Discovery proposal: Mn2Se2 (OSC-00689) — unmeasured magnetic-chalcogenide cell of the p4/nmm M2X2 family; downfold request

#76
by PhD-Shin - opened
submissions/PhD-Shin_Mn2Se2_discovery.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "author": "PhD-Shin",
3
+ "material_id": "2MnSe-1",
4
+ "osc_id": "OSC-00689",
5
+ "formula": "Mn2Se2",
6
+ "method_name": "Discovery: p4/nmm M2X2 magnetic-chalcogenide cell",
7
+ "provisional_score": 8.538,
8
+ "verified": false,
9
+ "nef": 0.7403,
10
+ "A_dwave": 0.03844,
11
+ "track": "discovery",
12
+ "claimed": true,
13
+ "note": "Discovery proposal, not in the active set. THIS IS A LOWER BOUND, NOT AN ESTIMATE, AND NOT A RANK CLAIM -- the purpose of this entry is to request an organizer downfold of a position your active set has never sampled. Within the p4/nmm 2:2 slot of the active table, split by anion type and magnetism, three cells are populated and one is empty: chalcogenide/non-magnetic (n=9, nef 0.461-1.419, t 0.128-0.259 eV), halide/non-magnetic (n=2, nef 0.447-0.552, t 0.216-0.241 eV), halide/MAGNETIC (n=3, nef 2.391-4.081, t 0.022-0.053 eV), and chalcogenide/MAGNETIC (n=0). Mn2Se2 falls in the empty cell, so no family regression over the published table can predict it -- there is no comparator in that cell. Physical reason to measure it: the published pipeline runs a non-spin-polarized pw.x SCF, so in a magnetic material the suppressed exchange splitting leaves a narrow, partly filled d manifold pinned at E_F; the three magnetic members of this slot indeed have 4-10x smaller t than the non-magnetic ones. Mn is d5 (exactly half-filled 3d), the strongest form of that condition, and Se widens the Mn-Mn separation relative to S (measured in-family: Fe2Se2 0.793 > Fe2S2 0.560; Ni2Se2 1.308 > Ni2S2 1.129). 2MnSe-1 is the more stable of the two C2DB Mn2Se2 polymorphs (e_hull 0.038 vs 0.114), metallic (gap_pbe 0.0), magnetic, 4 atoms per cell, sc_relevance 0.75, and no Mn2Se2 polymorph is in the active set. The claimed numbers are a deliberate floor: nef = 0.7403 is the MINIMUM nef among the active p4/nmm M2Se2 members (2ScSe-2), all of which are non-magnetic, and A_d = 0.03844 is the lowest value on the dome plateau (Ne=36). Please downfold it with the published pipeline and replace these claimed values with the real ones."
14
+ }