foundry-j / spec /COVERAGE_MATRIX.md
SNAPKITTYWEST's picture
October 2026 main drop: mirror from GitHub
fadf040 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
8.33 kB

Coverage Matrix β€” PROPERTIES.md ↔ harness

Target commit: 194e588 (pure-J Foundry F1).
Sources: spec/PROPERTIES.md (56 numbered properties); verify/PROPERTY_MAP.md (harness Primary/Related + measured results); verify/INVENTORY.md (non-mathematical / ignored note).
Measured log: logs/run-20261007-061701.log β€” PROPERTY_MAP reports 8 PASS / 1 FAIL / 0 BLOCKED (not 9/9).
No invented numbers. Status definitions exactly as Spec brief.

Status Definition
covered Listed in PROPERTY_MAP as Primary # or Related # and measured PASS
partial Listed as Primary/Related but measured FAIL; or harness works around Core (e.g. recurrence via rec_step not rec_run); or emission / CSL / AceCert / WORM props called out as non-mathematical / ignored by harness
untested Not mentioned in PROPERTY_MAP Primary or Related columns (and not in the ignored 47–56 band)

Prop Short name Status Evidence Notes
1 Goldilocks prime (decimal) covered goldilocks_add (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
2 Goldilocks prime (hex / named constant) covered goldilocks_add (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
3 Field elements are u64 reduced mod p covered goldilocks_add (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
4 Elem construction reduces untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
5 Congruence (2^{64} \equiv 2^{32}-1 \pmod{p}) covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
6 Fold constant EPSILON covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
7 128-bit product split covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
8 hi split into 32-bit halves covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
9 Reduction identity (fold) covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
10 Underflow handling on fold covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
11 Final conditional reduction after fold covered goldilocks_mul (Related 5–11) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
12 Single-limb reduce untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
13 Addition mod p covered goldilocks_add (Primary) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP; verify/tests/goldilocks.ijs
14 Subtraction mod p covered goldilocks_sub (Primary) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP; verify/tests/goldilocks.ijs
15 Multiplication via mulmod covered goldilocks_mul (Primary) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP; verify/tests/goldilocks.ijs
16 Fermat inverse partial goldilocks_inv (Primary) covered-but-FAIL β€” PROPERTY_MAP: 42*fp_inv(42) β†’ 11152786313141180820 (not 1); log run-20261007-061701
17 Binary exponentiation partial goldilocks_inv (Related) Listed with prop 16; same measured FAIL
18 Batch add/mul untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
19 K_MAX untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
20 MAX_DRIFT untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
21 PIRTM_MAGIC untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
22 PHI untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related; see Gaps
23 P_64 β€” first 64 primes untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
24 GENESIS_HASH_SIZE untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
25 Tier epsilons (contraction margins) untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
26 PMat entry shape covered pmat_insert (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
27 Insert domain checks covered pmat_insert (Primary) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP; verify/tests/pmat.ijs
28 Grading condition (stated) untested none Gap: validate_grading stub; not in harness map
29 Conservation theorem covered pmat_conservation (Primary) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP; verify/tests/pmat.ijs
30 Composition preserves grading (stated) untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
31 Compose monomial accumulation rule (as coded) untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related; see Gaps
32 Frobenius norm of PMat untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
33 Gershgorin disk bound covered spectral_contractive, spectral_expansive (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
34 Contractive test (Gershgorin) covered spectral_contractive, spectral_expansive (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
35 Power iteration (Rayleigh) untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
36 Contractive test (power iteration) untested none Not in PROPERTY_MAP Primary/Related
37 Analyze fallback policy covered spectral_contractive, spectral_expansive (Related) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP
38 Tested contractive / expansive examples covered spectral_contractive, spectral_expansive (Primary) PASS in PROPERTY_MAP; verify/tests/spectral.ijs
39 Recurrence equation partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) PASS measured, but PROPERTY_MAP notes harness loop via synth_weights+rec_step; Core rec_run still flattens StepInfo
40 Contraction condition partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) Same workaround note as prop 39
41 Unique fixed-point guarantee (narrative) partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) Same workaround note as prop 39
42 q estimate in step (as coded) partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) Same workaround note as prop 39
43 Soft projection partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) Same workaround note as prop 39
44 Weight budget split partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) Same workaround note as prop 39
45 Projector partial recurrence_converges (Related 39–45) Same workaround note as prop 39
46 Residual partial recurrence_converges (Primary) PASS measured via rec_step loop; PROPERTY_MAP: Core rec_run packing still broken (x_next ; info flattens)
47 WORM / seal chain invariant (system-level) partial none (ignored) INVENTORY: props 47–56 adjacent / gate-WORM theater, not in harness
48 Emission Suppress partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
49 Emission Attenuate scale partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
50 CSL neutrality partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
51 CSL beneficence partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
52 CSL commutation partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
53 AceCertificate safety margin partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
54 AceCertificate tail bound partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
55 Guardian spectral legality partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness
56 Consensus / false-positive bound (narrative) partial none (ignored) INVENTORY non-mathematical / ignored by harness

Summary counts

Status Count
covered 20
partial 20
untested 16
Total 56

Partial breakdown (for handoff)

Reason Props Count
Measured FAIL (goldilocks_inv) 16, 17 2
Harness workaround (rec_step / rec_run packing) 39–46 8
Ignored / non-mathematical (INVENTORY 47–56) 47–56 10

Harness measured (PROPERTY_MAP / log run-20261007-061701)

Result Count Detail
PASS 8 goldilocks_add, goldilocks_mul, goldilocks_sub, pmat_insert, pmat_conservation, spectral_contractive, spectral_expansive, recurrence_converges
FAIL 1 goldilocks_inv / prop 16
BLOCKED 0 β€”

Cite: verify/PROPERTY_MAP.md Summary counts; verify/INVENTORY.md Math count line.