SalutefaceAAC's picture
Improve README: 7 diverse sample records, LLM eval code, detailed limitations + evaluation guidance
a2de886 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
11.7 kB
---
language:
- en
license: apache-2.0
task_categories:
- text-classification
task_ids:
- multi-class-classification
tags:
- logical-fallacies
- reasoning
- critical-thinking
- argumentation
- rhetoric
- synthetic
pretty_name: Logical Fallacy Classification
size_categories:
- n<1K
dataset_info:
features:
- name: id
dtype: int64
- name: text
dtype: string
- name: fallacy_type
dtype: string
- name: label
dtype: string
- name: explanation
dtype: string
- name: domain
dtype: string
- name: difficulty
dtype: string
- name: subcategory
dtype: string
splits:
- name: train
num_examples: 137
- name: validation
num_examples: 23
- name: test
num_examples: 23
---
# Logical Fallacy Classification
A synthetic benchmark of **183 hand-authored examples** for detecting and classifying logical fallacies in natural language text. Each example is labelled with a fallacy type, a binary label (`fallacious` / `sound`), an explanation of the reasoning error, domain, difficulty level, and subcategory.
## Dataset at a Glance
| Field | Values |
|-------|--------|
| Total examples | 183 |
| Fallacy types | 20 (+ `none` for sound examples) |
| Labels | `fallacious`, `sound` |
| Difficulty levels | `subtle`, `moderate`, `overt` |
| Domains | politics, science, health, ethics, law, economics, education, philosophy, marketing, everyday |
| Splits | train / validation / test |
| License | Apache 2.0 |
## Fallacy Types
| Fallacy Type | Count | Description |
|---|---|---|
| `ad_hominem` | 12 | Attacking the person, not the argument |
| `straw_man` | 11 | Misrepresenting someone's position |
| `slippery_slope` | 10 | Unjustified chain of increasingly extreme consequences |
| `false_dilemma` | 10 | Presenting only two options when more exist |
| `appeal_to_authority` | 10 | Using authority outside their domain or without evidence |
| `hasty_generalization` | 10 | Drawing broad conclusions from small/biased samples |
| `post_hoc` | 9 | Assuming causation from temporal succession |
| `circular_reasoning` | 8 | Using the conclusion as a premise |
| `appeal_to_emotion` | 8 | Manipulating emotions instead of providing evidence |
| `appeal_to_popularity` | 8 | What is popular must be true/right |
| `false_equivalence` | 8 | Treating importantly different things as the same |
| `red_herring` | 8 | Introducing irrelevant information to distract |
| `appeal_to_nature` | 7 | Natural = good; unnatural = bad |
| `equivocation` | 7 | Using the same word in different senses |
| `sunk_cost` | 7 | Continuing because of past investment, not future value |
| `anecdotal_evidence` | 7 | Personal experience over statistical evidence |
| `no_true_scotsman` | 6 | Redefining categories to exclude counterexamples |
| `tu_quoque` | 6 | Deflecting criticism by pointing to the accuser's faults |
| `appeal_to_ignorance` | 6 | Absence of disproof as proof |
| `naturalistic_fallacy` | 5 | Deriving 'ought' from 'is' |
| `none` (sound) | 20 | Non-fallacious, well-reasoned statements |
## Sample Records
**Ad Hominem · circumstantial · overt**
```json
{
"text": "Senator Williams says we need stricter gun laws, but she's never even held a gun. Her opinion is worthless.",
"fallacy_type": "ad_hominem",
"label": "fallacious",
"explanation": "Dismisses the senator's policy argument based on her personal experience rather than engaging with the merits of gun legislation.",
"domain": "politics",
"difficulty": "overt",
"subcategory": "circumstantial"
}
```
**False Dilemma · binary_framing · overt**
```json
{
"text": "You're either with us or you're with the terrorists.",
"fallacy_type": "false_dilemma",
"label": "fallacious",
"explanation": "Presents only two mutually exclusive positions, ignoring the possibility of neutrality, nuance, or third options.",
"domain": "politics",
"difficulty": "overt",
"subcategory": "binary_framing"
}
```
**Slippery Slope · exaggerated_endpoint · subtle**
```json
{
"text": "If we accept one typo in official government documents, accuracy will soon become completely meaningless in public life.",
"fallacy_type": "slippery_slope",
"label": "fallacious",
"explanation": "Extends a trivial, isolated event to a systemic breakdown with no intermediate reasoning.",
"domain": "everyday",
"difficulty": "subtle",
"subcategory": "exaggerated_endpoint"
}
```
**Equivocation · lexical_shift · moderate**
```json
{
"text": "All laws have exceptions. Evolution is a law of nature. Therefore evolution has exceptions.",
"fallacy_type": "equivocation",
"label": "fallacious",
"explanation": "'Law' in jurisprudence (human rule) vs. scientific law (observed regularity) are different senses — the syllogism exploits this ambiguity.",
"domain": "science",
"difficulty": "moderate",
"subcategory": "lexical_shift"
}
```
**No True Scotsman · moving_goalpost · moderate**
```json
{
"text": "True Christians don't judge others. — What about the ones who do? — They're not true Christians.",
"fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman",
"label": "fallacious",
"explanation": "Immunizes the claim against counterexample by revising the definition of 'true Christian' post-hoc.",
"domain": "philosophy",
"difficulty": "moderate",
"subcategory": "moving_goalpost"
}
```
**Appeal to Nature · naturalistic_fallacy · moderate**
```json
{
"text": "Humans have always lived in hierarchical societies — inequality is just natural.",
"fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature",
"label": "fallacious",
"explanation": "Naturalness doesn't justify a social arrangement; many natural phenomena are harmful and we work to change them.",
"domain": "ethics",
"difficulty": "moderate",
"subcategory": "naturalistic_fallacy"
}
```
**Sound Reasoning · none · moderate**
```json
{
"text": "Multiple peer-reviewed meta-analyses consistently show that vaccines do not cause autism. Therefore the claim that vaccines cause autism is not supported by evidence.",
"fallacy_type": "none",
"label": "sound",
"explanation": "Cites convergent scientific evidence from high-quality studies; the conclusion follows from the evidence.",
"domain": "health",
"difficulty": "moderate",
"subcategory": ""
}
```
## Schema
```python
{
"id": int, # unique row identifier
"text": str, # the statement to classify
"fallacy_type": str, # fallacy name (see table above) or "none"
"label": str, # "fallacious" | "sound"
"explanation": str, # why this is (or isn't) a fallacy
"domain": str, # subject domain
"difficulty": str, # "subtle" | "moderate" | "overt"
"subcategory": str # finer-grained fallacy variant (may be empty for "none")
}
```
## Usage
```python
from datasets import load_dataset
ds = load_dataset("SalutefaceAAC/logical-fallacy-classification")
train, val, test = ds["train"], ds["validation"], ds["test"]
# --- Task 1: binary detection ---
for ex in train:
text = ex["text"]
label = 1 if ex["label"] == "fallacious" else 0
# --- Task 2: multi-class (20 fallacy types) ---
from collections import Counter
type_dist = Counter(ex["fallacy_type"] for ex in train)
print(type_dist.most_common(5))
# --- Difficulty-stratified split ---
subtle = test.filter(lambda x: x["difficulty"] == "subtle")
moderate = test.filter(lambda x: x["difficulty"] == "moderate")
overt = test.filter(lambda x: x["difficulty"] == "overt")
# --- Zero-shot LLM evaluation with anthropic SDK ---
import anthropic
client = anthropic.Anthropic()
def detect_fallacy(text: str) -> dict:
prompt = (
"Identify whether the following statement contains a logical fallacy. "
"If yes, name the fallacy type and briefly explain it. "
"If no, say 'sound reasoning'.\n\n"
f"Statement: {text}"
)
msg = client.messages.create(
model="claude-opus-4-7",
max_tokens=256,
messages=[{"role": "user", "content": prompt}]
)
return {"response": msg.content[0].text}
# evaluate on the test split
results = [detect_fallacy(ex["text"]) for ex in test]
```
## Splits
| Split | Size |
|-------|------|
| train | 137 |
| validation | 23 |
| test | 23 |
## Intended Use
- Fine-tuning and benchmarking classifiers for **logical fallacy detection**
- Evaluating large language model reasoning and critical thinking
- Educational tools for rhetoric and argumentation courses
- Fact-checking and misinformation detection pipeline components
## Methodology
All 183 examples were **hand-authored** by a domain expert with coverage of:
- 20 canonical logical fallacy types from informal logic
- 10 subject domains (politics, science, health, law, economics, ethics, philosophy, education, marketing, everyday)
- 3 difficulty levels: **overt** (easily spotted), **moderate** (requires attention), **subtle** (requires domain knowledge)
- 20 sound (non-fallacious) examples to prevent trivial detection biases
- Subcategory labels for finer-grained analysis within each fallacy type
## Limitations
- **Scale**: 183 examples is a benchmark, not a training corpus. Use for evaluation, few-shot prompting, or augmentation seeding — not standalone fine-tuning.
- **Synthetic construction**: All examples are author-controlled and "clean"; real-world fallacies are typically embedded in longer discourse with shared context.
- **Class imbalance**: 89% fallacious / 11% sound. Report balanced accuracy (macro-averaged recall) alongside raw accuracy to avoid trivial "always-fallacious" baselines.
- **Boundary cases excluded**: Sound examples are clearly sound; fallacious examples are clearly fallacious. Arguments that are fallacious only *in context* are not included.
- **Sound class too small** (n=20) for rigorous cross-domain analysis of non-fallacious reasoning.
- **English only**: Fallacy recognition is culturally situated; some types manifest differently across languages and rhetorical traditions.
- **Subcategory incompleteness**: Subcategories cover common variants but are not exhaustive within each fallacy type.
## Evaluation Guidance
For binary detection, always report **balanced accuracy** (macro-averaged recall) to avoid inflated scores from the class imbalance. A trivial "always-fallacious" classifier achieves 91.3% accuracy but only 50% balanced accuracy.
For multi-class identification, use **macro-F1** over the 20 types. Types with ≤6 examples (`no_true_scotsman`, `tu_quoque`, `appeal_to_ignorance`, `naturalistic_fallacy`) will show high variance — report confidence intervals or aggregate them in significance tests.
For difficulty-stratified analysis, report separately for **overt / moderate / subtle** subsets to reveal where a model fails rather than just overall accuracy.
See [REPORT.md](REPORT.md) for full evaluation protocols and comparison with related datasets.
## Related Work
- **LOGIC** (Jin et al., 2022) — 13,000 natural Reddit instances across 13 fallacy types; higher ecological validity, noisier labels. Complementary to this dataset.
- **MAFALDA** (Helwe et al., 2023) — French-language fallacy benchmark (200+ examples, 15 types).
- **ArgMining shared tasks** (2014–2023) — upstream argument quality and stance tasks at major NLP venues.
- **FallacyDet** (Goffredo et al., 2022) — political debate fallacy detection with pre-trained transformers.
## Citation
```
@dataset{salutefaceaac2026fallacies,
title = {Logical Fallacy Classification},
author = {SalutefaceAAC},
year = {2026},
publisher = {Hugging Face},
url = {https://huggingface.co/datasets/SalutefaceAAC/logical-fallacy-classification},
license = {Apache 2.0}
}
```