cfd-loss-rates / README.md
TradingLookup's picture
CFD loss-rate series v1.0.0 (provisional), data as of 6 Oct 2026
a1a4ee0 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
8.75 kB
metadata
license: cc-by-4.0
language:
  - en
pretty_name: CFD Loss-Rate Series (retail accounts losing money, by provider)
size_categories:
  - n<1K
tags:
  - finance
  - cfd
  - retail-trading
  - risk-disclosure
  - regulation
  - fca
  - esma
  - open-data
  - tabular
configs:
  - config_name: live
    data_files: cfd-loss-rates.csv
    default: true
  - config_name: history
    data_files: cfd-loss-rates-history.csv

CFD Loss-Rate Series

Risk note: CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. In this dataset, every provider says that most of its retail CFD accounts lose money. This is data, not advice.

Dataset summary

UK and EU rules make CFD providers print a standard risk warning that states what share of their retail accounts lost money over the previous 12 months. This dataset collects that one number for each provider, word for word from the provider's own website, with the date it was read, the legal entity named on the page and a SHA-256 fingerprint of the page text.

It has two tables:

Config File Rows What it holds
live cfd-loss-rates.csv 31 One row per provider: the current figure, read from the UK on 6 October 2026 (7 figures re-read and updated on 13 October 2026)
history cfd-loss-rates-history.csv 404 Quarterly figures for 18 providers from 2018-Q3 to 2026-Q4, read from Internet Archive (Wayback Machine) captures

cfd-loss-rates-summary.json holds the computed headline figures and cfd-loss-rates.datapackage.json is a Frictionless Data package describing the schema.

Headline figures (measured, data as of 6 October 2026, 7 figures updated 13 October 2026):

  • Median across the 31 providers: 73.46% of retail accounts lose money. Mean: 70.4%.
  • Range: 51% (eToro, legal entity not confirmed) to 84% (Libertex).
  • The 22 FCA-regulated providers on our list: median 71.8%, range 55% to 78.23%.
  • No provider's warning states 90%.

Release status: v1.0.0, provisional. An independent automated second read on 13 October 2026 matched 16 of 31 figures, found 0 changed, could not see the UK warning on 5 pages and was refused by 10 sites (it ran from a US connection).

Live page with the sortable table, per-provider pages and charts: CFD Loss-Rate Ledger on TradingLookup.

Supported uses

  • Comparing the loss figures that providers publish about their own clients.
  • Tracking how a provider's figure moved quarter by quarter since 2018.
  • Fact-checking claims such as "90% of traders lose money" against firms' own disclosures.
  • Teaching examples for small, well-documented tabular data with provenance columns.

It is not a measure of any one person's odds, and a lower figure does not make a provider safer or better.

Fields

cfd-loss-rates.csv (live, primary key slug)

Column Type Meaning
broker string Brand name
slug string URL-safe id; joins to the history file
entity string Legal entity the warning belongs to, as named on the page. Starts with "Not confirmed:" where the page lists several group companies (eToro, AvaTrade)
loss_rate_pct number (0–100) % of retail accounts that lose money, as stated by the firm
warning_text string The warning sentence, verbatim
source_url URI Page the warning was read from, after redirects
checked_at date Date the page was read (2026-10-06 or 2026-10-13)
evidence string SHA-256 of the page text, plus fetch method and location
second_read enum Result of an independent automated re-read: match, changed, not_found, blocked, or empty if not re-read
second_read_at string Date of the second read, YYYY-MM-DD
second_read_pct number Figure the second read found (empty unless match or changed). Never overwrites loss_rate_pct
second_read_url string Page the second read landed on, after redirects
second_read_evidence string Path of the saved page text or screenshot in our evidence archive, with SHA-256
second_read_note string Why a second read did not match, where needed
notes string Regulator (from our own list, not yet register-checked; "Not confirmed" when the entity is unconfirmed) and caveats
register_url string Regulator register page for the entity, once checked (empty in v1.0.0)
register_checked_at string Date the register was checked (empty in v1.0.0)

cfd-loss-rates-history.csv (history, primary key slug + quarter)

Column Type Meaning
broker string Brand name
slug string Joins to the live file
entity string Today's entity (not re-read from each archived page)
quarter string Calendar quarter of the archive capture, YYYY-Qn
loss_rate_pct number (0–100) % of retail accounts losing money on the archived page
archive_url URI The Wayback Machine capture
warning_text string The warning sentence on the archived page, verbatim

Source and method

  • What the number is. UK firms follow FCA COBS 22.5; EU firms follow ESMA's product intervention decision (Decision (EU) 2018/796), later made permanent by national regulators such as CySEC. The figure covers the firm's own retail CFD clients over the past 12 months, and firms recalculate it every quarter.
  • Reading. A script reads the text a UK visitor sees on each provider's site. Where the homepage carries no warning, it uses the firm's own page that does (CMC Markets, IG, Trading 212).
  • Strict match. A percentage counts only when the mandated wording follows it directly ("…% of retail investor accounts lose money…", or the German "…der Kleinanlegerkonten…").
  • Publish check. Publication stops if any figure differs from the number inside its own warning sentence. On 6 October 2026 there were 0 mismatches across 31 live and 404 history figures.
  • History. One Wayback Machine capture per quarter, read with the same rule. Gaps stay gaps; nothing is filled or estimated.
  • Second read. A separate automated check (user agent TradingLookupBot, robots.txt respected, no bot-wall bypass) re-reads each page later and records the result without overwriting the published figure.

Full write-up: how the loss-rate warnings are read.

Update frequency

Providers recalculate their figure quarterly. Each row carries its own read date, and a new dataset version is released when figures are re-read. Older versions are not rewritten.

Limitations

  • Provisional. Only 16 of 31 live figures were matched by the second read. No person has re-read them yet.
  • Regulator not register-checked. The regulator in notes comes from our own list. register_url is empty for every row in v1.0.0.
  • Two entities unconfirmed. eToro and AvaTrade show several group companies; the warning does not say which one the figure belongs to. They are left out of the FCA-only figure.
  • Not all UK firms. 22 figures are FCA-regulated firms, 6 CySEC and 1 BaFin (all read from the UK), plus the 2 unconfirmed.
  • History caveats. The live page and the archived page are not always the same URL. Five providers carry history flags in the summary file (eToro, AvaTrade, Spreadex, Trading 212, FxPro), for example the same figure many quarters running or two different figures on one archived page. Leave them out of trend comparisons.
  • Seven providers excluded because no figure could be read (Admirals, Interactive Brokers, Vantage, XM, FP Markets, Freedom24, Hantec Markets).
  • Group-level, backward-looking. Each figure describes a firm's clients as a group over a past year.

How to cite

TradingLookup (2026). CFD loss-rate series, v1.0.0 (provisional), data as of 6 October 2026. https://tradinglookup.com/brokers/cfd-loss-rates/. Licence: CC BY 4.0.

@misc{tradinglookup_cfd_loss_rates_2026,
  author       = {{TradingLookup}},
  title        = {CFD loss-rate series: share of retail accounts losing money, by provider},
  version      = {1.0.0},
  year         = {2026},
  note         = {Provisional release, data as of 6 October 2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://tradinglookup.com/brokers/cfd-loss-rates/}}
}

Licence

CC BY 4.0. Commercial use is allowed. Credit "TradingLookup" and link to the live page. The warning sentences are the providers' own words, quoted as facts about their disclosures.

Contact

Corrections: hello@tradinglookup.com. Fixes are logged on the site's corrections page.