GAO-Appropriations / README.md
Kmisener's picture
Upload 2 files
11cf914 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
10.8 kB
---
license: other
license_name: us-government-work
license_link: https://www.gao.gov/about/website-policies
language:
- en
pretty_name: GAO Appropriations Law (Fiscal Law) Decisions
size_categories:
- 10K<n<100K
task_categories:
- text-retrieval
- text-classification
- question-answering
tags:
- legal
- government
- appropriations
- fiscal-law
- us-federal
configs:
- config_name: default
data_files: gao_appropriations_corpus.jsonl
dataset_info:
config_name: default
features:
- name: url
dtype: string
- name: file_slug
dtype: string
- name: title
dtype: string
- name: b_numbers
dtype: string
- name: decision_date
dtype: string
- name: decision_year
dtype: int64
- name: released_date
dtype: string
- name: agency
dtype: string
- name: subject
dtype: string
- name: requester
dtype: string
- name: pillars
sequence: string
- name: doctrines
sequence: string
- name: statutes
sequence: string
- name: conclusion
dtype: string
- name: digest
dtype: string
- name: highlights
dtype: string
- name: text_source
dtype: string
- name: text_noise_pct
dtype: float64
- name: text_quality
dtype: string
- name: pdf_file
dtype: string
- name: text
dtype: string
splits:
- name: train
num_bytes: 551999106
num_examples: 67246
---
# GAO Appropriations Law (Fiscal Law) Decisions
**67,246 decisions of the U.S. Comptroller General and the Government
Accountability Office on the availability of appropriations — purpose, time
and amount — spanning 1922 to 2026.** 481.2M characters of full decision
text, mean 7,156 characters per decision.
This is the complete published `Appropriations Decision` series as GAO's own
catalogue defines it, not a sample.
## Loading
```python
from datasets import load_dataset
ds = load_dataset("Kmisener/GAO-Appropriations", split="train")
print(ds[0]["title"], ds[0]["decision_year"])
```
The schema is declared explicitly in this card's `features` block. That is
deliberate and load-bearing: several columns (`decision_date`, `conclusion`,
`requester`, `agency`, `digest`) are null for the first thousands of rows
because the corpus is ordered oldest-first and those fields come from section
headings that pre-1995 decisions do not use. Without an explicit schema,
Arrow infers them as null from the first block and then fails on the first
real value with `Column(/decision_date) changed from null to string`.
## Coverage, and what is deliberately not here
Pass 1 enumerated the catalogue in 702 date slices, each verified against the
item count GAO prints for it: **702 slices, 68,087 items, 0 short**. Pass 2
fetched **68,132 of 68,138** indexed URLs, or 99.99%; the 6 missing are dead
`-0` slugs that returned nothing on two attempts. 886 decisions with under
500 characters of text were then dropped, leaving 67,246.
**This covers one leaf of GAO's `ctype_search` taxonomy.** GAO's legal output
is a two-level tree, and `Appropriations Decision` is one branch of it:
| branch | items | here |
|---|---|---|
| `Appropriations Decision` | 68,086 | **yes, all of it** |
| `Antideficiency Act Report` | 23 | no |
| `Federal Agency Major Rule Report` — Congressional Review Act | 2,197 | no |
| `Other Decision` — includes CRA legal opinions | 503 | no |
| `Legal Other Written Product` | 2,297 | no |
| `Bid Protest Decision` | 33,292 | separate dataset |
**Congressional Review Act material is not in this dataset.** CRA compliance
reports on major rules live under `Federal Agency Major Rule Report`, and —
more easily missed — CRA *legal opinions* are filed under `Other Decision`,
whose first result is "U.S. Department of Education—Applicability of the
Congressional Review Act". Those opinions read like appropriations decisions
and reason about whether something is a rule under CRA, but GAO does not
classify them as appropriations decisions.
## The corpus is broader than "fiscal law"
`Appropriations Decision` carries the whole historical Comptroller General
decision series, not only fiscal-law questions. Measured by vocabulary over
all records: about 36% use appropriations vocabulary at all, about 16% carry
a strong bid-protest signal, and roughly half match neither — they are older
decisions on claims, military and civilian pay, travel allowances and
similar.
So **topic filters, not the file itself, define a fiscal-law dataset**:
```python
# the practical fiscal-law subset: 21,560 decisions (32.1%)
fiscal = ds.filter(lambda r: len(r["doctrines"]) > 0)
# stricter -- a named doctrine AND a statutory citation: 8,032 (11.9%)
strict = ds.filter(lambda r: r["doctrines"] and r["statutes"])
```
`statutes` alone is non-empty for 18,043 records (26.8%).
## Schema
| field | type | populated | notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| `url` | string | 100% | canonical gao.gov product URL |
| `file_slug` | string | 100% | on-disk stem, e.g. `b-155290` |
| `title` | string | 100% | |
| `b_numbers` | string | 100% | e.g. `B-336373` |
| `subject` | string | 100% | the title, or its right-hand side |
| `highlights` | string | 100% | GAO's own summary or published digest |
| `text` | string | 100% | **the complete decision**, footnotes and signature included |
| `text_source` | string | 100% | `page` (60,313) or `pdf` (6,933) |
| `text_noise_pct` | float64 | 100% | share of characters that look like OCR noise |
| `decision_year` | int64 | 97.7% | falls back to published/released date |
| `released_date` | string | 58.1% | |
| `doctrines` | list\<string\> | 32.1% non-empty | named rules used **or merely cited** |
| `statutes` | list\<string\> | 26.8% non-empty | normalised, e.g. `31 U.S.C. § 1502(a)` |
| `pdf_file` | string | 11.5% | GAO hosts PDFs only for recent decisions |
| `pillars` | list\<string\> | 5.0% non-empty | 3,392 records: `purpose` (2,516), `time` (609), `amount` (668) |
| `digest` | string | 3.4% | from a `DIGEST` heading |
| `agency` | string | 1.6% | from the title, before the em dash |
| `requester` | string | 1.5% | congressional requests only (`The Honorable …`) |
| `text_quality` | string | 1.3% | `ocr_suspect` where set (855 records) |
| `conclusion` | string | 0.9% | GAO's own `CONCLUSION` section, verbatim |
| `decision_date` | string | 0.4% | from a `Date:` line — **not reliably a bare date**, see below |
### Why the low rates are not a defect
The corpus' centre of gravity is far older than people expect: 1920s 2,214;
1930s 3,366; 1940s 3,320; 1950s 9,937; 1960s 12,420; 1970s 10,046; 1980s
15,095; 1990s 7,705 — and only 1,606 decisions after 2000.
`agency`, `decision_date`, `digest` and `conclusion` all depend on
conventions that are recent: an `<entity>—<question>` title, a `Date:` line,
a `DIGEST` or `CONCLUSION` heading. Pre-1995 decisions use none of them.
Titles are instead `B-228838 Sep 16 1987`, or a bracketed abstract, or a
plain sentence. **Do not filter a historical subset by `agency`** — it will
silently drop almost everything. Use `doctrines`, `statutes` or a text
match, which work across every era.
`highlights` is the field to read for historical decisions: it is 100%
populated and carries GAO's own published digest.
### Four things to know before trusting a field
1. **`doctrines` is a search index, not a set of holdings.** A hit means the
decision used the phrase or cited the statute, not that GAO decided on
that ground. A single bona fide needs case will also mention the
Antideficiency Act and the recording statute. Use it to narrow, then read.
2. **There is deliberately no `outcome` field.** Appropriations decisions
answer a legal question in prose, and the answer is routinely split
("AOC properly obligated its FY 2023 funds … AOC may not use its annual
appropriation for X"). On the sibling protest corpus, a classifier reading
the end of each decision agreed with GAO's own labels only 48% of the
time. Read `conclusion`, which is GAO's words, and label it yourself
against a hand-checked sample.
3. **The page, not the PDF, is the better text source** — the reverse of what
you would expect. GAO hosts full-report PDFs only for recent decisions;
the old ones are scans with poor OCR ("COMP TflOLLE\"R GENERAL"). The old
*pages* are clean keyed text. 855 records are flagged `ocr_suspect`.
4. **`decision_date` is not reliably a bare date — do not parse it blindly.**
Of the 272 records where it is set, 199 (73.2%) parse as a date. The other
73 over-captured the lines following GAO's `Date:` field, producing values
like `"September 29, 1988 To: Judgment Group Manager, Claims/GGD-Kenneth
Schutt Attention: Rufus Hill"`. Use `decision_year` (97.7%, an integer)
for anything chronological, and treat `decision_date` as a text hint. The
leading date is correct in every polluted value inspected, so a
leading-date regex recovers it if you need the day.
## Known limitations
- 6 decisions in GAO's catalogue have no page and are absent; each was
attempted twice.
- 886 decisions with under 500 characters of text were dropped from this cut.
They exist in GAO's catalogue.
- GAO's printed item counts run 1–4 above what pagination returns, so the
catalogue total drifts by a handful day to day as GAO publishes.
- Text is GAO's HTML body only — no navigation, footer or related-links
furniture ever entered it. GAO's protective-order notice is stripped; it is
a protest artifact and is rare here.
- `decision_year` is absent for 1,537 records that carry no usable date in
any of the three date fields.
## Provenance
Scraped from www.gao.gov between 2026-10-26 and 2026-11-05 directly from
GAO's own faceted search (`ctype_search:Appropriations Decision`), one page
snapshot and one PDF per decision retained, with every structured field
re-derived offline from the saved HTML. Enumeration was date-sliced and every
slice reconciled against the count GAO prints for it, because paging the
catalogue flat leaks about 3% of results through unstable ordering.
Crawl pacing was deliberately conservative and GAO's published rate limits
were respected.
## License
GAO decisions are works of the United States Government and are not subject
to copyright protection in the United States (17 U.S.C. § 105). This
compilation adds no additional restrictions. Attribution to the U.S.
Government Accountability Office is appropriate but not legally required.
## Citation
```bibtex
@misc{gao_appropriations_decisions,
title = {GAO Appropriations Law (Fiscal Law) Decisions},
author = {U.S. Government Accountability Office},
note = {Compiled corpus of 67,246 decisions, 1920--2026},
year = {2026}
}
```