TylerZ0931's picture
Update README.md
e95ffeb verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
9.22 kB
metadata
license: cc-by-4.0
language: en
tags:
  - personality
  - preference
  - personalization
  - memory

Dataset For Paper "Can LLMs Discern the Traits Influencing Your Preferences? Evaluating Personality-Driven Preference Alignment in LLMs"

PACIFIC (Preference Alignment for Choices Inference via Five-factor Identity Characterization) is a psychometrics-grounded dataset for studying whether Large Language Models can use stable personality traits — rather than exhaustive preference logs — as a latent signal for inferring user preferences on unseen queries.

It contains 1,200 preference–query pairs across 20 everyday domains, each with four candidate answers and full Big-Five (OCEAN) annotations on both the stated preference and every answer choice. The dataset is balanced so that all ten high/low trait directions are evenly represented (120 pairs each),

Why this dataset

As user history grows, models get worse at following stated preferences — prior work reports preference-following accuracy falling below 10% after ~10 turns. Humans do the opposite: they abstract many small observations into a stable sense of a person and generalize from it. PACIFIC operationalizes that idea by asking whether Big-Five traits can serve as a compact latent representation that connects preferences across domains through shared psychometric alignment rather than surface-level topical similarity.

Each item is deliberately constructed as a hard case: with the preference removed, a strong LLM scores at roughly chance (25%), because all four options look equally reasonable from the query alone. The correct answer only becomes clear once the user's personality-driven preference is known.

Dataset structure

Single split, JSON format:

Split train
Rows 1,200
Trait directions 10 (High/Low × O, C, E, A, N), 120 rows each
Domains 20
Size ~17.6 MB
Language English

Fields

Field Type Description
trait string Target Big-Five direction for the item, e.g. High Openness, Low Neuroticism (one of the ten).
topic string Domain the scenario belongs to, e.g. Home_Cooking, Personal_Finance (one of 20).
preference string The user's personality-driven preference statement.
question string The preference-sensitive user query. Answerable in general, but a generic answer tends to violate the preference.
explanation string Difficulty rationale: why a default/"safe" response would fail to respect the preference.
options list[string] The four candidate response texts (plain strings).
preference_statement dict Full OCEAN annotation of the preference (see below).
choices list[dict] The four candidate answers with per-choice OCEAN annotations.
ground_truth_choice_id int Index of the preference-adhering choice.

Nested annotation schema

Both preference_statement and each element of choices carry Big-Five annotations produced during dataset construction:

// preference_statement
{
  "text": "I find following traditional recipes step-by-step incredibly stifling ...",
  "related_to_personality": 1,
  "openness": 7,
  "openness_explanation": "The user's preference for improvising with 'avant-garde' combinations ...",
  // ... conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, neuroticism,
  //     each with an integer score (1–7 Likert) and a matching *_explanation
}
// one entry in choices[]
{
  "choice_id": 0,
  "text": "Use a basic apple pie framework but innovate by infusing ...",
  "related_to_personality": 1,
  "openness": 7,
  "openness_explanation": "The user explicitly wants to innovate ...",
  // ... remaining OCEAN traits with scores + explanations
}

Trait scores use a 7-point Likert scale (1 = very low expression, 7 = very high). For downstream label mapping the paper discretizes these as low (<4), *high* (>4), or unclear (=4). See the paper's supplement for the exact annotation rubric, including per-trait confidence weighting.

⚠️ Evaluation: option ordering

In the released items the preference-adhering option is generated first (ground_truth_choice_id is 0, i.e. choices[0]), with the three distractors following. When evaluating a model, shuffle the option order per item (and re-map the ground truth) to avoid rewarding position bias. Also note the dataset stores a 0-based ground-truth index; if you follow the paper's prompt format, which asks the model to return an integer in {1,2,3,4}, convert accordingly.

Intended uses

  • Preference-following / personalization evaluation — can a model apply a latent preference constraint instead of defaulting to generic helpfulness?
  • Cross-domain preference inference — testing whether trait-aligned preferences from other domains help answer a query whose preference was never explicitly stated.
  • Personality-informed retrieval — building and evaluating retrievers that surface trait-consistent context (e.g. the paper's persona-aware contrastive retriever, PiRAG).
  • Trait prediction from behavior — predicting OCEAN traits from preferences or from chosen answers.

Dataset creation

Items were synthesized with Gemini 2.5 Pro over the 20-topic taxonomy shared with PrefEval, but anchored to psychometric traits so coverage is balanced across all ten high/low directions rather than derived directly from topics.

Generation. For each item the pipeline produces a personality-driven preference, a preference-sensitive query, a difficulty rationale, and four candidate responses (one adhering, three plausible-but-misaligned distractors). A High-Violation constraint forces queries where a generic answer is likely to break the stated preference, so surface keyword matching is insufficient.

Annotation. Every preference and every choice is scored on all five OCEAN dimensions using a Dual-Strategy Annotation Protocol:

  • Mirroring strategy (O, C, E, A) — grounded in Self-Congruity Theory; high-trait users are annotated toward preferences that reinforce that trait (e.g. a highly Open user favors novelty/complexity).
  • Compensatory strategy (N) — Neuroticism is annotated along a Safety vs. Efficiency trade-off, since high-N users seek reassurance/predictability rather than "more neurotic" experiences, while low-N users prioritize efficiency.

Quality control. An independent judge model (GPT-4o-mini) retained only items where the ground truth optimally aligns with the preference while all distractors violate or ignore it, and where the preference logically reflects its assigned trait. A confidence threshold (τ = 0.7) filters uncertain pairs.

Human validation. 15 annotators from varied professional backgrounds completed a Big-Five test, then validated items matched to their own dominant trait. On trait-matched choice selection they reached ~78% average accuracy with high inter-annotator agreement (Fleiss' κ ≈ 0.86), and reported a 91% approval rate that the ground-truth option was the best fit. The automated evaluator agreed strongly with the human consensus (Cohen's κ ≈ 0.92).

Baseline findings (from the paper)

  • With the preference withheld, models sit near chance (~25%), confirming the distractors are genuinely hard.
  • Trait-aligned preference context substantially outperforms mixed-trait context, and adding unrelated preferences (contamination) reduces accuracy — organizing history by shared traits helps; raw volume does not (expanding mixed context from 5→25 preferences slightly hurt accuracy).
  • Given clean trait-aligned context, strong models approach ceiling (Gemini-2.5-Pro up to ~99%), indicating the bottleneck is context construction / retrieval, not reasoning.
  • Without trait labels, a plain dense retriever reaches ~30% while persona-aware contrastive fine-tuning (PiRAG) raises label-free accuracy to ~43%.
  • A social-desirability bias appears when predicting traits about users: models identify "high" traits well but collapse on "low" directions, likely an RLHF artifact.

Limitations

  • Traits are simplified to binary High/Low rather than continuous Likert values.

  • Evaluation is multiple-choice QA, not open-ended generation.

  • Preferences and manifestations are treated as culture- and language-independent (English only).

  • Content is LLM-synthesized (with human validation), so residual generator artifacts may remain.

  • 🔬 QA survey / demo: https://tylazhao.github.io/pacific-survey/

Note: Full multi-turn conversations for each preference and expanded usage examples are planned additions to the repo.

Please email tzhao15@uci.edu if you are interested in this project.

If you find this work useful, please cite our paper:

@article{zhao2026can,
  title={Can LLMs Discern the Traits Influencing Your Preferences? Evaluating Personality-Driven Preference Alignment in LLMs},
  author={Zhao, Tianyu and Li, Siqi and Shoukry, Yasser and Elmalaki, Salma},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.07181},
  year={2026}
}