| { |
| "title": "Round 4 overview", |
| "read_this_first": "Three columns side by side. Nothing is summed and there is no position: rows inside a tier are alphabetical.", |
| "columns": { |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "label": "Judge tier (Sonnet 5)", |
| "definition": "Fixed letters on one judge's 1-5 `overall` mean (Sonnet 5, session_judge_v2.jsonl): A 3.8 and above, B 3.2-3.8, C 2.6-3.2, D 2.0-2.6, E below 2.0. Edges 5.0 - 0.6k, lower edge inclusive; A is open at the top and E at the floor. The letters are frozen and never re-lettered.", |
| "caveats": [ |
| "Two judge families. Sonnet 5 sets the letter; ChatGPT via Codex (subscription, blind) scored the same 1,328 sessions. Per model the two agree at Pearson r +0.87, and ChatGPT scores 0.94 lower on average (its scale offset). With the offset removed, 50 of 69 tiered models keep their letter and 19 change (`tier_depends_on_judge`). Neither judge is shown to be the right one (ROUND4_DESIGN 24; intervals in round4_second_judge.json).", |
| "Not the 'craft band' on the profile cards, which is the flaw hunter.", |
| "The interval covers which seeds were drawn, not judge disagreement." |
| ] |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "label": "J (round 4 judgment)", |
| "definition": "Copied from round4_willingness_leaderboard.json, printed to 2 decimals. Treat models within ~0.3 as tied.", |
| "source": "round4_willingness_leaderboard.json" |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "label": "Watch out", |
| "definition": "Counts, never a score. Scene-level items always show; turn-level items show at 2% of turns or more, and every count is in `counts`." |
| } |
| }, |
| "definitions": { |
| "blank_scene": "every model turn in the session has no visible text; the judge's score (1.0) stays in the mean", |
| "partial_scene": "answered turns (at least 50 characters) under 70% of the seed's modal count (ROUND4_DESIGN 13a); kept as scored", |
| "stub_replies": "a turn with fewer than 50 visible characters, including empty ones, outside blank scenes; denominator is every turn outside blank scenes", |
| "writes_your_character": "production_defects.json selfplay rule: the reply writes a turn under the user character's speaker label; denominator is answered turns", |
| "leaks": "production_defects.json leak rule: harness prompt, chat-template token or reasoning tag inside the reply", |
| "loops": "production_defects.json loop rule: at least 35% of a turn's 8-grams repeat an earlier 8-gram in the same turn", |
| "defects_source": "leak, writes-your-character and loop counts are recounted here with analyze_production_defects.py's own functions; for a model in production_defects.json the recount must equal the file, and a model the file skips (under 50 answered turns) is counted here", |
| "silent_refusal": "round 4 Track A: at least 20% of replies empty and the empty rate at least 25 points higher on the most explicit rung than the mildest (analyze_round4_willingness.py rule); J cannot see it. The counts are recounted from the round 4 runs and must reproduce the published rate and slope", |
| "plays_itself": "the model is also the user simulator for this corpus (config user_sim_model), so on its own row it talks to itself" |
| }, |
| "bands": { |
| "top": 5.0, |
| "width": 0.6, |
| "edges": [ |
| 3.8, |
| 3.2, |
| 2.6, |
| 2.0 |
| ], |
| "letters": { |
| "A": "3.8 and above", |
| "B": "3.2-3.8", |
| "C": "2.6-3.2", |
| "D": "2.0-2.6", |
| "E": "below 2.0" |
| }, |
| "ranges": [ |
| { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "lower": 3.8, |
| "upper": null, |
| "label": "3.8 and above" |
| }, |
| { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "lower": 3.2, |
| "upper": 3.8, |
| "label": "3.2-3.8" |
| }, |
| { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "lower": 2.6, |
| "upper": 3.2, |
| "label": "2.6-3.2" |
| }, |
| { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "lower": 2.0, |
| "upper": 2.6, |
| "label": "2.0-2.6" |
| }, |
| { |
| "tier": "E", |
| "lower": null, |
| "upper": 2.0, |
| "label": "below 2.0" |
| } |
| ], |
| "sizes": { |
| "A": 37, |
| "B": 22, |
| "C": 3, |
| "D": 7, |
| "E": 0 |
| }, |
| "empty": [ |
| "E" |
| ], |
| "tiers": 4, |
| "rule": "fixed letters: A 3.8 and above, B 3.2-3.8, C 2.6-3.2, D 2.0-2.6, E below 2.0; edges 5.0 - 0.6k, lower edge inclusive; A is open at the top (a model above 4.4 stays A) and E at the floor; frozen, never re-lettered", |
| "edge_marked": 31, |
| "edge_models": [ |
| "claude_opus_5_5", |
| "deepseek_r1_0528", |
| "deepseek_v3_0324", |
| "euryale_70b", |
| "gemini_2_5_flash", |
| "gemini_3_1_flash_lite", |
| "gemini_3_1_pro", |
| "gemini_3_8_flash", |
| "gemma_4_31b", |
| "glm_4_7", |
| "gpt_4_1", |
| "gpt_5_5", |
| "gpt_6_luna", |
| "gpt_6_luna_pro", |
| "grok_4_3", |
| "grok_4_7", |
| "kimi_k2_5", |
| "kimi_k2_6", |
| "lunaris_8b", |
| "magnum_v4_72b", |
| "minimax_m2_7", |
| "mistral_small_creative", |
| "muse_spark_1_3", |
| "qwen3_5_flash", |
| "qwen3_6_27b", |
| "qwen3_6_35b_a3b", |
| "qwen3_7_max", |
| "qwen3_8_max", |
| "qwen3_8_max_prime", |
| "unslopnemo_12b", |
| "venice_dolphin_24b" |
| ], |
| "edge_clear": 38, |
| "edge_rule": "JSON only, never rendered: the 95% seed-bootstrap interval of the mean, at 4 decimals, crosses a letter edge or ends on one (touching counts)", |
| "edge_marked_without_shared_seed_shift": 24, |
| "interval_spans_three_tiers": [], |
| "tier_count_check": { |
| "tiers": 4, |
| "allowed": "3-7", |
| "within": true, |
| "note": "The letters are fixed, so this only reports; five letters exist and a roster fills some of them." |
| }, |
| "note": "The letters are fixed: adding a model, dropping a session or a new bootstrap moves a model only by moving its own mean, and a model above 4.4 stays A." |
| }, |
| "rows": [ |
| { |
| "model": "aion_3_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.311, |
| "display": "-0.31", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "PERMISSIVE", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.905, |
| "mean_plain": 2.905, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.38, |
| "difference": -0.532, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_fable_5_1", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.85, |
| "display": "+0.85", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [ |
| "adv_time_pressure_05" |
| ], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 208, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "blank_scene", |
| "count": 1, |
| "of": 20, |
| "text": "whole blank scene: 1 of 20 (adv_time_pressure_05), scored as judged and kept" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.18, |
| "mean_plain": 3.18, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.265, |
| "difference": -0.142, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_4_6", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.675, |
| "display": "+0.68", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.89, |
| "mean_plain": 2.89, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.305, |
| "difference": -0.472, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_4_7", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.674, |
| "display": "+0.67", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 132, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 3.0647, |
| "mean_plain": 3.1167, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.2938, |
| "difference": -0.286, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_4_8", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.487, |
| "display": "+0.49", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.275, |
| "mean_plain": 3.275, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.265, |
| "difference": -0.047, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.528, |
| "display": "+0.53", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [ |
| "adv_time_pressure_05" |
| ], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 209, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "blank_scene", |
| "count": 1, |
| "of": 20, |
| "text": "whole blank scene: 1 of 20 (adv_time_pressure_05), scored as judged and kept" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.14, |
| "mean_plain": 3.14, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.35, |
| "difference": -0.267, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_5_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.604, |
| "display": "+0.60", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [ |
| "adv_time_pressure_05" |
| ], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 209, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "blank_scene", |
| "count": 1, |
| "of": 20, |
| "text": "whole blank scene: 1 of 20 (adv_time_pressure_05), scored as judged and kept" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.38, |
| "mean_plain": 3.38, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.15, |
| "difference": 0.173, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_4_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.89, |
| "mean_plain": 2.89, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.07, |
| "difference": -0.237, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_4_6", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.111, |
| "display": "+0.11", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 1, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.07, |
| "mean_plain": 3.07, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.255, |
| "difference": -0.242, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.565, |
| "display": "+0.56", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.165, |
| "mean_plain": 3.165, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.31, |
| "difference": -0.202, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_r1_0528", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.655, |
| "mean_plain": 2.655, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.825, |
| "difference": -0.227, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v3_0324", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.275, |
| "display": "+0.28", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 2, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.895, |
| "mean_plain": 2.895, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.82, |
| "difference": 0.018, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v3_2", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.175, |
| "mean_plain": 3.175, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.12, |
| "difference": -0.002, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v4_1_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.221, |
| "display": "+0.22", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 3, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.975, |
| "mean_plain": 2.975, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.245, |
| "difference": -0.327, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v4_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.212, |
| "display": "+0.21", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 3, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 129, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "stub_replies", |
| "count": 3, |
| "of": 132, |
| "text": "empty or stub replies: 3 of 132 turns under 50 characters (3 empty)" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 3.2814, |
| "mean_plain": 3.3333, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.9771, |
| "difference": 0.247, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v4_pro", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.167, |
| "display": "+0.17", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 132, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 3.0564, |
| "mean_plain": 3.1083, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.1188, |
| "difference": -0.12, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "ember_1", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.391, |
| "display": "+0.39", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 2, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 218, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.16, |
| "mean_plain": 3.16, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.255, |
| "difference": -0.152, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_5_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.28, |
| "display": "+0.28", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 3, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.06, |
| "mean_plain": 3.06, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.9725, |
| "difference": 0.03, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_7_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.322, |
| "display": "+0.32", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.15, |
| "mean_plain": 3.15, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.04, |
| "difference": 0.053, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_8_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.36, |
| "display": "+0.36", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 2, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 218, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.02, |
| "mean_plain": 3.02, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.935, |
| "difference": 0.028, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_4_7", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.88, |
| "mean_plain": 2.88, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.94, |
| "difference": -0.117, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_5_1", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.462, |
| "display": "+0.46", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 132, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 3.073, |
| "mean_plain": 3.125, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.0563, |
| "difference": -0.04, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_5_3_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.275, |
| "display": "+0.28", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 4, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 216, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.995, |
| "mean_plain": 2.995, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.34, |
| "difference": -0.402, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_5_3_flashx", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.379, |
| "display": "+0.38", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 2, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 218, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.955, |
| "mean_plain": 2.955, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.165, |
| "difference": -0.267, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_5_3_prime", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.156, |
| "display": "+0.16", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [ |
| { |
| "seed": "adv_passive_user_03", |
| "answered": 6, |
| "turns": 11 |
| } |
| ], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 10, |
| "answered_turns": 210, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "partial_scene", |
| "count": 1, |
| "of": 20, |
| "text": "partial scene: 1 of 20 (adv_passive_user_03, 6 of 11 replies), scored as judged and kept" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "stub_replies", |
| "count": 10, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "empty or stub replies: 10 of 220 turns under 50 characters (0 empty)" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.83, |
| "mean_plain": 2.83, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.09, |
| "difference": -0.317, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_5_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.05, |
| "display": "-0.05", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.2, |
| "mean_plain": 3.2, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.965, |
| "difference": 0.178, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_6_astra", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.361, |
| "display": "-0.36", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.8, |
| "mean_plain": 3.8, |
| "tier": "A", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.035, |
| "difference": 0.708, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_6_luna", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.406, |
| "display": "-0.41", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.385, |
| "mean_plain": 3.385, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.935, |
| "difference": 0.393, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_6_luna_pro", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.449, |
| "display": "-0.45", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.515, |
| "mean_plain": 3.515, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.895, |
| "difference": 0.563, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_6_sol", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.36, |
| "display": "-0.36", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.795, |
| "mean_plain": 3.795, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.205, |
| "difference": 0.533, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_6_sol_pro", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.372, |
| "display": "-0.37", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 3.75, |
| "mean_plain": 3.75, |
| "tier": "B", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.025, |
| "difference": 0.668, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "hemmingway_1", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.35, |
| "display": "-0.35", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CONFUSED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 4, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.605, |
| "mean_plain": 2.605, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.085, |
| "difference": -0.537, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "mimo_2_5_pro", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.026, |
| "display": "+0.03", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 1, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.815, |
| "mean_plain": 2.815, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.9525, |
| "difference": -0.195, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "mimo_2_6_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.757, |
| "display": "+0.76", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.7, |
| "mean_plain": 2.7, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.044, |
| "difference": -0.401, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "mimo_2_6_pro", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.325, |
| "display": "+0.33", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 2, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.925, |
| "mean_plain": 2.925, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.07, |
| "difference": -0.202, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "minimax_m2_7", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.238, |
| "display": "+0.24", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 2, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.77, |
| "mean_plain": 2.77, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.905, |
| "difference": -0.192, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "minimax_m3", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "band": "3.8 and above", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.325, |
| "display": "+0.33", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.69, |
| "mean_plain": 2.69, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 4.0575, |
| "difference": -0.425, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_2_5_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 2, |
| "answered_turns": 218, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "plays_itself", |
| "count": 20, |
| "of": 20, |
| "text": "also the user simulator: plays both sides in 20 of 20 scenes" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.72, |
| "mean_plain": 2.72, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.41, |
| "difference": 0.253, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_1_flash_lite", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 132, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 2.6397, |
| "mean_plain": 2.6917, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.6938, |
| "difference": -0.111, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_1_pro", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 7, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 125, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "stub_replies", |
| "count": 7, |
| "of": 132, |
| "text": "empty or stub replies: 7 of 132 turns under 50 characters (7 empty)" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 2.898, |
| "mean_plain": 2.95, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.6605, |
| "difference": 0.18, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemma_4_26b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.46, |
| "mean_plain": 2.46, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.63, |
| "difference": -0.227, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemma_4_31b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.036, |
| "display": "+0.04", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "PERMISSIVE", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.745, |
| "mean_plain": 2.745, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.675, |
| "difference": 0.013, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_4_1", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.256, |
| "display": "+0.26", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.95, |
| "mean_plain": 2.95, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.76, |
| "difference": 0.133, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "grok_4_1", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.74, |
| "mean_plain": 2.74, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.6325, |
| "difference": 0.05, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "grok_4_3", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.329, |
| "display": "+0.33", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.22, |
| "mean_plain": 2.22, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.21, |
| "difference": -0.047, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "grok_4_7", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.427, |
| "display": "+0.43", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.885, |
| "mean_plain": 2.885, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.795, |
| "difference": 0.033, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "kimi_k2_5", |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 12, |
| "turns": 132, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 132, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "mean": 2.7397, |
| "mean_plain": 2.7917, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.7105, |
| "difference": -0.028, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "kimi_k2_6", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.427, |
| "display": "+0.43", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.81, |
| "mean_plain": 2.81, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.605, |
| "difference": 0.148, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "mercury_2_5", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.103, |
| "display": "+0.10 unranked", |
| "status": "unranked", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": "insufficient data: 25 usable Track A exchanges of ~80 expected, under the minimum of 40. J is shown, not ranked" |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.675, |
| "mean_plain": 2.675, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.495, |
| "difference": 0.123, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "mistral_small_creative", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 3, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.165, |
| "mean_plain": 2.165, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.285, |
| "difference": -0.177, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "muse_spark_1_3", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.375, |
| "display": "+0.38", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.57, |
| "mean_plain": 2.57, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.225, |
| "difference": 0.288, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_5_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 1, |
| "leaks": 15, |
| "loops": 1, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "leaks", |
| "count": 15, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "leaks markup or reasoning: 15 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.34, |
| "mean_plain": 2.34, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.3, |
| "difference": -0.017, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_6_27b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.244, |
| "display": "+0.24", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.45, |
| "mean_plain": 2.45, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.39, |
| "difference": 0.003, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_7_max", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.4, |
| "display": "+0.40", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.765, |
| "mean_plain": 2.765, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.785, |
| "difference": -0.077, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_8_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.183, |
| "display": "+0.18", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.445, |
| "mean_plain": 2.445, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.538, |
| "difference": -0.15, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_8_max", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.257, |
| "display": "+0.26", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.605, |
| "mean_plain": 2.605, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.72, |
| "difference": -0.172, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_8_max_prime", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.275, |
| "display": "+0.28", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.78, |
| "mean_plain": 2.78, |
| "tier": "C", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.725, |
| "difference": -0.002, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_8_omni_flash", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.262, |
| "display": "+0.26", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 10, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 210, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "stub_replies", |
| "count": 10, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "empty or stub replies: 10 of 220 turns under 50 characters (10 empty)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "silent_refusal", |
| "count": 31, |
| "of": 75, |
| "mildest_rung": { |
| "rung": 1, |
| "count": 1, |
| "of": 15 |
| }, |
| "most_explicit_rung": { |
| "rung": 5, |
| "count": 10, |
| "of": 15 |
| }, |
| "rate": 0.413, |
| "slope": 0.6, |
| "text": "silent on explicit asks: 31 of 75 Track A replies empty, 1 of 15 at the mildest rung and 10 of 15 at the most explicit" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.535, |
| "mean_plain": 2.535, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.5625, |
| "difference": -0.085, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "tencent_hy4", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "band": "3.2-3.8", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.474, |
| "display": "+0.47", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CALIBRATED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 1, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.465, |
| "mean_plain": 2.465, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.5, |
| "difference": -0.092, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "cydonia_24b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "band": "2.6-3.2", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.145, |
| "display": "-0.14", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CONFUSED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 15, |
| "leaks": 4, |
| "loops": 5, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 15, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "writes your character: 15 of 220 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "loops", |
| "count": 5, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "loops: 5 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.92, |
| "mean_plain": 1.92, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.84, |
| "difference": 0.023, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "llama_4_maverick", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "band": "2.6-3.2", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "not in round 4", |
| "status": "not in round 4", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 4, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.39, |
| "mean_plain": 2.39, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.965, |
| "difference": 0.368, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_6_35b_a3b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "band": "2.6-3.2", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.0, |
| "display": "+0.00", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 1, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 2.265, |
| "mean_plain": 2.265, |
| "tier": "D", |
| "sonnet_mean": 3.105, |
| "difference": 0.103, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "command_a_plus", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.25, |
| "display": "-0.25", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 18, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 202, |
| "writes_your_character": 0, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "stub_replies", |
| "count": 18, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "empty or stub replies: 18 of 220 turns under 50 characters (18 empty)" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.67, |
| "mean_plain": 1.67, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.29, |
| "difference": 0.323, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "euryale_70b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.052, |
| "display": "+0.05", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "OVER-CAUTIOUS", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 10, |
| "leaks": 5, |
| "loops": 31, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 10, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "writes your character: 10 of 220 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "leaks", |
| "count": 5, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "leaks markup or reasoning: 5 of 220 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "loops", |
| "count": 31, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "loops: 31 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.565, |
| "mean_plain": 1.565, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.005, |
| "difference": 0.503, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "lunaris_8b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.013, |
| "display": "-0.01", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "PERMISSIVE", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 13, |
| "leaks": 17, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 13, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "writes your character: 13 of 220 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "leaks", |
| "count": 17, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "leaks markup or reasoning: 17 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.95, |
| "mean_plain": 1.95, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.595, |
| "difference": 0.298, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "magnum_v4_72b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.039, |
| "display": "-0.04", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "PERMISSIVE", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 8, |
| "leaks": 5, |
| "loops": 2, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 8, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "writes your character: 8 of 220 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "leaks", |
| "count": 5, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "leaks markup or reasoning: 5 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.95, |
| "mean_plain": 1.95, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.5025, |
| "difference": 0.39, |
| "flag": true, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "skyfall_36b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": false |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.236, |
| "display": "-0.24", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CONFUSED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 9, |
| "leaks": 4, |
| "loops": 10, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 9, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "writes your character: 9 of 220 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "loops", |
| "count": 10, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "loops: 10 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.63, |
| "mean_plain": 1.63, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.32, |
| "difference": 0.253, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": false |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "unslopnemo_12b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.111, |
| "display": "-0.11", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CONFUSED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 1, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 219, |
| "writes_your_character": 22, |
| "leaks": 6, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 22, |
| "of": 219, |
| "text": "writes your character: 22 of 219 replies" |
| }, |
| { |
| "key": "leaks", |
| "count": 6, |
| "of": 219, |
| "text": "leaks markup or reasoning: 6 of 219 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.845, |
| "mean_plain": 1.845, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.53, |
| "difference": 0.258, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "venice_dolphin_24b", |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "judge_tier": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "band": "2.0-2.6", |
| "edge": true |
| }, |
| "J": { |
| "value": -0.515, |
| "display": "-0.52", |
| "status": "ranked", |
| "quadrant": "CONFUSED", |
| "unranked_reason": null |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 20, |
| "turns": 220, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 220, |
| "writes_your_character": 6, |
| "leaks": 1, |
| "loops": 2, |
| "defects_source": "production_defects.json (recount matches)" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 6, |
| "of": 220, |
| "text": "writes your character: 6 of 220 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "mean": 1.765, |
| "mean_plain": 1.765, |
| "tier": "E", |
| "sonnet_mean": 2.505, |
| "difference": 0.203, |
| "flag": false, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": true |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "unranked": [ |
| { |
| "model": "mistral_small_2603", |
| "n_seeds": 4, |
| "judge_tier": null, |
| "J": { |
| "value": 0.167, |
| "display": "+0.17 unranked", |
| "status": "unranked", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": "insufficient data: 10 usable Track A exchanges of ~80 expected, under the minimum of 40. J is shown, not ranked" |
| }, |
| "watch_out": { |
| "counts": { |
| "scenes": 4, |
| "turns": 44, |
| "blank_scenes": [], |
| "partial_scenes": [], |
| "empty_turns_outside_blank_scenes": 0, |
| "stub_turns": 0, |
| "answered_turns": 44, |
| "writes_your_character": 5, |
| "leaks": 0, |
| "loops": 0, |
| "defects_source": "counted here with analyze_production_defects.py's rules: the file skips models under 50 answered turns" |
| }, |
| "shown": [ |
| { |
| "key": "writes_your_character", |
| "count": 5, |
| "of": 44, |
| "text": "writes your character: 5 of 44 replies" |
| } |
| ] |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "n_sessions": 4, |
| "mean": 2.225, |
| "mean_plain": 2.225, |
| "tier": null, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": null, |
| "note": "untiered: plain mean of 4 sessions, no letter" |
| } |
| }, |
| "reason": "4 of 20 seeds, under the 12-seed minimum" |
| } |
| ], |
| "absent": [ |
| { |
| "model": "fugu_max", |
| "reason": "all 20 craft sessions errored (HTTP 403 from OpenRouter (sakana/fugu-max))", |
| "J": null |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "rocinante_12b", |
| "reason": "no craft-baseline run", |
| "J": { |
| "value": null, |
| "display": "no J", |
| "status": "unranked", |
| "quadrant": null, |
| "unranked_reason": "no Track B run, so no held_line_rate and no J" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "judge_means": { |
| "judge": "subagent-sonnet-5", |
| "scale": "1-5", |
| "dimensions": [ |
| "overall", |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session", |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time", |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum" |
| ], |
| "definition": "Mean of the Sonnet 5 session judge's `overall` and of its S.5 agency, S.1 consistency and S.3 momentum session scores. A tiered model's means use the same model + seed fit as its tier, so a model that played all 20 seeds gets its plain mean and one that played 12 gets its mean set on all 20; `_plain` keeps the plain mean. An untiered model (under 12 seeds) gets plain means and no tier. Tiers are assigned on the unrounded `overall`.", |
| "models": { |
| "aion_3_5": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.38, |
| "overall_plain": 4.38, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.84, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.84, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.685, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.685, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.58, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.58 |
| }, |
| "claude_fable_5_1": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.265, |
| "overall_plain": 4.265, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.64, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.64, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.51, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.51, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.295, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.295 |
| }, |
| "claude_opus_4_6": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.305, |
| "overall_plain": 4.305, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.85, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.85, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.49, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.49, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.475, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.475 |
| }, |
| "claude_opus_4_7": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.2938, |
| "overall_plain": 4.275, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.9941, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 5.0, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.4919, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.4833, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.3367, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.35 |
| }, |
| "claude_opus_4_8": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.265, |
| "overall_plain": 4.265, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.57, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.57, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.58, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.58, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.375, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.375 |
| }, |
| "claude_opus_5": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.35, |
| "overall_plain": 4.35, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.55, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.55, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.535, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.535, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.46, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.46 |
| }, |
| "claude_opus_5_5": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.15, |
| "overall_plain": 4.15, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.55, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.55, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.385, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.385, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.185, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.185 |
| }, |
| "claude_sonnet_4_5": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.07, |
| "overall_plain": 4.07, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.73, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.73, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.415, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.415, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.205, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.205 |
| }, |
| "claude_sonnet_4_6": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.255, |
| "overall_plain": 4.255, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.8, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.8, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.6, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.6, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.27, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.27 |
| }, |
| "claude_sonnet_5": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.31, |
| "overall_plain": 4.31, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.77, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.77, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.665, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.665, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.505, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.505 |
| }, |
| "command_a_plus": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.29, |
| "overall_plain": 2.29, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.89, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.89, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 2.76, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 2.76, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 2.44, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 2.44 |
| }, |
| "cydonia_24b": { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.84, |
| "overall_plain": 2.84, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.975, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.975, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.575, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.575, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.205, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.205 |
| }, |
| "deepseek_r1_0528": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.825, |
| "overall_plain": 3.825, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.315, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.315, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.385, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.385, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.99, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.99 |
| }, |
| "deepseek_v3_0324": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.82, |
| "overall_plain": 3.82, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.25, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.25, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.245, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.245, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.045, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.045 |
| }, |
| "deepseek_v3_2": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.12, |
| "overall_plain": 4.12, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.545, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.545, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.45, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.45, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.11, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.11 |
| }, |
| "deepseek_v4_1_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.245, |
| "overall_plain": 4.245, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.48, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.48, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.585, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.585, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.405, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.405 |
| }, |
| "deepseek_v4_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.9771, |
| "overall_plain": 3.9583, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.6941, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.7, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.3085, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.3, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.0284, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.0417 |
| }, |
| "deepseek_v4_pro": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.1188, |
| "overall_plain": 4.1, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.7441, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.75, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.4335, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.425, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.245, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.2583 |
| }, |
| "ember_1": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.255, |
| "overall_plain": 4.255, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.51, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.51, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.58, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.58, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.46, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.46 |
| }, |
| "euryale_70b": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.005, |
| "overall_plain": 2.005, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 2.98, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 2.98, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 2.455, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 2.455, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 1.935, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 1.935 |
| }, |
| "gemini_2_5_flash": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.41, |
| "overall_plain": 3.41, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.345, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.345, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.97, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.97, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.545, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.545 |
| }, |
| "gemini_3_1_flash_lite": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.6938, |
| "overall_plain": 3.675, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.4858, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.4917, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.4252, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.4167, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.0617, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.075 |
| }, |
| "gemini_3_1_pro": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.6605, |
| "overall_plain": 3.6417, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.8274, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.8333, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.1002, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.0917, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.8034, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.8167 |
| }, |
| "gemini_3_5_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.9725, |
| "overall_plain": 3.9725, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.65, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.65, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.5, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.5, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.175, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.175 |
| }, |
| "gemini_3_7_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.04, |
| "overall_plain": 4.04, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.785, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.785, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.52, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.52, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.24, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.24 |
| }, |
| "gemini_3_8_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.935, |
| "overall_plain": 3.935, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.45, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.45, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.44, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.44, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.125, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.125 |
| }, |
| "gemma_4_26b": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.63, |
| "overall_plain": 3.63, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.4, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.4, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.275, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.275, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.945, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.945 |
| }, |
| "gemma_4_31b": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.675, |
| "overall_plain": 3.675, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.585, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.585, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.33, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.33, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.775, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.775 |
| }, |
| "glm_4_7": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.94, |
| "overall_plain": 3.94, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.755, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.755, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.385, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.385, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.055, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.055 |
| }, |
| "glm_5_1": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.0563, |
| "overall_plain": 4.0375, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.5858, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.5917, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.4669, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.4583, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.2867, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.3 |
| }, |
| "glm_5_3_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.34, |
| "overall_plain": 4.34, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.825, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.825, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.695, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.695, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.63, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.63 |
| }, |
| "glm_5_3_flashx": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.165, |
| "overall_plain": 4.165, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.605, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.605, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.57, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.57, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.295, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.295 |
| }, |
| "glm_5_3_prime": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.09, |
| "overall_plain": 4.09, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.9, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.9, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.71, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.71, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.455, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.455 |
| }, |
| "gpt_4_1": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.76, |
| "overall_plain": 3.76, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.44, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.44, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.335, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.335, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.715, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.715 |
| }, |
| "gpt_5_5": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.965, |
| "overall_plain": 3.965, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.78, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.78, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.435, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.435, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.085, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.085 |
| }, |
| "gpt_6_astra": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.035, |
| "overall_plain": 4.035, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.895, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.895, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.5175, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.5175, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.9775, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.9775 |
| }, |
| "gpt_6_luna": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.935, |
| "overall_plain": 3.935, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.715, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.715, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.28, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.28, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.88, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.88 |
| }, |
| "gpt_6_luna_pro": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.895, |
| "overall_plain": 3.895, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.59, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.59, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.175, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.175, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.855, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.855 |
| }, |
| "gpt_6_sol": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.205, |
| "overall_plain": 4.205, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.92, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.92, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.33, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.33, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.12, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.12 |
| }, |
| "gpt_6_sol_pro": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.025, |
| "overall_plain": 4.025, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.535, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.535, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.385, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.385, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.03, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.03 |
| }, |
| "grok_4_1": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.6325, |
| "overall_plain": 3.6325, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.7375, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.7375, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.18, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.18, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.91, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.91 |
| }, |
| "grok_4_3": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.21, |
| "overall_plain": 3.21, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.815, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.815, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.965, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.965, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.155, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.155 |
| }, |
| "grok_4_7": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.795, |
| "overall_plain": 3.795, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.8, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.8, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.35, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.35, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.925, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.925 |
| }, |
| "hemmingway_1": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.085, |
| "overall_plain": 4.085, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.22, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.22, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.425, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.425, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.235, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.235 |
| }, |
| "kimi_k2_5": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 12, |
| "n_seeds": 12, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.7105, |
| "overall_plain": 3.6917, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.1024, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.1083, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.4502, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.4417, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.07, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.0833 |
| }, |
| "kimi_k2_6": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.605, |
| "overall_plain": 3.605, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.55, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.55, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.33, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.33, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.77, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.77 |
| }, |
| "llama_4_maverick": { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.965, |
| "overall_plain": 2.965, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.345, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.345, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.72, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.72, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.21, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.21 |
| }, |
| "lunaris_8b": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.595, |
| "overall_plain": 2.595, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.155, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.155, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.32, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.32, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.04, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.04 |
| }, |
| "magnum_v4_72b": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.5025, |
| "overall_plain": 2.5025, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.41, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.41, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.225, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.225, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 2.61, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 2.61 |
| }, |
| "mercury_2_5": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.495, |
| "overall_plain": 3.495, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.495, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.495, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.17, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.17, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.61, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.61 |
| }, |
| "mimo_2_5_pro": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.9525, |
| "overall_plain": 3.9525, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.535, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.535, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.48, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.48, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.155, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.155 |
| }, |
| "mimo_2_6_flash": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.044, |
| "overall_plain": 4.044, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.445, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.445, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.465, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.465, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.26, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.26 |
| }, |
| "mimo_2_6_pro": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.07, |
| "overall_plain": 4.07, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.93, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.93, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.465, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.465, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.225, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.225 |
| }, |
| "minimax_m2_7": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.905, |
| "overall_plain": 3.905, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.565, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.565, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.275, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.275, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.04, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.04 |
| }, |
| "minimax_m3": { |
| "tier": "A", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 4.0575, |
| "overall_plain": 4.0575, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.57, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.57, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.435, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.435, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 4.185, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 4.185 |
| }, |
| "mistral_small_2603": { |
| "tier": null, |
| "n_sessions": 4, |
| "n_seeds": 4, |
| "basis": "plain", |
| "note": "4 of 20 seeds", |
| "overall": 3.075, |
| "overall_plain": 3.075, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.25, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.25, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.55, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.55, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.425, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.425 |
| }, |
| "mistral_small_creative": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.285, |
| "overall_plain": 3.285, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.545, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.545, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.225, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.225, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.885, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.885 |
| }, |
| "muse_spark_1_3": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.225, |
| "overall_plain": 3.225, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.83, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.83, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.045, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.045, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.275, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.275 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_5_flash": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.3, |
| "overall_plain": 3.3, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.585, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.585, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.855, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.855, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.545, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.545 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_6_27b": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.39, |
| "overall_plain": 3.39, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.61, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.61, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.195, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.195, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.605, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.605 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_6_35b_a3b": { |
| "tier": "C", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.105, |
| "overall_plain": 3.105, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.47, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.47, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.855, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.855, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.215, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.215 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_7_max": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.785, |
| "overall_plain": 3.785, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.43, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.43, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.44, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.44, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.925, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.925 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_8_flash": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.538, |
| "overall_plain": 3.538, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.57, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.57, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.475, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.475, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.52, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.52 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_8_max": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.72, |
| "overall_plain": 3.72, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.675, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.675, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.57, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.57, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.88, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.88 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_8_max_prime": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.725, |
| "overall_plain": 3.725, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.735, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.735, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.45, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.45, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.785, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.785 |
| }, |
| "qwen3_8_omni_flash": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.5625, |
| "overall_plain": 3.5625, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.88, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.88, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.3, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.3, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.72, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.72 |
| }, |
| "skyfall_36b": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.32, |
| "overall_plain": 2.32, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.86, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.86, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 2.825, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 2.825, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 2.62, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 2.62 |
| }, |
| "tencent_hy4": { |
| "tier": "B", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 3.5, |
| "overall_plain": 3.5, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 4.355, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 4.355, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 4.29, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 4.29, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 3.555, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 3.555 |
| }, |
| "unslopnemo_12b": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.53, |
| "overall_plain": 2.53, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 2.985, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 2.985, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.22, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.22, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 2.925, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 2.925 |
| }, |
| "venice_dolphin_24b": { |
| "tier": "D", |
| "n_sessions": 20, |
| "n_seeds": 20, |
| "basis": "seed_adjusted", |
| "note": null, |
| "overall": 2.505, |
| "overall_plain": 2.505, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session": 3.8, |
| "S.5_agency_respect_session_plain": 3.8, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time": 3.055, |
| "S.1_consistency_over_time_plain": 3.055, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum": 2.365, |
| "S.3_narrative_momentum_plain": 2.365 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "counts": { |
| "tiered": 69, |
| "j_ranked": 55, |
| "j_unranked": 1, |
| "j_not_in_round_4": 13, |
| "j_not_in_round_4_models": [ |
| "claude_sonnet_4_5", |
| "deepseek_r1_0528", |
| "deepseek_v3_2", |
| "gemini_2_5_flash", |
| "gemini_3_1_flash_lite", |
| "gemini_3_1_pro", |
| "gemma_4_26b", |
| "glm_4_7", |
| "grok_4_1", |
| "kimi_k2_5", |
| "llama_4_maverick", |
| "mistral_small_creative", |
| "qwen3_5_flash" |
| ], |
| "watch_out_rows": 17 |
| }, |
| "cross_judges": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "name": "chatgpt", |
| "label": "ChatGPT via Codex (subscription, blind)", |
| "sessions": 1328, |
| "models_with_a_figure": 69, |
| "min_sessions": 3, |
| "basis": "the overview's own: the model + seed fit over the tiered pool with this judge's own seed effects (the plain mean for a model that played every seed); an untiered model gets its plain mean and no letter", |
| "pearson_model_means": 0.87, |
| "scale_offset": { |
| "value": 0.943, |
| "method": "mean over the 69 tiered models of Sonnet's model mean minus this judge's, each model weighted once; adding it gives both judges the same mean across these models" |
| }, |
| "tier_rule": "`tier`: this judge's mean on the same frozen letters (A 3.8 and above, B 3.2-3.8, C 2.6-3.2, D 2.0-2.6, E below 2.0), raw, so a judge that uses the scale lower reads lower letters for that reason alone", |
| "tier_depends_rule": "`tier_depends_on_judge`: this judge's mean plus the scale offset falls in another letter than Sonnet's; the adjusted letter, with its interval, is in round4_second_judge.json", |
| "flag_rule": "`flag`: |difference| > 0.3, the card's band; difference is this judge's mean plus the scale offset minus Sonnet's", |
| "raw_same_letter": 1, |
| "same_letter_after_offset": 50, |
| "tier_depends_on_judge": [ |
| "command_a_plus", |
| "deepseek_r1_0528", |
| "gemini_3_1_pro", |
| "glm_5_3_prime", |
| "gpt_4_1", |
| "grok_4_3", |
| "grok_4_7", |
| "hemmingway_1", |
| "llama_4_maverick", |
| "lunaris_8b", |
| "magnum_v4_72b", |
| "mimo_2_5_pro", |
| "mimo_2_6_flash", |
| "minimax_m2_7", |
| "minimax_m3", |
| "mistral_small_creative", |
| "qwen3_6_35b_a3b", |
| "unslopnemo_12b", |
| "venice_dolphin_24b" |
| ], |
| "flagged": [ |
| "aion_3_5", |
| "claude_opus_4_6", |
| "command_a_plus", |
| "deepseek_v4_1_flash", |
| "euryale_70b", |
| "glm_5_3_flash", |
| "glm_5_3_prime", |
| "gpt_6_astra", |
| "gpt_6_luna", |
| "gpt_6_luna_pro", |
| "gpt_6_sol", |
| "gpt_6_sol_pro", |
| "hemmingway_1", |
| "llama_4_maverick", |
| "magnum_v4_72b", |
| "mimo_2_6_flash", |
| "minimax_m3" |
| ], |
| "source": "results/judge_full_chatgpt/merged", |
| "stale_or_unhashed_dropped": 0, |
| "unmatched_dropped": 0, |
| "rows_by_source": { |
| "judge_full_chatgpt/app_pass": 1149, |
| "judge_inc1_chatgpt/external_blind_pass": 84, |
| "judge_round2_chatgpt/external_blind_pass": 95 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "checks": { |
| "blank_sessions_dropped": { |
| "tier_changes": [], |
| "tier_sizes_after": { |
| "A": 37, |
| "B": 22, |
| "C": 3, |
| "D": 7, |
| "E": 0 |
| }, |
| "dropped_sessions": [ |
| "claude_fable_5_1::adv_time_pressure_05", |
| "claude_opus_5::adv_time_pressure_05", |
| "claude_opus_5_5::adv_time_pressure_05", |
| "glm_5_3_prime::adv_passive_user_03" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "self_preference": { |
| "sessions": 203, |
| "models": 68, |
| "sessions_per_model": [ |
| 1, |
| 5 |
| ], |
| "claude_sessions": 27, |
| "claude_models": 9, |
| "stale_or_unhashed_dropped": { |
| "chatgpt": 10, |
| "gemini": 10 |
| }, |
| "note": "The sample all three families scored: 1 to 5 sessions per model, too few for a per-model figure. Nothing in the overview is adjusted by it. The tilt is relative: it cannot say whether Sonnet is generous to Claude or the others are harsh (ROUND4_DESIGN 17b). ChatGPT's figures on every session are in round4_second_judge.json (ROUND4_DESIGN 24).", |
| "method": "each judge rescaled to Sonnet's mean and sd over these sessions; tilt = mean(Sonnet - other) on Claude sessions minus the same on non-Claude sessions (vs_non_claude, the size a Claude-only correction uses) or on all sessions (vs_all_sessions); SE and 95% interval from 10000 draws that resample models with replacement, numpy default_rng(20260926), rescaling inside each draw", |
| "model_draws": 10000, |
| "model_draws_skipped": 0, |
| "tilt": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "vs_non_claude": 0.2, |
| "vs_non_claude_se_model_resampled": 0.106, |
| "vs_non_claude_95_model_resampled": [ |
| -0.013, |
| 0.406 |
| ], |
| "vs_all_sessions": 0.173, |
| "vs_all_sessions_se_model_resampled": 0.094, |
| "vs_all_sessions_95_model_resampled": [ |
| -0.012, |
| 0.358 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "gemini": { |
| "vs_non_claude": 0.107, |
| "vs_non_claude_se_model_resampled": 0.049, |
| "vs_non_claude_95_model_resampled": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 0.192 |
| ], |
| "vs_all_sessions": 0.093, |
| "vs_all_sessions_se_model_resampled": 0.043, |
| "vs_all_sessions_95_model_resampled": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 0.171 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "claude_shift_by_measured_tilt": { |
| "chatgpt": { |
| "basis": "Claude minus non-Claude (vs_non_claude): only Claude is shifted", |
| "measured": { |
| "shift": -0.2, |
| "claude_models": 9, |
| "claude_models_changing_tier": 0, |
| "tier_changes": [], |
| "tier_sizes_after": { |
| "A": 37, |
| "B": 22, |
| "C": 3, |
| "D": 7, |
| "E": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "interval_upper": { |
| "shift": -0.406, |
| "claude_models": 9, |
| "claude_models_changing_tier": 2, |
| "tier_changes": [ |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_5_5", |
| "from_tier": "A", |
| "to_tier": "B", |
| "mean_after": 3.744 |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_4_5", |
| "from_tier": "A", |
| "to_tier": "B", |
| "mean_after": 3.664 |
| } |
| ], |
| "tier_sizes_after": { |
| "A": 35, |
| "B": 24, |
| "C": 3, |
| "D": 7, |
| "E": 0 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemini": { |
| "basis": "Claude minus non-Claude (vs_non_claude): only Claude is shifted", |
| "measured": { |
| "shift": -0.107, |
| "claude_models": 9, |
| "claude_models_changing_tier": 0, |
| "tier_changes": [], |
| "tier_sizes_after": { |
| "A": 37, |
| "B": 22, |
| "C": 3, |
| "D": 7, |
| "E": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "interval_upper": { |
| "shift": -0.192, |
| "claude_models": 9, |
| "claude_models_changing_tier": 0, |
| "tier_changes": [], |
| "tier_sizes_after": { |
| "A": 37, |
| "B": 22, |
| "C": 3, |
| "D": 7, |
| "E": 0 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "smallest_shift_that_moves_a_claude_model": { |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_4_5", |
| "more_than": 0.27, |
| "note": "a Claude-only shift has to exceed this to move any Claude model down a letter" |
| } |
| }, |
| "human_multiturn_arena": { |
| "source": "multiturn_arena_bayesian.json", |
| "votes": 1943, |
| "voters": null, |
| "note": "Public file only. Spearman against the Sonnet 5 judge mean; p from 20000 label permutations.", |
| "all": { |
| "n": 20, |
| "spearman": 0.445, |
| "p": 0.0481 |
| }, |
| "without the user simulator": { |
| "n": 19, |
| "spearman": 0.384, |
| "p": 0.1079 |
| }, |
| "human_mean_by_tier": { |
| "A": { |
| "n": 9, |
| "mean": 1504.2 |
| }, |
| "B": { |
| "n": 10, |
| "mean": 1481.1 |
| }, |
| "C": { |
| "n": 1, |
| "mean": 1457.5 |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "judge_elo": { |
| "file": "round4_judge_elo.json", |
| "note": "ELO and rank range live there only" |
| }, |
| "inputs": { |
| "session_judge_v2.jsonl": "af47ffaf6ad2478a", |
| "production_defects.json": "2b54bcee3463b180", |
| "round4_willingness_leaderboard.json": "433018785f96df8f", |
| "craft_baseline_20260926_050941.json": "85ca536deeab078a", |
| "craft_baseline_20260924_231143.json": "5d810de4576db4e0", |
| "craft_baseline_20260924_224934.json": "5cdc00596feb3133", |
| "craft_baseline_20260924_143626.json": "0fe0e4b77888365f", |
| "craft_baseline_20260924_123104.json": "4de926c1ec681d8a", |
| "craft_baseline_20260924_122936.json": "09c7fd3c6e91f8bc", |
| "craft_baseline_20260921_174824.json": "3f4c94d84b2f05ef", |
| "craft_baseline_20260921_125936.json": "04da84eed4affc53", |
| "multiturn_merged_all_v2.json": "8f0b319b2ffe6a4d", |
| "r4_full_20260925_125329.json": "0b9f127672442ae4", |
| "r4_full_20260924_231143.json": "f175edcf6d6b8b04", |
| "r4_full_20260924_224934.json": "1076b40d8a2d6198", |
| "r4_full_20260924_150115.json": "2ef5c7fcc56ed774", |
| "r4_full_20260924_123104.json": "956fcd194e98b349", |
| "r4_full_20260921_180507.json": "48d5c3827f4af036", |
| "r4_full_20260806_095625.json": "35f8b96394d3798b", |
| "judge_full_chatgpt/merged/external_part_app.json": "e0b5e432f47214a6", |
| "judge_full_chatgpt/merged/external_part_reused_inc1_chatgpt.json": "a3643f112bf7a753", |
| "judge_full_chatgpt/merged/external_part_reused_round2_chatgpt.json": "6ff475f055c27932", |
| "judge_full_chatgpt/merged/_manifest.json": "2b7fe262127d13ea" |
| } |
| } |
|
|
