Scientific-Answer-Ranking / PRODUCT_SELECTION.md
RegalFire's picture
Publish verified RegalFire scientific product v2
4a0c408 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
2.44 kB

RegalFire scientific product selection

12 candidates; 5 selected. Scores are editorial assessment informed by actual record quality and 2026 scientific RAG evaluation work, not client commitments. Higher build-cost efficiency means lower implementation cost.

Candidate Score /100 Selected Actual records Decision
Scientific-Citation-Graph 82 True 888 888 mechanical reference edges with literal context and full source attribution.
Scientific-Answer-Ranking 80 True 73 73 genuinely multi-answer threads; community signals explicitly separated from truth.
Scientific-RAG-HardCases 80 True 258 258 property-selected cases; no invented correct-answer label.
Scientific-Code-and-Analysis-QA 79 True 72 72 threads and 174 exact preformatted scientific code blocks; no execution/correctness claim.
Scientific-Statistics-QA 71 True 89 89 source-grounded QA threads; statistical methods/retrieval pilot.
Scientific-Computational-Methods-QA 69 False not built Valid source exists, but a separate site-only QA duplicates the more distinctive code product.
Scientific-Methodology-QA 57 False not built No precise deterministic methodological-topic subset defined; avoid vague ontology labels.
Scientific-DataScience-QA 34 False not built Useful fit but collection not started: shared API quota 12, reserve 10.
Scientific-Chemistry-QA 33 False not built No independently approved question/answer/revision corpus.
Scientific-Physics-QA 33 False not built No independently approved question/answer/revision corpus.
Scientific-Astronomy-QA 31 False not built No independently approved question/answer/revision corpus.
Scientific-Math-QA 30 False not built Large public source, but no verified complete corpus in this run.

Research signals: Scientific QA RAG, LREC 2026, SciRet 2026, T2-RAGBench, EACL 2026. The family shares a 288-thread corpus. Selected product counts cannot be added as independent source volume. Public holdouts are not contamination-resistant. Shared API remaining quota was 12 at the last successful native collection. Reserve 10; deferred unverified domains instead of weakening source/license checks.