GlassGSM / README.md
reza2ei's picture
Duplicate from reza2ei/GlassGSM
2998f00
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
8.04 kB
---
license: mit
language:
- en
pretty_name: GlassGSM
size_categories:
- 10K<n<100K
task_categories:
- text-classification
tags:
- math
- robustness
- perturbation
- benchmark
- causal-inference
- gsm8k
- math-reasoning
configs:
- config_name: glassgsm
default: true
data_files:
- split: full
path: data/glassgsm/twins.parquet
- config_name: glassgsm_bases
data_files:
- split: full
path: data/glassgsm/bases.parquet
- config_name: glassgsm_pooled
data_files:
- split: full
path: data/glassgsm/pooled_bases.parquet
---
# GlassGSM
Meaning-preserving "twins" of the 1,319 GSM8K test problems, each labeled with whether the solver (`gpt-4o-mini`)
that solved the original problem fails on the twin. The data supports the study of *conditional causal difficulty*
(how fragile a task a model can already solve is to a rewrite that leaves the answer unchanged) and was
released with the paper *Fragility Is Not Reducible to Hardness: Conditional Causal Difficulty for LLMs*. It is the grade-school companion of [GlassMATH](../glassmath/).
**No twin is written by a language model.** All three perturbation families are applied by deterministic, seeded
code, so every twin is reproducible from the released scripts and carries no artifact of a generator model. A
language model enters only twice, both of them downstream of the perturbation: as the **solver** whose outcomes
become the labels, and as the **No-Op judge** in the audit described below.
**Code:** <https://github.com/upwork/Conditional_Causal_Difficulty_for_LLMs/> (training and evaluation of Frail-π, and the scripts that build this release).
## What is in a row
A **base** is an original GSM8K problem. A **twin** is the same problem after one perturbation that
must not change the gold answer. Each twin was posed to the solver and compared against the solver's result on the
base problem.
| `family` | what is done |
|---|---|
| `entity_rename` | person names are replaced with names from a neutral pool |
| `sentence_reorder` | the problem's sentences are reordered |
| `injection` | one or more setup sentences from a *different* GSM8K problem are injected; `injection_ops` is how many (1, 3, 5, 7, or 9) |
Fragility rises with perturbation dose: the original GSM-IC leaves 3.7% of problems fragile, while GlassGSM
raises this to 44.9% over the pooled doses (see the table below).
### Configs
| config | one row is | rows |
|---|---|---|
| `glassgsm` | one twin × one run setting `m` | 32,858 |
| `glassgsm_bases` | one base problem × `m`, with base-level aggregates | 6,595 |
| `glassgsm_pooled` | one base problem, pooled over all doses (unique twin texts) | 1,319 |
Each config has a single split named `full`. No train/test split is shipped; the paper uses repeated random
problem-level splits, so **split by `base_id`, never by row**: all twins of a base share a label structure and a
base text.
### Twin fields (`glassgsm`)
| field | type | meaning |
|---|---|---|
| `uid` | string | unique row key `solver/m{m}/twin_id` (`twin_id` alone is only unique within one `m`) |
| `base_id` | string | original problem id; `gsmic_adv-N` is index N of the GSM8K test split |
| `twin_id` | string | twin id within a run |
| `m` | int | run setting (1, 3, 5, 7, 9) |
| `solver` | string | solver model whose outputs produced the labels (`gpt-4o-mini` for every row) |
| `family` / `injection_ops` / `operator` | | perturbation family, number of injected sentences (null for non-injection), and the raw operator tag |
| `complexity`, `complexity_score` | | declared complexity proxy: a heuristic score in [0, 1] computed from the problem text (it correlates with problem length); `complexity` is `medium` for every row |
| `base_text`, `twin_text` | string | original and perturbed problem |
| `gold_answer` | string | final answer, extracted from GSM8K (`####`) |
| `base_solved` | bool | the solver answered the base correctly (modal answer of 5 samples at temperature 0.2) |
| `delta` | int | `Y(base) - Y(twin)` in {-1, 0, 1}; `1` means the twin is wrong where the base was right |
| `broke` | bool | `delta == 1`. It implies `base_solved`. Fragility is defined on rows where `base_solved` is true |
### Base fields (`glassgsm_bases`)
`base_id, m, solver, complexity, complexity_score, base_text, gold_answer, base_solved` plus `n_twins`, `d_obs`
(mean `delta` over the base's twins) and `d_wc` (max `delta`). They are exact aggregates of the twin rows,
shipped separately so they do not leak into twin-level modeling as if they were per-twin labels.
### Pooled fields (`glassgsm_pooled`)
`base_id, solver, complexity_score, base_text, gold_answer, base_solved` (majority over the five doses),
`n_unique_twins` (twins pooled over all doses, deduplicated on `(base_id, twin_text)`), `pi` (break rate over those
twins, the CCD; meaningful only where `base_solved`), `d_obs` (mean `delta`), `fragile` (`d_obs > 0.05`, the
paper's definition, over all problems) and `ccd_fragile` (`base_solved` and `pi > 0.05`).
## Statistics
*Break rate* = share of twins on a solved base that the solver gets wrong. *Fragile problems* = share of all
problems whose mean effect `d_obs` exceeds 0.05 (the paper's definition). *CCD-fragile* = share of solved problems
whose break rate `pi` exceeds 0.05.
Solver: `gpt-4o-mini` (temperature 0.2, 5 samples per prompt, modal answer).
| m | twins | base problems | break rate on solved bases | fragile problems | zero-effect problems |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1,319 | 1,319 | 6.6% | 6.2% | 92.0% |
| 3 | 3,957 | 1,319 | 8.8% | 17.8% | 79.3% |
| 5 | 6,594 | 1,319 | 10.7% | 27.4% | 69.7% |
| 7 | 9,210 | 1,319 | 11.6% | 34.1% | 62.9% |
| 9 | 11,778 | 1,319 | 12.5% | 39.6% | 56.9% |
| pooled | 18,309 unique | 1,319 | n/a | 44.9% | 48.6% |
Pooled over doses, 47.7% of the 1,242 solved problems are CCD-fragile. Fragility rises steadily with dose. The
pooled row is the GlassGSM row of the paper's Table 1 (44.9% fragile, 48.6% zero-effect, 13.9 unique twins per
problem); the original GSM-IC leaves 3.7% of problems fragile. Per-dose figures come from the `glassgsm` config and the pooled
figures from `glassgsm_pooled`.
## Construction and audit
Twins come from the three operator families above, and every one of them is produced by deterministic, seeded code
rather than by an LLM rewrite. Entity renaming substitutes recognised person names consistently from a fixed
gender-neutral pool; sentence reordering applies a hash-seeded shuffle of the setup sentences and leaves the
question sentence last; injection splices in setup sentences copied verbatim from a hash-chosen different GSM8K
problem. The same seed reproduces the same corpus, and each twin carries exactly one family. Before
release every (base, twin) pair is passed through a full-corpus filter: an LLM
adjudicator checks that the twin does not change or invalidate the gold answer, and deterministic checks drop
pairs with entity-name collisions, gold-answer-number collisions, or an extra question. This corpus is the
audited, resampled mix of those surviving pairs (no new LLM calls were made to build it).
## Provenance and licensing
Base problems and gold answers originate from GSM8K (MIT); injected sentences also come from GSM8K.
Perturbations and labels are new. The release is under the MIT license; the upstream notice is reproduced in
`NOTICE.md`.
## Loading
```python
import pandas as pd
twins = pd.read_parquet("data/glassgsm/twins.parquet")
solved = twins[(twins["solver"] == "gpt-4o-mini") & (twins["m"] == 9) & twins["base_solved"]]
```
## Citation
```bibtex
@misc{rezaei2026fragilityreduciblehardnessconditional,
title={Fragility Is Not Reducible to Hardness: Conditional Causal Difficulty for LLMs},
author={Mohammad Reza Rezaei and Dingxian Wang and Nikhil Verma and Sajjad Pakdamansavoji and Andrew Rabinovich and Zhao Chen},
year={2026},
eprint={2611.02065},
archivePrefix={arXiv},
primaryClass={cs.LG},
url={https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.02065},
}
```