PhaaNe's picture
KGGuard+W checkpoints, scores, data, caches and references (code commit 3616af2) (part 10)
2f94d1e verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
30.3 kB
# Robustness of the final method (E6)
Design split: mean over 3 seeds. Fresh splits: mean over splits, and how many splits the variant is *better* than the default.
## 1. Hyper-parameter sensitivity (test AP; dAP vs default; CV dAP = same change on the cross-fit estimate)
| variant | dbpedia_accuracy AP | dbpedia_accuracy dAP | dbpedia_accuracy CV dAP | dbpedia_accuracy ms dAP | dbpedia_accuracy ms better | factbench AP | factbench dAP | factbench CV dAP | factbench ms dAP | factbench ms better |
|:----------------------------------------------------------|----------------------:|-----------------------:|--------------------------:|--------------------------:|:-----------------------------|---------------:|----------------:|-------------------:|-------------------:|:----------------------|
| default (final configuration) | 0.4697 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0/5 |
| calibration bins = 5 | 0.4657 | -0.004 | -0.0015 | -0.0045 | 1/5 | 0.9285 | 0.0001 | -0.0151 | -0.0074 | 1/5 |
| calibration bins = 20 | 0.4741 | 0.0043 | -0.0013 | -0.0023 | 1/5 | 0.9311 | 0.0026 | -0.0022 | 0.0019 | 5/5 |
| smoothing kappa = 5 | 0.4709 | 0.0011 | -0.0015 | -0.0004 | 1/5 | 0.9289 | 0.0004 | 0.0004 | -0.0002 | 1/5 |
| smoothing kappa = 50 | 0.4699 | 0.0002 | 0.001 | 0.001 | 4/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | -0.0001 | -0.0002 | 2/5 |
| cross-fit folds k = 3 | 0.4718 | 0.0021 | 0.0038 | 0.0018 | 3/5 | 0.9283 | -0.0002 | -0.0049 | -0.0002 | 2/5 |
| cross-fit folds k = 10 | 0.4666 | -0.0031 | 0.0006 | 0.0024 | 4/5 | 0.9286 | 0.0001 | 0.0003 | 0.0005 | 3/5 |
| fold assignment seed = 1 | 0.4746 | 0.0048 | 0.0096 | -0.0046 | 1/5 | 0.9276 | -0.0009 | -0.0004 | 0.0001 | 2/5 |
| fold assignment seed = 2 | 0.4635 | -0.0062 | 0.0065 | -0.0033 | 1/5 | 0.929 | 0.0006 | -0.0046 | -0.0003 | 2/5 |
| in-sample prior as calibration reference (no out-of-fold) | 0.4745 | 0.0048 | 0.002 | 0.002 | 3/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | 0.0003 | 0.0001 | 3/5 |
| GAM learning_rate = 0.025 | 0.4638 | -0.0059 | -0.0039 | -0.0035 | 0/5 | 0.9275 | -0.001 | -0.0012 | -0.0012 | 1/5 |
| GAM learning_rate = 0.1 | 0.4725 | 0.0028 | 0.0017 | 0.001 | 4/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | -0.0007 | -0.0001 | 3/5 |
| GAM max_iter = 150 | 0.464 | -0.0058 | -0.0038 | -0.0035 | 0/5 | 0.9275 | -0.0009 | -0.0012 | -0.0013 | 1/5 |
| GAM max_iter = 600 | 0.4728 | 0.0031 | 0.0017 | 0.001 | 4/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | -0.0007 | -0.0001 | 3/5 |
| GAM max_leaf_nodes = 4 | 0.4672 | -0.0025 | 0.0007 | -0.0007 | 1/5 | 0.9276 | -0.0009 | -0.0003 | 0 | 3/5 |
| GAM max_leaf_nodes = 16 | 0.4698 | 0.0001 | -0 | 0 | 2/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | 0 | -0 | 2/5 |
| GAM min_samples_leaf = 20 | 0.4721 | 0.0023 | 0.0076 | 0.0003 | 2/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | -0.0001 | -0 | 0/5 |
| GAM min_samples_leaf = 80 | 0.4699 | 0.0001 | -0.0003 | -0.0004 | 2/5 | 0.9285 | 0 | 0 | 0.0001 | 4/5 |
| GAM l2_regularization = 0 | 0.4701 | 0.0004 | 0.0002 | -0.0003 | 1/5 | 0.9291 | 0.0006 | 0 | 0.0002 | 4/5 |
| GAM l2_regularization = 5 | 0.4684 | -0.0013 | -0.0009 | -0.0005 | 2/5 | 0.9274 | -0.0011 | 0 | -0.0001 | 1/5 |
| GAM without monotone constraints | 0.4634 | -0.0063 | -0.0022 | -0.0111 | 0/5 | 0.9429 | 0.0144 | 0.022 | 0.0225 | 5/5 |
## 2. Missing-evidence strategy (AP; 'X missing (natural)' = test facts whose source X is missing in the data)
| | ('dbpedia_accuracy', 'design') | ('dbpedia_accuracy', 'fresh splits') | ('factbench', 'design') | ('factbench', 'fresh splits') |
|:-----------------------------------------------|---------------------------------:|---------------------------------------:|--------------------------:|--------------------------------:|
| ('C missing (natural)', 'GBDT reference') | 0.6301 | 0.5971 | nan | nan |
| ('C missing (natural)', 'correct') | 0.5726 | 0.572 | nan | nan |
| ('C missing (natural)', 'mean') | 0.5823 | 0.5742 | nan | nan |
| ('C missing (natural)', 'native') | 0.6002 | 0.5795 | nan | nan |
| ('C missing (natural)', 'zero (proposed)') | 0.5846 | 0.5755 | nan | nan |
| ('S missing (natural)', 'GBDT reference') | nan | nan | 0.9718 | nan |
| ('S missing (natural)', 'correct') | nan | nan | 0.5355 | nan |
| ('S missing (natural)', 'mean') | nan | nan | 0.6141 | nan |
| ('S missing (natural)', 'native') | nan | nan | 0.9235 | nan |
| ('S missing (natural)', 'zero (proposed)') | nan | nan | 0.6133 | nan |
| ('S_sup missing (natural)', 'GBDT reference') | 0.6137 | 0.541 | nan | nan |
| ('S_sup missing (natural)', 'correct') | 0.5976 | 0.5357 | nan | nan |
| ('S_sup missing (natural)', 'mean') | 0.6161 | 0.5296 | nan | nan |
| ('S_sup missing (natural)', 'native') | 0.6191 | 0.5365 | nan | nan |
| ('S_sup missing (natural)', 'zero (proposed)') | 0.6214 | 0.5329 | nan | nan |
| ('T missing (natural)', 'GBDT reference') | nan | 0.475 | 0.9164 | 0.9429 |
| ('T missing (natural)', 'correct') | nan | 0.5 | 0.7967 | 0.7476 |
| ('T missing (natural)', 'mean') | nan | 0.4513 | 0.8279 | 0.7965 |
| ('T missing (natural)', 'native') | nan | 0.4914 | 0.8514 | 0.8239 |
| ('T missing (natural)', 'zero (proposed)') | nan | 0.4509 | 0.8307 | 0.7953 |
| ('W missing (natural)', 'GBDT reference') | nan | nan | 0.9956 | 1 |
| ('W missing (natural)', 'correct') | nan | nan | 0.9986 | 0.9985 |
| ('W missing (natural)', 'mean') | nan | nan | 0.9929 | 0.9882 |
| ('W missing (natural)', 'native') | nan | nan | 0.9925 | 0.9836 |
| ('W missing (natural)', 'zero (proposed)') | nan | nan | 0.9936 | 0.9882 |
| ('all', 'GBDT reference') | 0.4943 | 0.5019 | 0.9814 | 0.9836 |
| ('all', 'correct') | 0.4615 | 0.49 | 0.9039 | 0.894 |
| ('all', 'mean') | 0.4672 | 0.4937 | 0.9288 | 0.9276 |
| ('all', 'native') | 0.4755 | 0.497 | 0.9511 | 0.9526 |
| ('all', 'zero (proposed)') | 0.4697 | 0.4945 | 0.9285 | 0.928 |
## 3. Test-time source dropout, frozen models (dAP vs the same model without dropout; design split and fresh splits pooled)
| | dbpedia_accuracy dAP | factbench dAP | dbpedia_accuracy AP | factbench AP |
|:----------------------------------|-----------------------:|----------------:|----------------------:|---------------:|
| ('C', 0.1, 'correct') | 0.0005 | -0.0035 | 0.4798 | 0.8942 |
| ('C', 0.1, 'mean') | 0.0003 | -0.0012 | 0.484 | 0.9268 |
| ('C', 0.1, 'native') | 0.0003 | -0.0011 | 0.4893 | 0.9509 |
| ('C', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | 0.0003 | -0.0019 | 0.4855 | 0.9262 |
| ('C', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0003 | -0.0058 | 0.479 | 0.8919 |
| ('C', 0.3, 'mean') | 0.0003 | -0.0029 | 0.484 | 0.9251 |
| ('C', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0006 | -0.0024 | 0.4884 | 0.9496 |
| ('C', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0004 | -0.0035 | 0.4848 | 0.9246 |
| ('C', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0011 | -0.0091 | 0.4783 | 0.8886 |
| ('C', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0003 | -0.0051 | 0.4835 | 0.9229 |
| ('C', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0007 | -0.0029 | 0.4883 | 0.9491 |
| ('C', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0009 | -0.0055 | 0.4843 | 0.9226 |
| ('C', 1.0, 'correct') | -0.0009 | -0.0158 | 0.4785 | 0.8818 |
| ('C', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.0003 | -0.0099 | 0.4834 | 0.9182 |
| ('C', 1.0, 'native') | -0.0005 | -0.0053 | 0.4884 | 0.9467 |
| ('C', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0007 | -0.01 | 0.4845 | 0.9182 |
| ('M', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.0008 | -0.0017 | 0.4785 | 0.896 |
| ('M', 0.1, 'mean') | -0.0002 | 0.0001 | 0.4835 | 0.9282 |
| ('M', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0014 | 0 | 0.4876 | 0.952 |
| ('M', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0001 | 0.0002 | 0.4851 | 0.9283 |
| ('M', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0019 | -0.0034 | 0.4774 | 0.8943 |
| ('M', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.0002 | -0.0007 | 0.4835 | 0.9274 |
| ('M', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0047 | -0.0006 | 0.4843 | 0.9514 |
| ('M', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0004 | -0.0006 | 0.4848 | 0.9275 |
| ('M', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0026 | -0.0032 | 0.4768 | 0.8945 |
| ('M', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0005 | -0.0008 | 0.4832 | 0.9272 |
| ('M', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0055 | -0.001 | 0.4835 | 0.951 |
| ('M', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0002 | -0.0007 | 0.485 | 0.9274 |
| ('M', 1.0, 'correct') | 0.0002 | -0.0029 | 0.4796 | 0.8948 |
| ('M', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.0002 | -0.0031 | 0.4835 | 0.9249 |
| ('M', 1.0, 'native') | -0 | -0.0028 | 0.4889 | 0.9493 |
| ('M', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | 0.0001 | -0.003 | 0.4853 | 0.9251 |
| ('N', 0.1, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0005 | -0.0007 | 0.4986 | 0.9821 |
| ('N', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.0019 | -0.0045 | 0.4774 | 0.8932 |
| ('N', 0.1, 'mean') | 0.0001 | -0.0008 | 0.4838 | 0.9272 |
| ('N', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0019 | -0.0006 | 0.4871 | 0.9514 |
| ('N', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | 0.0002 | -0.0008 | 0.4854 | 0.9274 |
| ('N', 0.3, 'GBDT reference') | -0.006 | -0.002 | 0.493 | 0.9808 |
| ('N', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0129 | -0.0158 | 0.4665 | 0.8819 |
| ('N', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.004 | -0.0027 | 0.4797 | 0.9253 |
| ('N', 0.3, 'native') | -0.013 | -0.0016 | 0.476 | 0.9505 |
| ('N', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0035 | -0.0026 | 0.4817 | 0.9255 |
| ('N', 0.5, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0106 | -0.0021 | 0.4885 | 0.9807 |
| ('N', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0136 | -0.0219 | 0.4658 | 0.8757 |
| ('N', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0034 | -0.0039 | 0.4803 | 0.9242 |
| ('N', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0144 | -0.0019 | 0.4745 | 0.9502 |
| ('N', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0028 | -0.0035 | 0.4825 | 0.9246 |
| ('N', 1.0, 'GBDT reference') | -0.016 | -0.004 | 0.4831 | 0.9788 |
| ('N', 1.0, 'correct') | -0.0068 | -0.0142 | 0.4725 | 0.8834 |
| ('N', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.005 | -0.0063 | 0.4787 | 0.9217 |
| ('N', 1.0, 'native') | -0.0052 | -0.0031 | 0.4837 | 0.9489 |
| ('N', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0036 | -0.0061 | 0.4817 | 0.922 |
| ('S', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.003 | -0.0001 | 0.4763 | 0.8976 |
| ('S', 0.1, 'mean') | -0.0012 | 0 | 0.4825 | 0.928 |
| ('S', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0009 | -0.0009 | 0.488 | 0.9512 |
| ('S', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0012 | 0 | 0.484 | 0.9281 |
| ('S', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0045 | -0.0002 | 0.4748 | 0.8975 |
| ('S', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.0018 | 0 | 0.4819 | 0.928 |
| ('S', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0038 | -0.0023 | 0.4852 | 0.9497 |
| ('S', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0016 | -0 | 0.4836 | 0.9281 |
| ('S', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0064 | -0.0003 | 0.4729 | 0.8973 |
| ('S', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0025 | 0 | 0.4812 | 0.928 |
| ('S', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0019 | -0.0021 | 0.4871 | 0.9499 |
| ('S', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0026 | 0 | 0.4826 | 0.9282 |
| ('S', 1.0, 'correct') | -0.0074 | -0.0001 | 0.472 | 0.8976 |
| ('S', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.004 | -0 | 0.4798 | 0.928 |
| ('S', 1.0, 'native') | -0.0044 | -0.0005 | 0.4845 | 0.9515 |
| ('S', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0032 | 0 | 0.482 | 0.9282 |
| ('S_sup', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.0008 | -0.0012 | 0.4785 | 0.8965 |
| ('S_sup', 0.1, 'mean') | 0.0001 | -0.0008 | 0.4839 | 0.9272 |
| ('S_sup', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0003 | -0.0008 | 0.4887 | 0.9512 |
| ('S_sup', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0001 | -0.0008 | 0.4851 | 0.9274 |
| ('S_sup', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0047 | -0.0063 | 0.4746 | 0.8914 |
| ('S_sup', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.0013 | -0.0035 | 0.4825 | 0.9245 |
| ('S_sup', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0041 | -0.0034 | 0.4848 | 0.9486 |
| ('S_sup', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0025 | -0.0036 | 0.4828 | 0.9245 |
| ('S_sup', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0066 | -0.011 | 0.4727 | 0.8867 |
| ('S_sup', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0014 | -0.0057 | 0.4823 | 0.9223 |
| ('S_sup', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0044 | -0.0054 | 0.4846 | 0.9466 |
| ('S_sup', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.002 | -0.0059 | 0.4832 | 0.9222 |
| ('S_sup', 1.0, 'correct') | -0.0013 | -0.0125 | 0.478 | 0.8852 |
| ('S_sup', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.0002 | -0.0106 | 0.4835 | 0.9174 |
| ('S_sup', 1.0, 'native') | -0.0007 | -0.0105 | 0.4882 | 0.9415 |
| ('S_sup', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0008 | -0.0109 | 0.4844 | 0.9172 |
| ('T', 0.1, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0028 | -0.0008 | 0.4963 | 0.982 |
| ('T', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.002 | 0.0002 | 0.4773 | 0.8979 |
| ('T', 0.1, 'mean') | -0.0008 | 0.0001 | 0.483 | 0.9282 |
| ('T', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0126 | -0.0002 | 0.4764 | 0.9519 |
| ('T', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0009 | 0 | 0.4843 | 0.9282 |
| ('T', 0.3, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0057 | -0.0015 | 0.4933 | 0.9813 |
| ('T', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0038 | -0.0008 | 0.4755 | 0.8969 |
| ('T', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.0017 | -0.0009 | 0.482 | 0.9271 |
| ('T', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0263 | -0.002 | 0.4627 | 0.95 |
| ('T', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0015 | -0.001 | 0.4837 | 0.9272 |
| ('T', 0.5, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0096 | -0.0023 | 0.4895 | 0.9805 |
| ('T', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0127 | -0.0003 | 0.4667 | 0.8974 |
| ('T', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0063 | -0.0006 | 0.4775 | 0.9275 |
| ('T', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0256 | -0.0011 | 0.4634 | 0.9509 |
| ('T', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0058 | -0.0006 | 0.4794 | 0.9276 |
| ('T', 1.0, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0141 | -0.0047 | 0.485 | 0.9781 |
| ('T', 1.0, 'correct') | -0.007 | -0.0006 | 0.4723 | 0.8971 |
| ('T', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.0104 | -0.0008 | 0.4734 | 0.9272 |
| ('T', 1.0, 'native') | -0.013 | -0.002 | 0.476 | 0.9501 |
| ('T', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0104 | -0.0007 | 0.4748 | 0.9274 |
| ('W', 0.1, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0068 | -0.0625 | 0.4922 | 0.9202 |
| ('W', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.0061 | -0.0035 | 0.4732 | 0.8942 |
| ('W', 0.1, 'mean') | -0.0013 | -0.0073 | 0.4825 | 0.9207 |
| ('W', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0061 | -0.0647 | 0.4828 | 0.8873 |
| ('W', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0014 | -0.0079 | 0.4838 | 0.9203 |
| ('W', 0.3, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0107 | -0.1242 | 0.4884 | 0.8586 |
| ('W', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0238 | -0.0117 | 0.4556 | 0.886 |
| ('W', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.0042 | -0.0213 | 0.4796 | 0.9068 |
| ('W', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0064 | -0.1207 | 0.4826 | 0.8313 |
| ('W', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0039 | -0.022 | 0.4814 | 0.9061 |
| ('W', 0.5, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0111 | -0.1486 | 0.488 | 0.8342 |
| ('W', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.033 | -0.0217 | 0.4463 | 0.8759 |
| ('W', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0088 | -0.0351 | 0.4749 | 0.8929 |
| ('W', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0115 | -0.1359 | 0.4775 | 0.8161 |
| ('W', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0083 | -0.0358 | 0.4769 | 0.8924 |
| ('W', 1.0, 'GBDT reference') | -0.0218 | -0.1082 | 0.4773 | 0.8746 |
| ('W', 1.0, 'correct') | -0.0136 | -0.0312 | 0.4658 | 0.8664 |
| ('W', 1.0, 'mean') | -0.0148 | -0.0603 | 0.4689 | 0.8677 |
| ('W', 1.0, 'native') | -0.0156 | -0.0839 | 0.4733 | 0.8681 |
| ('W', 1.0, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.014 | -0.0607 | 0.4712 | 0.8674 |
| ('all', 0.1, 'correct') | -0.0163 | -0.0147 | 0.463 | 0.883 |
| ('all', 0.1, 'mean') | -0.0018 | -0.0114 | 0.4819 | 0.9166 |
| ('all', 0.1, 'native') | -0.0217 | -0.0705 | 0.4673 | 0.8815 |
| ('all', 0.1, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0018 | -0.0109 | 0.4834 | 0.9173 |
| ('all', 0.3, 'correct') | -0.0469 | -0.0599 | 0.4324 | 0.8378 |
| ('all', 0.3, 'mean') | -0.0149 | -0.0389 | 0.4688 | 0.8891 |
| ('all', 0.3, 'native') | -0.0657 | -0.1403 | 0.4232 | 0.8117 |
| ('all', 0.3, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0161 | -0.0387 | 0.4691 | 0.8895 |
| ('all', 0.5, 'correct') | -0.0626 | -0.107 | 0.4167 | 0.7907 |
| ('all', 0.5, 'mean') | -0.0274 | -0.079 | 0.4564 | 0.8491 |
| ('all', 0.5, 'native') | -0.0849 | -0.216 | 0.4041 | 0.736 |
| ('all', 0.5, 'zero (proposed)') | -0.0284 | -0.0819 | 0.4568 | 0.8462 |