398,0.031299591064453125,0.007220268249511719,0.024079322814941406,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.8092145919799805,6.178913116455078,0.014909744262695312,-0.08073949813842773,0.09564924240112305,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.0481276512146,5.121169567108154,0.10821676254272461,0.03794050216674805,0.07027626037597656,1.0,1.0
+2,B,7.997621536254883,7.6162109375,0.09232473373413086,0.02764749526977539,0.06467723846435547,1.0,1.0
+2,B,9.345571517944336,9.234868049621582,0.033799171447753906,-0.027480125427246094,0.061279296875,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.21489953994751,4.954995632171631,0.20613384246826172,0.08402872085571289,0.12210512161254883,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.323889255523682,6.483330249786377,0.024851322174072266,-0.06840658187866211,0.09325790405273438,1.0,1.0
+3,A,4.125418663024902,4.365080833435059,0.029545307159423828,0.012973785400390625,0.016571521759033203,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.556631088256836,5.455496788024902,0.05832815170288086,0.0006895065307617188,0.05763864517211914,1.0,1.0
+3,A,3.9474024772644043,3.7955515384674072,0.1366565227508545,-0.006093502044677734,0.14275002479553223,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.143749237060547,3.5804715156555176,0.1717541217803955,0.042121171951293945,0.12963294982910156,1.0,1.0
+3,A,6.547819137573242,6.116118431091309,0.06379175186157227,0.07174062728881836,-0.007948875427246094,1.0,0.0
+3,A,9.284416198730469,9.41127872467041,0.05834007263183594,-0.0072612762451171875,0.06560134887695312,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.781311988830566,5.681642532348633,0.05731821060180664,0.00167083740234375,0.05564737319946289,1.0,1.0
+3,B,4.789587020874023,4.565760612487793,0.08606529235839844,0.04339790344238281,0.042667388916015625,1.0,1.0
+3,B,7.38284969329834,7.810585975646973,-0.10447359085083008,-0.04566383361816406,-0.058809757232666016,0.0,0.0
+3,B,8.055337905883789,8.010066986083984,0.04943084716796875,0.021318435668945312,0.028112411499023438,1.0,1.0
+3,B,8.955938339233398,8.697010040283203,0.07636737823486328,-0.010351181030273438,0.08671855926513672,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.934483051300049,5.987215518951416,0.08170652389526367,-0.0017189979553222656,0.08342552185058594,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.0373430252075195,2.960010051727295,0.19334936141967773,0.01348257064819336,0.17986679077148438,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.348248481750488,6.126180648803711,0.05660057067871094,0.0758504867553711,-0.019249916076660156,1.0,0.0
+4,A,7.6973419189453125,7.634820938110352,0.2121591567993164,-0.03429889678955078,0.2464580535888672,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.8471479415893555,4.457095146179199,0.01821422576904297,-0.010891914367675781,0.02910614013671875,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.675615310668945,5.287601947784424,0.034911155700683594,0.10018491744995117,-0.06527376174926758,1.0,0.0
+4,A,5.554853439331055,5.055063724517822,0.013120174407958984,0.038752079010009766,-0.02563190460205078,1.0,0.0
+4,B,6.030457019805908,5.8057098388671875,-0.007145404815673828,-0.017969608306884766,0.010824203491210938,0.0,1.0
+4,B,6.698918342590332,5.852048873901367,0.16912841796875,-0.06045341491699219,0.2295818328857422,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.0468058586120605,5.874433517456055,0.030193805694580078,0.011967658996582031,0.018226146697998047,1.0,1.0
+4,B,7.254770278930664,6.474935531616211,0.29850339889526367,0.014978408813476562,0.2835249900817871,1.0,1.0
+4,B,8.317890167236328,7.564335823059082,0.09229469299316406,0.16370868682861328,-0.07141399383544922,1.0,0.0
+4,B,4.298234939575195,3.2507050037384033,0.4112722873687744,0.006254434585571289,0.4050178527832031,1.0,1.0
+5,A,4.891681671142578,4.708276271820068,0.16419744491577148,0.009338855743408203,0.15485858917236328,1.0,1.0
+5,A,6.319953918457031,5.677751541137695,0.07692623138427734,-0.011013507843017578,0.08793973922729492,1.0,1.0
+5,A,7.403562545776367,7.284399032592773,0.016935348510742188,0.007849693298339844,0.009085655212402344,1.0,1.0
+5,A,6.451829433441162,6.696488380432129,0.09722900390625,0.04492473602294922,0.05230426788330078,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.7898688316345215,6.439406394958496,-0.060718536376953125,-0.15611791610717773,0.09539937973022461,0.0,1.0
+5,A,5.311171531677246,4.8541951179504395,0.05989551544189453,-0.022600650787353516,0.08249616622924805,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.054815769195557,5.456230163574219,0.1615581512451172,0.07015657424926758,0.09140157699584961,1.0,1.0
+5,B,5.966301918029785,5.303574562072754,0.02993297576904297,0.07033061981201172,-0.04039764404296875,1.0,0.0
+5,B,9.263632774353027,8.895844459533691,0.11359691619873047,0.049709320068359375,0.0638875961303711,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.249509811401367,6.213594436645508,0.08800935745239258,-0.026485443115234375,0.11449480056762695,1.0,1.0
+5,B,8.410604476928711,8.194686889648438,0.038082122802734375,0.07197761535644531,-0.03389549255371094,1.0,0.0
+5,B,8.510919570922852,8.480401992797852,0.08750534057617188,0.054172515869140625,0.03333282470703125,1.0,1.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/hf_write_probe.txt

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+stage2r-b4-r7-r2 write probe 20260916T112742Z

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_lower_lr_replay.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,701 @@
+pair_index,cadence_slot,global_update,record_kind,mode,target_gap,specificity_gap,target_hinge_active,specificity_hinge_active
+0,inserted_midpoint,4,base,ZH_ZH,-0.055719852447509766,-0.028230667114257812,True,True
+0,inserted_midpoint,4,extra,ZH_EN,0.01190042495727539,0.010327816009521484,False,False
+0,historical_slot,8,base,ZH_ZH,0.004204273223876953,-0.0029959678649902344,False,False
+0,historical_slot,8,extra,ZH_EN,0.009390830993652344,0.02590656280517578,False,False
+1,inserted_midpoint,12,base,ZH_ZH,0.008183956146240234,-0.00047206878662109375,False,False
+1,inserted_midpoint,12,extra,EN_ZH,0.05455589294433594,-0.024023056030273438,False,True
+1,historical_slot,16,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0024480819702148438,-0.024892807006835938,False,True
+1,historical_slot,16,extra,EN_ZH,0.043946266174316406,0.0025272369384765625,False,False
+2,inserted_midpoint,20,base,ZH_EN,-0.029253005981445312,0.0055694580078125,True,False
+2,inserted_midpoint,20,extra,ZH_ZH,0.03672981262207031,0.022264480590820312,False,False
+2,historical_slot,24,base,ZH_EN,-0.010346174240112305,0.01470804214477539,True,False
+2,historical_slot,24,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04247474670410156,0.08713722229003906,False,False
+3,inserted_midpoint,28,base,EN_ZH,0.03254270553588867,-0.0218048095703125,False,True
+3,inserted_midpoint,28,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.009137392044067383,0.004920482635498047,True,False
+3,historical_slot,32,base,EN_ZH,0.12314319610595703,-0.016024112701416016,False,True
+3,historical_slot,32,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04056119918823242,0.051491498947143555,False,False
+4,inserted_midpoint,36,base,ZH_ZH,0.039551734924316406,0.02504587173461914,False,False
+4,inserted_midpoint,36,extra,ZH_EN,0.04908919334411621,0.04021739959716797,False,False
+4,historical_slot,40,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0030241012573242188,0.01319742202758789,False,False
+4,historical_slot,40,extra,ZH_EN,0.03625965118408203,0.025727272033691406,False,False
+5,inserted_midpoint,44,base,ZH_ZH,-0.01824188232421875,-0.0011749267578125,True,False
+5,inserted_midpoint,44,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0024499893188476562,0.011225700378417969,False,False
+5,historical_slot,48,base,ZH_ZH,-0.06471443176269531,-0.03115367889404297,True,True
+5,historical_slot,48,extra,EN_ZH,-0.016225814819335938,-0.0002918243408203125,True,False
+6,inserted_midpoint,52,base,ZH_EN,-0.021205425262451172,0.0005898475646972656,True,False
+6,inserted_midpoint,52,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.00013780593872070312,-0.02694082260131836,False,True
+6,historical_slot,56,base,ZH_EN,0.02268838882446289,-0.012958526611328125,False,True
+6,historical_slot,56,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.013736248016357422,-0.006703853607177734,True,True
+7,inserted_midpoint,60,base,EN_ZH,-0.005875587463378906,-0.006280422210693359,True,True
+7,inserted_midpoint,60,extra,ZH_ZH,0.008554458618164062,-0.007485866546630859,False,True
+7,historical_slot,64,base,EN_ZH,-0.006051540374755859,0.01665639877319336,True,False
+7,historical_slot,64,extra,ZH_ZH,0.008964061737060547,0.017669200897216797,False,False
+8,inserted_midpoint,68,base,ZH_ZH,0.030536651611328125,0.004044055938720703,False,False
+8,inserted_midpoint,68,extra,ZH_EN,0.012149810791015625,0.008595466613769531,False,False
+8,historical_slot,72,base,ZH_ZH,0.025887012481689453,-0.015456199645996094,False,True
+8,historical_slot,72,extra,ZH_EN,0.04030656814575195,0.03504133224487305,False,False
+9,inserted_midpoint,76,base,ZH_ZH,-0.025567054748535156,-0.003631591796875,True,False
+9,inserted_midpoint,76,extra,EN_ZH,0.0044536590576171875,0.05841970443725586,False,False
+9,historical_slot,80,base,ZH_ZH,-0.003055572509765625,0.014992713928222656,False,False
+9,historical_slot,80,extra,EN_ZH,-0.004372119903564453,0.057946205139160156,False,False
+10,inserted_midpoint,84,base,ZH_EN,-0.005276918411254883,0.06133413314819336,True,False
+10,inserted_midpoint,84,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.026422977447509766,-0.08701181411743164,True,True
+10,historical_slot,88,base,ZH_EN,-0.0005152225494384766,0.008388042449951172,False,False
+10,historical_slot,88,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.027210712432861328,-0.019893646240234375,True,True
+11,inserted_midpoint,92,base,EN_ZH,-0.003543376922607422,0.057552337646484375,False,False
+11,inserted_midpoint,92,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04893684387207031,0.06743407249450684,False,False
+11,historical_slot,96,base,EN_ZH,-0.010624885559082031,0.05605506896972656,True,False
+11,historical_slot,96,extra,ZH_ZH,0.03556084632873535,0.04366445541381836,False,False
+12,inserted_midpoint,100,base,ZH_ZH,0.06082773208618164,0.029870033264160156,False,False
+12,inserted_midpoint,100,extra,ZH_EN,0.0526738166809082,0.021654605865478516,False,False
+12,historical_slot,104,base,ZH_ZH,0.0722208023071289,0.0436854362487793,False,False
+12,historical_slot,104,extra,ZH_EN,0.08516216278076172,0.10089874267578125,False,False
+13,inserted_midpoint,108,base,ZH_ZH,0.010694026947021484,0.0017910003662109375,False,False
+13,inserted_midpoint,108,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0002827644348144531,0.08298301696777344,False,False
+13,historical_slot,112,base,ZH_ZH,-0.04112720489501953,0.010259628295898438,True,False
+13,historical_slot,112,extra,EN_ZH,-0.012105464935302734,0.033463478088378906,True,False
+14,inserted_midpoint,116,base,ZH_EN,0.07987785339355469,0.03598213195800781,False,False
+14,inserted_midpoint,116,extra,ZH_ZH,0.01571178436279297,0.07675695419311523,False,False
+14,historical_slot,120,base,ZH_EN,0.10720157623291016,0.06926107406616211,False,False
+14,historical_slot,120,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.026119709014892578,0.035692691802978516,True,False
+15,inserted_midpoint,124,base,EN_ZH,0.039800167083740234,-0.007937908172607422,False,True
+15,inserted_midpoint,124,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.05524921417236328,-0.040140628814697266,True,True
+15,historical_slot,128,base,EN_ZH,-0.0036602020263671875,0.004436016082763672,False,False
+15,historical_slot,128,extra,ZH_ZH,0.047100067138671875,0.041849613189697266,False,False
+16,inserted_midpoint,132,base,ZH_ZH,0.030242919921875,0.02965688705444336,False,False
+16,inserted_midpoint,132,extra,ZH_EN,-0.04085397720336914,-0.04666900634765625,True,True
+16,historical_slot,136,base,ZH_ZH,0.055721282958984375,0.048676490783691406,False,False
+16,historical_slot,136,extra,ZH_EN,0.006504535675048828,-0.0037441253662109375,False,False
+17,inserted_midpoint,140,base,ZH_ZH,0.052405595779418945,0.12224912643432617,False,False
+17,inserted_midpoint,140,extra,EN_ZH,0.02478647232055664,0.037952423095703125,False,False
+17,historical_slot,144,base,ZH_ZH,0.06490635871887207,0.14261484146118164,False,False
+17,historical_slot,144,extra,EN_ZH,0.014274120330810547,0.04636955261230469,False,False
+18,inserted_midpoint,148,base,ZH_EN,0.002727985382080078,0.20419692993164062,False,False
+18,inserted_midpoint,148,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.05422353744506836,0.006018161773681641,True,False
+18,historical_slot,152,base,ZH_EN,-0.006531715393066406,0.16599225997924805,True,False
+18,historical_slot,152,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.019709110260009766,0.00977182388305664,True,False
+19,inserted_midpoint,156,base,EN_ZH,-0.05497932434082031,-0.12326860427856445,True,True
+19,inserted_midpoint,156,extra,ZH_ZH,0.006998538970947266,0.015980243682861328,False,False
+19,historical_slot,160,base,EN_ZH,-0.021805286407470703,-0.028072834014892578,True,True
+19,historical_slot,160,extra,ZH_ZH,0.021137714385986328,-0.011186599731445312,False,True
+20,inserted_midpoint,164,base,ZH_ZH,-0.03504371643066406,-0.06548833847045898,True,True
+20,inserted_midpoint,164,extra,ZH_EN,0.029218196868896484,0.04299473762512207,False,False
+20,historical_slot,168,base,ZH_ZH,-0.002163410186767578,-0.045415401458740234,False,True
+20,historical_slot,168,extra,ZH_EN,0.07132339477539062,0.07133340835571289,False,False
+21,inserted_midpoint,172,base,ZH_ZH,-0.005617618560791016,0.0042724609375,True,False
+21,inserted_midpoint,172,extra,EN_ZH,0.01004648208618164,-0.039618492126464844,False,True
+21,historical_slot,176,base,ZH_ZH,0.022414684295654297,0.052332401275634766,False,False
+21,historical_slot,176,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0023908615112304688,-0.04630327224731445,False,True
+22,inserted_midpoint,180,base,ZH_EN,-0.011371135711669922,0.002087116241455078,True,False
+22,inserted_midpoint,180,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.35814523696899414,-0.3585062026977539,True,True
+22,historical_slot,184,base,ZH_EN,0.13341903686523438,-0.03491830825805664,False,True
+22,historical_slot,184,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.33597898483276367,-0.2675442695617676,True,True
+23,inserted_midpoint,188,base,EN_ZH,-0.026998519897460938,0.023031234741210938,True,False
+23,inserted_midpoint,188,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.04535961151123047,-0.039412498474121094,True,True
+23,historical_slot,192,base,EN_ZH,0.06767940521240234,0.029634475708007812,False,False
+23,historical_slot,192,extra,ZH_ZH,0.01608753204345703,-0.004124641418457031,False,False
+24,inserted_midpoint,196,base,ZH_ZH,-0.025197505950927734,-0.15875530242919922,True,True
+24,inserted_midpoint,196,extra,ZH_EN,-0.00930023193359375,0.028180599212646484,True,False
+24,historical_slot,200,base,ZH_ZH,0.005837440490722656,-0.12864017486572266,False,True
+24,historical_slot,200,extra,ZH_EN,-0.012914180755615234,0.02815532684326172,True,False
+25,inserted_midpoint,204,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0490117073059082,-0.03571939468383789,True,True
+25,inserted_midpoint,204,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0025997161865234375,0.01036834716796875,False,False
+25,historical_slot,208,base,ZH_ZH,-0.029010295867919922,0.018703460693359375,True,False
+25,historical_slot,208,extra,EN_ZH,-0.015413761138916016,-0.020966053009033203,True,True
+26,inserted_midpoint,212,base,ZH_EN,0.06437849998474121,-0.007281780242919922,False,True
+26,inserted_midpoint,212,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.0034761428833007812,0.030267715454101562,False,False
+26,historical_slot,216,base,ZH_EN,0.05390310287475586,0.02396249771118164,False,False
+26,historical_slot,216,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04537773132324219,0.09218025207519531,False,False
+27,inserted_midpoint,220,base,EN_ZH,0.011106014251708984,0.06221771240234375,False,False
+27,inserted_midpoint,220,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.020252704620361328,0.014911174774169922,True,False
+27,historical_slot,224,base,EN_ZH,-0.03930187225341797,0.0833139419555664,True,False
+27,historical_slot,224,extra,ZH_ZH,0.016040802001953125,0.028763771057128906,False,False
+28,inserted_midpoint,228,base,ZH_ZH,0.05609893798828125,-0.018767356872558594,False,True
+28,inserted_midpoint,228,extra,ZH_EN,-0.05360889434814453,0.006007671356201172,True,False
+28,historical_slot,232,base,ZH_ZH,0.07220697402954102,-0.004711151123046875,False,False
+28,historical_slot,232,extra,ZH_EN,0.0062181949615478516,0.0044438838958740234,False,False
+29,inserted_midpoint,236,base,ZH_ZH,0.018770694732666016,0.014360427856445312,False,False
+29,inserted_midpoint,236,extra,EN_ZH,-0.03262615203857422,0.05838727951049805,True,False
+29,historical_slot,240,base,ZH_ZH,0.02581310272216797,0.0345916748046875,False,False
+29,historical_slot,240,extra,EN_ZH,-0.053109169006347656,0.043367862701416016,True,False
+30,inserted_midpoint,244,base,ZH_EN,0.023673057556152344,0.007084369659423828,False,False
+30,inserted_midpoint,244,extra,ZH_ZH,0.01065826416015625,-0.06432247161865234,False,True
+30,historical_slot,248,base,ZH_EN,0.001996755599975586,0.03119969367980957,False,False
+30,historical_slot,248,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.02626514434814453,-0.0702352523803711,True,True
+31,inserted_midpoint,252,base,EN_ZH,-0.031002044677734375,-0.0022640228271484375,True,False
+31,inserted_midpoint,252,extra,ZH_ZH,0.041002750396728516,-0.013173580169677734,False,True
+31,historical_slot,256,base,EN_ZH,-0.010610580444335938,-0.03721761703491211,True,True
+31,historical_slot,256,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07041215896606445,0.0826711654663086,False,False
+32,inserted_midpoint,260,base,ZH_ZH,0.10423803329467773,0.06116962432861328,False,False
+32,inserted_midpoint,260,extra,ZH_EN,-0.02492666244506836,-0.03677034378051758,True,True
+32,historical_slot,264,base,ZH_ZH,0.07986831665039062,0.04698991775512695,False,False
+32,historical_slot,264,extra,ZH_EN,0.007215023040771484,-0.002079486846923828,False,False
+33,inserted_midpoint,268,base,ZH_ZH,0.08159160614013672,0.1040811538696289,False,False
+33,inserted_midpoint,268,extra,EN_ZH,0.1356642246246338,0.09119343757629395,False,False
+33,historical_slot,272,base,ZH_ZH,0.059168338775634766,0.0360870361328125,False,False
+33,historical_slot,272,extra,EN_ZH,0.15302753448486328,0.06563210487365723,False,False
+34,inserted_midpoint,276,base,ZH_EN,0.06936073303222656,0.0762176513671875,False,False
+34,inserted_midpoint,276,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.00113677978515625,0.032190799713134766,False,False
+34,historical_slot,280,base,ZH_EN,0.05975055694580078,0.08263206481933594,False,False
+34,historical_slot,280,extra,ZH_ZH,0.031481266021728516,0.055292606353759766,False,False
+35,inserted_midpoint,284,base,EN_ZH,-0.056987762451171875,0.06115150451660156,True,False
+35,inserted_midpoint,284,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.004781246185302734,0.01930856704711914,False,False
+35,historical_slot,288,base,EN_ZH,-0.00984334945678711,0.06051492691040039,True,False
+35,historical_slot,288,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0024809837341308594,0.05695819854736328,False,False
+36,inserted_midpoint,292,base,ZH_ZH,0.017612934112548828,0.04093456268310547,False,False
+36,inserted_midpoint,292,extra,ZH_EN,0.003949165344238281,0.02357339859008789,False,False
+36,historical_slot,296,base,ZH_ZH,0.0018439292907714844,-0.008975028991699219,False,True
+36,historical_slot,296,extra,ZH_EN,-0.04361224174499512,0.04875802993774414,True,False
+37,inserted_midpoint,300,base,ZH_ZH,0.04010629653930664,0.018796443939208984,False,False
+37,inserted_midpoint,300,extra,EN_ZH,-0.03199148178100586,-0.03583335876464844,True,True
+37,historical_slot,304,base,ZH_ZH,-0.014265060424804688,0.04820585250854492,True,False
+37,historical_slot,304,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0017862319946289062,-0.012470722198486328,False,True
+38,inserted_midpoint,308,base,ZH_EN,-0.06108522415161133,-0.008069992065429688,True,True
+38,inserted_midpoint,308,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02546405792236328,0.013071060180664062,False,False
+38,historical_slot,312,base,ZH_EN,-0.016536235809326172,0.0016837120056152344,True,False
+38,historical_slot,312,extra,ZH_ZH,0.007485389709472656,0.008976936340332031,False,False
+39,inserted_midpoint,316,base,EN_ZH,-0.00984954833984375,-0.019252300262451172,True,True
+39,inserted_midpoint,316,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0845041275024414,0.04862356185913086,False,False
+39,historical_slot,320,base,EN_ZH,-0.037270545959472656,-0.048468589782714844,True,True
+39,historical_slot,320,extra,ZH_ZH,0.018511295318603516,0.019243717193603516,False,False
+40,inserted_midpoint,324,base,ZH_ZH,-0.021888256072998047,-0.015679359436035156,True,True
+40,inserted_midpoint,324,extra,ZH_EN,0.018149375915527344,-0.007263660430908203,False,True
+40,historical_slot,328,base,ZH_ZH,0.004206657409667969,0.027170658111572266,False,False
+40,historical_slot,328,extra,ZH_EN,0.006076812744140625,0.009295940399169922,False,False
+41,inserted_midpoint,332,base,ZH_ZH,0.04327201843261719,-0.016904830932617188,False,True
+41,inserted_midpoint,332,extra,EN_ZH,-0.041689395904541016,0.019660472869873047,True,False
+41,historical_slot,336,base,ZH_ZH,0.08105611801147461,0.016490459442138672,False,False
+41,historical_slot,336,extra,EN_ZH,-0.027753353118896484,0.012351512908935547,True,False
+42,inserted_midpoint,340,base,ZH_EN,-0.0074732303619384766,0.038358449935913086,True,False
+42,inserted_midpoint,340,extra,ZH_ZH,0.2657947540283203,0.2292776107788086,False,False
+42,historical_slot,344,base,ZH_EN,0.015773296356201172,0.05879497528076172,False,False
+42,historical_slot,344,extra,ZH_ZH,0.2887248992919922,0.2107834815979004,False,False
+43,inserted_midpoint,348,base,EN_ZH,0.02361583709716797,0.0454096794128418,False,False
+43,inserted_midpoint,348,extra,ZH_ZH,0.06091785430908203,0.08625984191894531,False,False
+43,historical_slot,352,base,EN_ZH,0.04323577880859375,0.07147336006164551,False,False
+43,historical_slot,352,extra,ZH_ZH,0.027433395385742188,0.0641326904296875,False,False
+44,inserted_midpoint,356,base,ZH_ZH,0.02065134048461914,-0.027527809143066406,False,True
+44,inserted_midpoint,356,extra,ZH_EN,-0.0018787384033203125,-0.022904157638549805,False,True
+44,historical_slot,360,base,ZH_ZH,0.013983726501464844,-0.06097555160522461,False,True
+44,historical_slot,360,extra,ZH_EN,0.00409388542175293,-0.0022935867309570312,False,False
+45,inserted_midpoint,364,base,ZH_ZH,-0.016885757446289062,0.02126789093017578,True,False
+45,inserted_midpoint,364,extra,EN_ZH,-0.026189804077148438,0.009387493133544922,True,False
+45,historical_slot,368,base,ZH_ZH,0.008970260620117188,0.054802894592285156,False,False
+45,historical_slot,368,extra,EN_ZH,-0.028044939041137695,-0.013325691223144531,True,True
+46,inserted_midpoint,372,base,ZH_EN,-0.018712759017944336,-0.04315018653869629,True,True
+46,inserted_midpoint,372,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07160568237304688,-0.009055614471435547,False,True
+46,historical_slot,376,base,ZH_EN,0.0020852088928222656,-0.008706092834472656,False,True
+46,historical_slot,376,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02857685089111328,0.031809329986572266,False,False
+47,inserted_midpoint,380,base,EN_ZH,0.05531883239746094,0.04497861862182617,False,False
+47,inserted_midpoint,380,extra,ZH_ZH,0.06497335433959961,0.010399341583251953,False,False
+47,historical_slot,384,base,EN_ZH,0.05038738250732422,0.07202434539794922,False,False
+47,historical_slot,384,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0329437255859375,-0.03361034393310547,False,True
+48,inserted_midpoint,388,base,ZH_ZH,-0.036197662353515625,-0.02680492401123047,True,True
+48,inserted_midpoint,388,extra,ZH_EN,-0.00890970230102539,-0.024474620819091797,True,True
+48,historical_slot,392,base,ZH_ZH,-0.010428428649902344,0.010921001434326172,True,False
+48,historical_slot,392,extra,ZH_EN,-0.010538101196289062,-0.0029206275939941406,True,False
+49,inserted_midpoint,396,base,ZH_ZH,0.03130674362182617,0.13856172561645508,False,False
+49,inserted_midpoint,396,extra,EN_ZH,-0.053233981132507324,0.04347419738769531,True,False
+49,historical_slot,400,base,ZH_ZH,0.0330653190612793,0.15209245681762695,False,False
+49,historical_slot,400,extra,EN_ZH,-0.018816113471984863,-0.03181767463684082,True,True
+50,inserted_midpoint,404,base,ZH_EN,-0.002416849136352539,0.008735895156860352,False,False
+50,inserted_midpoint,404,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.0034542083740234375,0.01342153549194336,False,False
+50,historical_slot,408,base,ZH_EN,0.0603330135345459,0.07538676261901855,False,False
+50,historical_slot,408,extra,ZH_ZH,0.021852970123291016,0.021407604217529297,False,False
+51,inserted_midpoint,412,base,EN_ZH,0.06455087661743164,0.11829781532287598,False,False
+51,inserted_midpoint,412,extra,ZH_ZH,0.09992504119873047,0.021419048309326172,False,False
+51,historical_slot,416,base,EN_ZH,0.06416726112365723,0.09116721153259277,False,False
+51,historical_slot,416,extra,ZH_ZH,0.10730934143066406,0.012638568878173828,False,False
+52,inserted_midpoint,420,base,ZH_ZH,-0.027558326721191406,-0.08652257919311523,True,True
+52,inserted_midpoint,420,extra,ZH_EN,0.05711507797241211,0.06602001190185547,False,False
+52,historical_slot,424,base,ZH_ZH,-0.016654014587402344,-0.04837179183959961,True,True
+52,historical_slot,424,extra,ZH_EN,0.03234434127807617,0.041436195373535156,False,False
+53,inserted_midpoint,428,base,ZH_ZH,-0.014565706253051758,0.08989238739013672,True,False
+53,inserted_midpoint,428,extra,EN_ZH,0.03684425354003906,-0.15076208114624023,False,True
+53,historical_slot,432,base,ZH_ZH,0.040895700454711914,0.10980463027954102,False,False
+53,historical_slot,432,extra,EN_ZH,-0.006879329681396484,-0.09349346160888672,True,True
+54,inserted_midpoint,436,base,ZH_EN,-0.07203078269958496,-0.05872845649719238,True,True
+54,inserted_midpoint,436,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07716131210327148,0.0095367431640625,False,False
+54,historical_slot,440,base,ZH_EN,-0.011350631713867188,-0.0033216476440429688,True,False
+54,historical_slot,440,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04894065856933594,0.002696514129638672,False,False
+55,inserted_midpoint,444,base,EN_ZH,-0.010991096496582031,-0.01287078857421875,True,True
+55,inserted_midpoint,444,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.03216385841369629,-0.01893901824951172,True,True
+55,historical_slot,448,base,EN_ZH,0.008806705474853516,-0.01542806625366211,False,True
+55,historical_slot,448,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.05705618858337402,-3.337860107421875e-05,True,False
+56,inserted_midpoint,452,base,ZH_ZH,0.008033514022827148,0.04670262336730957,False,False
+56,inserted_midpoint,452,extra,ZH_EN,0.0862579345703125,0.017998933792114258,False,False
+56,historical_slot,456,base,ZH_ZH,0.0311276912689209,0.0540928840637207,False,False
+56,historical_slot,456,extra,ZH_EN,0.07471013069152832,-0.007138729095458984,False,True
+57,inserted_midpoint,460,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0009365081787109375,0.024772167205810547,False,False
+57,inserted_midpoint,460,extra,EN_ZH,0.02858734130859375,0.05024290084838867,False,False
+57,historical_slot,464,base,ZH_ZH,0.0040645599365234375,-0.016071319580078125,False,True
+57,historical_slot,464,extra,EN_ZH,0.022829532623291016,0.07921981811523438,False,False
+58,inserted_midpoint,468,base,ZH_EN,0.053142547607421875,0.029571056365966797,False,False
+58,inserted_midpoint,468,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.029337644577026367,-0.03711271286010742,True,True
+58,historical_slot,472,base,ZH_EN,0.05931663513183594,0.010609865188598633,False,False
+58,historical_slot,472,extra,ZH_ZH,0.004181861877441406,-0.020179033279418945,False,True
+59,inserted_midpoint,476,base,EN_ZH,0.2627429962158203,0.22991704940795898,False,False
+59,inserted_midpoint,476,extra,ZH_ZH,0.046114325523376465,0.050874948501586914,False,False
+59,historical_slot,480,base,EN_ZH,0.23479223251342773,0.17513608932495117,False,False
+59,historical_slot,480,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02595698833465576,0.042368292808532715,False,False
+60,inserted_midpoint,484,base,ZH_ZH,0.005688190460205078,-0.11881256103515625,False,True
+60,inserted_midpoint,484,extra,ZH_EN,0.05864238739013672,0.020123958587646484,False,False
+60,historical_slot,488,base,ZH_ZH,0.0013155937194824219,-0.03831958770751953,False,True
+60,historical_slot,488,extra,ZH_EN,0.06100034713745117,-0.011316776275634766,False,True
+61,inserted_midpoint,492,base,ZH_ZH,0.015499114990234375,0.041355133056640625,False,False
+61,inserted_midpoint,492,extra,EN_ZH,-0.09818458557128906,0.11197376251220703,True,False
+61,historical_slot,496,base,ZH_ZH,0.021071434020996094,0.05118608474731445,False,False
+61,historical_slot,496,extra,EN_ZH,-0.058188438415527344,0.10756349563598633,True,False
+62,inserted_midpoint,500,base,ZH_EN,-0.00393223762512207,0.04314422607421875,False,False
+62,inserted_midpoint,500,extra,ZH_ZH,0.10382843017578125,0.12482261657714844,False,False
+62,historical_slot,504,base,ZH_EN,0.011166572570800781,0.06924891471862793,False,False
+62,historical_slot,504,extra,ZH_ZH,0.059139251708984375,0.1148080825805664,False,False
+63,inserted_midpoint,508,base,EN_ZH,0.01986980438232422,0.18533992767333984,False,False
+63,inserted_midpoint,508,extra,ZH_ZH,0.002197742462158203,0.05045747756958008,False,False
+63,historical_slot,512,base,EN_ZH,0.019868850708007812,0.1370258331298828,False,False
+63,historical_slot,512,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.04569196701049805,0.0116119384765625,True,False
+64,inserted_midpoint,516,base,ZH_ZH,0.042565345764160156,0.07170391082763672,False,False
+64,inserted_midpoint,516,extra,ZH_EN,0.05040788650512695,0.046839237213134766,False,False
+64,historical_slot,520,base,ZH_ZH,0.049834251403808594,0.08510780334472656,False,False
+64,historical_slot,520,extra,ZH_EN,0.09563493728637695,0.03892087936401367,False,False
+65,inserted_midpoint,524,base,ZH_ZH,0.021902084350585938,0.006744384765625,False,False
+65,inserted_midpoint,524,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0590062141418457,-0.030247211456298828,True,True
+65,historical_slot,528,base,ZH_ZH,0.0171356201171875,-0.0028944015502929688,False,False
+65,historical_slot,528,extra,EN_ZH,-0.028752803802490234,-0.01215219497680664,True,True
+66,inserted_midpoint,532,base,ZH_EN,0.02949047088623047,-0.028461694717407227,False,True
+66,inserted_midpoint,532,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.014278888702392578,-0.03826475143432617,True,True
+66,historical_slot,536,base,ZH_EN,0.026782989501953125,0.005079984664916992,False,False
+66,historical_slot,536,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.0037736892700195312,-0.008310317993164062,False,True
+67,inserted_midpoint,540,base,EN_ZH,0.05505847930908203,-0.03447151184082031,False,True
+67,inserted_midpoint,540,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04463052749633789,-0.020502567291259766,False,True
+67,historical_slot,544,base,EN_ZH,0.016843795776367188,-0.025548934936523438,False,True
+67,historical_slot,544,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.0004734992980957031,0.0029811859130859375,False,False
+68,inserted_midpoint,548,base,ZH_ZH,-0.015662193298339844,-0.037854671478271484,True,True
+68,inserted_midpoint,548,extra,ZH_EN,0.0514826774597168,0.06596755981445312,False,False
+68,historical_slot,552,base,ZH_ZH,0.015438556671142578,0.044687747955322266,False,False
+68,historical_slot,552,extra,ZH_EN,0.04024934768676758,0.030908584594726562,False,False
+69,inserted_midpoint,556,base,ZH_ZH,0.0033278465270996094,0.04180002212524414,False,False
+69,inserted_midpoint,556,extra,EN_ZH,0.009476184844970703,0.0024547576904296875,False,False
+69,historical_slot,560,base,ZH_ZH,-0.006000995635986328,0.041970252990722656,True,False
+69,historical_slot,560,extra,EN_ZH,0.0072002410888671875,0.029695510864257812,False,False
+70,inserted_midpoint,564,base,ZH_EN,0.17197942733764648,0.1805253028869629,False,False
+70,inserted_midpoint,564,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.049211740493774414,0.007835149765014648,True,False
+70,historical_slot,568,base,ZH_EN,0.2479548454284668,0.2714262008666992,False,False
+70,historical_slot,568,extra,ZH_ZH,0.03232884407043457,0.040807485580444336,False,False
+71,inserted_midpoint,572,base,EN_ZH,0.0811147689819336,-0.012402057647705078,False,True
+71,inserted_midpoint,572,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.04935050010681152,-0.04249906539916992,True,True
+71,historical_slot,576,base,EN_ZH,0.11386394500732422,0.030954360961914062,False,False
+71,historical_slot,576,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0034978389739990234,-0.02039933204650879,False,True
+72,inserted_midpoint,580,base,ZH_ZH,0.038918495178222656,0.023004531860351562,False,False
+72,inserted_midpoint,580,extra,ZH_EN,0.018439054489135742,0.0721738338470459,False,False
+72,historical_slot,584,base,ZH_ZH,0.053076744079589844,0.04556703567504883,False,False
+72,historical_slot,584,extra,ZH_EN,0.0032896995544433594,0.03274083137512207,False,False
+73,inserted_midpoint,588,base,ZH_ZH,0.2369372844696045,0.22200870513916016,False,False
+73,inserted_midpoint,588,extra,EN_ZH,0.02918100357055664,0.04040670394897461,False,False
+73,historical_slot,592,base,ZH_ZH,0.21523785591125488,0.20585942268371582,False,False
+73,historical_slot,592,extra,EN_ZH,0.007194042205810547,0.021561145782470703,False,False
+74,inserted_midpoint,596,base,ZH_EN,0.027156829833984375,0.023223876953125,False,False
+74,inserted_midpoint,596,extra,ZH_ZH,0.033059120178222656,-0.0018839836120605469,False,False
+74,historical_slot,600,base,ZH_EN,0.033621788024902344,0.009271621704101562,False,False
+74,historical_slot,600,extra,ZH_ZH,0.038094520568847656,0.020866870880126953,False,False
+75,inserted_midpoint,604,base,EN_ZH,-0.05886030197143555,-0.07247209548950195,True,True
+75,inserted_midpoint,604,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07282543182373047,0.07215356826782227,False,False
+75,historical_slot,608,base,EN_ZH,-0.10434961318969727,-0.04300570487976074,True,True
+75,historical_slot,608,extra,ZH_ZH,0.09217357635498047,0.14302635192871094,False,False
+76,inserted_midpoint,612,base,ZH_ZH,0.05785846710205078,-0.03965282440185547,False,True
+76,inserted_midpoint,612,extra,ZH_EN,0.11800599098205566,0.16372179985046387,False,False
+76,historical_slot,616,base,ZH_ZH,0.04496574401855469,0.03754425048828125,False,False
+76,historical_slot,616,extra,ZH_EN,0.08662867546081543,0.11830401420593262,False,False
+77,inserted_midpoint,620,base,ZH_ZH,0.04627704620361328,-0.03750467300415039,False,True
+77,inserted_midpoint,620,extra,EN_ZH,0.010208606719970703,0.01572895050048828,False,False
+77,historical_slot,624,base,ZH_ZH,0.021405696868896484,0.0038628578186035156,False,False
+77,historical_slot,624,extra,EN_ZH,0.016812801361083984,0.018358230590820312,False,False
+78,inserted_midpoint,628,base,ZH_EN,0.1688823699951172,0.21448278427124023,False,False
+78,inserted_midpoint,628,extra,ZH_ZH,0.15089201927185059,0.14336562156677246,False,False
+78,historical_slot,632,base,ZH_EN,0.1834888458251953,0.23415637016296387,False,False
+78,historical_slot,632,extra,ZH_ZH,0.22164058685302734,0.1533961296081543,False,False
+79,inserted_midpoint,636,base,EN_ZH,0.00885152816772461,0.028772354125976562,False,False
+79,inserted_midpoint,636,extra,ZH_ZH,0.05392932891845703,0.05339813232421875,False,False
+79,historical_slot,640,base,EN_ZH,0.023190021514892578,0.032039642333984375,False,False
+79,historical_slot,640,extra,ZH_ZH,0.032535552978515625,0.019608497619628906,False,False
+80,inserted_midpoint,644,base,ZH_ZH,-0.030035972595214844,-0.039379119873046875,True,True
+80,inserted_midpoint,644,extra,ZH_EN,0.05592751502990723,0.08615422248840332,False,False
+80,historical_slot,648,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0077075958251953125,0.028552532196044922,True,False
+80,historical_slot,648,extra,ZH_EN,0.04348039627075195,0.0846548080444336,False,False
+81,inserted_midpoint,652,base,ZH_ZH,-0.02055644989013672,-0.044957637786865234,True,True
+81,inserted_midpoint,652,extra,EN_ZH,-0.06522750854492188,-0.008873939514160156,True,True
+81,historical_slot,656,base,ZH_ZH,-0.028163909912109375,-0.03858518600463867,True,True
+81,historical_slot,656,extra,EN_ZH,0.019186973571777344,0.05179166793823242,False,False
+82,inserted_midpoint,660,base,ZH_EN,-0.0373990535736084,-0.07572126388549805,True,True
+82,inserted_midpoint,660,extra,ZH_ZH,0.035819292068481445,0.019052505493164062,False,False
+82,historical_slot,664,base,ZH_EN,0.022318124771118164,-0.05263876914978027,False,True
+82,historical_slot,664,extra,ZH_ZH,0.08664464950561523,0.014809608459472656,False,False
+83,inserted_midpoint,668,base,EN_ZH,0.037487030029296875,0.013661384582519531,False,False
+83,inserted_midpoint,668,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.7263450622558594,-0.6507124900817871,True,True
+83,historical_slot,672,base,EN_ZH,0.02059316635131836,-0.06103086471557617,False,True
+83,historical_slot,672,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.5678062438964844,-0.5816998481750488,True,True
+84,inserted_midpoint,676,base,ZH_ZH,0.019831180572509766,0.045340538024902344,False,False
+84,inserted_midpoint,676,extra,ZH_EN,-0.0016560554504394531,0.019891023635864258,False,False
+84,historical_slot,680,base,ZH_ZH,0.004603385925292969,0.01685476303100586,False,False
+84,historical_slot,680,extra,ZH_EN,-0.005517482757568359,0.025952577590942383,True,False
+85,inserted_midpoint,684,base,ZH_ZH,-0.011021137237548828,-0.0428166389465332,True,True
+85,inserted_midpoint,684,extra,EN_ZH,-0.058825016021728516,0.04966878890991211,True,False
+85,historical_slot,688,base,ZH_ZH,-0.06255769729614258,-0.053681373596191406,True,True
+85,historical_slot,688,extra,EN_ZH,-0.06197404861450195,0.01615762710571289,True,False
+86,inserted_midpoint,692,base,ZH_EN,0.06168866157531738,0.06817221641540527,False,False
+86,inserted_midpoint,692,extra,ZH_ZH,0.011038780212402344,0.05884981155395508,False,False
+86,historical_slot,696,base,ZH_EN,0.05536818504333496,0.05898594856262207,False,False
+86,historical_slot,696,extra,ZH_ZH,0.059163570404052734,0.09153604507446289,False,False
+87,inserted_midpoint,700,base,EN_ZH,-0.09643793106079102,0.17162418365478516,True,False
+87,inserted_midpoint,700,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0004749298095703125,0.005983829498291016,False,False
+87,historical_slot,704,base,EN_ZH,-0.11027812957763672,0.12001705169677734,True,False
+87,historical_slot,704,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.0413813591003418,-0.024960041046142578,True,True
+88,inserted_midpoint,708,base,ZH_ZH,-0.01770782470703125,-0.09789133071899414,True,True
+88,inserted_midpoint,708,extra,ZH_EN,0.0026426315307617188,0.010709047317504883,False,False
+88,historical_slot,712,base,ZH_ZH,-0.06601762771606445,-0.12084054946899414,True,True
+88,historical_slot,712,extra,ZH_EN,0.056828975677490234,0.03818225860595703,False,False
+89,inserted_midpoint,716,base,ZH_ZH,0.11963844299316406,0.11646533012390137,False,False
+89,inserted_midpoint,716,extra,EN_ZH,0.0678243637084961,0.07554388046264648,False,False
+89,historical_slot,720,base,ZH_ZH,0.0981132984161377,0.09907102584838867,False,False
+89,historical_slot,720,extra,EN_ZH,-0.008198738098144531,-0.02904510498046875,True,True
+90,inserted_midpoint,724,base,ZH_EN,0.024201154708862305,0.1667783260345459,False,False
+90,inserted_midpoint,724,extra,ZH_ZH,0.08363771438598633,0.0486602783203125,False,False
+90,historical_slot,728,base,ZH_EN,-0.06414604187011719,0.06196427345275879,True,False
+90,historical_slot,728,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07423067092895508,0.11800670623779297,False,False
+91,inserted_midpoint,732,base,EN_ZH,-0.028707504272460938,-0.04990959167480469,True,True
+91,inserted_midpoint,732,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02593517303466797,0.0328679084777832,False,False
+91,historical_slot,736,base,EN_ZH,0.022507190704345703,-0.0017094612121582031,False,False
+91,historical_slot,736,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.025092601776123047,0.04656791687011719,True,False
+92,inserted_midpoint,740,base,ZH_ZH,-0.06345796585083008,0.041765689849853516,True,False
+92,inserted_midpoint,740,extra,ZH_EN,-0.02103447914123535,0.00879526138305664,True,False
+92,historical_slot,744,base,ZH_ZH,-0.03247499465942383,0.007395267486572266,True,False
+92,historical_slot,744,extra,ZH_EN,0.05635666847229004,0.0438077449798584,False,False
+93,inserted_midpoint,748,base,ZH_ZH,0.07821917533874512,0.04485487937927246,False,False
+93,inserted_midpoint,748,extra,EN_ZH,-0.007470607757568359,0.08503341674804688,True,False
+93,historical_slot,752,base,ZH_ZH,0.05911827087402344,0.021665573120117188,False,False
+93,historical_slot,752,extra,EN_ZH,-0.031612396240234375,0.003883838653564453,True,False
+94,inserted_midpoint,756,base,ZH_EN,0.014174699783325195,0.017286300659179688,False,False
+94,inserted_midpoint,756,extra,ZH_ZH,0.021110057830810547,0.05507516860961914,False,False
+94,historical_slot,760,base,ZH_EN,-0.0033626556396484375,0.03287982940673828,False,False
+94,historical_slot,760,extra,ZH_ZH,0.006802082061767578,0.09954357147216797,False,False
+95,inserted_midpoint,764,base,EN_ZH,-0.17610788345336914,-0.263455867767334,True,True
+95,inserted_midpoint,764,extra,ZH_ZH,0.03325510025024414,0.021778583526611328,False,False
+95,historical_slot,768,base,EN_ZH,-0.10964393615722656,-0.06167316436767578,True,True
+95,historical_slot,768,extra,ZH_ZH,0.004639625549316406,-0.020503997802734375,False,True
+96,inserted_midpoint,772,base,ZH_ZH,0.11289405822753906,0.08266401290893555,False,False
+96,inserted_midpoint,772,extra,ZH_EN,-0.10418128967285156,-0.01897716522216797,True,True
+96,historical_slot,776,base,ZH_ZH,0.11700677871704102,0.09830474853515625,False,False
+96,historical_slot,776,extra,ZH_EN,-0.05987834930419922,-0.036556243896484375,True,True
+97,inserted_midpoint,780,base,ZH_ZH,0.004897594451904297,-0.008451461791992188,False,True
+97,inserted_midpoint,780,extra,EN_ZH,0.0916132926940918,0.0814981460571289,False,False
+97,historical_slot,784,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0063953399658203125,-0.005959510803222656,True,True
+97,historical_slot,784,extra,EN_ZH,0.09397506713867188,0.10677480697631836,False,False
+98,inserted_midpoint,788,base,ZH_EN,0.05124473571777344,0.12165594100952148,False,False
+98,inserted_midpoint,788,extra,ZH_ZH,0.17568206787109375,0.18469524383544922,False,False
+98,historical_slot,792,base,ZH_EN,0.03963422775268555,0.1656935214996338,False,False
+98,historical_slot,792,extra,ZH_ZH,0.15606689453125,0.16333818435668945,False,False
+99,inserted_midpoint,796,base,EN_ZH,0.05719137191772461,0.045549869537353516,False,False
+99,inserted_midpoint,796,extra,ZH_ZH,0.24401259422302246,0.25922656059265137,False,False
+99,historical_slot,800,base,EN_ZH,0.07129335403442383,0.016530990600585938,False,False
+99,historical_slot,800,extra,ZH_ZH,0.24807095527648926,0.2515735626220703,False,False
+100,inserted_midpoint,804,base,ZH_ZH,0.1511216163635254,0.1529374122619629,False,False
+100,inserted_midpoint,804,extra,ZH_EN,-0.024419665336608887,-0.04044675827026367,True,True
+100,historical_slot,808,base,ZH_ZH,0.15744829177856445,0.14610624313354492,False,False
+100,historical_slot,808,extra,ZH_EN,-0.05206120014190674,-0.038841962814331055,True,True
+101,inserted_midpoint,812,base,ZH_ZH,0.04202079772949219,0.04279661178588867,False,False
+101,inserted_midpoint,812,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0135955810546875,-0.07126331329345703,True,True
+101,historical_slot,816,base,ZH_ZH,0.017330169677734375,-0.0022449493408203125,False,False
+101,historical_slot,816,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0014786720275878906,-0.02321624755859375,False,True
+102,inserted_midpoint,820,base,ZH_EN,0.14715337753295898,0.06991100311279297,False,False
+102,inserted_midpoint,820,extra,ZH_ZH,0.026194095611572266,0.015691280364990234,False,False
+102,historical_slot,824,base,ZH_EN,0.12824726104736328,0.06805109977722168,False,False
+102,historical_slot,824,extra,ZH_ZH,0.01993560791015625,-0.0155487060546875,False,True
+103,inserted_midpoint,828,base,EN_ZH,-0.09055519104003906,0.0706167221069336,True,False
+103,inserted_midpoint,828,extra,ZH_ZH,0.050332069396972656,-0.020286083221435547,False,True
+103,historical_slot,832,base,EN_ZH,-0.09309530258178711,0.05377483367919922,True,False
+103,historical_slot,832,extra,ZH_ZH,0.024565696716308594,0.01853322982788086,False,False
+104,inserted_midpoint,836,base,ZH_ZH,0.16605567932128906,0.20691442489624023,False,False
+104,inserted_midpoint,836,extra,ZH_EN,0.6981945037841797,0.6800642013549805,False,False
+104,historical_slot,840,base,ZH_ZH,0.18142271041870117,0.19350957870483398,False,False
+104,historical_slot,840,extra,ZH_EN,0.6814517974853516,0.6765484809875488,False,False
+105,inserted_midpoint,844,base,ZH_ZH,0.02671051025390625,0.044066429138183594,False,False
+105,inserted_midpoint,844,extra,EN_ZH,-0.02800607681274414,0.06668424606323242,True,False
+105,historical_slot,848,base,ZH_ZH,0.018033981323242188,0.06044197082519531,False,False
+105,historical_slot,848,extra,EN_ZH,-0.0010218620300292969,0.020528793334960938,False,False
+106,inserted_midpoint,852,base,ZH_EN,-0.0013859272003173828,-0.03857755661010742,False,True
+106,inserted_midpoint,852,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07050371170043945,0.01835775375366211,False,False
+106,historical_slot,856,base,ZH_EN,0.016202449798583984,-0.02797079086303711,False,True
+106,historical_slot,856,extra,ZH_ZH,0.08877849578857422,0.026015758514404297,False,False
+107,inserted_midpoint,860,base,EN_ZH,0.023290634155273438,0.10047054290771484,False,False
+107,inserted_midpoint,860,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.022706031799316406,0.07774758338928223,True,False
+107,historical_slot,864,base,EN_ZH,0.08200216293334961,0.10834789276123047,False,False
+107,historical_slot,864,extra,ZH_ZH,0.09170937538146973,0.1196296215057373,False,False
+108,inserted_midpoint,868,base,ZH_ZH,0.1437664031982422,0.10588550567626953,False,False
+108,inserted_midpoint,868,extra,ZH_EN,-0.10896849632263184,-0.025429248809814453,True,True
+108,historical_slot,872,base,ZH_ZH,0.12929439544677734,0.13648223876953125,False,False
+108,historical_slot,872,extra,ZH_EN,-0.04085206985473633,0.008434772491455078,True,False
+109,inserted_midpoint,876,base,ZH_ZH,0.04592132568359375,0.04361581802368164,False,False
+109,inserted_midpoint,876,extra,EN_ZH,0.15011262893676758,0.19163751602172852,False,False
+109,historical_slot,880,base,ZH_ZH,-0.013033866882324219,0.013317108154296875,True,False
+109,historical_slot,880,extra,EN_ZH,0.1392536163330078,0.18908309936523438,False,False
+110,inserted_midpoint,884,base,ZH_EN,0.07520365715026855,0.08519577980041504,False,False
+110,inserted_midpoint,884,extra,ZH_ZH,0.08354806900024414,0.11597204208374023,False,False
+110,historical_slot,888,base,ZH_EN,0.07948589324951172,0.08026623725891113,False,False
+110,historical_slot,888,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.028156757354736328,0.11524009704589844,True,False
+111,inserted_midpoint,892,base,EN_ZH,0.058547019958496094,0.018863201141357422,False,False
+111,inserted_midpoint,892,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04675436019897461,0.0874791145324707,False,False
+111,historical_slot,896,base,EN_ZH,0.061316490173339844,0.0349578857421875,False,False
+111,historical_slot,896,extra,ZH_ZH,0.024914264678955078,0.08449554443359375,False,False
+112,inserted_midpoint,900,base,ZH_ZH,0.09736919403076172,0.11590099334716797,False,False
+112,inserted_midpoint,900,extra,ZH_EN,-0.10402774810791016,-0.05791950225830078,True,True
+112,historical_slot,904,base,ZH_ZH,0.10839462280273438,0.1262521743774414,False,False
+112,historical_slot,904,extra,ZH_EN,-0.05158424377441406,-0.01925969123840332,True,True
+113,inserted_midpoint,908,base,ZH_ZH,0.08137822151184082,0.18632793426513672,False,False
+113,inserted_midpoint,908,extra,EN_ZH,0.037790775299072266,0.005007743835449219,False,False
+113,historical_slot,912,base,ZH_ZH,0.11940693855285645,0.1568465232849121,False,False
+113,historical_slot,912,extra,EN_ZH,0.021441936492919922,0.05901336669921875,False,False
+114,inserted_midpoint,916,base,ZH_EN,0.013678312301635742,0.11257243156433105,False,False
+114,inserted_midpoint,916,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.04472494125366211,0.0019998550415039062,True,False
+114,historical_slot,920,base,ZH_EN,-0.011690378189086914,0.08205413818359375,True,False
+114,historical_slot,920,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.031140804290771484,0.020949840545654297,True,False
+115,inserted_midpoint,924,base,EN_ZH,-0.012859344482421875,0.005213260650634766,True,False
+115,inserted_midpoint,924,extra,ZH_ZH,0.035494327545166016,0.017619609832763672,False,False
+115,historical_slot,928,base,EN_ZH,-0.08320379257202148,-0.07460260391235352,True,True
+115,historical_slot,928,extra,ZH_ZH,0.03695058822631836,0.07634258270263672,False,False
+116,inserted_midpoint,932,base,ZH_ZH,0.22383356094360352,0.20221853256225586,False,False
+116,inserted_midpoint,932,extra,ZH_EN,-0.005941867828369141,0.07412433624267578,True,False
+116,historical_slot,936,base,ZH_ZH,0.22148609161376953,0.24136972427368164,False,False
+116,historical_slot,936,extra,ZH_EN,0.04118990898132324,0.11989092826843262,False,False
+117,inserted_midpoint,940,base,ZH_ZH,-0.06690597534179688,-0.004748821258544922,True,False
+117,inserted_midpoint,940,extra,EN_ZH,0.0251007080078125,0.09103536605834961,False,False
+117,historical_slot,944,base,ZH_ZH,-0.05799245834350586,-0.02384042739868164,True,True
+117,historical_slot,944,extra,EN_ZH,-0.028422832489013672,0.106719970703125,True,False
+118,inserted_midpoint,948,base,ZH_EN,0.16590642929077148,0.10150718688964844,False,False
+118,inserted_midpoint,948,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.1285872459411621,-0.08454418182373047,True,True
+118,historical_slot,952,base,ZH_EN,0.1443624496459961,0.06993484497070312,False,False
+118,historical_slot,952,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.10343170166015625,-0.15221405029296875,True,True
+119,inserted_midpoint,956,base,EN_ZH,0.0032510757446289062,0.0028810501098632812,False,False
+119,inserted_midpoint,956,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.006709098815917969,-0.005038261413574219,True,True
+119,historical_slot,960,base,EN_ZH,-0.041352272033691406,-0.05312299728393555,True,True
+119,historical_slot,960,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.018416404724121094,-0.017556190490722656,True,True
+120,inserted_midpoint,964,base,ZH_ZH,-0.041237831115722656,-0.2036113739013672,True,True
+120,inserted_midpoint,964,extra,ZH_EN,0.025007247924804688,0.003498077392578125,False,False
+120,historical_slot,968,base,ZH_ZH,0.06804370880126953,-0.1124715805053711,False,True
+120,historical_slot,968,extra,ZH_EN,-0.0012040138244628906,0.008893966674804688,False,False
+121,inserted_midpoint,972,base,ZH_ZH,0.004014015197753906,-0.019121646881103516,False,True
+121,inserted_midpoint,972,extra,EN_ZH,-0.033679962158203125,0.05943775177001953,True,False
+121,historical_slot,976,base,ZH_ZH,0.0305023193359375,0.0555877685546875,False,False
+121,historical_slot,976,extra,EN_ZH,-0.042928218841552734,0.04581165313720703,True,False
+122,inserted_midpoint,980,base,ZH_EN,0.042397379875183105,-0.05307126045227051,False,True
+122,inserted_midpoint,980,extra,ZH_ZH,0.024979591369628906,0.04361248016357422,False,False
+122,historical_slot,984,base,ZH_EN,0.05333435535430908,-0.015773773193359375,False,True
+122,historical_slot,984,extra,ZH_ZH,0.026469707489013672,0.048549652099609375,False,False
+123,inserted_midpoint,988,base,EN_ZH,0.08140802383422852,0.2644476890563965,False,False
+123,inserted_midpoint,988,extra,ZH_ZH,0.05971336364746094,0.11209392547607422,False,False
+123,historical_slot,992,base,EN_ZH,0.04821968078613281,0.20850753784179688,False,False
+123,historical_slot,992,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07651329040527344,0.0336151123046875,False,False
+124,inserted_midpoint,996,base,ZH_ZH,0.07008790969848633,-0.009784221649169922,False,True
+124,inserted_midpoint,996,extra,ZH_EN,-0.04678821563720703,-0.012890815734863281,True,True
+124,historical_slot,1000,base,ZH_ZH,0.0841684341430664,-0.0569005012512207,False,True
+124,historical_slot,1000,extra,ZH_EN,-0.013086080551147461,0.00560450553894043,True,False
+125,inserted_midpoint,1004,base,ZH_ZH,0.06488704681396484,0.09313201904296875,False,False
+125,inserted_midpoint,1004,extra,EN_ZH,0.018832683563232422,0.10263586044311523,False,False
+125,historical_slot,1008,base,ZH_ZH,0.08697319030761719,0.10492229461669922,False,False
+125,historical_slot,1008,extra,EN_ZH,-0.020505905151367188,0.05970621109008789,True,False
+126,inserted_midpoint,1012,base,ZH_EN,-0.005897998809814453,-0.0024871826171875,True,False
+126,inserted_midpoint,1012,extra,ZH_ZH,0.046733856201171875,-0.029897689819335938,False,True
+126,historical_slot,1016,base,ZH_EN,0.032149553298950195,0.04034900665283203,False,False
+126,historical_slot,1016,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02283191680908203,-0.04578685760498047,False,True
+127,inserted_midpoint,1020,base,EN_ZH,0.0462498664855957,-0.018297195434570312,False,True
+127,inserted_midpoint,1020,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07573747634887695,0.018214702606201172,False,False
+127,historical_slot,1024,base,EN_ZH,0.05691814422607422,-0.02962350845336914,False,True
+127,historical_slot,1024,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.01764202117919922,-0.05267906188964844,True,True
+128,inserted_midpoint,1028,base,ZH_ZH,0.05268383026123047,0.012185096740722656,False,False
+128,inserted_midpoint,1028,extra,ZH_EN,0.058447837829589844,0.05710554122924805,False,False
+128,historical_slot,1032,base,ZH_ZH,0.009068012237548828,-0.022980690002441406,False,True
+128,historical_slot,1032,extra,ZH_EN,0.08889961242675781,0.06866216659545898,False,False
+129,inserted_midpoint,1036,base,ZH_ZH,0.13359928131103516,0.12270069122314453,False,False
+129,inserted_midpoint,1036,extra,EN_ZH,0.2398524284362793,0.1498270034790039,False,False
+129,historical_slot,1040,base,ZH_ZH,0.1271953582763672,0.1153411865234375,False,False
+129,historical_slot,1040,extra,EN_ZH,0.18319344520568848,0.13822531700134277,False,False
+130,inserted_midpoint,1044,base,ZH_EN,0.1661386489868164,0.090728759765625,False,False
+130,inserted_midpoint,1044,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.002544403076171875,0.04636955261230469,False,False
+130,historical_slot,1048,base,ZH_EN,0.14119338989257812,0.04389619827270508,False,False
+130,historical_slot,1048,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0041866302490234375,0.05517101287841797,False,False
+131,inserted_midpoint,1052,base,EN_ZH,-0.09548139572143555,-0.06554269790649414,True,True
+131,inserted_midpoint,1052,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.014519214630126953,0.027899742126464844,True,False
+131,historical_slot,1056,base,EN_ZH,-0.0321502685546875,0.04126262664794922,True,False
+131,historical_slot,1056,extra,ZH_ZH,0.022794246673583984,0.05225849151611328,False,False
+132,inserted_midpoint,1060,base,ZH_ZH,-0.015364646911621094,-0.023393630981445312,True,True
+132,inserted_midpoint,1060,extra,ZH_EN,0.9515302181243896,0.8892133235931396,False,False
+132,historical_slot,1064,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0503230094909668,-0.06783008575439453,True,True
+132,historical_slot,1064,extra,ZH_EN,0.89349365234375,0.8636012077331543,False,False
+133,inserted_midpoint,1068,base,ZH_ZH,0.02097320556640625,0.03545236587524414,False,False
+133,inserted_midpoint,1068,extra,EN_ZH,0.11680030822753906,0.13682174682617188,False,False
+133,historical_slot,1072,base,ZH_ZH,-0.009097099304199219,0.032044410705566406,True,False
+133,historical_slot,1072,extra,EN_ZH,0.07340621948242188,0.0986628532409668,False,False
+134,inserted_midpoint,1076,base,ZH_EN,-0.03618788719177246,0.04525470733642578,True,False
+134,inserted_midpoint,1076,extra,ZH_ZH,0.024863243103027344,0.00305938720703125,False,False
+134,historical_slot,1080,base,ZH_EN,0.011928081512451172,0.06035304069519043,False,False
+134,historical_slot,1080,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02667093276977539,0.017443180084228516,False,False
+135,inserted_midpoint,1084,base,EN_ZH,-0.0879831314086914,-0.014229297637939453,True,True
+135,inserted_midpoint,1084,extra,ZH_ZH,0.030289173126220703,0.0642862319946289,False,False
+135,historical_slot,1088,base,EN_ZH,0.002372264862060547,0.016683101654052734,False,False
+135,historical_slot,1088,extra,ZH_ZH,0.040218353271484375,0.03090953826904297,False,False
+136,inserted_midpoint,1092,base,ZH_ZH,0.12491035461425781,0.13836383819580078,False,False
+136,inserted_midpoint,1092,extra,ZH_EN,-0.026096105575561523,0.03401303291320801,True,False
+136,historical_slot,1096,base,ZH_ZH,0.0460052490234375,0.07954263687133789,False,False
+136,historical_slot,1096,extra,ZH_EN,-0.009297370910644531,0.021921396255493164,True,False
+137,inserted_midpoint,1100,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0023050308227539062,-0.032926082611083984,False,True
+137,inserted_midpoint,1100,extra,EN_ZH,-0.03599739074707031,-0.031432151794433594,True,True
+137,historical_slot,1104,base,ZH_ZH,-0.035050392150878906,-0.015888214111328125,True,True
+137,historical_slot,1104,extra,EN_ZH,-0.06984806060791016,-0.014471054077148438,True,True
+138,inserted_midpoint,1108,base,ZH_EN,-0.05607724189758301,0.07462811470031738,True,False
+138,inserted_midpoint,1108,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.12263631820678711,-0.10821676254272461,True,True
+138,historical_slot,1112,base,ZH_EN,-0.007777690887451172,0.05736279487609863,True,False
+138,historical_slot,1112,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.07920169830322266,-0.12302923202514648,True,True
+139,inserted_midpoint,1116,base,EN_ZH,-0.05656790733337402,0.045734405517578125,True,False
+139,inserted_midpoint,1116,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.0025663375854492188,-0.009172916412353516,False,True
+139,historical_slot,1120,base,EN_ZH,-0.0031342506408691406,0.03007817268371582,False,False
+139,historical_slot,1120,extra,ZH_ZH,0.044175148010253906,0.026889801025390625,False,False
+140,inserted_midpoint,1124,base,ZH_ZH,-0.030674457550048828,-0.027247905731201172,True,True
+140,inserted_midpoint,1124,extra,ZH_EN,0.0033426284790039062,0.05828845500946045,False,False
+140,historical_slot,1128,base,ZH_ZH,-0.00080108642578125,0.00014162063598632812,False,False
+140,historical_slot,1128,extra,ZH_EN,0.029394149780273438,0.006715178489685059,False,False
+141,inserted_midpoint,1132,base,ZH_ZH,0.031818389892578125,0.14060640335083008,False,False
+141,inserted_midpoint,1132,extra,EN_ZH,-0.02359175682067871,0.15767192840576172,True,False
+141,historical_slot,1136,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0019354820251464844,0.0532832145690918,False,False
+141,historical_slot,1136,extra,EN_ZH,-0.018787622451782227,0.11455726623535156,True,False
+142,inserted_midpoint,1140,base,ZH_EN,0.04563331604003906,0.05368614196777344,False,False
+142,inserted_midpoint,1140,extra,ZH_ZH,0.08124446868896484,0.10540342330932617,False,False
+142,historical_slot,1144,base,ZH_EN,0.07972240447998047,0.027838706970214844,False,False
+142,historical_slot,1144,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07282495498657227,0.10146760940551758,False,False
+143,inserted_midpoint,1148,base,EN_ZH,0.075714111328125,0.12046051025390625,False,False
+143,inserted_midpoint,1148,extra,ZH_ZH,0.09270095825195312,0.00013065338134765625,False,False
+143,historical_slot,1152,base,EN_ZH,0.09172391891479492,0.08383369445800781,False,False
+143,historical_slot,1152,extra,ZH_ZH,0.04906892776489258,0.035953521728515625,False,False
+144,inserted_midpoint,1156,base,ZH_ZH,0.019109249114990234,0.05093240737915039,False,False
+144,inserted_midpoint,1156,extra,ZH_EN,0.11208486557006836,0.06761598587036133,False,False
+144,historical_slot,1160,base,ZH_ZH,0.007365226745605469,0.11412382125854492,False,False
+144,historical_slot,1160,extra,ZH_EN,0.13688182830810547,0.11672830581665039,False,False
+145,inserted_midpoint,1164,base,ZH_ZH,0.08160638809204102,0.15133380889892578,False,False
+145,inserted_midpoint,1164,extra,EN_ZH,-0.008542537689208984,0.04713940620422363,True,False
+145,historical_slot,1168,base,ZH_ZH,0.06849145889282227,0.17647743225097656,False,False
+145,historical_slot,1168,extra,EN_ZH,0.014641404151916504,0.09779977798461914,False,False
+146,inserted_midpoint,1172,base,ZH_EN,0.11132216453552246,0.04206228256225586,False,False
+146,inserted_midpoint,1172,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.004818916320800781,0.0019183158874511719,False,False
+146,historical_slot,1176,base,ZH_EN,0.10066413879394531,0.04411792755126953,False,False
+146,historical_slot,1176,extra,ZH_ZH,0.01172494888305664,0.035284996032714844,False,False
+147,inserted_midpoint,1180,base,EN_ZH,0.14939284324645996,0.09494233131408691,False,False
+147,inserted_midpoint,1180,extra,ZH_ZH,0.20920324325561523,0.06002187728881836,False,False
+147,historical_slot,1184,base,EN_ZH,0.1299598217010498,0.13707923889160156,False,False
+147,historical_slot,1184,extra,ZH_ZH,0.16358566284179688,0.07783651351928711,False,False
+148,inserted_midpoint,1188,base,ZH_ZH,0.010117530822753906,-0.0028886795043945312,False,False
+148,inserted_midpoint,1188,extra,ZH_EN,0.11274099349975586,0.13342952728271484,False,False
+148,historical_slot,1192,base,ZH_ZH,0.028940200805664062,-0.038431644439697266,False,True
+148,historical_slot,1192,extra,ZH_EN,0.1751563549041748,0.1777803897857666,False,False
+149,inserted_midpoint,1196,base,ZH_ZH,0.06117510795593262,0.12012243270874023,False,False
+149,inserted_midpoint,1196,extra,EN_ZH,0.12330794334411621,0.17251229286193848,False,False
+149,historical_slot,1200,base,ZH_ZH,0.0945427417755127,0.1267251968383789,False,False
+149,historical_slot,1200,extra,EN_ZH,0.12071084976196289,0.1754441261291504,False,False
+150,inserted_midpoint,1204,base,ZH_EN,-0.03506779670715332,-0.04359793663024902,True,True
+150,inserted_midpoint,1204,extra,ZH_ZH,0.008102893829345703,0.09123945236206055,False,False
+150,historical_slot,1208,base,ZH_EN,-0.002675294876098633,0.01596057415008545,False,False
+150,historical_slot,1208,extra,ZH_ZH,0.032990455627441406,0.11350536346435547,False,False
+151,inserted_midpoint,1212,base,EN_ZH,-0.18611907958984375,-0.14978694915771484,True,True
+151,inserted_midpoint,1212,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.050369858741760254,-0.060738325119018555,True,True
+151,historical_slot,1216,base,EN_ZH,-0.1515188217163086,-0.06032085418701172,True,True
+151,historical_slot,1216,extra,ZH_ZH,0.017809629440307617,-0.025141596794128418,False,True
+152,inserted_midpoint,1220,base,ZH_ZH,0.014803647994995117,0.00022530555725097656,False,False
+152,inserted_midpoint,1220,extra,ZH_EN,0.301497220993042,0.23505115509033203,False,False
+152,historical_slot,1224,base,ZH_ZH,0.00849771499633789,0.03238368034362793,False,False
+152,historical_slot,1224,extra,ZH_EN,0.3066868782043457,0.1790471076965332,False,False
+153,inserted_midpoint,1228,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0058498382568359375,0.07598447799682617,True,False
+153,inserted_midpoint,1228,extra,EN_ZH,0.03812456130981445,0.0623016357421875,False,False
+153,historical_slot,1232,base,ZH_ZH,-0.0008945465087890625,0.06638956069946289,False,False
+153,historical_slot,1232,extra,EN_ZH,0.038521766662597656,0.05230379104614258,False,False
+154,inserted_midpoint,1236,base,ZH_EN,-0.01310873031616211,-0.0508882999420166,True,True
+154,inserted_midpoint,1236,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0655515193939209,-0.02186131477355957,False,True
+154,historical_slot,1240,base,ZH_EN,0.0016169548034667969,-0.03723645210266113,False,True
+154,historical_slot,1240,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02160787582397461,-0.02720332145690918,False,True
+155,inserted_midpoint,1244,base,EN_ZH,0.06957435607910156,0.05752277374267578,False,False
+155,inserted_midpoint,1244,extra,ZH_ZH,0.10214149951934814,0.06873798370361328,False,False
+155,historical_slot,1248,base,EN_ZH,0.07011222839355469,0.06733465194702148,False,False
+155,historical_slot,1248,extra,ZH_ZH,0.030811548233032227,0.05708611011505127,False,False
+156,inserted_midpoint,1252,base,ZH_ZH,0.09132719039916992,-0.012302398681640625,False,True
+156,inserted_midpoint,1252,extra,ZH_EN,0.0908060073852539,0.0550994873046875,False,False
+156,historical_slot,1256,base,ZH_ZH,0.09754419326782227,-0.059848785400390625,False,True
+156,historical_slot,1256,extra,ZH_EN,0.08233261108398438,0.03652763366699219,False,False
+157,inserted_midpoint,1260,base,ZH_ZH,0.000606536865234375,0.020270347595214844,False,False
+157,inserted_midpoint,1260,extra,EN_ZH,-0.06587433815002441,0.4504811763763428,True,False
+157,historical_slot,1264,base,ZH_ZH,-0.03258323669433594,0.00498199462890625,True,False
+157,historical_slot,1264,extra,EN_ZH,-0.03844332695007324,0.4619619846343994,True,False
+158,inserted_midpoint,1268,base,ZH_EN,-0.019516468048095703,0.0885016918182373,True,False
+158,inserted_midpoint,1268,extra,ZH_ZH,0.019173145294189453,0.07299470901489258,False,False
+158,historical_slot,1272,base,ZH_EN,-0.00903940200805664,0.10566091537475586,True,False
+158,historical_slot,1272,extra,ZH_ZH,0.07085466384887695,0.10808610916137695,False,False
+159,inserted_midpoint,1276,base,EN_ZH,0.03577232360839844,0.2541208267211914,False,False
+159,inserted_midpoint,1276,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.10662651062011719,-0.11653709411621094,True,True
+159,historical_slot,1280,base,EN_ZH,0.0282745361328125,0.23356151580810547,False,False
+159,historical_slot,1280,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.02261829376220703,-0.015351295471191406,True,True
+160,inserted_midpoint,1284,base,ZH_ZH,0.09418964385986328,0.11081123352050781,False,False
+160,inserted_midpoint,1284,extra,ZH_EN,0.052228450775146484,0.04608631134033203,False,False
+160,historical_slot,1288,base,ZH_ZH,0.10886573791503906,0.13779067993164062,False,False
+160,historical_slot,1288,extra,ZH_EN,0.04416084289550781,0.07072210311889648,False,False
+161,inserted_midpoint,1292,base,ZH_ZH,0.06726360321044922,0.17438125610351562,False,False
+161,inserted_midpoint,1292,extra,EN_ZH,-0.007861137390136719,0.0868983268737793,True,False
+161,historical_slot,1296,base,ZH_ZH,0.048575401306152344,0.1142263412475586,False,False
+161,historical_slot,1296,extra,EN_ZH,-0.013443470001220703,0.12424468994140625,True,False
+162,inserted_midpoint,1300,base,ZH_EN,0.0414583683013916,0.05785322189331055,False,False
+162,inserted_midpoint,1300,extra,ZH_ZH,0.0089263916015625,0.10235309600830078,False,False
+162,historical_slot,1304,base,ZH_EN,-0.018392562866210938,0.009673357009887695,True,False
+162,historical_slot,1304,extra,ZH_ZH,0.02563953399658203,0.040743350982666016,False,False
+163,inserted_midpoint,1308,base,EN_ZH,0.0033254623413085938,0.09195709228515625,False,False
+163,inserted_midpoint,1308,extra,ZH_ZH,0.06785774230957031,0.059461116790771484,False,False
+163,historical_slot,1312,base,EN_ZH,-0.005007266998291016,0.05397510528564453,True,False
+163,historical_slot,1312,extra,ZH_ZH,0.052190303802490234,0.021785259246826172,False,False
+164,inserted_midpoint,1316,base,ZH_ZH,0.013302803039550781,0.11337804794311523,False,False
+164,inserted_midpoint,1316,extra,ZH_EN,-0.05126786231994629,0.047174930572509766,True,False
+164,historical_slot,1320,base,ZH_ZH,0.044414520263671875,0.10321760177612305,False,False
+164,historical_slot,1320,extra,ZH_EN,-0.008361577987670898,0.049341678619384766,True,False
+165,inserted_midpoint,1324,base,ZH_ZH,-3.9577484130859375e-05,-0.06505966186523438,False,True
+165,inserted_midpoint,1324,extra,EN_ZH,0.024435997009277344,-0.032652854919433594,False,True
+165,historical_slot,1328,base,ZH_ZH,-0.056571006774902344,-0.04592561721801758,True,True
+165,historical_slot,1328,extra,EN_ZH,0.07806205749511719,0.010432243347167969,False,False
+166,inserted_midpoint,1332,base,ZH_EN,0.30108213424682617,0.3114047050476074,False,False
+166,inserted_midpoint,1332,extra,ZH_ZH,0.06797575950622559,0.09090852737426758,False,False
+166,historical_slot,1336,base,ZH_EN,0.31531763076782227,0.2716665267944336,False,False
+166,historical_slot,1336,extra,ZH_ZH,0.019473791122436523,0.010349273681640625,False,False
+167,inserted_midpoint,1340,base,EN_ZH,0.045584678649902344,0.01466989517211914,False,False
+167,inserted_midpoint,1340,extra,ZH_ZH,0.05863189697265625,-0.003444671630859375,False,False
+167,historical_slot,1344,base,EN_ZH,0.04207944869995117,0.008092403411865234,False,False
+167,historical_slot,1344,extra,ZH_ZH,0.06542181968688965,-0.001920461654663086,False,False
+168,inserted_midpoint,1348,base,ZH_ZH,0.3466973304748535,0.08709383010864258,False,False
+168,inserted_midpoint,1348,extra,ZH_EN,0.09839367866516113,0.06521320343017578,False,False
+168,historical_slot,1352,base,ZH_ZH,0.07908344268798828,-0.20420598983764648,False,True
+168,historical_slot,1352,extra,ZH_EN,0.0523531436920166,0.03143882751464844,False,False
+169,inserted_midpoint,1356,base,ZH_ZH,0.35117602348327637,0.3236277103424072,False,False
+169,inserted_midpoint,1356,extra,EN_ZH,0.14784479141235352,0.09922504425048828,False,False
+169,historical_slot,1360,base,ZH_ZH,0.3474311828613281,0.3016633987426758,False,False
+169,historical_slot,1360,extra,EN_ZH,0.08744239807128906,0.06162881851196289,False,False
+170,inserted_midpoint,1364,base,ZH_EN,-0.001956939697265625,0.05157470703125,False,False
+170,inserted_midpoint,1364,extra,ZH_ZH,0.12597417831420898,0.016829967498779297,False,False
+170,historical_slot,1368,base,ZH_EN,0.02761363983154297,0.10592269897460938,False,False
+170,historical_slot,1368,extra,ZH_ZH,0.16493797302246094,0.08153200149536133,False,False
+171,inserted_midpoint,1372,base,EN_ZH,-0.07953166961669922,-0.008482217788696289,True,True
+171,inserted_midpoint,1372,extra,ZH_ZH,0.16135597229003906,0.14511966705322266,False,False
+171,historical_slot,1376,base,EN_ZH,-0.06874847412109375,0.006292104721069336,True,False
+171,historical_slot,1376,extra,ZH_ZH,0.05881452560424805,0.14355897903442383,False,False
+172,inserted_midpoint,1380,base,ZH_ZH,0.015233039855957031,-0.06510305404663086,False,True
+172,inserted_midpoint,1380,extra,ZH_EN,0.13458514213562012,0.027871370315551758,False,False
+172,historical_slot,1384,base,ZH_ZH,0.049512386322021484,0.03171730041503906,False,False
+172,historical_slot,1384,extra,ZH_EN,0.11780619621276855,0.001291036605834961,False,False
+173,inserted_midpoint,1388,base,ZH_ZH,0.07806682586669922,-0.03083181381225586,False,True
+173,inserted_midpoint,1388,extra,EN_ZH,-0.012639999389648438,-0.040126800537109375,True,True
+173,historical_slot,1392,base,ZH_ZH,0.10566234588623047,-0.03347063064575195,False,True
+173,historical_slot,1392,extra,EN_ZH,-0.03284168243408203,-0.04684162139892578,True,True
+174,inserted_midpoint,1396,base,ZH_EN,0.15083026885986328,0.27364349365234375,False,False
+174,inserted_midpoint,1396,extra,ZH_ZH,0.2173459529876709,0.1918010711669922,False,False
+174,historical_slot,1400,base,ZH_EN,0.12047266960144043,0.2322542667388916,False,False
+174,historical_slot,1400,extra,ZH_ZH,-0.5610370635986328,-0.4356701374053955,True,True

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_replay_cadence_summary.json

@@ -0,0 +1,930 @@
+{
+  "run_id": "20260916T112742Z",
+  "stage": "scale0-s0-r2-replay-cadence-stability-ruler",
+  "formal_parent": {
+    "run": "20260914T011433Z",
+    "state_sha256": "06225f5b82917cf255fdda2aedebbef6a748ba8de942d31931e64957540097ac",
+    "optimizer_sha256": "a1403d67c852859682727c702fc970e085eb80c871008cbf0da40333a16a83e2",
+    "optimizer_step": 7680
+  },
+  "s0r2_trigger": {
+    "run": "20260916T082134Z",
+    "summary_sha256": "df019fb9014fd72434a1b57a835cc2d65acf66124c9140c08b56974a7c6026ae",
+    "verdict": "S0R2_REPLAY_STRENGTH_STABILITY_RULER_REPLAY_STRENGTH_INSUFFICIENT_HOLD_REVIEW_CADENCE"
+  },
+  "historical_s0r1_control": {
+    "run": "20260915T130704Z",
+    "summary_sha256": "915058fd3e853ca62fe9d35f55d536f10e3ff5d7e90a150a96bffea9cd5215bd",
+    "verdict": "S0R1_LOWER_LR_STABILITY_RULER_LOWER_LR_INSUFFICIENT_HOLD_REVIEW_REPLAY",
+    "lr_scale": 0.6,
+    "causal_coef": 1.0,
+    "replay_interval": 8,
+    "optimization_gain": 0.0008883391331440836,
+    "real_composite": 0.0005679889848538087,
+    "q2_full_relative": -0.0037554308634022166,
+    "gm_replication": {
+      "ZH_ZH": 4,
+      "ZH_EN": 6,
+      "EN_ZH": 3
+    }
+  },
+  "candidate_contract": {
+    "name": "REPLAY_EVERY_4",
+    "lr_scale": 0.6,
+    "lr_start": 3e-06,
+    "lr_end_full_schedule": 6e-07,
+    "lr_last_matched_shard": 2.9852460118681503e-06,
+    "causal_coef": 1.0,
+    "replay_interval": 4,
+    "replay_lm_coef": 0.1,
+    "historical_events": 175,
+    "inserted_events": 175,
+    "expected_replay_events": 350,
+    "expected_replay_rows": 700,
+    "historical_slot_identity_preserved": true,
+    "replay_rng_preserved": true,
+    "updates": 1400,
+    "tokens": 5017600,
+    "shard_sha256": "52805d5cdae439952920455d0a629e7eb624b044b04cdc3d61e00ba53f118740",
+    "sealed_sha256": "6316d9b4fe1b2d74b0ea01b29ec11c2e3bd40eb24e59b359a424969b7286431d",
+    "replay_manifest_sha256": "5e1b0b8dd8103fd64e3020e411377cab9e6d56e7db91812ebea5f919e8f6677b",
+    "value_retention_fraction": 0.5,
+    "optimization_retention_floor": 0.000795142567620007,
+    "real_retention_floor": 0.0006469303759952867
+  },
+  "preflight": {
+    "eligible": true,
+    "candidate": "REPLAY_EVERY_4",
+    "lr": 3e-06,
+    "selected_param_count": 88,
+    "selected_param_numel": 93246726,
+    "resume_loadback_maxdiff": 0.0,
+    "optimizer_state_gib": 0.6947425752878189,
+    "backward_peak_allocated_gb": 12.982968807220459,
+    "step_peak_allocated_gb": 6.096457481384277,
+    "strict_gradient_ok": true,
+    "gradient_audit": {
+      "L18_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.02560182362794876,
+        "max_norm": 0.0643659383058548,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L19_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.06044376617355738,
+        "max_norm": 0.16021151840686798,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L20_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.01130700297653675,
+        "max_norm": 0.04271823540329933,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L21_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.02265562117099762,
+        "max_norm": 0.059410400688648224,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L22_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.031953345984220505,
+        "max_norm": 0.10471230745315552,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L23_selector": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.001967541938557003,
+        "max_norm": 0.010160611011087894,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 14,
+        "tensor_count": 14
+      },
+      "L23_qk": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.5115180164575577,
+        "max_norm": 0.5340271592140198,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 2
+      },
+      "L23_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.20543591864407063,
+        "max_norm": 0.5118541121482849,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L24_selector": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.007638420874302808,
+        "max_norm": 0.03915992006659508,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 14,
+        "tensor_count": 14
+      },
+      "L24_qk": {
+        "mean_norm": 1.5388174653053284,
+        "max_norm": 1.5915096998214722,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 2
+      },
+      "L24_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.2599314067512751,
+        "max_norm": 0.5031452178955078,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L25_selector": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.0016790603579335897,
+        "max_norm": 0.007720598019659519,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 14,
+        "tensor_count": 14
+      },
+      "L25_qk": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.24017267301678658,
+        "max_norm": 0.3758721649646759,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 2
+      },
+      "L25_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.19846093617379665,
+        "max_norm": 0.48845240473747253,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      }
+    },
+    "mean_loss": 5.051098108291626
+  },
+  "train_result": {
+    "candidate": "REPLAY_EVERY_4",
+    "lr_scale": 0.6,
+    "lr_start": 3e-06,
+    "lr_last": 2.9852460118681503e-06,
+    "causal_coef": 1.0,
+    "replay_interval": 4,
+    "replay_lm_coef": 0.1,
+    "replay_events": 350,
+    "replay_rows_expected": 700,
+    "historical_events": 175,
+    "inserted_events": 175,
+    "rng_preserved_all_replays": true,
+    "updates": 1400,
+    "tokens": 5017600,
+    "finite_ok": true,
+    "strict_gradient_ok": true,
+    "gradient_audit": {
+      "L18_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.02573945075273514,
+        "max_norm": 0.07558400183916092,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L19_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.07526204676833004,
+        "max_norm": 0.242619127035141,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L20_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.024932805635035037,
+        "max_norm": 0.10978516191244125,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L21_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.019911716505885125,
+        "max_norm": 0.06996660679578781,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L22_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.04790968894958496,
+        "max_norm": 0.12541919946670532,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L23_selector": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.0022486396799012353,
+        "max_norm": 0.008619862608611584,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 14,
+        "tensor_count": 14
+      },
+      "L23_qk": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.6307445168495178,
+        "max_norm": 0.6497959494590759,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 2
+      },
+      "L23_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.23711363561451435,
+        "max_norm": 0.5996618270874023,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L24_selector": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.004057626356370747,
+        "max_norm": 0.017869630828499794,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 14,
+        "tensor_count": 14
+      },
+      "L24_qk": {
+        "mean_norm": 1.944928765296936,
+        "max_norm": 1.9902688264846802,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 2
+      },
+      "L24_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.30675957165658474,
+        "max_norm": 0.5522920489311218,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      },
+      "L25_selector": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.0016213428253714873,
+        "max_norm": 0.006869146134704351,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 14,
+        "tensor_count": 14
+      },
+      "L25_qk": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.3929658308625221,
+        "max_norm": 0.64432692527771,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 2,
+        "tensor_count": 2
+      },
+      "L25_propagation": {
+        "mean_norm": 0.17615677854046224,
+        "max_norm": 0.4467543661594391,
+        "nonzero_tensors": 5,
+        "tensor_count": 5
+      }
+    },
+    "protected_diff": {
+      "reader_q": 0.0,
+      "reader_k": 0.0,
+      "source_writer": 0.0,
+      "embedding_sample": 0.0,
+      "v_proj": {
+        "18": 0.0,
+        "19": 0.0,
+        "20": 0.0,
+        "21": 0.0,
+        "22": 0.0,
+        "23": 0.0,
+        "24": 0.0,
+        "25": 0.0
+      }
+    },
+    "protected_ok": true,
+    "dtn_param_maxdiff": 0.0,
+    "dtn_params_exact": true,
+    "dtn_profile": {
+      "domain_nll": {
+        "EN": {
+          "0": 4.594286680221558,
+          "1": 4.674565672874451,
+          "2": 4.130592465400696,
+          "3": 4.0885783433914185
+        },
+        "ZH": {
+          "0": 6.66491973400116,
+          "1": 6.618886470794678,
+          "2": 6.2554261684417725,
+          "3": 6.232618570327759
+        },
+        "CODE": {
+          "0": 2.357787162065506,
+          "1": 2.360119551420212,
+          "2": 1.8324012458324432,
+          "3": 1.765764445066452
+        },
+        "REASON": {
+          "0": 4.154005944728851,
+          "1": 4.363408982753754,
+          "2": 3.724253237247467,
+          "3": 3.679648280143738
+        }
+      },
+      "mean_d2_over_d1": 0.13534006780961974,
+      "mean_d3_over_d2": 0.015540055714050961,
+      "mean_d3_gain_vs_no_dtn": 0.13505520533260537,
+      "router_distribution": [
+        0.19298308458008867,
+        0.0004020071133394052,
+        0.2845512336829981,
+        0.5105785765260505,
+        0.0008776732453774115,
+        0.010607424851145927
+      ],
+      "router_entropy_norm": 0.6004617612292782,
+      "router_max_share": 0.5105785765260505,
+      "output_scale": 0.9994887113571167
+    },
+    "phase_audits": [
+      {
+        "local_update": 350,
+        "trained_tokens": 1254400,
+        "lr": 2.9990800561699405e-06,
+        "opt_weighted": 0.0002502784301822106,
+        "real_composite": 0.0005474318100284388,
+        "min_real_improvement": -0.0003024239622446154
+      },
+      {
+        "local_update": 700,
+        "trained_tokens": 2508800,
+        "lr": 2.996311093304134e-06,
+        "opt_weighted": 0.000112703771276156,
+        "real_composite": 0.0005166753776812156,
+        "min_real_improvement": -0.0012684312284231812
+      },
+      {
+        "local_update": 1050,
+        "trained_tokens": 3763200,
+        "lr": 2.991697373693759e-06,
+        "opt_weighted": 0.00038258027020961454,
+        "real_composite": 0.0011040707005314115,
+        "min_real_improvement": -2.2450706154841565e-05
+      },
+      {
+        "local_update": 1400,
+        "trained_tokens": 5017600,
+        "lr": 2.9852460118681503e-06,
+        "opt_weighted": 0.0006933628862113668,
+        "real_composite": 0.0008810629392947296,
+        "min_real_improvement": -0.001179921305897915
+      }
+    ],
+    "phase_stable": true,
+    "final_opt_post": {
+      "EN": 4.026181081930797,
+      "ZH": 6.202977538108826,
+      "CODE": 1.781147042910258
+    },
+    "final_opt_relative": {
+      "EN": 0.00043827063513586907,
+      "ZH": 0.001587349251660804,
+      "CODE": -0.0005844253425365127
+    },
+    "final_opt_weighted": 0.0006933628862113668,
+    "real": {
+      "general": 5.242080529530843,
+      "en_stream": 4.189017097155253,
+      "zh": 6.33304504553477,
+      "code": 1.8348201910654705,
+      "reasoning": 3.9791655937830606,
+      "long_en": 3.8224875926971436,
+      "long_zh": 6.416696548461914,
+      "code_stream": 1.4823619325955708
+    },
+    "real_relative": {
+      "general": -0.00016056091178935362,
+      "en_stream": 4.62034893489105e-05,
+      "zh": 0.0015991948560503807,
+      "code": -0.002171799415197456,
+      "reasoning": 0.0005141056826556377,
+      "long_en": 0.0008487629340219326,
+      "long_zh": 0.0015282545680064658,
+      "code_stream": -5.546501943328174e-05
+    },
+    "real_composite": 0.00010005143676994445,
+    "min_real_relative": -0.002171799415197456,
+    "resume_loadback_maxdiff": 0.0,
+    "final_optimizer_step": 9080.0,
+    "loss_first_100": 4.436290622651577,
+    "loss_last_100": 4.39575831130147,
+    "grad_norm_max": 6922.3173828125,
+    "grad_norm_last350_max": 6922.3173828125,
+    "replay_rows": 700,
+    "target_hinge_active": 207,
+    "specificity_hinge_active": 182
+  },
+  "adjudication": {
+    "train_basic_ok": true,
+    "q2": {
+      "n": 96,
+      "beta0_nll": 8.780492017666498,
+      "full_nll": 7.471775824824969,
+      "target_ko_nll": 7.680929372708003,
+      "control_ko_nll": 7.431892727812131,
+      "gain_abs": 1.308716192841529,
+      "gain": 0.1490481615618316,
+      "target_penalty": 0.20915354788303375,
+      "specificity_abs": 0.24903664489587207,
+      "target_attribution": 0.15981581723147514,
+      "specificity_normalized": 0.1902907950998568,
+      "by_len": {
+        "1024": {
+          "gain": 0.1666487701334709
+        },
+        "1536": {
+          "gain": 0.12889412213599857
+        },
+        "2048": {
+          "gain": 0.15308557069429726
+        }
+      }
+    },
+    "q2_deconfounded": {
+      "label": "S0R3_REPLAY_EVERY4_Q2_DECONF",
+      "own_gain": 0.1490481615618316,
+      "base_full_nll": 7.5581445917487144,
+      "candidate_full_nll": 7.471775824824969,
+      "full_relative_change": -0.011427244593604976,
+      "candidate_target_penalty": 0.20915354788303375,
+      "candidate_specificity_abs": 0.24903664489587207,
+      "target_delta": 0.01283445954322815,
+      "specificity_delta": 0.015575081110001499,
+      "by_len_gain": {
+        "1024": 0.1666487701334709,
+        "1536": 0.12889412213599857,
+        "2048": 0.15308557069429726
+      },
+      "legacy_target_attribution": 0.15981581723147514,
+      "legacy_specificity_normalized": 0.1902907950998568,
+      "by_len_ok": true,
+      "ok": true
+    },
+    "q2_repaired": true,
+    "deconfounded_memory": {
+      "label": "S0R3_REPLAY_EVERY4_VS_F0A_DECONF",
+      "detail": {
+        "ZH_ZH": {
+          "mode": "ZH_ZH",
+          "n": 72,
+          "base_full_nll": 5.958117422130373,
+          "candidate_full_nll": 5.8428888652059765,
+          "full_relative_change": -0.019339759316659388,
+          "candidate_own_gain": 0.047145638515272405,
+          "candidate_target": 0.10635573003027174,
+          "candidate_specificity": 0.1169226500723097,
+          "target_delta_mean": 0.016493837038675945,
+          "specificity_delta_mean": 0.03759182824028863,
+          "panel_cluster_target_ci95": [
+            -0.01211811105410258,
+            0.04590073559019301
+          ],
+          "panel_cluster_specificity_ci95": [
+            0.017088658279842798,
+            0.05797836515638564
+          ],
+          "point_replication_count": 6,
+          "replication_ok": true,
+          "families": {
+            "A": {
+              "base_full_nll": 5.5181544290648565,
+              "candidate_full_nll": 5.45649649699529,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.01117365105710093,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.0370877877428661,
+              "candidate_target": 0.10412942038642035,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.12205211983786689,
+              "target_delta": 0.013037217987908259,
+              "specificity_delta": 0.04179135296079847,
+              "gate": true
+            },
+            "B": {
+              "base_full_nll": 6.3980804151958885,
+              "candidate_full_nll": 6.229281233416663,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.026382785277020825,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.0557846783925058,
+              "candidate_target": 0.10858203967412312,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.11179318030675252,
+              "target_delta": 0.019950456089443624,
+              "specificity_delta": 0.033392303519778774,
+              "gate": true
+            }
+          },
+          "panel_detail": [
+            {
+              "panel_id": 0,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.03760392900756092,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.027136533859812316,
+              "candidate_target": 0.027512530485788982,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.05112497011820475,
+              "target_delta_mean": -0.018806238969167072,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.020370841026306152,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 1,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.05980052083708967,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.020376366428840158,
+              "candidate_target": 0.21714136997858682,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.22226615746816,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.06947006781895955,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.06124836206436157,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 2,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.019372399943305824,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.002728336592208726,
+              "candidate_target": 0.07730480035146077,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.07272756099700928,
+              "target_delta_mean": -0.004494627316792806,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.0030104716618855796,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 3,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.015065574173788086,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.0039716128256260435,
+              "candidate_target": 0.0513839324315389,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.06881276766459148,
+              "target_delta_mean": -0.0123519500096639,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.015312174956003824,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 4,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.11071478966430479,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.02828539255760117,
+              "candidate_target": 0.1996102531750997,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.15451188882191977,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.07272676626841228,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.05275885264078776,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 5,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.04373136454910657,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.03450820552938769,
+              "candidate_target": 0.06518149375915527,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.132092555363973,
+              "target_delta_mean": -0.007580995559692383,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.07285026709238689,
+              "point_gate": true
+            }
+          ],
+          "primary_gate": true
+        },
+        "ZH_EN": {
+          "mode": "ZH_EN",
+          "n": 72,
+          "base_full_nll": 4.801753666665819,
+          "candidate_full_nll": 4.6920031905174255,
+          "full_relative_change": -0.022856332033500744,
+          "candidate_own_gain": 0.2224139015318467,
+          "candidate_target": 0.35800696743859184,
+          "candidate_specificity": 0.24475809931755066,
+          "target_delta_mean": 0.024809516138500638,
+          "specificity_delta_mean": 0.020195739136801824,
+          "panel_cluster_target_ci95": [
+            0.007744805680380926,
+            0.041162338521745466
+          ],
+          "panel_cluster_specificity_ci95": [
+            0.006087117724948459,
+            0.03464575277434455
+          ],
+          "point_replication_count": 4,
+          "replication_ok": true,
+          "families": {
+            "A": {
+              "base_full_nll": 4.570537467797597,
+              "candidate_full_nll": 4.527437362405989,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.009429986231439183,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.20804214752374503,
+              "candidate_target": 0.40378151337305707,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.33064503802193534,
+              "target_delta": 0.009749929110209166,
+              "specificity_delta": 0.01833254761166042,
+              "gate": true
+            },
+            "B": {
+              "base_full_nll": 5.0329698655340405,
+              "candidate_full_nll": 4.856569018628862,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.03504905684279524,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.23534970625538384,
+              "candidate_target": 0.31223242150412667,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.15887116061316597,
+              "target_delta": 0.03986910316679215,
+              "specificity_delta": 0.022058930661943227,
+              "gate": true
+            }
+          },
+          "panel_detail": [
+            {
+              "panel_id": 0,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.23281168725207035,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.006824568092299371,
+              "candidate_target": 0.2556074261665344,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.1721669634183248,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.055790881315867104,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.04871914784113566,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 1,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.14697352134270025,
+              "full_relative_change": 0.0012443195074158043,
+              "candidate_target": 0.14978577693303427,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.05769715706507365,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.02470153570175171,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.038668413956960045,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 2,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.21038320884213654,
+              "full_relative_change": 0.042293334229477716,
+              "candidate_target": 0.4666631023089091,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.3876946767171224,
+              "target_delta_mean": -0.010947922865549723,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": -0.0031062960624694824,
+              "point_gate": false
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 3,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.25110503997023037,
+              "full_relative_change": 0.004074252066913343,
+              "candidate_target": 0.3490339716275533,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.16629135608673096,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.028718888759613037,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.01610422134399414,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 4,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.2777405571358578,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.08626958291325539,
+              "candidate_target": 0.5313607454299927,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.4305570125579834,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.04098592201868693,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.015525519847869873,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 5,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.2144525379786315,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.0889733588784143,
+              "candidate_target": 0.39559078216552734,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.2541414300600688,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.009607791900634766,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.00526342789332072,
+              "point_gate": false
+            }
+          ],
+          "primary_gate": true
+        },
+        "EN_ZH": {
+          "mode": "EN_ZH",
+          "n": 96,
+          "base_full_nll": 6.11661746352911,
+          "candidate_full_nll": 5.821334786713123,
+          "full_relative_change": -0.04827548536043599,
+          "candidate_own_gain": 0.02791312355328288,
+          "candidate_target": 0.08323998252550761,
+          "candidate_specificity": 0.09670878946781158,
+          "target_delta_mean": 0.01616254945596059,
+          "specificity_delta_mean": 0.03449813028176626,
+          "panel_cluster_target_ci95": [
+            0.0073306312163670855,
+            0.024858345588048298
+          ],
+          "panel_cluster_specificity_ci95": [
+            0.030162997543811798,
+            0.03994495918353399
+          ],
+          "point_replication_count": 5,
+          "replication_ok": true,
+          "families": {
+            "A": {
+              "base_full_nll": 6.1719676206509275,
+              "candidate_full_nll": 5.840382372339566,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.053724398553534634,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.015406274234406925,
+              "candidate_target": 0.07532447079817454,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.0893729825814565,
+              "target_delta": 0.006788894534111023,
+              "specificity_delta": 0.026091997822125748,
+              "gate": true
+            },
+            "B": {
+              "base_full_nll": 6.061267306407292,
+              "candidate_full_nll": 5.80228720108668,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.04272705561869005,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.040185264276944466,
+              "candidate_target": 0.09115549425284068,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.10404459635416667,
+              "target_delta": 0.025536204377810165,
+              "specificity_delta": 0.04290426274140676,
+              "gate": true
+            }
+          },
+          "panel_detail": [
+            {
+              "panel_id": 0,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.03101960460928021,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.04443108273336776,
+              "candidate_target": 0.11130684614181519,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.12606030702590942,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.01913750171661377,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.03142809867858887,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 1,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.024491836082665322,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.08950069539871018,
+              "candidate_target": 0.0962858647108078,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.10632099211215973,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.03045816719532013,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.033096686005592346,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 2,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.021382560796941508,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.016527895934791835,
+              "candidate_target": 0.11511686444282532,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.14704526960849762,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.024899184703826904,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.033275023102760315,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 3,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.0006671635821269183,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.04999601771028401,
+              "candidate_target": 0.05301055312156677,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.08336591720581055,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.0019784867763519287,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.04667434096336365,
+              "point_gate": false
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 4,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.04639372611560516,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.02369348068442355,
+              "candidate_target": 0.10381335020065308,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.11097423732280731,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.0010013878345489502,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.035634517669677734,
+              "point_gate": true
+            },
+            {
+              "panel_id": 5,
+              "candidate_own_gain": 0.04180164729651194,
+              "full_relative_change": -0.06039681478387913,
+              "candidate_target": 0.019906416535377502,
+              "candidate_specificity": 0.0064860135316848755,
+              "target_delta_mean": 0.019500568509101868,
+              "specificity_delta_mean": 0.026880115270614624,
+              "point_gate": true
+            }
+          ],
+          "primary_gate": true
+        }
+      },
+      "primary_all": true,
+      "replication_all": true,
+      "ok": true
+    },
+    "gm_repaired": true,
+    "gm_replication": {
+      "ZH_ZH": 6,
+      "ZH_EN": 4,
+      "EN_ZH": 5
+    },
+    "dtn_profile": {
+      "domain_nll": {
+        "EN": {
+          "0": 4.594286680221558,
+          "1": 4.674565672874451,
+          "2": 4.130592465400696,
+          "3": 4.0885783433914185
+        },
+        "ZH": {
+          "0": 6.66491973400116,
+          "1": 6.618886470794678,
+          "2": 6.2554261684417725,
+          "3": 6.232618570327759
+        },
+        "CODE": {
+          "0": 2.357787162065506,
+          "1": 2.360119551420212,
+          "2": 1.8324012458324432,
+          "3": 1.765764445066452
+        },
+        "REASON": {
+          "0": 4.154005944728851,
+          "1": 4.363408982753754,
+          "2": 3.724253237247467,
+          "3": 3.679648280143738
+        }
+      },
+      "mean_d2_over_d1": 0.13534006780961974,
+      "mean_d3_over_d2": 0.015540055714050961,
+      "mean_d3_gain_vs_no_dtn": 0.13505520533260537,
+      "router_distribution": [
+        0.19298308458008867,
+        0.0004020071133394052,
+        0.2845512336829981,
+        0.5105785765260505,
+        0.0008776732453774115,
+        0.010607424851145927
+      ],
+      "router_entropy_norm": 0.6004617612292782,
+      "router_max_share": 0.5105785765260505,
+      "output_scale": 0.9994887113571167
+    },
+    "dtn_structure_ok": true,
+    "strict_causality_ok": true,
+    "causality": [
+      {
+        "kind": "OLD",
+        "seq_len": 512,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "OLD",
+        "seq_len": 1024,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "OLD",
+        "seq_len": 1536,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "OLD",
+        "seq_len": 2048,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "CHINESE",
+        "seq_len": 512,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "CHINESE",
+        "seq_len": 1024,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "CHINESE",
+        "seq_len": 1536,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "CHINESE",
+        "seq_len": 2048,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "MIXED",
+        "seq_len": 512,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "MIXED",
+        "seq_len": 1024,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "MIXED",
+        "seq_len": 1536,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      },
+      {
+        "kind": "MIXED",
+        "seq_len": 2048,
+        "max_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0,
+        "mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff": 0.0
+      }
+    ],
+    "structural_ok": true,
+    "value_retention_ok": false,
+    "change_vs_s0r1": {
+      "control_replay_interval": 8,
+      "candidate_replay_interval": 4,
+      "control_q2_full_relative": -0.0037554308634022166,
+      "candidate_q2_full_relative": -0.011427244593604976,
+      "control_replication": {
+        "ZH_ZH": 4,
+        "ZH_EN": 6,
+        "EN_ZH": 3
+      },
+      "candidate_replication": {
+        "ZH_ZH": 6,
+        "ZH_EN": 4,
+        "EN_ZH": 5
+      },
+      "control_opt_gain": 0.0008883391331440836,
+      "candidate_opt_gain": 0.0006933628862113668,
+      "control_real_composite": 0.0005679889848538087,
+      "candidate_real_composite": 0.00010005143676994445
+    }
+  },
+  "loadback_ok": true,
+  "loadback_maxdiff": 0.0,
+  "qualified_checkpoint": false,
+  "restart_from_f0a_if_pass": true,
+  "VERDICT": "S0R3_REPLAY_CADENCE_STABILITY_RULER_STRUCTURAL_REPAIR_BUT_VALUE_INSUFFICIENT_HOLD"
+}

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_replay_strength_causality.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
+kind,seq_len,max_abs_prefix_logit_diff,mean_abs_prefix_logit_diff
+OLD,512,0.0,0.0
+OLD,1024,0.0,0.0
+OLD,1536,0.0,0.0
+OLD,2048,0.0,0.0
+CHINESE,512,0.0,0.0
+CHINESE,1024,0.0,0.0
+CHINESE,1536,0.0,0.0
+CHINESE,2048,0.0,0.0
+MIXED,512,0.0,0.0
+MIXED,1024,0.0,0.0
+MIXED,1536,0.0,0.0
+MIXED,2048,0.0,0.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_replay_strength_en_zh.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,97 @@
+panel_id,family,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_drop_penalty,control_median_penalty,target_minus_control_median,target_positive,target_beats_control_median
+0,A,6.999407768249512,6.372079849243164,0.12958526611328125,0.03772258758544922,0.09186267852783203,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.095797538757324,4.950479507446289,0.2561960220336914,-0.020885467529296875,0.2770814895629883,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.214296340942383,5.583897590637207,-0.06084156036376953,-0.10808706283569336,0.04724550247192383,0.0,1.0
+0,A,7.054404258728027,6.600185394287109,0.1444835662841797,0.026842117309570312,0.11764144897460938,1.0,1.0
+0,A,4.767258644104004,4.926836013793945,-0.047301292419433594,-0.11156272888183594,0.06426143646240234,0.0,1.0
+0,A,4.598929405212402,4.310999870300293,0.09111642837524414,-0.03594970703125,0.12706613540649414,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.77540922164917,5.32098388671875,0.035054683685302734,0.00018310546875,0.034871578216552734,1.0,1.0
+0,A,6.343132972717285,5.77617883682251,0.11963844299316406,0.12683963775634766,-0.007201194763183594,1.0,0.0
+0,B,5.5162858963012695,4.751226425170898,0.3358421325683594,0.05525350570678711,0.28058862686157227,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.03165340423584,6.160456657409668,-0.00653839111328125,-0.015263557434082031,0.008725166320800781,0.0,1.0
+0,B,5.3064422607421875,5.580122470855713,0.16317129135131836,-0.12061262130737305,0.2837839126586914,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.401269912719727,5.03529167175293,0.11546802520751953,0.05288410186767578,0.06258392333984375,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.367285251617432,4.9682769775390625,0.2649869918823242,0.029819488525390625,0.2351675033569336,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.714129447937012,6.630295276641846,0.12193059921264648,-0.13574552536010742,0.2576761245727539,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.792006492614746,6.297430038452148,0.05923652648925781,0.04289054870605469,0.016345977783203125,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.696663856506348,5.565929412841797,0.05888080596923828,-0.06038379669189453,0.11926460266113281,1.0,1.0
+1,A,6.575647354125977,6.328668117523193,-0.07958316802978516,-0.04791831970214844,-0.03166484832763672,0.0,0.0
+1,A,5.054854393005371,5.132045745849609,0.17790889739990234,-0.054882049560546875,0.23279094696044922,1.0,1.0
+1,A,4.355924129486084,4.724575042724609,-0.044280052185058594,-0.033583641052246094,-0.0106964111328125,0.0,0.0
+1,A,6.991786003112793,6.705212593078613,-0.02549123764038086,0.036131858825683594,-0.06162309646606445,0.0,0.0
+1,A,5.02006721496582,4.877048492431641,0.05562782287597656,-0.08802652359008789,0.14365434646606445,1.0,1.0
+1,A,6.874322414398193,6.421111583709717,0.09988641738891602,0.1436314582824707,-0.04374504089355469,1.0,0.0
+1,A,5.347412109375,4.951358795166016,0.06549692153930664,-0.029148578643798828,0.09464550018310547,1.0,1.0
+1,A,7.146754741668701,7.043807029724121,0.1306896209716797,0.025908470153808594,0.1047811508178711,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.461033821105957,6.222365856170654,-0.04673337936401367,-0.20322942733764648,0.1564960479736328,0.0,1.0
+1,B,7.310315132141113,6.843632698059082,0.05073356628417969,0.06046485900878906,-0.009731292724609375,1.0,0.0
+1,B,7.030411243438721,6.418174743652344,0.12827014923095703,0.1077423095703125,0.02052783966064453,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.593005180358887,5.652419090270996,0.1445322036743164,-0.059131622314453125,0.20366382598876953,1.0,1.0
+1,B,4.528285980224609,3.688922882080078,0.2767913341522217,0.054956912994384766,0.22183442115783691,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.507467746734619,5.761146545410156,-0.00762176513671875,-0.07312774658203125,0.0655059814453125,0.0,1.0
+1,B,8.57759952545166,8.41589641571045,0.2220163345336914,0.005161285400390625,0.21685504913330078,1.0,1.0
+1,B,7.873283386230469,7.631014823913574,0.3923301696777344,-0.005511283874511719,0.3978414535522461,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.04300594329834,5.101822853088379,0.04200935363769531,-0.02246713638305664,0.06447649002075195,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.823066711425781,4.791866779327393,0.042372703552246094,-0.006762027740478516,0.04913473129272461,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.160092830657959,7.0251922607421875,0.07044219970703125,0.058766841888427734,0.011675357818603516,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.979709625244141,5.233259201049805,0.05644798278808594,-0.10290288925170898,0.15935087203979492,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.301588535308838,7.868050575256348,0.04805803298950195,0.08036279678344727,-0.03230476379394531,1.0,0.0
+2,A,7.160966873168945,7.797168731689453,0.11775493621826172,-0.18344879150390625,0.30120372772216797,1.0,1.0
+2,A,6.195219993591309,5.566156387329102,0.39763450622558594,-0.0181884765625,0.41582298278808594,1.0,1.0
+2,A,6.331231117248535,6.682194709777832,0.1697540283203125,0.029516220092773438,0.14023780822753906,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.861721038818359,5.65239143371582,0.024781227111816406,-0.1017913818359375,0.1265726089477539,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.886247634887695,4.742980003356934,0.27593994140625,-0.049607276916503906,0.3255472183227539,1.0,1.0
+2,B,8.169722557067871,6.677494049072266,0.48684263229370117,0.060065269470214844,0.42677736282348633,1.0,1.0
+2,B,3.8829784393310547,3.917970895767212,0.02702808380126953,-0.04305005073547363,0.07007813453674316,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.262005805969238,6.137073993682861,0.033480167388916016,-0.03846168518066406,0.07194185256958008,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.746891975402832,5.320585250854492,-0.0010018348693847656,-0.016208171844482422,0.015206336975097656,0.0,1.0
+2,B,6.004411697387695,5.508570671081543,0.0940408706665039,-0.023649215698242188,0.1176900863647461,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.462911128997803,7.169074535369873,-0.04371500015258789,-0.13302850723266602,0.08931350708007812,0.0,1.0
+3,A,3.715162992477417,4.502547740936279,0.0348663330078125,-0.18416738510131836,0.21903371810913086,1.0,1.0
+3,A,7.424768447875977,6.642857074737549,0.01764392852783203,0.03542804718017578,-0.01778411865234375,1.0,0.0
+3,A,4.14670467376709,4.6173200607299805,0.004024505615234375,-0.05796241760253906,0.06198692321777344,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.336841583251953,5.57924747467041,0.12234830856323242,0.005726814270019531,0.11662149429321289,1.0,1.0
+3,A,7.921686172485352,7.247333526611328,0.07933521270751953,0.06497478485107422,0.014360427856445312,1.0,1.0
+3,A,4.455789089202881,4.53971529006958,-0.011451244354248047,-0.06270790100097656,0.051256656646728516,0.0,1.0
+3,A,4.843049049377441,5.144920349121094,-0.012639045715332031,0.0050868988037109375,-0.01772594451904297,0.0,0.0
+3,A,7.412618637084961,7.666245937347412,0.13378572463989258,-0.046079158782958984,0.17986488342285156,1.0,1.0
+3,B,4.922248363494873,4.961800575256348,-0.016621112823486328,-0.04515409469604492,0.028532981872558594,0.0,1.0
+3,B,7.311283111572266,7.146961212158203,0.15214157104492188,0.011815071105957031,0.14032649993896484,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.070547103881836,5.172277450561523,-0.017226696014404297,-0.05426311492919922,0.03703641891479492,0.0,1.0
+3,B,3.961686134338379,4.322797775268555,0.052857398986816406,-0.10474061965942383,0.15759801864624023,1.0,1.0
+3,B,7.424347400665283,6.8871002197265625,0.2605900764465332,-0.023263931274414062,0.28385400772094727,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.240886688232422,5.878047943115234,0.14246749877929688,0.034392356872558594,0.10807514190673828,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.3883185386657715,5.118392467498779,-0.013722896575927734,-0.004726409912109375,-0.00899648666381836,0.0,0.0
+3,B,5.3107404708862305,5.398477077484131,-0.080230712890625,-0.06004476547241211,-0.02018594741821289,0.0,0.0
+4,A,6.827904224395752,7.120957851409912,0.07677316665649414,-0.02616262435913086,0.102935791015625,1.0,1.0
+4,A,7.9705352783203125,7.428816795349121,0.04093456268310547,-0.013353347778320312,0.05428791046142578,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.374605178833008,4.426618576049805,0.15339183807373047,-0.02231121063232422,0.1757030487060547,1.0,1.0
+4,A,9.885924339294434,9.842317581176758,0.09409332275390625,-0.028318405151367188,0.12241172790527344,1.0,1.0
+4,A,7.064513683319092,7.003327369689941,-0.06877517700195312,-0.04736614227294922,-0.021409034729003906,0.0,0.0
+4,A,3.7037720680236816,3.9359521865844727,0.01386260986328125,0.02921605110168457,-0.01535344123840332,1.0,0.0
+4,A,5.57838249206543,5.512275695800781,0.12425374984741211,0.013347625732421875,0.11090612411499023,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.416208267211914,5.273638725280762,0.17885112762451172,-0.032486915588378906,0.21133804321289062,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.166676044464111,4.351794242858887,0.2163228988647461,0.03487682342529297,0.18144607543945312,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.4893951416015625,6.399493217468262,-0.05196571350097656,-0.0222625732421875,-0.029703140258789062,0.0,0.0
+4,B,5.975957870483398,5.718446731567383,0.00559234619140625,-0.013119220733642578,0.018711566925048828,1.0,1.0
+4,B,4.679648399353027,4.736456871032715,0.004596710205078125,-0.03307819366455078,0.037674903869628906,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.572725296020508,5.322726726531982,0.12707948684692383,-0.022582054138183594,0.14966154098510742,1.0,1.0
+4,B,4.664209842681885,2.5502588748931885,0.5756754875183105,0.038448333740234375,0.5372271537780762,1.0,1.0
+4,B,7.92910099029541,7.768557548522949,0.07212066650390625,0.05239295959472656,0.019727706909179688,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.984249114990234,5.378810882568359,0.0982065200805664,-0.02181529998779297,0.12002182006835938,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.298760414123535,5.316017150878906,0.1820058822631836,-0.005770683288574219,0.1877765655517578,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.321577072143555,4.976262092590332,0.037250518798828125,0.04797983169555664,-0.010729312896728516,1.0,0.0
+5,A,7.045862197875977,7.217584609985352,-0.20391178131103516,-0.05458784103393555,-0.1493239402770996,0.0,0.0
+5,A,7.005779266357422,6.73594856262207,-0.05546998977661133,0.01945209503173828,-0.07492208480834961,0.0,0.0
+5,A,6.920148849487305,6.752386093139648,-0.04916095733642578,-0.025178909301757812,-0.02398204803466797,0.0,0.0
+5,A,5.237917900085449,4.728784561157227,0.17201995849609375,0.04311990737915039,0.12890005111694336,1.0,1.0
+5,A,4.579596519470215,4.077880859375,0.12964344024658203,0.03347587585449219,0.09616756439208984,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.0265092849731445,3.9582178592681885,0.42923808097839355,-0.06777524948120117,0.4970133304595947,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.299263954162598,6.461565971374512,-8.535385131835938e-05,-0.0060672760009765625,0.005981922149658203,0.0,1.0
+5,B,7.338563919067383,7.1365461349487305,0.007625102996826172,-0.020226478576660156,0.027851581573486328,1.0,1.0
+5,B,4.705776214599609,4.511740684509277,0.038308143615722656,0.00797891616821289,0.030329227447509766,1.0,1.0
+5,B,7.684524059295654,7.730960845947266,-0.014790534973144531,0.009785652160644531,-0.024576187133789062,0.0,0.0
+5,B,6.382864952087402,6.686284065246582,0.0379180908203125,-0.05228900909423828,0.09020709991455078,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.6248250007629395,6.714432239532471,0.003996372222900391,0.023247241973876953,-0.019250869750976562,1.0,0.0
+5,B,5.4470086097717285,4.462553977966309,0.039931297302246094,0.11191844940185547,-0.07198715209960938,1.0,0.0
+5,B,7.6114821434021,6.944559097290039,-0.43601560592651367,0.14966392517089844,-0.5856795310974121,0.0,0.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_replay_strength_q2.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,97 @@
+seq_len,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_ko_nll,control_ko_nll
+1024,10.224124908447266,8.3480224609375,8.738935470581055,8.304637908935547
+1024,11.24421501159668,11.060548782348633,11.197674751281738,11.039013862609863
+1024,6.984829902648926,7.081370830535889,7.204989910125732,7.145155906677246
+1024,7.563981056213379,6.889286041259766,7.003019332885742,6.832897186279297
+1024,7.244675159454346,6.411783218383789,6.9552412033081055,6.365011215209961
+1024,9.678119659423828,7.213201522827148,8.465788841247559,7.185874938964844
+1024,8.956314086914062,6.687470436096191,6.922942161560059,6.6936798095703125
+1024,7.585890769958496,5.671835899353027,6.23496150970459,5.67917013168335
+1024,8.23902702331543,6.964674949645996,7.295810222625732,7.067729473114014
+1024,8.548989295959473,6.852489471435547,6.998741149902344,7.1774983406066895
+1024,6.894572734832764,5.658147811889648,5.747898578643799,5.577606201171875
+1024,7.413776397705078,6.059129238128662,6.386183738708496,6.105313301086426
+1024,8.67839527130127,7.699674606323242,8.050548553466797,7.77827262878418
+1024,10.689176559448242,8.533950805664062,8.729757308959961,8.442413330078125
+1024,8.500450134277344,5.363697528839111,5.3366193771362305,5.234931945800781
+1024,7.276036262512207,5.824742794036865,5.903032302856445,6.084676265716553
+1024,8.261077880859375,7.638770580291748,7.679332733154297,7.657617568969727
+1024,7.451401233673096,5.921593189239502,6.136142253875732,5.985100746154785
+1024,6.903059005737305,6.386947154998779,6.425963401794434,6.421788215637207
+1024,7.656686782836914,5.659327030181885,5.873701572418213,5.793302536010742
+1024,8.049172401428223,7.159115791320801,7.252778053283691,7.208501815795898
+1024,9.305801391601562,8.664907455444336,8.738971710205078,8.425704002380371
+1024,8.594223976135254,6.671443939208984,6.984095573425293,6.601398944854736
+1024,7.648861885070801,5.305451393127441,5.274869441986084,5.155620098114014
+1024,6.937459945678711,5.311189651489258,5.242179870605469,5.111093521118164
+1024,9.619599342346191,8.402908325195312,8.405416488647461,8.29704475402832
+1024,8.42111873626709,7.3330864906311035,7.357672691345215,7.220774173736572
+1024,8.197404861450195,6.217840671539307,5.913097381591797,5.963916778564453
+1024,10.491382598876953,9.378894805908203,10.114736557006836,8.960784912109375
+1024,11.918230056762695,9.91617202758789,9.901750564575195,10.235921859741211
+1024,6.797512054443359,5.730230331420898,6.033578872680664,5.707181453704834
+1024,10.740198135375977,9.250112533569336,9.133237838745117,9.242912292480469
+1536,7.929171562194824,6.979092597961426,7.15265417098999,7.055359363555908
+1536,8.293545722961426,7.145394802093506,7.637022018432617,7.197119235992432
+1536,6.362321853637695,3.657459259033203,3.6730551719665527,3.6417245864868164
+1536,10.583967208862305,9.060490608215332,9.835697174072266,9.056722640991211
+1536,5.5563740730285645,4.458480358123779,4.405173301696777,4.543916702270508
+1536,10.614770889282227,9.704458236694336,10.050046920776367,9.671589851379395
+1536,10.488103866577148,8.26545524597168,8.277198791503906,7.7766265869140625
+1536,9.726122856140137,8.84229850769043,9.111324310302734,8.972670555114746
+1536,10.315780639648438,8.720625877380371,8.802406311035156,8.4518404006958
+1536,8.036267280578613,8.768627166748047,8.629993438720703,8.840153694152832
+1536,11.142324447631836,10.230090141296387,10.287887573242188,10.164166450500488
+1536,9.613142013549805,9.045743942260742,9.072229385375977,8.995796203613281
+1536,6.637901306152344,5.842795372009277,5.981157302856445,5.511970520019531
+1536,8.994645118713379,6.828851222991943,7.933239459991455,6.739697456359863
+1536,9.595452308654785,9.61185359954834,9.695009231567383,9.602666854858398
+1536,10.887371063232422,9.959525108337402,9.97541618347168,9.953235626220703
+1536,9.790202140808105,7.785796642303467,7.949024200439453,7.7787909507751465
+1536,8.918510437011719,7.40974235534668,7.7108354568481445,7.528984069824219
+1536,12.222929954528809,10.46865463256836,11.29604721069336,10.510658264160156
+1536,8.487998008728027,6.839118957519531,7.562625408172607,6.827891826629639
+1536,11.010770797729492,10.040168762207031,10.466287612915039,9.684087753295898
+1536,10.313092231750488,9.063239097595215,9.975369453430176,8.635374069213867
+1536,11.621739387512207,10.914361000061035,10.77883529663086,10.909053802490234
+1536,7.048953056335449,5.576512813568115,5.520587921142578,5.5327887535095215
+1536,10.72560977935791,10.019929885864258,10.096898078918457,9.95494270324707
+1536,5.693403720855713,5.842792987823486,6.742220878601074,5.864898204803467
+1536,8.890243530273438,7.138002395629883,7.406261920928955,6.962902545928955
+1536,7.5433125495910645,5.555943489074707,6.065594673156738,5.581643104553223
+1536,11.094202041625977,9.982622146606445,10.037124633789062,9.776859283447266
+1536,7.760440826416016,6.381962299346924,6.520465850830078,6.397292137145996
+1536,7.626566410064697,6.265262603759766,6.253514289855957,6.253025054931641
+1536,10.055380821228027,9.334449768066406,9.672952651977539,9.362092971801758
+2048,8.877420425415039,7.067675590515137,7.24631404876709,7.059460639953613
+2048,8.875852584838867,7.822269439697266,8.31857967376709,7.817013740539551
+2048,10.91117000579834,8.661766052246094,8.619443893432617,8.693981170654297
+2048,9.298178672790527,9.217126846313477,9.245017051696777,9.133813858032227
+2048,9.269136428833008,7.09112024307251,7.103521347045898,7.030923843383789
+2048,7.662194728851318,6.003239631652832,6.203981399536133,6.071121692657471
+2048,9.124794006347656,7.173357963562012,7.278070449829102,7.094846248626709
+2048,8.79482650756836,7.073769569396973,7.44549560546875,7.052559852600098
+2048,11.134733200073242,9.455619812011719,9.647821426391602,9.408915519714355
+2048,8.92827320098877,8.296689987182617,8.396689414978027,8.22732925415039
+2048,9.512434959411621,8.22170639038086,8.931074142456055,8.105385780334473
+2048,4.625914096832275,4.129490375518799,4.140652656555176,3.964076042175293
+2048,8.199987411499023,7.10731315612793,7.317073822021484,7.0606369972229
+2048,5.68681526184082,4.098668575286865,4.275548458099365,4.098177909851074
+2048,9.549081802368164,8.524821281433105,8.587430000305176,8.522040367126465
+2048,10.209589004516602,8.997304916381836,9.01644515991211,8.999600410461426
+2048,9.263175010681152,9.05697250366211,9.042498588562012,9.032848358154297
+2048,7.019598960876465,6.012833595275879,6.091050148010254,6.018146514892578
+2048,7.09710693359375,4.703222274780273,4.931643009185791,4.292673110961914
+2048,7.293522834777832,5.4061784744262695,5.459624767303467,5.250613212585449
+2048,7.971972942352295,5.977999687194824,5.9988274574279785,5.748871803283691
+2048,7.506112575531006,6.835953712463379,6.833245277404785,6.8240156173706055
+2048,9.314516067504883,8.07249927520752,8.082049369812012,8.274535179138184
+2048,10.36157512664795,7.9660325050354,8.612711906433105,7.887826442718506
+2048,8.017317771911621,8.254884719848633,8.421252250671387,8.202363967895508
+2048,10.388225555419922,8.195950508117676,8.220012664794922,8.534210205078125
+2048,7.408236026763916,5.37117862701416,5.346179962158203,5.647400379180908
+2048,9.46134090423584,8.446300506591797,8.993728637695312,8.302835464477539
+2048,7.157444000244141,6.351014137268066,6.522596836090088,6.171317100524902
+2048,10.258753776550293,10.44360065460205,10.47008228302002,10.397079467773438
+2048,10.949882507324219,9.720263481140137,9.766423225402832,9.649911880493164
+2048,6.5016679763793945,4.525835037231445,4.590309143066406,4.4480814933776855

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_replay_strength_zh_en.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@
+panel_id,family,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_drop_penalty,control_median_penalty,target_minus_control_median,target_positive,target_beats_control_median
+0,A,7.0577545166015625,6.74220085144043,0.1638479232788086,0.0012507438659667969,0.1625971794128418,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.160486221313477,4.711857795715332,0.005839824676513672,0.0066165924072265625,-0.0007767677307128906,1.0,0.0
+0,A,4.913610935211182,3.3561244010925293,-0.0010266304016113281,-0.03200244903564453,0.030975818634033203,0.0,1.0
+0,A,5.052826881408691,3.1113314628601074,0.6357173919677734,0.39354610443115234,0.2421712875366211,1.0,1.0
+0,A,7.223825454711914,6.48808479309082,0.37616968154907227,0.0356903076171875,0.34047937393188477,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.45328950881958,4.4471940994262695,0.16907978057861328,0.02340221405029297,0.1456775665283203,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.648272514343262,7.057194232940674,0.025966167449951172,-0.023351669311523438,0.04931783676147461,1.0,1.0
+0,B,4.393914222717285,3.7746503353118896,0.5194013118743896,-0.09225082397460938,0.611652135848999,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.874573707580566,5.238962173461914,0.576848030090332,0.06821012496948242,0.5086379051208496,1.0,1.0
+0,B,5.681117534637451,4.16717004776001,0.37114763259887695,0.1492753028869629,0.22187232971191406,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.213891506195068,3.445827007293701,0.20283842086791992,0.298764705657959,-0.09592628479003906,1.0,0.0
+0,B,8.956460952758789,6.249061584472656,0.021459579467773438,0.1721343994140625,-0.15067481994628906,1.0,0.0
+1,A,4.266714096069336,3.503586769104004,0.3390226364135742,0.037035226821899414,0.3019874095916748,1.0,1.0
+1,A,3.9254798889160156,2.6534934043884277,0.4234738349914551,0.07354497909545898,0.3499288558959961,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.9491777420043945,6.408342361450195,-0.05892467498779297,-0.0706014633178711,0.011676788330078125,0.0,1.0
+1,A,6.134390830993652,5.963807106018066,-0.07773256301879883,-0.07089996337890625,-0.006832599639892578,0.0,0.0
+1,A,6.306930065155029,4.6759538650512695,0.2478928565979004,0.24008512496948242,0.007807731628417969,1.0,1.0
+1,A,4.83038330078125,4.389760494232178,0.19998693466186523,-0.025596141815185547,0.22558307647705078,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.113907814025879,3.9629836082458496,0.08134603500366211,0.5217022895812988,-0.4403562545776367,1.0,0.0
+1,B,4.007174491882324,3.280259847640991,0.17418193817138672,0.12841320037841797,0.04576873779296875,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.014835357666016,3.105396032333374,0.48369812965393066,0.1828453540802002,0.30085277557373047,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.528164863586426,6.156818389892578,0.08329153060913086,-0.010007381439208984,0.09329891204833984,1.0,1.0
+1,B,8.587000846862793,9.320782661437988,-0.1393747329711914,-0.20744037628173828,0.06806564331054688,0.0,1.0
+1,B,7.806528091430664,6.692177772521973,0.04056739807128906,0.3059825897216797,-0.2654151916503906,1.0,0.0
+2,A,5.847787857055664,3.473029851913452,0.4921386241912842,0.23218226432800293,0.25995635986328125,1.0,1.0
+2,A,3.8455703258514404,4.4743804931640625,0.11951923370361328,0.009840965270996094,0.10967826843261719,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.238744735717773,6.91934871673584,0.058930397033691406,0.0899505615234375,-0.031020164489746094,1.0,0.0
+2,A,6.6675872802734375,4.586175918579102,0.3219022750854492,-0.00220489501953125,0.32410717010498047,1.0,1.0
+2,A,6.284707546234131,5.83789587020874,0.20853853225708008,-0.17401361465454102,0.3825521469116211,1.0,1.0
+2,A,7.7139506340026855,5.552002906799316,1.1251845359802246,0.16201496124267578,0.9631695747375488,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.22719669342041,5.179539680480957,0.2790813446044922,-0.02687358856201172,0.3059549331665039,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.516940116882324,4.078171730041504,0.41728734970092773,0.09652471542358398,0.32076263427734375,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.176568031311035,5.381500244140625,0.7300825119018555,-0.07209157943725586,0.8021740913391113,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.580033779144287,3.7544031143188477,0.36784982681274414,0.3886251449584961,-0.020775318145751953,1.0,0.0
+2,B,5.9304938316345215,4.765523433685303,0.4164719581604004,0.1813502311706543,0.2351217269897461,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.4403181076049805,4.800710678100586,1.0629706382751465,0.062315940856933594,1.000654697418213,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.2021636962890625,3.5662686824798584,0.10200905799865723,0.3759627342224121,-0.2739536762237549,1.0,0.0
+3,A,4.841524124145508,4.8402557373046875,0.012920379638671875,-0.04122352600097656,0.05414390563964844,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.985219955444336,4.317977428436279,0.07315206527709961,0.07893085479736328,-0.005778789520263672,1.0,0.0
+3,A,6.9015092849731445,4.718839168548584,1.1061291694641113,0.2286992073059082,0.8774299621582031,1.0,1.0
+3,A,6.086369514465332,3.0583834648132324,0.3453695774078369,0.4419822692871094,-0.09661269187927246,1.0,0.0
+3,A,6.074472904205322,3.6792800426483154,0.7073061466217041,0.0820620059967041,0.625244140625,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.988759994506836,4.701992511749268,0.41434383392333984,0.22061777114868164,0.1937260627746582,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.1725053787231445,4.581906795501709,0.7378334999084473,0.24442195892333984,0.4934115409851074,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.383833408355713,5.102893829345703,0.14780044555664062,0.09776782989501953,0.050032615661621094,1.0,1.0
+3,B,7.057919025421143,5.244548797607422,0.16848278045654297,0.16811847686767578,0.0003643035888671875,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.525599479675293,6.234506607055664,0.1588001251220703,0.04109954833984375,0.11770057678222656,1.0,1.0
+3,B,6.157609939575195,4.1562819480896,0.21426057815551758,0.2544722557067871,-0.04021167755126953,1.0,0.0
+4,A,5.269636631011963,2.7050983905792236,2.6044557094573975,-0.008767366409301758,2.613223075866699,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.455465316772461,3.8714706897735596,0.7632205486297607,0.09748578071594238,0.6657347679138184,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.057101249694824,3.9457716941833496,0.13921022415161133,0.013296365737915039,0.1259138584136963,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.222623825073242,4.455681800842285,-0.00021982192993164062,0.03968477249145508,-0.03990459442138672,0.0,0.0
+4,A,4.691170692443848,3.295802354812622,0.36179089546203613,0.08458948135375977,0.27720141410827637,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.241726398468018,5.6223673820495605,0.11763477325439453,-0.03852128982543945,0.15615606307983398,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.214787483215332,4.604681015014648,0.6930217742919922,0.13947010040283203,0.5535516738891602,1.0,1.0
+4,B,8.573358535766602,5.010052680969238,0.4028949737548828,0.46784305572509766,-0.06494808197021484,1.0,0.0
+4,B,5.1455488204956055,3.901186943054199,0.33927297592163086,0.11385822296142578,0.22541475296020508,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.045673847198486,3.8665354251861572,0.4217078685760498,0.10005831718444824,0.32164955139160156,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.561623573303223,4.637264728546143,0.33237171173095703,0.1775498390197754,0.15482187271118164,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.953122138977051,4.9541473388671875,0.20096731185913086,0.023097515106201172,0.1778697967529297,1.0,1.0
+5,A,10.264991760253906,10.268919944763184,-0.11287117004394531,-0.06716442108154297,-0.045706748962402344,0.0,0.0
+5,A,5.163052082061768,3.4128103256225586,0.8777647018432617,0.14371681213378906,0.7340478897094727,1.0,1.0
+5,A,4.230767250061035,3.2761385440826416,0.03415226936340332,0.11756682395935059,-0.08341455459594727,1.0,0.0
+5,A,6.400201320648193,5.175365924835205,0.13072490692138672,0.1445326805114746,-0.01380777359008789,1.0,0.0
+5,A,3.7922983169555664,2.278550386428833,1.2978858947753906,-0.011185646057128906,1.3090715408325195,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.050047397613525,3.2041919231414795,1.2259385585784912,0.021424055099487305,1.204514503479004,1.0,1.0
+5,B,6.479709625244141,4.6576433181762695,0.1444263458251953,0.19163990020751953,-0.04721355438232422,1.0,0.0
+5,B,5.781857967376709,5.348400592803955,0.05312395095825195,0.1558055877685547,-0.10268163681030273,1.0,0.0
+5,B,8.161516189575195,5.279721736907959,0.1322484016418457,1.0190825462341309,-0.8868341445922852,1.0,0.0
+5,B,4.412644863128662,3.8200039863586426,0.048769474029541016,0.05196380615234375,-0.0031943321228027344,1.0,0.0
+5,B,5.924332618713379,6.023046493530273,0.1524643898010254,-0.18994569778442383,0.3424100875854492,1.0,1.0
+5,B,4.411151885986328,2.300537347793579,0.7624616622924805,0.11995577812194824,0.6425058841705322,1.0,1.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_replay_strength_zh_zh.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@
+panel_id,family,beta0_nll,full_nll,target_drop_penalty,control_median_penalty,target_minus_control_median,target_positive,target_beats_control_median
+0,A,5.077829360961914,5.250338554382324,-0.23799514770507812,-0.04241037368774414,-0.19558477401733398,0.0,0.0
+0,A,4.421975135803223,4.772916316986084,-0.00926351547241211,-0.20450878143310547,0.19524526596069336,0.0,1.0
+0,A,6.830989837646484,5.9151716232299805,0.22607040405273438,0.052669525146484375,0.17340087890625,1.0,1.0
+0,A,5.026124954223633,4.986424446105957,-0.00903940200805664,0.02788066864013672,-0.03692007064819336,0.0,0.0
+0,A,4.642368316650391,5.021335124969482,-0.07224321365356445,-0.09392213821411133,0.021678924560546875,0.0,1.0
+0,A,5.06829833984375,4.954913139343262,-0.1773366928100586,0.032588958740234375,-0.20992565155029297,0.0,0.0
+0,B,5.417942047119141,5.713285446166992,-0.04587841033935547,-0.067352294921875,0.02147388458251953,0.0,1.0
+0,B,3.690688133239746,3.0204217433929443,0.16367697715759277,0.009092569351196289,0.15458440780639648,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.600552558898926,6.930105686187744,0.24127912521362305,-0.004878520965576172,0.24615764617919922,1.0,1.0
+0,B,7.796571731567383,7.3574042320251465,0.07382726669311523,0.0015969276428222656,0.07223033905029297,1.0,1.0
+0,B,8.143758773803711,7.269982814788818,0.09301233291625977,0.07129716873168945,0.021715164184570312,1.0,1.0
+0,B,6.705144882202148,6.581791877746582,0.08404064178466797,-0.06540298461914062,0.1494436264038086,1.0,1.0
+1,A,5.911498069763184,5.582012176513672,0.1722579002380371,-0.05301809310913086,0.22527599334716797,1.0,1.0
+1,A,4.5531816482543945,4.811577796936035,0.04225587844848633,0.04239606857299805,-0.00014019012451171875,1.0,0.0
+1,A,5.860117435455322,4.964238166809082,0.7010173797607422,-0.014542579650878906,0.7155599594116211,1.0,1.0
+1,A,4.443840026855469,4.117055892944336,0.06091880798339844,-0.0110015869140625,0.07192039489746094,1.0,1.0
+1,A,3.711423397064209,3.9432246685028076,0.08214592933654785,-0.03713631629943848,0.11928224563598633,1.0,1.0
+1,A,6.477508068084717,5.201830863952637,0.8822674751281738,0.040205955505371094,0.8420615196228027,1.0,1.0
+1,B,7.005721092224121,6.610367774963379,0.19406890869140625,-0.07087945938110352,0.26494836807250977,1.0,1.0
+1,B,4.244316101074219,4.526578903198242,0.04468345642089844,-0.020658016204833984,0.06534147262573242,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.643148422241211,6.217992782592773,0.15169906616210938,0.036070823669433594,0.11562824249267578,1.0,1.0
+1,B,6.173837184906006,6.294565200805664,0.06096982955932617,-0.0025577545166015625,0.06352758407592773,1.0,1.0
+1,B,7.190107345581055,6.3715057373046875,0.19992971420288086,0.007164478302001953,0.1927652359008789,1.0,1.0
+1,B,5.8835649490356445,5.385002136230469,0.013482093811035156,0.022459030151367188,-0.008976936340332031,1.0,0.0
+2,A,7.194003582000732,6.731771469116211,0.1089930534362793,-0.01724529266357422,0.12623834609985352,1.0,1.0
+2,A,5.086414337158203,5.439191818237305,0.08684492111206055,-0.09493541717529297,0.18178033828735352,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.051700592041016,4.354938507080078,-0.006892681121826172,0.23808956146240234,-0.24498224258422852,0.0,0.0
+2,A,6.493345737457275,5.462042808532715,0.11359500885009766,0.10127687454223633,0.012318134307861328,1.0,1.0
+2,A,4.728868007659912,4.59887170791626,0.05152177810668945,0.1363520622253418,-0.08483028411865234,1.0,0.0
+2,A,9.423473358154297,9.767157554626465,0.014097213745117188,-0.03875160217285156,0.05284881591796875,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.163059711456299,5.9064860343933105,0.021396160125732422,-0.19826078414916992,0.21965694427490234,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.138954162597656,5.017546653747559,0.081146240234375,0.00067901611328125,0.08046722412109375,1.0,1.0
+2,B,7.49741792678833,7.351729869842529,0.1243753433227539,-0.020272254943847656,0.14464759826660156,1.0,1.0
+2,B,9.94482707977295,9.643470764160156,0.08277416229248047,0.020069122314453125,0.06270503997802734,1.0,1.0
+2,B,5.299746990203857,4.9673051834106445,0.16714859008789062,0.02142953872680664,0.14571905136108398,1.0,1.0
+2,B,6.205211162567139,6.4904375076293945,0.0826578140258789,-0.09350395202636719,0.1761617660522461,1.0,1.0
+3,A,3.8919496536254883,4.270011901855469,0.06281089782714844,0.023285865783691406,0.03952503204345703,1.0,1.0
+3,A,5.155069828033447,5.496438980102539,0.08363628387451172,-0.1291489601135254,0.2127852439880371,1.0,1.0
+3,A,3.8714005947113037,3.6041951179504395,0.3049964904785156,0.030341148376464844,0.2746553421020508,1.0,1.0
+3,A,6.36767578125,4.448701858520508,0.14593791961669922,0.2821693420410156,-0.1362314224243164,1.0,0.0
+3,A,7.324559211730957,6.7331085205078125,0.02657938003540039,0.0043163299560546875,0.022263050079345703,1.0,1.0
+3,A,9.624968528747559,9.934350967407227,0.021921157836914062,-0.07945060729980469,0.10137176513671875,1.0,1.0
+3,B,5.466350555419922,5.885862350463867,-0.011079788208007812,-0.12261962890625,0.11153984069824219,0.0,1.0
+3,B,4.281764507293701,4.006591796875,0.03653717041015625,0.061321258544921875,-0.024784088134765625,1.0,0.0
+3,B,6.610803604125977,7.272812366485596,-0.15458345413208008,-0.14082765579223633,-0.01375579833984375,0.0,0.0
+3,B,7.149714469909668,6.99313497543335,0.041135311126708984,-0.011993885040283203,0.05312919616699219,1.0,1.0
+3,B,9.39814567565918,9.287111282348633,-0.12225818634033203,-0.16214466094970703,0.039886474609375,0.0,1.0
+3,B,5.1614885330200195,5.252140045166016,0.18097400665283203,0.035605430603027344,0.1453685760498047,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.89431619644165,3.3295087814331055,0.17092347145080566,0.06650495529174805,0.10441851615905762,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.407055854797363,6.058907508850098,0.2128286361694336,0.15781021118164062,0.05501842498779297,1.0,1.0
+4,A,6.861955642700195,6.598012924194336,0.44477176666259766,-0.025404930114746094,0.47017669677734375,1.0,1.0
+4,A,4.1555681228637695,4.391011714935303,0.023198604583740234,-0.11924123764038086,0.1424398422241211,1.0,1.0
+4,A,5.7784881591796875,5.382878303527832,0.0039920806884765625,0.0818014144897461,-0.07780933380126953,1.0,0.0
+4,A,5.67211389541626,5.3364691734313965,0.09383535385131836,0.025823116302490234,0.06801223754882812,1.0,1.0
+4,B,5.386153221130371,4.404111385345459,-0.016672134399414062,0.052365779876708984,-0.06903791427612305,0.0,0.0
+4,B,7.21576452255249,5.911778926849365,0.35411787033081055,0.05623817443847656,0.297879695892334,1.0,1.0
+4,B,6.159496307373047,5.903771877288818,0.028648853302001953,0.04481172561645508,-0.016162872314453125,1.0,0.0
+4,B,8.483834266662598,7.568432331085205,0.4297299385070801,0.01698017120361328,0.4127497673034668,1.0,1.0
+4,B,7.897724151611328,7.127623081207275,0.07421875,0.19668960571289062,-0.12247085571289062,1.0,0.0
+4,B,3.57991361618042,2.4538989067077637,0.5757298469543457,-0.013198614120483398,0.5889284610748291,1.0,1.0
+5,A,4.987730503082275,4.9734649658203125,-0.18129301071166992,-0.3836202621459961,0.20232725143432617,0.0,1.0
+5,A,6.7431488037109375,6.1460418701171875,0.08728790283203125,-0.06117439270019531,0.14846229553222656,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.065853118896484,4.757863521575928,0.046680450439453125,0.02947998046875,0.017200469970703125,1.0,1.0
+5,A,6.504290580749512,6.36551570892334,0.16664791107177734,0.10953521728515625,0.057112693786621094,1.0,1.0
+5,A,5.059316635131836,6.4120025634765625,-0.036838531494140625,-0.7314538955688477,0.694615364074707,0.0,1.0
+5,A,6.63135290145874,6.320376873016357,0.04152727127075195,0.009222030639648438,0.032305240631103516,1.0,1.0
+5,B,5.744901180267334,4.847271919250488,0.1219625473022461,0.06766223907470703,0.05430030822753906,1.0,1.0
+5,B,5.910009384155273,4.746596813201904,0.036055564880371094,0.04738473892211914,-0.011329174041748047,1.0,0.0
+5,B,9.739190101623535,9.282974243164062,0.18248462677001953,0.04462623596191406,0.13785839080810547,1.0,1.0
+5,B,5.693960189819336,5.758001327514648,0.20830726623535156,-0.03992414474487305,0.2482314109802246,1.0,1.0
+5,B,7.637505531311035,7.366318702697754,-0.03612709045410156,0.04253196716308594,-0.0786590576171875,0.0,0.0
+5,B,9.24187183380127,8.529711723327637,0.14548301696777344,0.06279754638671875,0.08268547058105469,1.0,1.0

experiments/scale0/s0_r2_replay_strength/20260916T112742Z/s0r3_s0r1_vs_replay_cadence.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+branch,lr_scale,causal_coef,replay_interval,optimization_gain,real_composite,q2_full_relative,zh_zh_replication,zh_en_replication,en_zh_replication,structural_ok
+HISTORICAL_S0R1_CAUSAL_1P00,0.6,1.0,8,0.0008883391331440836,0.0005679889848538087,-0.0037554308634022166,4,6,3,False
+REPLAY_EVERY_4,0.6,1.0,4,0.0006933628862113668,0.00010005143676994445,-0.011427244593604976,6,4,5,True