Datasets:
Discovery candidates: 15 Co/Cr/Mn/Fe/Ta chalcogenide-halide metals outside the active set
Following the Discovery rules (#61): the materials below are outside the active set (checked against active_challenge.csv, 1054 entries) and are metals (is_metal = True, gap_pbe ~ 0). They are nominated for the organizer downfolding pipeline; I have not yet run QE on them, so no canonical N(E_F) is claimed here -- the nomination is based on chemistry and the C2DB metadata.
Rationale: the current top of the board is dominated by layered Fe/Cr halides and chalcogenides with high non-spin N(E_F) (e.g. Br2Fe2, Fe2I2, Cr2I2Se2). The list below extends the same chemical space (M = Mn, Cr, Co; X = I, Te, Se, S; plus Ta/Nb and Ga/Al spacers) into compositions that are not yet in the active set. Several are magnetic=Yes; per #61 they are scored with the canonical non-spin value, so the downfolding result -- not the magnetic ground state -- decides.
| # | material_id | C2DB uid | formula | atoms | magnetic | gap (PBE) | e_hull | family | C2DB page |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1MnAl2Te4-1 | 1MnAl2Te4-1 | Al2MnTe4 | 7 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.050 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/1MnAl2Te4-1 |
| 2 | 2AsCrTe3-1 | 2AsCrTe3-1 | As2Cr2Te6 | 10 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.035 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2AsCrTe3-1 |
| 3 | 2CoNbSe3-1 | 2CoNbSe3-1 | Co2Nb2Se6 | 10 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.016 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CoNbSe3-1 |
| 4 | 2CoNbTe3-1 | 2CoNbTe3-1 | Co2Nb2Te6 | 10 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.038 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CoNbTe3-1 |
| 5 | 2CoTa2Se5-1 | 2CoTa2Se5-1 | Co2Se10Ta4 | 16 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.000 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CoTa2Se5-1 |
| 6 | 2CoTaSe3-1 | 2CoTaSe3-1 | Co2Se6Ta2 | 10 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.012 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CoTaSe3-1 |
| 7 | 2CoTaTe3-1 | 2CoTaTe3-1 | Co2Ta2Te6 | 10 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.036 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CoTaTe3-1 |
| 8 | 1GeTe2Co3-1 | 1GeTe2Co3-1 | Co3GeTe2 | 6 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.027 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/1GeTe2Co3-1 |
| 9 | 2NbCo2Se3-1 | 2NbCo2Se3-1 | Co4Nb2Se6 | 12 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.033 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2NbCo2Se3-1 |
| 10 | 2NbCo2Te3-1 | 2NbCo2Te3-1 | Co4Nb2Te6 | 12 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.028 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2NbCo2Te3-1 |
| 11 | 1CoGa2Se4-1 | 1CoGa2Se4-1 | CoGa2Se4 | 7 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.026 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/1CoGa2Se4-1 |
| 12 | 1CoGa2Se4-2 | 1CoGa2Se4-2 | CoGa2Se4 | 7 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.027 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/1CoGa2Se4-2 |
| 13 | 2CrITe-1 | 2CrITe-1 | Cr2I2Te2 | 6 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.000 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CrITe-1 |
| 14 | 2CrNbSe5-1 | 2CrNbSe5-1 | Cr2Nb2Se10 | 14 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.005 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CrNbSe5-1 |
| 15 | 2CrTaSe5-1 | 2CrTaSe5-1 | Cr2Se10Ta2 | 14 | Yes | 0.000 | 0.004 | TMD | https://c2db.fysik.dtu.dk/material/2CrTaSe5-1 |
Notes:
- All 15 are absent from the current active table (so they enter as Discovery, per rule 1-2 of #61).
1CoGa2Se4-1and1CoGa2Se4-2are two polytypes of the same formula; I list both in case the downfolding differs.- If a candidate is already covered by an earlier proposal thread (#60, #63, #65, #66, #67), please treat this as a duplicate and keep the earlier one.
- Any canonical downfold is welcome; I will follow up with the QE numbers when my own SCF runs finish.
QE numbers for 2CrITe-1 (OSC-00546, Cr2I2Te2, 6 atoms) — our own SCF + the published pipeline/downfold.py:
- setting: PBE, non-spin, 6x6x1, pslibrary PAW 1.0.0, ecutwfc 40 Ry / ecutrho 320 Ry, conv_thr 1e-6
- SCF: 16 k-points, E_F = -0.3433 eV
- N(E_F) = 3.2394 states/eV/atom
- active band: n_band = 1.0528 -> delta_hole = -0.0528, t = 0.0467 eV
- estimated OSC index (canonical A_d at |delta| = 0.0556): 3.2394 x 0.04523 x 300 = 43.96
- pipeline cross-check: the same setup reproduces the organizer value for 2BrFe-1 (Br2Fe2), N(E_F) = 4.096 vs the published 4.081 (+0.4%)
Caveats: our non-spin SCF lands slightly above half filling, so the sign of delta differs from the active-table convention; I used |delta| for the A_d lookup (particle-hole symmetry). Magnetic=Yes material, run non-spin per the canonical convention (#61). The number is provisional -- please re-downfold canonically.
QE numbers for 2AsCrTe3-1 (OSC-00441, As2Cr2Te6, 10 atoms) — same setup as the previous message:
- PBE, non-spin, 6x6x1, pslibrary PAW 1.0.0, ecutwfc 40 Ry / ecutrho 320 Ry, conv_thr 1e-6
- SCF: 20 k-points, E_F = -0.445 eV
- N(E_F) = 2.2358 states/eV/atom
- active band: n_band = 1.1209 -> delta_hole = -0.1209, t = 0.0481 eV
- estimated OSC index (canonical A_d at |delta| = 0.1111): 2.2358 x 0.04726 x 300 = 31.70
Same caveats: non-spin canonical convention (magnetic=Yes), |delta| used for the A_d lookup, provisional -- to be replaced by the organizer canonical downfold.
Attribution note for this thread: 2CrITe-1 (Cr2I2Te2, OSC-00546) was already submitted by our account (1Dmeds) in PR #19 on 2026-10-02 (file 1Dmeds_OSC-00546.json, non-spin QE PBE 6x6x1, provisional index under our same-band rule). Per the first-proposer rule in #49, could the canonical result for this id be credited to the earliest PR carrying it (#19)? We have no objection to it being downfolded now. Thank you.
Thank you for the nominations and the QE numbers, sdoygb, and for the attribution note, 1Dmeds. The candidates are queued for canonical downfolding; the result will be posted in #49. On OSC-00546 (Cr2I2Te2): PR #19 (2026-10-02) is the earliest proposal carrying this id, so first-proposer credit follows #19 under the rule in #49.