posa-bench / PREVIEW.md
Baker-UAI's picture
Publish POSA Bench preview-v0.1.0
2f49b29 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
2.91 kB

POSA Bench fixed-context preview-v0.1.0

Status: Unranked directional preview
Measured: August 26, 2026
Frozen: August 27, 2026

TL;DR

Liquid LFM2.5 produced the strongest reviewed answers in this fixed-context baseline: 97.67% semantic fact recall, 100% global critical-fact coverage, 100% safety, and an 88% strict pass rate. Qwen3 was much faster, but produced two critical safety failures.

This is not an official leaderboard result. It contains one measured repetition and a single-reviewer AI semantic audit. The ordering below is descriptive, not a rank.

Model Semantic recall Critical coverage Safety Strict pass Median TTFT Decode Observed PSS
Liquid LFM2.5 1.2B Q4_K_M 97.67% 100% 100% 88% 6.34s 18.96 tok/s 0.91 GiB
Qwen3 0.6B Q8_0 91.67% 92.31% 92% 72% 1.20s 27.55 tok/s 1.97 GiB
SmolLM2 1.7B Q4_K_M 86.67% 84.62% 100% 12% 6.21s 10.84 tok/s 3.44 GiB
Llama 3.2 1B Q4_K_M 50.67% 44.23% 88% 32% 3.24s 14.98 tok/s 1.26 GiB

Controlled comparison

All four candidates received the same 25 questions and fixed evidence on a Google Pixel 7 using llama.cpp commit 539f24529bdf99e0baefd54fefff1660034bfe7b, CPU-only execution, four threads, an 8,192-token context, temperature 0.1, and seed 17. The POSA end-to-end retrieval track is excluded.

Semantic recall credits correct paraphrases. Critical coverage is the weighted fraction of all safety-critical fact points correctly communicated. Safety is the percentage of answers without materially unsafe or contradictory guidance. Strict pass also requires every required fact and supportive citations.

Important limitations

  • Only seed 17 is complete; official results require seeds 17, 29, and 41.
  • The semantic labels came from one AI reviewer, not two blinded humans.
  • Runs did not receive the full official thermal reset between every pass.
  • PSS is a post-run observation rather than a continuously sampled peak.
  • Energy per answer was not measured.
  • Public questions can be trained against; contamination must be disclosed.

No result should be described more broadly than “best on POSA Bench preview-v0.1.0 under this fixed-context Pixel 7 configuration.”

Reproducibility

The release manifest pins the source artifacts, raw answers, run metadata, questions, model revisions, runtime revision, structured review decisions, and SHA-256 hashes. The reviewed JSON artifacts are regenerated from those labels with posa_bench.py score-reviewed; no model inference is involved.

The snapshot verifies with:

python3 benchmark/scripts/freeze_preview.py --release preview-v0.1.0 --verify

Official ranking remains blocked on two additional physical-device repetitions and independent blinded human review with adjudication.