Datasets:
|
Download README.md from ThakiCloud/B200-LowBit-Quantization-Benchmarks: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 11 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ThakiCloud/B200-LowBit-Quantization-Benchmarks/resolve/main/README.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/ThakiCloud/B200-LowBit-Quantization-Benchmarks/README.md
-
curl -L -o README.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/ThakiCloud/B200-LowBit-Quantization-Benchmarks/resolve/main/README.md
11 kB
| license: cc-by-4.0 | |
| pretty_name: B200 Low-Bit Quantization Benchmarks (Qwen3-8B, D81) | |
| language: | |
| - en | |
| - ko | |
| tags: | |
| - quantization | |
| - nvfp4 | |
| - mixed-precision | |
| - blackwell | |
| - b200 | |
| - vllm | |
| - benchmark | |
| task_categories: | |
| - text-generation | |
| size_categories: | |
| - n<1K | |
| configs: | |
| - config_name: arms | |
| data_files: data/final81_arms.csv | |
| - config_name: axes | |
| data_files: data/final81_axes.csv | |
| - config_name: paired | |
| data_files: data/paired_comparisons.csv | |
| # B200 Low-Bit Quantization Benchmarks (Qwen3-8B) | |
| Aggregate results, recipes and serving measurements from the paper | |
| *Beyond Bitwidth: Deployment-Constrained Mixed-Precision Quantization for Multilingual LLM Inference on NVIDIA Blackwell* | |
| (submitted to arXiv; the link will be added once it is public). | |
| This repository holds **results only**: the record of the D81 experiment (aggregate accuracy, paired differences, | |
| kernel checks, serving measurements and the A81 precision allocation). It is **not** the 5,168-item FINAL-81 | |
| benchmark or any other evaluation set, and it cannot be used to rerun the evaluation on its own. It contains no model | |
| weights, no evaluation items, no per-item predictions and no calibration text. The quantized checkpoints evaluated in | |
| the paper were not retained. | |
| A separate build of the A81 recipe is released as weights in | |
| [ThakiCloud/Qwen3-8B-NVFP4A16-INT8-Mixed-B200](https://huggingface.co/ThakiCloud/Qwen3-8B-NVFP4A16-INT8-Mixed-B200). | |
| That checkpoint was evaluated on its own, on an independent set (REL-81), and its card reports those results. | |
| They are not part of the paper's numbers and are not included in the files here. | |
| ## What was tested | |
| Base model: `Qwen/Qwen3-8B` (Apache-2.0). Hardware: one NVIDIA B200. Serving: vLLM 0.29.0, batch size 1. | |
| Every quantized configuration had to pass, on a sealed evaluation set it was never tuned on: | |
| - runtime weight memory below 5.98 GiB (measured weight-load bytes / 2^30), | |
| - Korean retention and tier retention of at least 0.90 relative to BF16, | |
| - overall, numeric and reasoning accuracy no more than 3 points below BF16, and format-error rate no more than | |
| 2 points above BF16, | |
| - time per output token at most 1.1 x BF16, | |
| - every quantized linear layer served by its intended packed kernel (no float fallback). | |
| The confirmatory set (FINAL-81) has 5168 items: 1565 Korean, 1043 English, 1320 numeric, | |
| 870 reasoning, 300 Korean math and 70 Korean in-domain. Its SHA-256 prefix is | |
| `26a1fadc91b6`. Items are not redistributed. | |
| ## Main result | |
| | Arm | Memory GiB | Tier ret. | Korean ret. | TTFT p50 ms | TPOT ms | tok/s (b1) | TPOT / BF16 | Gate | | |
| |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | |
| | BF16 | 15.268 | - | - | 15.251 | 3.9154 | 255.4 | 1.0 | reference | | |
| | A81 | 5.917 | 0.9311 | 0.9036 | 15.39 | 3.6759 | 272.0 | 0.9388 | PASS | | |
| | NVFP4 W4A4 | 5.977 | 0.8867 | 0.8208 | 42.26 | 2.5837 | 387.0 | 0.6599 | FAIL | | |
| | B81 | 5.153 | 0.8103 | 0.6996 | 16.823 | 3.3792 | 295.9 | 0.8631 | FAIL | | |
| | GPTQ W3 | 4.864 | 0.7477 | 0.6428 | 16.276 | 3.3895 | 295.0 | 0.8657 | FAIL | | |
| A81 (NVFP4A16 body, 46 INT8 modules, INT8 `lm_head`) was the only configuration that passed every gate: | |
| 5.917 GiB (61.2% below BF16), tier retention 0.931, Korean retention 0.904. | |
| All 144 quantized linear layers ran on the intended kernels (98 MarlinNvFp4, 46 Marlin). | |
| ## Paired comparisons | |
| Differences are accuracy points on the same items; intervals are simultaneous at the listed z. | |
| | Comparison | Set | Diff (pp) | CI | Status | | |
| |---|---|---|---|---| | |
| | A81 - NVFP4 W4A4 | FINAL-81 | +1.4 | [+0.2, +2.6] | confirmatory (preregistered) | | |
| | B81 - GPTQ W3 | FINAL-81 | +4.1 | [+2.3, +5.9] | confirmatory (preregistered) | | |
| | A81 - NVFP4 W4A4, Korean axis only | FINAL-81 | +1.1 | [-1.1, +3.3] | report-only | | |
| | A81 - NVFP4 W4A4, reasoning axis only | FINAL-81 | +3.8 | [+0.3, +7.2] | report-only | | |
| | A81 - NVFP4 W4A4 | SEL-81 | +3.4 | [+2.3, +4.6] | selection set | | |
| | NVFP4A16 (BF16 head) - NVFP4 W4A4 | DEV-80 | +2.8 | [+1.6, +4.0] | exploratory | | |
| | NVFP4A16 + INT8 units + INT8 head (D80 17-unit allocation) - NVFP4A16 (BF16 head) | DEV-80 | -0.3 | [-1.3, +0.8] | exploratory | | |
| | B81 with 50% Korean calibration - B81, Korean axis | SEL-81 | +2.2 | [-0.9, +5.4] | preregistered calibration test | | |
| | B81 with 50% Korean calibration - B81, reasoning axis | SEL-81 | -12.3 | [-16.8, -7.9] | preregistered calibration test | | |
| ## How to read these numbers | |
| - **Narrow Korean margin.** A81's Korean retention cleared the 0.90 gate by 0.0036 on 1565 Korean items. | |
| A different rebuild could land on the other side of the gate. | |
| - **Attribution is exploratory.** On the development set, moving from NVFP4 W4A4 to 16-bit activations (NVFP4A16) | |
| accounts for much of the gain (+2.8 points [+1.6, +4.0]). Adding INT8 modules on top changed accuracy by | |
| -0.3 points [-1.3, +0.8], using an earlier 17-unit allocation. The effect of A81's own 46-unit | |
| allocation was not identified on an independent set. | |
| - **Speed trade-off.** NVFP4 W4A4 had the highest batch-1 decode throughput (387 tok/s) but a TTFT of 42.3 ms | |
| and failed the quality gates. A81 decodes at 272 tok/s with a TTFT of 15.4 ms. These are batch-1 numbers; | |
| throughput at higher batch sizes was not measured. | |
| - **Not bitwise reproducible.** The SEL-81 and FINAL-81 builds of A81 had different checkpoint hashes | |
| (`9c4bce0c5e91` vs `7e6fcc531386`). Quality variance across rebuilds was not measured. | |
| - **Korean-heavy calibration did not transfer.** Recalibrating B81 with 50% Korean text changed Korean accuracy by | |
| +2.2 [-0.9, +5.4] (not significant) and reasoning by -12.3 [-16.8, -7.9] on SEL-81. A81 used the default | |
| calibration mix. | |
| ## Files | |
| - `data/final81_arms.csv` — memory, quality retention, serving latency and gate verdict per arm. | |
| - `data/final81_axes.csv` — per-axis aggregate accuracy (BF16 vs quantized) per arm. | |
| - `data/paired_comparisons.csv` — paired differences with confidence intervals. | |
| - `data/kernel_verification.json` — kernel assignment per arm, mismatches, float fallbacks. | |
| - `data/run_metadata.json` — gates, set identity, hardware, serving configuration, build hashes. | |
| - `recipes/a81_allocation.json` — A81 module-level precision allocation (which projections are INT8). | |
| - `REPRODUCE.md` — how to rebuild A81 and re-measure it. | |
| - `MANIFEST.sha256` — file hashes. | |
| ## Data sources and license | |
| ### What this repository contains | |
| Every file here is a measurement or a setting produced by ThakiCloud: per-arm and per-axis accuracy aggregates, | |
| paired differences with intervals, kernel assignments, serving latency, gate thresholds, set hashes and the A81 | |
| allocation. These files are released under CC BY 4.0. They contain no question, passage, answer option, gold label, | |
| generated output, per-item score or calibration text from any source dataset. A re-audit on 2026-11-17 scanned all | |
| 9 published files (392 string values) and found no item text and no item-keyed field. No AI-Hub data was used. | |
| ### Sources of the evaluation sets (not redistributed) | |
| FINAL-81 (5,168 items), SEL-81 (5,052) and DIAG-81 (1,998) were built by a script that pins each source to a Hub | |
| revision. The license column is what the dataset card declares at that revision. | |
| | Source | Hugging Face repo | Revision | License (Hub card) | D81 axis | Citation | | |
| |---|---|---|---|---|---| | |
| | KMMLU | `HAERAE-HUB/KMMLU` | `d61b3f19e552c576bf5960dd24289763edc36a88` | CC BY-ND 4.0 | Korean | Son et al., NAACL 2025 (arXiv:2402.11548) | | |
| | KoBEST (BoolQ, COPA, HellaSwag, SentiNeg; test) | `skt/kobest_v1` | `a5ea15e3ac77ed694b79f6204eb31889a2ba989f` | CC BY-SA 4.0 | Korean in-domain (report-only) | Jang et al., COLING 2022 (arXiv:2204.04541) | | |
| | MMLU (test) | `cais/mmlu` | `c30699e8356da336a370243923dbaf21066bb9fe` | MIT | English | Hendrycks et al., ICLR 2021 (arXiv:2009.03300) | | |
| | ARC (Challenge, Easy; test) | `allenai/ai2_arc` | `210d026faf9955653af8916fad021475a3f00453` | CC BY-SA 4.0 | English | Clark et al., 2018 (arXiv:1803.05457) | | |
| | HellaSwag (validation) | `Rowan/hellaswag` | `218ec52e09a7e7462a5400043bb9a69a41d06b76` | none declared (see notes) | English | Zellers et al., ACL 2019 (arXiv:1905.07830) | | |
| | BIG-Bench Hard | `lukaemon/bbh` | `982bb89fd79532a8ac676a61fc42eb1aeec63f99` | none declared (see notes) | Reasoning | Suzgun et al., Findings of ACL 2023 (arXiv:2210.09261) | | |
| | BIG-bench (41 tasks) | `tasksource/bigbench` | `b8ee34693560a13a9feac6aa5540449e18b7eddb` | Apache-2.0 | Reasoning | Srivastava et al., TMLR 2023 (arXiv:2206.04615) | | |
| | MuSR | `TAUR-Lab/MuSR` | `7c365b439a222150f317764d4f16ae6c96d7d94a` | CC BY 4.0 | Reasoning | Sprague et al., ICLR 2024 (arXiv:2310.16049) | | |
| | HRM8K (`gsm8k_test`, `ksm_test`) | `HAERAE-HUB/HRM8K` | `c360cabf8d733a82455565358b3dc965aab9ba8d` | MIT | Korean math (report-only) | Ko et al., 2025 (arXiv:2501.02448) | | |
| | Numeric generator | ThakiCloud code, seeds 8101, 8102, 8103 | — | no third-party text | Numeric | — | | |
| ### Redistribution conditions | |
| This repository publishes none of the material above, so its CC BY 4.0 license covers only our own measurements. | |
| If you rebuild the sets with `REPRODUCE.md`, download each source yourself and follow its license: | |
| - **KMMLU (CC BY-ND 4.0).** You may share the dataset unchanged with attribution, but you may not share adapted | |
| material. Reformatted prompt files, subsets in our item schema and per-item outputs can count as adapted material. | |
| Do not redistribute rebuilt KMMLU files. | |
| - **KoBEST and ARC (CC BY-SA 4.0).** Adapted material must credit the source and be shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. Rebuilt | |
| KoBEST or ARC items cannot be relicensed under CC BY 4.0 together with the files here. | |
| - **MuSR (CC BY 4.0), MMLU and HRM8K (MIT), BIG-bench (Apache-2.0).** Attribution and the license notice are required | |
| when redistributing. | |
| This is a summary of the declared licenses, not legal advice. | |
| ### Notes from the license check (2026-11-17) | |
| - **HellaSwag.** The Hub mirror declares no license at the pinned revision. The original GitHub repository | |
| (`rowanz/hellaswag`) was blocked when checked, following a DMCA notice filed by wikiHow on 2026-09-14 (recorded in | |
| `github/dmca`). HellaSwag contexts include text derived from wikiHow articles. We treat redistribution of HellaSwag | |
| items as unresolved; this repository contains none. | |
| - **BIG-Bench Hard.** The Hub mirror declares no license, and no license file was detected in the upstream repository | |
| (`suzgun/BIG-Bench-Hard`). Its tasks come from BIG-bench (Apache-2.0); we did not establish a separate license for BBH. | |
| - **DEV-80.** Two rows of the paired-comparison table use DEV-80, a set from the earlier D80 stage built by an earlier | |
| version of the same script. Its source list was not re-audited for this README. | |
| `Qwen3-8B` is distributed by its authors under Apache-2.0. | |
| ## Citation | |
| ```bibtex | |
| @misc{han2026beyondbitwidth, | |
| title = {Beyond Bitwidth: Deployment-Constrained Mixed-Precision Quantization for Multilingual LLM Inference on NVIDIA Blackwell}, | |
| author = {Han, Hyojung}, | |
| year = {2026}, | |
| note = {Preprint in preparation} | |
| } | |
| ``` | |