MR-Bench-H / docs /CONSTRUCTION.md
Bluexxx's picture
MR-Bench-H v2.0.1
e259ac7 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
4.03 kB
# Construction and provenance
MR-Bench-H is built in three stages, as described in the paper (Section 2.2 and supplementary Section B): candidate mining, reader-panel screening and blind human validation. The released test set contains 900 clips: 620 LS and 280 NS; control clips are excluded from the release.
| Stage | LS | NS | Control | Total |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| Candidate pool | 1,474 | 380 | 186 | 2,040 |
| Reader-panel pass | 798 | 363 | 176 | 1,337 |
| Final retained, human-validated test set | 620 | 280 | 0 | 900 |
| LS/NS items outside the final test set | 178 | 83 | 0 | 261 |
| Panel-passing controls tracked separately | 0 | 0 | 176 | 176 |
Of 2,040 candidates from validation and test splits and unseen corpora, 1,337 pass the panel and 900 the annotators (620 LS, 280 NS).
## Stage 1: candidate mining
Candidates are mined from unimodal judgments on the MMSA sources, explicit versus implicit emotion annotations on MUStARD++, and the text-only view of a trained fusion model on MELD and IEMOCAP. LS candidates have misleading linguistic evidence; NS candidates have misleading non-verbal evidence. Reference and distractor polarities are binary and opposite.
## Stage 2: reader-panel screening
Four instruction-tuned text LLMs from three families (Qwen2.5-7B, Qwen3-8B, Yi-1.5-9B and Phi-3.5-mini) answer the binary sentiment question from the transcript alone. An LS candidate passes when at least three readers answer the distractor polarity. NS candidates and controls pass when at least three readers answer the reference polarity. This leaves 1,337 panel-passing items.
## Stage 3: blind human validation
Three annotators independently assess each shuffled clip with its labels hidden. They answer Q2 from the transcript alone, Q5 from the muted video, then Q1 from the full clip; they also identify the decisive channel (Q3) and ambiguity (Q4).
- **LS retention:** the majority gives Q1 = reference polarity, Q2 = distractor polarity, Q3 in {voice, face, mixed}, and Q4 = no ambiguity.
- **NS retention:** the majority gives Q1 = reference polarity, Q5 = distractor polarity, Q3 in {words, voice, mixed}, and Q4 = no ambiguity.
These majority-vote criteria retain 620 LS and 280 NS clips. Control accuracy is used to flag careless annotators. The annotation workflow is described in [ANNOTATION_GUIDE.md](ANNOTATION_GUIDE.md).
## Agreement
Annotator agreement is **Fleiss' κ = 0.75**. Every retained LS and NS clip meets the criteria above, so majority-vote accuracy on the released clips is fixed by the rule and is not reported as a result. Control clips are excluded from the release and are not selected by these criteria; the majority answer matches the label on 91.0% of them, which flags careless annotators.
Every released row has `validated: true` and `validation.n_annotators: 3`. Individual annotator votes are not distributed; the item-level fields `validation.agreement` and `validation.evidence_channel` are `null`.
## Per-source counts
Candidates after stage 1, items passing the reader panel (stage 2) and items retained after human validation (stage 3), as LS / NS / controls (Table S4 of the paper).
| Source | Language | Candidates | Reader panel | Validated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CMU-MOSI | EN | 83 / 135 / 22 | 23 / 130 / 21 | 14 / 119 / 0 |
| CMU-MOSEI | EN | 139 / 177 / 32 | 53 / 175 / 28 | 23 / 119 / 0 |
| CH-SIMS | ZH | 48 / 26 / 7 | 38 / 22 / 7 | 24 / 16 / 0 |
| CH-SIMSv2 | ZH | 96 / 42 / 14 | 74 / 36 / 14 | 49 / 26 / 0 |
| MUStARD++ | EN | 101 / -- / 10 | 69 / -- / 10 | 53 / -- / 0 |
| MELD | EN | 407 / -- / 41 | 176 / -- / 39 | 176 / -- / 0 |
| IEMOCAP | EN | 600 / -- / 60 | 365 / -- / 57 | 281 / -- / 0 |
| **Total** | | 1,474 / 380 / 186 | 798 / 363 / 176 | 620 / 280 / 0 |
## Reproducibility
`release_manifest.json` records the SHA-256 hashes of the distributed files and the UID-set hash. JSONL and Parquet contain the same 900 records. Annotation returns, restricted IEMOCAP fields and original media are outside the public release.