Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
rank
int64
model
string
test_date
string
access_route
string
settings
string
cost_usd
string
cost_per_edit_usd
string
passes
int64
partials
int64
fails
int64
output_size
string
charged_total_usd
string
list_total_usd
string
source_url
string
1
Meta Muse Image
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: meta/muse-image/text-to-image (aspect_ratio 3:4; output_format png); edits: meta/muse-image/edit (output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$0.08
$0.011
6
0
0
1344 × 1792 (3:4); edits grew slightly
0.0770
0.0770
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
2
MiniMax H3-Image
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: minimax/h3-image/text-to-image (aspect_ratio 4:5; resolution 2k; output_format png); edits: minimax/h3-image/edit (resolution 2k; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$0.26
$0.038
6
0
0
1824 × 2304; edits softer than source
0.2580
0.2580
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
3
FLUX 3 Image
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: black-forest-labs/flux-3/text-to-image (aspect_ratio 4:5; resolution 2k; output_format png); edits: black-forest-labs/flux-3/image-edit (resolution 2k; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$0.70
$0.10
6
0
0
1824 × 2288, kept
0.7000
0.7000
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
4
Nano Banana 2
2026-07-24
WaveSpeed
2K where supported; first output, each edit from its own untouched source
$0.74
$0.105
6
0
0
2K, kept
not recorded
not recorded
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
5
Grok Imagine Image 2.0
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: x-ai/grok-imagine-image-v2.0/text-to-image (aspect_ratio 3:4; resolution 2k; quality medium); edits: x-ai/grok-imagine-image-v2.0/edit (resolution 2k; quality medium); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$0.62
$0.09
5
1
0
1776 × 2368 (3:4, JPEG), kept
0.6200
0.6200
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
6
Qwen Image 3.0 Pro
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: alibaba/qwen-image-3.0-pro/text-to-image (aspect_ratio 4:5; resolution 2k; enable_prompt_expansion False); edits: alibaba/qwen-image-3.0-pro/edit (resolution 2k; enable_prompt_expansion False); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$0.54
$0.078
5
1
0
1831 × 2289, kept
0.5430
0.5430
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
7
Seedream 5.5
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: bytedance/seedream-v5.5 (aspect_ratio 4:5; resolution 2k; output_format png; background auto); edits: bytedance/seedream-v5.5/edit (resolution 2k; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$0.28
$0.041 ($0.043)
5
1
0
1831 × 2289; edits grew slightly
0.2787
0.2930
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
8
Seedream 5.0 Pro
2026-07-24
WaveSpeed
2K where supported; first output, each edit from its own untouched source
$0.63
$0.09
5
1
0
2K, kept
not recorded
not recorded
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
9
Krea 3
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: krea/v3/text-to-image (model berry; reasoning_level medium; size 1632*2048; output_format png); edits: krea/v3/edit (model berry; reasoning_level medium; size 1632*2048; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$1.24
$0.191 ($0.21)
5
1
0
1632 × 2048; edits softer than source
1.2434
1.3700
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
10
Nano Banana 2.1
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: google/nano-banana-2.1/text-to-image (resolution 2k; output_format png; enable_web_search False; enable_image_search False; aspect_ratio 4:5); edits: google/nano-banana-2.1/edit (resolution 2k; output_format png; enable_web_search False; enable_image_search False); first output, each edit from the untouched sou...
$0.39
$0.056 ($0.062)
5
0
1
1856 × 2304, kept
0.3888
0.4320
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
11
GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: openai/gpt-image-2.6-sunburst/text-to-image (resolution 2k; quality max; complexity high; output_format png; aspect_ratio 4:5); edits: openai/gpt-image-2.6-sunburst/edit (resolution 2k; quality max; complexity high; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$3.04
$0.437 ($0.485)
4
2
0
1712 × 2144, kept
3.0420
3.3800
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
12
Nano Banana Pro
2026-07-24
WaveSpeed
2K where supported; first output, each edit from its own untouched source
$0.98
$0.14
4
2
0
2K, kept
not recorded
not recorded
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
13
GPT Image 2.6 Flare
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: openai/gpt-image-2.6-flare/text-to-image (resolution 2k; quality max; complexity high; output_format png; aspect_ratio 4:5); edits: openai/gpt-image-2.6-flare/edit (resolution 2k; quality max; complexity high; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$3.04
$0.437 ($0.485)
3
3
0
1712 × 2144, kept
3.0420
3.3800
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
14
GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: openai/gpt-image-2.5-sunburst/text-to-image (resolution 2k; quality max; output_format png; aspect_ratio 4:5); edits: openai/gpt-image-2.5-sunburst/edit (resolution 2k; quality max; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$4.29
$0.615
3
3
0
1712 × 2144, kept
4.2900
4.2900
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
15
GPT Image 2.5 Flare
2026-11-17
WaveSpeed
source: openai/gpt-image-2.5-flare/text-to-image (resolution 2k; quality max; output_format png; aspect_ratio 4:5); edits: openai/gpt-image-2.5-flare/edit (resolution 2k; quality max; output_format png); first output, each edit from the untouched source, prompt only
$4.29
$0.615
3
3
0
1712 × 2144, kept
4.2900
4.2900
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
16
Qwen Image 2.0 Pro
2026-07-24
WaveSpeed
2K where supported; first output, each edit from its own untouched source
$0.49
$0.07
3
2
1
Shrank to 928 × 1152
not recorded
not recorded
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
17
GPT Image 2
2026-07-24
WaveSpeed
2K where supported; first output, each edit from its own untouched source
$0.76 / $2.86
$0.11 medium, $0.41 high
2
3
1
Shrank to 1792 × 2240
not recorded
not recorded
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/
18
FLUX.2 Max
2026-07-24
WaveSpeed
2K where supported; first output, each edit from its own untouched source
$0.49
$0.07
2
3
1
Shrank to 928 × 1152
not recorded
not recorded
https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/

TGK AI Image Editors

Article: https://theseguysknow.io/best-ai-image-generator-editor-test/ (updated 17 November 2026)

Version: v2 (17 November 2026). Zenodo DOI for this version: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24322904. v1: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24316573.

Eighteen editors, six edit tasks and 108 graded edits. Six editors were tested on 24 July 2026 and twelve on 17 November 2026, all through WaveSpeed. Every editor generated its own café source photo from the same prompt, then made six separate edits from that untouched source, using the prompt only. We kept the first output of every job. Midjourney V8.1 took part in July as a generation-only model and is excluded from the edit ranking.

The image inventory lists 135 assets: 19 source generations (seven from July, including Midjourney V8.1, and twelve from November), 108 edit outputs, seven July feature images and the November feature image. Images are linked, not included.

Results

rank model test_date passes / partials / fails full test per edit
1 Meta Muse Image 2026-11-17 6 / 0 / 0 $0.08 $0.011
2 MiniMax H3-Image 2026-11-17 6 / 0 / 0 $0.26 $0.038
3 FLUX 3 Image 2026-11-17 6 / 0 / 0 $0.70 $0.10
4 Nano Banana 2 2026-07-24 6 / 0 / 0 $0.74 $0.105
5 Grok Imagine Image 2.0 2026-11-17 5 / 1 / 0 $0.62 $0.09
6 Qwen Image 3.0 Pro 2026-11-17 5 / 1 / 0 $0.54 $0.078
7 Seedream 5.5 2026-11-17 5 / 1 / 0 $0.28 $0.041 ($0.043)
8 Seedream 5.0 Pro 2026-07-24 5 / 1 / 0 $0.63 $0.09
9 Krea 3 2026-11-17 5 / 1 / 0 $1.24 $0.191 ($0.21)
10 Nano Banana 2.1 2026-11-17 5 / 0 / 1 $0.39 $0.056 ($0.062)
11 GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst 2026-11-17 4 / 2 / 0 $3.04 $0.437 ($0.485)
12 Nano Banana Pro 2026-07-24 4 / 2 / 0 $0.98 $0.14
13 GPT Image 2.6 Flare 2026-11-17 3 / 3 / 0 $3.04 $0.437 ($0.485)
14 GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst 2026-11-17 3 / 3 / 0 $4.29 $0.615
15 GPT Image 2.5 Flare 2026-11-17 3 / 3 / 0 $4.29 $0.615
16 Qwen Image 2.0 Pro 2026-07-24 3 / 2 / 1 $0.49 $0.07
17 GPT Image 2 2026-07-24 2 / 3 / 1 $0.76 / $2.86 $0.11 medium, $0.41 high
18 FLUX.2 Max 2026-07-24 2 / 3 / 1 $0.49 $0.07

Costs are what we paid on the test date (July list prices; November charges from WaveSpeed billing, with the list price in brackets where a discount applied). They are not current price quotes. The November full test covers the source and six edits.

Method and limitations

  • November runs used 2K where offered and the highest practical quality: max for the GPT Image models and medium for Grok, its highest. Meta Muse Image and Grok used 3:4 because neither offers 4:5. Prompt expansion was off wherever the form allowed it.
  • Every November job is in evidence_records.csv with its endpoint, settings, output size, list price, charge and WaveSpeed prediction ID.
  • The verbatim November prompts are in test_prompts.csv. The July edit wording was not preserved; the July requests match the six summaries.
  • The GPT Image 2 quality setting used in July is not established.
  • Published images are WebP or PNG copies of the recorded outputs and may be resized.
  • Six edits on one scene don't cover every editing job. Masks, inpainting brushes and reference images were not tested.

Files

  • model_results.csv: 18 editors with rank, test date, settings, costs, grade counts and output size.
  • evidence_records.csv: 108 graded edits with the grade, the reason for each Partial or Fail, image URL and run details.
  • image_inventory.csv: every source, edit and feature image with its published caption.
  • test_prompts.csv: the source prompt and six edit prompts.
  • SCORING.md, DATA_DICTIONARY.md, CHANGELOG.md, CITATION.bib, LICENSE.

Dataset mirrors and citation

Hugging Face: https://huggingface.co/datasets/These-Guys-Know/tgk-ai-image-editors Kaggle: https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/mikehazard/tgk-ai-image-editors Zenodo (this version): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24322904 Zenodo (v1): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24316573

Downloads last month
45

Collection including These-Guys-Know/tgk-ai-image-editors