text stringlengths 0 596 |
|---|
initial β C1 |
C1 β C2 |
C2 β C3 |
C3 β C4 |
where: |
* `initial β C1` evaluates the complete mechanical execution of C1. |
* `A β B` jointly evaluates the mechanical interaction from A to B and the complete execution of B. |
Do not evaluate A's own execution again in `A β B`. |
Thus, each component execution and each transition are evaluated exactly once. |
--- |
## A. MECHANISM EXECUTION |
For the target component of each segment, check whether: |
* it correctly and sufficiently completes its specified `action`; |
* motion type, direction, range, magnitude, and resulting state are mechanically appropriate; |
* its response is physically consistent with the incoming interaction; |
* pivots, hinges, axes, and connected parts behave correctly; |
* motion remains continuous without teleportation, detachment, abnormal deformation, or interpenetration; |
* it genuinely performs its intended mechanical function rather than merely moving. |
* Necessary passive auxiliary structures are allowed, but auxiliary structures that artificially reduce the difficulty of achieving the intended mechanical behavior should be penalized. For example, adding side walls to a ramp solely to prevent the ball from falling off simplifies the required mechanical construction. |
Do not give a high score merely because a component visibly moves. Its motion must correctly perform its specified `action` and obey basic physical and mechanical principles. |
### Domino Chain |
A Domino Chain should exhibit genuine sequential propagation: |
Incoming Object β First Domino β Second Domino β ... β Final Domino |
The incoming object should primarily trigger the first domino, and each later domino should be triggered primarily by the preceding domino. |
Lower the corresponding ECM segment score if multiple dominoes are directly triggered by the incoming object, fall independently or simultaneously, or otherwise fail to exhibit clear domino-by-domino propagation. |
Do not judge correctness merely by whether all dominoes eventually fall. |
--- |
## B. CAUSAL CONNECTIVITY |
For each `A β B`, determine whether A successfully triggers B through a real, effective, and physically plausible mechanical interaction: |
A produces mechanical output |
β the output physically reaches and acts on B |
β B responds because of that interaction. |
Check whether: |
* A produces an output capable of triggering B; |
* the output physically reaches and acts on B; |
* B responds after and because of A; |
* positions, directions, distances, and motion ranges support the interaction; |
* contact, collision, catching, release, connection, or mechanical transmission is physically plausible; |
* there is no unexplained remote triggering, teleportation, interpenetration-based triggering, premature triggering, or implausible energy transfer. |
Temporal order alone is not sufficient evidence of causality. |
As an auxiliary causal test, ask: |
**If A's mechanical action were removed, would B still execute in essentially the same way?** |
If clearly yes, A may have been bypassed and the corresponding ECM segment score should be reduced. |
--- |
## C. CAUSAL CHAIN BREAK RULE |
The system must form one continuous chain: |
initial β C1 β C2 β ... β CN |
If the chain fails at a segment: |
1. Score the failing segment according to the degree of successful interaction and target-component execution actually observed. |
2. If the failure prevents continuous mechanical propagation from reaching downstream components, **all subsequent segments must receive 0**. |
3. Later independent motion of downstream components cannot restore their scores. |
For example, if C2 fails to successfully trigger C3: |
* `initial β C1`: score normally |
* `C1 β C2`: score normally |
* `C2 β C3`: score according to observed partial success |
* `C3 β C4` and all later segments: **0** |
Only components reached through continuous mechanical propagation from `initial` are eligible for non-zero downstream segment scores. |
--- |
## D. SEGMENT SCORING |
For `initial β A`, evaluate A's complete execution. |
For `A β B`, jointly evaluate: |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.