Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
experiment_id
large_stringlengths
19
158
merge_id
large_stringlengths
21
31
model_family
large_stringclasses
7 values
model_a
large_stringclasses
220 values
model_b
large_stringclasses
266 values
model_a_checkpoint
large_stringclasses
214 values
model_b_checkpoint
large_stringclasses
246 values
model_a_hash
large_stringclasses
0 values
model_b_hash
large_stringclasses
0 values
model_a_parameters
float64
1.41B
1.41B
βŒ€
model_b_parameters
float64
1.41B
1.41B
βŒ€
architecture
large_stringclasses
5 values
tokenizer_a
large_stringclasses
23 values
tokenizer_b
large_stringclasses
21 values
initialisation_relationship
large_stringclasses
3 values
training_relationship
large_stringclasses
4 values
tokenizer_relationship
large_stringclasses
3 values
provenance_group
large_stringclasses
9 values
merge_method
large_stringclasses
13 values
alignment_method
large_stringclasses
6 values
vocabulary_transport
bool
2 classes
interpolation_strength
large_stringclasses
14 values
method_configuration
large_stringlengths
52
1.03k
random_seed
large_stringclasses
1 value
copies_parent
large_stringclasses
3 values
is_control
bool
2 classes
benchmark
large_stringclasses
12 values
task
large_stringclasses
466 values
split
large_stringclasses
6 values
dataset_revision
large_stringclasses
0 values
evaluation_samples
large_stringclasses
11 values
evaluation_metric
large_stringclasses
8 values
metric_direction
large_stringclasses
2 values
model_a_score
float64
0
165
βŒ€
model_b_score
float64
0
80
βŒ€
better_parent_score
float64
0
81.7
βŒ€
naive_merge_score
float64
-2.78
137
βŒ€
merged_model_score
float64
-29.88
348
merge_loss
float64
-2.2
344
βŒ€
merge_gain
float64
-307.15
49
βŒ€
merge_success
large_stringclasses
2 values
alignment_gain
float64
-35.33
85.5
βŒ€
code_commit
large_stringclasses
0 values
config_hash
large_stringlengths
12
12
evaluation_timestamp
large_stringclasses
0 values
checkpoint_path
large_stringclasses
870 values
evaluation_status
large_stringclasses
2 values
result_status
large_stringclasses
5 values
limitations
large_stringclasses
1 value
notes
large_stringclasses
293 values
source_file
large_stringclasses
39 values
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:1169e6c1026c
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
5.487839
0.336538
0.576838
False
null
null
6d7c1b3a9c0a
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:4b7495cb8895
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
6.557728
1.406427
-0.493051
False
null
null
0f6d609fe752
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:8bde6ce6bb5d
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
5.489198
0.337897
0.57548
False
-0.001359
null
6e014c66727e
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:a126942058ff
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
5.425749
0.274447
0.638929
False
0
null
255fda9f4348
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:add0c5c49439
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
6.064678
0.913376
0
False
null
null
2f09569ce98a
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:b3d2f0e9c493
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
6.068787
0.917486
-0.004109
False
-0.004109
null
a507cd103b43
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:be13b9e2fb1d
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
5.425749
0.274447
0.638929
False
null
null
57ae147008a5
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100
beetle_controlled:e2527a1e14b8
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.690197
5.151301
6.064678
6.554136
1.402834
-0.489458
False
0.003592
null
295de40d5b5d
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:1a97c1d8dac7
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
5.487294
0.335992
0.577436
False
-0.002285
null
627dd580ad21
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:2459ecf74ad6
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
5.420536
0.269235
0.644194
False
0
null
adc150d09a4e
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:802a00e66322
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
5.485009
0.333707
0.579721
False
null
null
54f209a5f9d4
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:a07ad968a1cd
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
6.507419
1.356117
-0.442688
False
null
null
e4a387c77476
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:d4b43a48f29d
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
6.50404
1.352738
-0.43931
False
0.003379
null
e664a2a18276
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:d576614ed035
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
5.420536
0.269235
0.644194
False
null
null
0ef591f124b1
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:e7e1e0a1af04
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
6.06473
0.913429
0
False
null
null
a290e636ed1d
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de
beetle_controlled:ee90d0ad9f48
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-deu-eng
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-deu-eng__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-de", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.151301
5.69419
5.151301
6.06473
6.070219
0.918917
-0.005488
False
-0.005488
null
6be8dac68699
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:20d177b01001
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.387205
0.069504
0.137136
False
null
null
70d40257eece
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:508cdd58ebd1
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.649032
0.331332
-0.124692
False
null
null
9408b77a58f4
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:5e76500fd31c
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.53147
0.213769
-0.00713
False
0
null
279fbb37d446
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:79f1061d1bfe
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.649032
0.331332
-0.124692
False
0
null
183ac4d5cb66
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:93df4655a3b0
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.52434
0.20664
0
False
null
null
e9fadfa11503
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:c618e60da154
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.387205
0.069504
0.137136
False
0
null
6e9ff0542f95
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:d7b1e6f5372e
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.53147
0.213769
-0.00713
False
null
null
0293eb42c085
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:fe05ace8b3ec
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.472335
5.3177
5.52434
5.52434
0.20664
0
False
0
null
f4efbca47225
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:01a219f4f856
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
6.051979
0.734278
-0.422401
False
0
null
785bb4c07bcd
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:2b92426064ad
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
5.397898
0.080197
0.23168
False
null
null
33c92f86dc19
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:37642fef7312
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
6.051979
0.734278
-0.422401
False
null
null
83cdbeca7d93
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:5fe69a50d87e
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
5.629578
0.311877
0
False
null
null
fe33d645c4e9
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:6bed89a0b009
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
5.582415
0.264714
0.047163
False
0
null
56eeee8b8c0c
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:82717386ea59
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
5.397898
0.080197
0.23168
False
0
null
ce56312f92d9
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:a7242a17f113
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
5.629578
0.311877
0
False
0
null
ac8f942c75dc
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:b90366bd1149
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
7.921827
5.3177
5.629578
5.582415
0.264714
0.047163
False
null
null
0274ffeffb1d
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:3af4b3fd86e8
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.414678
0.096977
0.099953
False
0
null
3f9f3df29de3
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:4de4e437d2ef
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.514631
0.19693
0
False
null
null
29a87543d308
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:ba9086609e6d
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.414678
0.096977
0.099953
False
null
null
b0ab35f0b3f5
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:bff3fc39bdc7
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.531013
0.213312
-0.016382
False
null
null
42753c7b78ef
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:c4717f9edae6
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.572278
0.254578
-0.057647
False
0
null
73d1cb6402b4
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:eef657ab38b5
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.531013
0.213312
-0.016382
False
0
null
cf33b90d87fa
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:f1b60ea34969
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.572278
0.254578
-0.057647
False
null
null
7ef30b4c8157
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:f38670bdef9b
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
5.34824
5.3177
5.514631
5.514631
0.19693
0
False
0
null
e65df5772a3c
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:0c3e57fde1ab
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.521628
0.203928
0
False
null
null
f905f59861e3
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:47e71ea448c1
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.388683
0.070983
0.132945
False
null
null
519643177423
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:634f1153ef82
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.521628
0.203928
0
False
0
null
bbe6c73f94c6
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:684395ad376e
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.540348
0.222648
-0.01872
False
0
null
739f1c381651
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:a61a11586a5d
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.75787
0.440169
-0.236241
False
0
null
0444bfb3366a
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:cb631343b96c
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.75787
0.440169
-0.236241
False
null
null
7bf843ba3e29
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:e25fe1dbe146
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.540348
0.222648
-0.01872
False
null
null
69adc78d4ddb
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell
beetle_controlled:f660d2d01336
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-ell-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-80-late-b5-fineweb-100m-ell", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.3177
6.938141
5.3177
5.521628
5.388683
0.070983
0.132945
False
0
null
0b0a9a01c03f
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=unique-prefix, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:1faad5683109
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.211883
0.236132
0
False
null
null
231534b849e9
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:2c155bca455d
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.211883
0.236132
0
False
0
null
2bc5c4f1f00c
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:3d559bd138e2
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.211883
0.236132
0
False
0
null
dd0e6dbb138f
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:68da471b7bd0
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.051208
0.075458
0.160675
False
0
null
5b87c53d80ed
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:a184fd2bf7a8
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.051208
0.075458
0.160675
False
null
null
cd6d4144d7f3
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:b1d0ba9a0eec
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.330939
0.355188
-0.119056
False
null
null
10963b378324
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:b4888969bece
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.330939
0.355188
-0.119056
False
0
null
b54b3995e01f
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:c7f8416500d5
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-classroom-20-b4-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.146159
5.975751
6.211883
6.211883
0.236132
0
False
null
null
5123b0227487
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:587cb8d632dc
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.669156
0.693405
-0.371305
False
0
null
623c32c2fe6d
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:621b4139f130
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.669156
0.693405
-0.371305
False
null
null
ed49d0b6fb62
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:7a884e37bc93
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.297851
0.3221
0
False
null
null
b0260c15c727
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:911f36eb1ad1
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.066514
0.090764
0.231337
False
0
null
f8a2441fa5ef
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:9b932897df95
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.297851
0.3221
0
False
0
null
0c89b508df35
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:b324c9d6a114
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.066514
0.090764
0.231337
False
null
null
8dd95d12373a
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:b7801e86d6ca
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.279626
0.303875
0.018225
False
null
null
b2f4dc711ebb
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine
beetle_controlled:d070e29f5790
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-sequential-33-67-b3-fine", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
7.64251
5.975751
6.297851
6.279626
0.303875
0.018225
False
0
null
a71d03d82ef0
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:066161e14446
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.219365
0.243614
0
False
0
null
abfca8370f41
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:1da150b08359
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.089604
0.113853
0.129761
False
null
null
8e35c29b7efe
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:4d3753f6018c
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.261321
0.28557
-0.041955
False
0
null
722b3ff6132c
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:57a90f40a193
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
ties
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "ties"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.261321
0.28557
-0.041955
False
null
null
fb00b235a05d
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:7eb3b1529974
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.237715
0.261964
-0.01835
False
0
null
53a67c4ca384
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:ce5516e8f9ab
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
task_arithmetic
permutation
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "aligned", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "task_arithmetic"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.089604
0.113853
0.129761
False
0
null
65f841db364f
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:d1bd15c9c4cf
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
average
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "average"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.219365
0.243614
0
False
null
null
12ddba4c8950
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; in the 2,800-row panel20 ...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
beetle_controlled:v1:zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-
beetle_controlled:fd9cd650dbad
beetle_controlled
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
hf://Beetle-FineWeb-100M/beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100
null
null
null
null
unknown
null
null
shared
divergent_history
shared
shared|divergent_history|shared
qmd
none
false
null
{"align_method": "permutation", "base": "naive", "bench": "v1", "pair_id": "zoo-curriculum-beetle-bilingual-balanced-b1-fineweb-100m-est-eng-1xa100__beetle-bilingual-l2-50-simultaneous-b2-fineweb-", "panel20_complete_case": true, "recipe": "qmd_guided"}
null
False
false
lm_nll
nll_unit=not_recorded(v1)
heldout
null
null
nll
lower
5.975751
6.020135
5.975751
6.219365
6.237715
0.261964
-0.01835
False
null
null
fdb8699df324
null
verified
evaluated
model_a_hash, model_b_hash, code_commit and evaluation_timestamp are not recorded in the historical result files
bench=v1; factor=curriculum; regime=beetle_curriculum; scale_tag=fineweb-100m; parents from provenance_labels.csv (name_b_recovery=pairing-rule, candidates=1, status=ok); init verdict=SHARED (E-19 measurement); training relationship: shared init + different training stream = divergent_history; operator recorded as qmd_...
results/provenance_merge_bench/provenance_merge_bench.csv
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

Model Merging & Capability Transfer Dataset

A dataset of merge experiments, not just checkpoints. Every row says which two models were merged, how, under which alignment and configuration, and how the result scored on downstream tasks next to both parents and the naive merge, measured under the same protocol. Negative results, controls, unverified and incomplete runs are included, and their status is explicit.

It contains 18,171 merge experiments, 64,180 evaluations of 18,507 checkpoints, and 59,087 rows in the flat merged_models table.

Configurations

merged_models is the default configuration: one long-format row per pair Γ— method Γ— alignment Γ— benchmark Γ— task Γ— metric, carrying parent, naive and merged scores and the derived merge loss, gain and success. merges, evaluations and models are the linked tables it is built from. summary holds the derived statistics.

from datasets import load_dataset
flat = load_dataset("Cross-Mergeability/model-merging-benchmark", "merged_models")["train"]
evals = load_dataset("Cross-Mergeability/model-merging-benchmark", "evaluations")["train"]

Experiment families

experiment_family merges methods unverified
beetle_controlled 11364 average, qmd, task_arithmetic, ties 1996
beetle_published 869 average, csp, dare, opcm, other, qmd, svc, task_arithmetic, ties 56
cross_architecture 788 average, dare, interpolation, ot_fusion, slerp, task_arithmetic, ties 121
llama_forks 18 chat_vector 0
mergebench 72 average, dare, other, task_arithmetic, ties 72
polypythia 4028 average, interpolation, other, slerp, task_arithmetic, ties 0
toksuite 1032 average, qmd, task_arithmetic, ties 0

How often a merge beats its better parent

These counts are for comparisons where both parents and the merge were scored in the same experiment:

model_family comparisons beats_best_parent
beetle_controlled 9368 1107
beetle_published 378 2
cross_architecture 1232 65
polypythia 5460 0
toksuite 5160 0

Metrics

All losses are signed so that positive means worse than the better parent:

  • Merge loss. For NLL, merged βˆ’ min(A, B). For accuracy, max(A, B) βˆ’ merged.
  • Merge gain. naive_merge_loss βˆ’ method_merge_loss. Positive means the method improved on plain averaging. It does not mean the result is useful.
  • Merge success. The merge strictly beats the better parent on that metric.
  • Alignment gain. Loss of the unaligned twin (same pair, method and configuration) minus loss of the aligned merge.

NLL and accuracy are never mixed in one row. A parent is used as a baseline only when it was scored in the same experiment_id.

Row status (result_status)

result_status rows
parent_baseline_missing 34537
evaluated 21598
unverified 2053
naive_baseline_missing 809
naive_baseline_not_applicable 90
  • evaluated: the merge and both parents were scored under one protocol.
  • parent_baseline_missing: the merge was scored but a parent was not, in that experiment. This happens, for example, for PolyPythia per-paradigm BLiMP, where only the parents' aggregate BLiMP was recorded, and for Beetle published NLL, where only the better-parent NLL was recorded.
  • naive_baseline_missing: there is no plain-average twin in the same experiment.
  • naive_baseline_not_applicable: the method has no plain-average twin by design (chat-vector transfer, OT fusion).
  • unverified: the source flags the value.

Pair Γ— method combinations that were never run have no row.

Known limitations

  • Copies a parent. copies_parent=True marks rungs whose output is one parent's tensors, for example SVC/OPCM single-parent fills. They are not evidence of composition.
  • Aligned equals naive. In the published Beetle rungs, the aligned merges are byte-identical to the naive ones, because the aligner returned the identity; see notes.
  • Calibration overlap.
    • OT fusion is scored on sentences inside the set used to fit the transport plans, so it is provisional.
    • PolyPythia alignment is fitted on the same FLORES blocks it is scored on.
  • Task arithmetic without a shared base. Where the parents share no base, task arithmetic and TIES are parent interpolations, not conventional task vectors (see merge_config).
  • MergeBench. Rows are published scores, not re-evaluated, and the 5-expert merges have no parent_a/parent_b.
  • Not recorded. Parent checkpoint hashes, code commits, evaluation timestamps and most dataset revisions are absent from the historical result files and are left null.
  • Wikitext-scored transport rungs. The 56 Beetle transport rungs scored on wikitext are unverified.

Provenance and reproduction

Every row has a source_file, and sources.json lists every file each adapter read. Rebuild from the repository with python -m merge_dataset.build_dataset; the scripts are in scripts/. The tables are generated, never maintained by hand.

Citation

To be added by the authors.

Downloads last month
43