| # Ledger: every clip, every miss, both products |
|
|
| This is the full per-clip record behind the counts in README.md. It exists so nobody has to take |
| the totals on faith. |
|
|
| **Products in this ledger.** "Product B" is a commercial veterinary AI scribe, run on |
| 2026-09-02 through its own documented upload flow on a trial account, under a real identity. |
| Two of its outputs are scored per clip: the raw transcript (its speech-recognition layer, seen |
| through its own transcript panel), and the SOAP note (the actual product: one stock template, |
| default settings, one generation per case, no edits). "Perch" is scored from the production |
| matcher, on the same 70 (id, voice) pairs, through two speech-recognition configurations it |
| runs in production side by side. Both configurations are shown; neither is named, on purpose |
| (see README.md, "What this is not"). |
|
|
| **How to read a cell.** "found: X, Y" means drug X and drug Y were recovered, correctly spelled, |
| in that output. "missed" means the drug never appears, correctly spelled, anywhere in that |
| output. "no false offer" on a trap row with no truth drugs means nothing was charted that |
| wasn't genuinely said. A false offer, where one happened, is called out explicitly in that row |
| and explained below the table. |
|
|
| **Method note.** These classifications come straight from `results_full.txt` in the internal |
| run this repo was built from (the exact per-clip miss and false-offer lists produced by the |
| scorer this repo's `score.mjs` is ported from), cross-checked against `corpus.jsonl`'s truth |
| list. Re-deriving these same numbers from `score.mjs` plus your own `outputs.jsonl` for either |
| product is exactly what the scorer is for; see README.md. |
|
|
| | id | trap | dictated (truth drugs) | Product B: transcript | Product B: SOAP (the product) | Perch: configuration A | Perch: configuration B | |
| |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| |
| | f001 | no | Apoquel, oclacitinib | missed: Apoquel, oclacitinib | found: oclacitinib; missed: Apoquel | found: Apoquel, oclacitinib | found: Apoquel, oclacitinib | |
| | f002 | no | Cerenia, maropitant, famotidine | found: Cerenia; missed: maropitant, famotidine | found: Cerenia, maropitant, famotidine | found: Cerenia, maropitant, famotidine | found: Cerenia, maropitant, famotidine | |
| | f003 | no | Vetmedin, pimobendan, furosemide | found: Vetmedin, pimobendan; missed: furosemide | found: Vetmedin, pimobendan, furosemide | found: Vetmedin, pimobendan, furosemide | found: Vetmedin, pimobendan, furosemide | |
| | f004 | no | Baytril, enrofloxacin | missed: Baytril, enrofloxacin | found: Baytril; missed: enrofloxacin + false offer: Roflexacin | found: enrofloxacin; missed: Baytril | found: enrofloxacin; missed: Baytril | |
| | f005 | no | Clavamox, amoxicillin-clavulanate, meloxicam | found: Clavamox, amoxicillin-clavulanate, meloxicam | found: amoxicillin-clavulanate, meloxicam; missed: Clavamox | found: Clavamox, amoxicillin-clavulanate, meloxicam | found: Clavamox, amoxicillin-clavulanate, meloxicam | |
| | f006 | no | Rimadyl, carprofen | found: carprofen; missed: Rimadyl | found: carprofen; missed: Rimadyl | found: Rimadyl, carprofen | found: Rimadyl, carprofen | |
| | f007 | no | Panacur, fenbendazole, pyrantel | found: Panacur, fenbendazole; missed: pyrantel | found: Panacur, fenbendazole, pyrantel | found: Panacur, fenbendazole; missed: pyrantel | found: Panacur, fenbendazole, pyrantel | |
| | f008 | no | isoflurane, Simbadol, buprenorphine | found: isoflurane, buprenorphine; missed: Simbadol | found: Simbadol, buprenorphine; missed: isoflurane | found: isoflurane, buprenorphine; missed: Simbadol | found: isoflurane, buprenorphine; missed: Simbadol | |
| | f009 | no | Apoquel, oclacitinib, Seresto | found: Seresto; missed: Apoquel, oclacitinib | found: oclacitinib, Seresto; missed: Apoquel | found: Apoquel, oclacitinib; missed: Seresto | found: Apoquel, oclacitinib, Seresto | |
| | f010 | no | Cerenia, maropitant | found: Cerenia; missed: maropitant | found: Cerenia, maropitant | found: Cerenia, maropitant | found: Cerenia, maropitant | |
| | f011 | no | carprofen, Rimadyl | found: carprofen; missed: Rimadyl | found: carprofen, Rimadyl | found: carprofen, Rimadyl | found: carprofen, Rimadyl | |
| | f012 | no | pimobendan, Vetmedin | found: pimobendan, Vetmedin | found: pimobendan, Vetmedin | found: pimobendan, Vetmedin | found: pimobendan, Vetmedin | |
| | f013 | no | maropitant, Cerenia, metronidazole | found: Cerenia, metronidazole; missed: maropitant | found: maropitant, metronidazole; missed: Cerenia | found: maropitant, Cerenia, metronidazole | found: maropitant, Cerenia, metronidazole | |
| | f014 | no | Clavamox | missed: Clavamox | found: Clavamox | found: Clavamox | found: Clavamox | |
| | f015 | no | Bravecto, NexGard, Simparica Trio | found: Bravecto, NexGard; missed: Simparica Trio | found: Bravecto, NexGard, Simparica Trio | missed: Bravecto, NexGard, Simparica Trio | found: Bravecto, NexGard, Simparica Trio | |
| | f016 | no | Apoquel | missed: Apoquel | found: Apoquel | found: Apoquel | missed: Apoquel | |
| | f017 | no | Vetmedin | found: Vetmedin | found: Vetmedin | missed: Vetmedin | found: Vetmedin | |
| | f018 | no | Librela | found: Librela | found: Librela | missed: Librela | found: Librela | |
| | f019 | no | gabapentin, levetiracetam | found: gabapentin; missed: levetiracetam | found: gabapentin, levetiracetam | found: gabapentin, levetiracetam | found: gabapentin, levetiracetam | |
| | f020 | no | ProHeart | found: ProHeart | found: ProHeart | found: ProHeart | found: ProHeart | |
| | f021 | no | Galliprant | missed: Galliprant | found: Galliprant | found: Galliprant | found: Galliprant | |
| | f022 | no | famotidine | missed: famotidine | found: famotidine | found: famotidine | found: famotidine | |
| | f023 | no | Malaseb, Cytopoint | found: Cytopoint; missed: Malaseb | found: Cytopoint; missed: Malaseb | found: Cytopoint; missed: Malaseb | found: Malaseb, Cytopoint | |
| | f024 | no | phenobarbital | found: phenobarbital | found: phenobarbital | found: phenobarbital | found: phenobarbital | |
| | f025 | no | trazodone | found: trazodone | found: trazodone | found: trazodone | found: trazodone | |
| | f026 | no | meloxicam, gabapentin | found: gabapentin; missed: meloxicam | found: meloxicam, gabapentin | found: meloxicam, gabapentin | found: meloxicam, gabapentin | |
| | f027 | no | omeprazole, metronidazole | found: metronidazole; missed: omeprazole | found: omeprazole, metronidazole | found: omeprazole, metronidazole | found: omeprazole, metronidazole | |
| | f028 | no | doxycycline, prednisolone | found: doxycycline, prednisolone | found: doxycycline, prednisolone | found: doxycycline, prednisolone | found: doxycycline, prednisolone | |
| | f029 | no | Convenia | found: Convenia | found: Convenia | found: Convenia | found: Convenia | |
| | f030 | no | atenolol | missed: atenolol | found: atenolol | found: atenolol | missed: atenolol | |
| | f031 | no | Bravecto, praziquantel | found: Bravecto; missed: praziquantel | found: Bravecto, praziquantel | found: Bravecto, praziquantel | found: Bravecto, praziquantel | |
| | f032 | no | Apoquel | missed: Apoquel | found: Apoquel | found: Apoquel | found: Apoquel | |
| | f033 | no | enalapril, furosemide | found: enalapril, furosemide | found: enalapril, furosemide | found: enalapril, furosemide | found: enalapril, furosemide | |
| | f034 | no | methimazole | missed: methimazole | found: methimazole | found: methimazole | found: methimazole | |
| | f035 | no | Vetsulin | found: Vetsulin | found: Vetsulin | found: Vetsulin | found: Vetsulin | |
| | f036 | no | chlorhexidine, cephalexin, itraconazole | found: chlorhexidine, itraconazole; missed: cephalexin | found: chlorhexidine, cephalexin, itraconazole | found: chlorhexidine, itraconazole; missed: cephalexin | found: chlorhexidine, cephalexin, itraconazole | |
| | f037 | no | mirtazapine | found: mirtazapine | found: mirtazapine | found: mirtazapine | found: mirtazapine | |
| | f038 | no | dexmedetomidine, ketamine, butorphanol | found: ketamine, butorphanol; missed: dexmedetomidine | found: dexmedetomidine, ketamine, butorphanol | found: dexmedetomidine, ketamine, butorphanol | found: dexmedetomidine, ketamine, butorphanol | |
| | f039 | no | amikacin, ondansetron | missed: amikacin, ondansetron | found: amikacin, ondansetron | found: amikacin, ondansetron | found: amikacin, ondansetron | |
| | f040 | no | clindamycin | found: clindamycin | found: clindamycin | found: clindamycin | found: clindamycin | |
| | f041 | no | Entyce | missed: Entyce | missed: Entyce | missed: Entyce | missed: Entyce | |
| | f042 | no | Heartgard, Frontline | found: Frontline; missed: Heartgard | found: Heartgard, Frontline | found: Heartgard, Frontline | found: Heartgard, Frontline | |
| | f043 | no | Zycortal, prednisolone | found: prednisolone; missed: Zycortal | found: Zycortal, prednisolone | found: Zycortal, prednisolone | found: Zycortal, prednisolone | |
| | f044 | no | Atopica | missed: Atopica | found: Atopica | found: Atopica | found: Atopica | |
| | f045 | no | Adequan | found: Adequan | found: Adequan | found: Adequan | found: Adequan | |
| | f046 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f047 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f048 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f049 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f050 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f051 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f052 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f053 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f054 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f055 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f056 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f057 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f058 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f059 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f060 | yes | Apoquel | missed: Apoquel | found: Apoquel | missed: Apoquel | missed: Apoquel | |
| | f061 | yes | Cerenia | found: Cerenia | found: Cerenia | found: Cerenia | found: Cerenia | |
| | f062 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer + false offer: phenylpropanolamine | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f063 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f064 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f065 | yes | dexmedetomidine | found: dexmedetomidine | found: dexmedetomidine | found: dexmedetomidine | found: dexmedetomidine | |
| | f066 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f067 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f068 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f069 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| | f070 | yes | (none on formulary) | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | no false offer | |
| ### Notes on specific clips |
|
|
| - **f004**: Product B heard "batril and roflexacin"; charted Baytril correctly but also charted "Roflexacin" as a second, separate medication. Roflexacin does not exist; enrofloxacin is the generic half of Baytril, so this doubles one antibiotic order into two. Perch (both configurations) charted enrofloxacin and missed the Baytril brand; neither Perch configuration added a second drug. |
| - **f001**: Apoquel (the brand half) dropped from the chart; oclacitinib (generic) recovered. Pattern repeats on f005, f006, f009, f013. |
| - **f005**: Clavamox (brand) dropped from the chart; amoxicillin-clavulanate and meloxicam both recovered. |
| - **f006**: Rimadyl (brand) dropped from the chart; carprofen (generic) recovered. |
| - **f008**: Simbadol/buprenorphine recovered; isoflurane dropped entirely from the chart (the only clip where an anaesthetic gas, not a brand/generic pair, was lost). |
| - **f009**: Apoquel (brand) dropped again; oclacitinib and Seresto both recovered. |
| - **f013**: Cerenia (brand) dropped from the chart; maropitant (generic) recovered. |
| - **f021**: Heard as "Galloprint"; Product B's repair layer corrected it to Galliprant in the chart. A genuine recovery, credited in README. |
| - **f023**: Malaseb heard as "malice of baths"; Product B and one Perch configuration both missed it, the other Perch configuration recovered it. |
| - **f030**: Heard as "8 nilal"; Product B's repair layer recovered atenolol correctly. One of Perch's two speech configurations missed it, the other recovered it. Credited to Product B in README: a real strength worth naming. |
| - **f036**: SOAP charted "Cefalexin" (an INN spelling variant of cephalexin, credited, not a miss or a false offer). |
| - **f041**: Entyce defeated every cell measured (Product B transcript and SOAP, both Perch configurations). Separately, RESULTS.md notes the SOAP visit narrative used the word "Entice" adjacent to the medication list; "entice" is an ordinary English word so the automated false-offer scorer does not flag it, but it is worth a human eye. |
| - **f043**: Dictation about a real Addison's disease case needing Zycortal. Not related to the separate Bexacat/Zycortal safety finding below, which comes from a different, later test set. |
| - **f058**: Trap: "the next guard shift schedule change," a scheduling phone note, no patient. Product B's transcript wrote "the NexGard shift schedule change" and the brand name carried into the visit narrative text. This did not appear as a charted medication bullet (so the automated scorer counts 0 false offers here), but it is a real vocabulary-bias miss at the transcript/narrative level and is treated as a finding in README, not hidden by the scoring technicality. Both Perch configurations transcribed "next guard shift" correctly. |
| - **f061**: Off-list sucralfate genuinely dictated alongside on-list Cerenia; both correctly charted by Product B. Not a false offer because sucralfate was actually said. |
| - **f062**: Trap: Proin dictated for urinary incontinence (off formulary, not a truth drug here). Product B correctly charted Proin, then added "(phenylpropanolamine)" next to it. Phenylpropanolamine is the correct generic name for Proin, but the clinician never said that word, so it counts as a false offer under this benchmark's rule: charting a word nobody said. Not a fabricated drug, but an unstated addition to the record. |
| - **f063**: Trap: Dasuquin or Cosequin, either brand fine, no drug listed (both off formulary). RESULTS.md notes the chart rendered one of them as "Kosquin," a misspelling; it did not register as an automated false offer because the underlying name was genuinely dictated. |
| ### Totals (raw counts, 70 clips, 84 dictated drug instances) |
|
|
| | cell | dictated drug instances | found | missed | false offers | |
| |---|---|---|---|---| |
| | Product B, raw transcript | 84 | 47 | 37 | 0 | |
| | Product B, SOAP note (the product) | 84 | 75 | 9 | 2 | |
| | Perch, configuration A | 84 | 71 | 13 | 0 | |
| | Perch, configuration B | 84 | 78 | 6 | 0 | |
|
|
| No cell is clean, and the misses land in different places. Entyce (f041) was missed by every |
| cell. On f004, both Perch configurations missed the Baytril brand and kept enrofloxacin, while |
| Product B's note kept Baytril and charted the invented Roflexacin where enrofloxacin should |
| have been. Simbadol (f008) was missed by Product B's transcript and by both Perch |
| configurations, and recovered by Product B's note. That difference in shape is the point of |
| publishing this. |
|
|
| ### Two misses that are ours, not Product B's, and not in this 70-clip set |
|
|
| This ledger is scoped to the 70-clip run against Product B on 2026-09-02. Two other findings |
| belong at the same weight and are recorded here rather than left out because they didn't happen |
| on this particular clip set: |
|
|
| - **Zycortal, charted for a Bexacat trap.** A separate trap clip (a later, larger test set, |
| written the same blind way: an author who never saw the matcher, describing a diabetic cat |
| "doing well on Bexacat, that's the oral option instead of insulin," a real feline drug that is |
| deliberately not on this benchmark's formulary) was matched, at the time, by the Perch build |
| running before 2026-09-14/15. That build charted Zycortal, a real but wrong drug, from the |
| garbled audio. The build running now declines to chart anything on that clip: it hears the |
| audio support Bexacat better than Zycortal and charts neither, leaving the word for the vet. |
| We are naming our own build and the date on purpose. |
| - **ProHeart, from a candidate design that never shipped.** While building the current matcher, |
| one configuration under evaluation charted ProHeart from a misheard "pretreated." It never |
| reached production; this test set is exactly what caught it before it could. |
|
|
| Neither of these is folded into the totals table above, because neither happened on this 70-clip |
| run. They are recorded here at the same prominence as Product B's Roflexacin and NexGard |
| findings because a test set that only publishes a competitor's misses is a sales document. This |
| one publishes its own. |
|
|
